The FDA Has Banned NMN Supplements!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024
- The FDA has released a letter banning NMN supplement sales
Here are the links to the research papers referenced in the video:
www.naturalpro...
www.regulation...
www.metrobiote...
www.scientific...
xconomy.com/bo...
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
Donate towards my Rapamycin & Exercise clinical study: bit.ly/3QwugRx
✔️ Sign up for my monthly Longevity Newsletter: drstanfield.co...
✔️ Roadmap - Look Young & Feel Strong: drstanfield.co...
✔️ Twitter: / bradstanfieldmd
✔️ Patreon: / bradstanfieldmd
If you like this video please smash the thumbs up button, it really helps with the RUclips algorithm :-)
#NMN #Resveratrol #DavidSinclair
The links above are affiliate links, so I receive a small commission every time you use them to purchase a product. The content contained in this video, and its accompanying description, is not intended to replace viewers’ relationships with their own medical practitioner. Always speak with your doctor regarding the content of this channel, and especially before using any products, services, or devices discussed on this channel.
![Tee Grizzley - Detroit (Feat. 42 Dugg) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aeKfTtt0x14/mqdefault.jpg)
• Follow-up video here: ruclips.net/video/RdnGm2_odfA/видео.html
• Full FDA statement on NMN: www.regulations.gov/document/FDA-2022-S-0023-0051
• www.donotage.org/products | Use code BRAD for 10% off
Thanls so much Dr. Brad for the heads-up 💯👍
Is this just David Sinclair being greedy and trying to gain the system for his own benefit. Has anyone ever noticed if you look at David Sinclair lately he looks like a rogue mad scientist? He looks like a cartoon version of Underdogs evil arch memises? I think his obsession of Metformin is mainly because he is too lazy to reap the rewards of exercise......
Would it only be NMN being banned and not NR? I'm actually thinking of buying NR anyways when I reach my mid 30s
we can't blame and attributes every bad thing to David Sinclair..he is trying to address aging issues and trying to come up with solutions.sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't.don't run conspiracy theories around his work.no one wants to kill human beings intentionally.sometimes his theories might go wrong as it's the part of research.
How about Niacin ? Also banned ?
Love how the USA calls it "lobbying" instead of corruption lmao.
and that happens in your country too, if you're awake....
@@Simon-talks if you have honest politicians and journalists, you can limit it. Market forces and no demand from americans will make this continue, until you push your political class in numbers
Yeah that place is a joke in so many ways, that's why passing gun laws are so difficult - lobbying (bribery/corruption)
Lobbying is a word usually used with negative implications. It’s a specific corrupt behavior.
@@ronnie5329 what is an honest politician
If the fda doesn’t want you to have it that means that it works
The LAST thing that they want is for us to live longer and healthier. That’s one conclusion we can draw from the last 2 years. Corruption at its finest
Exactly
Straight to the point
Exactly what I was thinking...
Exactly ❤
It's weird that just because someone is researching stuff as a "drug" it becomes illegal to take as a supplement. WTF.
If it doesn't make sense, it's an excuse or manipulation tactic they use to control something. Which is take the supplement off the shelf for their benefit.
Thats how whole industry works. Imagen the government assume people are to dumb.
I think it makes sense if there's possibility of Ill effects. What I don't understand is why aren't they taking this same course of action with covid vaccines when it's clearly giving healthy young people blood clots and heart issues.
@@WarrantChen Sources? Where's the research that explicitly explores these correlations?
@@whotookthacookie I will delete my comment. But if you need evidence for everything without thinking for yourself then so be it. I don't hate vaccines. Vaccines are good, but approach can someitmes be wrong. Is all i am saying. I refrain from helping the community.
It’s a “drug” because it works, which means they want their ~4M$ in FDA application fees.
Thank you for exposing this. So sickening. Thank you so much for all you are doing for us out here.
NMN is highly unstable at room temperature, good regulations on the supplement would be beneficial as it may have detremental effects otherwise, comparing it to vitamin c as in the video does not make sense. To call this lobbying because the ingredient is studied as a drug is just ridiculous. What is wrong with studying a drug? Furthermore claiming that this is some sort of consipiracy of David Sinclair to ban competitors is not substantiated, a scientists should come with facts not conspiracies. Finally he claims this happens before, i can't recall resveratrol being banned/ or is it by definition wrong to sell your company? I liked stanfield, but honestly starting with personal attacks just makes him lose credibility
The FDA is funded by the pharmaceutical mafia, which now rules the world. No competition allowed.
@@CharGC123 and what does that have to do with David Sinclair?
It isn't lost. Oral NMN has to drop a phosphate molecule and become NR (nicotinamide riboside, niagen) before it can enter a cell anyway. NR is still available and won't be banned over-the-counter. After NR enters the cells, it picks up a phosphate molecule, and then converts to NAD. No problem.
@@jeffgilligan2004 NOPE - NR is
transposed to NMN - taken up becoming NAD+ - go back and review the biochem
Dr Brad, thanks so much for exposing the root of all this "lobbying". I used to have a lot of respect for Dr Sinclair, but this isn't good. Since you exposed him on the resveratrol scam I've hardly been seeing much about him and all of a sudden he came up with this again! What a man! Thanks for helping us to know his true colours.
I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
At the end of the day everyone wants to earn money or fame. Gone are they days when people especially scientists like Tesla wanted to work only for passion and love towards science
Well Sinclair is Jewish, but maybe that's got nothing to do with it.
@@germanicelt Yes, his being Jewish has nothing to do with this.
The Wellness Messiah did a video that countered Stansfield’s take on Resveratrol. It’s worth a look. It seems to me Dr Stanfield has a bit of a “personal” thing regarding Dr Sinclair. Also, DoNotAge, which Standsfield touts, markets Resveratrol. This is an emerging and constantly changing market. Let’s try to go with the flow of information without making it personal.
You are always genuinely looking out for out best interests, health, and our wallets. We appreciate you. Everyone please find some way to support this doc.
How is this genuine, the dude literally claims Sinclair is "running" the company while he s an advisor. To call this lobbying because the ingredient is studied as a drug is just ridiculous. What is wrong with studying a drug? Furthermore claiming that this is some sort of consipiracy of david sinclair to ban competitors is not substantiated, a scientists should come with facts not conspiracies. Finally he claims this happens before, i can't recall resveratrol being banned/ or is it by definition wrong to sell your company? I liked stanfield, but honestly his beef with Sinclair is getting ridiculous.
@@aaa-jd3in I respect your points here and I am sincere in this. Now you are braced for my big ''however''....... I am associated with 2 dozen faculty members. The faculty at Harvard has heard and seen enough of David's ways. I personally became inadvertently entangled within one of David's big lies and it dinged my credibility for awhile. David ''came a bit late to the the party'' when he belatedly figured out what everyone had already know since Dr Weil revealed you cannot derive benefits from taking resveratrol in supplements nor even from the richest of Pinot Noir wine. [[ but maybe from organic, never heated cranberries ]]. So David declared he had replaced all Resveratrol in his own personal diet with EVOOO [ THE EXTRA ''O'' indicated ''organic'' ]] . But then, 3-4 months later, he cleverly reverted back to unethically recommending supplementing w/ resveratrol in public forums just to ''save face'' so it would not make him look bad.
@@chuckbecker8735 Thank you for your reply, I agree on the Resveratrol story btw (don't know how well you know him in Harvard, I know in the biomedical field he did a lot of important and high quality studies, I think claiming he is a fraud because of controversy regarding a few papers would be an overexegaration, science imo is rejecting old findings with new) now as a person I agree he overexaggerates his claim. My problem is just that claiming he is part of some sort of conspiracy without actual prove is just disingenous. I respect Stanfield, and his efforts in previous videos, I just think he is way out of line on this one
@@aaa-jd3in Again, your points deserve an a or aa. David is a still a research rockstar and both you and I very much respect Dr Stanfield.
@@chuckbecker8735 agree, let's hope more clarity comes soon. Nobody has any benefit in this controversy. Thank you for your comments, it was very inisghtful
The more I learn about Sinclair the more I distrust him
He wants you to be healthy up to the day you suddenly die and stop working if you ask me. I think he is trying to solve what I will call "the retirement problem", which is to say that they don't want commoners living long enough to be an expense.
I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
My friend takes resveratrol and swears by it. He’s 40 and has a full head of hair. Perhaps it’s the No Kids haha but he really likes resverstrol
@@kenw1849 there's no solid evidence it works.
@@Cenot4ph it might be working though
So Dr Sinclair has founded a company to manufacture a proprietary variation of NMN and is now working to remove NMN from the market, so he can monopolies it with his proprietary version.
Seems that way
Your channel is what the internet should be all about. Valuable knowledge accessible to the world. Thank you!
Yes, I expected this and predicted, exactly, that Sinclair would be behind this so that he can file a patent and make a fortune.
I really can't stand that man. He's a real jerk.
he's only doing what many of these medical scientists do. driven by greed. you only have to look at how big pharma operates, not to mention the issues with the covid vaccine where docs everywhere jumped on the bandwagon as they were paid for each jab given to their patients.
remember how the barrington declaration was disparaged and silenced? all in the name of making huge profits off the back of untested covid vaccines.
Well, the same can be said about chromadex and NR, filing a patent for a natural compound.
I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
@@BITCOIN_TO_1OOOO0OOOOOOOOOOO They didn't ban NR they only patented their version
@@theancientsancients1769 the poster mentioned Sinclair getting a patent, that's what I was referring to
Man I am so sick of the shady culture surrounding this industry. Its all about the $$$ and not about peoples health and wellbeing.
Never was lol
Follow the money
I read that NAC is under similar situation, but that the FDA found a way to allow NAC supplements to be marketed & sold to US consumers despite it. So, now the NMN manufacturers and marketers are hoping for the same solution for NMN instead of a blanket ban.
Also, my appreciation for Dr David Sinclair has gone down a huge notch because of his company taking the dirty approach with MIB-626.
Regarding NAC, the FDA simply stated that they have the option to not enforce a ban, although they still hold that NAC is classified as a drug. It remains to be seen whether this will be the case with NMN, since MIB is lobbying to be the pharmaceutical supplier in the market place. There is a lot of money at stake for MIB and its shareholders ,including Sinclair. Wonder what his devoted and heretofore unquestioning fanbase will think of this...
@@C2C. I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
Sinclair uses botox and denies it. He is extremely deceptive.
Thanks to the FDA ... NAC was hard to get in the height of the Pandemic when it's ability to clear the lungs of mucus buildup would have been extremely beneficial grrr
@@theancientsancients1769 Too true... yet I still have a soft spot for him because his book was my intro to the modern longevity field. Arggh!
Thank you Dr Brad. Keep exposing that fraud. I do remember you comparing the number of clinical trials of NR vs NMN (the former vastly outnumbering the latter), and now it makes sense why Sinclair is shilling for NMN so much.
Anything to stop people taking good health into their own hands.
FDA be like: Pursuing good health does not lead to good health. Only Big Pharma can lead you to good health.
Rubbish.
Don’t give up on supplements. Diet and amino acids are a definite part of regimen that should be included in your anti aging. If you keep researching you will find many things that work and will never be banned !
Collagen is one of them
fasting is free & works the best ;)
@@VB-zx1yk in combo with of course
I've worked in the supplement business for years, since then, they've banned a dozen ingredients we constantly have to keep pulling stuff from the shelves.
Thanks for jumping on this so quickly, Brad. Very disconcerting that (a) the FDA would do this and (b) somehow Dr. Sinclair has influenced the decision. I'm perplexed about Sinclair -- I'm experiencing cognitive dissonance btwn his public persona and these issues re resveratrol and now NMN.
I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
@@theancientsancients1769 Well, should this Sinclair saga ever come to conclusive ending, you may be proven right. But it's inaccurate to say that he's been "written off by experts". Experts routinely support and engage with Sinclair. Just a few days ago, a prominent scientist at the esteemed Buck Institute interviewed him, and he routinely is sought out by scientists and doctors such as Andrew Huberman, PhD and Peter Attia, MD. I think there are complexities embedded in the Sinclair persona, and I hope the balance is positive.
Sinclair is a snake
He wants to make money. He uses botox and pretends he doesn't. The man is a snake.
@@gamblinguru33 We posted simultaneously lol
David Sinclair always focused on regular exercise, optimal diet, good quality sleep along with +-these supplements. Supplements are not mandatory
Yeah. He has given lectures on other healthy lifestyles.
I hope they didn't ban NMN. It appears it says β-NMN is banned because that is a polymorph being studied as a pharmacological.
no it says NMN look at the 1 minute timestamp not beta-nmn just NMN. "we conclude that NMN is excluded from the definition of a dietary supplement"
Oh wow, this stuff must be really good then. I'm gonna try it now. Thanks FDA!
Cheers Dr Brad, this is exactly why I never jumped on the band wagon and will continue to do what I've been doing for a very long time which is great diet, exercise, etc
FDA needs to be stopped or banned 😊
Bozo.
No. Don’t the baby out with the bath water.
I agree....
@@edguyrocks5865 Don't be silly.
This is concerning, but (at this time) NMN is still being sold. For example, all of the usual good and bad sellers on Amazon (U.S.) are still advertising it. There may be a closing window of time though for people who want to buy it.
They will take it down soon.
Thanks for the heads up. I just placed a one-year supply order. I never want to be without this again. I know that you didn't notice a difference, but I have muscle dystonia, so I seem to "go through " far more ATP than most people, and MNM has been a lifesaver for me. I don't get worn out halfway through the day anymore. It doesn't matter that it doesn't measurably raise NAD plus levels in muscle tissue. It seems to just make ENOUGH available when it's needed so I don't run out of steam like a little wind-down toy.
And yes, resveratrol is trash.
I totally agree with you. I do not trust FDA, while I am work as a consultant physician.
Well reversatrol is good if taken in doses no higher than 500 mg…. I suspect that the same will happen with Fisetin…..
@@auriellenazro2516 I just started a resveratrol supplement a little over one month ago taking 500 mg per day. I’m new to all of this still. Should I not be taking this daily?
Try plain niacin 5X per day. Keeps cellular NAD levels topped-up for pennies. Don't forget glycine/glutamine/NAC also (for ALL reasons, not only NAD).
@@alan2102X I read the book Niacin - The Real Story. It is about high dose niacin supplementation. I've also read at least one study showing that niacin increases NAD. Glycine and NAC are good too. I have to look into glutamine. 5X a day" What dose do you feel is beneficial for NAD? Why 5 times? Keeping the levels up?
What a shame... I bought so much of it for my parents.
Thank you dr.Brad.. respect 🙏
David Sinclair clearly pulling some sort of scam
dodgy as fuck that guy.
I lost interest in him when he trashed meat
@@IvorMektin1701 well i guess that's reason enough to lose interest in someone. of course there are other reasons to do with his character also 🤣🤣
@@MixtrisUFOimages
Ever seen a sane vegan? Me neither
@@IvorMektin1701 and endorsed Visor
Have to say I have been taking NMN for over a year & noticed no change at all.
*They are NOT our friend anymore... for years*
They were founded by big pharm to promote big pharm agenda and knock herbs and supplements out of the market. Then they make a patent medicine like metformin from those same herbs and throw people like royal rife (the discoverer) in jail for using the herbs.
I get the feeling they are afraid of the public having access to life extension supplements. We get NMN naturally in our food, so concentrating NMN is really no different no concentrating vitamin C.
The problem is it doesn't make use young again. We need a supplement to make us young again.
it's also anti-cancer, where the health industry profit most from (chemo etc)
Complete shame on David Sinclair, thank you for covering this news!
Such great advice, Brad. And so sad/angering to watch the greed game being played by a respected scientist.
People with money should stock up lol
Yes, like some others I saw this coming. Thanks for everything you are doing.
Thank you for the timely update and for pointing out the connection between the resveratrol debacle and NMN.
wow thanks alot for doing this and going all the way to bottom with this
The bottom being the Sinclair residence.
Well in Europe NMN is considered a chemical for research purposes only and you are still able to buy it without issues.
I get my NMN from a US based supplier they still list it on their website no changes. Many new studies have demonstrated benefits to NMN lately.
i stopped NMN. It's just too expensive. Instead, I gave up alcohol and cones, completely. Figured if I wanted a magic anti-ageing pill then I'd start at the number one killa ageing cause in my life. And wow, no pill can induce this feeling.
I take NMN from Do Not Age and I think it’s helpful.
Thank you David Sinclair.
I wonder how this ban would affect products from other countries? I get my supplies mostly from Australia and England and I am not in the US.
I like how the FDA just openly admitted that the definition of a supplement or prescription and thus control or non-control is directly related to the commercial interests of those seeking FDA branding. Government does not advance science.
I stopped taking NMN and a host of other "anti-aging" supplements, when I saw/felt no difference after 3 months. If anything, I felt worse. Now stick to quality diet, exercice, high quality Multivitamins, fish oil, olive oil & lemon juice.
As I am not in US, I hope, europe wont be affected
I can't find any online source that has stopped selling NMN yet. I guess we should load up.
Can you recommend any trusted NMN vendors?
Vitamin B13 orotic acid and vitamin B3 could make the change due to there action to the NAD+ Pathway . Keep going !
It's a crucial supplement for heart disease
But at the moment, the companies that sell NMN in the U.S. are still selling it. Is there going to be a time in the next few months when they will have to stop new production and only sell off their existing stock?
The FDA considers that the NMN is not just a dietary supplement but an active molecule currently investigated as a pharmaceutical drug. I see this as a positive for the NMN. It does work well enough to be considered a drug.
And as other commenters have already said, here we are talking about the B-NMN. Not the NMN
Literally two days before this I came across Greg doucettes go2 Max which has NMN in it. Purchased it but I'm still waiting for it lol.
If the FDA is against it.... is good for you!!! ....AND VICE-VERSA.
Dr. Brad, thank you so very much for informing us of all these new developments related to NMN. I am beginning to have doubts in the genuineness of Dr. Sinclair. I think we all need to dig much deeper into these issues and find out what is really going on with Dr. Sinclair.
Oy vey!
This is on brand for David Sinclair. He’s now moving into endgame that ends up with him making bag and everyone else holding it.
Shocking. Gov't health care is a racket.
absofuckinglutely including private healthcare. all in it for the money
I just found out that you are actually right! exercise is the BETTER bet!!
David Sinclair appears to be a better business person than a scientist
Possibly an even better scam artist 🤷♂️
Is there a difference between B-NMN and NMN? Or are they the same? Maybe B-MNM is banned, but not NMN?
Ive been taking NMN+REV for several months and I notice that in here we are discussing about B-NMN WHICH IS : MIB-626
David Sinclair wants to corner the market
Thank you so much for summarizing this issue so concisely. I always appreciate your supplement news. Personally, I don't take NMN or NR because the quantities found in supplements were too high and put my body in a demethylized state. On a separate note, have what are your thoughts on a supplement called Epicathechin? Does it live up to the hype? Thanks again!
Did you ever try adding TMG?
Take 500mg TMG daily.
How did you determine that you were demethylised?
Are you talking about EGCG from green tea?
@@Fomites Homocysteine test.
I suspected this was coming when Sinclair would say he was involved in commercial endeavors but never be more specific.
Brad, thanks for this video. What do you think of this brand new study regarding NR and cancer? Maybe you can do a video on this paper: Reference: “A bioluminescent-based probe for in vivo non-invasive monitoring of nicotinamide riboside uptake reveals a link between metastasis and NAD+ metabolism” by Tamara Maric, Arkadiy Bazhin, Pavlo Khodakivskyi, Georgy Mikhaylov, Ekaterina Solodnikova, Aleksey Yevtodiyenko, Greta Maria Paola Giordano Attianese, George Coukos, Melita Irving, Magali Joffraud, Carles Cantó and Elena Goun, 29 October 2022, Biosensors and Bioelectronics. I saw an article on scitechdaily headline: "Warning: Popular Vitamin Supplement Causes Cancer Risk and Brain Metastasis"
Fasting also increases NAD+, and regular niacin probably works just as well as nmn, it just doesn't have anyone promoting it. There are studies of niacin improving grip strength in the elderly just as much as nmn does, which is a big indicator because they did not exercise and this is a big marker of aging.
yup. niacin is ok as long as you take a small dose. anything above 500mg can potentially be problematic. although i hear some people take as much as 3 g of it.
@@MixtrisUFOimages the older you get the less you can take..I started having issues with things like high intraocular pressure etc among other alarming things. So i switched to NMN. I dont take as much as most people do like 1g or whatever more like 500mg ish as far as what it does it helps with things but it doesn't do a lot of the stuff many people claim it does. Anyhow I wonder if sinclair will try to go after supplies in other countries or he will be content with just the USA. (lets see what he does.. slimey little bugger that he is ...)
@@Pixel-junkies wow! i was getting the intraocular pressure too when i began taking at 500mg so i reduced to 100mg and only take once or twice a week. most of the time i forget to take it so on average i probably take 3- 4 times a month
what other things did you experience on it?
I can see why its banned. you can easily get niacinamide in the UK. Niacin is difficult to get hold of. luckily one online shop is the only one i know in the uk that sells it
Plain old exercise boosts NAD levels in senior citizens similar to that of college age people in at least one study. I am not sure, but I think that there was a second study with similar results. My guess is most people do not need NAD boosters if they exercise frequently. My guess is that people have been misled on NAD boosting supplements.
@@jackbuaer3828 You can't exercise much when elderly and it probably boosts it mainly in the muscle
If sinclair created a proprietary form of nmn why did conspired to remove nmn as a dietary supplement? Please explain
So he wants the market all to himself with a "proprietary" version. I always thought that he was a bit shady, which is not based on his research or any specific facts about his work, but his kinda squeamish behaviour and body language in interviews, it's like he's checking if he can get away with a statement, it's hard to describe, but it always bugged me. Thank you for clarifying this, it helps a lot.
Thanks for your clear and concise analysis! This channel really is a fountain of up-to-date knowledge.
I am curious whether this changes your view on NR? As things stand today, would you still add it to your regimen at 45?
Search for a recent paper on how NR has been found to accelerate cancer growth
@@NihilisticAnarchist jerk
Well, thanks for that Dr. Sinclair. You convince me to jump on the NMN bandwagon and now your self serving interests (at least the co. you co founded) may stop me from purchasing NMN. I'll have to see if it will be also banned here in Canada.
Definitely a slick salesman. Devious too.
Defund Dr.Sinclar
I’d like to hear about Sinclair’s statement on this. Along with NMN being sold on Amazon, so many faulty products on there. NMN over time turns into nicotinamide which is an unstable version of NMN and actually turns off sirtuins which can lead to accelerated aging…
the big pharma cartel(who owns and runs the "FDA") makes sure to ban anything that works, so that they can make it as a "drug" and sell it for billions.....
If you want to buy NMN buy from do not age
I'm happy with my humble niacin.
@@coronaviruslivestream6821 yeah, that’s a good source. Also Renue by Science is quite good. They offer Lipo products hence their NMN is Liposomal and the best one I’ve tried thus far…
I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
Must be of benefit...and drug companies want to monetize it.
Or... maybe it has tremendous efficacy to some illness, and as usual... pharma wants to corner the market on treatment.
Not sure what everyone is using in terms of a brand, and I thought I share my experiences with NMN supplements. I have been using NMN for about 11 months, I am a 68-year-old male and I have tried over 20 different brands. The only one that seems to work for me personally is Probase Nutrition NMN Powder, simply because they are a well-known California brand, and I had their NMN independently tested for purity and impurities. Theirs came in at 99.89% purity and had zero lead in it. It seems some people on here have used Probase (the brand) NMN as well and they seem to be happy as well. Hope this helps!
Thank You for this honest info! So much appreciated always!
Thanks for the update Brad. What about NR supplements?
Will they be affected by this decision?
Not affected and I don't think NR will be affected in the future.
NR Won't be affected as it had solid dietary supplements research ! NMN in most countries is not even recognised as a dietary supplement
Chromadex’s Tru Niagen (NR) is FDA approved. It won’t be affected.
And why does Sinclair's face look all shot up with filler? He's starting to look like he's from another planet.
Because it is all shot up with filler.
Thank you for your research. I would never have known this.
Poor ethics by Dr Sinclair, indeed. Very disappointing, and this repeats a pattern that you had already highlighted.
That must mean it works.
It means it does something at least…
Same happened with NAC, when they discovered it was very useful for producing glutathione and fight cvd. 😅
It would be more accurate to say, that it means it is the interest of Sinclair to be the exclusive profucer of a supplement he hyped. I am still looking for the human data convincing me of its efficacy.
It works in some specific condition, but not in the longevity.
We don't have convincing evident that it can prolong the lifespan neither in mice (ITP) nor human.
the big pharma cartel(who owns and runs the "FDA") makes sure to ban anything that works, so that they can make it as a "drug" and sell it for billions.....
Thank you Brad. That’s why we subscribe to your RUclips channel and support you on Patreon. Not a good day for the longevity community.
So As you said, I was shock to get an E mail from Revue by Science company saying that UK & Europe stores stopped Supplying NMN.What about Resveratrol I used to get every other day.
How shall we get now no idea.
Any feedbacks will be helpful 🙏😔 Thanks, I'm in a shock🤯
It seems that greedy business people always try and lobby for themselves rather than what is best for the people they are often making money from. Thanks for the video and info. I am taking NR, but was thinking about NMN. Probably won't have that option now, which is fine. I do twenty to thirty things a day for my healthspan...
your posts and data always have been beneficial for me in terms of health, interest and knowledge, thanks for what you have done
But doesn’t the FDA only effect the United States? Most NMN is made in China.
I have seen you leave a comment on seeky science show's recent podcast on NMN and NR with Charles Brenner. Does that interview change your position on importance of NMN/NR relative to niacin? Any update on your current take on NMN/NR would be great.
FDA says is not good for me? I'm stockpiling :) Best recomendation ever 😘
Sounds like NR and Niacin both provide similar benefits so people still have options.
What?! Amazon still has NMN available on their app/website.
It's all over the internet. Ebay has over 800 hits for NMN.
Not for long. This is FDA overreach... but on the bright side, NR has a LOT more human trial data.
Even if NMN has no health benefits there is still the placebo effect that people think they're getting younger and now it's being taken away. I personally will be taking more parsley flakes to lower my CD-38 and be taking in the future NR. Thanks for this surprising information.
If taking NR look into NR6 which has its co factors sold by Xtend life
+apigenin from dried parsley + niacin+ nicotinamide+ tmg+ d ribose for nad boosting
My placebo effect is that at 64 I am now working out 6 days a week. I’ll take it.
Interestingly there is a new study by University of Missouri-Columbia on NR, suggesting a cancer link. Can't link it on YT but search for " Popular dietary supplement causes cancer risk, brain metastasis, study suggests"
It’s a little ironic that was published 2-3 days after the NMN ban. Something smells stinky.
The thing is, the mice in that study were already programmed to get breast cancer, and even the control group mice who weren’t fed NR still got cancer.
My guess is Big Pharma is just trying to keep people frail and sick so more people use their shit.
@@7TheWhiteWolf It was done by Goun at University of Missouri, with co authors in the EU. I'm not so sure "big pharma" have much of a barrow to push here, big pharma make more money of you live longer.
Im using Niacin via the Enduracin wax release formula for both cholesterol effects and juicing the NAD+ cycle. I take 1000mg a day (sometimes 2000mg).
I take NR rather than NMN anyway
Dr. Brad, what is your take on the efficacy of taking a high dose of (the cheaper) Niacin versus (the much more expensive) NR?
100mg to 150mg Nicotinic Acid I take daily and it has reduced my cholesterol levels significantly. Dr Brad takes daily 100mg of that he said in many videos after stopping NMN
Appreciate the heads up, thanks Brad!
sirt1 is activated by LIGHT fluorescent light, maybee we should give light as a medicine to people to extend lifespan ;)
NMN will Potentially be approved as a drug instead of a supplement. Wait and see.
This process could take years
What about Nicotinamide Riboside NR?
has FDA certification as a supplement, so can be sold and marketed as a supplement
@@DrBradStanfield 🥇⚡👌🙂 thank you
Thank you for this important work, Dr. Stanfield!
What gives government the right to tell me and my doctor what I can or cannot take?
There's a study published in Neuroscience News for Nov. 11 2022 suggesting that NR has been implicated in higher rates of brain cancer and metastasis. Dr. Stanfield, what do you think of this study and it's conclusions? I enjoy how you review recent studies and comment on their relative merits. Thank you!
I read and I am concerned about this also...😳any opinion about this🥺
It have been earlier studies that also say this. But in all this studies they feed isokated cancer cells in a dish and some forms of cancer grow faster with NR. The conclusion is. If you have cancer ther is a risk with taking NR. Other studies say that NR inhibit cancer grows by boosting the body so it can defeat cancer easily. So it depends on what cancer the person has. It the person do not have cancer it looks like the data suggest that NR lower risk of cancer.
Wow! Can't say I am totally shocked but it is still absolutely outrageous.
I was warning of Sinclair since 2006! Newbies in this industry only hyped him who are unaware of his past when he was written off by experts
It is merely applying the law by banning NMN.
@@theancientsancients1769 dude
Me neither, after all he is Jewish!
Similar thing happened with NAC and it’s still on the shelves of stores and on the internet for sale everywhere. Nice post but a little over alarmist-this is Brad’s way of getting clicks
Thank you for shedding light on this topic.
Dr Brad you would do anything for clickbait, and all your followers are totally misinformed by you, NMN has not been banned by the FDA the pharmaceutical drug that us MI26 is being developed as a drug therefore cannot be sold as a supplement just like any other drug like metformin. Also Sinclairs company are showing great results so far with this NAD booster and he is trying to make a difference in this world, stop the hating and state the fact
Agreed, sadly most of the posters here don't understand the difference between someone who pretends to understand the science and is desperately looking to make himself a Social Influencer and someone who is actually in the field with over 60 patients and 200 published articles in scientific journals.
I think Dr Brad is amazing & he does a great job as a Med science communicator. Unfortunately, he cant keep his cool on Sinclair. Most likely due that he was personally dissed and demeaned by Sinclair himself.
@@ballapalleballe I am unaware that Sinclair even knows he exists, David Sinclair is busy doing actual science and has no time to debate with people like Brad who are just looking to make a name for themselves. You see Brad there is like a movie critic, Movie critics are people who don't have the talent to actually produce a movie they simply point out the negatives of the movie as they see it. The Steven Spielbergs and James Camerons of the world aren't going to personally address the movie critics or even acknowledge they exist, they are too busy producing movies. David Sinclair doesn't know I exist, but I am certainly not going to make a RUclips video telling everyone what a greedy SOB he is. I appreciate the insights that he gives me into what is actually taking place in the labs today and that he takes time to do interviews and blogs on the subject matter.
If this is indeed the case, this seems to be an appalling action by David Sinclair. If he has genuinely screwed the market for his own gain, everyone should boycott him.
This is how pharma works across the board. It's all about money
This is all an over reaction