I think his colleagues were worried that Quinn (the trans girl) would be offended by his questioning, that's why they tried to stop him from asking his questions.
@@bobbierobinson6269 Sorry there Bill, I didn't understand your comment. You changed pronouns half-way through, so I don't know how you're talking about.
yeah but we cant have the kid questioning it... love how they portray the parents as against it, when its now, normally the parents/teachers pushing it on there kids. honestly they should just leave kids alone. the world is confusing enough.
@@snowballthecat7542oh i disagree in the sense that there are schools with staff that are putting this stuff in these kids heads, grooming them into it. Its pretty disturbing!
The fact he was all « not possible biologically he’s a boy » And then turned into actually trying to understand even by asking stupid questions is so precious
@@QueerDergyour a boy or a girl. There are only 2 genders. If your born with a penis your a boy and if your born with a 🐱 your a girl. It’s that simple so shut up geek
@@m1forevs.He's condused and probably has parents grooming him to be a girl because they'd rather molest a girl. You know like most parents of confused transgenders.
For anyone confused. He's autistic and can pretty much only understand facts, hard biological facts. He is genuinely curious and wants to know more because he does not understand it.
@@Joco999autistic people tend to struggle with abstract things, but better with things we can see and understand, so if you ask us to imagine something we will struggle, Also meaning we ask MORE questions than the average person when it comes to mental things, like understanding opinions, feelings and view points since we cant really imagine being in someone else's positions. Yet when it comes to things with a science behind it or that sticks to a rule, like 1. sciences,math and engineering or 2. music,art and design. We tend to stick to one side of things by either attempting to master 1 ( things with a lot of logic behind it) or 2 ( things with a lot of creativity behind it) and struggle with the other due to a lack of understanding, but these things become our world and that causes us to struggle with the understanding of emotions and social situations. Or atleast this is my point of view
@@orisisgamers7854that’s not in the clip. Just because you enjoy the phobia of trans people, doesn’t mean that others delight in their suffering too. Go touch some grass or something, loser.
@@matthewtantillo8173she does she just identify with it and that’s not wrong even if u don’t understand u don’t need to unless u feel like u might be transgender too be respectful all genders are taught this it’s common sense
@@armyblink7928no you shouldnt be respectful to this shit if you have a penis you are a male if you have a vagina you are a woman nobody cares about what you want to identify as this is the truth like it or hate it
@@tqcticall if u want to be addressed as a female out of common respect and boundaries I’ll address u as so it’s be completely up to u but I think that u would be non binary I’m a straight female so I wouldn’t exactly know but I try out of respect
They shut him down because it’s unprofessional for a doctor to ask a patient questions like that, especially questions that might make her uncomfortable, if they’re not relevant to her case
Honestly the fact that he’s asking questions and trying to understand is a whole lot better than just shutting down the whole conversation like his colleagues are doing.
no its isnt, that was not the time of place to have a conversation like that they were in the middle of treating a patient. he could have had the conversation another time and with a different person if the girl didn't want to explain, trans people do not owe you or anyone else an explanation
He just wants to understand. He’s not trying to be mean. He understands things in a factual sense, not emotional. So all he’s trying to do is figure out how her brain works so he can understand why she wants to be a girl. Same thing he does with every other patient, tries to figure them out. I love this show. Especially bc the girl was so understanding and happy to explain her point of view to him
Was her on her parents. These is caused by her parents that wanted a boy and never got one. So since they had a girl they told her repeatedly she is a boy. Her biology hobbies and preferences all show female girl no trans of any biological problem. Just parent problem that are propably the things from lgtb
Yeah. She seemed to understand that he (the doctor) didn’t fully understand and was just curious. (Also the questions probably helped with any nervousness. Distracting and all that.)
I like this. He's trying to understand gender dysphoria and how the whole gender thing works. He's not transphobic, just curious and eager to learn. And the girl is happy to educate him on the matter and very understanding. She knows he's different and she adapts. That's how the world should work. Curiosity, kindness and understanding.
He isn’t trying to understand..he is asking questions of what, in his mind, is typical girl behavior because he knows that everyone is wrong and it is a boy-who turns out to have testicular cancer..which, again, is his mind is something he learned happens to males.
@n0ah24_7 yeah dude it's a whole TV series. The Good Doctor. It's about a doctor with autism. The creator of the show is an actor in it too, if you ever see the Asian doctor it's him.
@@mr.nuggit8240While I fundamentally agree with this ideology, I believe this episode is also trying to express how autism makes it harder to understand these kinds of subjects.
@@Tanner-v1w "Correct pronouns" Names, I understand because name is something you can change and a name being "masculine" or "feminine" doesn't really have an objective base but pronouns are not like that, they are supposed to help you identify a subject's characteristics.
Makes me wonder if I am autistic because that is how I see it. I have no clue what it feels like to be a girl. It’s just a statement of fact that I am. I had no say in the matter.
@@Winterbaby1977this has nothing to do with autism autism doesn’t make you transphobic . The point the show is trying to show is autism’s lack of regualr understanding as other humans to emotional sensitivity and typically saying what’s on their mind . You are not autistic just because you’re transphobic 😅dumbest thing I’ve read today
When asked “other than biologically, how do you know you’re supposed to be a boy?” And he answers “I’m not supposed to be anything. I’m a boy that’s it.” is quite an eye opener. We aren’t supposed to be anything, we are just what we are.
@@AJHornet1the problem is not in the individual self perception, it's when they force everyone else to participate in their own self perception, and even start insulting people who don't comply
This kid understands he has autism and respectfully answers the questions without taking offence Edit: Why so much hate just don't comment if your gonna be rude about it
First off, it's "I am with the Doctor with Autism" if you are referring without knowing his name, grammatically that's correct Second, if this is a transphobic comment, screw you and keep your utterly horrible "opinion" to your damn self Third, it's natural to question your sexuality or gender, the Q in LGBTQ stands for "Questioning", to think you dislike transgender people is just an ass thing to say, Quinn biologically is male but *she* identifies as female, born male assigned as female, no phase, a phase my ass, sex is what you are born with, *not* gender
@@JoeMama-td6tq Just some context to the transphobes, I am pretty sure they mean "gender doesn't equal sex" You are welcome assholes JoeMama (still funny even here), I am with you!
His question doesn’t make sense because he’s about science. He’s a medical professional that isn’t a psychologist and he speaks that way because of his level of autism. Maybe instead of making fun of how someone speaks, you listen and learn
@@plantkidd_how is agreeing with something right ..edgy ,biology is first before emotions ...and emotions are built in by biology ..so if one is biologically a male and or female ..you cant and will never change that
@@christuspilatus and why shouldn't anyone question it? if no questions are asked, where can we get any answers? the kid's still young and figuring the world out, and kid's allowed to explore things. So is Shaun, he's figuring out something he doesn't understand, why can't he have questions when the very person who can give very personalised answers is just right there and ready to provide insights. He's learning, and isn't malicious, whoever stops this learning process should consider themselves narrow-minded. Pretty ironic.
@@floofrules no, that's why the ppl where shutting him downxD he was not supposed to ask questionsxD If you ask me personally I say ask away. 🤷 idgaf Facts are more important than feelings
@@floofrules he literally stated his own feelings regarding someone else's gender as "the absolute truth " without considering if he is even completely correct about it. So this kind of question basically functions as nothing but a dismissal of that little kid's life experience. I'm autistic too and at some point we also have to learn that asking intrusive questions is a bad thing and hurts other people whose experiences are different from our own
As a recently diagnosed autistic person, I highly understand his curiosity. For ages I've wanted to know why I am the way I am and I did a BUNCH of research. Was super cool to learn
It's a hospital show which means they should be going based by biology.ex your want not going to check trans woman if "she's" pregnant if they come in with a bloated stomach
@@joshuaoverlord5327 I understand how one may come to that conclusion, but in fact in US hospitals they will respect the gender identity of patients coming in for a few reasons. Firstly, history of identity and transition, as well as documented gender dysphoria (ICD-10 F64.0) are extremely important to a case study. In addition, using a patient’s preferred pronouns and name are some of the easiest ways to alleviate gender dysphoria and ensure the patient stays in a stable (and possibly improving) mental state throughout their stay.
I thought it was cute when he ran up after he had thought about it and wants to ask a lot of questions. I like that he changed into wanting to understand why or how. Pretty cool to try to understand and communicate and not just shut someone out after your opinion.
It's not opinion that he's a boy, it's a fact. He is a boy. XY chromosomes means a boy. Boys have different medical concerns than girls. If a girl in the orphanage says she's a princess, that doesn't make it true.
As someone who has autism you do wanna ask 20 questions to someone who's new to you and you are curious. The actor portrayed autism in a way that I can understand the perspective
@@sunberry1792 the show portrays it as if he's never heard of it in his life. Remember that he has savant syndrome so he probably would understand what it is. I'd overlook it if it was an isolated thing but the show infantelizes him a LOT. For example when someone has to explain what a lie is to him. It's just unnecessary and it's clear a lot of the time the people writing it doesn't understand what they're working with... That's my main problem with the show
The wholesomeness in their interaction made me cry. He just wants to understand, and she's answering his questions, knowing that is what he is doing. If everyone approached everything like this, imagine how better the world could be.
@alfamejeu7237 I don't know if you realize this, but there is no "normal". What you may consider normal, someone else will consider crazy, and vice versa. The problem isn't that people aren't "normal", the problem is that people think they need to judge others about things that are none of their business. Just because some people are unhappy with their lives and feel the need to bring down everyone else, instead of finding something that makes them happy. Find a hobby and stop being miserable. 🙄🙄🙄
@@cherinuchell4578 there is a normal, everyone is born female or male, that’s normal. People like you are delusional or support those delusional people, you’re a harm to society. Get help.
There’s this beautiful scene at the end where he decides to float in a pool, literally, after hearing her say being able to present as herself let her feel like her weight was lifted, like she was floating in a pool. Someone asks him what he’s doing, and he just says ‘understanding’
He is genuinely curious, and he does want to understand, but I think he wants to understand "why ""he"" thinks ""he"" is a girl.". Because from his point of view, he can't seem to understand the transition from one gender to another. It's not necessarily his fault. It's more of society's. Sorry. I'm not good at explaining things in text form.
@@MiraAlmoqbali girl you’re wrong as fuck. 🤣💀 and you clearly have not watched any of this nor do you understand how his brain works, so why are you even sayin anything
@@0rin1sg0dif a boy wants to be a girl it’s the parents trying to get them to be that way and telling them it’s ok even though it makes no sense biologically or in any other way besides the fact that if you do think that you are a girl when you are clearly a boy then you are mentally I’ll and need help
@@MisdroHe just didn’t know what it was, ended up being supportive in the end of the episode, calling her she and saying “she’s more of a purple kind of girl” I’m pretty sure
The fact they get acquainted more due to his quest of wanting to find the reasoning of why, but upsets me that his colleagues just wanted to shut him up. He has autism and she obviously can see it and felt at ease answering his intriguing genuine harmless curiosity
Guys remember, if some one says XY chromosomes are both genders in one, they are wrong, XY chromosomes are a male, and for females, they have XX chromosomes so that means XY chromosomes are not something else than a male so that means its 2 genders.
@@Christopherson2006 chromosomes define sex, not gender, and actually there is more than just xx and xy, take intersex people for example, they don’t have just xx or xy so the idea of sex being binary in itself is false. Then there’s the gender debate, gender is a social construct, we apply male to xy and female to xx. If we look at history there are many examples of cultures that believed in more than 2 genders like Hawaiian culture believe there were 3. We’re so used to the way gender is presented as being directly linked to sex when it in reality is linked to psychology and how the person feels they want to present themselves, the way it’s taught is outdated.
@@Christopherson2006so first you underexposed little idiot, there are 3 biological genders and second, what you mean is gender identification. There are like 71 ore something of them. You little middle ages clown🤡🤡
My takeaway from this is, instead of continuously denying her claim about her gender or dismissing it altogether, he tried to understand her and her condition. He didn't tease, bully or fear her. He gave her a chance to explain herself. As it should be when we don't understand something.
@@soulresonance4073 sorry my school actually teaches me science and not weird sexual behavior. But I do know that sex is based on biology and gender is just a delusion made by the left.
I love the Good Doctor and how they approach topics like this. It's never from a place of malice with Dr Murphy, everyone else may be a dick but Shaun is always doing things out of the curiosity of his heart
However, transfolk constantly get questioned by hateful dickhats who are trying to dredge up more ammo to attack and hurt them with. So while everyone may understand that he's not trying to be hurtful, NOT trying to be hurtful doesn't mean you aren't being hurtful. So it's still best to kind of stop him and instead tell him to read up on it, there's a lot of documentation and interviews and such.
Your stupid. Its not really, The shows not really Why are people so dumb How do you get so emotional about a show created by old stright rich white men that you hate and yet praise them for there progressive shows that they feed you becuase your dumb enough to believe its real. God you are such a failer of a human.
@@Squidlark Yeah it's pretty close to someone on that section of the spectrum. Reminds me of my high functioning nephew where mine is far more low key and shows up in minor forms like sensory issues.
For all the people in the comments making this a transgender debate, the point of the Full clip is that the biological gender matters since the patient has testicular cancer. When it’s a matter of health and surgery, the fact is the patient is biologically still male, although they identify as female. It’s not about the Doctor being ignorant. Also the point of the show is that the doctor has autism so that might also be why he can’t comprehend gender identities Edit: just realized auto correct happened the first time
someon told me there was recenty a trans man that died bc the ER staff didnt think to check for ectopic pregancy bc the patiet presenter themelves as male 🤷♀️ im sorry it happened, but it was a predictable event.
Gender identities? Are you trying to reduce Gender down to things like what clothes someone wears and what color they like? If so, you have 6 year old grasp on Gender.
@@luciddream2033 I’m saying that the doctor in the clip can’t seem to comprehend what it means to identify as a different gender. No one mentioned colored clothing and it never was about clothing.
as an autistic person who genuinely still has difficulty understanding trans people and wants to genuinely learn but is afraid to ask, its truly nice to see that people are willing to be understanding and kind.
@@_buhbuhbillyAlthough I may not be that particular fellow, I too am curious about trans people - or rather gender as as a whole. I dont tend to ponder about issues like these because I feel it's none of my business, and also because I feel like people are hyper polarized about things like this. You see, I'd like to understand it as a whole. I know, rather complicated, but see, autism is a social disorder. One wouldnt expect someone who has a hard time understanding social things to understand social issues like this. One more thing I'm curious about is why do people think autistic people are like idc about gender, when thats.. yet again a social issue. 😢 My apologies if I'm asking a lot of you, im genuinely curious and id love to understand.
@@goldengail3418not a trans but I do talk with many trans people. I think u can see trans people like any other people suffering with mental issue because that's what they suffer: dysphoria. Just because most of us born with a penis or a vagina, that doesn't mean you feel like u should have it between your legs. There are in fact many trans people who suffer with urinary infection because they are so disgusted by their genitals that they even avoid pee! But I'm also talking from a medical perspective, of course there are many social layers into this topic and there's also genfluids, non-binaries, etc, but I'm gonna avoid this because I don't really know that much to be able to do so. Also, although trans people have a mental issue, that doesn't mean they are sick or have a disease and that they should accept the body they were born. Therapy to learn how to cope, hormones and surgery are the way to "treat" them, because just like austim, there is nothing wrong with being different. U just have to learn how to deal with your particularities, but there's ways and ways to deal with it. Also, there are ones who must do the surgery, others just feels like the hormones is enough, I'd say it really is an spectrum thus the need of therapy to undestand what's the best solution for each case
Because sometimes it’s not as simple as someone who genuinely doesn’t understand and is trying to. And to people who are ignorant and still misgender them knowing their sexuality. She understands that he is trying to learn and not be rude. The doctors need to no for scientific reasons and treatment but they are also referring to them as she. Because they are a girl. They identify as a girl.
it’s a dude not a girl men can’t magically turn into women and women can’t magically turn into men a biological male just as a biological female can never change their XY or XX chromosomes respectfully, every chromosome, every cell in a body regardless of any surgery they undergoe will remain chromosomes and cells of the sex they were born with trying to dispute this fact just makes you look like an idiot that accepts whatever the media tells them
@@randomuploadsism if you watch the show you would know he wasn't belittling he was trying to understand and at the end of the episode he figures it out and refers to quin by there preferred pronouns
Murphy says “the patient doesn’t have appendicitis, he has testicular cancer” and the OTHER doctor says “….she” Dr.Murphy is way too autistic to make a snide, joky comment like that lol. He’s too literal.
@@christopherjacquez8605why do you care? Is it your life? 😂 so worried about what other people do with THEMSELVES, that maybe if you didn’t, you’d be further in life
I loved this scene. It’s not made with malice, or to make fun of either autistic or transgender people. Dr. Murphy was curious about a concept he was unfamiliar with, and the girl seemed unbothered by his innocent questions. Fantastic writing here
@@willburgerrotmg2867 the difference is you don’t have gender dysphoria so you’re not trans.. cis people like you and i aren’t dysphoric of the bodies we were born with..
@@someguyxoxo8027 it isn't even necessarily hard. They can just call me by my pronouns, and still say that my sex is whatever. It isn't a lot of effort and it makes the patient a lot more comfortable. Forcibly not using them and making a huge point about it is just bringing unnecessary politics into the check up room. Who cares what you have to call your patient just to make them that little bit more comfortable and safe in a place like a hospital.
@@krool_aid9835 First this started by talking about biology alone and so you give up on that and agree hes right with that. Second you want the doctors that may be dealing with dire situations to make sure to add a extra calculation in their head to make sure when to say your biological sex and what you want to be? Doesn't seem like the best of ideas. Also "forcibly" you know that making someone say something they don't really want to say is more forceful then someone just saying a fact that is necessary, right? Who cares about what you want to be called just let the doctors do what they need to safe you from awful illness and even death.
@@someguyxoxo8027 the thing is it's barely even a matter of passing. That girl *looks* like a girl. That doctor specifically looked at her files, and called that girl by her sex, despite her wishes AND her presentation. Of course her sex is male, everybody in the room knew that, but they were still calling her by her preferred pronouns. The actual comment implies that doctor is in the right for calling some girl in a medical setting a man because it's "biologically correct" or whatever. Nobody said that you need to ignore their biological sex, it's just not that hard at all to call that girl she/her. Doctors should be the least bit flexible, especially in the US where every time you go to the hospital nothing is done and your bill is like $10,000+. God forbid you want the doctor to treat you with basic decency and minimum respect.
It’s honestly a really fair representation of the linear thinking that many people with ASD have. I appreciate how the kiddo in this scene entertains the questions and tries to answer honestly while still asserting she’s a girl.
Answered both honestly and it looked like she genuinely enjoyed being asked about her femininity. I haven't seen the episode but I'd like to know if she got to ask him questions about being autistic. From what little I've seen of the show, I think he'd be happy to answer her questions in turn.
She seems to understand that he has autism and seems to be happy that he is trying to understand what makes her feel like a girl, he is trying to understand which is a lot more than most people who don't understand try to do
You're not supposed to be anything. You're a boy there is no deeper purpose to the fact You're male. It's just a fact and you can't change that. XY vs XX once you find a way to change the chromosomes in every single one of your cells then tell me you can change your gender.
But he is not professional. He was supposed to do his job instead of keep asking unrelated questions. He should have kept his questions for after the procedures.
@@thegoosling8947 bottom surgery does not remove or add anything biological. A male to female surgery removes an appendage and adds a wound. Medically speaking, top or bottom surgery actually creates another reason your doctor needs to know.
@@thegoosling8947 you can have a sex change and all the surgeries you want but it still doesnt change your chromosomes X & Y/X & X. Your anatomy can change but your biology cant. Humans arent natural hermaphrodites like snails, thats why we call it human mutation in genes when it does happen.
![Chino Pacas - Smith (ft. Junior H & Fuerza Regida) [Video Visualizador Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BVK6k56X30Y/mqdefault.jpg)
The kid seems to understand he has autism and is happy to entertain his questions. Kinda sucks that his colleagues shut him down
He is correct tho he is just following biological facts
I think his colleagues were worried that Quinn (the trans girl) would be offended by his questioning, that's why they tried to stop him from asking his questions.
@@deepredd yeah, it's definitely better to spare her feelings, than to actually cure him.😂
@@bobbierobinson6269 Sorry there Bill, I didn't understand your comment. You changed pronouns half-way through, so I don't know how you're talking about.
@@bobbierobinson6269 bro can’t even misgender properly 💀
“20 questions are up”
“I only asked 4”
He’s real
Nah bro
He’s him
1.2k likes 1 replies 💀 lemme fix that
@@dylanjuneau357 himothy
Haha, 420
@@samsonblvdhimothy the great
The kid had no problem answering the dudes questions he’s just curious
yeah but we cant have the kid questioning it... love how they portray the parents as against it, when its now, normally the parents/teachers pushing it on there kids. honestly they should just leave kids alone. the world is confusing enough.
@@Honed-true. If it wasn't for shitty parents and stereotypes, things such as sex change operations wouldn't even be necessary
@@snowballthecat7542oh i disagree in the sense that there are schools with staff that are putting this stuff in these kids heads, grooming them into it. Its pretty disturbing!
Huh
@@A83-A83grooming kids into what?
"I'm not a boy, I'm a girl!"
"YOU HAVE TESTICULAR CANCER"
Hahahaha
🤣🤣
LOL
lmaoo i think that's what actually happens lmao
💀
The fact he was all « not possible biologically he’s a boy »
And then turned into actually trying to understand even by asking stupid questions is so precious
Right!!
Frustrating to have stupid questions and have people think you’re being a jerk. I just have dumb questions. 😢
You can tell too by his body language he was being genuinely curious and challenging his own views
@@nanochiccmhm he is just trying to figure out how it works which is totally understandable
Questions asked so one can learn or understand are never stupid!
To be fair, he doesn't understand that. He only understands facts and biological facts. He's genuinely curious
And he isn't wrong either
@Hacker_606_ Yeah, he is. He's incorrect, sex and gender aren't the same. Sex is the biological stuff. Gender is a social construct.
@@QueerDergyour a boy or a girl. There are only 2 genders. If your born with a penis your a boy and if your born with a 🐱 your a girl. It’s that simple so shut up geek
@@QueerDergI like that take
@@JohnCena-tp4gh yup, it's a take that has a 6 year degree in biology to back up.
He’s genuinely curious with no ill intent, they shouldn’t have shut him down 😭
no they should of because she’s only how old she’s still probably figuring it out
@@m1forevs.He's condused and probably has parents grooming him to be a girl because they'd rather molest a girl. You know like most parents of confused transgenders.
Well the conversation was over when Murphy says that boy is a XY chromosome male man dude he his him guy all the same thing.
The had no Ill intent either but the parents could see that as grounds for suing their protecting the hospital
Her appendix is about to rupture and kill her, they ain’t got time for that
For anyone confused. He's autistic and can pretty much only understand facts, hard biological facts. He is genuinely curious and wants to know more because he does not understand it.
What, other people are not curious for facts?
@@Joco999autistic people tend to struggle with abstract things, but better with things we can see and understand, so if you ask us to imagine something we will struggle,
Also meaning we ask MORE questions than the average person when it comes to mental things, like understanding opinions, feelings and view points since we cant really imagine being in someone else's positions. Yet when it comes to things with a science behind it or that sticks to a rule, like 1. sciences,math and engineering or 2. music,art and design. We tend to stick to one side of things by either attempting to master 1 ( things with a lot of logic behind it) or 2 ( things with a lot of creativity behind it) and struggle with the other due to a lack of understanding, but these things become our world and that causes us to struggle with the understanding of emotions and social situations. Or atleast this is my point of view
@@-amaranth- Thank you very much for the explanation, much appreciated.
Im autistic
@@gregomano2220 I'm also acoustic
I love how open she is to answering his questions and helping him understand though 😭 like most people would be offended
sHE
Not a she, but a HE...you are part of the problem
@@jarekhornbeckso all girls are boys?
Why do women use that 😭 emoji instead of using their brains for once?
@@jarekhornbeckawwww you did such a good job respecting pronouns!! Do you want a treat?
its kinda wholesome how he isnt hatefull but instead seeks to understand
He stating the fact.
You guys do realise stuff like this is why LGBT acceptance is droping
In the end the boy who doesn’t know what he is has testical cancer 😂😂😂😂
@@damjanmladic9327that's wild blud
@@holydrip2082but it's the truth blud
"I am a girl"
"I AM A SURGEON"
Lol
5 y olds now a days, the f you mean Jimmy's a girl now?
I AM! I AM A SURGEON!
I love how he starts asking questions at the end lol he seemed to genuinely want to know more
Yea and how in the next clip he suggests something that would kinda help her feel better in her body and also remove the cancer
I don't think so he's just being homophobic
@@Mooooorning I don't think you know what that word means haha
@@Mooooorning no
@@Mooooorning he isn't being homophobic. He has autism and hasn't ever emcounted this before and therefor is asking questions to understand
“20 questions is over”
“I only asked 4”
XD best part of this clip
No no best part of the full clip is: well "she" has testicular cancer . 😂😂😂😂followed up by well now he can pass by as a she
@@orisisgamers7854that’s not in the clip. Just because you enjoy the phobia of trans people, doesn’t mean that others delight in their suffering too. Go touch some grass or something, loser.
There’s no good parts in this clip it’s such a disappointment
@@tophatman9168 u suck
@tophatman9168 i wanna know why do you think that😊
Cut out the best part. "Well SHE has testicular cancer." Fucking gold.
😅 that's a sure going to be a girl now😅
@@UCHIHADMADARA XD I was thinking the same thing!
was boutta say this
never watched good doctor, but that the girl with testicular cancer was on house md, think you got them mixed up unless good doctor yoinked that
@hydrarl3869 I haven't watched Good doctor either. I just saw another reel of this episode where it had the part I mentioned.
"I AM A BOY! I AM A BOY DR.STURGIS!"
Yung sheldon
Sturgis? Wrong show ☠️
@@ken6056 its the actor tho
fr@@eyaph
I am a surgeon
I like how quinn is being really respectful and answering the questions without getting annoyed or angered or something
Thats how the conversation should go honestly.
That's how you knows it's not real. Sadly
God forbid you question them irl
that's how trans people are irl, or at least me lol
@@fercastaneda1627 lol yeah they really arent
“How do you know you’re supposed to be a boy?”
“Your question doesn’t make sense, I’m not supposed to be anything”
“I AM A SURGEON”
I am asir gean, dr. Han
@@Soumya_108it translated to i love you lol
@@snickerooo 😂 😂 maybe the ai is setting us up
I AM A DOOR I AM A DOOR
I thought i was a boy cause i have nuts and a cock
The child was really nice for understanding the situation
Yea as if the child understands jack......he doesn't even understand his own gender. 😂
@@matthewtantillo8173she does she just identify with it and that’s not wrong even if u don’t understand u don’t need to unless u feel like u might be transgender too be respectful all genders are taught this it’s common sense
@@armyblink7928no you shouldnt be respectful to this shit if you have a penis you are a male if you have a vagina you are a woman nobody cares about what you want to identify as this is the truth like it or hate it
@@armyblink7928so i’m a male if tomorrow i feel like i’m a female that makes me a female?
@@tqcticall if u want to be addressed as a female out of common respect and boundaries I’ll address u as so it’s be completely up to u but I think that u would be non binary I’m a straight female so I wouldn’t exactly know but I try out of respect
"I'm girl"
"And this cancer in your testicles?"
Lol!
He didn't understand and he just wanted to understand. Why did they shut him down? She seemed more than happy to respond to his questions....
She?
You mean he
XY = Male
@@EemMiIiLlLl get off my comment you intolerant troll.
@@EemMiIiLlLlshe
They shut him down because it’s unprofessional for a doctor to ask a patient questions like that, especially questions that might make her uncomfortable, if they’re not relevant to her case
@@starscreamapologist3003 she looked perfectly comfortable and even continued answering after they told him to stop asking
Honestly the fact that he’s asking questions and trying to understand is a whole lot better than just shutting down the whole conversation like his colleagues are doing.
I think people thought it was wrong he was questioning the kid and not asking the other adults
Fuck that someone should be asking the kid these questions so they can get to the bottom of what the fuck went wrong w them
There is nothing to understand XY = Male, XX = female, its binary and can't be changed simple as that.
no its isnt, that was not the time of place to have a conversation like that they were in the middle of treating a patient. he could have had the conversation another time and with a different person if the girl didn't want to explain, trans people do not owe you or anyone else an explanation
The questions: "no hes not"
Nice question there
He just wants to understand. He’s not trying to be mean. He understands things in a factual sense, not emotional. So all he’s trying to do is figure out how her brain works so he can understand why she wants to be a girl. Same thing he does with every other patient, tries to figure them out. I love this show. Especially bc the girl was so understanding and happy to explain her point of view to him
Was her on her parents. These is caused by her parents that wanted a boy and never got one. So since they had a girl they told her repeatedly she is a boy. Her biology hobbies and preferences all show female girl no trans of any biological problem. Just parent problem that are propably the things from lgtb
The boy was understanding
@@mattt115yea be ignorant and hurtful and go fuck off
Yeah but its an emergency, you can ask whatever you want after the surgery is complete
“The boy”
The fact that he only got curious Instead of upset and the child seemed to be enjoying his questions is wonderful
Yeah. She seemed to understand that he (the doctor) didn’t fully understand and was just curious. (Also the questions probably helped with any nervousness. Distracting and all that.)
This is what tolerance should be. Not expecting everyone to follow your norms and thinking anyone that doesn’t is out to get you. -a trans person
He's acting pretty upset actually
I don't think he's malicious, he seems genuinely confused and curious
He's not curious he's spot on. It's the one laying down that's confused
He was concerned too, he probably knew it was testicular.
@@who399thanks for your opinion, no one asked
@crazynachos4230 another one triggered by truth...
@@crazynachos4230 it's not my opinion she has testicle cancer...
I like this. He's trying to understand gender dysphoria and how the whole gender thing works. He's not transphobic, just curious and eager to learn. And the girl is happy to educate him on the matter and very understanding. She knows he's different and she adapts. That's how the world should work. Curiosity, kindness and understanding.
the girl??😂
I wholeheartedly agree, I think it was a wholesome interaction all around.
He isn’t trying to understand..he is asking questions of what, in his mind, is typical girl behavior because he knows that everyone is wrong and it is a boy-who turns out to have testicular cancer..which, again, is his mind is something he learned happens to males.
He
W take
I love how later in the episode he says "She has testicular cancer" in the snarkiest way
Tell me which episode this is lmao
Dude no way it’s a episode
@n0ah24_7 yeah dude it's a whole TV series. The Good Doctor. It's about a doctor with autism. The creator of the show is an actor in it too, if you ever see the Asian doctor it's him.
@@n0ah24_7it is lol
BAHAHAHAHA
He was just genuinely confused and also curious. He wasn’t being mean just being straight forward. Respect
At the end the kid was just enjoying his questions for her honestly
they cut the best part where he said ''well... SHE has testicular cancer.'', you're right though
* him
*him
@@MeZi326her*
It’s a her bf if she wants to be a her she can be whatever she wants
“20 questions are up”
“I only asked 4” hahaha 🤣 love him
To many questions 😂😂
That's what my answer would be too.
I’m autistic to and this is kinda true, also that girl has testicular cancer
@@eternity303. You mean boy.
@@B.A.B.G.no no, girl*
Trying to understand each other's perspective is so much more constructive than just making assumptions.
THIS COMMENT >>
That's what the episode is about
True
Is he serious!😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@mr.nuggit8240While I fundamentally agree with this ideology, I believe this episode is also trying to express how autism makes it harder to understand these kinds of subjects.
People can think what they want but when it comes to medicine, biology really matters.
But it doesn't hurt anyone to use the correct name and pronouns so why not?
@@Tanner-v1w
"Correct pronouns"
Names, I understand because name is something you can change and a name being "masculine" or "feminine" doesn't really have an objective base but pronouns are not like that, they are supposed to help you identify a subject's characteristics.
@@holyromanemperor420Yep, and if they present as masc or fem, what pronouns do you use?
@@Tanner-v1wI don’t use their pronouns I tell them to grow up
@@UNDRGRNDOFFICIAL you just used the pronoun "their", meaning you *do* use pronouns for people. i do not see your point
"IM NOT SUPPOSED TO BE SOMTHING i'm a boy"
the best part
Yes
Makes me wonder if I am autistic because that is how I see it. I have no clue what it feels like to be a girl. It’s just a statement of fact that I am. I had no say in the matter.
@@Winterbaby1977 you're not autistic this is what normal feels like. We all are same
@@Winterbaby1977this has nothing to do with autism autism doesn’t make you transphobic . The point the show is trying to show is autism’s lack of regualr understanding as other humans to emotional sensitivity and typically saying what’s on their mind . You are not autistic just because you’re transphobic 😅dumbest thing I’ve read today
@@Winterbaby1977 so your autistic because you don't know what it feels like to be a girl?
“20 questions are up!”
“I only asked four-“
That got me😭
Most relatable line I've seen today..
Nah like.. fr let him ask his questions. They dont hurt her and it’s helping him.
@@Suprxme_E I think you mean to say "They dont hurt him* and it helps him."
This "girl" ended up having testicular cancer. Science always tells the truth
@@daniflorin5350 Her*
His line of questioning was so pure.
No, he's just a transphobe.
@@BlackEpyon fam you foreal? He's autistic in the show. Kid didnt even understand sarcasm in the first episodes
@@BlackEpyonhe is not scared what do you mean?
@@BlackEpyon there's no such thing as transphobe since there's no such thing as trans
California be shaking rn lol 😆
“how do you know you’re a boy!?”
“i’m not…. I AM A SURGEON, DR. HAN”
I 🦐🦐🦐 AM A STURGEON 🦐🦐
@@thatdude9091 YOU ARE A SURGEON 🥟🥟🥟
@@BRXIGYOU'RE A SURGEON
@@ammaargotgame HOLY FUCK IM A SURGEON
I AM A SURGEON 😭😭😭🤬😡🤬
I love how Quinn didn’t get all pissy when Shawn was asking questions and saying that stuff and she answered his questions❤❤
When asked “other than biologically, how do you know you’re supposed to be a boy?” And he answers “I’m not supposed to be anything. I’m a boy that’s it.” is quite an eye opener. We aren’t supposed to be anything, we are just what we are.
yes and transgender people are what they are
Exactly
And nobody knows what’s in anyone else’s pants, so let people present however they want.
Yes and made up rules in the form of gender roles were putnin place, like societal boxes basedmon what is between your legs
@@AJHornet1the problem is not in the individual self perception, it's when they force everyone else to participate in their own self perception, and even start insulting people who don't comply
Honestly they should have let him ask his other 16 questions
If it is appendicitis, they need to not waste time. If it bursts, the kid could die.
@@leannemori9688 it was testicular cancer
@@leannemori9688nigga it’s a show 😂
@@leannemori9688house being intentionally dense:
Even this guy with autism understands that there is only a man and a woman.
In this scene they find out that it's testicular cancer for anyone wondering
😂
XD
@@pq44animations56 bro you are funny as hell you had me dying for like 5 minutes straight
Female testicles are complicated.
Haaaaaa.
bro woke up and said "🗿 day"
🗣️🔥🔥🔥W comment
for u guys wondering what happened quinn ended up having testicular cancer 💀
"Im a girl" like man shut the fuck up if you have testicles and xy chromosomes you are a fucking boy
Oh...
Thanks for that 💀👍
That’s sad
What
This kid understands he has autism and respectfully answers the questions without taking offence
Edit: Why so much hate just don't comment if your gonna be rude about it
Why are people talking about this like it isn't fiction?
@@lpschaf8943 I know its fiction
@@humanperson758 Yep. Still sounds odd to me the way the most comments here are written.
except the kid ends up having testicular cancer... which is something a girl can't do.
@@mateusloubachbro named matt
I like how he was genuinely interested and intrigued at the end
Then he'll be the Surgeon who cuts off her penis
@@ProblematicBella they are not people they are in fact Things.
What happens is that Quinn or whatever has testicular cancer or smth
@@firewyrm3964 you treat it lmfao, we've had gender transitions for decades you clod
@Byoink only one gender gets treated for testicular cancer and that's the males
I'm with The Autistic guy
me too
First off, it's "I am with the Doctor with Autism" if you are referring without knowing his name, grammatically that's correct
Second, if this is a transphobic comment, screw you and keep your utterly horrible "opinion" to your damn self
Third, it's natural to question your sexuality or gender, the Q in LGBTQ stands for "Questioning", to think you dislike transgender people is just an ass thing to say, Quinn biologically is male but *she* identifies as female, born male assigned as female, no phase, a phase my ass, sex is what you are born with, *not* gender
Until the next scene
gender ≠ sex
@@JoeMama-td6tq Just some context to the transphobes, I am pretty sure they mean "gender doesn't equal sex"
You are welcome assholes
JoeMama (still funny even here), I am with you!
He’s not a boy..
HE IS A SURGEON
I AM A SURGEON
😂😂😂
He would disagree because biologically he's a boy not a surgeon 🙄 how does someone biologically become a surgeon?
Asir jean
@@niqabinextdoor3045r/swoosh
“Your question doesn’t make sense” he says in the most anxious way ever
He's right
@@rick3593blah blah blah just say your edgy already
His question doesn’t make sense because he’s about science. He’s a medical professional that isn’t a psychologist and he speaks that way because of his level of autism. Maybe instead of making fun of how someone speaks, you listen and learn
@@plantkidd_how is agreeing with something right ..edgy ,biology is first before emotions ...and emotions are built in by biology ..so if one is biologically a male and or female ..you cant and will never change that
@@plantkidd_he is still right. Normal people don't go around being obsessed about their own gender identity. They just are.
Bro is the definition of “keepin it real”
He’s autistic this is not a chosen behaviour
He was genuinely curious, I hate that they shut him down just like that.
You are not supposed to question this.
@@christuspilatus and why shouldn't anyone question it? if no questions are asked, where can we get any answers? the kid's still young and figuring the world out, and kid's allowed to explore things. So is Shaun, he's figuring out something he doesn't understand, why can't he have questions when the very person who can give very personalised answers is just right there and ready to provide insights. He's learning, and isn't malicious, whoever stops this learning process should consider themselves narrow-minded. Pretty ironic.
@@floofrules no, that's why the ppl where shutting him downxD he was not supposed to ask questionsxD
If you ask me personally I say ask away. 🤷 idgaf
Facts are more important than feelings
@@floofrules he literally stated his own feelings regarding someone else's gender as "the absolute truth " without considering if he is even completely correct about it. So this kind of question basically functions as nothing but a dismissal of that little kid's life experience. I'm autistic too and at some point we also have to learn that asking intrusive questions is a bad thing and hurts other people whose experiences are different from our own
Watch the episode
As a recently diagnosed autistic person, I highly understand his curiosity. For ages I've wanted to know why I am the way I am and I did a BUNCH of research. Was super cool to learn
Ok cool i guess?
@@yoshikagesoriif you didn’t care why comment 😂
cap, hop on rehab u got a lobotomy for breakfast
@@yoshikagesorishut up
Giggity goo
i love how the girl understands that murphy's questions arent meant to degrade and shame her but rather they were simply out of pure curiousity
No Dr Murphy is just based
Him
Boy
@@TM-wm7omyou have an obsession
@@garay9996 so do you, get a grip. It's not your life why do you care so much
Kid : I'm not a boy I'm a girl.
Me : Then you won't be needing that. ✂️
She’d probably be chill with that so long as it was done safely
@@otherlegoHe'd*
@@Manwithaplanderlinde according to your videos, you dont look much older than 13 at most... probably less. get outta here
@otherlego yet if a thirteen year old boy wanted to ✂️ their balls because he was thinking he was a girl your fine with it 🤔
@@otherlegobuddy you support transitioning at a young age go on somewhere.
"they shouldn't have shut him down"
they're in a hospital scenario, they wont always have the time to entertain his questions lol
It's not like it's dying!
Also it's a TV SHOW!
It's not like it's Dying!
It's a hospital show which means they should be going based by biology.ex your want not going to check trans woman if "she's" pregnant if they come in with a bloated stomach
@@joshuaoverlord5327 I understand how one may come to that conclusion, but in fact in US hospitals they will respect the gender identity of patients coming in for a few reasons. Firstly, history of identity and transition, as well as documented gender dysphoria (ICD-10 F64.0) are extremely important to a case study. In addition, using a patient’s preferred pronouns and name are some of the easiest ways to alleviate gender dysphoria and ensure the patient stays in a stable (and possibly improving) mental state throughout their stay.
I thought it was cute when he ran up after he had thought about it and wants to ask a lot of questions. I like that he changed into wanting to understand why or how. Pretty cool to try to understand and communicate and not just shut someone out after your opinion.
He’s flummoxed
It's not opinion that he's a boy, it's a fact. He is a boy. XY chromosomes means a boy. Boys have different medical concerns than girls. If a girl in the orphanage says she's a princess, that doesn't make it true.
This is so dumb Lmao
autistics are naturally curious about things we don't understand
@@slushybongwateri really don’t mean to be a snowflake but i think calling people with autism “autistics” is a bit dehumanizing.
As someone who has autism you do wanna ask 20 questions to someone who's new to you and you are curious.
The actor portrayed autism in a way that I can understand the perspective
Holy shit i think i have autism why is that always my first reaction to meeting ppl
My problem with this scene is that he's supposed to be a good doctor but he doesn't know what gender dysphoria is
@@Zamu273 since he has autism even if he did learn it in school he probably didn’t understand it then either
@@sunberry1792 the show portrays it as if he's never heard of it in his life. Remember that he has savant syndrome so he probably would understand what it is. I'd overlook it if it was an isolated thing but the show infantelizes him a LOT. For example when someone has to explain what a lie is to him. It's just unnecessary and it's clear a lot of the time the people writing it doesn't understand what they're working with... That's my main problem with the show
@@Zamu273he was just stating the facts 👍
“ I’m not supposed to be anything, I am a boy”
The wholesomeness in their interaction made me cry. He just wants to understand, and she's answering his questions, knowing that is what he is doing. If everyone approached everything like this, imagine how better the world could be.
@alfamejeu7237 I don't know if you realize this, but there is no "normal". What you may consider normal, someone else will consider crazy, and vice versa. The problem isn't that people aren't "normal", the problem is that people think they need to judge others about things that are none of their business. Just because some people are unhappy with their lives and feel the need to bring down everyone else, instead of finding something that makes them happy. Find a hobby and stop being miserable. 🙄🙄🙄
@@cherinuchell4578 there is a normal, everyone is born female or male, that’s normal. People like you are delusional or support those delusional people, you’re a harm to society. Get help.
@@alfamejeu7237normal is relative. I learned young that everyone sees EVERYTHING differently
@@cherinuchell4578he is a boy
@@alfamejeu7237why? Better for who? For you?
There’s this beautiful scene at the end where he decides to float in a pool, literally, after hearing her say being able to present as herself let her feel like her weight was lifted, like she was floating in a pool. Someone asks him what he’s doing, and he just says ‘understanding’
Him*
as a trans person this episode and especially this scene had me BAWLING
@@zombifiedgaming6485nope 😊
Which movie/show?
@@akshayamahadevan6743the good doctor
I love that. "I'm not supposed to be anything."
Unironically great answer.
Great answer. People need to accept this simple fact: there are feminine men, and masculine women. Sorry.
@@InfamousAMH Which are you?
That’s how I feel.
@@cheezitfargworth Neither. Just a man with man-like traits. Only thing special about me is ADHD and ASD 😂
He's casually having a panic attack about this-
He's not having a fucking panic attack, he's just curious.
We should all have a panic attack about it my dear
this is just how the actor is trying to portray the characters autism
Cause he's the only one being honest.
makes sense. that little boy is doomed and everyone like him.
I love that he's asking questions because he's genuinely curious & wants to understand.
He is genuinely curious, and he does want to understand, but I think he wants to understand "why ""he"" thinks ""he"" is a girl.". Because from his point of view, he can't seem to understand the transition from one gender to another. It's not necessarily his fault. It's more of society's.
Sorry. I'm not good at explaining things in text form.
No, he wants to prove to the boy that he is male.
But he's still right tho.
@@MiraAlmoqbali girl you’re wrong as fuck. 🤣💀 and you clearly have not watched any of this nor do you understand how his brain works, so why are you even sayin anything
@@0rin1sg0dif a boy wants to be a girl it’s the parents trying to get them to be that way and telling them it’s ok even though it makes no sense biologically or in any other way besides the fact that if you do think that you are a girl when you are clearly a boy then you are mentally I’ll and need help
Its actually important for medical attention to know the real sex
It's pretty much the only situation when it is important.
@@Chronologist89 yikez
@@trolldestroyer9988 I'm gonna do to my body whatever I please!
@@Chronologist89 for you cuz u get no bitches so no one else wants to know your real gender
@@Chronologist89 You're one of them?
Dr Murphy is da GOAT 🐐
Stoopid
people be really saying people are the “goat” because, supposedly, making fun of gender dysphoria is funny…
@@MisdroHe just didn’t know what it was, ended up being supportive in the end of the episode, calling her she and saying “she’s more of a purple kind of girl” I’m pretty sure
@@Misdro the kid is just delusional she should get some mental help
@@Misdro cause you cant feel like a woman being a man. It is by definition not possible
Dr. Murphy isn't a male, *_HE IS A STURGEON_*
HELP IM CACKLING HAHAHAHAH🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Name please
A sturgeon is a type of fish…
*HE IS A SURGEON*
*DOCTOR LUCASISHERE*
*HE IS A SURGEON*
@@dragonofdestiny8321good job for knowing that I guess
Aww man you cut out the part I find funniest. “Well SHE has testicular cancer” always has me dying lmfao
They did the same thing in house but it was a guy who was immune to testosterone instand of trans
Kinda weird that you’re dying over a cancer diagnosis but I fw it 😂
@@godzillaplayz5235At least it's not real
@@godzillaplayz5235its irony
@@moter1533 cancer is stored in the balls
The fact they get acquainted more due to his quest of wanting to find the reasoning of why, but upsets me that his colleagues just wanted to shut him up. He has autism and she obviously can see it and felt at ease answering his intriguing genuine harmless curiosity
She's a he not a she
@@EnclaveSgt "She's a he"? then why did you use she?
@@EnclaveSgtCope
@@agentswrath So the LGTV people could follow along the conversation
@@paddybarber477 seethe harder, it won't make it true
Guys remember, if some one says XY chromosomes are both genders in one, they are wrong, XY chromosomes are a male, and for females, they have XX chromosomes so that means XY chromosomes are not something else than a male so that means its 2 genders.
Dr murphy: I am not supposed to be anything.
Also dr murphy: I AM A SURGEON
It's sad that you can't comprehend the huge difference between those two statements.
@@darksoul3439 nah man he’s a surgeon
HE STURGEON 👹👹
@@darksoul3439no way u taking this serious 💀💀💀
What is this show called? Also, where can I watch it?
If the kid was willing to answer his questions, then the only insensitive ones are his colleagues for shutting him up
In his collegues defense they are in a hospital on the clock
Well, yes, but they are in a hospital scenario so.
But is the doctor trans. Everyone’s trans today even you and me . Weeeeeeee! Trans
@@goofybatz So you mean that in a hospital people are not supposed to ask personal assertive questions to diagnose someone?
@@Mostbee he was asking questions about her being a girl, not really important. Sure, maybe after they'd treated her he could ask but..
It’s kinda wholesome that even tho he doesn’t understand, he’s very curious and wanted to learn
He’s just sigma he understand more than half the people in this world
@@Ravie.why did u have to bring up "sigma" dawg that ain't u man 😭😭
What's there to learn about a mental illness
Science exists for some reason.
@@Christopherson2006 chromosomes define sex, not gender, and actually there is more than just xx and xy, take intersex people for example, they don’t have just xx or xy so the idea of sex being binary in itself is false.
Then there’s the gender debate, gender is a social construct, we apply male to xy and female to xx. If we look at history there are many examples of cultures that believed in more than 2 genders like Hawaiian culture believe there were 3. We’re so used to the way gender is presented as being directly linked to sex when it in reality is linked to psychology and how the person feels they want to present themselves, the way it’s taught is outdated.
@@Christopherson2006so first you underexposed little idiot, there are 3 biological genders and second, what you mean is gender identification. There are like 71 ore something of them. You little middle ages clown🤡🤡
bro was really interested 💀
My takeaway from this is, instead of continuously denying her claim about her gender or dismissing it altogether, he tried to understand her and her condition. He didn't tease, bully or fear her. He gave her a chance to explain herself. As it should be when we don't understand something.
"He" has a testicular cancer
@@Mosa-gx4cdyou obviously don’t understand the difference between Sex&Gender. Go back to school.
@@soulresonance4073🙄
@@soulresonance4073 sorry my school actually teaches me science and not weird sexual behavior. But I do know that sex is based on biology and gender is just a delusion made by the left.
@@soulresonance4073and you didn’t understand their comment “he” or she who tf cares had testicular cancer
I love the Good Doctor and how they approach topics like this. It's never from a place of malice with Dr Murphy, everyone else may be a dick but Shaun is always doing things out of the curiosity of his heart
However, transfolk constantly get questioned by hateful dickhats who are trying to dredge up more ammo to attack and hurt them with. So while everyone may understand that he's not trying to be hurtful, NOT trying to be hurtful doesn't mean you aren't being hurtful. So it's still best to kind of stop him and instead tell him to read up on it, there's a lot of documentation and interviews and such.
@@KayrielWith actual information, not just opinion… correct?
Your stupid.
Its not really,
The shows not really
Why are people so dumb
How do you get so emotional about a show created by old stright rich white men that you hate and yet praise them for there progressive shows that they feed you becuase your dumb enough to believe its real. God you are such a failer of a human.
@@Kayrielok but he’s correct he’s a dude not a girl
Bro don’t put that word in a chat there are little kids
this guy is an incredible actor hes able to portray a severely autistic person so unbelievably well
Really? Cause that looked like really terrible acting to me.
@@Squidlark i bet you'd perform better pal. Probably. Probably not ;)
@@rareflux I'm not an actor though.
@@Squidlark Yeah it's pretty close to someone on that section of the spectrum. Reminds me of my high functioning nephew where mine is far more low key and shows up in minor forms like sensory issues.
Have you ever met an autistic adult? 😅 This show is terrible.
the sturgeon cookin 🔥🔥
For all the people in the comments making this a transgender debate, the point of the Full clip is that the biological gender matters since the patient has testicular cancer. When it’s a matter of health and surgery, the fact is the patient is biologically still male, although they identify as female. It’s not about the Doctor being ignorant. Also the point of the show is that the doctor has autism so that might also be why he can’t comprehend gender identities
Edit: just realized auto correct happened the first time
someon told me there was recenty a trans man that died bc the ER staff didnt think to check for ectopic pregancy bc the patiet presenter themelves as male 🤷♀️ im sorry it happened, but it was a predictable event.
Gender identities? Are you trying to reduce Gender down to things like what clothes someone wears and what color they like? If so, you have 6 year old grasp on Gender.
@@luciddream2033 what?
@luciddream2033w ell, I am saying that it boils down to what you were born with.
That's it.
@@luciddream2033 I’m saying that the doctor in the clip can’t seem to comprehend what it means to identify as a different gender. No one mentioned colored clothing and it never was about clothing.
as an autistic person who genuinely still has difficulty understanding trans people and wants to genuinely learn but is afraid to ask, its truly nice to see that people are willing to be understanding and kind.
I am trans AND autistic, ama
I'm trans and diagnosed autistic, and I'd gladly help you out if you're still not informed :)
Trans are not real especially kids
@@_buhbuhbillyAlthough I may not be that particular fellow, I too am curious about trans people - or rather gender as as a whole. I dont tend to ponder about issues like these because I feel it's none of my business, and also because I feel like people are hyper polarized about things like this.
You see, I'd like to understand it as a whole. I know, rather complicated, but see, autism is a social disorder. One wouldnt expect someone who has a hard time understanding social things to understand social issues like this. One more thing I'm curious about is why do people think autistic people are like idc about gender, when thats.. yet again a social issue. 😢 My apologies if I'm asking a lot of you, im genuinely curious and id love to understand.
@@goldengail3418not a trans but I do talk with many trans people. I think u can see trans people like any other people suffering with mental issue because that's what they suffer: dysphoria. Just because most of us born with a penis or a vagina, that doesn't mean you feel like u should have it between your legs. There are in fact many trans people who suffer with urinary infection because they are so disgusted by their genitals that they even avoid pee! But I'm also talking from a medical perspective, of course there are many social layers into this topic and there's also genfluids, non-binaries, etc, but I'm gonna avoid this because I don't really know that much to be able to do so. Also, although trans people have a mental issue, that doesn't mean they are sick or have a disease and that they should accept the body they were born. Therapy to learn how to cope, hormones and surgery are the way to "treat" them, because just like austim, there is nothing wrong with being different. U just have to learn how to deal with your particularities, but there's ways and ways to deal with it. Also, there are ones who must do the surgery, others just feels like the hormones is enough, I'd say it really is an spectrum thus the need of therapy to undestand what's the best solution for each case
The kid was chill yet everyone else keeps freaking out
Because sometimes it’s not as simple as someone who genuinely doesn’t understand and is trying to. And to people who are ignorant and still misgender them knowing their sexuality. She understands that he is trying to learn and not be rude. The doctors need to no for scientific reasons and treatment but they are also referring to them as she. Because they are a girl. They identify as a girl.
I love how he tries to understand why she feels like a girl ❤
It was a man.
I can't watch these clips without hearing "I AM A SURGEON! DR. HAN!!"
Nooo that’s so damn funny tho
I AM A SURGEON….
I. AM A SURGEON!!!
@@-DCComicEditor- I AM A SURGEON!!!
I AM A FISH
@German Japanese Fan I AM A STURGEON
I mean he really was just genuinely curious about their thoughts and why they were the way they are. And the girl didnt seem to mind answering
it’s a dude not a girl
men can’t magically turn into women and women can’t magically turn into men
a biological male just as a biological female can never change their XY or XX chromosomes respectfully, every chromosome, every cell in a body regardless of any surgery they undergoe will remain chromosomes and cells of the sex they were born with
trying to dispute this fact just makes you look like an idiot that accepts whatever the media tells them
boy*
*boy
@@operatorkore701*girl
@@shaydenprime275*girl
Shawn was just curious, let him ask his questions 😭
Even if the questions are belittling?
@@randomuploadsismthe kid could probably understand the doctor has autism, it's fine
@@randomuploadsism It's just common w
@@randomuploadsismbelittling? For asking a question that is based on fact and logic, unlike the trans bs?
@@randomuploadsism if you watch the show you would know he wasn't belittling he was trying to understand and at the end of the episode he figures it out and refers to quin by there preferred pronouns
The best bit was cut out, after the scan doctor Murphy says “well SHE has testicular cancer”
Murphy says “the patient doesn’t have appendicitis, he has testicular cancer” and the OTHER doctor says “….she”
Dr.Murphy is way too autistic to make a snide, joky comment like that lol. He’s too literal.
“I’m more of a purple girl” Bro summoned a whole fandom
Was that the sturgeon of 87?!?
i love purple!
I literally had to read it twice to get it, lol 😂
I love purple 💜
@@bruhbrehii you mean the fish?
It’s so cute how he’s trying so hard to understand
Understand why he's delusional saying he's a girl 💀
2hen its just a mental illness
understand some bullshit nigga
@@christopherjacquez8605he has autism
@@christopherjacquez8605why do you care? Is it your life? 😂 so worried about what other people do with THEMSELVES, that maybe if you didn’t, you’d be further in life
I loved this scene. It’s not made with malice, or to make fun of either autistic or transgender people. Dr. Murphy was curious about a concept he was unfamiliar with, and the girl seemed unbothered by his innocent questions. Fantastic writing here
Dr murphy is correct though
@@ggCA07Doctor Murphy is eventually accepting of her because he understands. Guess YOU still have some learning to do though.
*boy
@@JoeMama-1diothow are we the ones who need to learn when y’all can’t tell the difference between a girl and a boy 😂
@@willburgerrotmg2867 the difference is you don’t have gender dysphoria so you’re not trans.. cis people like you and i aren’t dysphoric of the bodies we were born with..
He isn’t wrong, it doesn’t matter if it’s a fucking zi/zir, we’re talking biologically. That’s the whole fucking point of this episode too.
Speaking about medical issues happening with someone's sex doesn't mean you can't use their preferred pronouns, that's just a dick move
@@krool_aid9835 he was just saying biologically. Also telling other people they have to call you what they want is also a dick move.
@@someguyxoxo8027 it isn't even necessarily hard. They can just call me by my pronouns, and still say that my sex is whatever. It isn't a lot of effort and it makes the patient a lot more comfortable. Forcibly not using them and making a huge point about it is just bringing unnecessary politics into the check up room. Who cares what you have to call your patient just to make them that little bit more comfortable and safe in a place like a hospital.
@@krool_aid9835 First this started by talking about biology alone and so you give up on that and agree hes right with that. Second you want the doctors that may be dealing with dire situations to make sure to add a extra calculation in their head to make sure when to say your biological sex and what you want to be? Doesn't seem like the best of ideas. Also "forcibly" you know that making someone say something they don't really want to say is more forceful then someone just saying a fact that is necessary, right? Who cares about what you want to be called just let the doctors do what they need to safe you from awful illness and even death.
@@someguyxoxo8027 the thing is it's barely even a matter of passing. That girl *looks* like a girl. That doctor specifically looked at her files, and called that girl by her sex, despite her wishes AND her presentation. Of course her sex is male, everybody in the room knew that, but they were still calling her by her preferred pronouns. The actual comment implies that doctor is in the right for calling some girl in a medical setting a man because it's "biologically correct" or whatever. Nobody said that you need to ignore their biological sex, it's just not that hard at all to call that girl she/her. Doctors should be the least bit flexible, especially in the US where every time you go to the hospital nothing is done and your bill is like $10,000+. God forbid you want the doctor to treat you with basic decency and minimum respect.
Both patient and Dr Murphy have humble intent to learn and understand. This is admirable.
And its sadly more than can be said for most transphobes
Learn and understand what? Mental disorders?
It’s honestly a really fair representation of the linear thinking that many people with ASD have. I appreciate how the kiddo in this scene entertains the questions and tries to answer honestly while still asserting she’s a girl.
... they cut out the part where he had testicular cancer. Reality set in hard for their kid.
Answered both honestly and it looked like she genuinely enjoyed being asked about her femininity. I haven't seen the episode but I'd like to know if she got to ask him questions about being autistic. From what little I've seen of the show, I think he'd be happy to answer her questions in turn.
Yeah well HE is a boy. So yeah
@@Minnesota_Central Shaun? I thought he was a surgeon. :P
@@AgentNintaku yes him as well quite perceptive of you.
She seems to understand that he has autism and seems to be happy that he is trying to understand what makes her feel like a girl, he is trying to understand which is a lot more than most people who don't understand try to do
Wait he (the doctor) has autism
@@Jame-fs2zg yes
@@ShroomPrincess988 ohh that explains alot
there is nothing deep to understand
Copied comment
Bro I swear he started flirting when he was askin the questions
I love the way he says that “I’m not suppose to be anything”
Technically, the kid is supposedly an human 🤓
@@Wellshema Boy
Bcs HE IS SURGEON
You're not supposed to be anything. You're a boy there is no deeper purpose to the fact You're male. It's just a fact and you can't change that. XY vs XX once you find a way to change the chromosomes in every single one of your cells then tell me you can change your gender.
@@navidvarzeghani2789 🤓🤓🤓
That was so cute when he started asking the questions 😭😅 the kid seemed excited to answer and the doctor was excited to know
But he is not professional. He was supposed to do his job instead of keep asking unrelated questions. He should have kept his questions for after the procedures.
@@amohogride3739Im saying tf and she didn't sound excited at all, just understanding.
@@amohogride3739 it’s just a show 😭
be quiet the doctor was extremely disrespectful
@@notyayanguyen1735he’s autistic and curious let him be
I love how the patient was so patient with his questions, patient ppl are the best
Kirby
Anyway ball cancer
The patient was patient
@@pavlokagioglu8724 the most patient patient of all
@@coolmanwee8138 the patient patients are getting too patient
Bro won the whole choccolate factory just to become a doctor
“How do you know you are supposed to be a boy?”
“ because i have a di-“
And BA-
"and then i'm a girl cause i have puss-"
A beard
@@shlksye that's what boys have
And a wide body
Yall really acting like he wasn't screaming "I am a Surgeon" just about a week ago 😭
He has his moments lol
LMFAO HES AUTISTIC LEAVE HIM ALONE 😭😭🙌
Fr 💀
He's u h autistic and people with autism react in different ways
Oh gosh I remember that 🥲
Video cut out the part where Murphy says "not appendicitis, quinn has testicular cancer" 😅
Which is why biology matters.
Respecting ones gender identity does not mean ignoring biology
@@justcallmejessz3712 except after bottom surgery where your logic fails entirely... also neurochemistry matters a shit ton aswell
@@justcallmejessz3712 facts
@@thegoosling8947 bottom surgery does not remove or add anything biological. A male to female surgery removes an appendage and adds a wound. Medically speaking, top or bottom surgery actually creates another reason your doctor needs to know.
@@thegoosling8947 you can have a sex change and all the surgeries you want but it still doesnt change your chromosomes X & Y/X & X. Your anatomy can change but your biology cant. Humans arent natural hermaphrodites like snails, thats why we call it human mutation in genes when it does happen.
Bro was so down bad he had to confirm the human’s gender
Doctor: "Sir.."
Patient: "It's Ma'am!!"
Doctor: "Ma'am.. You have testicular cancer"
*dead*😂
cringe joke, find something new
An oldie but a goodie... too bad it's all the time now
@@iwannadie2919 real
2016 called, they want their shitty joke back
"How do you know you're supposed to be a boy?"
"I'm not a boy, I'M A SURGEON"
I AM A STURGEON
DOCTOR HAN
DOCTOR HAN, U AM A SURGEON
@@Nuclear_Microwave "u am" 💀
@@thhndy SURGEON HAN DOCTOR AM U