Every Islamic country is filled with this type of hate. It's mandatory in Islam to hate the infidel. Muslims out of India and Israel! Meir Kahane was right!
Watch the other videos of Palestinians talking. I wish this was true but majority only see peace if Israelis did not exist and all Israel was Palestine. That's the meaning of peace to a majority of them, sadly. They don't see sympathy for Israelis and they don't believe in compromise.
+Ahmad A. Thabata That's a last gasp from a loser Ahmad and a view shared by many losers. Every day Israel exists is a true victory over medievalism thinking and stalemates. The problem with empires, is that when a power loses it , it never stops dreaming in getting it back, but never does. proof? The Romans? The Ottomans? The Persians?, The Nazis? The British? The Soviets? Good bye. The Moslems have lost their empire over a hundred years ago. they've achieved very little since. Think about it.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
We did jihad in Egypt till Golda Maer cried asking for US help then we took them behind the factory chair in Camp David 1979. Jihad has many forms. Fights and war is one of them. Diplomatic pornography is another form, referring to taking Begin to a gang bang with the Americans
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
I am a Muslim from Malaysia and i am saddened by the hatred and suspicion..on both sides. I just pray that the rational ones from both sides somehow gradually outnumber the loonies. And i was utterly amazed by the female student who refused to condemn the killing of innocent Israelis.
Israeli occupiers are not innocents Palestinians are real owners time will soon come insha Allah when will erase the Zionist Occupier Israel occupiers will have to return forcefully or willingly to the Country Where they came from This is happen insha allah
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's....
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
+smootskin in an absence of the ""palestinian" supporters..", what exactly would you do? how would it change the situation? still, the fact that even among liberal minded folks none couldn't say it is amazing.
sunshin3man I would request the so called "Palestinians" to protest to their leaders and request an end to the bloodshed and to start negotiation without conditions. Can you show me a peace protest in Gaza or in the West bank? Not organized by a Left wing Jewish organization, but by themselves!
+smootskin so, you are saying that "the supporters" do not allow you to make the request? i still can't see your point. i do not know of any peace protests in Gaza nor West bank. i believe it is somewhat similar to the fact you don't see protests in Iran, North Korea, or how protests go in Russia.
Ay Yu It's only "typical" because be it clowns, or demented bees or faux Mickey Mouses, we see how the Arabs teach their children. We joke to keep from crying for the kids,,,
Honestly, I think 99% of the issue with this is that they're being asked to do something that sounds like a soundbite, specifically about the Israelis. I feel most of them are likely avoiding it purely out of fear of retaliation from extremists, rather than a genuine hatred toward innocent Israelis. Had the question simply been "I condemn the killing of innocents, including Israelis and Palestinians", then I think there would have been much more success. But at the same time, there is a lot of ignorance present in Palestine, more so than in Israel itself, and that certainly encourages some more hateful and hostile views (particularly amongst those who think all Israelis are terrible people simply because they have never seen an Israeli that wasn't a soldier). Palestine and Israel just need to be educated about each other, rather than remaining cut off from each other and reinforcing false views of each other. I would honestly wonder what would happen if the interviewer had reported about having already asked the Israelis about it to the group of women, and the men toward the end.
+Mark Simons They can. But they're afraid not only of speaking but also of their own thoughts. It's clear in the video. But also, I think the question in itself is wrongly done.
Many are afraid to get in trouble with their government or their fellows. But their religion clearly tells them killing innocent civilians is wrong. I know at least that much about Islam. Reasonable imams will tell you that terrorists are not even truly Muslim in the true sense of the word in that they are not submitting to God's word.
Muhammad said "The Jews will fight with you, and you will be given victory over them so that a stone will say, 'O Muslim! There is a Jew behind me; kill him! "
I find it quite hypocritical that when asked about the killing of a 9 year old Palestinian, the Israeli guy got of by saying that he condemns all kids being killed, but when the Palestinian guy said the same thing,it wasn't enough.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
I'm so pissed off at this translator, he's misquoting. Plus, the cameraman lied, not all the Israelis who were asked to did the same did. Don't make these vids pretending to be neutral.
+yennen cant be bothered to watch the whole thing but there was a lady sitting at the start who was talking and the translator misinterpreted her, when she was asks if she condemns the killings he said she said "its not a bad thing" but its out of context, that's not what she meant.
Tyran Pesut I understood that she could speak Arabic; I take objection to her suggesting, that she knew what that Phonystinian meant; which implies, not a problem with the translations, but rather holding a greater understanding of the woman's comments.
No offense to your translator, but being a fluent Arabic and English speaker I can easily tell that the people speaking in Arabic ARE having a harder time understanding the question than wanting to say yes because the word innocent if being swallowed. A better phrased question would be to ask Palestinians what they think of innocent Israelis being killed by Palestinians, and then make sure they understand that you are talking about absolutely innocent people, not soldiers. I feel like more people will condemn the killings that way. Same thing with the Israelis, but I don't know hebrew so I cannot judge. thank you very much! I enjoy your videos!
Josh Sertic I don't know which history book you read but the crusaders came from Europe and not Palestine. Thats not fending against aggression by any stretch.
J walking So from your standpoint you are saying that it is permissible to allow Palestinians to wage jihad on their neighbors to "fend against aggression" but yet you do not believe it is permissible for Europe to wage crusades against their neighbors to "fend against aggression". Right, I'm glad you stand on such a moral high-ground that you can choose who is right and moral and who is wrong and evil.
The first European crusades took place because the Umyyad Caliphate instigated war by marching to the gates of Europe, and they killed, raped and enslaved all in their wake. The first crusade was launched by Christendom after the Umyyad Caliphate had started aggressions against the Byzantine Empire and against Christians in Hispaniola. The first crusade was launched to retake Christian land that was forcibly taken by Arabs. It's too bad the Arabs are sore losers, they instigated war and they lost. I'm not sure which history book you're reading from but it probably is just about as historically accurate as your depiction of history in the Middle East. I'd just like to thank you for having no idea about any of the history you are arguing about, and also degrading this debate to nothing more than slandering. Maybe you should do more reading than speaking, it'll do you some good.
it's sad that these people are too scared to say this to the camera because they're afraid of the people around them getting them in trouble. Good to see that support for these things is going down, although it is still very high. Not surprised in a region with so much tension though.
as muslims we don't have an issue with jewish, our problem with Israel as a country in palastine land. Return the land to palastinians and you have the right to live under their roles in peace or someday even after 1000 years we should have it back and by the end " what was taken by force, can only be restored by force". KEEP IT IN YOUR MIND
Most Arabs arrived when Jews started growing apples the size of cantaloupes and they saw it was better living then many Arab regions they formerly inhabited. It was NEVER a sovereign Arab country, the terms Palestine was a Roman word paying homage to the long deceased group called the Philistines. Virtually any and every ancient artifact found there is bears Jewish origin. At the same time Arabs fled to Palestine for a better life, Jews were kicked out of nearly every Arab land. There was never a Palestinian people with a unique language or place of origin or culture. Unlike the Jews who originated there.
In terms of Arabs arriving when Jews began arriving, you can look at Ottoman census records and see that these claims are exaggerated. 1) The Arab riots that in 1929, and later in 1930s came about as a result of the landlords(located in Damascus and other places) sold their lands to Jewish organizations. Arab serfs did not own the land and the Jewish organizations wanted them moved or gone.
- Your summary of Ahmad Menasra's story is not accurate and putting it like that makes it seem like the killing, torturing and violence that Palestinian kids see is not real. - As an Arabic speaker, I can tell that the man translating was not confirming the "innocent" part properly and his voice was low. This invalidates some of the answers. The lady translator was good.
Just saying. The guy answered your question in many different ways. He is against the killing of any child whether Israeli or Palestinian. Answering your specific question would have contradicted his answer to you.
24:21 A "Palestinian refugee since 1948"? Is he joking? He wasn't born in 1948! Maybe his parents or grand parents were refugees, but he obviously was born in the west bank and he grew up there. So, he is a citizen, NOT A REFUGEE, of the west bank. Period. How can you be refugees for 3 generations? Move on people. Don't stagnate in the past. Release it. You are here now. This is your country and this is your home...wherever "this" is: west bank, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, Egypt....The US, Canada, ...wherever you ended up.
"I forgot the Arab superstition of not telling someone your mother's name in public". That's an extremely racist statement Corey. That was very insensitive of you, I mean the guy's mom was killed, so it's much more likely a personal reason that prevented him from saying her name. But immediately you attribute it to some stereotype about Arabs. Your bias really shows in these videos. Disliked.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
Well if you put so many restrictions on the people of Palestine no wonder they are bred with hate, give them same rights as Israeli's and in 10 years all will be different.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
The problem here is that many Palestinians are wrongly interpreting the question to have something to do for the resistance as a whole rather thn the individual killing of an innocent person.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's. so most of the pali's thought he was talking about the "soldiers" not the civillians,the translation is also unclear and swallows the word innocent as if asking for it,I was also confused at first.
Curious why several people said they were against it, but when asked to use the word condemn, wouldn't. Does this word have other connotations? Or is it like how many Muslims will say that ISIS's actions are against Islam, but won't say they aren't Muslims because that is for God alone to judge?
You're right! There are so many different views and mindsets in islam so we cant be sure thats the reason they wouldn't say it. But I have been thought that its sinful to use the word "condemn" about anyone. Its also not a commonly used word for people that don't speak english that well so why not use the word "against" instead? Some in the video even say they are against, but he insist that they use the word "condemn" as if he knows that its not something they can easily say
The position is really very simple. We are off down the killing road - fact! The only way to change it is to stop making it Us Vs Them. The sooner smart people go after the root cause of the problem, the faster we will see progress. The blame game gets you nowhere.
Well, one thing is clear. Each side is very good at explaining its own side of the story and listing its own victims. And neither side is very good at admitting that the other side might have a point or its own version of the story or innocent civilians.
one of the major problems are issues like that in 10:50 and 11:42, there are good palestinians but they fear to say what they think because of their society and surrounding. this is one of the issues that both the Israel government and the Palestinian national authority are not trying to solve and even talk about it in the media.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
@@raghadradi8840 Yeah he's trying to come up with a softer way to ask his fellow arabs the querstion and their answers look worse when you see the question in the video title
@@JBrooksNYS no he wasnt,he doesnt speak arabic well I had a hard time getting it, which was why they look confused when answering,and he keeps swallowing the word "innocent" so it seemed like he was asking about the government/soldiers not the civillians,he asked them if it was right for a palestinian army to plan operations? the lady especially meant she doesnt want the civillians killed,but then he changed it and said "do you think pali soldiers should plan and fight?" obviously anyone's answer would be yes. this isnt the first time this translator did this.he did it alot,so I recommend watching the new video's instead with the new female translator her translations are defintly clearer.
@@raghadradi8840 ive seen most of the videos. I know there are many comments on this male translators videos about bad translations. I thought he was being biased rather than simply not speaking arabic well
Feel like lots of them couldn't say the exact phrase out of being scared of others around them- one of the women even told exactly that, she could not say it because she was scared about how others around who would hear her would react, although saying she was against it; and if she was like that, many of the others might be as well. Also I do not speak Arabic so I don't know how people interpreted the question and how the translator conveyed it and their answers for that matter.
This video just shows the difference and attitude between a tribal society "Palestine" and an individualistic one "Islrael". The Palestinians care more about other people's opinion about them whereas Israelis don't.
17:53 Ahmad and his cousin have committed a stabbing, " according to Israeli intelligence", his cousin has been left bleeding till death, while ahmad has been recovered in a hospital 'Israeli hospital' because he has the Israeli id. the footage of Ahmad bleeding while Israelis insult him was very humiliating. The girls meant Mohammed Abu Khdeir who was burnt ! Dawabshi Family have the same fate.
Children, babies , Women -you know all these groups that Palestinians (Arabs) kill without mercy en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_suicide_attacks
It's simple, for every 1 killed israeli civilian there's 15000 killed palestinian civilians, not saying killing innocent people is alright but thats why they don't condemn it, most of them have memories of loved ones killed by Israel so that takes over their thinking, also they don't see israeli's out in the streets condemning and protesting about the killing of innocent palestinians, which is a thing that's done on a weekly if not daily basis by israeli soldiers.
and whose fault is that? that so many innocent Palestinians have died, never wage war when you can't protect your people. Poor strategic planning or Hamas just doesn't give a fuck about the Palestinian people.
@@wngdhssr they never accepted a loss and keep blaming the stronger side, even worse is the libleft supporting them - so their whining is justified...they will never build something and have progress if that's their mindset
any arab and pro-palestine person who i asked what will be the solution to the problem after a debate, they can't tell me anything rational. and what WILL be the solution? someone, GIVE ME A GOOD SOLUTION TO THIS PROBLEM THAT I WON'T BE ABLE TO COUNTER.
+Sami Seif and then what? you want to dismantle an entire nation of seven million people, an ally to the USA and a part of the UN.. a leading nation in technological development and scientific discoveries. what are you going to do with these people? on the other hand you have the palestinians, people who lived on that land which was already occupied by Britain. there was no nation there and Israel was allowed to be established there. If you condemn Israels' existence then by the same logic you should condemn the establishment of the US and give the land back to the indians.
+Sami Seif What the palestinians are referring to when they say that Israelis are killing their own is Israeli military forces trying to defend the country from terrorist attacks. Someone in the video even said "with what? we don't have anything to attack them with" bitch please, where do all those qassam rockets come from? alla's ass? Fact of the matter is that Israelis don't go around stabbing palestinians and driving them over or plant bombs in highly populated areas. They DELIBERATELY target civilian populations (which is a war crime), and not only that, the reason why majority of palestinians are killed in battle is because the terrorists HIDE AMONG their civilians in schools and homes.
+Nathan Ginzburg you didn't address any of his points. He didn't say the israeli's should leave he just said Israel should follow international law and give Palestinians their rights
+Tru Vids "How about Israel just follows international law and leaves all the land that it doesn't legally own" It does follow international laws, and it does own that land, who the hell do you think gave it to them. The didn't just come there and declare it theirs, they were allowed to and supported by the western nations. Once again, since there was no palestine this isn't called "taking over another nation" and ONCE AGAIN if you condemn Israel's existence then by the same logic you should pack your shit and move from the US
Nathan Ginzburg With every sentence you demonstrate that you know less and less about international law. The Israeli settlements in the West Bank and Gaza are illegal under international law. That's what the statement was referring to. And don't "once again" me, I don't condemn Israel's existence
Can you ask Israelis, do you think settling "illegally" in Palestinian territory is the root cause of the last few decades of violence? Also could you ask Israelis, do you think the civilian death tolls (israeli v palestinian) has been proportionate through-out the last 20 years?
Ask: Israelis if you (Jewish people's) have enough land to live in why you displace Palestinians from thier homes and do settlements there. Asks Palestinians: if you can't win back the land you believe is yours why don't you just accept the the two state policy so that you live peace with your children and at least prevent to loose everything and every land remains now.
it is not fair to ask the SAME question for the criminals (Israelis) which occupy Palestinians land and between the (Innocents) the Palestinians !! it is unacceptable!!
it's clear that a lot of these people are afraid and that there are not free to express their own opinions.I'm sure that they would prefer to live in peace if they could.
They can't, can they? Sadly all too many outside the conflict zone have difficulty too. I am happy to condemn the killing of innocent Israelis. Though I also condemn many of the actions of the IDF, and even worse the settlers - and especially the policies of the Netanyahu government that do not create any escape route for the Palestinians.
I don't understand the replies in the comments. The Palestanians said that they condemn the murder of children and women of Israeli OR Palestanian descent. Almost all of them said this. Yet people are calling them names and insulting them in the comments and saying stuff like "I kniew it!" wtf? Do you guys live in a bubble world where everything is reversed?
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's. so most of the pali's thought he was talking about the "soldiers" not the civillians,the translation is also unclear and swallows the word innocent as if asking for it,I was also confused at first.
Just compare the number of Palestinians killed to the number of isrealis ! A stark difference Last year alone more than 300 Palestinian children Women youth elderly Journalists paramedics were killed in cold blood and these people were unarmed having only slings and stones as their weapons against the army having the most sophisticated weapons .
+Jad Scape Ikr.. like theyre twisting what they say.. one time they condemn killing from both sides but then they cant even say that to the camera.. ridicilous
4:22-8:35 Abed: "I am against anyone hurting any other person. What idea he has, what passport...i dont give a shit" "Its not okay to kill anyone, Palestinian or Israeli" "I am absolutely against this" "I am against anyone hurting any kids, from any side. Its not the kids fault" "I condemn it, but i think Israel is worse" Corey: "You cant condemn it! Im asking a specific question, you cant answer it!" (this was 4 painful minutes to watch. I think the guy obviously tries to point out how he is against it, but he needs to watch his mouth when being on camera. Corey`s channel is good, but he cant control his emotions at times)
Now I get it. You're really smart! You must know that the "condemn" is a very big word in islam and some people even think its sinful to say about anyone? A lot of these people repeatedly say they are against the killing of innocent Israelis but you insist that they use the word "condemn" as if you know they cant say it!
Corey, fire your translator, he is terrible. I am an Arabic speaker and he has a hard time explaining to people what you mean. he can't even speak Arabic very well.
the note about ahmed manasra could have been better. his cousin had the primary role in the stabbing and was killed on the spot. israel bashers loved the video of israelis cursing at ahmed as he lay on the ground after being hit by a car. i would think the 3 women would have seen it. the boy was later shown in the hospital but i guess no arab media showed it. electronic intifada says the boys stabbed "a teen" and a man. the "teen" was 2 months away from his bar mitizvah riding his bike. ahmed was sentenced to 12 years but it was later shortened to 9.5
The question is simple enough. Can you speak to the camera and say " I condemn the killing of innocent Israelis"? People interviewed have a real problem in considering Israelis as being innocent. Some notably do it out of fear.Innocence in this context for some of those interviewed cannot be acknowledged. Some of the commentators on this thread are also having a problem with it. Thre lies the real problem and the person who wrote in to ask the question has produced revealing responses.
They seem to have a problem with considering Israelis as humans. They condemn killing of innocent people, but not of innocent Israeli Jews. So clearly the latter don't form a subset of "innocent people" in their mind.
The question is simple enough. Can you speak to the camera and say " I condemn the killing of innocent Nazis"? People interviewed have a real problem in considering Nazis as being innocent. Some notably do it out of fear. Innocence in this context for some of those interviewed cannot be acknowledged. Some of the commentators on this thread are also having a problem with it. Thre lies the real problem and the person who wrote in to ask the question has produced revealing responses.
Just a question Corey, when it is about Children Mohammed el Dora was killed for almost 20 years, he was a child can you investigate it, what happened to the killer ?
you should not force the question so much. It ruins the beauty of the whole project. I really like watching these videos because of the authenticity. by you pushing them and causing them to get emotional, it reduces this authenticity.
It's kind of annoying how the lady at 2:41 brought up Islam. This has nothing to do with Islam!!!! There are Palestinian Christians and when Palestinian JEWS. Smh
This is actually not that different from the Israeli video, even though they would say your statement. The Israelis also refuse to believe that Israelis would kill innocent people, especially the army. The army can do no wrong in their eyes. Any killing they do is justified to all Israelis just like the Palestinians feel that Palestinians would never kill women, children, or old people. You're suffering from the same myths. They will say your line for the camera, but if you question them on specifics, they don't condemn more than a handful of incidents.
Were they the Palestinians who drove the isrealis out of their homes took away their lands butchered them made them to leave their land and live as refugees in 1948 and afterwards ?
Steve WideAwake lol Israeli gov is atheist..and again you are ignorant..non traitors..treason 'gentiles' are Righteous..as any country and 'religious book' will see the stranger.
Steve WideAwake sorry if it bothers you that Israeli defend themselves. your ancestor didn't mind when they were kill in the past..so your opinion show it where the sun don't shine. ops done with the chat.
There aren't too many places on earth with this level of hate...
+Stephen Harper
Lol, not many that you see
+Stephen Harper Your sadly very wrong
Except Israel.
Every Islamic country is filled with this type of hate. It's mandatory in Islam to hate the infidel. Muslims out of India and Israel! Meir Kahane was right!
you sound confident considering you just made an incorrect statement
can't wait for Palestinians and Israelis to be at peace with each other
hattar00 lol my bad, "Israelis" right
Palestine hates peace though.
I'm a Jew. I won't tolerate this! This conflict needs to end. We NEED peace!
No they are afraid
Watch the other videos of Palestinians talking. I wish this was true but majority only see peace if Israelis did not exist and all Israel was Palestine. That's the meaning of peace to a majority of them, sadly. They don't see sympathy for Israelis and they don't believe in compromise.
Im going to have nightmares of clowns.
It's a killer clown in denial!
Great premise for a new Stephen King novel.
@@MrTubularBalls John Wayne Gacy was also a clown..
And this is why Palestinians will NEVER have a country west of the Jordan river. Shame...
Give it time and it will All be ours.
+Ahmad A. Thabata That's a last gasp from a loser Ahmad and a view shared by many losers. Every day Israel exists is a true victory over medievalism thinking and stalemates. The problem with empires, is that when a power loses it , it never stops dreaming in getting it back, but never does. proof? The Romans? The Ottomans? The Persians?, The Nazis? The British? The Soviets? Good bye. The Moslems have lost their empire over a hundred years ago. they've achieved very little since. Think about it.
Ahmad A. Thabata how much? 2 years passed and isreal still our country and it always be 🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼
Mark McElroy and like i said.. she always be!
@@ahmada.thabata8615👏🏻❤
“I condemn the killing of innocent civilians, but Israel doesn’t have the right to exist”. Pretty much summarises even the best intentioned palis
no such thing as innocent israeli
I do appreciate what you are doing here Corey and I will happily say as a Palestinian that I condemn the killings of innocent Israeli's
Quote of the freaking century: "It's jihad, not terrorism." That sums up Islam...
hahahah ikr
Tbh, also the _"So we are just the same, us and them."_ - I'd reply "well, then if they're so terrible, how does that make you?!"
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
no tyler youre just dumb and racist
@@wngdhssrsit down
3:40 'It's jihad, not terrorism' Shows how brainwashed and deluded a lot of these people are...
There's actually a huge difference but little people know
Jihad means a struggle in general. It doesn't have to be a holy war.
We did jihad in Egypt till Golda Maer cried asking for US help then we took them behind the factory chair in Camp David 1979. Jihad has many forms. Fights and war is one of them. Diplomatic pornography is another form, referring to taking Begin to a gang bang with the Americans
Sounds to me that u are the delusional one here
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
I am a Muslim from Malaysia and i am saddened by the hatred and suspicion..on both sides. I just pray that the rational ones from both sides somehow gradually outnumber the loonies. And i was utterly amazed by the female student who refused to condemn the killing of innocent Israelis.
Israeli occupiers are not innocents Palestinians are real owners time will soon come insha Allah when will erase the Zionist Occupier Israel occupiers will have to return forcefully or willingly to the Country Where they came from
This is happen insha allah
I commend you for being against violence brother, none deserve to die further both shld demilitarise and live in harmony.
Gh hh
I never figured there was a difference between jihad and terrorism when someone is murdered...
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's....
because youre dumb alex
_"Clown dude - Ramallah"_ 😂😂 And his answer fit..
he spoke truth & facts
They are absolutely irrational and clueless. No hope really.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
Poor man, does he ever feel like he's talking to a wall?
i would never believe it if i hadn't seen it.
+sunshin3man That's the problem with the "palestinian" supporters.. they believe what the Muslims are telling them
+smootskin in an absence of the ""palestinian" supporters..", what exactly would you do? how would it change the situation?
still, the fact that even among liberal minded folks none couldn't say it is amazing.
sunshin3man I would request the so called "Palestinians" to protest to their leaders and request an end to the bloodshed and to start negotiation without conditions.
Can you show me a peace protest in Gaza or in the West bank?
Not organized by a Left wing Jewish organization, but by themselves!
+smootskin so, you are saying that "the supporters" do not allow you to make the request? i still can't see your point.
i do not know of any peace protests in Gaza nor West bank. i believe it is somewhat similar to the fact you don't see protests in Iran, North Korea, or how protests go in Russia.
sunshin3man You just noted the side affect of the culture problem in this region.
They don't have the same principles as the West does.
Oh great..It's Killy-the-Clown. Gotta love Palestinian children entertainment.
+MirroringTruth Haha typical Zionist humour
Ay Yu
It's only "typical" because be it clowns, or demented bees or faux Mickey Mouses, we see how the Arabs teach their children. We joke to keep from crying for the kids,,,
@@MirroringTruthzio
@@ayub96❤
Honestly, I think 99% of the issue with this is that they're being asked to do something that sounds like a soundbite, specifically about the Israelis. I feel most of them are likely avoiding it purely out of fear of retaliation from extremists, rather than a genuine hatred toward innocent Israelis. Had the question simply been "I condemn the killing of innocents, including Israelis and Palestinians", then I think there would have been much more success.
But at the same time, there is a lot of ignorance present in Palestine, more so than in Israel itself, and that certainly encourages some more hateful and hostile views (particularly amongst those who think all Israelis are terrible people simply because they have never seen an Israeli that wasn't a soldier). Palestine and Israel just need to be educated about each other, rather than remaining cut off from each other and reinforcing false views of each other. I would honestly wonder what would happen if the interviewer had reported about having already asked the Israelis about it to the group of women, and the men toward the end.
Hh
You're naive
It's a shame the interviewees cannot think beyond what their religion and their government tells them.
+Mark Simons They can. But they're afraid not only of speaking but also of their own thoughts. It's clear in the video.
But also, I think the question in itself is wrongly done.
restrict yourself from all civil rights and then see how you feel
Many are afraid to get in trouble with their government or their fellows. But their religion clearly tells them killing innocent civilians is wrong. I know at least that much about Islam. Reasonable imams will tell you that terrorists are not even truly Muslim in the true sense of the word in that they are not submitting to God's word.
@@michaelf9664 that would mean Hamas aren't muslims lel
God bless Israel and the Jewish people! 💜
Muhammad said "The Jews will fight with you, and you will be given victory over them so that a stone will say, 'O Muslim! There is a Jew behind me; kill him! "
Corey, when you are in area a/ area b, do you act like you are solely Canadian and not Israeli, for your safety?
+Valencia Katsopoulos he acts like a canadian.
I find it quite hypocritical that when asked about the killing of a 9 year old Palestinian, the Israeli guy got of by saying that he condemns all kids being killed, but when the Palestinian guy said the same thing,it wasn't enough.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
I'm so pissed off at this translator, he's misquoting. Plus, the cameraman lied, not all the Israelis who were asked to did the same did. Don't make these vids pretending to be neutral.
+Zena H hey could you quote some examples?
+yennen cant be bothered to watch the whole thing but there was a lady sitting at the start who was talking and the translator misinterpreted her, when she was asks if she condemns the killings he said she said "its not a bad thing" but its out of context, that's not what she meant.
+Zena H How would you know what she meant; were you privy to the conversation. ?
+Chosen for a reason
Common sense should bring you to the conclusion that she can speak Arabic
Tyran Pesut I understood that she could speak Arabic; I take objection to her suggesting, that she knew what that Phonystinian meant; which implies, not a problem with the translations, but rather holding a greater understanding of the woman's comments.
كفو يا فلسطينيين أخوكم من السعودية المدينة المنورة
No offense to your translator, but being a fluent Arabic and English speaker I can easily tell that the people speaking in Arabic ARE having a harder time understanding the question than wanting to say yes because the word innocent if being swallowed. A better phrased question would be to ask Palestinians what they think of innocent Israelis being killed by Palestinians, and then make sure they understand that you are talking about absolutely innocent people, not soldiers. I feel like more people will condemn the killings that way. Same thing with the Israelis, but I don't know hebrew so I cannot judge.
thank you very much! I enjoy your videos!
Right so if jihad is not terrorism than how could a crusade be justified as one?
+Josh Sertic Jihad meaning fending for themselves from aggression in that context
+J walking and would a crusade not be in the same context also? It cannot be right for one and wrong for the other......
Josh Sertic I don't know which history book you read but the crusaders came from Europe and not Palestine. Thats not fending against aggression by any stretch.
J walking So from your standpoint you are saying that it is permissible to allow Palestinians to wage jihad on their neighbors to "fend against aggression" but yet you do not believe it is permissible for Europe to wage crusades against their neighbors to "fend against aggression". Right, I'm glad you stand on such a moral high-ground that you can choose who is right and moral and who is wrong and evil.
The first European crusades took place because the Umyyad Caliphate instigated war by marching to the gates of Europe, and they killed, raped and enslaved all in their wake. The first crusade was launched by Christendom after the Umyyad Caliphate had started aggressions against the Byzantine Empire and against Christians in Hispaniola. The first crusade was launched to retake Christian land that was forcibly taken by Arabs. It's too bad the Arabs are sore losers, they instigated war and they lost.
I'm not sure which history book you're reading from but it probably is just about as historically accurate as your depiction of history in the Middle East. I'd just like to thank you for having no idea about any of the history you are arguing about, and also degrading this debate to nothing more than slandering. Maybe you should do more reading than speaking, it'll do you some good.
Were the Jews not in the land before the Arabs? So who occupied whom?
Y'ALL FROM ABRAHAM, YO, NOW JUST HUG AND BE NICE!
✌ 🇮🇱🤝🇵🇸 ❤
They saying what they did to them but not what palastines did to israel
it's sad that these people are too scared to say this to the camera because they're afraid of the people around them getting them in trouble. Good to see that support for these things is going down, although it is still very high. Not surprised in a region with so much tension though.
That clown really set the tone for most of this video.
Corey, please do another interview with Ahmed. I think we need it.
as muslims we don't have an issue with jewish, our problem with Israel as a country in palastine land. Return the land to palastinians and you have the right to live under their roles in peace or someday even after 1000 years we should have it back and by the end " what was taken by force, can only be restored by force".
KEEP IT IN YOUR MIND
Most Arabs arrived when Jews started growing apples the size of cantaloupes and they saw it was better living then many Arab regions they formerly inhabited. It was NEVER a sovereign Arab country, the terms Palestine was a Roman word paying homage to the long deceased group called the Philistines.
Virtually any and every ancient artifact found there is bears Jewish origin. At the same time Arabs fled to Palestine for a better life, Jews were kicked out of nearly every Arab land. There was never a Palestinian people with a unique language or place of origin or culture. Unlike the Jews who originated there.
Your an idiot who can't backup your claims
+Muhammad Taha You're just butthurt.
+Muhammad Taha You're just butthurt.
@@abucanaan5335
She just did. I suggest you look it up yourself.
In terms of Arabs arriving when Jews began arriving, you can look at Ottoman census records and see that these claims are exaggerated. 1) The Arab riots that in 1929, and later in 1930s came about as a result of the landlords(located in Damascus and other places) sold their lands to Jewish organizations. Arab serfs did not own the land and the Jewish organizations wanted them moved or gone.
Why can he smile? Did he think he is smart?
For a clown, he wasn't very funny
Spooky, for sure.
- Your summary of Ahmad Menasra's story is not accurate and putting it like that makes it seem like the killing, torturing and violence that Palestinian kids see is not real.
- As an Arabic speaker, I can tell that the man translating was not confirming the "innocent" part properly and his voice was low. This invalidates some of the answers. The lady translator was good.
Just saying. The guy answered your question in many different ways. He is against the killing of any child whether Israeli or Palestinian. Answering your specific question would have contradicted his answer to you.
24:21 A "Palestinian refugee since 1948"? Is he joking? He wasn't born in 1948! Maybe his parents or grand parents were refugees, but he obviously was born in the west bank and he grew up there. So, he is a citizen, NOT A REFUGEE, of the west bank. Period. How can you be refugees for 3 generations? Move on people. Don't stagnate in the past. Release it. You are here now. This is your country and this is your home...wherever "this" is: west bank, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, Egypt....The US, Canada, ...wherever you ended up.
Please use a different translator! This guy is not being clear with his translation.
you're very passive aggressive
+hattar00
1) I'm sucking up to you XD
2) Now that I've won you over I'm gonna join you to my agenda
hattar00 just a parody of your funny comment nothing more :)
hattar00 I was so moved by your comment, it was like an emotional rollercoaster for me. :)
hattar00 How sexist. I'm triggered.
hattar00 I'd say the idiot is the one who can't figure out sarcasm. woops! :)
We are not in the dark ages......... teach Love from childhood and see if you don't derive peace in 7years
Arabs are in dark ages
"I forgot the Arab superstition of not telling someone your mother's name in public". That's an extremely racist statement Corey. That was very insensitive of you, I mean the guy's mom was killed, so it's much more likely a personal reason that prevented him from saying her name. But immediately you attribute it to some stereotype about Arabs. Your bias really shows in these videos. Disliked.
I'm impressed by the two palestinian girls who condemned in 15:05.
me too, but this is actually sad that we need to be surprised by this very basic thing in the western world
why do u set up ur children to be martyrs?
You interviews a FREAKING CLOWN.,?! Hahaha, made my day :)
I guess some clowns are murderous... -_-
Nowadays look at the case of the family of El Kurd !!
@@phanx0m924 John Wayne Gacy
@@CanadianMonarchist 😂 😂 😂
why are you asking a clown a serious Question
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
Well if you put so many restrictions on the people of Palestine no wonder they are bred with hate, give them same rights as Israeli's and in 10 years all will be different.
The guy at 18:00 was so gorgeous until he opened his mouth.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
The problem here is that many Palestinians are wrongly interpreting the question to have something to do for the resistance as a whole rather thn the individual killing of an innocent person.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's. so most of the pali's thought he was talking about the "soldiers" not the civillians,the translation is also unclear and swallows the word innocent as if asking for it,I was also confused at first.
Curious why several people said they were against it, but when asked to use the word condemn, wouldn't. Does this word have other connotations? Or is it like how many Muslims will say that ISIS's actions are against Islam, but won't say they aren't Muslims because that is for God alone to judge?
You're right! There are so many different views and mindsets in islam so we cant be sure thats the reason they wouldn't say it. But I have been thought that its sinful to use the word "condemn" about anyone. Its also not a commonly used word for people that don't speak english that well so why not use the word "against" instead? Some in the video even say they are against, but he insist that they use the word "condemn" as if he knows that its not something they can easily say
The position is really very simple. We are off down the killing road - fact! The only way to change it is to stop making it Us Vs Them. The sooner smart people go after the root cause of the problem, the faster we will see progress. The blame game gets you nowhere.
Well, one thing is clear. Each side is very good at explaining its own side of the story and listing its own victims. And neither side is very good at admitting that the other side might have a point or its own version of the story or innocent civilians.
Susan Kane Well, that's one way of looking at it.
one of the major problems are issues like that in 10:50 and 11:42, there are good palestinians but they fear to say what they think because of their society and surrounding.
this is one of the issues that both the Israel government and the Palestinian national authority are not trying to solve and even talk about it in the media.
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
2:50 Somebody should explain to this woman that just because she wants the land Israel has that doesn't mean it belongs to her.
I think palastines forgot what they did to israel
i wouldnt look into a strangers camera and say what he told me to say either... whether I agree with the statement or not
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's.
@@raghadradi8840 Yeah he's trying to come up with a softer way to ask his fellow arabs the querstion and their answers look worse when you see the question in the video title
@@JBrooksNYS no he wasnt,he doesnt speak arabic well I had a hard time getting it, which was why they look confused when answering,and he keeps swallowing the word "innocent" so it seemed like he was asking about the government/soldiers not the civillians,he asked them if it was right for a palestinian army to plan operations? the lady especially meant she doesnt want the civillians killed,but then he changed it and said "do you think pali soldiers should plan and fight?" obviously anyone's answer would be yes. this isnt the first time this translator did this.he did it alot,so I recommend watching the new video's instead with the new female translator her translations are defintly clearer.
@@raghadradi8840 ive seen most of the videos. I know there are many comments on this male translators videos about bad translations. I thought he was being biased rather than simply not speaking arabic well
Feel like lots of them couldn't say the exact phrase out of being scared of others around them- one of the women even told exactly that, she could not say it because she was scared about how others around who would hear her would react, although saying she was against it; and if she was like that, many of the others might be as well. Also I do not speak Arabic so I don't know how people interpreted the question and how the translator conveyed it and their answers for that matter.
Hi +Corey-Gil-Shuster , you mentioned in this video that you asked an analogous question to Israelis. When will you upload that video?
This video just shows the difference and attitude between a tribal society "Palestine" and an individualistic one "Islrael". The Palestinians care more about other people's opinion about them whereas Israelis don't.
17:53 Ahmad and his cousin have committed a stabbing, " according to Israeli intelligence", his cousin has been left bleeding till death, while ahmad has been recovered in a hospital 'Israeli hospital' because he has the Israeli id. the footage of Ahmad bleeding while Israelis insult him was very humiliating. The girls meant Mohammed Abu Khdeir who was burnt ! Dawabshi Family have the same fate.
Why wouldn't you insult someone who stabbed someone innocent?
@Corey Gil-Shuster : If this question was asked to me I'd ask you to define "innocent israelis".
whats your point
you dont know what innocent mean? you stupid you know that? you need to think if child is innocent or not? fuck you
corey is bias thats it..when he gets a favourable answer from palestinians he doesnt like it..he wants to frame the palestinians in a bad light
Children, babies , Women -you know all these groups that Palestinians (Arabs) kill without mercy en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_suicide_attacks
@@shirley7089 someone shld update the wiki there were more attacks recently I think
It's simple, for every 1 killed israeli civilian there's 15000 killed palestinian civilians, not saying killing innocent people is alright but thats why they don't condemn it, most of them have memories of loved ones killed by Israel so that takes over their thinking, also they don't see israeli's out in the streets condemning and protesting about the killing of innocent palestinians, which is a thing that's done on a weekly if not daily basis by israeli soldiers.
and whose fault is that? that so many innocent Palestinians have died, never wage war when you can't protect your people. Poor strategic planning or Hamas just doesn't give a fuck about the Palestinian people.
@@wngdhssr they never accepted a loss and keep blaming the stronger side, even worse is the libleft supporting them - so their whining is justified...they will never build something and have progress if that's their mindset
Terrible... Deeply shocked.
The translator Sucks,
The second woman did not hear the word "innocent", and the translator dodn't mention this word more than once.
this is depressing
any arab and pro-palestine person who i asked what will be the solution to the problem after a debate, they can't tell me anything rational. and what WILL be the solution? someone, GIVE ME A GOOD SOLUTION TO THIS PROBLEM THAT I WON'T BE ABLE TO COUNTER.
+Sami Seif and then what? you want to dismantle an entire nation of seven million people, an ally to the USA and a part of the UN.. a leading nation in technological development and scientific discoveries. what are you going to do with these people? on the other hand you have the palestinians, people who lived on that land which was already occupied by Britain. there was no nation there and Israel was allowed to be established there. If you condemn Israels' existence then by the same logic you should condemn the establishment of the US and give the land back to the indians.
+Sami Seif What the palestinians are referring to when they say that Israelis are killing their own is Israeli military forces trying to defend the country from terrorist attacks. Someone in the video even said "with what? we don't have anything to attack them with" bitch please, where do all those qassam rockets come from? alla's ass? Fact of the matter is that Israelis don't go around stabbing palestinians and driving them over or plant bombs in highly populated areas. They DELIBERATELY target civilian populations (which is a war crime), and not only that, the reason why majority of palestinians are killed in battle is because the terrorists HIDE AMONG their civilians in schools and homes.
+Nathan Ginzburg you didn't address any of his points. He didn't say the israeli's should leave he just said Israel should follow international law and give Palestinians their rights
+Tru Vids "How about Israel just follows international law and leaves all the land that it doesn't legally own" It does follow international laws, and it does own that land, who the hell do you think gave it to them. The didn't just come there and declare it theirs, they were allowed to and supported by the western nations. Once again, since there was no palestine this isn't called "taking over another nation" and ONCE AGAIN if you condemn Israel's existence then by the same logic you should pack your shit and move from the US
Nathan Ginzburg With every sentence you demonstrate that you know less and less about international law. The Israeli settlements in the West Bank and Gaza are illegal under international law. That's what the statement was referring to.
And don't "once again" me, I don't condemn Israel's existence
Can you ask Israelis, do you think settling "illegally" in Palestinian territory is the root cause of the last few decades of violence? Also could you ask Israelis, do you think the civilian death tolls (israeli v palestinian) has been proportionate through-out the last 20 years?
Catastrophic translator
Ask: Israelis if you (Jewish people's) have enough land to live in why you displace Palestinians from thier homes and do settlements there.
Asks Palestinians: if you can't win back the land you believe is yours why don't you just accept the the two state policy so that you live peace with your children and at least prevent to loose everything and every land remains now.
And another thing......it's a bad set up to be condescending in telling people to turn to a camera and answer a question already answered.
Ask both of Israeli and Palestinia what they think about Gay Marrige. THis should be interenting
I'm a Jew and my fear of clowns just intensified 1:00
Maybe you should read some Ilan Pappé book
@@halimanairalopeznayar9518 That was debunked long ago
it is not fair to ask the SAME question for the criminals (Israelis) which occupy Palestinians land and between the (Innocents) the Palestinians !! it is unacceptable!!
For analogy it's like asking the jew to condemn jew who killed innocent Nazi
it's clear that a lot of these people are afraid and that there are not free to express their own opinions.I'm sure that they would prefer to live in peace if they could.
They can't, can they?
Sadly all too many outside the conflict zone have difficulty too.
I am happy to condemn the killing of innocent Israelis. Though I also condemn many of the actions of the IDF, and even worse the settlers - and especially the policies of the Netanyahu government that do not create any escape route for the Palestinians.
I don't understand the replies in the comments. The Palestanians said that they condemn the murder of children and women of Israeli OR Palestanian descent. Almost all of them said this.
Yet people are calling them names and insulting them in the comments and saying stuff like "I kniew it!" wtf? Do you guys live in a bubble world where everything is reversed?
as someone that speaks arabic,the translations were wrong,the guy asked them "do you think its right for palestinians to plan operations?" which is clear why they said they allow it because its self defence,this isnt the first time this guy makes mistranslations,this is an old video,the new video's have another female translator and she way better and clear. like the women at 3:55 she said at first she is allright with not killing all isre.ali people,which is why she said they arent terro.rists, he then asked her "do you think its right for pali's to even plan operations?" obviously she would say yes. because thats self defence from the army. glad he isnt there anymore in corey's new video's. so most of the pali's thought he was talking about the "soldiers" not the civillians,the translation is also unclear and swallows the word innocent as if asking for it,I was also confused at first.
Just compare the number of Palestinians killed to the number of isrealis ! A stark difference
Last year alone more than 300 Palestinian children Women youth elderly Journalists paramedics were killed in cold blood and these people were unarmed having only slings and stones as their weapons against the army having the most sophisticated weapons .
Am i the only one who thinks that all of them didnt really understand the question?
+Wavyguy96 some did but could t answer or does t answer the question they used a D tour
Agree, that's very depressing that they are avoiding the question
+Nose Nose Lol im Arab too
+Jad Scape Ikr.. like theyre twisting what they say.. one time they condemn killing from both sides but then they cant even say that to the camera.. ridicilous
where on camara some did it after a D tour,some how i got feeling and perhaps not all appear attacking israel or the western world is okay
corey speaks to Palestinians a lot differently compared to the Israelis
+T Azad (YOY) When you get a negative answer, you react differently to a positive one.. that's the difference
+smootskin good point i guess
The guy said he condemns killing innocents like 30 times and he keep trying to trip him up.
4:22-8:35
Abed: "I am against anyone hurting any other person. What idea he has, what passport...i dont give a shit" "Its not okay to kill anyone, Palestinian or Israeli" "I am absolutely against this" "I am against anyone hurting any kids, from any side. Its not the kids fault" "I condemn it, but i think Israel is worse"
Corey: "You cant condemn it! Im asking a specific question, you cant answer it!"
(this was 4 painful minutes to watch. I think the guy obviously tries to point out how he is against it, but he needs to watch his mouth when being on camera. Corey`s channel is good, but he cant control his emotions at times)
Now I get it. You're really smart! You must know that the "condemn" is a very big word in islam and some people even think its sinful to say about anyone? A lot of these people repeatedly say they are against the killing of innocent Israelis but you insist that they use the word "condemn" as if you know they cant say it!
Corey, fire your translator, he is terrible. I am an Arabic speaker and he has a hard time explaining to people what you mean. he can't even speak Arabic very well.
the note about ahmed manasra could have been better. his cousin had the primary role in the stabbing and was killed on the spot. israel bashers loved the video of israelis cursing at ahmed as he lay on the ground after being hit by a car. i would think the 3 women would have seen it. the boy was later shown in the hospital but i guess no arab media showed it. electronic intifada says the boys stabbed "a teen" and a man. the "teen" was 2 months away from his bar mitizvah riding his bike. ahmed was sentenced to 12 years but it was later shortened to 9.5
Jews living there were known as Palestinian Jews. The originally PLO was started by people who were born and raised in Egypt and elsewhere.
some very good work my friend.
The question is simple enough. Can you speak to the camera and say " I condemn the killing of innocent Israelis"? People interviewed have a real problem in considering Israelis as being innocent. Some notably do it out of fear.Innocence in this context for some of those interviewed cannot be acknowledged. Some of the commentators on this thread are also having a problem with it. Thre lies the real problem and the person who wrote in to ask the question has produced revealing responses.
They seem to have a problem with considering Israelis as humans. They condemn killing of innocent people, but not of innocent Israeli Jews. So clearly the latter don't form a subset of "innocent people" in their mind.
+xinxian kongqi Agreed.
The question is simple enough. Can you speak to the camera and say " I condemn the killing of innocent Nazis"? People interviewed have a real problem in considering Nazis as being innocent. Some notably do it out of fear. Innocence in this context for some of those interviewed cannot be acknowledged. Some of the commentators on this thread are also having a problem with it. Thre lies the real problem and the person who wrote in to ask the question has produced revealing responses.
they have been killing since 1948 and no one condemned , i don't think the Israelis have forgotten the genocides they had done in 1948
Peace can never come if both sides don't learn to condemn their own wrong actions.
you were agressive towards the interviewers.
Just a question Corey, when it is about Children Mohammed el Dora was killed for almost 20 years, he was a child can you investigate it, what happened to the killer ?
That was a sham. The boy was not killed. Try again
you should not force the question so much. It ruins the beauty of the whole project. I really like watching these videos because of the authenticity. by you pushing them and causing them to get emotional, it reduces this authenticity.
I do not think people are understanding the word "condemn". I think they are thinking it means forgive....
It's kind of annoying how the lady at 2:41 brought up Islam. This has nothing to do with Islam!!!! There are Palestinian Christians and when Palestinian JEWS. Smh
+Ashley Very few "Palestinian" Christians are left and there almost no "Palestinian" Jews.
+Ashley "Palestinian" Christians, besides being a tiny group, are a persecuted minority.
This is actually not that different from the Israeli video, even though they would say your statement. The Israelis also refuse to believe that Israelis would kill innocent people, especially the army. The army can do no wrong in their eyes. Any killing they do is justified to all Israelis just like the Palestinians feel that Palestinians would never kill women, children, or old people. You're suffering from the same myths. They will say your line for the camera, but if you question them on specifics, they don't condemn more than a handful of incidents.
He dont speak english nor arabic
Corey please ask Israeli IDF : WILL THEY CONDEMN TO KILL PALESTINIAN INNOCENT PEOPLE?
+Dasatra Rap A guy who goes and stabs someone else and then gets shot is not "innocent".
+Deathaura how about a bunch people who lauched rocket and bombing anyone houses ? will you say them as "innocent"?
@@dasatraMedia yes Hamas is not innocent
Were they the Palestinians who drove the isrealis out of their homes took away their lands butchered them made them to leave their land and live as refugees in 1948 and afterwards ?
the arabic guy translating at around 3:25 doesnt know what he is doing, and did a poor job
Trying to flip the cards hey?
+Steve WideAwake want to talk about flipping knives ? www.haaretz.com/israel-news/1.712403 hypocrite.
Steve WideAwake lol news from 2002..girl killed in a shooting..retaliation of the killing of a soldier.
Steve WideAwake listen BOTH sides are guilty..but any who tries to kill the other..might get kill first. this is no 'flipping cards'
Steve WideAwake lol Israeli gov is atheist..and again you are ignorant..non traitors..treason 'gentiles' are Righteous..as any country and 'religious book' will see the stranger.
Steve WideAwake sorry if it bothers you that Israeli defend themselves. your ancestor didn't mind when they were kill in the past..so your opinion show it where the sun don't shine. ops
done with the chat.
So gentiles fighting over a land that none of them actually owned 2000 years ago