Ngl I used to be a Leila (not as bad) it didn’t take long for me to change as I realized I was hurting people that I loved for boys that didn’t reciprocate. I feel like that’s why I also felt for her much more than most viewers but yeah she is pretty bad, I don’t know if change is possible as she is definitely crazy (that bomb threat 😬).
I liked that it didn't have typical "cool kids" who were the bad guys and "dork kids" who were the good guys. Everyone was just an actual human being and there wasn't any black or white. Everyone had faults and also some good in them. Also, Laila was supposed to be hated. She did her job well.
It really pisses me off that the POC writers were actually abused behind the scenes and left the show as result. It’s kind of ironic considering the producers are teaching us about racism while being racist themselves.
netflix is the definition of performative activism. all this talk about blm and "black stories matter" but half their shows have racist shit going on behind the scenes, with whites writing stories for poc characters, which is why the characters of color get sidelined and written shitty. and white hairdresses behind the scenes not even knowing how to do hairstyles for black hair in the cast for the black actresses (hair that half the human population has). did you hear what happened with the cast of dear white people?? apparently the director was racist or something. something i have noticed as a white person
As far as I know this whole controversy started because one writer tweeted something. She said that she and two other POC writers where treated badly. So they quit. But, who are those other two writers? Why haven't they said something, or supported her? In her tweet she asked for magazines or media to interview them and there where several offers...where are they?
I've seen her tweets and she seems to be a person who always speks the truth but she never elaborate about this..? Why didn't she took the opportunity to talk about it with the media? She didn't do anything besides tweeting an explosive comment?
@@luiscalzoncit2820 Let's see, they are poc writers in Hollywood, which is a place that discriminates against poc writers. Use your brain and figure out why they wouldn't speak up.
This she was such a performative activist for so many things and watching her insert herself in situations that didn’t have to deal with her or when she kneeled just cause she saw Dom and her friends doing it to. And even the feminism thing like she’s so quick to make fun of other women like Leila and I don’t even like her but still there was no reason to make fun of her in the first episode and onward even if she is shit
@@venus9727 exactly. It’s the same people that like to force them selves into situations & speak on things they don’t understand who are friends with disgusting people
BIG FACTS 🗣️ Like the teacher definitely had a issue with her but sis...your whole nipple is out. And don't get me started how she made the wallet situation worse 😑
You people do realize that black people would not have gotten as far as they have with civil rights if liberal white people didnt get involved in activism, right?
@@alexstyles5808 one, chill with the you people my guy 🤣✋🏾, two "performative activist" is someone who talks all about equal rights and liberty for all, but do none of the actual action that's needed to make change. Or they only care about the topic when it's about them/for selfish reasons. In the context of the show, Joey did what she did for her own reasons so , she's not the liberal white you're trying to stick up for. 🤷🏾
honestly i think all the characters were made to have flaws and be unlikable to show that no one is perfect, i mean obviously they all need to get their shit together because my GOD
At some point in a show you’re meant to like the characters, not like them, maybe relate to them a bit and like them after a while. That’s how it happens in real life. Have you ever watched a movie where you had a love/hate relationship with the bad guy. Kinda like how people feel with joker. Have you ever had a friend that had a bad trait but you still loved them, that’s how it is in real life. If all the characters are irritating then they need to go back to the drawing board
@@tta1390 I don't understand why people hate on Dom. That's your likable character and her friends are precious. Plus, the siblings are no unlikable per se, Leila's friend is super nice, and the saxophonist is confused and threw away his future, but he felt he was doing the right thing. I saw this season mainly as the setting for the next one tbh.
Everyone except for Jay, Owen, Omar (Leila’s new bf), and Rachel (Leila’s friend). The show is literally them dealing with everyone else’s bs. Never dishing out to others
Dom's friends helped her when she told them that she couldn't go to prom with the boy she liked. She wouldn't go to prom because she had an arranged marriage. It was sad because she didn't want to get married even though, her family needed the money.
I actually liked the main characters... because they felt like real people and were not bad despite their flaws. Things like Joey's white feminism or Syd's misogyny/internalized homophobia, felt intentional becase those things allowed the characters to have arcs and grow. And then there were the super chill characters like Jayson, who was more of an immature kid than a bad person and Dom, who was gorgeous and smart and perfect. The only truly unlikable character for me was Leila, who ACTUALLY did things out of malice and messed with very serious stuff. In general I don't think characters have to be perfect to be likable and I actually enjoy when they have room to grow... and I'm not talking about the guys who raped Joey because they were clearly not meant to be liked in the first place... it's not a flaw making the antagonists unlikable. Oh and hey I remember you saying the series was problematic but never saying why. I really don't get why it's problematic.
Oh shoot, you're right I should've been more clear in the video! For the problematic things I was referencing I was mainly alluding to how the show took on and had characters make comments on terrorism along with the casual racism sprinkled throughout
@@imuRgency I think that was intentional because people are really like that, no cap, especially people who say they are "woke" at the end of the day you are still American
@@steamyvegetables1445 it was super subtle... little things like recommending Leila for that list, I'm pretty sure he also told his sister that she was at fault for sending the nudes that got leaked. Of course it's extremely subtle, he's a good person but contributes to misogyny with micro-aggressions
I was impressed how they handled difficult topics on this show (for a netflix high school drama). This is the first time that I've seen a show actually show the consequences and trauma of SA. The psychological horror, the exhaustion of the process, the injustice... so upsetting and unfortunately realistic. Regardless if you like Joey as a character or not, I think the show did a great job at making us empathize with her. This is a very important point to me because I've seen shows that have SA scenes but only to shock the audience and after that nobody cares anymore. The plot just goes on like nothing happened. It makes me really mad because these scenes are very upsetting to me but the topic is never adressed again
To me it just felt like a more realistic euphoria- there was always a lot happening that it was lowkey hard to keep up. I liked it tho, I really could see myself in the characters. Something I think keeps happening with tv shows that display high school dramas is that nobody really fws the characters, but IMO that's fine because at the end of the day this isn't a movie- it's supposed to be displaying a more realistic high school experience and growth just doesn't happen that fast.
‘realistic euphoria’ that’s the best description i’ve heard of the show. my school was almost the exact same as the show in some aspects so i felt like i was watching drama go on at my school lmao
Yess omg. It’s filmed near where I live and is at places I go to all the time so it feels so real. Plus the guy who plays Owen goes to my school so it rlly feels accurate
I don’t know why I want to feel bad for Joey cause of what happened to her and I do feel bad and that should never happen to anyone female or male, but the way she’s such a performative activist especially a white feminist. I can’t shake this feeling that if it was someone else who had gotten assaulted especially by her friends she would still be friends with them and defend them to hell and back. Especially with Leila like I don’t like her but honestly the way the white boy treated her wasn’t it and Joey just laughed at it her laughed behind her. And it’s so weird how many people relate to Joey and call her an activist when she really isn’t. Is it weird I feel that she would act like this?
@@alexstyles5808 because it’s not feminism at all, white feminism only helps white women not all women. Women of colors issues are constantly ignored because it involves race as well. But a lot of white women don’t want to include this discuss because they believe it will hinder the progress of feminism (actual facts). I’ve literally written a paper on how white feminism or feminism in general isn’t for women. Like in the case of Joey and Dom, Dom who was the actual victim was ignored when she was Joey inserted herself into a conversation that she had no part in. Because Joey was a white girl they took her words over Dom a black girl which caused two black kids to be suspend and expelled. That is not feminism at all, she thinks she’s doing something when really she’s made things worse for the people it really affects. Feminism isn’t just for white women it was made to create equality for everyone. White feminism is basically white supremacy by white women which is why so many unjust things are still occurring especially to women of color. White feminism is a bad thing and shouldn’t exist at all
i thought it represented causal racism pretty well honestly. the two white boys saying racist things and then claiming their allies is very realistic (at least for me).
I feel like Laila sent the bomb threat also bc it cancelled that play that Sid’s sister was directing. Laila got the understudy role but never actually rehearsed anything, so when she actually got the part, she was unprepared and rightfully kicked from the show but she got mad for some reason. That’s another reason why I don’t like her.
The racist thing with sid I saw it happen all the time in high school. I watch this boy whose family is Egyptian and he would let his lacrosse friend call him a terrorist. Thee only time he stood up to them us when he was otp with his mom and speaking Arabic and they started saying he was talking about blowing shit up. UGH BOILS MY BLOOOD! Like the yt kids dont care. Periodt. Rude as hell
To me the show is way more relatable than most of the teen shows. The characters are the types of people we all know and it covers real life issues. Shows like Euphoria are just bizarre to me because it's like eh worst case scenario of highschool. Grand Army had a lot of bad things happen in it but I like that it didn't super over sexualize the girls like Euphoria.
I feel like no one is talking about how much chemistry the actors have with each other. Might seem like a small thing, but it's definitely noticeable, and one of the things that kept me watching
Grand Army is the most realistic depiction of high school I have ever seen. I also appreciate how diverse the show was, I rarely see any brown skin black girls and south Asian people on my screen! My only gripe with the show is that I felt like they did too much with the sex. At times, it felt like the characters were oversexualized but besides that, I really enjoyed it.
As a high school student in nyc, this show was pretty accurate. The atmosphere was familiar to me if that makes any sense like the way they acted in school was similar to what Im used to. The show had a lot going on and I have to say it was entertaining. To clarify, while it may be familiar to me, it is in no way a good thing. Nyc high schools suck for the most part, the only part that’s interesting is all the drama that goes on. Just like the show, there’s a lot going on and it’s entertaining but most of the time the events aren’t good events.
same i go to hs in nyc and this show just felt like home. which honestly opened my mind to how effed up nyc highschools are. the dramas really toxic nowhere.
I agree so much even the pace of the show felt good cuz its how NYC really is we focus on a important issue for like a solid month don't solve it at all but move on like Nothing happened
I agree with what you said about the casual racism and how they’re like I’m not racist but continue to call Sid awful names but I feel like they did that intentionally. That’s def how it is in real high schools now and I think they were trying to make a statement on microaggression and how passive they were
I liked the show because I feel like it’s one of the closest portrayals of current teenage life... which is not saying much. Bar is on the ground. Directors really think we’re perpetually stuck in the 1980s. Anyways, it brought me certain awareness about topics like feminism and SA, etc... id even say it was one of the main shows that got me interested in feminism (and I learned not to approach it Joey’s way 😬). I’d say the characters are flawed, but still redeemable. Except Layla, she can really just 👉🏻🚔 I was really rooting for her at first two, as I am a former pick-me (embarrassing af). I think most girls are, and we all learn to grow out of it and want the best for each other. But she just kept getting worse and ✋🏻🙄
same, in the first episodes I related to Leila. At her age, I was also so desperate for male attention uugggh I cringe every time thinking about it. But, when you are a teenage girl, it really feels like your worth is determined on whether boys like you. But then the murder fantasies came and I was like... ok girl you need serious therapy
Dom was my girl. As a Haitian, I identified so much with her family struggles. And yeah, I know people who got payed to marry someone and give them a green card. Joey and Leila were so... infuriating!
To be honest I don't know if I liked the show, but it felt a lot real to me, like I am based in India, so my culture is obviously different, but I could understand Dom's issues, have seen Liela in rl, and douchbags boys, the girl Joey who is woke and put herself into uncomfortable situation to prove herself(have been me, a little) but If I have to compare it to Euphoria, I will chose Grand Army any day, I have seen people going gaga over how great Euphoria is, and again I don't know the culture there, But to me GA seemed a lot real, it tries to cover many topics and I don't blame it for that
I think the reason why some westerners go crazy over euphoria is mainly the fashion, vibe and music and not the actual show because the show itself is very flawed, I am especially uncomfortable with the fact that it is on HBO and has nudity, because even though adults play them, it's still nude teenagers that are being shown, as they are supposed to be teens, and young as well, I just can't relate to Euphoria at all, it doesn't feel very authentic to me, I think they should have set it in University instead. I don't know why directors and writers are so intent on portraying high schoolers, these grown people are so desperate to portray children 10 or more years their junior. Why can't we have college, and I mean good college shows anymore. Also the show seriously is lacking in diversity, In grand army there were south and east Asian people and black teens, euphoria does not have that. I mean they want to tell the authentic teen experience, but choose to brutally traumatize their only black character who never actually did anything wrong but seek white validation I guess.
@@kimberleywilliams7802 euphoria is very flawed, all those teen agers apart from Nate, have parents who are hardly earning, but all of them are so fancily dressed, Rue is able to buy drugs, Jules is sleeping around with people who is of her father's age and is very casual about it, I don't know is it really this casual in USA? I hated euphoria
@@theawantikamishra Right? Jules is literally wearing pieces RIGHT off of the runway, she's wearing thousand dollar clothes from top class designers to indie brands, an trust me those brands ain't cheap, I'm talking over 1000 dollars, who has that kind of money? not a teen, I'm sorry that takes me out of the show, where's the realism and continuity? I don't want to say I hate it because some people say that's their experience (?) , but I do
@@theawantikamishra also where is Rue getting money to buy drugs?, and don't let euphoria fool you, teens would NOT be casual about that kind of thing, if anything they'd be trying to actively hide it.
I refuse to watch euphoria after s1. There’s an overload of yelling and abuse. And even tho I know sex isn’t taboo, I think I’m still having to unlearn the shame behind sex. It’s just sooo overwhelming having to hear yelling and watch sex scenes every 5 seconds😭😭😭I think it’s also bc they’re playing teenagers, and they just keep showing everything. The show just triggered me so badly, that I was like “nahhh” I don’t think I want to watch anymore shows with SA either. Like I just can’t watch many things that add a bunch of triggers. I get trying to show awareness, but I do think euphoria executes it...maybe not poorly? But it’s just a LOT. I probably won’t watch grand army, for the fact it has SA topics. I’ll just get overwhelmed
personally i think joey was doing her best with the small understanding she had about racism and sexism and other social issues. i think because we’re watching these characters after we’ve already been through high school or from a second-person perspective, we can see exactly where they went wrong and judge them for it, but in the moment a lot of us would have acted similarly or know people who we don’t exactly hate, who act similarly
I started the show being actually surprised by how realistic it was,you can say whatever you want about how unlikable the characters are,but they are exactly the people I met in real life and decided to keep my distance from,they can have their own struggles and we can identify with them but they all make mistakes and it felt very real to me...that being said I'm glad you made this video because I literally couldn't finish it after the SA scene,it was way too triggering to me that I closed it and didn't look back,I'm but surprised Leila got worse though,she annoyed me so much
I really liked the show. It has to be the most realistic portrayal of hs I've ever seen. And the fact that it takes places in Brooklyn made it even better. 😌👌🏾
i really like the character of joey because you can actually see how superficial everything in her life was before the SA. i think one of the most impactful scenes is when she goes out for a run and sees her friends that assault her and she just has a full on panic attack, it’s like, she can’t even just go for a jog or dance or go to school anymore. it’s even more impactful BECAUSE you saw her performative activism and how careless she was about things before
Please try Blood & Water it's a South African Netflix original. First of it's sorts for SA..coz we not really into teen dramas here, but that one is a good one.
“It just kinda seemed unfinished.” Idk if you know this but the was a cute little pandemic. I get the feeling that they got cut off by ms. Rona. Like they even mentioned the coronavirus situation in one of the later episodes so they were filming when this was a thing in our awareness and I feel like they probably just had to wrap it up when things got crazy. I’m not sure but that’s what it seemed like to me
Okay I feel like Jay wasn’t that bad of a character, I feel like we’ve all done something messed up in our life that we didn’t think through, jay honestly never meant to do anything to mess up dom or Owen. He felt bad bc he’s human I feel like they represented him well, if anyone with a good heart was in the same situation they would react the same way as jay
I will say as someone who went to school in BK NYC ( literally not far from the fake location of this school) kids have called in bomb threats as senior pranks. It happens a min of once a year. Its so fucked up but atm everyone is so used to it and because we walk. over to the elementary school a few blocks away most people leave and go shopping.
Is it a common consensus that people don't like this show? I enjoyed parts of it, especially how not 30 everyone seemed and how much it seems like it's set in actual modern highschool (though I'm 22 now so what do I know). Everything else I just chalked up to it being one of ~those~ teen drama shows. Especially how much you want to shake the characters who just don't get it. I enjoyed the trigger warning for the SA that they put in the show (and was able to skip past it), but I found it weird that they didn't warn for every single flashback. I was personally surprised how triggering I found the opening scene. I haven't been through it, and I'm Canadian, so I didn't think i had that baggage. Anything based on past events (Columbine) haven't affected me because it feels very fictional due to the time, but I didn't realise until watching this that we all really wondered if it would happen to us every day. So basically if any American is reading this and wondering, approach it with caution. Edit: man, Dom and friends really carried this show. After hearing what you think of it, yeah, without their through line of friendship the rest would be worse.
"how not 30" LMAOOO but yess i think as far as realism goes it was definitely more accurate to the HS than most which is why maybe people dont like it because it be hitting a little too close to home
Idk if i actually liked this show, but i really like how real it is, i was expecting like "the good character and the villain" type of show but nope and i really appreciate thay
I think this is the most realistic portrayal of high school I've ever seen in a show. I actually loved every character except Leila obviously lol. Joey reminds me a lot of myself, but her activism is all social media based not a bad thing probably the only way she knows but yeah. I don't think her activism is performative she just has different ideas of right and wrong. Why was it wrong she took a knee if she also believes black lives matter? When she interfered with Dom she did what she felt was right but it wasn't, not all her fault cause the teacher was biased though. I loved Sids story because those microaggressions are real. He was finding himself and it was a literal fight. The representation of both cultures between Dom and Sid were awesome too. I loved the representation.
yeah I felt like Joey truly believes in the activism but she doesn't know yet how she actually has to behave in some situations, after all she's still just a teen and has much to learn
i feel like she’s ignorant in a way a LOT of white teen girls/even guys are, they mean well but haven’t been taught or had the opportunity to really learn, internalise and understand what exactly they’re preaching. still not okay i guess but i feel like she’s not as terrible as ppl think? idk
I really loved this show. It felt really realistic and I know that people didn't really like the characters or misogyny and racism, I feel like that's the point of the show. It in some way shows people's actual struggles in life; the casual racist remarks people face, the narcissistic behaviours people show, the way people preach about activism but aren't willing to call out the people close to them, etc. It just shows what happens in real life and if you guys want a more in depth kind of review you can watch Tee Noir's review on this, it's really good.
Yeah I hate how people assume that just because a show/movie portrays racism or misogyny that means they’re pro-racism like no they’re just trying to show it. the same thing happened in ginny and georgia
leila sent the bomb threat so that the drama performance she wasn't in wouldn't go ahead... not because she wanted to get back with her bsf. anytime she wasn't the centre of attention she had to ruin it
It was too real that was the problem, in the times we are living in we yearn for fantasy. That's why Euphoria is one of the most watched. It's treated more like a dream/nightmare of life. It has some realistic story lines but they are brought to extremes that would never happen and are pure entertainment. It was good timing for Euphoria. Grand Army might have worked way more in the late 90's early 2000's, when a lot more shows like that were on.
I definitely agree with the ending I was so confused with Joey dancing at the end and I understand Jayson point but like you said it was the worst cliff hanger
I really loved it, I understand not liking the characters but the show represent high schoolers really well and makes a great job showing them as real persons
I liked it’s realism and I think it had a lot of room to grow and improve. It’s a shame it got cancelled, I wanted to see what they would do with season 2. It sucks to hear about the black/POC writers, why am I not surprised?
As an Indian , I personally related to how the Indian family was portrayed..like it's very real.. the way Sid's dad came around only when he got into Harvard , it was like that for me too...indian parents will sell their souls for good grades lmao💔 and the micro agressions to Sid was too real...like it's always like that , white people act they're allies but then act like that (most of the time) The show was very real to me and I think it was intentional for the show to make the characters unlikable and flawed Too bad it got cancelled and now we won't see the complete character arcs
I actually found this show to be surprisingly decent and realistic for a Netflix highschool based show (Dom was my fav character). I also think it was pretty important to show off Joey's character and how much she changes... what happens to her is horrible and disgusting but it's interesting to see this show follow the trope of "destroying" a stereotypical white feminist (or just what media considers a strong female character) in some sort of sexual way... it's unfortunate, but that's a weird fetish for lots of people. However, I think they did that on purpose, even in the show they call Joey a "performative activist." Kind of to show off how some women really do see feminism through a narrow, single person viewpoint, I think. I wish they would change her viewpoint on feminism and performative activism though, not based on SA, but I guess it was also important to show that not everyone is your friend (referring to Joey's disgusting douchebag "friends"). ALSO, Leila was absolutely horrible, she was so hard to watch and I skipped most of her scenes. All the other characters were a little boring though IMO. Nothing stood out too much. Overall the show wasn't... bad I guess? it's interesting looking back on it.
I think all of the "problematic" parts were meant to be on purpose for example the casual racism and joeys performative activism. these parts show things that happen in real life and no one takes seriously
I actually think that what made the show so compelling was the fact that all the characters were somewhat flawed and not entirely likeable. I liked that it challenged us to think about causality and accountability. I think the fact that we weren’t so attached to any of the personalities made us more critical about their character arcs?
I only watched the first couple episodes (I stopped before the episode where Joey got assaulted) so I didn’t really watch all of joeys scenes, but I did like that she took a stand against the dress code and the female solidarity when they all took off their bras that day to support her
there was alot of misogyny and sexism throughout the show but that was there to bring light to the topics or atleast thats what they were trying to do but it came out all wrong and sloppy without actually addressing the misogyny, the creators just left it there and moved on to a different topic. Also i feel like jayson never really screwed owen over, it was owens idea to steal doms purse and he was the one to go inside her bag, even tho jay apologized alot to owen for it, it never was his fault. alsooo leila didnt send a threat because she wanted her bff back but she wanted to cancel the play because she screwed up her chance for the lead role more than once and if she cant be a part of the play than no one can. the whole season was pretty problematic but i want to watch the next season, most stories were left abruptly and every story wasnt remotely interconnected thats kid of why i want to watch the next season, this and to see character development because the base plot is good and the creators were trying to make a change by bringing up important taboo topics and grand army still has potential for a really good season 2 if they just fix the problematic parts and bring everyones story a little more interconnected.
i think the show made the white kids super micro-aggressive on purpose, because as much as they kept saying they weren’t racism they clearly were and you could see it. also it is very true that black and brown people are held to this super high standard by their parents and society at large
Hey ImuRgency. Great review! You should definitely watch the HBO show industry and review the show on your RUclips channel. The wildness is insane, but the intensity and emotions are so palpable in the moment. Definitely take a look at that show in its entirety. Have a nice day as well ImuRgency. 😃
i think the point of joey and her friends (up until episode 3) was to accurately portray white liberals in our time. i think they had a lot to handle from the first episode, so it would’ve been best if we just watched the characters deal with the fallout of the literal bomb threat rather than the hamfisted attempts we got at a suspenseful show. i think the sa scene was too much and wasn’t used really in good faith. i feel like we could’ve gotten to know (and maybe like) joey more before we were introduced to straight up trauma.
i 100% agree on the SA take. i actually really liked the show and the characters, i thought they got a really good mix of personalities and just ‘real’ ppl, but i cant rewatch it because of how heavily they went on Joey’s SA case. the scene, the aftermath, the confrontations, it’s good that it’s finally being addressed on TV more than a quick ‘u hurt me! >:(‘ kind of way, but it was very heavy and took up a lot of the season, there was no time to breathe or process what was going on.
Regarding the end I heard somewhere they had to suspend production around the time cuz you know COVID happened so maybe they had something more planned but couldn’t do it
This is sooo true damn it. I just finished watching it and I’m speechless. You put my thoughts into words... and yeah the characters r really unlikeable. I thought it was really frustrating coz sometimes I feel sympathy 4 the characters but then they do really problematic things...
There were so many good points said in the comments wow that I kinda wish I made in my review . Joey definitely picked on Lelia while claiming to be a feminist and there were so many other issues I missed . Great review and comments
The way I hate Leila. Like I feel for her in a sense, but the fact that she was doing all that was not needed. Girl only cared for herself:')
Unfortunately though we all know a Leila
@@KC-ep6sg I am 24 now, I have seen Liela in my life turning out to be a good person now, hoping the same for character
@@KC-ep6sg Fr😭😭
@@theawantikamishra right I hope her character actually grows. Cause that whole school bomb thing was not it!!
Ngl I used to be a Leila (not as bad) it didn’t take long for me to change as I realized I was hurting people that I loved for boys that didn’t reciprocate. I feel like that’s why I also felt for her much more than most viewers but yeah she is pretty bad, I don’t know if change is possible as she is definitely crazy (that bomb threat 😬).
I liked that it didn't have typical "cool kids" who were the bad guys and "dork kids" who were the good guys. Everyone was just an actual human being and there wasn't any black or white. Everyone had faults and also some good in them.
Also, Laila was supposed to be hated. She did her job well.
Agreed!
I think that’s y I found it weird cuz it was surprisingly real not like those other fake high school movies I began to enjoy it tho
Laila didn’t seem real to me though, she was a caricature
@@raindropsonroses3919 oh but I promise you ppl like that exists
yesss
It really pisses me off that the POC writers were actually abused behind the scenes and left the show as result. It’s kind of ironic considering the producers are teaching us about racism while being racist themselves.
netflix is the definition of performative activism. all this talk about blm and "black stories matter" but half their shows have racist shit going on behind the scenes, with whites writing stories for poc characters, which is why the characters of color get sidelined and written shitty. and white hairdresses behind the scenes not even knowing how to do hairstyles for black hair in the cast for the black actresses (hair that half the human population has). did you hear what happened with the cast of dear white people?? apparently the director was racist or something. something i have noticed as a white person
Right and because of that if u notice the show is not being promoted as much
As far as I know this whole controversy started because one writer tweeted something. She said that she and two other POC writers where treated badly. So they quit. But, who are those other two writers? Why haven't they said something, or supported her? In her tweet she asked for magazines or media to interview them and there where several offers...where are they?
I've seen her tweets and she seems to be a person who always speks the truth but she never elaborate about this..? Why didn't she took the opportunity to talk about it with the media? She didn't do anything besides tweeting an explosive comment?
@@luiscalzoncit2820 Let's see, they are poc writers in Hollywood, which is a place that discriminates against poc writers. Use your brain and figure out why they wouldn't speak up.
For me personally, Joey was the human embodiment of white Feminism🤷🏾♀️
This she was such a performative activist for so many things and watching her insert herself in situations that didn’t have to deal with her or when she kneeled just cause she saw Dom and her friends doing it to. And even the feminism thing like she’s so quick to make fun of other women like Leila and I don’t even like her but still there was no reason to make fun of her in the first episode and onward even if she is shit
@@venus9727 exactly. It’s the same people that like to force them selves into situations & speak on things they don’t understand who are friends with disgusting people
BIG FACTS 🗣️ Like the teacher definitely had a issue with her but sis...your whole nipple is out. And don't get me started how she made the wallet situation worse 😑
You people do realize that black people would not have gotten as far as they have with civil rights if liberal white people didnt get involved in activism, right?
@@alexstyles5808 one, chill with the you people my guy 🤣✋🏾, two "performative activist" is someone who talks all about equal rights and liberty for all, but do none of the actual action that's needed to make change. Or they only care about the topic when it's about them/for selfish reasons. In the context of the show, Joey did what she did for her own reasons so , she's not the liberal white you're trying to stick up for. 🤷🏾
honestly
i think all the characters were made to have flaws and be unlikable to show that no one is perfect, i mean obviously they all need to get their shit together because my GOD
At some point in a show you’re meant to like the characters, not like them, maybe relate to them a bit and like them after a while. That’s how it happens in real life. Have you ever watched a movie where you had a love/hate relationship with the bad guy. Kinda like how people feel with joker.
Have you ever had a friend that had a bad trait but you still loved them, that’s how it is in real life. If all the characters are irritating then they need to go back to the drawing board
@@tta1390 I don't understand why people hate on Dom. That's your likable character and her friends are precious. Plus, the siblings are no unlikable per se, Leila's friend is super nice, and the saxophonist is confused and threw away his future, but he felt he was doing the right thing. I saw this season mainly as the setting for the next one tbh.
I liked that about the show cause that's how people are in real life? It's not always bad guys against the good guys.
Everyone except for Jay, Owen, Omar (Leila’s new bf), and Rachel (Leila’s friend). The show is literally them dealing with everyone else’s bs. Never dishing out to others
@@anabaron4824 yh like i feel like the opened a can of worms and forgot to close it. But season 2 may be better
Dom not only has all the things she struggles with in the show but also has to CARRY the damn show on her back like what
Dom's friends helped her when she told them that she couldn't go to prom with the boy she liked. She wouldn't go to prom because she had an arranged marriage. It was sad because she didn't want to get married even though, her family needed the money.
Nah all the character contribute for me, even if i don't like them
Fr
Zaperator 44 true, because honestly all the characters were super realistic especially to their family situations and personally lives
Let’s be fr now
I actually liked the main characters... because they felt like real people and were not bad despite their flaws. Things like Joey's white feminism or Syd's misogyny/internalized homophobia, felt intentional becase those things allowed the characters to have arcs and grow. And then there were the super chill characters like Jayson, who was more of an immature kid than a bad person and Dom, who was gorgeous and smart and perfect. The only truly unlikable character for me was Leila, who ACTUALLY did things out of malice and messed with very serious stuff. In general I don't think characters have to be perfect to be likable and I actually enjoy when they have room to grow... and I'm not talking about the guys who raped Joey because they were clearly not meant to be liked in the first place... it's not a flaw making the antagonists unlikable.
Oh and hey I remember you saying the series was problematic but never saying why. I really don't get why it's problematic.
Oh shoot, you're right I should've been more clear in the video! For the problematic things I was referencing I was mainly alluding to how the show took on and had characters make comments on terrorism along with the casual racism sprinkled throughout
@@imuRgency I think that was intentional because people are really like that, no cap, especially people who say they are "woke" at the end of the day you are still American
Wait when was Syd Misogynistic?
@@steamyvegetables1445 it was super subtle... little things like recommending Leila for that list, I'm pretty sure he also told his sister that she was at fault for sending the nudes that got leaked. Of course it's extremely subtle, he's a good person but contributes to misogyny with micro-aggressions
I definitely agree
I was impressed how they handled difficult topics on this show (for a netflix high school drama). This is the first time that I've seen a show actually show the consequences and trauma of SA. The psychological horror, the exhaustion of the process, the injustice... so upsetting and unfortunately realistic. Regardless if you like Joey as a character or not, I think the show did a great job at making us empathize with her.
This is a very important point to me because I've seen shows that have SA scenes but only to shock the audience and after that nobody cares anymore. The plot just goes on like nothing happened. It makes me really mad because these scenes are very upsetting to me but the topic is never adressed again
To me it just felt like a more realistic euphoria- there was always a lot happening that it was lowkey hard to keep up. I liked it tho, I really could see myself in the characters. Something I think keeps happening with tv shows that display high school dramas is that nobody really fws the characters, but IMO that's fine because at the end of the day this isn't a movie- it's supposed to be displaying a more realistic high school experience and growth just doesn't happen that fast.
‘realistic euphoria’ that’s the best description i’ve heard of the show. my school was almost the exact same as the show in some aspects so i felt like i was watching drama go on at my school lmao
this is exactly it!
yep i agree with this
euphoria is realistic this just felt like euphoria but less focused on the drug/alcohol aspect of high school
Yess omg. It’s filmed near where I live and is at places I go to all the time so it feels so real. Plus the guy who plays Owen goes to my school so it rlly feels accurate
I don’t know why I want to feel bad for Joey cause of what happened to her and I do feel bad and that should never happen to anyone female or male, but the way she’s such a performative activist especially a white feminist. I can’t shake this feeling that if it was someone else who had gotten assaulted especially by her friends she would still be friends with them and defend them to hell and back. Especially with Leila like I don’t like her but honestly the way the white boy treated her wasn’t it and Joey just laughed at it her laughed behind her. And it’s so weird how many people relate to Joey and call her an activist when she really isn’t. Is it weird I feel that she would act like this?
Being a white feminist is bad because?
@@alexstyles5808 because it’s not feminism at all, white feminism only helps white women not all women. Women of colors issues are constantly ignored because it involves race as well. But a lot of white women don’t want to include this discuss because they believe it will hinder the progress of feminism (actual facts). I’ve literally written a paper on how white feminism or feminism in general isn’t for women. Like in the case of Joey and Dom, Dom who was the actual victim was ignored when she was Joey inserted herself into a conversation that she had no part in. Because Joey was a white girl they took her words over Dom a black girl which caused two black kids to be suspend and expelled. That is not feminism at all, she thinks she’s doing something when really she’s made things worse for the people it really affects. Feminism isn’t just for white women it was made to create equality for everyone. White feminism is basically white supremacy by white women which is why so many unjust things are still occurring especially to women of color. White feminism is a bad thing and shouldn’t exist at all
@@venus9727 👏🏾👏🏾 that was so perfectly explained!
@@tinakupa5167 thank you☺️
so trueeee
i thought it represented causal racism pretty well honestly. the two white boys saying racist things and then claiming their allies is very realistic (at least for me).
lailas one of those girls who thinks she's the 'main character'
She will be in season 2
@@dionruffin3996 I am afraid so, God I hate her character
@@theawantikamishra I hated Joey much more
@@dionruffin3996 same
Maybe she will get her character development .@@theawantikamishra
I feel like Laila sent the bomb threat also bc it cancelled that play that Sid’s sister was directing. Laila got the understudy role but never actually rehearsed anything, so when she actually got the part, she was unprepared and rightfully kicked from the show but she got mad for some reason. That’s another reason why I don’t like her.
She needs to get caught and go to jail no joke.
It’s a shame we won’t get to find out
That is an interesting thought. 👍🏾
The racist thing with sid I saw it happen all the time in high school. I watch this boy whose family is Egyptian and he would let his lacrosse friend call him a terrorist. Thee only time he stood up to them us when he was otp with his mom and speaking Arabic and they started saying he was talking about blowing shit up. UGH BOILS MY BLOOOD! Like the yt kids dont care. Periodt. Rude as hell
Of course the ignorant Lacrosse players did that
Same with me in middle school, and the thing is all his friends were poc, Hispanics and a black person.
To me the show is way more relatable than most of the teen shows. The characters are the types of people we all know and it covers real life issues. Shows like Euphoria are just bizarre to me because it's like eh worst case scenario of highschool. Grand Army had a lot of bad things happen in it but I like that it didn't super over sexualize the girls like Euphoria.
I could not agree more with your take! So sad season 2 was cancelled!
I feel like no one is talking about how much chemistry the actors have with each other. Might seem like a small thing, but it's definitely noticeable, and one of the things that kept me watching
I wanna hang out with Dom’s character and friends. They’re my cup of tea 😌
yesss
dom and her friends carried the show 💖
Grand Army is the most realistic depiction of high school I have ever seen. I also appreciate how diverse the show was, I rarely see any brown skin black girls and south Asian people on my screen! My only gripe with the show is that I felt like they did too much with the sex. At times, it felt like the characters were oversexualized but besides that, I really enjoyed it.
i actually didn’t feel like they were oversexualized, what made you feel that way?
As a high school student in nyc, this show was pretty accurate. The atmosphere was familiar to me if that makes any sense like the way they acted in school was similar to what Im used to. The show had a lot going on and I have to say it was entertaining. To clarify, while it may be familiar to me, it is in no way a good thing. Nyc high schools suck for the most part, the only part that’s interesting is all the drama that goes on. Just like the show, there’s a lot going on and it’s entertaining but most of the time the events aren’t good events.
same i go to hs in nyc and this show just felt like home. which honestly opened my mind to how effed up nyc highschools are. the dramas really toxic nowhere.
I agree so much even the pace of the show felt good cuz its how NYC really is we focus on a important issue for like a solid month don't solve it at all but move on like Nothing happened
honestly, dom and her friends are the best characters on the show and they should have a spinoff centered around them
I agree with what you said about the casual racism and how they’re like I’m not racist but continue to call Sid awful names but I feel like they did that intentionally. That’s def how it is in real high schools now and I think they were trying to make a statement on microaggression and how passive they were
okay but man getting all these sponsorships... why do i feel like a proud mom??
I liked the show because I feel like it’s one of the closest portrayals of current teenage life... which is not saying much. Bar is on the ground. Directors really think we’re perpetually stuck in the 1980s.
Anyways, it brought me certain awareness about topics like feminism and SA, etc... id even say it was one of the main shows that got me interested in feminism (and I learned not to approach it Joey’s way 😬).
I’d say the characters are flawed, but still redeemable. Except Layla, she can really just 👉🏻🚔 I was really rooting for her at first two, as I am a former pick-me (embarrassing af). I think most girls are, and we all learn to grow out of it and want the best for each other. But she just kept getting worse and ✋🏻🙄
same, in the first episodes I related to Leila. At her age, I was also so desperate for male attention uugggh I cringe every time thinking about it. But, when you are a teenage girl, it really feels like your worth is determined on whether boys like you.
But then the murder fantasies came and I was like... ok girl you need serious therapy
wow it is cool a show makes you interested in feminism. crazy how media can impact us in real life like that. you seem cool
The way how Dom was trying to help take care of her brother and her sisters while she was in school is a lot of pressure.
Dom was my girl. As a Haitian, I identified so much with her family struggles. And yeah, I know people who got payed to marry someone and give them a green card. Joey and Leila were so... infuriating!
To be honest I don't know if I liked the show, but it felt a lot real to me, like I am based in India, so my culture is obviously different, but I could understand Dom's issues, have seen Liela in rl, and douchbags boys, the girl Joey who is woke and put herself into uncomfortable situation to prove herself(have been me, a little) but If I have to compare it to Euphoria, I will chose Grand Army any day, I have seen people going gaga over how great Euphoria is, and again I don't know the culture there, But to me GA seemed a lot real, it tries to cover many topics and I don't blame it for that
I think the reason why some westerners go crazy over euphoria is mainly the fashion, vibe and music and not the actual show because the show itself is very flawed, I am especially uncomfortable with the fact that it is on HBO and has nudity, because even though adults play them, it's still nude teenagers that are being shown, as they are supposed to be teens, and young as well, I just can't relate to Euphoria at all, it doesn't feel very authentic to me, I think they should have set it in University instead. I don't know why directors and writers are so intent on portraying high schoolers, these grown people are so desperate to portray children 10 or more years their junior. Why can't we have college, and I mean good college shows anymore. Also the show seriously is lacking in diversity, In grand army there were south and east Asian people and black teens, euphoria does not have that. I mean they want to tell the authentic teen experience, but choose to brutally traumatize their only black character who never actually did anything wrong but seek white validation I guess.
@@kimberleywilliams7802 euphoria is very flawed, all those teen agers apart from Nate, have parents who are hardly earning, but all of them are so fancily dressed, Rue is able to buy drugs, Jules is sleeping around with people who is of her father's age and is very casual about it, I don't know is it really this casual in USA? I hated euphoria
@@theawantikamishra Right? Jules is literally wearing pieces RIGHT off of the runway, she's wearing thousand dollar clothes from top class designers to indie brands, an trust me those brands ain't cheap, I'm talking over 1000 dollars, who has that kind of money? not a teen, I'm sorry that takes me out of the show, where's the realism and continuity? I don't want to say I hate it because some people say that's their experience (?) , but I do
@@theawantikamishra also where is Rue getting money to buy drugs?, and don't let euphoria fool you, teens would NOT be casual about that kind of thing, if anything they'd be trying to actively hide it.
I refuse to watch euphoria after s1. There’s an overload of yelling and abuse. And even tho I know sex isn’t taboo, I think I’m still having to unlearn the shame behind sex. It’s just sooo overwhelming having to hear yelling and watch sex scenes every 5 seconds😭😭😭I think it’s also bc they’re playing teenagers, and they just keep showing everything. The show just triggered me so badly, that I was like “nahhh” I don’t think I want to watch anymore shows with SA either. Like I just can’t watch many things that add a bunch of triggers. I get trying to show awareness, but I do think euphoria executes it...maybe not poorly? But it’s just a LOT. I probably won’t watch grand army, for the fact it has SA topics. I’ll just get overwhelmed
personally i think joey was doing her best with the small understanding she had about racism and sexism and other social issues. i think because we’re watching these characters after we’ve already been through high school or from a second-person perspective, we can see exactly where they went wrong and judge them for it, but in the moment a lot of us would have acted similarly or know people who we don’t exactly hate, who act similarly
I watched the ending, like, five times. I didn't give a crap about the other characters. That last scene with Jayson made me cry every single time.
it was so powerful and seeing his grandfather look proud of him made me happy.
I started the show being actually surprised by how realistic it was,you can say whatever you want about how unlikable the characters are,but they are exactly the people I met in real life and decided to keep my distance from,they can have their own struggles and we can identify with them but they all make mistakes and it felt very real to me...that being said I'm glad you made this video because I literally couldn't finish it after the SA scene,it was way too triggering to me that I closed it and didn't look back,I'm but surprised Leila got worse though,she annoyed me so much
I really liked the show. It has to be the most realistic portrayal of hs I've ever seen. And the fact that it takes places in Brooklyn made it even better. 😌👌🏾
i really like the character of joey because you can actually see how superficial everything in her life was before the SA. i think one of the most impactful scenes is when she goes out for a run and sees her friends that assault her and she just has a full on panic attack, it’s like, she can’t even just go for a jog or dance or go to school anymore. it’s even more impactful BECAUSE you saw her performative activism and how careless she was about things before
Dom is the only one who deserves rights. I love her so much
U hit all the points with this one especially about ms laila she was concerning
absolutely sinister
She was weird and suspicious
I will say that as a member of GenZ, being unlikeable as a main character is important to embody 99% of us.
Please try Blood & Water it's a South African Netflix original. First of it's sorts for SA..coz we not really into teen dramas here, but that one is a good one.
“It just kinda seemed unfinished.” Idk if you know this but the was a cute little pandemic. I get the feeling that they got cut off by ms. Rona. Like they even mentioned the coronavirus situation in one of the later episodes so they were filming when this was a thing in our awareness and I feel like they probably just had to wrap it up when things got crazy. I’m not sure but that’s what it seemed like to me
I actually heard that it was shot in 2018-2019
@@kimberleywilliams7802 it was shot in may-september of 2019
@@dan1elisaac then how did they reference corona?
@@roxc453 maybe they added that audio in later?
@@kphoria1009 no there were scenes that showed news about covid. I think it was likely filmed late 2019-early 2020
Okay I feel like Jay wasn’t that bad of a character, I feel like we’ve all done something messed up in our life that we didn’t think through, jay honestly never meant to do anything to mess up dom or Owen. He felt bad bc he’s human I feel like they represented him well, if anyone with a good heart was in the same situation they would react the same way as jay
WHEN I TELL YOU I WAS WAITING ....
you ask i (try to) deliver
@@imuRgency yessss !!
I will say as someone who went to school in BK NYC ( literally not far from the fake location of this school) kids have called in bomb threats as senior pranks. It happens a min of once a year. Its so fucked up but atm everyone is so used to it and because we walk. over to the elementary school a few blocks away most people leave and go shopping.
Can the show just continue and focus only on Dom and her friends? They were the only characters that didn't annoy me beyond belief
I feel like if it weren't for the pandemic the ending would have been so much more satisfying
I would love to hear your thoughts on On My Block and Bridgerton for a future video!
This show hurt me like every teen show on Netflix
but then you find out he's actually "🌸💗🌷🧁👾🌸💗🌺❇️💮💗💖💟💞💖" i died 😂
😂😂😂😂
Is it a common consensus that people don't like this show? I enjoyed parts of it, especially how not 30 everyone seemed and how much it seems like it's set in actual modern highschool (though I'm 22 now so what do I know). Everything else I just chalked up to it being one of ~those~ teen drama shows. Especially how much you want to shake the characters who just don't get it.
I enjoyed the trigger warning for the SA that they put in the show (and was able to skip past it), but I found it weird that they didn't warn for every single flashback.
I was personally surprised how triggering I found the opening scene. I haven't been through it, and I'm Canadian, so I didn't think i had that baggage. Anything based on past events (Columbine) haven't affected me because it feels very fictional due to the time, but I didn't realise until watching this that we all really wondered if it would happen to us every day. So basically if any American is reading this and wondering, approach it with caution.
Edit: man, Dom and friends really carried this show. After hearing what you think of it, yeah, without their through line of friendship the rest would be worse.
"how not 30" LMAOOO but yess i think as far as realism goes it was definitely more accurate to the HS than most which is why maybe people dont like it because it be hitting a little too close to home
@@imuRgency My high school experience was nothing like this, and if this show is what every high schooler in America experience than...I'm concerned.
@@cookie1271 this ain't even the half of it here
This show was very deep. It shows the reality of students of color who aren’t privileged. Excited to see the next season
STOPPPP. I loved the ending. It definitely gave what was supposed to have been given for me.
shut up im so excited for this
Basicgorllllllll!!!!!🤭🤩
As soon as you described Syd and was like “he’s basics perfect” I just knew he was gonna be gay.
Idk if i actually liked this show, but i really like how real it is, i was expecting like "the good character and the villain" type of show but nope and i really appreciate thay
With Jay the best quote to describe him is: "The road to hell is paved with good intentions" - the bible lol
I think this is the most realistic portrayal of high school I've ever seen in a show. I actually loved every character except Leila obviously lol. Joey reminds me a lot of myself, but her activism is all social media based not a bad thing probably the only way she knows but yeah. I don't think her activism is performative she just has different ideas of right and wrong. Why was it wrong she took a knee if she also believes black lives matter? When she interfered with Dom she did what she felt was right but it wasn't, not all her fault cause the teacher was biased though. I loved Sids story because those microaggressions are real. He was finding himself and it was a literal fight. The representation of both cultures between Dom and Sid were awesome too. I loved the representation.
yeah I felt like Joey truly believes in the activism but she doesn't know yet how she actually has to behave in some situations, after all she's still just a teen and has much to learn
Because she doesn’t understand context
i feel like she’s ignorant in a way a LOT of white teen girls/even guys are, they mean well but haven’t been taught or had the opportunity to really learn, internalise and understand what exactly they’re preaching. still not okay i guess but i feel like she’s not as terrible as ppl think? idk
yeah i don’t think she’s as terrible as people make her out to be. she’s just a teenager trying to do what she can, but what she can do isn’t much
Agree 1000% on the ending... it just felt unfinished
5:23 I definitely wasn’t expecting this edit 😂
yesss I didn’t like any of the characters either! Dom was okay though
girl the way i been waiting on this
I really loved this show. It felt really realistic and I know that people didn't really like the characters or misogyny and racism, I feel like that's the point of the show. It in some way shows people's actual struggles in life; the casual racist remarks people face, the narcissistic behaviours people show, the way people preach about activism but aren't willing to call out the people close to them, etc. It just shows what happens in real life and if you guys want a more in depth kind of review you can watch Tee Noir's review on this, it's really good.
Yeah I hate how people assume that just because a show/movie portrays racism or misogyny that means they’re pro-racism like no they’re just trying to show it. the same thing happened in ginny and georgia
leila sent the bomb threat so that the drama performance she wasn't in wouldn't go ahead... not because she wanted to get back with her bsf. anytime she wasn't the centre of attention she had to ruin it
It was too real that was the problem, in the times we are living in we yearn for fantasy. That's why Euphoria is one of the most watched. It's treated more like a dream/nightmare of life. It has some realistic story lines but they are brought to extremes that would never happen and are pure entertainment. It was good timing for Euphoria. Grand Army might have worked way more in the late 90's early 2000's, when a lot more shows like that were on.
comment challenge 🤪: i made a mistake somewhere in the video... first to comment the time stamp and what it was gets a heart
8:20
8:19 you forgot to put whatever it was above your hands LOL
yeah I think it gonna be his face matching up with the sound that you hear at that time
I definitely agree with the ending I was so confused with Joey dancing at the end and I understand Jayson point but like you said it was the worst cliff hanger
I AM SOO ANGRY THEY CANCELLED THE SHOW, I WANTED TO SEE JOEY GET JUSTICE
I really loved it, I understand not liking the characters but the show represent high schoolers really well and makes a great job showing them as real persons
Doms back must be hurting from carrying the whole damn show
I feel u but tbh this show is the most accurate representation of highschool tv show that I have seen at least
"Bamboozlement" is the most perfect word here! 🤣
I liked it’s realism and I think it had a lot of room to grow and improve. It’s a shame it got cancelled, I wanted to see what they would do with season 2. It sucks to hear about the black/POC writers, why am I not surprised?
Dom's my favorite character. so relatable to me working almost full time while studying and dreaming of getting into some good college.
in this house we love and stan john ellis
I fully understand why leila was put up for adoption
If you want a funnier take on hs I definitely recommend watching American Vandal. Definitely had me rolling😂
I thought it was like fiction the first episode when all that went down I was like guess I was wrong. 😂
@@ummm2176 the show is fiction.
@@carelletsopmo9366 i think im thinking about another show then sry
This show made me so anxious and idek why. After I watched it I cried for like an hour.
As an Indian , I personally related to how the Indian family was portrayed..like it's very real.. the way Sid's dad came around only when he got into Harvard , it was like that for me too...indian parents will sell their souls for good grades lmao💔 and the micro agressions to Sid was too real...like it's always like that , white people act they're allies but then act like that (most of the time)
The show was very real to me and I think it was intentional for the show to make the characters unlikable and flawed
Too bad it got cancelled and now we won't see the complete character arcs
i was waiting for this after your critique of ginny and georgia!!
I actually found this show to be surprisingly decent and realistic for a Netflix highschool based show (Dom was my fav character). I also think it was pretty important to show off Joey's character and how much she changes... what happens to her is horrible and disgusting but it's interesting to see this show follow the trope of "destroying" a stereotypical white feminist (or just what media considers a strong female character) in some sort of sexual way... it's unfortunate, but that's a weird fetish for lots of people. However, I think they did that on purpose, even in the show they call Joey a "performative activist." Kind of to show off how some women really do see feminism through a narrow, single person viewpoint, I think. I wish they would change her viewpoint on feminism and performative activism though, not based on SA, but I guess it was also important to show that not everyone is your friend (referring to Joey's disgusting douchebag "friends"). ALSO, Leila was absolutely horrible, she was so hard to watch and I skipped most of her scenes. All the other characters were a little boring though IMO. Nothing stood out too much. Overall the show wasn't... bad I guess? it's interesting looking back on it.
I think all of the "problematic" parts were meant to be on purpose for example the casual racism and joeys performative activism. these parts show things that happen in real life and no one takes seriously
Most of the characters are so annoying but what i like about the show, it's that it is realistic.
can i just take a moment to say how much i truly enjoy your videos, thank you!! never stop
found your channel recently and ive been really enjoying it. your show commentaries are always super interesting (:
Welcome! Glad you enjoy it! :)
YOU FINALLY WATCHED IT 😩😩 (nd I see you with the sponsorship 😏)
my favorite character out of this show is just leilas friend
I just recently found your channel and I'm so glad I did I literally love your videos!!! I've been binging your channel lmfao
I actually think that what made the show so compelling was the fact that all the characters were somewhat flawed and not entirely likeable. I liked that it challenged us to think about causality and accountability. I think the fact that we weren’t so attached to any of the personalities made us more critical about their character arcs?
I love your videos and opinions so much. Your very well spoken 😂❤️
I only watched the first couple episodes (I stopped before the episode where Joey got assaulted) so I didn’t really watch all of joeys scenes, but I did like that she took a stand against the dress code and the female solidarity when they all took off their bras that day to support her
there was alot of misogyny and sexism throughout the show but that was there to bring light to the topics or atleast thats what they were trying to do but it came out all wrong and sloppy without actually addressing the misogyny, the creators just left it there and moved on to a different topic. Also i feel like jayson never really screwed owen over, it was owens idea to steal doms purse and he was the one to go inside her bag, even tho jay apologized alot to owen for it, it never was his fault. alsooo leila didnt send a threat because she wanted her bff back but she wanted to cancel the play because she screwed up her chance for the lead role more than once and if she cant be a part of the play than no one can. the whole season was pretty problematic but i want to watch the next season, most stories were left abruptly and every story wasnt remotely interconnected thats kid of why i want to watch the next season, this and to see character development because the base plot is good and the creators were trying to make a change by bringing up important taboo topics and grand army still has potential for a really good season 2 if they just fix the problematic parts and bring everyones story a little more interconnected.
i think the show made the white kids super micro-aggressive on purpose, because as much as they kept saying they weren’t racism they clearly were and you could see it. also it is very true that black and brown people are held to this super high standard by their parents and society at large
Been waiting for this since that story post, glad it’s here!
Hey ImuRgency. Great review! You should definitely watch the HBO show industry and review the show on your RUclips channel. The wildness is insane, but the intensity and emotions are so palpable in the moment. Definitely take a look at that show in its entirety. Have a nice day as well ImuRgency. 😃
Not me binging the whole season in a day just to watch this video 😭😂
i think the point of joey and her friends (up until episode 3) was to accurately portray white liberals in our time. i think they had a lot to handle from the first episode, so it would’ve been best if we just watched the characters deal with the fallout of the literal bomb threat rather than the hamfisted attempts we got at a suspenseful show. i think the sa scene was too much and wasn’t used really in good faith. i feel like we could’ve gotten to know (and maybe like) joey more before we were introduced to straight up trauma.
i 100% agree on the SA take. i actually really liked the show and the characters, i thought they got a really good mix of personalities and just ‘real’ ppl, but i cant rewatch it because of how heavily they went on Joey’s SA case. the scene, the aftermath, the confrontations, it’s good that it’s finally being addressed on TV more than a quick ‘u hurt me! >:(‘ kind of way, but it was very heavy and took up a lot of the season, there was no time to breathe or process what was going on.
It’s the sponsorships you’ve been getting for me 🙌🏾🙌🏾
BYE I LOVE THIS SHOW
Regarding the end I heard somewhere they had to suspend production around the time cuz you know COVID happened so maybe they had something more planned but couldn’t do it
that's what i thought too but then I thought it was weird because they actually referenced COVID in the show which made me think theyd end that way
Tee Noir did a video on this show and I knew not to check it out.
always stanning tee noir
I was saying the show sounded like a mess to me. Not Tee
@that dang otaku 👍🏾
sick to see your account growing dude!! congratulations, love your videos
I loved Grand Army
This is sooo true damn it. I just finished watching it and I’m speechless. You put my thoughts into words... and yeah the characters r really unlikeable. I thought it was really frustrating coz sometimes I feel sympathy 4 the characters but then they do really problematic things...
There were so many good points said in the comments wow that I kinda wish I made in my review . Joey definitely picked on Lelia while claiming to be a feminist and there were so many other issues I missed . Great review and comments
Me being from nyc This show is really how people in nyc really are as a teenager this a show if you from nyc you would love it