No one sounds sub-par singing this song. Every Jenna I've heard and seen has just blown it out of the water, yet doesn't replicate the others. They bring something unique each time, which is why I love hearing their interpretations
Yes! I actually based one of my characters on her 'look' in something I'm writing because I can't get over how gorgeous and personable she is! I never want to say anything so I don't sound too creepy though (Love you Hannah, I promise she's a good character!).
Every single person who has played Jenna on Broadway has absolutely blown me away and I have always loved Katherine’s take on She Used to Be Mine. So powerful and broken at the same time
If you haven't yet, please listen to Alison Luff's version of this song. It's truly something special. ALSO the version done by THUNK a cappella is incredible and WILL make you cry.
Alison Luff's She used to be mine is amazing! I feel like she approaches the song in a very different way than most singers do and it's so enjoyable to watch.
I was rewatching the ben platt and sara bareillles episode of carpool karaoke, I couldn’t stop thinking that you should watch it if you haven’t already! It’s amazing, just the two of them singing there hearts out 👌🏻🙌🏻
please please please react to shoshana bean’s version of this song, you won’t regret it! she is amazing, it’s so raw and beautiful. her vocals are insane and you can really feel jenna’s emotions. also the riffs are *flawless* ! i’m seeing shoshana in concert in december and i’m very very excited! edit: we didn’t get to see it, i cried for months. BUT STILL REACT TO HER! :)
Is Make It Rain the one where she has a bunch of instruments behind her and there's like a fog machine? Or maybe I just think there is because she is MAGICAL and her voice is amazing??
I've been following Katharine since that 5th season of American Idol. Was part of a small online community back then that cheered her on and, well, adored her. Kat Pack!
hello Hannah! I think you'll cry to Alison Luff's rendition of this song. it's in Broadwaycom as well. she also played Jenna in Waitress. I adore Katharine but I think there's just too much riffs that the emotions start to get kinda lost. thnx!
I would love for you to react to Found/Tonight (DEH/Hamilton crossover) or You Outta Know (Jagged Little Pill). Thanks for all you do! 💕 EDIT: Thanks for the likes! Hopefully Hannah will see this!
I started watching the flash only a while back and I keep on hearing about the musical episode. But now u say Jeremy Jordan? JEREMY JORDAN?!?!? Pls tell me which season and episode so I can binge just for Jeremy Jordan
@@anabestie It's season 3 episode 17, I think it's called duet, and the beginning/explanation of why is that happening is shown in supergirl season 2 at the end of episode 16
ahhh Hannah is literally always just a ray of sunshine during these cloudy times... thank you for being a positive light in the RUclips creator community!!
Yessss Lucie sings this song incredibly! I saw both her and Kat as Jenna and deffo preferred Lucie’s version! Although both are amazing and I cried to both 😂🥺
@@katiet8962 I’m hoping to see Lucie one the UK tour 🤞🏻 I was fortunate enough to see Sara Bareilles as Jenna in London last February and I cried so much when she sang this song 😭🥺
Yes, we are trying to sing this at home😅 You’re vocal reactions are honestly so helpful as someone who has never had access to to professional vocal coaching 🫶
I would be really interested to see Hannah dissect the differences in Taylor Swifts voice from the two Fearless albums. Since watching these videos, I’ve learned to recognize some differences there. I would love to see what she thinks. I love these videos. They’re becoming my comfort videos. Go Hannah!
It's not made of stone BUT Jeremy Jordan does perform another highly emotional song that'll make you wanna cry. His version of 'Losing My Mind' makes my heart hurt.
Ooooh I love her! You really need to watch her on Netflix! She's on a serie who is really fun, and she sings! I don't know the name of the show in English because in French, they changed it, for a new title... In english, idk why 🤷♀️. In French, the show is named "The Country-Sitter". And yeah, she's amazing in this!
I saw her as Jenna 5 weeks before it closed and it was INCREDIBLE. I loved her as Jenna so much!! If Waitress was still on Broadway, I would absolutely go see it again!!
Please listen/watch both Alison Luff and Jordin Sparks singing she used to be mine! They are my two favorite to have sang that song and Jordin Sparks is probably the best stunt casting ever that was actually good!
I just noticed that I have been watching a show called Scorpion. It's a show about geniouses and Katharine plays Paige, who is not a genious but she helps the others especially Walter become more human as he has an IQ of 157 but the Lowest EQ. Who else knows what I'm on about? Can't believe I only just recognised her. 💛🙏
I knew Katherine from when she did Scorpion, there is an episode where she sings a little bit and I thought her voice was beautiful, I knew she did Waitress but I’ve never heard it until now, this is amazing
Since American Idol, I’ve always admired Katharine’s control! And love how you broke down everything she did, Hannah! Amazing! (AND PS- LOVE YOUR NAILS- lol)
I love that every single time I watch a video and Hannah gets teary it is the exact moment I start getting teary. it makes me feel way better about the amount I cry at music
Continuing my campaign for you to react to 'Cell Block Tango' from the 2015 Miscast - your boys Jeremy Jordan and Ben Platt are joined by Joshua Henry, Christopher Fitzgerald, Leslie Odom Jr. & Walter Bobbie.
I saw her in Waitress in the West End (London) about 6 times and she was FANTASTIC every single time. She managed to sing this flawlessly while crying at the same time ! Madness !!
I just recorded my own version of this song the other day and no i need to take your tips to heart and do it again. It’s such an amazing song and Katherine is simply awesome in all things she does so this version is definitely my favorite
I actually just performed this song for my school the other night. I was practicing trying to use several of the things you mentioned on Jeremy Jordan’s version. It didn’t come out perfect but it was still incredibly fun to do and everyone loved it. All that to say thank you for your indirect help 🙏
Her melismas are so beautiful and clean. I aspire to this level of musicianship. Also I’ve learned so much from your vocal coach videos. I’m trained in musical theatre and fell into baroque choral music but had no idea of the terms and techniques I was using until I watched your coaching videos so THANK YOU!
Hannah, Your voice is beautiful! I thoroughly enjoyed the couple of times you sang, even if it was just a line, or a quick exercise. Beautiful! And I loved the song you critiqued. Love Katherine McPhee, and "She Used To Be Mine" is one of my favorite songs. Thank you for sharing!!!
You are spot on! Katharine's less is more delivery is what makes her version different from others. All the Jennas did an awesome job, but most focus on the bigger belting notes while Katharine has such a great balance between adding breath and belt to make it conversational but powerful. And the transition from chest to mix is so smooth. Thanks for reviewing this!
i was lucky enough to watch katherine perform this live and my word - i completely forgot there were hundreds of other people around me, she is PHENOMENAL
It is entirely accurate to assume that we are all trying to sing this song at home
Don't judge me LOL
Agreed.
XD
Absolutely lol
😂
Yes and when Im not belting it in my kitchen its on the lullaby rotation for my two baby girls.
No one sounds sub-par singing this song. Every Jenna I've heard and seen has just blown it out of the water, yet doesn't replicate the others. They bring something unique each time, which is why I love hearing their interpretations
YASSSSS THATS JUST THE FEELING
Allison Luff’s, Shoshana Bean’s, AND Jordan Sparks’ rendition of the song has me sobbing EVERY. SINGLE. TIME.
@@Caleb_Zurita SAME!!! I LIKE NICOLETTE ROBINSON'S VERSION ALSO (PROBABLY BECAUSE SHE'S MARRIED TO LESLIE ODOM, JR.)
@@GrinningLikeaDelicateJamesDean To Aaron Burr himself? Damn
Is it just me or is Hannah always gorgeous in all of her videos?
It's not just you
She's absolutely beautiful
Agreed
i second that.
Yes! I actually based one of my characters on her 'look' in something I'm writing because I can't get over how gorgeous and personable she is! I never want to say anything so I don't sound too creepy though (Love you Hannah, I promise she's a good character!).
@@darsynia not quite the same but i literally showed my hair colorist a screenshot of hannah to get my red :)
Hannah, we NEED some SMASH reactions from you! I mean, JEREMY JORDAN AND KATHARINE MCPHEE SINGING TOGETHER IN THE SECOND SEASON WAS EVERYTHING!!! ♥
And when Katherine McPhee and Megan Hilty sing That's Life, it's soooo good
Also let me be your star or don't forget me 😔 all so beautiful, how I miss that TV show
YESSSSS!!!!
Yes I’ve said smash before!! 🙏🏼
omg yes smash!!
Her voice is fragile, yet strong!
I get what u mean i love it !
Every time I hear this song, I ugly cry. But I don't regret crying.
me too , me too
@@Gleek702 ✋🏽😭
You *HAVE* to react to Shoshanas version of this!! My absolute favourite, soooo much emotion!
yesyesyesyesyes!!!!!! shoshana’s the best ever! i’m going to her concert in december :) her emotions and vocals are *insane*
YES YES YES!!!! Hannah YOU HAVE TOO. Sho is one of my faves Jennas.
YESSSS
Normaly i hate to compare singers, cause every singer has its own style... but: Shoshana"s version is absolut Incredible.
OMG YESS
Every single person who has played Jenna on Broadway has absolutely blown me away and I have always loved Katherine’s take on She Used to Be Mine. So powerful and broken at the same time
The advice you gave in this video was so helpful, Hannah! I kept pausing to sing to feel what you meant 😂
Me too! Hahah so helpful
If you haven't yet, please listen to Alison Luff's version of this song. It's truly something special. ALSO the version done by THUNK a cappella is incredible and WILL make you cry.
omg yes PLEASE react to the version by THUNK a cappella
My favorite versions are Jordan Sparks’, Alison Luff’s, and Shoshana’s!!
Shoshana's version is insane.
alison luff's is incredible
Listen to Lucie Jones, hers is insane! When I saw it we the audience gave a standing ovation for 5 minutes! It was breathtaking
Love this list, they're all good.Alison Luff is my top favorite.
Alison Luff’s is probably the angriest and saddest I have ever heard. Her technique is impeccable. I wish she got more accolades for it than she has
Allison Luff’s version of She Used to be Mine is by far my favourite. Her anger is just so relatable and heartbreaking.
Yes!! Saw her live! Incredible!!
Alison Luff's She used to be mine is amazing! I feel like she approaches the song in a very different way than most singers do and it's so enjoyable to watch.
YES! She sings so spitefully yet sad and lounging at the same time. It’s masterful and technically the most stellar in my opinion
I was rewatching the ben platt and sara bareillles episode of carpool karaoke, I couldn’t stop thinking that you should watch it if you haven’t already! It’s amazing, just the two of them singing there hearts out 👌🏻🙌🏻
please please please react to shoshana bean’s version of this song, you won’t regret it! she is amazing, it’s so raw and beautiful. her vocals are insane and you can really feel jenna’s emotions. also the riffs are *flawless* ! i’m seeing shoshana in concert in december and i’m very very excited!
edit: we didn’t get to see it, i cried for months. BUT STILL REACT TO HER! :)
Agree! Katherine's version is lovely, but Shoshana's rips me apart!
Please react to Shoshona Bean singing Make it Rain, or her singing Used to be Mine both are amazing!
Is Make It Rain the one where she has a bunch of instruments behind her and there's like a fog machine? Or maybe I just think there is because she is MAGICAL and her voice is amazing??
Oof that performance of make it rain makes me cry and gives me all the feels and chills. Sooooo good
Omg Make it Rain would be amazing!!!
Omg PLEASE, Make It Rain is INCREDIBLE
PLEASE give us an Alison Luff She Used to be Mine reaction video, i sit in awe every time i see it
I've been following Katharine since that 5th season of American Idol. Was part of a small online community back then that cheered her on and, well, adored her.
Kat Pack!
you should watch shoshana beans version and her and cynthia erivos duet cuz they are gorgeous together .
Exactly!!! I love Shoshana’s version
I will never stop recommending Shoshana. Absolutely stunning
Shoshana will definitely make her cry
Which duet? If you mean I Did Something Bad, I co-sign this suggestion.
@@sadie513 yh
hello Hannah! I think you'll cry to Alison Luff's rendition of this song. it's in Broadwaycom as well. she also played Jenna in Waitress. I adore Katharine but I think there's just too much riffs that the emotions start to get kinda lost. thnx!
Absolutely amazing, very soft yet very strong sounding. Shoshana’s version of this is amazing too!
Her Jenna is so vulnerable. I adore her
I would love for you to react to Found/Tonight (DEH/Hamilton crossover) or You Outta Know (Jagged Little Pill). Thanks for all you do! 💕
EDIT: Thanks for the likes! Hopefully Hannah will see this!
I would definitely love a Found/Tonight react!
Broadway.com has a Witch Medley that is so good!!! it's Poor Unfortunate Souls, Come Little Children, No Good Deed, and Last Midnight!!💘
I think you should react to the flash musical episode. There are really great performances and Jeremy Jordan is in it. :)
YES PLEASE
I started watching the flash only a while back and I keep on hearing about the musical episode. But now u say Jeremy Jordan? JEREMY JORDAN?!?!? Pls tell me which season and episode so I can binge just for Jeremy Jordan
@@anabestie It's season 3 episode 17, I think it's called duet, and the beginning/explanation of why is that happening is shown in supergirl season 2 at the end of episode 16
YESSS it's cringe af but has some good performances in it 😂
Oh YES please!! It's my favorite musical episode with the ouat one🥰
I saw this musical twice with Katharine McPhee and this song just blew me away! I cried the first time I listened to this song live. 💖💖💖
ahhh Hannah is literally always just a ray of sunshine during these cloudy times... thank you for being a positive light in the RUclips creator community!!
YAS!!! Back on the “She used to be mine” train ❤️.
Please react to Alison Luff’s version, it’s gave me shivers and I’m obsessed!
You should react to Lucie Jones singing this song. She was the West End Jenna after Kat. She’s fantastic and brings so much emotion to Jenna 🥺
Yessss Lucie sings this song incredibly! I saw both her and Kat as Jenna and deffo preferred Lucie’s version! Although both are amazing and I cried to both 😂🥺
@@katiet8962 I’m hoping to see Lucie one the UK tour 🤞🏻 I was fortunate enough to see Sara Bareilles as Jenna in London last February and I cried so much when she sang this song 😭🥺
My absolute favourite is Lucie Jones. Unbelievable vocal control.
I saw Katharine in London and cried👏🏽my👏🏽eyes👏🏽out👏🏽
SHOSHANA BEAN - SHE USED TO BE MINE! one of the most breathtaking and emotional performances i’ve EVER seen
Yes, we are trying to sing this at home😅 You’re vocal reactions are honestly so helpful as someone who has never had access to to professional vocal coaching 🫶
Because we are all trying to sing this song at home. Lol
At some point please react to Alison Luff’s version of this song (also from Broadwaycom). It’s my favorite version!
Yes! Please
I would be really interested to see Hannah dissect the differences in Taylor Swifts voice from the two Fearless albums. Since watching these videos, I’ve learned to recognize some differences there. I would love to see what she thinks.
I love these videos. They’re becoming my comfort videos. Go Hannah!
It's not made of stone BUT Jeremy Jordan does perform another highly emotional song that'll make you wanna cry. His version of 'Losing My Mind' makes my heart hurt.
Ooooh I love her! You really need to watch her on Netflix! She's on a serie who is really fun, and she sings! I don't know the name of the show in English because in French, they changed it, for a new title... In english, idk why 🤷♀️. In French, the show is named "The Country-Sitter".
And yeah, she's amazing in this!
Saw Katherine in London like 6 times . . . she NAILED it every time !
She was my Jenna the day before it closed on broadway. I miss her. I know everything that happened with her but you can’t Deny how talented she is.
I saw her as Jenna 5 weeks before it closed and it was INCREDIBLE. I loved her as Jenna so much!! If Waitress was still on Broadway, I would absolutely go see it again!!
Please listen/watch both Alison Luff and Jordin Sparks singing she used to be mine! They are my two favorite to have sang that song and Jordin Sparks is probably the best stunt casting ever that was actually good!
I just noticed that I have been watching a show called Scorpion. It's a show about geniouses and Katharine plays Paige, who is not a genious but she helps the others especially Walter become more human as he has an IQ of 157 but the Lowest EQ. Who else knows what I'm on about? Can't believe I only just recognised her. 💛🙏
Loved that show! Sad that it ended like it did though.
I love Scorpion ! Such a great show ! Btw Walter has an IQ of 197, not 157 😊
@@lizzydebrem Oh yeah whoops 197 Haha. Such a good show.
yes, we are all trying to sing this song.
Every time Jenna sings “She is lonely most of the time” I well up😢
I was so privilege to hear her preform this on broadway and i got absolute CHILLS! She was amazing!!
I knew Katherine from when she did Scorpion, there is an episode where she sings a little bit and I thought her voice was beautiful, I knew she did Waitress but I’ve never heard it until now, this is amazing
Your videos never fail to make me smile! 😘
Since American Idol, I’ve always admired Katharine’s control! And love how you broke down everything she did, Hannah! Amazing! (AND PS- LOVE YOUR NAILS- lol)
Could you react to MALINDA singing "when she loved me" or "never enough" (Greatest Showman) ? ✨💕
I love that every single time I watch a video and Hannah gets teary it is the exact moment I start getting teary. it makes me feel way better about the amount I cry at music
Day 4 of asking Hannah to react to the lovely Joshua Colley! :)
Omg I would LOVE that!!!😍👏🏼
I was in TEARS. Katharine McPhee is incredible and I really appreciated your comments on her technique!
Gosh, I must annoy my neighbours so much with that song!
Omggg please do the Jordin Sparks version of She Used to Be Mine 💙
Yes! That is one of my favorite versions!
@@nicoleheartscheer it's so good right?! 💙
How about reacting to songs from "Over the Moon"? Especially Ultraluminary and Hey Boy, as those are sung by the one the only goddess Phillipa Soo
Yes!!
💯💯💯
YESSS!! I have always loved Katherine, super happy to see this react!! 💜
Continuing my campaign for you to react to 'Cell Block Tango' from the 2015 Miscast - your boys Jeremy Jordan and Ben Platt are joined by Joshua Henry, Christopher Fitzgerald, Leslie Odom Jr. & Walter Bobbie.
I love this song so much
You definitely should listen to Smash songs from season 2 with her and Jeremy. Absolutely love these Songs.
i sing this song on repeat all the time! love Katherine McPhee QUEEN!!!!!!
Shoshana Bean’s version makes me feel SOOOOO much. Her emotional performance is breathtaking.
She is in the new netflix show comfort country , her character is super funny and cute , she also sing there and i'm super in love with her
Time to check out Shoushana Bean and Alison Luffs versions of this song. It’s only fair to listen to them all. 😊
Don’t worry, I try to and want to sing this at home. Great video, I’m happy that you reacted to this. 💕 I love you❤️❤️
Alison luff’s version is amazing!
I saw her in Waitress in the West End (London) about 6 times and she was FANTASTIC every single time. She managed to sing this flawlessly while crying at the same time ! Madness !!
She used to be mine by Shoshana Bean, best version of the song imo😍✨
I just recorded my own version of this song the other day and no i need to take your tips to heart and do it again.
It’s such an amazing song and Katherine is simply awesome in all things she does so this version is definitely my favorite
You need to react to olivia rodrigo performing Deja vu live!!! It came out today on mtv!!
I actually just performed this song for my school the other night. I was practicing trying to use several of the things you mentioned on Jeremy Jordan’s version. It didn’t come out perfect but it was still incredibly fun to do and everyone loved it. All that to say thank you for your indirect help 🙏
You should definitely react to even when/ the best part by Olivia Rodrigo and Joshua Bassett! It’s so good!❤️
i have been waiting for this one!!! love katherine so much !
You should definitely react to Sara Bareilles singing the same song at the Graham Norton show, that performance gives me chills
Yeeeees!!
Always singing this stuff at home, totally correct!
More Disney reactions! Or Voiceplay reactions! I don’t know a single theatre song! ❣️
Her melismas are so beautiful and clean. I aspire to this level of musicianship. Also I’ve learned so much from your vocal coach videos. I’m trained in musical theatre and fell into baroque choral music but had no idea of the terms and techniques I was using until I watched your coaching videos so THANK YOU!
you can do the rest of jennas singing it, there's shoshana bean, alison luff, jordin sparks
we're never done w she used to be mine
You should react to Liu Yifei singing reflection. She sings that sing beautifully. You have to hear it and react to it
I completely agree with you. No thought of technique on the stage. All emotion. Completely makes sense and I’m glad you brought that up! ♥️
Aaron LaVigne singing Gethsemane on Broadwaycom is SO GOOD.
Absolutely love this! Saw Katharine as Jenna on Broadway and she slayed it
Hannah have a life crisis over tea: 1:41
i love the vibes youre giving off in this video hannah, like watching tv with an old friend
Love Katherine! Her voice is incredible. You should react to SMASH. She is so good in that.
Hannah, Your voice is beautiful! I thoroughly enjoyed the couple of times you sang, even if it was just a line, or a quick exercise. Beautiful! And I loved the song you critiqued. Love Katherine McPhee, and "She Used To Be Mine" is one of my favorite songs. Thank you for sharing!!!
Can we get a SMASH reaction?! Because I know all of us want to watch more Jeremy Jordan
EVERYTHING ABOUT KATHERINE IS GORGEOUS AND HER SINGING IS ABSOLUTELY STUNNING!!!!!!
please oh my god please react to alison luff’s version
You are spot on! Katharine's less is more delivery is what makes her version different from others. All the Jennas did an awesome job, but most focus on the bigger belting notes while Katharine has such a great balance between adding breath and belt to make it conversational but powerful. And the transition from chest to mix is so smooth. Thanks for reviewing this!
Yes!! My ocs voice claim!!
I have been trying to learnt his song and your advice was really helpful. Thank you :)
Could you pleas finish the TINY DESK BTS video and I really suggest THE TRUTH UNTOLD BTS - live💜💜🥺
To be honest I really want to hear covers (of any songs) from Hannah. Her voice is so impressive.
IF KAT IS MAKING YOU CRY I DARE YOU TO WATCH ALISON LUFF
1:59 and I felt goosebumps 😭 the way Hannah smiled just a few seconds the song started melted my heart 💕
please react to Alison Luff's version of "She Used To Be Mine"!!!
I HAD to watch both this version and Jeremy Jordan's of this song again accompanied by Hannah's style of reaction
pleaaaaase react to Alison Luff's version, i think she's one of the best Jennas :3
I love katherine McPhee's voice so much
You should react to AURORA singing live, she is amazing! Love you.❤️❤️😍
i was lucky enough to watch katherine perform this live and my word - i completely forgot there were hundreds of other people around me, she is PHENOMENAL