Live💥Karen Read Trial Day 26💥Tpr Paul’s Pirouette Theory & Whiffin’s Infomercial💥Huge L for CW‼️

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 июн 2024
  • Trooper Joseph Paul, MSP Accident Reconstruction Expert - Direct (cont'd from Day 25) & Cross by Alan Jackson, Esq.;
    Ian Whiffin, CW Expert re: 2:27 "hos long to die in cold" Google search Testimony;
    Trooper Nicholas Guarino, MSP cellphone forensics & computer forensics, Direct (to be cont'd on Day 28) Text messages between Karen Read & John O'Keefe.
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @attorneymelanielittle
    WAYS TO SUPPORT:
    VENMO: www.venmo.com/u/Melanie-Littl...
    BUY ME A MATCHA: www.buymeacoffee.com/mlittlen
    CASH APP : cash.app/$AttyMelanieLittle
    #karenread #johnokeefe #norfolkcounty #freekarenread #canton #massachusetts #commonwealth #justiceforjohnokeefe #fbi #bostonglobe #aclu #firstamendment #1stamendment #trial #forensics #forensicscience #jury #triallawyer
    #lawyerreacts #lawyer #legalanalysis #truecrime #law #lawtube #crime #criminallaw
    I have been receiving so many inquiries regarding my on-camera makeup, skincare and haircare that I have listed them all in my
    AMAZON STOREFRONT: www.amazon.com/shop/the.melan...
    WARNING: Some of these products may be life-changing. You're welcome. Oh, and I may earn commissions if you happen to buy anything.
    FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL: Instagram: / the.melanie.little
    MY IMDb: www.imdb.me/melanielittle
    NOT LEGAL ADVICE: This video is made solely for the purpose of commentary for entertainment and educational purposes, and no attorney -client relationship is created through comments or interaction with this channel. All suspects are deemed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Комментарии • 289

  • @25yrsotj
    @25yrsotj 8 дней назад +21

    🚨🚨Please keep the comments classy, NO victim shamming, NO profanity, NO harassing anyone and NO Doxxing ! Thank You ! 🚨🚨

    • @janetteehan8230
      @janetteehan8230 8 дней назад

      Hi Melanie- a Bostonian and KR supporter here. Please ask or get the message to the defense team to lay off the sarcasm. I understand their frustration but it’s not a good look and may backfire with the jurors.

    • @Jina_G
      @Jina_G 8 дней назад +1

      ​@@janetteehan8230 I disagree....the jury could possibly be hanging off the sarcasm as it's warranted....

    • @NielNBob
      @NielNBob 8 дней назад +1

      do these rules apply to lally?

    • @25yrsotj
      @25yrsotj 7 дней назад +1

      @@crayonwriter that’s the way Melanie wants it, if you don’t like it, watch elsewhere !

  • @kaymusictaylor7214
    @kaymusictaylor7214 8 дней назад +28

    This garbage is allowed, but defense has to beg and plead for their witnesses to be allowed.

    • @Jina_G
      @Jina_G 8 дней назад +2

      He's a great witness for the defence!!

  • @Watchdog_McCoy_5.7x28
    @Watchdog_McCoy_5.7x28 8 дней назад +38

    If a woman's freedom wasn't hanging in the balance, I'd say the accident reconstruction witness was absolute comedy gold.
    The phone experts also never were definitely able to prove Jen McCabe did not make the search at 227am. Her husband, the IT guy imo is the one that deleted it and covered the tracks.

  • @wildwesthogs3702
    @wildwesthogs3702 8 дней назад +9

    The missing key cycles must have been butt deleted.

  • @lizl2432
    @lizl2432 8 дней назад +41

    That text “I’m going home the kids are alone”, proves to me she didn’t kill him.

    • @criticaldarling1982
      @criticaldarling1982 8 дней назад +9

      Right!! Like what was the CW trying to prove with that “diabolical” text 🙄

    • @PrettyEyezT
      @PrettyEyezT 8 дней назад +4

      It always was just her trying to get him to come home had she killed him why would she be texting someone she know she hit

    • @NewtOKC
      @NewtOKC 8 дней назад +2

      I have long believed that KR was never even at 34 Fairview. I think John got a ride with someone at the bar and she left from the bar to go to Johns house. That’s why she said to Jen McCabe they need to go back to the bar to look for him. It was McCabe who redirected her to 34 Fairview. KR was so frantic at this point, she just assumed JM knew better. Little did she know. 😢

    • @primalcritters
      @primalcritters 6 дней назад

      ​@@NewtOKC100 %. Regardless even if she did go to Fairview and forgot, she still didn't hit him. No injuries from a vehicle whatsoever proven by the Reconstruction from the fbi. No injuries on his body consistent with vehicular homicide. Injuries consistent with a fight and a dog attack

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 6 дней назад

      ​@@NewtOKC
      hint: she didn't say that to Jen liar McCabe....

  • @timelymanner-nz
    @timelymanner-nz 8 дней назад +16

    I feel for Officer John O'Keefe's family. This whole investigation has shown zero respect for them.

  • @claudia70031
    @claudia70031 8 дней назад +20

    The more I watch Mrs O'Keefe i get the feeling she is not really in to finding the truth what happened to her son, her hate for Karen is blinden her. It's so sad for her

    • @archangel807
      @archangel807 8 дней назад +3

      Why was son John never married at 45

    • @PrettyEyezT
      @PrettyEyezT 8 дней назад +2

      On Friday it almost seemed as if his brother and sister in law maybe starting to realize Karen was framed just by their reaction

    • @bobking4031
      @bobking4031 6 дней назад

      In my opinion the Okeefe family couldn't see past their nose. They wouldn't know the truth if it jumped up and bit them on the arse. Their mind is made up and nothing will change that i feel sorry for narrow minded people like the O'keefe family.

    • @bobking4031
      @bobking4031 6 дней назад

      @@PrettyEyezT Nope nothing will change their mind they are narrow minded

  • @susanarbogast5224
    @susanarbogast5224 8 дней назад +22

    Poor Trooper Paul. He was scared to death & stammering. Clearly no expert in his field. I was so embarrassed for him. As a juror, I would not put any confidence in anything he said.

    • @esmereldapinchon1422
      @esmereldapinchon1422 8 дней назад +6

      He was put in a bad position.

    • @wendyc1902
      @wendyc1902 8 дней назад +2

      Trooper Paul sounds like a toddler at times with his speech, so yes, I felt sorry for him at times too.
      Bless his heart he probably believed he did a good job.
      I didn't feel like he was being intentionally deceitful, I felt like he was given terrible information and I'll bet when he was working the scene he scratched his head on multiple occasions!
      He was probably told, a brother in law enforcement was murdered by a woman who intentionally hit him with her SUV...tell us how it happened.
      Now on the stand, of course he has to defend his work.
      His Shytty superiors put him up to this!

    • @missliss2581able
      @missliss2581able 7 дней назад +1

      @@wendyc1902he’s not a child though. And he agreed to testify to things that do not make any sense in an effort to put a woman in prison for the rest of her life. He could have told Lally “I cannot truthfully testify to this theory of the accident” and that would have been the end of it because Lally cannot knowingly suborn perjury. In my view, he’s getting the treatment he deserves in people thinking he’s an incompetent liar.

    • @jeffhampton7405
      @jeffhampton7405 День назад

      @@missliss2581ableFrom what I’ve seen, Lally has no problem suborning perjury. I’d like to see him disbarred.

  • @suzannebaker8777
    @suzannebaker8777 8 дней назад +15

    Jenn MCCabe didn’t delete anything. Her husbands IT company did it for her.

    • @suzannebaker8777
      @suzannebaker8777 8 дней назад +7

      Or Higgins federal resource he accessed for his phone.

  • @Thumbelina-pj5wt
    @Thumbelina-pj5wt 8 дней назад +9

    If I was destroyed this badly on the stand, I’d quit and become a dog walker or something

  • @HappyPupMomma
    @HappyPupMomma 8 дней назад +15

    Sounds like he didn’t want to break up with her because he was using her to help raise the kids. Selfish. He treated her like shit! Very sad.

    • @bobking4031
      @bobking4031 8 дней назад +4

      Yes Kerry Roberts stated Karen was nothing more than a baby sitter with benefits. That shows me there was talk amongst so called friends. I wonder what type a man JO really was and how many of the friends he was on with.

  • @ginasemons7401
    @ginasemons7401 8 дней назад +29

    My heart breaks for Karen. She was feeling so under appreciated and I feel like John was just using her 😢

    • @caravanbeethoven4449
      @caravanbeethoven4449 8 дней назад +17

      @ginasemons7401
      Me too. She just wanted answers and he wasn’t willing to give them.
      She sounded sad, not mad! 😔

    • @Jina_G
      @Jina_G 8 дней назад +4

      My heart breaks for her too. But she's an extremely intelligent woman - a professor I believe, and she's one tough cookie. And has millions of people standing right beside her x

    • @sharontriffitt7031
      @sharontriffitt7031 8 дней назад +1

      I agree Karen was feeling under appreciated. It seems she did a lot for the children. John using her? Not sure. Perhaps taking her for granted. Either way it's tragic for everyone.

  • @Jina_G
    @Jina_G 8 дней назад +8

    Watching from Australia, where our kangaroos roam the land, not the courthouse.

    • @sharontriffitt7031
      @sharontriffitt7031 8 дней назад +1

      And our Wombats are animals not Law Enforcement. Hi from Tassie

  • @sngray11
    @sngray11 8 дней назад +16

    Thank you Melanie, mods, members and this community for being my support system throughout this trial. 💗 My song for the CW witnesses that testified today is “Anti-Hero” by Taylor Swift. Lallygagging Lally keeps presenting Proctored evidence and nothing burgers at the motions in lemonade stand.

  • @sethfroman7044
    @sethfroman7044 8 дней назад +8

    I was stating this since Friday, that his “trigger” info was coming from the tow truck guy. Look at the ring footage. Tow truck driver guns it, wheels spinning, jerks the wheel hard, bc he almost hits the flat bed, there is so much snow he has to plow through. I suspected that was the event

  • @Berendo4ever
    @Berendo4ever 8 дней назад +5

    I've never said OMG and WTF out loud so many times during a trial before

  • @StElmosFire53
    @StElmosFire53 8 дней назад +10

    Someone needs the buck to stop at them. MSP, GOVERNOR, OR PROSECUTOR NEEDS TO STOP THIS CHARADE

    • @2hearts1song4ever8
      @2hearts1song4ever8 8 дней назад +5

      Lally needs to walk in waving a white flag tomorrow. IMO

  • @melmac685
    @melmac685 8 дней назад +14

    Those txt did make Karen sound like she was a "friend w/benefits" ...JOK found her convenient, imo👀

  • @Jessica-pd5wx
    @Jessica-pd5wx 8 дней назад +3

    Loved seeing you and Natalie together!!! Nothing like seeing two strong, beautiful ladies come together. I really love yalls “girl power” and the way you both promote and are not threatened by other strong, beautiful women. Yalls firecracker personalities compliment each other so well!! ♥️

  • @hellenjennissen6176
    @hellenjennissen6176 8 дней назад +12

    Congratulations Ms Melanie Little with 50K viewers! You definitely deserve it !!❤💞🌹

  • @ItsKimmiC_
    @ItsKimmiC_ 8 дней назад +4

    Today was the first day I’ve watched and I’m so glad I found you and the rest of my people. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I’ll be returning back tomorrow. Thank you for keeping it classy.

  • @lorettadrover6553
    @lorettadrover6553 8 дней назад +7

    The calculation of the stuff 🤣🤣🤣🤣what a joke. Trooper Paul got destroyed like I have never seen in my life …

  • @r-e_mii
    @r-e_mii 8 дней назад +5

    Congrats on 50k🎉
    Shame on CW for putting Trooper Paul on the stand with the info he had, completely showing how erroneous this investigation was. On a moral level, i feel bad that he may feel embarrassed due to not being good with public speaking, speech issues plague many.
    Ps: Whiffen is former LE

  • @marendameron
    @marendameron 8 дней назад +2

    Melanie, I’ve watched other law commentators on this same day, and you are the only one that is this skeptical of Whiffin. Thank you for your perspective! (Also, as a physics teacher, I was screaming at the phone watching Paul 😳 ugh!)

  • @pbentsonable
    @pbentsonable 8 дней назад +5

    Trooper Paul probably left the court room cried and started looking for a new job.

  • @SD-hj2et1nt6z
    @SD-hj2et1nt6z 8 дней назад +4

    I love that you keep Lally’s direct examination more entertaining- otherwise we’d all be bored and not be able to watch. Truly grateful for your commentary and watching with you. Also love seeing all the photos of your visit to Dedham last Friday! I made the attempt to come to Dedham but it started down-pouring as I drove closer to Dedham so I turned around and went back home! Bummed I didn’t get to meet you in person! Glad you got some a warm welcome from the FKR supporters!!!

  • @debrasalmon2498
    @debrasalmon2498 8 дней назад +4

    I hope the Gov after what Proctor said. is watching this, these are her state troopers.

  • @mikeurban93
    @mikeurban93 8 дней назад +3

    First, keep in mind Celebrite report clearly indicates a search was made at 2:27 and deleted. So the defense witness is simply supporting/verifying this evidence.
    There is an old brainteaser. “If a chicken and a half laid an egg and a half, how much would a pound of butter weigh?” Many people answer, “a pound and a half.”
    However, the answer is “1 pound.” A pound of butter will always weigh a pound- nothing can change that fact. The prosecution witnesses say lots of words that are confusing to a jury, but if my understanding is correct, none of it matters.
    A Write Ahead Log (.WAL) file is a temporary file that is never updated once it has been flushed to the database. Think of it like a time capsule that has been sealed. If Jen put her search in a time capsule and locked it under ground for eternity, then anything that happens after the fact is irrelevant.
    I will give the prosecution possibly one (unhelpful) point. These (WAL) files are “flushed” out at regular intervals. Perhaps every 5 minutes (estimate). But all that means is the search may have been done between 2:22 and 2:27 - either way it’s before the timestamp on the WAL file.
    If you want more detail, let me know. There is more to this.
    As far as the deletes. Notice how the prosecution witnesses don’t agree, and both seem confused about the deletes. This is a horse of a different color. I can explain my theory on that as well if you want me to.
    Keep in mind, the gold standard Celebrite report supports the defense not the prosecution.

  • @Shelley1466
    @Shelley1466 8 дней назад +7

    It potentially perhaps maybe could have but potentially could have been wildly wrong. But could have been right too, correct? 🤦🏻‍♀️

  • @suzannebaker8777
    @suzannebaker8777 8 дней назад +5

    Why is it witnesses for the prosecution claim everybody else’s reports are incorrect but theirs 🤥

  • @suzannebaker8777
    @suzannebaker8777 8 дней назад +7

    “Kill Me” Trooper Guarino. 😮

    • @lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090
      @lawrenceandcheryldoudiet5090 8 дней назад +1

      To me, it sounded like Lally saying that on a hot mic. Sounds just like when he eats the mic when he objects. Look at the witness’s mouth when it’s being said.

  • @lisolette1
    @lisolette1 8 дней назад +6

    I think she was pacing herself with seltzer at the bar because she had to drive , and then got to 1 meadows and started to drink

  • @caravanbeethoven4449
    @caravanbeethoven4449 8 дней назад +11

    I really really hope to God that Karen sues everyone involved in this horrible scam!
    💖 to Karen!

  • @lynleywesterbeke7106
    @lynleywesterbeke7106 8 дней назад +3

    What a roller coaster of emotions. Laughter, surprise, confusion, sadness. I have for a long time felt JOK was mayby a little commitment avoidant. He sounds like a lovely, gregarious person who easily made connections with others. This does not negate from the possibly he was also not great with committed romantic relationships.

  • @MyLizzie22
    @MyLizzie22 8 дней назад +4

    Thank you Melanie for your compassion and understanding what Karen has been through. I can relate to her illnesses and pain. Crohns disease is a killer. Imagine 10 operations on her intestines. Multiple Sclerosis too. Even the biologics have awful side effects.
    My theory is that John could not make a commitment. She started feeling rejected. Im sure he had his own demons with trauma as well. Its just really sad life was so difficult for them both. May God heal Karen and the O’Keefe family.

  • @aliciastalksessions
    @aliciastalksessions 8 дней назад +4

    Lally is monotone. Wait!😮 did that man just say the crime scene told him👀. The crime scene spoke to him is that what dude just said?🙄

  • @bill9729
    @bill9729 8 дней назад +4

    Paul sounds like he is presenting a junior high science project.

    • @FreeloaderWoodchuck
      @FreeloaderWoodchuck 8 дней назад

      And he had his mom run out at 9pm to get him a trifold poster board the night before this presentation 🤣

  • @Whackjob_
    @Whackjob_ 8 дней назад +8

    The reason all trooper heads are shaved is so that they weren't memorable to the jury. The goal is to make the jury only remember the last trooper to testify, who is both very presentable and has his full head of hair. He is the jury's final memory of a "trooper".
    However, it backfired. Trooper Joseph Paul, even with his shaved head, was painfully memorable more than any other witness. Also, blending shaved heads will never make the jury forget Proctor's behavior.

    • @2hearts1song4ever8
      @2hearts1song4ever8 8 дней назад +2

      💯

    • @gagecarlsen3872
      @gagecarlsen3872 8 дней назад

      Glad to know If you Shave your head you’re not memorable 🙄

    • @Whackjob_
      @Whackjob_ 8 дней назад +4

      @@gagecarlsen3872 Since you missed the point of the post.. The goal was to present one that is not like the rest and to present that one very last.

    • @gagecarlsen3872
      @gagecarlsen3872 8 дней назад +1

      @@Whackjob_”the goal is to make them remember the last guy with the full head of hair.” As if that makes him more memorable… you said it. Not me.

    • @Whackjob_
      @Whackjob_ 8 дней назад +2

      @@gagecarlsen3872 Yes, the full head of hair contrasts against the multiple bald heads. That was the entire point of my post.
      Would you prefer we make this an unrealistic safe space where no one talks about bald heads?

  • @physics4290
    @physics4290 8 дней назад +3

    In fairness, it's possible that Jen McCabe googles "It's raining men" every day. He said the list was not exhaustive.

  • @lillyshaw9439
    @lillyshaw9439 8 дней назад +5

    Those texts from John to Karen were sad. He sounded a bit mean to her. 😢

  • @melmac685
    @melmac685 8 дней назад +6

    And about those shattered pieces of taillight..it's amazing to me a bump in JOKs driveway "didn't do 😅damage" according to CW, but BEING IN an evidence bag WILL create more pieces ?? Make that make sense ..js 😮

  • @sethfroman7044
    @sethfroman7044 8 дней назад +4

    Hopefully Trooper Paul comes forward after all this and explains what truly happened behind closed doors. I believe he was pressured into this case and to write a BS report. Hope he comes forward and tells all how dirty the MSP and DA’s office is

    • @ItsKimmiC_
      @ItsKimmiC_ 7 дней назад +1

      I think that’s why he had as much trouble as he did. He has a conscience. He will probably never come clean because to do so he will have to admit to perjury.

  • @kaymusictaylor7214
    @kaymusictaylor7214 8 дней назад +3

    It's hideous that the judge allowed this.

  • @kimmcdonald8443
    @kimmcdonald8443 8 дней назад +1

    Replay here! Omg Melanie; I just saw Action Jackson do a pirouette in the middle of saving Karen's life. 😂😂😂😂 the look on his face at is priceless!

  • @criticaldarling1982
    @criticaldarling1982 8 дней назад +9

    How do you do an accident reconstruction if you don’t know the height & weight of the victim or the weight of the vehicle 😂 Today I learned the Plastic is harder than Steel, & Human skin is harder than plastic. Therefore Skin is harder than Steel 💪🏼🙌🏼

  • @DramaMustRemainOnTheStage
    @DramaMustRemainOnTheStage 8 дней назад +4

    These kids were legally old enough to stay home alone none of this is Karens fault. She got used by John for a ride. No no no. THESE REXT MAKE HER EVEN MORE INNOCENT

  • @jaysmith5047
    @jaysmith5047 8 дней назад +2

    True. Okeefe family should direct their ire toward Proctor, not Karen.

  • @kjn3005
    @kjn3005 8 дней назад +1

    We were so excited to see you Friday at the courthouse getting a warm and wonderful reception❤ Melanie you are full of truth and grace! We appreciate you❣️ I don’t know how Karen has kept her sanity sitting through this trial day after day with such grace!
    Justice for Karen Read❤️❤️❤❤

  • @Katiekay.
    @Katiekay. 8 дней назад +27

    Trooper Paul was set up by the DA and this is heartbreaking to watch him stutter and stumble through this is painful... I truly believe he is a victim who the CW knew did not have the credentials to be testifying about the accident reconstruction and yet they strong-armed him into the hot seat under false pretenses. He was crucified and embarrassed and made to be their sacrificial lamb.... i would be FURIOUS if I was him.... This is despicable

    • @gagecarlsen3872
      @gagecarlsen3872 8 дней назад +14

      He could have done what was right and said “I’m not testifying to something I have no knowledge about” I don’t think he was forced. I could be wrong but I feel like he brought it on himself! 🤷‍♂️

    • @melodiecason2799
      @melodiecason2799 8 дней назад +6

      ​@@gagecarlsen3872I agree with you.

    • @noodlesmom01
      @noodlesmom01 8 дней назад +5

      It was soooo hard to watch!!

    • @alexwyatt2911
      @alexwyatt2911 8 дней назад +7

      I would agree with you _if_ Trooper Paul hadn’t repeatedly been such an argumentative brat. There were so many moments that he reminded me of a snotty 13-year-old boy trying to lie to his teacher to weasel his way out of trouble.

    • @r-e_mii
      @r-e_mii 8 дней назад +4

      I felt so bad for him. He obviously doesn't speak well & while it's not how someone says something, it's what they say that's true, this officer is disposable to them. Whether or not he knew the info or was told it was good enough won't ever be answered, I think he kept challenging Jackson because he had been reassured.

  • @kristinastoico7422
    @kristinastoico7422 8 дней назад +2

    Karen looked like she had a sense of relief when AJ was talking about the key cycles.

  • @delenem6991
    @delenem6991 8 дней назад +4

    so Wiffin is talking about untested tech tools he wrote, but arent actually part of the Celebrite tools ... ok... and he didnt think it could have been deleted... so if she gave it to an IT tech to clean up stuff she didnt want found... they could easliy do it...

  • @lauraliz6201
    @lauraliz6201 7 дней назад +1

    1:21:00 “it just did”
    Saving these lovely moments for posterity

  • @erikamad5
    @erikamad5 8 дней назад +1

    Thank You! I had a really bad day but laughed out loud with you on replay!

  • @Fredburg4485
    @Fredburg4485 7 дней назад

    I own a Toyota and I had to sign an agreement that they would be collecting data about my driving and operation of the vehicle when I bought it.

  • @HappyPupMomma
    @HappyPupMomma 8 дней назад +4

    I’m sorry but the fact that OJO was ignoring her calls only makes him look like an a-hole. DOES NOT GO FROM THIS TO KILLING HIM! This is so moronic!

  • @lizl2432
    @lizl2432 8 дней назад +6

    Thank God I have you to watch this with because a certain “lawtuber” who is the only other woman with the quick quips and wit that I watch is great but she speaks over the dialogue of the witnesses and it drives me insane.
    I don’t know how so many people are able to watch it that way, my brain was twitching Friday when you weren’t here. So thank you for your pauses and commentary.

    • @astrialindah2773
      @astrialindah2773 6 дней назад

      I know exactly who you're talking about, and every time I do watch her videos I'm yelling at the screen for her to shut up shut up shut up so I can hear what is being said in the trial! I love how Melanie mutes the trial so that she can make her point 😍

  • @user-ps2nk7uk7c
    @user-ps2nk7uk7c 7 дней назад

    Guarino called John Officer O’Keefe! Well it’s ABOUT DAMN TIME.

  • @kaymusictaylor7214
    @kaymusictaylor7214 8 дней назад +9

    Still no evidence Officer O'Keefe was hit by Karen's car.

  • @laurigravis8471
    @laurigravis8471 8 дней назад

    Just thank you, people go through this nonsense every day

  • @wildauzziewoman
    @wildauzziewoman 8 дней назад +1

    I would have wanted a photo with u too Mel. You’re my kinda gal ( not like that) I mean you are strong, gutsy & straight to the point! 🇦🇺🌹🥰

  • @laurajreicher
    @laurajreicher 5 дней назад

    When Trooper Paul talks about the cup, just imagine The Beatles “Here, there, and Everywhere” Revolver

  • @ccjohn14_6
    @ccjohn14_6 8 дней назад +1

    That cop said "kill me now" because he knew what he was about to read.

  • @Kralechka
    @Kralechka 7 дней назад

    The accident reconstructionist should have been a key witness for Lally. He did such a poor job validating him

  • @MimiDidi121
    @MimiDidi121 8 дней назад +13

    I feel bad for Karen we’d all probably be mortified if anyone read the texts messages when we’re in a fight with our significant other! I’m ready for the Commonwealth to stop defending Jen McCabe, and start trying to prosecute Karen Read! Here we are eight weeks into testimony and we have no idea how this happened or what his cause of death was. I’m beyond frustrated. We all believe she’s innocent and the CW isn’t doing anything to change our minds. We’re supposed to believe she’s innocent, by the way, until or unless she’s proven guilty.

    • @mikedirado4270
      @mikedirado4270 8 дней назад +4

      I do feel bad for Karen. But if i was a juror i would know that is just normal stuff. And there nothing in the texts that make me feel any different. But i do understand your opinion. I think the commonwealth is doing a terrible job.

    • @gagecarlsen3872
      @gagecarlsen3872 8 дней назад +1

      @@mikedirado4270who are you kidding? This isn’t normal for them to spend weeks not even proving Karen’s guilt. Not normal stuff if you’re a juror.

    • @mikedirado4270
      @mikedirado4270 8 дней назад +3

      @@gagecarlsen3872 hey gage. Maybe you didn’t understand me. Im pretty bad at explaining things. My ADHD things. I meant there was nothing that came out of the text messages that changed my mind. The jurors are all from Boston. Im from Philly. Sometimes in relationships this happens. I think its normal. And i would think the jury would agree.

    • @mikedirado4270
      @mikedirado4270 8 дней назад +2

      @@gagecarlsen3872 also gage. I have watched about 100 trials. And i think KR is innocent as much as I thought Daryll brooks is guilty. I just meant i think the jurors would understand sometimes text gets heated. Its normal. It doesn’t mean you would run someone over

    • @jborrego2406
      @jborrego2406 8 дней назад

      ​@@mikedirado4270don't worry what you wrote was understandable I totally understand you were talking about the text messages

  • @SarahClancy8
    @SarahClancy8 8 дней назад +6

    I’m at 2:22:07 in the feed…. and they’re talking about all of these different things that were deleted and they’re looking at the list of everything they keep talking about 227 but that’s UTC time next to every single piece of time it says -5, which is what you would do in order to calculate Eastern standard time. So they’re talking about stuff that didn’t even happen at that time….. i’m hoping Jackson and Yannetti destroy him, but I’m just hoping to set up. That’s what I’m gonna see…. But once again, they are trying to pull the wool over peoples eyes

    • @joelletaylor8939
      @joelletaylor8939 8 дней назад +2

      To use Jen McCabe‘s words… “If you’re going to cherry pick”. 🧐

    • @joelletaylor8939
      @joelletaylor8939 8 дней назад +3

      I too hope they caught what you did. I have paid more attention since Jen actually called all of her deleted messages… “Cherry picking”.

  • @Shelley1466
    @Shelley1466 8 дней назад +4

    Late but he wasn’t responding earlier in day. No wonder she was mad. I would be too!

  • @Carabsn
    @Carabsn 8 дней назад +2

    So sad to watch what’s going on. Karen was in a relationship and finding out John had great qualities but the drinking! It was his priority and totally gravitating to drinking. It’s sad. It happens and it stinks. Karen wanted the best for all. Those other woman calling and ignoring Karen weren’t helping. They should have been glad for John but chose to be the judge and jury even though they didn’t know what’s clearly was the issue

  • @bcastle2397
    @bcastle2397 7 дней назад +1

    It just did!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @sallyenright3066
    @sallyenright3066 8 дней назад +2

    Love your channel.

  • @lindala2602
    @lindala2602 7 дней назад

    I've tried the embarresment to be as unprepared for an exam as this. The difference is i was just trying to pass new testament greek not put someone in jail for life

  • @ElizabethLizziBennett33
    @ElizabethLizziBennett33 6 дней назад

    What gives them the right to dismantle her car, destroy the mother board the brain of the car for absolutely NOTHING!! I'M FURIOUS WITH THESE SO CALLED LAW ENFORCEMENT PROFESSIONALS!!! I HAVE NO WORDS!

  • @delenem6991
    @delenem6991 8 дней назад +2

    Clever phone. it only deleted the butt dials and dodgy stuff

  • @andreabroughton7394
    @andreabroughton7394 8 дней назад +2

    I work for the MA trial courts. We are closed Wednesday 6/19

    • @StElmosFire53
      @StElmosFire53 8 дней назад +1

      What are they saying at the perverbial water fountain about this case. Why is it not being stopped with charges dropped. The head of MSP and many others heads are going to roll IMO

  • @rosaliebryant-ahearn3604
    @rosaliebryant-ahearn3604 8 дней назад +1

    Hopefully Trooper Paul gets more education. He was truly out of his depth and should not been put in this position. I feel for him.

  • @Jina_G
    @Jina_G 8 дней назад +2

    So how far up or down the street was Karen stationary before she put the pedal to the metal in reverse? 🤔

  • @Jina_G
    @Jina_G 8 дней назад +1

    I hope AJ and DV watch yours and Marks (on the young jurks) streams Melanie.... just in case they miss something that you and Mark pick up....🤞

  • @Jina_G
    @Jina_G 8 дней назад

    Trooper Paul.... best witness of this trial bless him.

  • @digitdeb7435
    @digitdeb7435 8 дней назад +1

    Congratulations on the 50 k Melanie

  • @diannestickney8197
    @diannestickney8197 8 дней назад +1

    He's a trooper with a full head of hair.

  • @diannestickney8197
    @diannestickney8197 8 дней назад +3

    What if the internal investigation leads to who or what really happened will there be another full investigation and trial?

  • @kathyleung1235
    @kathyleung1235 8 дней назад

    Love your site1

  • @rachelpearson3706
    @rachelpearson3706 6 дней назад

    I just watched the hot mic moment. He knows what he's about to read and how awful it is for the world to read their personal messages.

  • @MFC7625
    @MFC7625 6 дней назад

    The English guy used his own software, which is not accredited. He produced documents that he typed himself, not extractions. He discredited Cellebrite, which is used in every single investigation across the States.

  • @louisejeffries7155
    @louisejeffries7155 8 дней назад +2

    I do wonder if the computer man might have a plagiarism suit chasing him now

  • @DramaMustRemainOnTheStage
    @DramaMustRemainOnTheStage 8 дней назад +2

    @attorney melanie little I have not heard anyone say like i have I do not blame karen for not going into that house with a bunch of drunk cops and snit friends Karen was the outsider I dont think it was meant for those in the house to have killed john but it happened. She didnt deserve his bs or his friends

  • @gaylecorwin3460
    @gaylecorwin3460 8 дней назад

    2:40:53 I think Tpr Paul is literally telling us that the math doesn't make sense and AJ saying, yep, you're right! 24 mph in any direction isn't going to reindeer anyone anywhere, and even though I don't know the equations, and the jury probably forgot physics, too, we all know that this stinks. 🤦‍♀️

  • @sylvias7111
    @sylvias7111 8 дней назад +6

    I have MS , the mild one, but to ask Karen to take the whole upbringing of someone else's children upon her shoulders with all her medical conditions is truly brutal. I don't think John was such a saint. He and his family are part of Canton cops inner circle too..right?

  • @Ferus37
    @Ferus37 8 дней назад +1

    I feel like the prosecution have missed something important when it comes to the phone search.
    Disproving the defense's theory does not prove Karen killed anyone. That part requires separate evidence. They're not the same thing. (And proving 1 search didn't happen does neither.)
    Proving a puddle isn't milk doesn't prove that it's blood.

    • @feliztudor9463
      @feliztudor9463 8 дней назад +1

      You are using logic. Don't. Logic is optional just like the law of conservation of momentum. All just guidelines at best.

  • @jonnyreb3032
    @jonnyreb3032 7 дней назад

    Looking at a a paper on Searles eqausion. for a direct strike the vehicle woulf have to be goinging 26.8 MPH to throw John 30+ feet

  • @erikamad5
    @erikamad5 8 дней назад

    So so sad! Thanks for being live-I’m one if the replay clan.

  • @StageFright2
    @StageFright2 8 дней назад +2

    Ok… seriously, they got a dude from the Genius Bar to testify!!!! Bruce Banner or Tony Stark weren’t available… oh right…. Delete delete…. Peter Parker…..maybe???? Smh.

  • @ChimeraTruely
    @ChimeraTruely 7 дней назад

    1:53:00 Seems Paul is taking advantage of the fact that the Court struck his June 14 2024 testimony where he tried to slip in his belief that the Glass on the Bumper came from the Cup John was holding. He tried to claim it as a fact, but it had to be stricken from the record because it had already been proven that the glass did not match the cup.

  • @christianpadgett7923
    @christianpadgett7923 8 дней назад +1

    So Anthony Rizzo is run into by a 200 pound man and it breaks his arm but a Lexus hitting John O'Keefe just leaves scratches?

  • @debrasalmon2498
    @debrasalmon2498 8 дней назад +1

    I don't like all these days off for the jury. They go back to work and everyone is talking about. They know what days your at work and what days the court have off. News papers with a trooper on the front page say the MSP Want YOU. and listing all the things Protor did as the job requirement. Having to stay off social media. I have faith in the jury but with this case if would be hard.

  • @deidreb.6540
    @deidreb.6540 8 дней назад +1

    Just wondering if phone witness was aware of Higgins extracting phones at FBI offices?

  • @LostVagus
    @LostVagus 8 дней назад +2

    Playlist: "I'll Tumble 4 Ya" - Culture Club --For Trpr Paul 😅

  • @lindala2602
    @lindala2602 7 дней назад +1

    Objection, maths!!!

  • @jonnyreb3032
    @jonnyreb3032 7 дней назад

    I don't like the fact Lally gets to object to almost every question without stating grounds and Judge Bev just grant or denies without stating grounds

  • @PennyThompson-nh9wf
    @PennyThompson-nh9wf 8 дней назад

    You are great

  • @25yrsotj
    @25yrsotj 8 дней назад +3

    In Law Enforcement, like any other profession, seniority means a lot. The 2 Troopers that testified today were tossed under the bus. They were given the “crime scene” pics and notations and told the work backwards and come up with a theory ! As you can see, no senior detective took the case or has testified ! They’re all had under 15 years with Proctor being the other exception ! It’s telling me that this goes up higher than a lieut or even the da’s office ! No senior detective or cop is gonna risk their job, pension, family and jail time when their close to retirement ! I had 2nd, 3rd and 4th hand embarrassment for the first kid and then it was gone, he proved he was an idiot and puppet ! Personally I would’ve taken his guns and shield and sent him to The MSP psych dr as soon as he got off the stand !

    • @Trish.Norman
      @Trish.Norman 6 дней назад +1

      I have a question? Could he have said No without losing his job? Also, I don’t understand the hierarchy, or the chain of command here. Can the MSP say No to the district attorneys office? How does that work? Who has the ultimate authority?

    • @25yrsotj
      @25yrsotj 6 дней назад +1

      @@Trish.Norman the chain of command is usually strict in the PD and the big bosses don’t have anything to do with the cops or even sgts and lieuts on patrol ! The big bosses got where they are cuz they play the political game also ! I’m gonna venture too say that the lieuts from the MSP looked for a cop that had a transfer request in or that was in a little bit of a jam and offered to push the transfer or jam away if they took the measurements and made up testimony that matched the measurements. Could the kid have said No, sure and he’d be transferred to a place he didn’t want to work, lose whatever tour he had and the bosses would be on BJ’s a55 everyday. A lot of the PD / FD jobs are also about who you know !

    • @Trish.Norman
      @Trish.Norman 6 дней назад

      @@25yrsotj Thank you for answering! ;-)