Thank you DraftKings for sponsoring this video. Don’t miss out on all the action this week at DraftKings! Download the DraftKings app today! Sign-up using dkng.co/utree or through my promo code UTREE.
@@MazeDaGr8 maybe some legendary or horribles ones, he could do on the NBA, maybe the NHL, MLB... (not the MLS, not even the teams give a shit about that)
@@FelipeYoshioCordeirodeSouza If he does the NBA draft, then I would find it hysterical if he graded all 2000 first round picks. That draft has a ton of garbage to sort through, in most people’s opinion.
Not to mention guys like Roquan Smith, Quenton Nelson, Minkah Fitzpatrick, Denzel Ward, Tremaine Edmunds, DJ Moore, Vita Vea & more. And those are just the guys drafted in the first round.
@@Ma5t3rKush89 Actually, the prior year, Drew Pearson trolled Philly. Then everyone roasted Dallas in Dallas. Ackers being the best troll of the bunch.
"Hey Dallas fans, last time you were in a super bowl NONE OF THESE DRAFT PICKS WERE BORN YET" - David Akers, defining what it looks like when a place kicker is "on the jazz"
I really like this concept of revisiting Drafts every five years Although I hope you consider doing this for even older Drafts like say 2012, 2001 Maybe even '89
89 is notable for the four Hall of Famers in the first five selections, and Steve Atwater later in round one also made it in. Not as much depth as some years that are considered as good as it is typically (23 total pro bowlers is actually pretty low compared to some), but the best selections make it an excellent class overall. A hot take I have related to 1989’s draft: Tony Mandarich in 1989 is certainly a terrible pick, but he’s not the worst pick ever. True, he was an unsuccessful tackle who was gone in three years (would be ok for Indy years later though), and the next three picks were Barry Sanders, Derrick Thomas and Deion Sanders. But if Green Bay wanted to take a tackle, then 1989 wasn’t the year to take one; none made a pro bowl or received any individual recognition from what I can tell. While the Hall of Famers afterward were right there, none were linemen. Todd Blackledge in 1983 was a far worse pick. Sure, eighth overall vs second, but he didn’t pan out, and Dan Marino and Jim Kelly were both taken by the next Kansas City pick so they missed out on Hall of Famers who could have played the same position.
I would love to see Tree get Ryan Leaf to join him for a draft of that late 90s-mid 00s era In fact, if possible id make Ryan Leaf your go-to tag partner for crapping on drafts and/or giving drafts their due. Also I imagine he and tree would get on well... and I imagine he has a legendary F U Spanos buried within him 😂
@@fortynights1513 Kansas City tried this exact same strategy again in 2017. But this time, they would fix that mistake by drafting what could possibly be the most talented QB in NFL history when his career is all said and done. The rest of the AFC West is going to hate Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs for years to come, especially my Broncos. I wasn’t alive in the John Elway-era (I was born in 2002), but man, do I wish I could go back to those days.
Drafts that old have been revisited time and time again, especially notable ones like those. I imagine tree isn’t in a rush to just repeat the things that have already been said million times, it’s hard to add anything new, especially when the players have all retired and don’t have a chance to change how people view them.
2018 really was a fantastic draft for the Ravens. Even with how things have played out since then, getting Lamar, Mark Andrews, Orlando Brown, Deshon Elliott, Bradley Bozeman, and Gus Edwards in the same year is just awesome to see.
"Even with how things have played out since then" right. Roman "just played out" calling The Worst passing plays for three years ruclips.net/video/JgfB_4DgnEQ/видео.html, Harbaugh & the owner "just accidentally" kept him on. I'm absolutely 100% certain that their intent in doing this was to sink *the team* & not specifically LJ8's chances of getting a big paycheck. Absolutely certain. & I'm also 100% certain that the Giants would rather pay Daniel Jones that much $ just to keep their offense stagnant than to pay just a little more to get LJ7 to win them a super-bowl. I'm also 100% certain that the Patriots, Broncos, Jets, Dolphins, Commanders, Seahwaks & every south division team (except Jacksonville) is 100% certain of their super-bowl winning hopes without him. Especially the Bucs who aren't rebuilding & are going to make it with Baker Mayfield. All of this just "worked out." 🤭 🙄
Too bad they missed so badly on Hurst with the first pick knowing what Andrews did (not to mention the next TE picked, Dallas Goedert, has been better than Hurst too)
@@ZJBorg tbf it's not like Hurst is a bad player, it's just that both the guy drafted after you and the next guy drafted to challenge you were so good
The Giants somehow managed to convince people that Saquon was overrated or disappointing for 6 seasons. If he was drafted to a real team, he probably would have 10k yards by now.
@@yetekt6953 And won a divisional title, and two playoff wins (Not to mention helping lead the Browns to their first playoff appearance in 18 years and helped them win it). Baker just needed to be in the right situation. Just hated how the Browns did him. At least Tampa did him right.
i'd classify baker as a meh pick rather than a bust, but i appreciate the detailed background you've given acknowledging that the browns failed him in many ways. i have serious doubts that allen or lamar would've survived the dysfunction either
@@calcaleb7041 how. He literally turned around that franchise in 2 years and he was one bad call away from a afc championship appearance. He’s definitely a meh
i mean hindsight is a bitch sure look at 2021 literally every single NFL fan said Jalen Hurts was a writeoff and what did he do the next season ? lead the Eagles all the way to the Superbowl where he came Heartbreakingly close to winning a Ring hell even Josh Allen was said to be a Writeoff after 2 seasons yet he's now the best QB the Bills had have since Jim Kelly tbh that's not saying much but still
@@kurtpunchesthings2411as an Alabama fan I really loved hurts and wanted the bears to take hurts and trade mitch as the time I always saw the potential. Bears would've prob ruined the kid anyways haha
Baker, Darnold, Goff, Stafford, all have shown incredible comebacks in the 2024-2025 season so far as of week 12. I think all 4 deserve some newfound praise.
Jordan Mailata in the 7th round was a home run. A basically worthless pick, and they went with a guy who’d never played a down of football before, they probably didn’t expect much but it couldn’t have been more worth it. I remember seeing the Rugby highlight reel and thinking “If this guy figures out football he could be insane as an athletic tackle.”
Funny thing about Mailata, there was only one other team who even bothered to scout him at the pathway program. Tree's Pittsburgh Steelers, who probably would have taken him at 246 had Philly not swapped 7th rounders with the Patriots
For Cleveland, he was. He had four seasons of incredibly uneven play that didn't get the Browns anywhere of note (that they won a playoff game for the first time ever with him is nice but like... they were playing against a paper tiger. Fucking Tim Couch could have won) and got ran out of town before his rookie contract was finished for barely any compensation. For a first overall pick? That's a bust.
@@TheShinyFeraligatr And like Tim Couch, Baker got screwed over by the organization itself. It wasn't the QB that was the issue. It was the Browns. Note how they (Haslam) ditched him to get a QB with multiple sexual assault charges and they haven't done anything other than get clowned by the Texans in the playoffs. Also, Tampa pretty much revived his career. Won a divisional title, won a playoff game. And he's still doing good. Blame the organization, not the player.
@@AutoArtemAuto I think Baker Mayfield has a long, fruitful career in the NFL ahead of him, bar something terrible happens. But that pick was a bust for Cleveland because they got fucking nothing out of him.
Baker was kinda a bust considering he was a 1st over all pick … when the browns moved on from him it was because they had enough talent for a Super Bowl run but baker couldn’t get it done … baker was just blessed to end up in Tampa in a offense with a bunch of weapons and a fan base that doesn’t really have a lot of pressure on him because Tom Brady just got done giving them a championship
2018 is an interesting bunch to unpack. The teens of round one especially. Also, hot take of mine: Saquon Barkley may be the last running back to be taken as high as he was here because of how much value individual running backs are said to have to most teams now.
@@Dee-jd6ym If you mentally switch Hurst and Andrews in your mind then remember that Hurst's trade to ATL turned into JK Dobbins it doesn't feel so bad.
@@Dee-jd6ym Hurst was the right selection. It's just rotten luck that he never developed. The only reason we traded him after 2019 is that we needed our 2nd Round pick back after the NFLPA took it from us for tampering with DeAndre Hopkins. And it's ironic that the Ravens are trying a 2nd time to get him.
2019 Ravens were an excellent team that unfortunately didn’t win a playoff game. Much like the 73 Rams, and to a lesser degree 11 Packers, and 87 49ers and a few others, they will go down as a statistically great, overlooked season because of the lack of a deep playoff run.
But that's mostly because their all on different teams. They are on better teams. Browns, Giants, and Jets sucked and looking at where they are now is basically the exact same scenario. All 3 still suck.
Boy oh boy what a draft class this was. I think this was the first draft class where people started to realize that outside of generational talents like Joe Burrow, the term “NFL-ready QB” began to collapse. Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold were the two that people deemed as “NFL-ready QBs” and they were the biggest busts of the QB class this year.
A bunch of good suggestions for The Trade series: The Trade: RG3 to the Redskins The Trade: Trent Richardson to the Colts The Trade: Mitchell Trubisky to the Bears The Trade: Ryan Leaf to the Chargers The Trade: DeAndre Hopkins to the Cardinals
The sad thing is that I really do believe RG3 could have at least been a good QB, if not one of the best in the league, if it wasn't for THAT ONE LEG INJURY. I knew even watching the replay of it live that it was going to be a bad, career defining one.
i know it will be in the future but in like 3 years The Trade Aaron Rodgers to the Jets because it's crazy how it could be seen as a generational flop of a trade or it may even become one of the greatest trades of all time if the Jets can get a ring with him
The Trade: Randy Moss to the Raiders. a.k.a.: Owner Red McCombs' final Fuck You to the Minnesota Vikings. And how Moss was sent to his doom, until snagged by The Hoodie to revive his career as a Patriot.
This really is a fascinating series. I also would love a 10 year rerecap of these drafts as well so you can look at a lot of these guys entire careers!
I feel like even at the time Tree made this saying Mayfield was a bust was a huge stretch but now its just laughable, of course he was failing when he was injured in 2021 and on the Panthers in 2022
As a Ravens fan, this was our best draft since 1996, and its fitting that it was the last draft that Ozzie Newsome was in charge of. Look at who we got. Lamar Jackson, Mark Andrews, Orlando Brown Jr, DeShon Elliott, and Bradley Bozeman. That's close to a generational draft. Not to mention we made Philadelphia drink the stupid for Timmy Jernigan and Mike Wallace in order to get Lamar. Speaking of Lamar, and the Ravens, they are plotting a scheme in order for them to make a huge move for DeAndre Hopkins. We have Andrews, OBJ, and Bateman already, WE'RE GETTING D-HOP EVEN IF WE GIVE UP GUS EDWARDS AND DEVIN DUVERNAY! (The problem is that we have to compete with the Chiefs and Bills to get him) If we get Hopkins, Lamar is easily signing an extension.
Yeah you gotta point there, mate Yeah we've got some good players in the Drafts over the years but this was our best draft Overall in years. If we can get D-Hop and lamar signs this contract (along with staying healthy) then we should be good going forward
@@MazeDaGr8 Honestly I think we will get D-Hop even if we trade our 1st Round pick. Why? Because Deonte Banks, who pundits think the Ravens could take at 22, they might be able to get him in the 2nd Round. It would be a win-win trade. Arizona sheds the Hopkins contract and gets two 1st Round picks, Lamar gets another outstanding receiver to work with, the Ravens get a 2nd and 5th in the deal as well, and the Cardinals are out of Cap Hell. EVERYONE WINS!
@@michaelhession2105 Are you saying the ravens traded Jernigan and Wallace for Lamar? If so, your wrong. They traded the eagles 2 second round pics which the Eagles used on Dallas Goedert and Miles Sanders who were both great picks
I think Baker deserves a "meh". With all their QB picks in the first round he was the first to inspire any real faith in the team. One rough season caused the Browns to turn on him in an outright farce. Also Denzel Ward being a success and Saquon not for injury concerns is weird. They have equal pro bowls and Saquon has three 1k yard seasons.
Baker as a bust is unfair in ways because if he never played with that blown shoulder it would be a different story. If he somehow revives his career in Tampa bay that’ll be nice.
It's also safe to say any of the other QBs in that draft wouldn't have done as well in the circumstances. Allen and Lamar would not have dropped into good systems, darnold and Rosen simply sucked. He was the best pick and did pretty decent all things considered
I've been waiting for this since last week. God bless Jaire "The Great" Alexander. Speaking of which, Green Bay could've just taken Jaire at their original pick (#14) but the trade down with the saints (#14->#27) got them a 2019 1st, then moved up 9 spots with Seattle (#27->#18) for only a 3rd and a 6th to grab him. An absolute hosejob by Gutekunst in his 1st year as GM. Also, loving your inclusion of Sonic CD music in your recent vids.
I honestly thought there was no way you would be able to accurately describe baker as the number 1 pick in terms of what happened and the bust/boom angle, but you nailed it. Impressive
24:29 I’m not joking when I say Ik this by heart and can repeat it on command including the announcers “uhoh” and “ OO!””oh!”. Literally best draft pick announcement ever
When we look back on Baker Mayfield years from now, he won't be considered a bust imo. He not only brought the Browns of all teams to the promised lands, he actually won them a playoff game. Something I don't think will happen for a long time going forward
Truly one of the better drafts in recent memory IMO. Can't believe how much incredible talent came from the later rounds. If only Baltimore would pay thier best QB in franchise history...
Watched the whole video just to watch David Akers troll Dallas magnificently. You didn't disappoint. Gets me every time! We prefer to call Dallas Goedert by the nickname "Phil" in our household (:
Good on you UrinatingTree for highlighting the 7th Round pick by the Eagles of Jordan Mailata! Man's done incredible work to come from his background and play a key role for the Eagles to make the Super Bowl a few months ago.
Coming back to this after Baker Mayfield became the first visiting QB to have a perfect passer rating at Lambeau Field. I’d say he’s a meh. Glad to see him turn things around with Tampa.
its actually crazy to look at this draft because normally, 5 years u can tell where a player is in there career but I feel like this is one of the few drafts where u have to wait another 5 years to tell where half these players truly are
I like coming back to these kind of videos to show that someone like Baker can be considered a bust one year and have a resurgence to another playoff win the next. Hes finally in a respectable organization that can understand him and develop a game under him
The injury theme was so strong with some of these poor kids. Penney in particular was sad because he clearly is an extremely talented kid. Hope he has at least one full season in the NFL before he's done. Also, Seattle should never use their first pick on running backs...it just doesn't work out for them.
They did not this year. The last time we used a first round pick on a back and it worked out was Curt Warner in 1983 arguably (unless John L Williams was also a first in 86).
@@fortynights1513 haha, that's going back 40 years to find a good 1st rounder RB. I was thinking more along the lines of Penney (who sadly has been unlucky with injuries) or Christine Michael off the top of my head. Michael was a second rounder but Seattle's first pick, if I recall.
Ah, nostalgia. This was the draft that coincided with my really getting back into football. Good times when we thought Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold would be good
Josh Rosen as a bust I will forever maintain came down to people continuing to fuck around with him and putting him in a position to fail. Guy was legit and got put on teams that immediately went ohh shiny at the next guy.
This absolutely lifts my miserable day. I've been so excited for this video because I love when you tackle past history, it's one of my most watched Playlists. Thanks Tree 💛🖤💛🖤
Thank you DraftKings for sponsoring this video. Don’t miss out on all the action this week at DraftKings! Download the DraftKings app today! Sign-up using dkng.co/utree or through my promo code UTREE.
Yay
Tell that to Jamison Williams Tree
Gotta love hypocritical sponsorships. I'm pointing at the NFL, not at you Tree. Get that money!
LOL, I made a post about Goodell and it already got taken down, again, LOL
@@MSU-DetroitFan He should have protected himself with Nord VPN
This is such an underrated series
It really is, I wish he would do this for Older Drafts as well
@@MazeDaGr8 that would be great
@@MazeDaGr8 maybe some legendary or horribles ones, he could do on the NBA, maybe the NHL, MLB... (not the MLS, not even the teams give a shit about that)
@@FelipeYoshioCordeirodeSouza If he does the NBA draft, then I would find it hysterical if he graded all 2000 first round picks. That draft has a ton of garbage to sort through, in most people’s opinion.
@@fortynights1513 HAHAHAHAHA to think that the best player from that class was Turkoglu LOL
Oh, 2018... With Baker, Allen, Lamar, Donald, and Rosen. What a draft...
Not to mention guys like Roquan Smith, Quenton Nelson, Minkah Fitzpatrick, Denzel Ward, Tremaine Edmunds, DJ Moore, Vita Vea & more. And those are just the guys drafted in the first round.
Bro tried sneaking in Rosen and Darnold 💀
@@davidpearson5208 wdym they were definitely in this draft. Only proof I'm aware of that Rosen was a real person.
who tf is donald
@@GuyN0ir im just saying that they were trash
David Akers announcement for the Eagles drafting Dallas Goedert in Dallas of all places will always be one of the best moments in Draft history.
@ReinSouls he basically started all the whole "trollin' rival city team at the draft" thing every guest announcer does now 😂😂
@@Ma5t3rKush89 It kinda started a year earlier, when Cowboys legend Drew Pearson trolled the Philly audience.
@@Ma5t3rKush89 Actually, the prior year, Drew Pearson trolled Philly.
Then everyone roasted Dallas in Dallas. Ackers being the best troll of the bunch.
"Hey Dallas fans, last time you were in a super bowl NONE OF THESE DRAFT PICKS WERE BORN YET" - David Akers, defining what it looks like when a place kicker is "on the jazz"
I remember being so surprised by Akers' voice like "oh THAT'S what he sounds like"
crazy how a change in scenery can revitalize careers. top 3 picks are thriving this year on new teams.
All 3 of those teams who drafted them are in the exact same place as their were in 2018.
Baker , Saquon , & Darnold have all revitalized their careers!
100% agree, what’s funny is they did once they left the teams that drafted them
I really like this concept of revisiting Drafts every five years
Although I hope you consider doing this for even older Drafts like say 2012, 2001 Maybe even '89
89 is notable for the four Hall of Famers in the first five selections, and Steve Atwater later in round one also made it in.
Not as much depth as some years that are considered as good as it is typically (23 total pro bowlers is actually pretty low compared to some), but the best selections make it an excellent class overall.
A hot take I have related to 1989’s draft:
Tony Mandarich in 1989 is certainly a terrible pick, but he’s not the worst pick ever.
True, he was an unsuccessful tackle who was gone in three years (would be ok for Indy years later though), and the next three picks were Barry Sanders, Derrick Thomas and Deion Sanders.
But if Green Bay wanted to take a tackle, then 1989 wasn’t the year to take one; none made a pro bowl or received any individual recognition from what I can tell.
While the Hall of Famers afterward were right there, none were linemen.
Todd Blackledge in 1983 was a far worse pick. Sure, eighth overall vs second, but he didn’t pan out, and Dan Marino and Jim Kelly were both taken by the next Kansas City pick so they missed out on Hall of Famers who could have played the same position.
I would love to see Tree get Ryan Leaf to join him for a draft of that late 90s-mid 00s era
In fact, if possible id make Ryan Leaf your go-to tag partner for crapping on drafts and/or giving drafts their due. Also I imagine he and tree would get on well... and I imagine he has a legendary F U Spanos buried within him 😂
@@fortynights1513 Kansas City tried this exact same strategy again in 2017. But this time, they would fix that mistake by drafting what could possibly be the most talented QB in NFL history when his career is all said and done.
The rest of the AFC West is going to hate Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs for years to come, especially my Broncos. I wasn’t alive in the John Elway-era (I was born in 2002), but man, do I wish I could go back to those days.
Drafts that old have been revisited time and time again, especially notable ones like those. I imagine tree isn’t in a rush to just repeat the things that have already been said million times, it’s hard to add anything new, especially when the players have all retired and don’t have a chance to change how people view them.
Yes PLEASE tree
2018 really was a fantastic draft for the Ravens. Even with how things have played out since then, getting Lamar, Mark Andrews, Orlando Brown, Deshon Elliott, Bradley Bozeman, and Gus Edwards in the same year is just awesome to see.
Ravens definitely got a haul of great players in the draft that year.
"Even with how things have played out since then" right. Roman "just played out" calling The Worst passing plays for three years ruclips.net/video/JgfB_4DgnEQ/видео.html, Harbaugh & the owner "just accidentally" kept him on.
I'm absolutely 100% certain that their intent in doing this was to sink *the team* & not specifically LJ8's chances of getting a big paycheck. Absolutely certain. & I'm also 100% certain that the Giants would rather pay Daniel Jones that much $ just to keep their offense stagnant than to pay just a little more to get LJ7 to win them a super-bowl. I'm also 100% certain that the Patriots, Broncos, Jets, Dolphins, Commanders, Seahwaks & every south division team (except Jacksonville) is 100% certain of their super-bowl winning hopes without him.
Especially the Bucs who aren't rebuilding & are going to make it with Baker Mayfield. All of this just "worked out." 🤭 🙄
And yet they haven’t done shit with that haul
Too bad they missed so badly on Hurst with the first pick knowing what Andrews did (not to mention the next TE picked, Dallas Goedert, has been better than Hurst too)
@@ZJBorg tbf it's not like Hurst is a bad player, it's just that both the guy drafted after you and the next guy drafted to challenge you were so good
4:13 Saquon is tearing it up with the Eagles. Just goes to show what a player can do under the right system with proper coaching and good ownership.
The Giants somehow managed to convince people that Saquon was overrated or disappointing for 6 seasons. If he was drafted to a real team, he probably would have 10k yards by now.
Baker change this grade literally the season after this was posted. Talent always stands out
As did Darnold and Saquon. Just goes to show a change of scenery can do wonders for a player lost at sea.
I think Baker deserves a revisist on that "bust" label. Thank God Tampa did him justice.
He’s still a bust
@@yetekt6953how much did you earn in your AAF career ?
@@yetekt6953 Care to explain?
@@AutoArtemAuto he’s a 1st overall pick and so far in his career the only thing he’s done is make 1 pro bowl.
@@yetekt6953 And won a divisional title, and two playoff wins (Not to mention helping lead the Browns to their first playoff appearance in 18 years and helped them win it). Baker just needed to be in the right situation. Just hated how the Browns did him. At least Tampa did him right.
Bro u could resist this entire draft class again. Thats how much can change in 2 years!! Its insane how stacked this class was
i'd classify baker as a meh pick rather than a bust, but i appreciate the detailed background you've given acknowledging that the browns failed him in many ways. i have serious doubts that allen or lamar would've survived the dysfunction either
the man had a new coach every year except years 4 and 5 how he did well there is beyond me
He’s a bust 😂 Labum has one less playoff win and he’s a bust 😂
@@calcaleb7041 how. He literally turned around that franchise in 2 years and he was one bad call away from a afc championship appearance. He’s definitely a meh
He is only a bust as a #1 overall pick.
1st overall better be a all pro HOF the Best in the Draft. BusT
Goddamn this QB pool was DEEP. Even Quaterbacks who were considered "busts" are having career renaissances!
Look forward to this every year. Practically every take Tree has is freezing cold after 5 years
i mean hindsight is a bitch sure look at 2021 literally every single NFL fan said Jalen Hurts was a writeoff and what did he do the next season ? lead the Eagles all the way to the Superbowl where he came Heartbreakingly close to winning a Ring hell even Josh Allen was said to be a Writeoff after 2 seasons yet he's now the best QB the Bills had have since Jim Kelly tbh that's not saying much but still
But his urine stays warm
@@kurtpunchesthings2411as an Alabama fan I really loved hurts and wanted the bears to take hurts and trade mitch as the time I always saw the potential. Bears would've prob ruined the kid anyways haha
Freezing cold? Is that some kind of sex joke? You're not funny dude and I think you should apologize son.
@@jennyanydots2389 you need to repent for your dirty mind. a "hot take" becomes "freezing cold" if it is very inaccurate 5 years later
Baker, Darnold, Goff, Stafford, all have shown incredible comebacks in the 2024-2025 season so far as of week 12. I think all 4 deserve some newfound praise.
Considering that PHI didn’t have a first round pick, they found a ton of talent and future starters in this draft.
Honestly might be one of our best drafts.
When you had that amazing first appearance in the second round, you know things are going to be good.
Jordan Mailata in the 7th round was a home run. A basically worthless pick, and they went with a guy who’d never played a down of football before, they probably didn’t expect much but it couldn’t have been more worth it. I remember seeing the Rugby highlight reel and thinking “If this guy figures out football he could be insane as an athletic tackle.”
Funny thing about Mailata, there was only one other team who even bothered to scout him at the pathway program. Tree's Pittsburgh Steelers, who probably would have taken him at 246 had Philly not swapped 7th rounders with the Patriots
@@alexrudolph301 As a football fan, I love to see it. As a Giants fan, I hate to see it. Jeff Stoutland is the best in the biz.
3:08 bust for the Browns, success for the Buccaneers at least.
Yeah, these vids can def get funny with hindsight
I WAS SO WORRIED THIS WASNT GONNA COME OUT. I love this series thank you Tree!
Saying baker was a bust even 8 months ago was crazy ngl but it’s even more crazy now
For Cleveland, he was. He had four seasons of incredibly uneven play that didn't get the Browns anywhere of note (that they won a playoff game for the first time ever with him is nice but like... they were playing against a paper tiger. Fucking Tim Couch could have won) and got ran out of town before his rookie contract was finished for barely any compensation. For a first overall pick? That's a bust.
@@TheShinyFeraligatr And like Tim Couch, Baker got screwed over by the organization itself. It wasn't the QB that was the issue. It was the Browns. Note how they (Haslam) ditched him to get a QB with multiple sexual assault charges and they haven't done anything other than get clowned by the Texans in the playoffs. Also, Tampa pretty much revived his career. Won a divisional title, won a playoff game. And he's still doing good. Blame the organization, not the player.
@@AutoArtemAuto I think Baker Mayfield has a long, fruitful career in the NFL ahead of him, bar something terrible happens. But that pick was a bust for Cleveland because they got fucking nothing out of him.
Baker was kinda a bust considering he was a 1st over all pick … when the browns moved on from him it was because they had enough talent for a Super Bowl run but baker couldn’t get it done … baker was just blessed to end up in Tampa in a offense with a bunch of weapons and a fan base that doesn’t really have a lot of pressure on him because Tom Brady just got done giving them a championship
Looking back from 2024, Baker and Donald probably deserve a second look with their bust status.
2018 is an interesting bunch to unpack. The teens of round one especially.
Also, hot take of mine: Saquon Barkley may be the last running back to be taken as high as he was here because of how much value individual running backs are said to have to most teams now.
Agreed. Bijan is the best prospect since Saquon and he might not go top 20
@@willclapp1845 He went 8 to Atlanta
@@silkychris999 great player but holy reach for a position u didnt need to improve on
Not a hot take rbs are not highly valued anymore.
@@willclapp1845looks like it wasn’t a reach so far
Somehow, Tree unjinxed Baker.
Wow looking back the 1st round was absolutely loaded with talent.....and Josh Rosen
Correction. "And Rosen and Darnold
Rosen May have had some ability, but he clearly had ego issues, and didn’t pan out.
@@dominiccarranza2184what about Darnold? You mean mvp candidate Sam Darnold?
Great to see Baker turning it around and picking up the pieces.
Yup, had a great run into the playoffs that shows he still knows how to do it
2018 draft was a VERY enjoyable experience as a Ravens fan, paved the way for the greatest regular season in franchise history.
@@Dee-jd6ym If you mentally switch Hurst and Andrews in your mind then remember that Hurst's trade to ATL turned into JK Dobbins it doesn't feel so bad.
@@Dee-jd6ym Hurst was the right selection. It's just rotten luck that he never developed. The only reason we traded him after 2019 is that we needed our 2nd Round pick back after the NFLPA took it from us for tampering with DeAndre Hopkins. And it's ironic that the Ravens are trying a 2nd time to get him.
2019 Ravens were an excellent team that unfortunately didn’t win a playoff game.
Much like the 73 Rams, and to a lesser degree 11 Packers, and 87 49ers and a few others, they will go down as a statistically great, overlooked season because of the lack of a deep playoff run.
@fortynights1513 They were a fun team to watch but also ran into the worst possible match-up at the wrong time.
@@fortynights1513 i dont think they were particularly talented, just healthy
I would love to see a Revisiting for NHL draft classes. So many of those picks become complete busts and others are grand slams
I want to see the 2015 draft
This please. My coyotes draft choices could be an entire essay In terrible choices
same
I would like to do a 2007 NFL Draft because that draft is identical to 2018 NFL draft.
@@Ibelikemj or the 2017 draft when the Flyers take Elias Pettersson instead of uber bust Nolan Patrick.
As an Eagles fan, that David Akers clip there will forever be absolute gold.
Agreed and One of My Favorite Moments in The NFL Draft As a Eagles Fan Myself!
David Akers cutting a WWE heel promo at dallas at the end is one of my favorite draft moments OAT
It was glorious!
Crazy how the top 3 grades are now all successes
But that's mostly because their all on different teams. They are on better teams. Browns, Giants, and Jets sucked and looking at where they are now is basically the exact same scenario. All 3 still suck.
Boy oh boy what a draft class this was. I think this was the first draft class where people started to realize that outside of generational talents like Joe Burrow, the term “NFL-ready QB” began to collapse. Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold were the two that people deemed as “NFL-ready QBs” and they were the biggest busts of the QB class this year.
Rosen was so NFL ready that the Cardinals brought in Sam Bradford to start the season.
Got into your videos with the 2017 NFL Draft revisit. And here I am a year later.
nfl weebs unite
A bunch of good suggestions for The Trade series:
The Trade: RG3 to the Redskins
The Trade: Trent Richardson to the Colts
The Trade: Mitchell Trubisky to the Bears
The Trade: Ryan Leaf to the Chargers
The Trade: DeAndre Hopkins to the Cardinals
Oh, yeah, the Colts pick turned into JOHNNY FUCKING FOOTBALL
The final seconds of the Ricky Williams video I think was a sign that a vid on RG3 is coming soon.
The sad thing is that I really do believe RG3 could have at least been a good QB, if not one of the best in the league, if it wasn't for THAT ONE LEG INJURY. I knew even watching the replay of it live that it was going to be a bad, career defining one.
i know it will be in the future but in like 3 years The Trade Aaron Rodgers to the Jets because it's crazy how it could be seen as a generational flop of a trade or it may even become one of the greatest trades of all time if the Jets can get a ring with him
The Trade: Randy Moss to the Raiders.
a.k.a.: Owner Red McCombs' final Fuck You to the Minnesota Vikings.
And how Moss was sent to his doom, until snagged by The Hoodie to revive his career as a Patriot.
This really is a fascinating series. I also would love a 10 year rerecap of these drafts as well so you can look at a lot of these guys entire careers!
It’s funny how Mayfield, Barkley and Darnold have all balled out recently after this video came out
That's because all 3 got out of bad teams. Looking back 6 years later and all 3 teams still suck.
The 2018 class is probably one of the most packed classes ever. Very rare that this many picks end up working out.
yeah, I'm surprised looking at it just how many good players there are here
Especially for Quarterbacks.
I feel like even at the time Tree made this saying Mayfield was a bust was a huge stretch but now its just laughable, of course he was failing when he was injured in 2021 and on the Panthers in 2022
Tree gets his pick in before the clock runs out you love to see it 🥳
And now Baker is a franchise qb leading Tampa Bay to success after losing BRADY of all people! Fortune reversal
The fact Saquon is now a key piece in Philly and there's a genuine Darnold might get paid in Minnesota makes everything a lot funnier 💀
This video really shows bakers comeback ark
the first 3 picks all need a major reevaluation after this season. 2024 was a wild year
This was one of the best drafts in recent memory. I feel bad for Josh Rosen. Dude gets past around like a joint.
To be fair he did kind of behave like an asshole
Or like your mom's bee whole at the family Christmas party.
2:52 “the sexier option” is certainly an interesting term to use there
As a Ravens fan, this was our best draft since 1996, and its fitting that it was the last draft that Ozzie Newsome was in charge of. Look at who we got. Lamar Jackson, Mark Andrews, Orlando Brown Jr, DeShon Elliott, and Bradley Bozeman. That's close to a generational draft. Not to mention we made Philadelphia drink the stupid for Timmy Jernigan and Mike Wallace in order to get Lamar. Speaking of Lamar, and the Ravens, they are plotting a scheme in order for them to make a huge move for DeAndre Hopkins. We have Andrews, OBJ, and Bateman already, WE'RE GETTING D-HOP EVEN IF WE GIVE UP GUS EDWARDS AND DEVIN DUVERNAY! (The problem is that we have to compete with the Chiefs and Bills to get him) If we get Hopkins, Lamar is easily signing an extension.
Yeah you gotta point there, mate Yeah we've got some good players in the Drafts over the years but this was our best draft Overall in years. If we can get D-Hop and lamar signs this contract (along with staying healthy) then we should be good going forward
@@MazeDaGr8 Honestly I think we will get D-Hop even if we trade our 1st Round pick. Why? Because Deonte Banks, who pundits think the Ravens could take at 22, they might be able to get him in the 2nd Round. It would be a win-win trade. Arizona sheds the Hopkins contract and gets two 1st Round picks, Lamar gets another outstanding receiver to work with, the Ravens get a 2nd and 5th in the deal as well, and the Cardinals are out of Cap Hell. EVERYONE WINS!
@@michaelhession2105 Are you saying the ravens traded Jernigan and Wallace for Lamar? If so, your wrong. They traded the eagles 2 second round pics which the Eagles used on Dallas Goedert and Miles Sanders who were both great picks
The amazing series has returned. Love seeing the differences from the original 2018 draft video.
2017 was the first draft he made a video breaking down, 2018 was the first one where he actually covered the whole first round
Yes I Know that. But the previous video was the original video about the 2018 draft. So that's what I meant
I wouldn't call Sony Michel a bust and I'm not even a Pat's fan...like you said, dude helped them get a ring!
Actually, he has two rings, he was also one of the important piece for Rams to win that Super Bowl.
@@taskdon769 …even better! NOT a bust.
Hes out of the league. WASHED@@LuigiL75
I think Baker deserves a "meh". With all their QB picks in the first round he was the first to inspire any real faith in the team. One rough season caused the Browns to turn on him in an outright farce.
Also Denzel Ward being a success and Saquon not for injury concerns is weird. They have equal pro bowls and Saquon has three 1k yard seasons.
Baker as a bust is unfair in ways because if he never played with that blown shoulder it would be a different story. If he somehow revives his career in Tampa bay that’ll be nice.
It's also safe to say any of the other QBs in that draft wouldn't have done as well in the circumstances. Allen and Lamar would not have dropped into good systems, darnold and Rosen simply sucked. He was the best pick and did pretty decent all things considered
Love watching old draft recaps before the draft
Really happy to see Jakob Johnson in the "Notable undrafted players" category. Germany was thrilled when he made it to the league.
One of the best parts of the lead up to the NFL draft. Can't wait for 2019 next year.
I've been waiting for this since last week. God bless Jaire "The Great" Alexander.
Speaking of which, Green Bay could've just taken Jaire at their original pick (#14) but the trade down with the saints (#14->#27) got them a 2019 1st, then moved up 9 spots with Seattle (#27->#18) for only a 3rd and a 6th to grab him. An absolute hosejob by Gutekunst in his 1st year as GM.
Also, loving your inclusion of Sonic CD music in your recent vids.
Crazy to see this 2 years later after Darnold and Baker turned their careers around
No it is crazy. I thought well this aged like milk
The top 3 picks from 2018 went from busts to franchise legends in 2024
Ohhh boyyy, now I can’t wait for the 2019 revisit.
POV watching this after baker, Darold and Sqaun after there best years
Pats fan here. Wanted Nick Chubb and Lamar from this draft, and got Michel and Wynn. Will never forget this
I’m happy this series returned!
Man, that guy announcing Philly's pick at the end was fantastic. That is old-school pro wrestling HEAT right there.
David Akers... former kicker of many years with Philadelphia, ended his career with the 49ers
This video aged very interestingly
I honestly thought there was no way you would be able to accurately describe baker as the number 1 pick in terms of what happened and the bust/boom angle, but you nailed it. Impressive
I think Sam darnald redeemed himself this year with the Vikings
24:29 I’m not joking when I say Ik this by heart and can repeat it on command including the announcers “uhoh” and “ OO!””oh!”. Literally best draft pick announcement ever
Please do more of these videos! Revisit some of the old 2000 drafts
So about that Darnold perspective
The Ghosts of New York came back to haunt him 🤣
This is a great retrospective series
We need to revisit this revisit
The 2018 nfl draft video was the first UT video I ever watched. Been here ever since… and became a Steelers fan.
Josh Rosen is such a comedian 😂
I’ve loved this series since the first one. Can’t wait for next years release!
When we look back on Baker Mayfield years from now, he won't be considered a bust imo. He not only brought the Browns of all teams to the promised lands, he actually won them a playoff game. Something I don't think will happen for a long time going forward
I was waiting for this day, I'm so excited!! I hope you can finally make that world Cup vid soon tho, no rush
Truly one of the better drafts in recent memory IMO. Can't believe how much incredible talent came from the later rounds. If only Baltimore would pay thier best QB in franchise history...
Well do I have good news for *you*...
Love the Jet Set Radio Future music that was one of my most favorite childhood games of all time🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
After the 2024 regular season this desperately needs a regrade
Watched the whole video just to watch David Akers troll Dallas magnificently. You didn't disappoint. Gets me every time! We prefer to call Dallas Goedert by the nickname "Phil" in our household (:
Man I love this draft class, when it's on the field.
Good on you UrinatingTree for highlighting the 7th Round pick by the Eagles of Jordan Mailata! Man's done incredible work to come from his background and play a key role for the Eagles to make the Super Bowl a few months ago.
seeing this now, baker isn’t a bust anymore. he did some work with the buccs
His time in Cleveland was more mid, but he proved to simply need a change of scenery
Here after baker completely turned his career around and became a high quality starting qb in tampa bay
Looking forward to 2019's retrospective hopefully next week...
Same
Crazy how baker and same have changed in the 2 years after this video…
Coming back to this after Baker Mayfield became the first visiting QB to have a perfect passer rating at Lambeau Field. I’d say he’s a meh. Glad to see him turn things around with Tampa.
its actually crazy to look at this draft because normally, 5 years u can tell where a player is in there career but I feel like this is one of the few drafts where u have to wait another 5 years to tell where half these players truly are
These are always great. Here’s to another five points meltdown this year!
LOL... The push notification of Lamar's extension came at the exact time I was seeing him selected in this video!
$185 millons guaranteed! If Lamar Jackson was a sexual predator he could have received even more!
You jinxed Baker by labeling him as a Bust. Look at him now in Tampa
baker is mid at best
Can't wait for the NHL Drafy coverage from the UrinatinTree. This years NHL entry draft is bomb loaded with tallent !!!!!
It's funny watching this knowing baker is actually good now
UT on Calvin Ridley: "Just do us all a favour and stay away from the gambling apps."
Also UT: "A big thanks to our sponsor, DraftKings!"
Lol yeah
Omg i just realized that the tree jynx hit baker Mayfield
And sort of sam darnold it just came a little later
The guy at the end with the "Last time...born yet" line was gold.
Who’s here after baker just blew the eagles back out
I like coming back to these kind of videos to show that someone like Baker can be considered a bust one year and have a resurgence to another playoff win the next. Hes finally in a respectable organization that can understand him and develop a game under him
The injury theme was so strong with some of these poor kids. Penney in particular was sad because he clearly is an extremely talented kid. Hope he has at least one full season in the NFL before he's done. Also, Seattle should never use their first pick on running backs...it just doesn't work out for them.
They did not this year.
The last time we used a first round pick on a back and it worked out was Curt Warner in 1983 arguably (unless John L Williams was also a first in 86).
@@fortynights1513 haha, that's going back 40 years to find a good 1st rounder RB. I was thinking more along the lines of Penney (who sadly has been unlucky with injuries) or Christine Michael off the top of my head. Michael was a second rounder but Seattle's first pick, if I recall.
NGL this is my favorite and first ever nfl draft I watched so much talent and so many busts 😂😂
Ah, nostalgia. This was the draft that coincided with my really getting back into football. Good times when we thought Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold would be good
Josh Rosen as a bust I will forever maintain came down to people continuing to fuck around with him and putting him in a position to fail. Guy was legit and got put on teams that immediately went ohh shiny at the next guy.
@@thelinedrive he was cocky af and sucked every chance he got after that, not giving him the benefit of the doubt
@@thelinedrive Funniest part is that everything you said now looks like might apply to Darnold lmao
This absolutely lifts my miserable day. I've been so excited for this video because I love when you tackle past history, it's one of my most watched Playlists. Thanks Tree 💛🖤💛🖤
He’s gotta come back to this draft
love how you been doing this so long that you can go back and watch your initial opinion on the draft and than watch this
This would be SO different if done 1 or 2 years ago. Shocking how quick things change