I think it was Tommy Chunks. Jason has only been playing with Green Day since just before Warning in '99. Before that, I think he was working in a record shop in Oakland whilst playing with Pinhead Gunpowder, hence how he and Billie knew each other.
Do you have a video recording of the concert ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Achilles Rink, Schenectady, NY, USA ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Nice Guys Finish Last Hitchin' a Ride Big Yellow Taxi The Grouch Geek Stink Breath 2000 Light Years Away Longview Welcome to Paradise Brain Stew Jaded Knowledge Basket Case She Iron Man / Master of Puppets Redundant Scattered Platypus (I Hate You) King for a Day Prosthetic Head When I Come Around Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)
SOOO underated song
diablomdq yes !
green day
no it's not, never has been...
how is it not?
Underated but so enjoy listen and play this song
Why have they rarely played this song live? Its one of their best songs
Cuz it's redundant in their setlist hehehehehe
muitos acordes, o billie não iria lembrar😂😂😂
@@gabrielthambiah744
one of their top 3 songs imho
this is the first video i see them performs redundant (full band)!
me too actually
A rare live performance of Redundant.
Too rare, if you ask me. They should play it more often!
@@silhouettoofaman2935 there's another version of Redundant with the full band but only audio.
There are several videos of this song but this is one of the only ones with the full band. Most of them are just an acoustic encore performance.
One of the best songs by Greenday yet most underrated
It's so underrated, it should have been on Warning!
my favorite!
I was there. Old school
is there jason white hiding somewhere, because you can hear the solo but you can't see anybody playing it
I think it was Tommy Chunks. Jason has only been playing with Green Day since just before Warning in '99. Before that, I think he was working in a record shop in Oakland whilst playing with Pinhead Gunpowder, hence how he and Billie knew each other.
@@davidparsons97 or a looper pedal
What you can hear is actually Billie playing.. he hits some open strings while he plays the power chords
We rocked back in the day
OMG THIS IS SO GOOD the quality isn't the best but GD makes up for it!!!
I wish I saw Green Day on their Nimrod tour
voice of god
This favorite song 😢
Oh man! I've only seen acoustic/solo performances of this song!
It feels like I’m really there. What a nice time capsule. Thank you for this.
this is amazing. that is all.
26, head shake, full of punk in veins
Do you have a video recording of the concert
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Achilles Rink, Schenectady, NY, USA
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nice Guys Finish Last
Hitchin' a Ride
Big Yellow Taxi
The Grouch
Geek Stink Breath
2000 Light Years Away
Longview
Welcome to Paradise
Brain Stew
Jaded
Knowledge
Basket Case
She
Iron Man / Master of Puppets
Redundant
Scattered
Platypus (I Hate You)
King for a Day
Prosthetic Head
When I Come Around
Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)
Great performance of redundant
And look at the crowd... not a single damn phone in there. :)
One of my biggest problems with my generation
Taylor Santangelo Boom. Agreed.
brdane Though I'm glad some people filmed the old performances
*****
Yeah, with actual good-quality cameras.
there are no smart phones that time
Billie: i say WHOO!!!
Crowd : WHOOO
344 likes and no dislike. God's favorite band
now 388 - 0
448 and no dislike
Still no dislike. Very rare
504 and counting
@@smithyweberjeger-manjensen8839 577
Amazing... I had 4 months :) in this time
Now let me guess 4 years and 5 months right?
We're living in repetition
Content in the same old shtick again
Now the routine's turning to contention
Like a production line going over and over and over
Roller coaster
Now I cannot speak, I lost my voice
I'm speechless and redundant
'Cause I love you's not enough
I'm lost for words
Choreographed and lack of passion
Prototypes of what we were
Went full circle 'til I'm nauseous
Taken for granted now
I waste it, faked it, ate it, now I hate it
'Cause I cannot speak, I lost my voice
I'm speechless and redundant
'Cause I love you's not enough
I'm lost for words
Now I cannot speak, I lost my voice
I'm speechless and redundant
'Cause I love you's not enough
I'm lost for words
Now I cannot speak, I lost my voice
I'm speechless and redundant
'Cause I love you's not enough
I'm lost for words
Traducir al español
Fuente: LyricFind
Compositores: Billie Joe Armstrong / Frank E. / Iii Wright / Frank Edwin Wright Iii / Michael Pritchard / Mike Dirnt / Mike Ryan Pritchard / Tre Cool
Letra de Redundant © Warner Chappell Music, Inc
this is my 3rd favourite GD song atm
Is last scream from music video clip scary woman? Yeah yeah must be scary woman!
sad times
🔥
wooo
Real green day
I thought the guy at 0:22 will just keep leaving throughout the song
0 dislike
200 Like!
Nixon And no dislikes!