The Canadian Government Might KILL My Channel (And Many Others) || SPEEDPAINT + COMMENTARY
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- Head to squarespace.co... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code duchesscelestia
Here's my art studio's website, if you want to see an example of the kind of thing you can build using Squarespace: royalstarships...
SIGN THE PETITION: action.openmed...
DIGITAL FIRST CANADA LETTERS: digitalfirstca...
MORE INFORMATION: openmedia.org/...
______________________
THRONE: throne.me/u/du...
PATREON: / duchesscelestia
KO-FI: ko-fi.com/cele...
DISCORD: / discord
STORE: www.etsy.com/c...
CARRD: duchesscelesti...
______________________
Music by Chillhop: chillhop.com/li...
Psalm Trees - bringmesun: / gyvus
L'Indécis - Fried Potatoes chll.to/43172c3a
![UNDERTALE PACIFIST ROUTE Ep. 1 [RUINS]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QRwJQluRBuE/mqdefault.jpg)
SIGN THE PETITION: action.openmedia.org/page/114150/petition/1?ea.tracking.id=tw
DIGITAL FIRST CANADA LETTERS: digitalfirstcanada.ca/bills/fix-c11/
MORE INFORMATION: openmedia.org/article/item/whats-wrong-with-bill-c-11-an-faq#How%20will%20Bill%20C-11%20affect%20the%20content%20I%20see?%C2%A0
I signed the petition before, let’s hope bill c-11 never gets through
It wouldn't let me sign the petition since I'm not Canadian, but I sent the letter. I really hope the bill does not pass in its current state.
@@pixiestyx if you're not Canadian, mind your own business! I don't want to be force fed American garbage by the Google corporate giant algorithm!
Hopefully more Canadians sign this petition. Knock on wood.
@@MrVincentTremblay Did you watch the video? This bill wouldn't affect only Canadians, and would set an awful precedent.
You can always guarantee that when they say "This law is not meant to do this", it *absolutely* WILL!
As an American, take with a grain of salt.
But even if this bill does pass in the Canadian government, RUclips is an American company. If RUclips doesn't comply, the worst thing that the Canadian government can do would be to block RUclips access to Canadians, which frankly I don't see them doing without massive backlash. That, plus we could see a rise in VPN usage by Canadians just so they can post vids as if they are from other places and avoid the CanCon bill.
Keep in mind that "block RUclips access to Canadians" also means "block PAYMENTS to Canadian RUclipsrs". There's no way in hell Google could get away with servicing Canadians that sidestep their own laws while still paying AdSense to them or taking payment for RUclips Red. That alone would constructively put them on Canadian soil.
@@SuperSmashDolls That's fair. But my main point is that even if this were to pass, I can't see RUclips changing their whole system just for Canada, more likely just pulling out at worst, or just ignoring the Canadian government and getting banned
Its all about those clicks
@@leonardo9259 aw yes one of the biggest strenghts and weakness of the overlords
The Canadian government will fine RUclips until they comply. Given alphabet's track record, I don't think they'll waste any time whatsoever in complying, to the point that I don't expect it will ever even come to a threat: they'll pre-emptively comply. The algorithm already has region specific flavors, so this will be pretty trivial for them to just add in a fresh dose of stupid that rearranges the Canadian recommendations. They don't actually have to change the entire system. I suspect RUclips's only real grievance with the suggested changes is more government oversight, not a deep caring for their customers. Especially since they themselves have made the move to promoting more "authoritative" content on the main page in certain countries.
Also: You can't force ppl to like something they don't care for. Ppl going to hate the thing that is being forced on them. It's simple.
Especially if the Canadian content in question they're being forced to watch ends up turning out to be half-baked, zero effort, and cringe in the absolute WORST way.
Plus it's likely going to DECREASE Canada's population & those who stay will likely become isolated from the rest of the world.
@@ExtremeWreck ok i doubt its gonna become isolated to that degree, but i can see just a lot of canadians (me included) hating our government lol
@@fivetopoint Clearly you haven't heard of how the Canadian government is desperately trying to make all Canadian content SPECIFICALLY about Canada & is further enforcing that rule all over the place. Trust me, James Somerton is suffering through this himself. You can't even be from the United States either because they'll just make it so that you can't do CRAP.
They'll DEFINITELY be going full on Jehovah's Witnesses levels of isolation soon enough.
@@confinedspiral9969 If it's THAT "in your face" though, then yeah people will be annoyed & want to just stop supporting Canadian RUclips channels outside of SomeOrdinaryGamers.
I'm a bit late on this, but wouldn't Québec be hit the most out of all of this? I don't wanna say the English part of Canada wouldn't be affected, but could you imagine the loss of viewers content creators form Québec would suffer? Not only that, we already don't have many videos in French that come from Québec, most of our watchlist are from France! FROM FRANCE! It's a bit ridiculous how they force everything to be French here for the preservation of the language, but now everything is gonna be in English on the RUclips or Tiktok. I don't know what to think of this. I live from RUclips, from watching kpop, documentaries, videogames playthrough... and all of that will change cause our government decided so?
Dear government,
Respectfully so, we ain't toddlers, please, we know what to watch and how to educate ourselves.
F*ck off with kindness,
An angry Québecer :v
Québec is not Canada. That bill C-11 would certainly reflect that.
"we know what to watch and how to educate ourselves"
That's exactly what Canada/USA/etc fear the most about the internet, and why they actively destroy or infiltrate any communities or sites that promote freedom of speech or freedom of thought.
I'm an American. I feel the same way about my own government. My current favorites are the way health insurance is mandated, and the way you're required to give the government money so THEY can save up for YOUR retirement. Dear American government, you are not my mother. You have no business forcing me to save my money for anything. You have no business forcing me to get health insurance when I'm young and healthy and have never had a major health problem and have every reason to think I don't need it. Get your hideous nose out of my business and go manage your own finances. Which, as if I needed more reasons to ignore your financial advice, are a dumpster fire.
SO in other words this bill is unintentionally going to, instead of properly promoting Canadian content, cause it to become suppressed because they don't actually understand what they are messing with. Yeah that tracks for government interactions. Even from the various explanations I have heard this sounds more like a bill that is going to cause Isolation more than anything else. Which is bad in almost any capacity, but also for business.
This is why the government shouldn’t interfere with the internet
And big business. Although it's kinda a circular relationship
Not entirely. "Sometimes" (aka all the time) when governments "interfere" with the internet it's for the greater good. The reason you don't find scammers, pedophiles, and any type of bad person you can think of on the internet *all* the time is because governments all over the world are working hard to make normal people and especially children safe on the internet (not to state the obvious, but hearing a case about one of those people once every other week in a crime and "exposing" channel after you look for it because you want to watch something instead of talking to another human being while you eat, that is not "all the time"). Sometimes they fail. Sometimes they succeed. Sometimes they punish, harm, or make things harder for innocent people like in this case. Sometimes the "harm" is caused by a misunderstanding, incorrect basis information, and yes sometimes it is even prompted completely and purely by monetary gain. My point is: the government should interfere in the internet all the time but within a limit of common sense, and privacy.
So we are going to allow Cp, black markets, piracy, pedos, hackers, bots, spam and other scums take over the internet? NO thanks
But they gonna, cause everythng is political.
@@dissonanceparadiddle on the contrary, they should intervene with big businesses and leave small ones alone
As a Canadian, this really scares me as I already quite enjoy RUclips, and I *really* don't want the algorithm more screwed then it already is.
Same.
Same youtube is all i have 😭😭
Same.. I'm A content creator and DEAR GOD.. I adore my channel, my friends.. I NEED IT.. ITS ALL MY LIFE REALLY IS..
Nice incel flag
@@strongestgamer2501 ?
i read the title as ‘The canadian government may kill me’ and was highly concerned for a second 0-0
LMAO
Same-
Ngl same
I thought so too for a second 💀
Well Canada has been euthanizing people. I wouldn’t call that health care.
I don’t actively look for Canadian content creators but I like finding them here on RUclips. And it happens largely thanks to the algorithm. I didn’t need the bill to do any of that work for me-and if I really wanted to look for more Canadian content creators here, I’d actively look for them.
But as it is, I like being able to see Canadians shine alongside non-Canadian content creators. It’s like knowing that we can be relevant and don’t need to present ourselves in a specific way just to be able to be seen. Part of this success, though, is due to our ability to learn from non-Canadian creators too. Limiting RUclips to only show Canadian content for Canadians makes it feel so insular… and that comes with its own potential issues.
And lastly, as a very small creator who struggles to make time for her channel between work and life responsibilities, the thought of this bill making me have to work even harder to get traction is depressing. I am just on my own, as with many other small creators, and so much goes into producing content and marketing it. Needing to spend additional time trying to figure out your statistics between 2 different theatres of RUclips? You’d need to do this as a full time job, and for many small creators like myself that’s not an option on the table yet. Even then, with this bottleneck in place it makes the risk to go RUclips full time even higher.
I really hope this bill doesn’t pass. And thank you for sharing, Celestia. It really helps educate people so we understand exactly what is happening, even if it may not be relevant to some.
This is making moving to the US more appealing
As someone who's literally never heard of you before, I'm glad you made this video, and signed the petition. Hope it helps.
Same lmao. This randomly showed up in my recommended.
Never seen your channel before but glad I saw your video talking about this.
This is, at least in part, showing up so randomly because RUclips and Google have been pushing anti-C11 content hard. This includes outright embedded banners from Google/RUclips themselves -- so there's no "it's just the algorithm" excuse, they've been intentionally manipulating what content is presented. That an enormous foreign corporation has so much influence over domestic politics, political viewpoints, and political outcomes is not really a good thing and is one of the things that, historically, Canadian content laws have at least helped to prevent.
While there certainly are (a lot of) issues with Canadian content laws in modern contexts, they're *not* wholly bad and the way Google has manipulated what's presented to align with their financial goals should probably concern people too.
@@milokiss8276 I just found it now
@@gracekim25 same
As an American who enjoys and loves your content, I so sorry that you and your fellow creators in Canada are dealing with this. I wish I could sign your petition link to help out, but I can't :(
Why can’t you?
@@Imjustkendall 'cause I'm a broke college student whose a citizen of American and not a citizen of Canada
@@ms.laceysaeke9721 oh excuse my dumbassery
@@Imjustkendall Yeah, no worries ^u^
You can still sign the petition even if you’re not Canadian! Celestia basically says this at 13:58.
I’m American myself, and I just thought I’d mention it. :)
As a German and subsequently certified "This video isn't available in your country"-PTSD patient, I can tell you with absolute certainty that RUclips will break before it bends to local law. We all like to curse at big companies for their self-interest and economy driven decision making, but this, fortunately, is a hill RUclips is willing to die on.
The algorithms and systems in place to promote content are designed for exactly one thing and one thing only: To maximise view time of videos that are advertiser friendly.
In other words, the entire platform is designed to generate revenue by suggesting stuff people are into enough to suffer through ads for.
Reframing the context of that statement: Any change to the algorithm is likely a massive cut in revenue, as now it is promoting content that does not generate money for RUclips.
Whatever happens with that law, one thing is for certain: RUclips will never fuck with the algorithm to satisfy a single country's laws, as no matter how big or small the country, the loss in revenue is likely larger than any fine they would have to pay for disregarding said law. What will happen is that RUclips will likely go to court over laws like this and bury the countries legislation in more work than any non-US lawyer is willing to take on. If there is one thing the USA is good at, it's making you regret challenging them.
Here's to hoping you are correct.
Can confirm still getting some Nam'flashbacks from the "This video isn't available in your country" time....
There's no hill to die on, a company is not there to challenge the government FOR your rights. Sure they are supposed to lobby for some of their interest but they are a company first. Capitalism should be no mystery by this point to people. People who expect youtube and others to fight for their rights is WHY people are learning they have to fight for them. Companies aren't supposed too, it's not the capitalist way. And if they did, you have to know it would be their rights first, then maybe yours... Relying on a business to defend anything but its bottom line is how you loose your rights one-by-one. RUclips serves over 5-Billion people, they can not possibly abide by or push for local law changes everywhere their streams flow.
I'm not confident RUclips would go to _court_ over it. If the bill does pass I think it's more likely RUclips will just leave Canada outright
This more of a censorship rather than promoting Canadian contents. Baby Fidel is butt hurt with the freedom convoy and envies the Communist Chinese control of information.
As a Canadian I *love* finding out that a video I’m enjoying was made by a Canadian, it’s just a fun li’ll moment of “oh hey thats where I’m from! :)”
But that only happens because I was ALREADY enjoying the video, and because *not every* video I see is made by a Canadian. If all I saw was Canadian content it wouldn’t be nearly as fun, not to mention that I think a big appeal of *online* content is that it’s not restricted in the same way physical content is. There are no borders online and I really like that I can randomly be recommended a video from Japan, or Peru, or Denmark. It’s really fun being able to see creators from other cultures and to get a glimpse of how they use the internet and what kind of media/art they’re making.
As a Canadian, yes it’s cool to see when something is made by a Canadian but I still prefer to watch what I want regardless on who made it. So thank you for saying this ❤
You said it better than I could. You know, I'd think this would be something that the Russian government would do. It's kind of sad seeing my country pull this kind of bullcrap.
you can still watch whatever you want, but canadian content must be prioritized in Canada. We support our own before it gets pushed out.
I hate living in Canada
@@MykalNines And what happens when people don't click it because they don't want to watch it? It gets recommended less globally because people aren't clicking it. Meaning, it would directly be a detriment to Canadian content creators. You didn't think this through, did you Captain Canuck?
@@GhostInThePepsi people will click it for the same reason that people pay to be at the top of the Google search. Laziness. It will give a better chance of exposure for Canadian content.
I’m a Canadian viewer, most of the music I listen to is from Finland, Sweden and Norway. Hardly anyone in Canada produces that kind of music as it’s not popular here. For context, I listen to extreme metal. Most metal record labels are from Nordic countries, hardly any are from Canada. I can only think of one Canadian who is in a death metal band. I find new bands through RUclips, occasionally a music video will pop up and I’ll check it out. Again, a majority of these bands are from Nordic countries. I know a few bands from Greece, Australia and Hungary but none from Canada. If this law passes, I will have a hard time finding new bands. I will also possibly miss out on new music videos or albums.
First 3 words are a big L
@@strongestgamer2501 I honestly have to agree with you. It would’ve been an even bigger L if I said what province too.
Oof, that'd be horrible to lose. I'm someone who really likes finding more obscure music that way too, though I don't live in Canada
@@wintershock I don’t even want to hear what province you are in, being in BC is a massive L. Literally got the two worse name merged together, “Bri’ish” “Columbia”
If you search for it you will find it -
Wow, think I'm screwed then since I'm a US citizen that lives in Canada. "Not Canadian enough; don't promote"
I think you did a good job explaining this bill. I agree that if it gets passed, then it opens up problems for other countries as they would feel validated to do the same.
Yeah, I think that’s the worse problem to be honest. People who aren’t from Canada but live there cannot post content, which in my opinion, is extremely xenophobic!
@@Adeerwithnotlogic Canada is more racist than any other country in the world.
L for being in a shit country
@@Adeerwithnotlogic sorry whats xenophobic mean?
@@fauxhuman0 Basically means intolerance to foreigners.
I may not be Canadian, but I’m definitely gonna bump this in the algorithm! This is important, globally-concerning shit that really shouldn’t be put in government hands, and I’m glad you’re informing people of it!
globaly concerning - where were your support when the EU passed article 13, that effected the Internet as a whole in Europe? none existend, so please
because in a business’s hands is so much better? like come on
Which hands are more appropriate?
"Bump this in the algorithm"? How do you do that? I've never heard of that
That’s because they haven’t done anything yet you don’t see how much power they gain form it also the eu is supposed to be about trade they should not have that kind of power
You are definitely a spreading more awareness than you think, this video showed up and I’ve never even seen your channel before! Thank you for teaching me about this because I had not heard about it
Also your channel ascetic paired with your voice is so relaxing and wholesome!!
Pair that with great art and that’s an amazing combo.
Side note after finishing the video this bill sounds like something a oppressive country like china or Korea would do. Definitely scary.
Also I couldn’t sign the petition from America it requires Canadian postal codes
If this bill gets pushed thru, and I hate to say it. The "Don't Recommend Channel" feature is going to get used a lot by me. I already have a hard enough time finding good stuff to watch as it is. If the CRTC is going make that even more difficult, then I simply don't know.
As a Canadian I'm becoming more and more appalled by current government(s) day by day.
Americans: first time?
This should be the first line in every government book: “the government doesn’t care about you.”
As a Canadian content creator myself, I completely agree. I don't want so many people to lose their channels because of the government (including my own). I love sharing stuff as a content creator all over social media, and this bill should NEVER be passed!
Did u sign the petition
L
Where is the petition
@@strongestgamer2501Is that all you can say?
@@Spoopy01In the pinned comment
A LOT of creators live in Canada. Just the nature of the regulation tells me it's more censoring, but extra steps. I get trying to promote country-specific creators to generate more success within that country but it could definitely be done better. Not only could this kill current small creators like you said, but hurts up-and-coming creators just for being citizens where things are proposing being MORE flawed. I see lots of hoop-jumping and luck being needed more than what we already have
They deserve how their government tackles medical care
@@strongestgamer2501 what does this mean
@@Envy_May Canadians get free healthcare, but it's only free because we pay taxes for it.
@@Creatorsan no i know that's the same here but what was this person saying
@@Creatorsan That's literally just every public healthcare system, and even then it seems like the government is just doing whatever it can to just cut healthcare funding either way (and from the looks of things, it feels like loosening the already infamously loose euthanasia restrictions might be some convenient excuse to do just that). I'd still rather put up with them than deal with the inherent greed seen in privatized healthcare, but obviously it's not an excuse to be complacent.
Nope, I work in the telecom industry in Canada, it's already shitty enough how we don't have enough competition for it here, but it's also the fact that the CRTC is ran like a business and is not sided for the ppl living here no matter how much the say they are, they really are not. So many canadaians don't realize the power CRTC really have over our technology here in Canada and if this bill passes, well we just don't really know what they'll do or how far they'll go :((
RUclips is pushing your view. Never saw your content before but this got pushed up. Caught my attention and had no idea this was going on. Passing it on to others who might not be aware too. Thank you for the information and I for sure do not want to see this go through. Best wishes.
I signed this bill for my other Canadian content creators earlier this year. Guess what? I FRICKIN SIGNED IT AGAIN! AND I'LL KEEP SIGNING IT FOR THEM UNTIL WE KILL THIS BILL TOGETHER! ✊
Hi
Isn't that illegal?
@@voidsage9359 Not when you sign the global one/as a concerned global citizen.
Maybe if they changed their voting habits to something less stupid.
I've also signed the petition and send a letter to the Senate, the last thing I want is my RUclips feed dominated by corporations lobbying to the CRTC which I guarantee will happen if this passes
They've amended the bill this week. This will apparently only apply to music and recording artists, not content creators. But, we shall see!
The Canadian Government shouldn't be allowed to dictate our content and shouldn't. This is the line they should not cross. When it comes to freedom of creativity, this will stiffen us and will only isolate us. The ability to share and work together as artists is the best freedom anyone could ever have. In the words of Willy Wonka "We are the music makers and we are the dreamers of the dreams"! The worst part is this: How far will this go? Will they then dictate an artists muse? "Hey, where did you get the inspiration from?" "I was inspired when I went to Italy!" "Nope not Canadian enough". What is Canadian anyways? Canada was made from the bones and blood of the First Nations people and from immigrants. You want pure Canadian Content? Then give back the land to the First Nations. We'll wait!
The Canadian spirit however, was formed from multiple sources, from co-operation and collaboration from other cultures! That's what puts the "Great" in Great White North! Canadian Content, will always be Canadian Content, so long as we keep the original spirit alive. The spirit of co-operation and unbound freedom for creativity. Who cares if a song in a persons video was made from a non-Canadian. Did the Government forget that some towns were named so after other towns not from Canada? If the Government wants nothing but Canadian made content and wants to dictate how the content is made, then their going to have to change a lot of Canada, just to accommodate this new bill. The Government isn't protecting Canadian content, their actually killing off what makes Canadian content. Their committing creativity genocide. Sorry for my Rant, I just truly think the Government needs to keep away and dismiss that bill entirely, otherwise the Government itself will prove to everyone, that they are in fact unpatriotic.
There is a hidden agenda behind the bill, its all about censorship.
Yea well trudea is a tyrant its nothing new. This kinda shit is to be expected. They want to control RUclips which in turn controls criticism against the Canadian government. and probably many other twisted reasons to pass this law.
As an American who just found this channel, don’t give your government more power. Whether you agree with it or not. It only leads to stupidity
One of your neighbors to the south - but many of the content creators I subscribe to and follow are Canadian - glad to hear the petition worked!
I looked into signing your petition, but it appears to only be meant for Canadian citizen. But I did pass your video onto other platforms that I have access.
I hope that your fellow Canadians are able to raise the number of signed signatures needed to end the bill before it is passed.
Fellow retards*
Woah, I didn't know about this and the video explains what's going on really well!
The implications of Governments controlling what we can see on the Internet is quite terrifying. I already live in a quite homophobic country and can already imagine what they would regulate and I hate it
Leaving the comment for the Algoritm, hope more people who didn't know about this find out about the situation
Monkey pox community member
I am wondering if this could even impact some of the vtubers that work for such industries such as Hololive EN. I am aware that at least Kronii and Mumei are both Canadian, as well as Ina, or if Yagoo and the whole of Cover Corp is going to have to have to say something. Nina Kosaka of Nijisanji is also Canadian. This could get messy.
Vtubers are for manchildren and canadians shouldn't be online
they will most definitely be affected and much of NIJIEN is Canadian, Rosemi, Enna, Millie, Elira, Selen, Nina, then Mumein Ina, and Kroni so while their regulars will still tune in, it will be doubly important to get likes, which these streamers never ask for
@@EndoftheBeginning17 Yeah, oh Haruka is also Canadian. This law seems to be very ill conceived on Canada's part.
@@naraku971 tbf, the Canadian government was ill conceived.
Fauna too.
Imagine the government rage if RUclips provided a way to opt out of their control. Naturally the government would rage and demand it removed, but the key thing it would need to publicly do so, and thus be seen as this evil gov that doesn't want their citizens to not be under their control.
WAIT WHAT!? What the hell is going on in Canada's government's minds!?
I have very mixed feeling about this law. Although it could actually help some Canadian content creators who are struggling, but it could also bring others down. In other words, it has benefits but also consequences.
Literally no
It's to help already established Candian RUclipsrs, People like Duchess, and Ordinary Gamers would be effected greatly
She said it probably won't help struggling content creators, because if it's pushed to too many people who aren't interested, the algorithm will see it as a bad video and will actually push it less than if nothing changed.
It's like if they had zero reviews prior, but now have a bunch of negative ones
@@nauscakes1868 If anything it's probably gonna lead to even LESS Canadian RUclipsrs doing things.
@@Friendstoyourend i don't understand your comment.
If your saying people like duchess will be affected in a negative way, then yeah *I literally just said that* 😐
"But it could also bring others down"
If not, then I dont get it
It has no benefit whatsoever
If you didn't mention "canadian" every other second, I would mistake it was talking about China.
I'm American but a lot of news I hear out of Canda does feel like it's trying to be China lite....
@@fatalblue I'm American and it sounded like something I'd hear our own government officials try to do. No one in government wants the internet to be as open as it is, mainly because they don't like how people younger than them use it.
@@fatalblue you got NO fucking idea dude. Justin "Joseph Stalin" Trudeu has petty much increased the price of EVERYTHING by x2-3 in terms of cost of living. you think that paying $4/Gal is expensive? HA! fuck i wish it was that cheap up here! try more like $7-8 (we're currently sitting at $1.56/L right now AKA 6.24/Gal just in my town and thats AFTER dropping from around $2.10 - $2.20/L from the summer, which would have put it at over $8/L), he's basically trying to take away our rights to protest as well as defend ourselves with his new bill to ban certain hunting rifles etc. he's done NOTHING but cause damage to this country and is damn near unanimously despised now throughout all of Canada. he even shows blatent disrespect for the war vets of opposing parties and accused them of standing with Hitler during the protest, which was utter BS and wasn't actually what he believed it to be but he wouldn't know that cause his head's always stuck so far up his ass.
@Anime4Life !! Damn. We're not exactly in the best shape either rn but it sounds extra tough for ya'll. How much longer are you stuck with Trudeu? I'm hoping we can dump our Geriatric-in-Cheif next year for someone better AND younger (not that I'm particularly optimistic. I'm pretty sure the last time I didn't feel like I was voting between bad and bad was back with Obama lol)
@@fatalblue we're stuck with him for however long Ontario/Toronto want him for. legit i am not kidding you NOTHING ELSE matters outside of those 2 provinces. i've done the math and even if you gave all the babies all around Canada the second they were born out of the vag the right to vote it STILL wouldn't make a difference simply due to how the seating is done. 50%+ of the voting seats are in Ontario/Toronto alone the remaining is scattered all throughout Canada. so even if all the rest of Canada gets together against him, unless Toronto/Ontario wants him out, the best we can hope for is a miscount. unlike the states we DON'T have a set amount of time or limits on the amount of terms they can serve. we hold a vote every 4 years, but unlike the states where they can hold the presidency for 2 terms back-to-back (i believe is how it goes) before they're forced to retire, Trudumb can just keep going at it until he's satisfied...or he just completely destroys any shred of dignity Canada has left.
Sent a letter, and added my own personal pleas to the pre-determined message (I don't know if anyone will read it). I tried. It is a never ending battle supporting smaller, independent individuals. The Art community has been hit hard this year. I hope (and yeah, I pray), this legislation doesn't go through. I am subbed to this channel and many other small Canadian video essayists/artists/etc. I hope this doesn't pass, because I don't want them to get pushed into oblivion by the algorithm.
There’s a canadian creator I watch a lot, his animations always bring a smile to me. It would really suck if this does somehow pass, but I’m sure he’d most likely be able to move if he wanted to.
Signed! Never seen your channel before but will definitely give it a look-see! I'm always a fan of Canadian creators and definitely don't want to see them get even more screwed over by their government
reminds me a lot of Germanys/ Europes article 13. Here we had an article passed about copyright by people who didn't understand the topic at all. They said no upload filters and guess what came, despite big protests against it by mainly younger people. ...
Here we have another similar thing. The government passing laws without considering or understanding the consequences.
Oh I think they understand the consequences, they just don’t care.
The point of the bill isn’t to help Canadians. It’s to suppress regular people’s voices who might have opinions that criticize the government, while amplifying the reach of corporate media which is state-owned 7:13 .
Obviously, they had to disguise the bill as something like this in order to get it through more easily.
This is what they get for letting gun control take place in their shitty country
Sadly that seems like a strong possibility.
That's how it starts. Can't wait for China 2.0 lol
This has been proven by many recent actions taken by said government.
Worst case, anything non-Canadian made or affiliated is censored or shadow banned through this new bill. Including content creators from CA thats part of a foreign network (half of Niijisanjii EN for example).
Best case, nothing but "Visit Canada" or "Visit X Province" adverts being forced upon everyone (even non-Canadians) like there is no tommorow.
Kinda joking but who knows. The most silly and obviously destructive laws and policies have been passed and sustained before so...
As a Canadian who wants to start making content myself, this sounds awful. Hoping the bill gets shot down ASAP
As an American that used to work heavily with a Canadian telecom company vendor in an IT role who I will not name as they share the name with a Childhood PBS Icon of mine, I can understand your concerns. Working with this company was not a fun experience, and the amount of power they had was eye opening. I can only hope that this bill does not pass, and that the affect is minimal, since many of my favorite creators are Canadian.
As a Canadian citizen who JUST got started on making art content on RUclips to show my passion to everyone, this makes me wanna give up on doing passion if passed cause how will I show my passion to everyone, especially those who wanna learn from me and such?
Please don’t ever stop doing what makes you happy.
Us creatives have to stick together.
As a German youtube lurker and artist who is interested in art-related videos I did a simple thought experiment how I would feel if such a law would be established in my country, and it gives me the shivers to imagine the outcome, since only around 10% of the content I view on this site is actually German content and a lot of subjects that interest me are barely covered by German youtube channels. So yeah, I would surely be annoyed by getting forcefully patronized about my preferred content and get pushed to national related topics out of my field of interests by law-enforced recommendations.
I'm Brazilian and I think I'm subscribed to only one or two brazilian channels. The owner lives in Cansada
I feel the same way as an Australian. I like Australian skits because I personally understand them, but when it comes to my other interests, such as video games, I don't see many Australians at all or the Australian is only 1 member of a team that plays online. This might also have to do with Australian laws surrounding video games. For some reason my government just hates them. Those bastards banned Disco Elysium! I just want to play the funny depressed cop game! Now I have to pirate the damn thing!
As a fellow german I can relate, althou there are only 3 channels in german I watch, and that's cos I know one of the creators (Orkenspalter TV), or like the alternative way they report about ongoings in germany.
I puke enough getting stuff like the Funke-shit (Walulis etc.) on my landingpage every now and then.
@@DawnOfMutilation
You should honestly fall to your knees praising the Funk people, because due to that project being somewhat successful Germany won't ever introduce any similar laws restricting independent creators.
You speak as if this were censorship. We're only talking about youtube recommendations. It won't change your subscriptions and at worst you'd have to scroll a lil bit more for the content you prefer in your search results.
Quick heads up to people using that generated letter form CHANGE THE DEFAULT LETTER! The weight of identical letters is important sure, but my local legislation has started just throwing away any letters not from an address in our jurisdiction because some issue saw some official inundated with hundreds of identical letters daily, which she then took the time to read individually, and by the end she felt like she didn't actually know what the people wanted because it was all form letters, and she couldn't even think straight over the personalized ones because of all the identical ones.
Tldr
@@strongestgamer2501 TL;DR: if you use a service to send a form letter to someone change from the default letter.
@Strongest Gamer Have you ever read before? Is your brain so fried you can only read two sentences before your eyes glaze over and you start drooling? How do you function in daily life? Did you even have the attention span to watch the video or do you just float around aimlessly typing stupid shit in RUclips comments?
TL;DR you have the intellect of an amoeba
@@Carmelpoptart Dude, not cool.
@@MudakTheMultiplier What's not cool is this mans inability to comprehend more than a single sentence
I will not tolerate this ignorance I have had enough of this bullshit
Holy crap, I have youtube premium, so I NEVER knew about this until your helpful video. As a Canadian, I'm scared about this, the bill could also censor news or fill it with Canadian-sided bias.
As a Canadian content creator, 90% of my viewers are american, Trudeau is literally a dictator I don’t understand why more ppl aren’t mad rn
I never understood Canada's obsession with Canadian content. Americans really didn't care that half of the shows on TV are Canadian. I hope this bill doesn't pass because I've seen lots of good cartoons get ruined because they've been forced to add more and more Canadian content which made the plots forced and awkward
It is always a thing if you two similar countries (or groups of people in general) where one of them is smaller. The bigger one floods the smaller one in some way which is bad for it's own culture, language... And even if there is not too big of an (accidental) overreach there is still the same jealousy present which a smaller brother has or someone who always draws second compared to his friend. There are many places where it is nothing more than a funny joke but there are also many places where it can be all the way to struggle for survival.
I feel like that is because the sheer volume of American content is far greater than say Canadian content they never feel the need to seek it out.
Keep in mind though there are niches where having country specific media is important.
Channels that cover News being a prime example most independent news channels are US based and even the few Canadian ones that exist focus on US news for the clicks.
Another is a media company that may review products or other content like Linus Tech Tips.
That said I think this bill is a big over reach and would do more harm then good.
Part of the Canadian identity is a crippling insecurity complex about our neighbors to the south. Instead of having a realistic view about our relationships globally there's this weird exaggerated "safe" image that gets presented to the world that keeps anyone from acknowledging our genuine faults
Because we need to make sure our domestic media industry doesn't completely get suppressed by American media? Like do you realize how many companies would go out of business and how many people would lose jobs if broadcasters could just buy a shit ton of cheaper American shows and movies?
Clearly it means that Total Drama Island makes up 80% of their Gross Domestic Product
I’m Canadian and I really hope this bill doesn’t pass through. The bill’s main idea does have the potential help some Canadians if it is carried out right it can but definitely hurt many other content creators
I hope it does
@@strongestgamer2501 Tell the world you're an incel who stillsucks their mom's wrinkled tits without telling the world you're an incel who sucks their mom's wrinkled tits.
@@strongestgamer2501 How does that boot taste?
Well it did give us show like the racoons, among others, so there is something about promoting local content.
Mmm yes, Trudeau's government helping Canadians. Definitely.
When you said this bill only benefits the big media companies, you hit the exact reason this bill exisits. Big Media has ALWAYS hated RUclips because it cuts into their profits. The Big 4, (Rogers, Bell, Telus and Cogeco/Videotron,) have been looking for a way to get their paws on youtube for years. The fact that they have the CRTC in their backpockets almost gaurantees smaller, ( and some larger,) creators will be pretty much done, is something that is certainly not lost on them and I'm 100% postive this will be a VERY BAD thing for us when it passes. I hate to say it, but if it's already gone through the house it almost gaurantees it passing. It's a VERY rare thing that the Senate actually goes against what Parliament has already passed, in fact, I can't even rember the last time it happened. RUclips does not mean squat in Ottawa unfortunately. Unless they start buying politicians the way the big 4 have, it's pretty much a done deal at this point.
I’m a Canadian, and I’ve been majorly concerned about this bill for a long time. I like being able to find whatever I want to watch on the internet, and don’t feel it’s appropriate for the government to shove down its own recommendations based on what arbitrarily counts as “sufficiently Canadian”.
Governments have a unique talent of coming up with measures nobody asked for...
As a UK Citizen there's not much I can do but ive shared your video in hopes someone who is Canadian will see I'll likely share it on a few platforms, I wouldn't want channels like this disappearing.
as a canadian viewer, I really appreciate this as art commentary isn't the kind of content I really like to watch, so I can say thank you for making a video about this topic, as I don't think I would have seen anything like this otherwise, and I can tell this has blown up given that it was actually recommended to me on youtube's front page.
Canadian Government: let’s force RUclips to only show Canadian content to Canadians!
Everywhere else because of the algorithm: wow Canadian content sucks, let’s stop showing it unless legally required!
Oh man, 'CanCon' strikes again.
wait does that affect Markiplier because he moved to Canada, I think all the country will be mad for noticing no more Markiplier video on the Algorithm (not really)
(I'm not that much attentive about Markiplier, not in the mood to feel motivated, I'm seriously depressed to find a excuse like deleting the comment like if it never existed)
@@teddywafflechannel2292 Mark didn't move to Canada lmao
@@teddywafflechannel2292 when did he move to canada ??? He did a video a year ago where he visited and ate all the time hortans but i don't think he actually moved here to stay
@@TheJewBagel Well, I mean, he did 'move' to Canada. You don't visit Canada if you don't physically move over to there. :P
this is why the government and internet don't mix at all
I swear a bill like this hit the floor in the 2000's. Sounds VERY familiar.
As a Canadian youtuber who hopes to get my content seen, Im worried af about this Bill
I hope it passes
@@strongestgamer2501 Well, FUCK you in particular then you asshole, you're just being an ass about this.
@@strongestgamer2501 Why? Because you wanna be edgy?
Same here, I'm starting to get anxious
@@strongestgamer2501 imagine hoping that this bill passes, couldn't be me.
This is the first time I've ever heard of this issue and I haven't even seen the RUclips ad campaign you're mentioning (maybe it's because I'm American.) But either way, I'm so sorry that you're going through this and I hope that the situation gets resolved.
You don't sound American
Thank you so much for bringing this topic up as not much people have. As a Canadian it's actually scary how good things can see at first but honestly can be extremely negative.
I may live in the United States but I know that the Canadian Government has their heads up their asses and are obsessed with power and control. Its getting ridiculous and its nice to see content creators and many others standing up against this bill. I certainly hope that everything works out for you and any other Canadian RUclipsrs out there.
I don’t want my liked Canadian RUclipsrs to fail just so the gov can push an agenda. I hope it doesn’t get pushed.
Same
I remember when I looked at Canada as maybe the best country on Earth and always dreamed to move there someday or at least go visit. Now seems like some weird dystopia I wouldn't dare put a foot on even if I got paid to go there. It's just surreal how things switched so badly.
@ajayr1383 for me at least it is, with the super weird laws to protect media, freezing of founds of some protesters and mostly the eutanasya law that it's first suggested for the disable or homeless rather than actual help, talking as someone who lives in a third world country it's quite bizarre, not even us get that level of weird. Also no country is perfect but Canada long ago seemed like the best one by far.
You unironically look at a pile of shit and call it the best
@@strongestgamer2501 Forgive the third world country 9 years old past me for believing living in a country without shootings everyday, violent deaths per hour, frecuent kidnapping, good salaries and be able to own a car and buy cookies and chips more often than once a month was better than my own and not a pile of shit on my perspective.
@ajayr1383 that's more of the modern look, not as bad as China but looking in that direction right now. Pretty sure the "nice" thing is not but still had better oportunities even by being shady, still would take old Canada anytime.
Canada is just America with no Electoral College
As a small Canadian creator, this concerns me greatly! I really hope this doesn't get passed, because I really don't want to see the algorithm screwed up even more then it already is...
I'm a neighbor to your South and the news from up North over the last year has been frightening. The totalitarian changes are hitting far too close to home.
This came up cause I started to watch Canadian politics a bit more. However, staying cause I love a good art channel (Canadian artist as well, and I love getting inspired)
I really hope they dont go through with this
Me too..
trudeau government. this is their shtick. us Gun owners are fighting our own war agaisnt bill c21, but are looking at a loss just like how we lost c11 too.
not to mention all of the other bills they are introducing that do stupid shit like this.
best part? cant protest it, trudeau doesnt like people voicing their concerns that way.
Me too, I'm getting anxious
me too
they will new internet it about control and censor ship the freedoom of expression gone forever a perfect control you will need to watch you step every were get over billed and on ad on ad they will invent vpn law and all that
As a Canadian to consumes content primarily from other countries as that's what interests me this bill is terrifying to me ⊙﹏⊙ this is why government shouldn't be allowed to interfere with the internet unless it's explicitly necessary....
Wow. The government in every country. Hello from the states. I'm so sorry this may happen to you. I am rooting for our Canadian content creators. I really really hope this bill isn't passed.
Most informative RUclips video I’ve ever watched during breakfast
The fact I'm a Canadian kinda got me concerned bc I hope to start an actual chancel-
Dang, hope that the bill doesn't pass... i never heard of this tysm for making a video for this!!
Go outside
@@strongestgamer2501 shouldn't you be the one to go outside because you have been replying on comments on this video for a while
Jeeesus, hopefully the petitions and letters get through to reps and MPs
Cope
@@strongestgamer2501 get out of this comment section asap
Never seen any of this channel before, nor am I Canadian, but this was a very informative and well-put together video. Thank you for doing your part to bring this up.
As I listened the thought of Canada turning into China came in.
This is scarily getting into fully controlling what we can view and or create as Canadians it’s reminding me of the situation in dictatorships where the fully control the media
You've done an excellent job of framing this issue, and explaining its nuances. I've shared this video with my own audience (and of course have signed the petition/sent my own letter). These situations often make us feel powerless - but at the end of the day, while I have no idea whether such things really have the power to move the needle, it's the least we can do to weigh in and claw back just a little bit more control from the things that otherwise dictate our lives.
Me when I saw the notif for this video: What beef does Trudeau have with the smart anime lady? WHAT DOES SHE KNOW?
Women trying to be funny
@@strongestgamer2501 bro why are you commenting on this video telling people to go outside.. by doing that your just stooping down to their level. If you believe they should go outside, go outside yourself bro 💀
Also… you should probably go outside if your saying “WoMaN nOt FunNy”
@@nabstablook22 They're literally just going onto every comment just to make people mad. Telling others to "go outside" is definitely massive projection on their part.
@@ArbitraryOutcome I know lmao
As a Canadian who makes unlisted videos, This really gave me out a warning! It would suck if all the Canadian youtube channels just get killed off, Thanks for the warning!
As a Canadian, as well as an online DJ with an online radio station I would like to highly recommend to my fellow Canadians: Start checking out VPNS while you can now. I got mine right from day one of this absurd bill being announced. I have a sneaky suspicion that VPN sites will be mysteriously blocked after the bill is passed.
I'm a Canadian-American. I live in the United States. I'm not sure what would stop this law from applying to me based purely on citizenship, even though I don't live in Canada and haven't been back for five years. What bullshit.
As a Canadian who still lives in Canada
I want to leave
> goes to sign the petition
> "need a canada zip code"
ok fine i'll look one up✌
How'd it go?
@@arurramoon1965 i mean it went through fine if that's what you mean?
I'm also a small Canadian content creator. Myself and others have worked incredibly hard to get where we are now so I hope that this isn't the end for us Canadian creators...
i know a canadian content creator who makes animations and I'm just afraid everything(around me and that content creator's people who they trust) may end up being different when that content creator is gone
One thing to always think about: even if the government had completely good intentions… they are not in power forever, the next guy that comes along has different intentions and is free to do so
Oh it's going to pass, but we just need to hope that it doesn't nuke our channels.
This is the top example of government laying their hands into area that they shouldn't have thought of touching to begin with. It's just making the world a worse place with no reason at all.
As a Canadian i hope that this will not happen i enjoy posting content even if my channel is small lets hope that the petition reaches its goal!
I am like: are they encouraging a Canadian stereotype?
What content is Canadian enough anyway?
@@kittygirl0872 Apologetic personality, maple syrup and ice hockey.
@@zigaudrey I thought you were going to mention the OTHER stereotype being that of apathy and indifference.
@@ArbitraryOutcome That was a quick thinking. This was the most stereotyping think on Canadian culture the other could think of. They are more than that!
@@zigaudrey eh
Somehow had entirely missed this and luckily the algorithm was all "yo nerd, you really need to see this" thank you for the vid Duchess, I've hit up both links you posted.
I'm French and it was recommended to me ^^
If you move, come to France, the healthcare is accessible. And it's hotter than the UK with less rain.
Well if the algorithm has done one thing right, it was to recommend your channel to me and if the whole internet censorship drama from a couple years back here in germany(article 13 or however it was called) has taught me something, its that almost nothing will change, so here is to hoping your channel wont be killed.
For the algorithm, keep youtube ours, and don't let C11 destroy creators
This sounds like a terrible situation, and I can't imagine what will happen if things like this spread. Most of the channels I watch are not made in America. Can't imagine if I never discovered them because I was pushed American content.
Funny that they are determining if you're Canadian enough. If you're a Canadian citizen, that should be Canadian enough.
As a Canadian viewer and content creator, this scares me a lot. Thank you for talking about this
I’m scared too so,you’re not alone.
I’m just going to start up my channel. Goodness, truly not liking this.
Several of my favourite youtube channels are by Canadians: comedians, nail art, and so on...
D: