Talking bout Lily's eyes, when the memories show we can see that young Lily had brown eyes, but Harry had bloody blue eyes all the damn saga. I just don't get it
@@damaristaydevelezgomez4776 in the books Lily had green eyes. They initially had Daniel Radcliffe wear contact lenses that changed his eye color, but he couldn’t tolerate the contact lenses because they’d irritate his eyes. In the films they tried resolving this by just saying “you have your mother’s eyes” without mentioning color. For young Lily having brown eyes, I guess they thought the flashbacks were so brief it wouldn’t be too noticeable but I’m not certain.
Movie snape I assume has always been one of the most favored characters in HP, especially in this scene. He felt more like a strict teacher who emphasizes with people and shows a lack of severe hatred for harry, unlike book snape. He also doesn't bully students 24/7.
I cried for Harry and Lily, not Snape. I mean, the scene of Lily when she died to save Harry, and the knowledge that now Harry has to die too... Snape was just there listening to the news lol.
I actually thought there was always something fishy about him killing Dumbledore. The way he had been built as a character, being very mysterious, having a name that seems evil from the start, and being someone that all the signs will say to hate, yet sprinkled with acts of kindness THAG leave us confused, such as the numerous times he saved Harry. Simply making him a bad guy would’ve wasted the potential of the character that ended up being born, and I had faith Rowling wouldn’t let that happen. Though I must admit, I never could have imagined such a drastic turn around, and one that involved his entire life. Easily my favorite character.
@@peterd1623 yeah i deeply agree with you. In the books he sometimes was honestly very annoying but still i always had complete faith in Dumbledore so when he killed Dumbledore it was very fishy that how he could've possibly dicieve some one like him. I admire Rowlling for such a creativity.
The only thing I hate about a Harry Potter book is the fact that it ends. Not the ending, nor necessarily that it ended. I get so lost in the book that at the end I miss it.
I love what you said. 1000 percent true. Harry’s first words about snaps. Then his last words. He had the utmost respect for Severus snape. Sir Alan Rickman, R.I.P you will be missed Always……. 🙏
@@Gusto-dk3rv The fact that Rickman sir is no more exacerbates the scene of Prof. Snape's death even more🥺. Snape will always be one of the most respected fictional characters ever created❤. And thank you, I love talking to fellow Potterheads.💐
Rickman once said that J.K. only told him how the true story was for Snape in the first film, so he knew how he was going to play his role for the rest of the series. What a legend!
Nope,he was only told that theres is more to Snape than he seems. So acted on it, evwn when he killed Dumbledore, i refused to believe that he is a bad guy.
While we don't know for sure wgat she said to him, I am pretty sure it's along the line of "Snape was in love with Lilly, and hates on Harry for this reason".
@@shashwatsinha5291 She told him before she wrote the last books, if I remember correctly, when they first finished the initial casting and she knew Alan Rickman was gonna be Severus Snape for sure, though I could be wrong.
I’m the only one in my family that read the books before watching the movie and when we were watching the movie my parents and sister were like “he’s the bad guy” and in like “if you say so...”
He was brave like a Gryffindor He was loyal as a Hufflepuff He was as cunning as a Slytherin He was as clever as a Ravenclaw Rest in peace Severus Snape Rest in peace Alan Rickman
@@tararocksong5085 He was perfect for this role. But then if u look up his other roles, you'll see that he is actually a monotonous actor. I'm glad i didnt watch alot. I quickly turned it off so that my brain doesnt lose the magic.
The truth the hat was in doubt because it was suitable for the 4 houses but his decision to go to the house of the snake is because his mother was from that house his mother the first person I admire
Im so glad jkr shared that one tidbit she did with alan rickman! That let him see a clear path for snape and he adjusted what the script said by saying thats not what snape would do or say here. He was true to snapes real character the whole way through every movie. RIP good Sir!
And having it being followed by a shot of Snape holding Lily's body in his arms, crying. Beautiful work. It's probably the most emotional shot in the whole franchise.
and his shaky voice when he killed dumbledoor, and when he made the vow with narcissist. it was so subtle alan's acting that once we heard it we feel the pain in him for having to kill the man he respected most.
@@lady_raineidv9297 in game of thrones little finger was in love with ned stark’s wife and then little finger goes on to attempt to marry the daughter of the 2 because the daughter reminded him of the wife
Ria Gavieta Book snape:do not love harry Movie snape:love Harry I think the movie is greater about Snape In book he is all gray but in movie he is white.
And Rowling had it planned from the very start. Rickman said in an interview that Rowling pulled him aside while filming the first movie and told him Snape's entire story.
“You’ve been raising him like a pig for slaughter” I love that Snape immediately saw that Dumbledore had just been using Harry and now was asking him to be sacrificed!
Not really. Your patronus changes into the patronus of your true love. Lily's was a dove, the mate to a stag for James. They were meant to be together. But Snape's became a dove because Lily was his true love, that's how much he loved her. We also saw that happening in HPU with Tonks and Lupin
@@queeneva3 No, if two person have opposite gender of same animal as their patronus doesn't mean that they are meant to be together. Lily Evans loved James and did marry him. Severus Snape loved Lily Potter more than himself, I think, he was nearly devoted to her, so his patronus changed into a doe.
@@9yearoldepicgamersoldier129 he is a dick to Harry? He has been helping Harry through out the years! He tried to help Harry to be stronger. Jk Rowling said that when Snape saw Harry for the first time, he was thinking "he should've been mine"
and pretty much every single scene that man has been in tbh, but this scene alone proves why his performance is the best of these movies... (although Gary Oldman was pretty awesome too)
Daniel M I can explain a few of these, the scene is dumbledore and snape talking about how Harry has a horcruz (can’t remember how to spell it ) inside his scar so he must die too . The doe is Lilly potter just like Harry’s patronus was a stag like his father . As for the last question I’m unsure too .
@@smellyfeet11 Lily's patronus is a doe, and Snape's patronus also was a doe because he truly lived Lily so much. And it hasn't changed. So when Dumbledore asks, "After all this time?" He means "you still love Lily, after all this time?" At the making of that memory, it had been a couple of years since Lily had died and many more since she and James had married. But Snape never let go. And that is why Dumbledore is surprised, at love's potential and at the best side of Snape, the unwavering love and selflessness. And Snape loved her to his last breath, answering "Always."
As a non-Harry Potter Fan that stumbled on this clip from searching Star Trek clips. Does he "always" say "always?" Is it something he says or what? Very emotional scene thou, I only watched til Goblit.
@@toolizawesome no but there is a very famous scene at the end of the movies/books where dumbledore asks ''after all this time? '' and Snape answers ''always''... You can look up for this scene it's very important for Snapes story line and it's so well acted!
Man this gets me all the time. Snape was never a bad person, he was just broken. Alan Rickman potrayed his character beautifully. May his soul Rest in Peace.
What is a bad person? A good person? Snape should teach you, among many things, that "the line between good and evil is drawn down the center of every human heart". -aleksandyr solhenitzyn
lol what how was he not a bad person do you know what a death eater is????? he was a fully evil death eater before voldy killed lilly as he was completely ok letting voldy kill james and harry
For those people who always had problems with Snape because he was a bully to the students, had been a death eater and is viewed by some as more obsessed with Lily than in love with her, I think that the books are sprinkled with bits of information that give lots of clues into his character and understanding of some of the bad decisions he made. It is pretty apparent that Snape’s family life was very unhappy. His muggle father appeared to be abusive from the glimpses we get. And other muggle children in his community, like Petunia, treated him badly because his poverty resulted in his odd dress and appearance. When you combine this with the fact that he was an extremely smart, bookish boy who appeared to also be a loner, you can see why he would be a prime target for recruitment by a group like the Death Eaters. There are plenty of real life parallels to such things, taking away the magical element of course. At one point in the books Harry referred to himself, Snape and Voldemort as the Lost Boys who found a home at Hogwarts. When Dumbledore brought Snape onto the teaching staff at Hogwarts Snape was still very young. In fact, he was only a couple of years out of being a Hogwarts student himself. And we know that Snape had been bullied as a student at Hogwarts. Now he was in a position of authority. And it is highly unlikely that he had experienced much social development of his own in the meantime. For all these reasons, I think it is easy to see why Snape became a bully as a teacher. You would hope that people who are bullied would avoid doing the same thing to other people. But unfortunately, we know that people who are bullied often become the next set of bullies. This is not trying to excuse Snape’s behavior toward the students he was teaching. But it is a way to understand why he would behave this way. As far as whether Snape’s feelings for Lily fall into the category of love or obsession, I don’t think it really makes a big difference in the end. Either way he risked life and limb, and put himself into danger, over and over in order to fulfill the vow he made to Dumbledore to protect Lily’s son. Snape was in the end a very flawed man who was also a hero and one of the best literary characters I have ever had the pleasure to encounter in a story. He was my favorite character in the entire series from the moment we heard that wonderful monologue in Harry’s first potions class. And to Harry he was the bravest man he ever knew.
@@blackeyedlily @blackeyedlily Brilliantly said and what you have written is often overlooked. Snape is the most misunderstood man in the entire HP series yet harbors nothing but love and protectivity for the students, especially Harry. He led a rough life but eventually immortalized himself through his sacrifice. Snape is easily my favorite character!
Chamber of Secrets is the only one I didn’t see in theaters…I literally could not wait. It was amazing to see on the big screen. I was ~9 when the first movie was released and 17/18 when the last came out, it was like I grew up with the characters 🥺
@@nvignesh Vader being Lukes father was more shocking and a bigger twist. But this was more emotional and meaningful. This scene reminded me more of when Obi-wan and anakin fought. Or when Vader turned on Sidious in the throne room. I think Snape deep down felt hurt that he was never able to care for harry when he was a child. And kept harry emotionally distant not only to protect harry but to protect his own emotional well-being.
@@johnnymendez3814 that might be a reason but snape could have left harry as he was also the son of his not so good friend james potter.... but he chose to protect , even after lily was long gone
Dumbledore had far beyond goals than just protecting Harry, like he sacrificed his sister for the good of the world Harry was just a special card of the game which Dumbledore wouldn't lose
I wouldn't say on the exact level since the I am your father literally broke how ppl saw vader and was THE plot twist of the century...but close enough
Get Real That only happened in the movies tho, not in the books. Similar thing with this scene when Dumbledore says ‘don’t tell me you’ve grown to care for the boy’, Snape was supposed to say ‘not the boy’ and then show his Patronus to show that it was for Lily, not Harry
@@k-ster7870 he killed him but that was a favor to him causr he was dying because of touchinh the cursed ring of Gaunt. But I still say he was a git but no doubt he had a very important role in Harry's victory and he was a very brave man. An annoying one though 😁
The fact that Snape was always protecting Harry is heartwarming and heartbreaking. Seeing Snape holding Lily was heartbreaking and seeing his raw emotions. Snape made the ultimate sacrifice by being a double agent.
@@ligma5042 if you don't want an argument then why are you going through responding to any comment praising snape 🤣 and i literally don't care bro i'm clearly not trying to argue
Red Leader he says ‘lily’ who was snapes true love, that’s why his patronas had matched that of Lilly’s. Of course she was Harry’s mum, and that’s the reason he has looked after harry for all these years, because he felt guilty. He thought if he could protect the boy, he would be squaring his debt with James, when he saved snapes life when they were kids.
When Snape says always, it always leaves me in tears because that just shows how much love Snape had for Lily. It’s probably one of the most wonderful scenes ever when we get to find out what type of person Snape truly is
To add to this, the reason Snape is my favourite person in Harry Potter is because of how intelligent he is. Throughout the entire series, he is the one man who was on both the dark and light side, while hiding his true commitment to the light the entire time. It was Snape who gained the trust of one of the most evil & powerful wizards of all time, and even then Dumbledore still dies even with Snape's help, the fact that Snape had to maintain through 19 years this level of composure makes him soooo badass to me. Not to mention he looks like Owen Wilson and Keanu Reeves combined 😂
It’s probably the worst chapter. Great finale, don’t get me wrong, I loved it. The Severus twist is fantastic. But everything that comes before the battle of hogwarts is like mission impossible achieved by three clueless teenagers. The writer just pushed too much on the accelerator
I grew up watching the movies at the cinema, but as a child I never understood how good the plot and the depth of the characters are. Today, after rewatching it all over again, I'm an absolute fan, I give this franchise a standing ovation as one of the most genius masterpieces ever made! My biggest wish is that they produce more things from the Harry Potter universe in the format that we currently consume. I know they made the Grindelwald movies but I believe there are much more interesting things to explore in this world. A well-produced series on some online subscription service about Snape's youth, Lilly Potter, is my dream.
Midly disagree. It has beautiful characters but if you think about it too hard alot of the plot falls apart. But then again its a series meant for the youth so me and alot of people didnt care about that stuff when reading it for the first time. But thats perfectly fine. Its a fantasy world and is intended to make you forget.
I think the only movies that are on par with the Harry Potter movies especially around that time is The Lord of the Rings. They both have a fantastic plot, a deep and rich backstory, fantastic and dynamic characters with beautiful acting and set design.
The hardest part about this scene is that we learn what Snape really means when he says Harry has his mother’s eyes. It’s not how they look, it’s how they see others. Harry and his mother both saw the good in people and would never hurt a fly intentionally, they’re both incredibly kind people and see others as if there is always good inside of them, they don’t judge, they don’t hate, they’re genuine loving eyes that want the best for those around them. It’s a heartbreaking moment to see, especially Snape and Lily as kids and how tragic that story was…
Well not entirely true for Harry you know, i mean he casted a Cruciatus curse on Amycus Carrow (Against a death eater of course but he still count as a "fly") and you really need to have the intention for that to work ...
@@androideditors James was a dumb teen when he did it. Snape was a grownass man. There is a difference. Snape chose to bully Neville Hermione and other students just for fun. Knowing damn well how it feels to be bullied. It makes it even worse
same.. i loved him the moment i found out he didn’t jinx harry’s broom, he was “muttering his little counter-curse” as quirrell so gracefully put it, and all my friends judged me until we all watched the last one together and i dont think i have ever seen them apologize for anything so quickly..
I was born too young to understand that part. The last movies were too dark for my young brain back then. But when i’ve saw them later, this is the most memorable scenes i’ve ever seen. Such a good written character.
i relate to you deeply on this, ever since i was a kid i still thought snape was the bad guy and good thing he died, watched in as an adult teen now that i realise how beautiful snape truly is and bawled my eyes out TT.
Same. Now that I’ve seen all the films with a real pair of eyes, and a solid set of emotions, I can gladly admit I’ve seen the “EXPECTO PATRONUM” scene about 30 times, because of its sheer beauty. But this scene was the biggest, most important twist of them all. I’m glad this scene was never spoiled for me.
Or even before that when dying Snape tells him, he has his mother's eyes.. I think this is the real moment he understands that Snape never was an enemy. The look on Harrys face always hits me hard, well acted!
who gives a shit how harry felt? imagine being a bullied introvert with the dickhead who bullies you taking your only true love and then you even have to risk your life to protect their arrogant kid who hates you.
@@knuckle-sandwichmma681 to be fair, Harry only hated Snape because Snape hated him first and was rly mean to him for what he thought was no reason. If Snape treated Harry better especially initially, Harry wouldn't have hated him
@@racheldarmawangsa9589 but then it's natural to have a little hate for our ex-lovers child! But then we'd also want to protect knowing they're parents has died
This whole scene broke me so hard I felt so bad for snape he had almost everything taken away from him he did care about Harry he was just reminded of his father which triggered him
Bruiser Bunny he didn’t care about Harry! In this scene he was supposed to say (canonically) ‘for him?’, as in, 'not him' after Dumbledore said ‘don’t tell me you’ve grown to care for the boy’ and then show his patronus to show who he cared for: Lily. But not Harry. He was too bitter about James to care for Harry.
Bruh hella no, this showed that Snape is just a overbearing man child. Yes your first love/ connection went to someone else. Guess what? EVERYONE goes through heartbreak. It take strength to push forward and live your life. Being a dick to the child of the woman who broke your heart is nothing but abusive. And Harry also losing his mom should of made it that Snape is nicer to Harry. They both lost the woman they loved. Theres plenty of threads and videos from women calling out Snape behavior.
I was 12 years old when i watched deathly hollows part 2 in cinema, my childish brain never understood this scene due to hatred that built up since the first movie until this scene. I rewatched all movies at 17 and realised that snape was the good guy. I am now 21 and since the 2nd completion of series whenever i came across this scene, i cry
I hope you have read the books too. This scene, Snape story ark and so much more doesn’t even compare in the movie adaptations (although I enjoy the movies too)
@AyushGurung What a lot of people tend to ignore about the love potions is that, essentially, they're roofies. They override the drinker's judgement, making them consent to a relationship, however brief it is, that they probably wouldn't want under their own volition. Snape likely knew that Voldemort, himself, was conceived via a love potion, as well as the problems that this caused. He couldn't make himself do that to Lily, however much he might've been tempted. You're right about that decision, showing his true character. (10/24/2021)
@@Ryujinn999 I definitely recommend reading the books. there are weak spots along the series, for me it was in book two and book four where I stopped reading for a while, but overall the series is fantastic in my opinion and worth reading until the end. Also watching the movies first might diminish your reading experience so although the movies range from decent to very good I would finish the books before considering watching the movies.
I have never seen a Harry Potter movie in the cinema. But hearing the godly voice of Dumbledore and Severus is incredible. Their voices are so deep and powerful, also the acting and the story coming together in this particular scene is phenomenal.
Tell me I'm wrong - The character development of Snape is the best, not only in HP, but in any franchise. The fact that we, within one scene, went from hating the shit out of him, to love him almost more than Harry Potter... RIP Alan Rickman, you will never be forgotten.
@@jcdenton6577 projecting much? Harry ends up with Ginny, Ron with Hermione. Neville also finds a woman. Mr. Weasley, Lupin and Hagrid all find love. They’re all bad guys then? Snape isn’t the only “good guy”. He made poor life decisions unfortunately when he joined the Death Eaters which drove him away from Lily. He’s incredibly brave after that and he regrets not being able to save her, yes. But that doesn’t prove that good guys never win lol.
@@jcdenton6577 You're right, it's not based on true events, it's actually based on a book series where Snape is infinitely more cruel and unpleasant than he's ever depicted in the films. Snape was a complex character, he was brave and he was clever, but he was by no means a "good guy". Snape was perfectly happy to serve the dark side until Lily, a childhood crush, was in danger. He then proceeded to terrorise her son, as well as the rest of the non-Slytherin students for years and years. Snape lavished at the idea of Sirius receiving the dementor's kiss. And even during this memeory sequence in the books, he scavenges through Sirius (now Harry's) house to find a letter and photo from Lily, including a photo of Lily, James, and Harry, and he tears off the part with Lily and the end of the letter where she states her love, and leaves the house in a mess. Snape is a creep; he was _obsessed_ with Lily. I feel sorry for anyone who thinks Snapes love, while genuine, is in anyway healthy.
The fact that snape has a patronus is proof of the goodness in his heart. Remember death eaters are allies with dementors so they do not need patronuses
he spied on the most dangerous wizard of all time who was also one of the best legilimens ( wizard who can read people's mind) for dumboldore. snape doesn't need a patronus to prove his goodness in his heart....
i loved him the moment i found out he didn’t jinx harry’s broom, he was “muttering his little counter-curse” as quirrell so gracefully put it, and all my friends judged me until we all watched the last one together and i dont think i have ever seen them apologize for anything so quickly..
@@alexuswerntz99 Same. He was my favorite character long before the later books. I got into many an argument (all in good fun of course) after he killed Albus in book 6. We were still waiting for 7 to come out and I took my stand for Snape. I KNEW he was good. Of course, everyone else told me I was crazy, he is the most evil, we hate him, etc. There are little Easter eggs like the one you mentioned sprinkled throughout. Easy to miss. I know it's a fictional story, but it's one of the things I'm most proud of. It was fantastic when book 7 was finally released.
@@alexandraempie3842Dude take my heart and keep it safe w/ you. Coz you are the first person who liked Snape's Character after reading "The books", coz I thought I was the only one in who thought so!!!❤️🩹
I have no shame to admit that I cried for Snape. I hated him for so many years but this, just tore open my heart. Rickman was a legend. RIP Edit : Omg, thanks a lot you guys for the likes.
Couldn’t agree more. Little me thought he was part of “the AXIS of evil” lol. What amazes me is how well this image was maintained. From the troll attack, to the cursing of his broom, to the unbreakable vow, to the murder of dumbledore, there was never a moment where one would stop and think “wait, is there a higher motivation for all this?” Then you see this moment. And everything you’ve ever known about the character is wrong, and the missing piece is finally filled in.
One of the most heartbreaking things i read a while ago that i never thought of was, snape died not knowing harry got to live. I havent stopped crying since reading it
@@terabaap1775 I think james knew that they would probably end up dead because he failed to protect them from Voldemort himself and he was only in the next room
@@anitabonghit7606 yeah, that could've happened. But I think James must've thought that both Harry and Lily survived because he'd have thought that Lily would apparate along with Harry and would've saved both their lives.
Kero kerem This may come as an even bigger shock, but I was (and still am) such a big fan of Harry Potter and have all the books and read each multiple times, but I looked towards this movie even more than I did for the Avengers. Endgame’s the second movie I ever cried at in a movie theater, too. That and Toy Story 3. I would’ve added this movie, but didn’t see it in a movie theater which I really regret.
“No, I am your father!”-Darth Vader “Ride now! RIDE TO RUIN AND WORLDS ENDS DAY! DEATH!” -Theoden “Pirates life”-Jack Sparrow “ *Always* ” - Severus Snape Four great sagas and each has a memorable quote.
Dumbledore : " Lily... After all this time " Snape : " ALWAYS"😪 Snape did not see Harry as the son of a man he hated the most instead he went on seeing Harry as the son of the woman he loved ❤❤
Muy cierto, es muy cierto lo que dices y es increíble eso, cuanto la llegó a amar que incluso aún despues de su muerte la siguió amando y protegió lo mas importante para ella, Harry Potter
If Harry hadn't been there to collect Snape's tears, and if Snape never shared the tears Harry wouldn't have known the truth about Snape or even how to beat Voldemort...that's crazy
That's a haunting thought and there are no other witnesses to those facts either. All the marauders dead, dumbledore dead. Although perhaps the portrait of Phineas Nigellas Black in Dumbledores study or maybe Nearly Headless Nick ?
Its why when Snape was dying with Harry he was practically begging in desperation because he knew this was his last chance. Which is even more heartbreaking.
@@Blade9e7 In the books before Snape dies, Rowling mentions that in shrieking shack, Snape stared at the snake inside protective bubble while talking to Voldemort while voldemort was talking about the elder wand's inability to perform for him to the maximum. But snape repeatedly asked Voldemort to let him go find Harry and bring Harry to him. Snape remembered Dumbledore advicing him to tell Harry that Harry had to die because of being a horcrux himself , when and only when there comes a time when Voldemort fears for nagini. Snape wanted to go find Harry and tell him so. Then Voldemort mentioned elder wand and Snape killing Dumbledore and Snape understood what Voldemort was planning to do to master elder wand. Then only Snape knew that Voldemort intended to kill him , that he won't be able to find Harry and that Dumbledore was the previous master of elder wand and Dumbledore had other plans about elder wand's ownership when he asked Snape to kill him. Dumbledore didn't thought Voldemort would find elder wand . He simply wanted the owner to die so as to prevent the succession of mastering the wand. Snape realised that Dumbledore hid this piece of information from him before he was asked to make the promise about murdering Dumbledore. Snape looked away from nagini only when he realised this. He was following Dumbledore's instructions to the dot . Poor Severus.
@@Blade9e7 In the end Snape did fear he might never get a chance to tell Harry about Dumbledore's revalation of 'harry being a horcrux and should die ' . Remember, a wizard should willingly give his memories . He should have chosen only to give his memories of conversations with Dumbledore. But he chose to give all of his memories connecting him, lilly , the Marauders , his childhood before Hogwarts and Dumbledore . In the end he wanted Harry to realise that he have ALWAYS cared for harry and served Dumbledore for the sole purpose . And because no one can vouch for his because Dumbledore only knew this secret and he is dead.
@@thenerdfather5309 Phineas nigellus yes perhaps, being hung in Dumbledore's study. But not nearly headless Nick. He was a ghost , yes. But he didn't have a portrait of him in the headmaster's room. He would know the history, that's all.
No! Snape is my favourite character. And an origin story will ruin everything the books and movies have built. AND THE MOST IMPORTANT REASON: Severus Snape = Alan Rickman
I know that most people think that this is Snape’s ”the moment” when we learn all of his motivations and etc. but I always saw this as “Dumbledore moment”. I mean Snape’s kinda right, Dumbledore kept Harry alive only so that he could die at the right moment (and most likely he didn’t even know that Harry could come back from the dead). And when Snape shocked (pretty appropriate reaction if you ask me) accuses Dumbledore of raising Harry like a pig to slaughter Dumbledore doesn’t show remorse. No, he looks at Snape and ironically asks ”Have you grown to care for the boy?”... For me that was the moment when we saw in Harry Potter the younger, manipulative side of Dumbledore that fascinates me so much. ‘Cause he was really ready to send Harry to death “FOR THE GREATER GOOD”
I don't think Dumbledore planned for him to die. I'm not sure if one realizes it, but Dumbledore set in motion for Harry Potter to become master of death. Harry had the stone sent to him by AD, he already had the cloak and became the master to the elder wand. Dumbledore didn't want Harry to die. He only wanted him to face death - to make him the master of death.
I'm pretty sure Dumbledore knew - or at least suspected - that Harry would not stay dead. He had a look of triumph when Harry said Voldemort used his blood to return.
I know he is manipulative. But to blame him for doing literally the only thing that would stop Voldemort is a bit hypocritical. Literally nothing else could have been done. If he did not do exactly this, Voldemort would have remained immortal. And literally billions would have been enslaved or slaughtered. Yes he is manipulative. But he needed to make that decision. And he could not tell a soul of it. Doom an innocent boy to death, and groom him into a self sacrificing reckless hero. So that he could do what must be done. So that he would. Dumbledore is not an evil person. He is manipulative and he likes power. He was the most powerful wizard alive, arguably. And for all that power and knowledge, the only thing he could do. Is destroy the life of another young person. Imagine that situation. Almost revered as a god. Powerless to do anything. It's easy to judge when you don't have to make the hard decisions.
I remember me watching this in a full cinema and right after this scene, the film turns completely silent and so did the audience. It felt like everybody was is shock, even forgetting to breath. Not a single noise. Nothing. That was one of the most striking moments I've ever experienced in a cinema.
I was a kid I remember I didn't wanna get spoiler before seeing the movie but then I still read it cuz I couldn't help it and then I found out he was good lol
Abigail Tay I only started properly watching the movies this year when they came on ITV as they do every September, and I could never find myself hating him, no matter what he did or what he had appeared to have done (cough cough philosophers stone). been my favourite character from the very beginning
There were moments where you did hate him but then moments where you empathized with him, it was never easy for Snape to do all this stuff for Dumbledore yet he chose to do it anyway and my guess is he did it mainly for Lily because he loved her that much
Never hated him, I always thought he was severe but rightful, I had many teachers like him.. and every time they will be the ones will teach you the most in unique way
When he said “always” and the audience started clapping I burst into tears. What a wonderful man Alan was, he played Snape absolutely on point. When I was younger, I asked my dad, “daddy, is the actor in real life mean just like Snape?” My dad went on to explain acting to me. And from then on, I loved Alan. I was heartbroken to hear about his death. I look up to him so much still and I know he will always be remembered. Always. 😭🤍 he deserved more time here. RIP the one and only Alan Rickman. I am better because of you.
Dumbledore believed that love is the greatest power of all. When he realised that Snape's love for Lilly exists after all this time, understood that he was totally right. Simultaneously he was so surprised because he understood that everything can change over the years, but love stays untouched, unconditional, unconventional and with the same power from the beginning till the end.
Crushing my heart.... especially since Snape really had a pure heart at the end. I'm certain he knew the wand was faithful to Draco and not him. But prefered sacrificing his life not to endanger Draco's. A true hero, who never needed recognition to be loyal and brave🙏
Snape’s a true Hogwarts student and we didn’t realize it until it was too late. He’ll be sorely missed throughout the years of the wizarding world. He’s a Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw and Slytherin all in one.
He couldn't reveal it was Draco, since that would be putting him in danger. He made the unbreakable vow to protect him. Therefore Snape would've died regardless.
He may not have necessarily known. The legend behind the elder wand seemed to indicate that the allegiance changed with the murder of the previous master. Voldemort himself believed it. Snape was indeed very clever and a supremely good occlumens, but we do not know how versed he was in wandlore.
Don't forget to check out my other videos of other audience reactions from this Harry Potter marathon event on my channel
I was wondering where these videos were shot cuz these type of reactions are only from my India. They clap whistle like no one can...
Do you have more?
@@Aditya1998pandey yes on my channel, enjoy 😊
@@Fadooola7 I've watched all the 17 videos.. Actually I was asking for more 😅
@@Aditya1998pandey ah okay my bad, unfortunately no :/
RUclips: “Are you still going to cry on this scene after all this time?”
Me: “Always.”
Garry Tarens LMFAOOOOO
In 2020 too......
Yes
😭
I still dont understand he said after all this time what did he mean?
The reason why the last words of severus snape was “look at me” because the last thing he wanted to see was lily’s eyes.
Yep 🥺😭😭😭
Talking bout Lily's eyes, when the memories show we can see that young Lily had brown eyes, but Harry had bloody blue eyes all the damn saga. I just don't get it
But that last words still hit me
@@damaristaydevelezgomez4776 in the books Lily had green eyes. They initially had Daniel Radcliffe wear contact lenses that changed his eye color, but he couldn’t tolerate the contact lenses because they’d irritate his eyes. In the films they tried resolving this by just saying “you have your mother’s eyes” without mentioning color. For young Lily having brown eyes, I guess they thought the flashbacks were so brief it wouldn’t be too noticeable but I’m not certain.
"Kiss me potter, I wanna know if you have your mother's lips too"
Im not even sorry 😂
after he said "always" even your phone started crying
Lmao 😂
Yes my tear drops fell onto it and now it's sliding down
As he said always my windows started clapping.
"Always"- Severus Snape
Nope, just battery juice
Burnt my fucking hands
Snape being able to produce a perfect patronus in a miserable life, is a conversation worthy.
You forget Lilly.
@@guillermoa.nerygomez8782 Lily died when he was 21... after that he had nothing or no one to make him happy. So yeah he was miserable.
O
@@LaurianeBL What happy memory did Harry have?
@@guillermoa.nerygomez8782 He knew love, and friendship... and he felt sorry for someone 🤔
“I don’t play villains, I play very interesting people.” -Alan Rickman. 🙏🏼🐐
Rip in piece 😭
@@eradinthadeal2609 He did..
What does the goat stand for
@@aidenlewis6057 Greatest Of All Time
@Faiz Fuad I know but I mean like why a goat emoji and not just saying GOAT
This one scene changed one of the most hated characters in HP into one of the most loved
Movie snape I assume has always been one of the most favored characters in HP, especially in this scene. He felt more like a strict teacher who emphasizes with people and shows a lack of severe hatred for harry, unlike book snape. He also doesn't bully students 24/7.
I never hated Snape, I was mad when I thought he back stabbed Dumbledor.
I love Harry Potter
Husna Harghandiwal Harry Potter is the inspiration of my life as a wizard fan I love Harry James Potter the best wizard ever
Rachel Arreola me to
This was the moment when the Whole World cried for the Half Blood Prince.
Rajarshi Sarkar this make me cry
The Whole World is true. I agree with that. If you don't cry when Snape put Patronus and say Always, You heartless.
i knoww right😭😭😭😭
I cried for Harry and Lily, not Snape.
I mean, the scene of Lily when she died to save Harry, and the knowledge that now Harry has to die too... Snape was just there listening to the news lol.
@@olgac.9636 Yes, Lily was a hero
The way Alan almost whispers _Expecto Patronum_ is incredible. Fantastic actor, RIP
@@MTFBWY923 I mean... they do explain it quite clearly. It's not like is some sort of obscure theory or something. It is indeed a fact.
The fact you need a powerfully happy memory to conjure a patronus too and he was prob thinking of her - I'll just be over here sobbing
@@MTFBWY923 He loved her so much that his own Patronum morphed into hers.
@@MTFBWY923 youre not that fast are you
@@Clonesoldier501 You are a bully. I'd pick dumb over a bully everytime.
Snape is that strict teacher that you hate in high School but at the end he is the only one you would call back many years after graduation
True
So trueee
He's the wizard Mr. Feeney
Trevor Laub yesss
I can relate...
Snape being a good guy was the biggest cinematic plot twist since Vader told Luke he was his father. Never saw it coming..
well he did protect harry in other instances... but i get what you mean
I actually thought there was always something fishy about him killing Dumbledore. The way he had been built as a character, being very mysterious, having a name that seems evil from the start, and being someone that all the signs will say to hate, yet sprinkled with acts of kindness THAG leave us confused, such as the numerous times he saved Harry. Simply making him a bad guy would’ve wasted the potential of the character that ended up being born, and I had faith Rowling wouldn’t let that happen. Though I must admit, I never could have imagined such a drastic turn around, and one that involved his entire life. Easily my favorite character.
@@peterd1623 yeah i deeply agree with you. In the books he sometimes was honestly very annoying but still i always had complete faith in Dumbledore so when he killed Dumbledore it was very fishy that how he could've possibly dicieve some one like him. I admire Rowlling for such a creativity.
Tbh i saw it coming since the first movie and i was 8 at the time
Khalid Almofawaz damn khalid you must be so intelligent to have realised that at the tender age of 8
This movie is like a movie, which you don't want to be ended.
exactly how I feel
Ten point for the darkvwolff
Fantastic beasts now!!! I hope they don’t ruin it
The only thing I hate about a Harry Potter book is the fact that it ends. Not the ending, nor necessarily that it ended. I get so lost in the book that at the end I miss it.
Yes True
You can study acting for 100 years and not be able to say “always” as alan said it amazing
Nobody could have done it better... nobody! Dear sweet Alan was perfect as Snape. RIP sweet Severus and Alan 😥😢💔❣️🙏😇
"You know noothin Jon Now."
I'm pretty sure I won't be able to say 'Always' after 100 years
Saw this somewhere today:
Harry's first words about Snape: "Who's that man..?"
Harry's last words about Snape:"..the bravest man I ever knew."
I love what you said. 1000 percent true. Harry’s first words about snaps. Then his last words. He had the utmost respect for Severus snape. Sir Alan Rickman, R.I.P you will be missed Always……. 🙏
@@Gusto-dk3rv The fact that Rickman sir is no more exacerbates the scene of Prof. Snape's death even more🥺. Snape will always be one of the most respected fictional characters ever created❤. And thank you, I love talking to fellow Potterheads.💐
Thank you for the response. It is great to talk with a true fan.
Feels like Harry answered his own question & finally understands.
@@P.Whitestrake yes🙃 I love just how beautifully this series was penned down🌻
Rickman once said that J.K. only told him how the true story was for Snape in the first film, so he knew how he was going to play his role for the rest of the series. What a legend!
Damn that's crazy
Nope,he was only told that theres is more to Snape than he seems. So acted on it, evwn when he killed Dumbledore, i refused to believe that he is a bad guy.
While we don't know for sure wgat she said to him, I am pretty sure it's along the line of "Snape was in love with Lilly, and hates on Harry for this reason".
Didnt he knew it already from the book??
@@shashwatsinha5291 She told him before she wrote the last books, if I remember correctly, when they first finished the initial casting and she knew Alan Rickman was gonna be Severus Snape for sure, though I could be wrong.
Meanwhile me when watching the first harry potter: mr snape must be the voldemort
LMAO YES OMG AHHAHAHAAHAHA
LMAOOO HAHAHAHA EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT HAHAHA
LMAOOOOOOO
I’m the only one in my family that read the books before watching the movie and when we were watching the movie my parents and sister were like “he’s the bad guy” and in like “if you say so...”
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
He was brave like a Gryffindor
He was loyal as a Hufflepuff
He was as cunning as a Slytherin
He was as clever as a Ravenclaw
Rest in peace Severus Snape
Rest in peace Alan Rickman
He should be in a better place 🙏
Well said. No one can play Severus Snape quite like Alan Rickman.
@@tararocksong5085
He was perfect for this role. But then if u look up his other roles, you'll see that he is actually a monotonous actor. I'm glad i didnt watch alot. I quickly turned it off so that my brain doesnt lose the magic.
@@RonLarhz, I did watch his performance in Alice in Wonderland (new version) as the Absolute the Caterpillar and was really impressed with his moods.
The truth the hat was in doubt because it was suitable for the 4 houses but his decision to go to the house of the snake is because his mother was from that house his mother the first person I admire
why i cried
50% - snape died
50% - tHe dAmN mUsiC
True
True
The track is 'Dumbledore's farewell'... Thank me later
@@austinred458 no im going to thank you now
110% Because Alan Rickman is gone😖😭🖤💔
No other actor could have replaced Alan Rickman as Snape. What a phenomenal performance.
Im so glad jkr shared that one tidbit she did with alan rickman! That let him see a clear path for snape and he adjusted what the script said by saying thats not what snape would do or say here. He was true to snapes real character the whole way through every movie. RIP good Sir!
Yeah absolutely 💯 phenomenal 👏
Yep
If they were to remake it then only one actor would be even remotely a possible choice: Adam Driver. But even he couldn’t live up to Alan Rickman imo
I think Jeremy Irons could've done it if there was no Alan Rickman but yeah it's true he was perfect for the role.
best line of the whole series full stop.
“After all this time?”
“Always”
And having it being followed by a shot of Snape holding Lily's body in his arms, crying. Beautiful work. It's probably the most emotional shot in the whole franchise.
"Hardly any of you remember that my favorite color was lilac."
@@djiboutinationalanthem5252 It might have been funny, if he hadn't turned out to be a fraud.
@@djiboutinationalanthem5252 that’s not in the british version of the film
i can’t deal with the goosebumps...
That "Always" gives me goosebumps and teary eyes everytime I watch it....😭😭😭
Yessss😭😭😭
It is essential...essential.......essential....................
and his shaky voice when he killed dumbledoor, and when he made the vow with narcissist. it was so subtle alan's acting that once we heard it we feel the pain in him for having to kill the man he respected most.
Time stamp?
And people there ruining the moment. They all should be in sadly silent, dammit. Not clappin their hands!
The moment when you realise Snape hated the James he saw in Harry but Loved the lily in him at the same time
i’m just happy hes not a girl bcuz then snape would do some littlefinger shit
Thats why he said to Harry "Look at me" when he was dying because he wanted to see Lilly's eyes.
A love-hate relationship?
@@janajost907 ... what's a littlefinger shit? and why am i scared of what that entails
@@lady_raineidv9297 in game of thrones little finger was in love with ned stark’s wife and then little finger goes on to attempt to marry the daughter of the 2 because the daughter reminded him of the wife
Rickman should have gotten a god damn award for this scene
fuck yes
Yes, he should have received an Academy Award for this truly, unbelievable character that he played so beautifully! RIP Alan Rickman
And second best one is "equally guilty" scene.
@@AnonymouShadow0420 the academy is super corrupt and was largely controlled by Weinstein for a long time
I know it’s fricken amazing
This scene was truly heartbreaking. Snape was always there, waiting. He never stopped loving Lily and he unconsciously loved Harry as well.
Well, he didn't love Harry, but he cared for him.
Ria Gavieta
Book snape:do not love harry
Movie snape:love Harry
I think the movie is greater about Snape
In book he is all gray but in movie he is white.
No actually Snape not loved harry but protected just because of lily
He could see Lily through Harry's eyes. "You have your Mother's eyes"
@@oldb12 he never said that in book. Last word Snape said to harry is "look at me".
He was rejected by his owns, hated by his owns, took care of their sons, just because he loved her. What a masterpiece of a story.
And Rowling had it planned from the very start. Rickman said in an interview that Rowling pulled him aside while filming the first movie and told him Snape's entire story.
I heard Alan was aware of the details but he approached Rowling for insight
This is probably the best scene in all Harry Potter. It’s a work of art.
Man up.
@@KnightoftheLord1 Cringe
Its my fav so scene sooooo i agree
So truee
Definitely my fav 🥲
"You've been raising him like a pig for slaughter"😭
That make me think of bacon and now Im hungry
that is off topic man
JackWilly how?
In this moment I rlly didn‘t know what to think of Dumbledore
Jennifer Wolf fr i thought harry would be mad but he wasn’t at all
I see that the RUclips algorithm reunites us again
i miss rickman
Always.
xOGam1ng Dude your profile picture 😂👌🏻
After all this time?
*Always*
#2019Nov
“You’ve been raising him like a pig for slaughter” I love that Snape immediately saw that Dumbledore had just been using Harry and now was asking him to be sacrificed!
Snape's patronus was a doe, so was Lily's. She was the most happiest memory he ever had 😭
Not really. Your patronus changes into the patronus of your true love. Lily's was a dove, the mate to a stag for James. They were meant to be together. But Snape's became a dove because Lily was his true love, that's how much he loved her. We also saw that happening in HPU with Tonks and Lupin
@@queeneva3 doe*
That's not exactly how it works but yeah you got the spirit
@@queeneva3 No, if two person have opposite gender of same animal as their patronus doesn't mean that they are meant to be together.
Lily Evans loved James and did marry him.
Severus Snape loved Lily Potter more than himself, I think, he was nearly devoted to her, so his patronus changed into a doe.
@@queeneva3 You are wrong here too Hermione's and Ron's patronus weren't same
Dumbledore: After all this time?
Snape: Always...
Audience: *appluding*
Respect for Alan Rickman right there, man.... that hit me in the heart....
But still it doesnt remove the fact that ge was a dick to harry. Good things doesnt remove the bad things.
@@9yearoldepicgamersoldier129 so was Harry's father to Snape..
@@9yearoldepicgamersoldier129 he is a dick to Harry? He has been helping Harry through out the years! He tried to help Harry to be stronger. Jk Rowling said that when Snape saw Harry for the first time, he was thinking "he should've been mine"
snape was the closest thing harry had to a father. and snape was rude to harry because he was pissed off that harry chose gryffindor.
@@koma7778 honesty, I don't think that the fact that Harry was sorted into Gryffindor has anything to do with it.
Snape: Always.
Audience: _HE SAID THE THING_
Now this... This made me laugh. Thank you 😂
Dumbledore:after all this time
Snape:Always has been
Snape:*calmly puts gun in dumbledore's head
Snape:*gently pulls the trigger
But that applause was everything tho
Ya
I was literally CRYING when I saw Snape saying Always😭😭😭😢
No matter how many times I see this scene, I just breakdown in tears
Always
Occlumency doesn't work here, even if you try as hard as you can.
Same here🥺
1:58 always 😢
That face he makes before casting the patronus and after it flees... work of a true artist
and pretty much every single scene that man has been in tbh, but this scene alone proves why his performance is the best of these movies... (although Gary Oldman was pretty awesome too)
His expression..his eyes..the love for Lily. I am very glad Alan Rickman portray Snape.
Rest in peace the great Alan Rickman.
Mind explaining this scene? What is happening here? With the patronus fleeing and dumbledore asking "after all this time?". I forgot
Daniel M I can explain a few of these, the scene is dumbledore and snape talking about how Harry has a horcruz (can’t remember how to spell it ) inside his scar so he must die too . The doe is Lilly potter just like Harry’s patronus was a stag like his father . As for the last question I’m unsure too .
@@smellyfeet11 Lily's patronus is a doe, and Snape's patronus also was a doe because he truly lived Lily so much. And it hasn't changed. So when Dumbledore asks, "After all this time?" He means "you still love Lily, after all this time?" At the making of that memory, it had been a couple of years since Lily had died and many more since she and James had married. But Snape never let go. And that is why Dumbledore is surprised, at love's potential and at the best side of Snape, the unwavering love and selflessness. And Snape loved her to his last breath, answering "Always."
“Stay close to me.” “Always.”
“Are you with me?” “Always.”
“After all this time?” “Always.”
Ben Ester lily.. severus ♥♥
Hotel? Trivago...
As a non-Harry Potter Fan that stumbled on this clip from searching Star Trek clips. Does he "always" say "always?" Is it something he says or what? Very emotional scene thou, I only watched til Goblit.
@@toolizawesome no but there is a very famous scene at the end of the movies/books where dumbledore asks ''after all this time? '' and Snape answers ''always''... You can look up for this scene it's very important for Snapes story line and it's so well acted!
Always and forever.
For me this was the greatest scene in the whole series.
Me too
Most emotional scene. Not the best scene overall.
EWrayB2002 for him he said
i still dont get it tho. was snape harry father?
@@tommyblade8093 nope
Man this gets me all the time. Snape was never a bad person, he was just broken.
Alan Rickman potrayed his character beautifully. May his soul Rest in Peace.
What is a bad person? A good person? Snape should teach you, among many things, that "the line between good and evil is drawn down the center of every human heart". -aleksandyr solhenitzyn
lol what how was he not a bad person do you know what a death eater is????? he was a fully evil death eater before voldy killed lilly as he was completely ok letting voldy kill james and harry
For those people who always had problems with Snape because he was a bully to the students, had been a death eater and is viewed by some as more obsessed with Lily than in love with her, I think that the books are sprinkled with bits of information that give lots of clues into his character and understanding of some of the bad decisions he made. It is pretty apparent that Snape’s family life was very unhappy. His muggle father appeared to be abusive from the glimpses we get. And other muggle children in his community, like Petunia, treated him badly because his poverty resulted in his odd dress and appearance. When you combine this with the fact that he was an extremely smart, bookish boy who appeared to also be a loner, you can see why he would be a prime target for recruitment by a group like the Death Eaters. There are plenty of real life parallels to such things, taking away the magical element of course. At one point in the books Harry referred to himself, Snape and Voldemort as the Lost Boys who found a home at Hogwarts. When Dumbledore brought Snape onto the teaching staff at Hogwarts Snape was still very young. In fact, he was only a couple of years out of being a Hogwarts student himself. And we know that Snape had been bullied as a student at Hogwarts. Now he was in a position of authority. And it is highly unlikely that he had experienced much social development of his own in the meantime. For all these reasons, I think it is easy to see why Snape became a bully as a teacher. You would hope that people who are bullied would avoid doing the same thing to other people. But unfortunately, we know that people who are bullied often become the next set of bullies. This is not trying to excuse Snape’s behavior toward the students he was teaching. But it is a way to understand why he would behave this way. As far as whether Snape’s feelings for Lily fall into the category of love or obsession, I don’t think it really makes a big difference in the end. Either way he risked life and limb, and put himself into danger, over and over in order to fulfill the vow he made to Dumbledore to protect Lily’s son. Snape was in the end a very flawed man who was also a hero and one of the best literary characters I have ever had the pleasure to encounter in a story. He was my favorite character in the entire series from the moment we heard that wonderful monologue in Harry’s first potions class. And to Harry he was the bravest man he ever knew.
@@blackeyedlily @blackeyedlily Brilliantly said and what you have written is often overlooked. Snape is the most misunderstood man in the entire HP series yet harbors nothing but love and protectivity for the students, especially Harry. He led a rough life but eventually immortalized himself through his sacrifice. Snape is easily my favorite character!
Most people only turn bad because of the situations they’re put in
My biggest regret will always be not watching this masterpiece in theatre
Same actually
Chamber of Secrets is the only one I didn’t see in theaters…I literally could not wait. It was amazing to see on the big screen. I was ~9 when the first movie was released and 17/18 when the last came out, it was like I grew up with the characters 🥺
Honestly same
i would totally be the one to start the cheering
Lol i just watched this scene in the middle while i was coming out of my room, when my big brother was watching it. And i was like 'Whaaaaat!'
there was never a bigger and emotional twist of story than this
Vader telling Luke he is his father. But this is dang close.
@@GORT70 there was a suspense to it but this just makes me emotional af dont kno why
@@nvignesh Vader being Lukes father was more shocking and a bigger twist. But this was more emotional and meaningful. This scene reminded me more of when Obi-wan and anakin fought. Or when Vader turned on Sidious in the throne room.
I think Snape deep down felt hurt that he was never able to care for harry when he was a child. And kept harry emotionally distant not only to protect harry but to protect his own emotional well-being.
Start watching Naruto for even greater emotional twists
@@adjjoshi lol I watched more than 5000 episodes of anime
Severus Snape, you beautiful bastard.
Thank you, Alan Rickman, for giving us this deep and wonderful character. Rest in eternal peace, sir.
1destined lol
🖤
Probably one of the most powerful scenes in the entire cinematic history of cinemas.
Glad to have witnessed this.
Nah
learn to read, book >
i honestly think more than Dumbledore , snape cared for harry but the worst part is that Harry finds out that Snape was good after he died...
I don’t think Snape really cared for Harry, but consciously he felt he had to protect him because of his never ending love for Lily
Yes he did..:(
Just like itachi from the anime naruto😫
@@johnnymendez3814 that might be a reason but snape could have left harry as he was also the son of his not so good friend james potter.... but he chose to protect , even after lily was long gone
Dumbledore had far beyond goals than just protecting Harry, like he sacrificed his sister for the good of the world
Harry was just a special card of the game which Dumbledore wouldn't lose
This is a “i am your father” level scene
“NO! THATS IMPOSSIBLE!”
@@levifillmlre8687 search you feelings Luke, you know what it's true
I wouldn't say on the exact level since the I am your father literally broke how ppl saw vader and was THE plot twist of the century...but close enough
@@jonas-zk3uv you know it to be true*
@@CR7GOATofFootball thanks, I need to rewatch esb I haven't seen it in ages
I always knew Snape was a good man since The Prisoner of Azkaban, when Lupin tried to attack Harry and his friends, he stood between them
Get Real That only happened in the movies tho, not in the books. Similar thing with this scene when Dumbledore says ‘don’t tell me you’ve grown to care for the boy’, Snape was supposed to say ‘not the boy’ and then show his Patronus to show that it was for Lily, not Harry
I knew since first movie because he tried to save Harry
You know in the books such a thing never happens! He's a real git in the books but i still admire him
And of course when killed Dumbledore
@@k-ster7870 he killed him but that was a favor to him causr he was dying because of touchinh the cursed ring of Gaunt. But I still say he was a git but no doubt he had a very important role in Harry's victory and he was a very brave man. An annoying one though 😁
The fact that Snape was always protecting Harry is heartwarming and heartbreaking. Seeing Snape holding Lily was heartbreaking and seeing his raw emotions. Snape made the ultimate sacrifice by being a double agent.
Also the unbreakable promise its like comiting suicide for the porpuse
Snape went from being a treacherous monster to being a misunderstood angel in less than a minute 😭😭 THAT it art
Lol he's still a petty ass but we like flawed characters for that
Snape? An ANGEL?
@@ligma5042 yes bitch grow up 😌
@@shadybeashooketh1911 sorry, but he's not an angel. if you want to start an argument please don't. I've had enough of those. 🙂
@@ligma5042 if you don't want an argument then why are you going through responding to any comment praising snape 🤣 and i literally don't care bro i'm clearly not trying to argue
Dumbledore: After all this time?
Snape: Always...
Audience: appluding
Me: Crying
yes me too
What does Dumbledore say right before "after all this time" I can't tell. And why do they applaud?
Red Leader he says ‘lily’ who was snapes true love, that’s why his patronas had matched that of Lilly’s. Of course she was Harry’s mum, and that’s the reason he has looked after harry for all these years, because he felt guilty. He thought if he could protect the boy, he would be squaring his debt with James, when he saved snapes life when they were kids.
exactly😢😢😢
Brandon Cook paying for he revealed the existence of the prophecy to voldemort which lead to Lily's death.
One of the most emotional scenes in all of movies
Don't be emotional
@@norpriest521 ?
It gets me everytime
Seen worst but I still love this scene :, (
Nah. The most emotional. Not question about it. Well, except maybe when Sirius dies.
When Snape says always, it always leaves me in tears because that just shows how much love Snape had for Lily. It’s probably one of the most wonderful scenes ever when we get to find out what type of person Snape truly is
To add to this, the reason Snape is my favourite person in Harry Potter is because of how intelligent he is. Throughout the entire series, he is the one man who was on both the dark and light side, while hiding his true commitment to the light the entire time. It was Snape who gained the trust of one of the most evil & powerful wizards of all time, and even then Dumbledore still dies even with Snape's help, the fact that Snape had to maintain through 19 years this level of composure makes him soooo badass to me. Not to mention he looks like Owen Wilson and Keanu Reeves combined 😂
@@cruzjacknife8699 snape was a death eater for a time, and definitely killed many innocent people. He was dark for a number of years.
you are right, me too, every time :'(
@@jaybee3367 rest in piece Alan Rickman.
Best chapter and one of the best scenes
Nah the one where Snape finds the marauders map and they all insult him was funny as fuck.
Por qué veo a muchos con esa foto de perfil
Calm Yourself one of the best twists in history
Prince’s Tale❤️❤️❤️❤️
It’s probably the worst chapter. Great finale, don’t get me wrong, I loved it. The Severus twist is fantastic. But everything that comes before the battle of hogwarts is like mission impossible achieved by three clueless teenagers. The writer just pushed too much on the accelerator
I'm not crying. You're crying 😢
You're right :'(
We all are crying
🤡
yes i am
I AM😭😭😭
I grew up watching the movies at the cinema, but as a child I never understood how good the plot and the depth of the characters are. Today, after rewatching it all over again, I'm an absolute fan, I give this franchise a standing ovation as one of the most genius masterpieces ever made! My biggest wish is that they produce more things from the Harry Potter universe in the format that we currently consume. I know they made the Grindelwald movies but I believe there are much more interesting things to explore in this world. A well-produced series on some online subscription service about Snape's youth, Lilly Potter, is my dream.
my god, you translated my thoughts. please do
I also liked the movies more when I watched older
Midly disagree. It has beautiful characters but if you think about it too hard alot of the plot falls apart. But then again its a series meant for the youth so me and alot of people didnt care about that stuff when reading it for the first time. But thats perfectly fine. Its a fantasy world and is intended to make you forget.
Relax bro
I think the only movies that are on par with the Harry Potter movies especially around that time is The Lord of the Rings. They both have a fantastic plot, a deep and rich backstory, fantastic and dynamic characters with beautiful acting and set design.
Being most hated all the time, but most loved at the last. He is like Itachi.
yess!!!
Hahaha otaku
@@ccuencat and what? I would class myself one too.
@@ccuencat it is sad u dont even know what is art :')
who's itachi
The hardest part about this scene is that we learn what Snape really means when he says Harry has his mother’s eyes. It’s not how they look, it’s how they see others. Harry and his mother both saw the good in people and would never hurt a fly intentionally, they’re both incredibly kind people and see others as if there is always good inside of them, they don’t judge, they don’t hate, they’re genuine loving eyes that want the best for those around them. It’s a heartbreaking moment to see, especially Snape and Lily as kids and how tragic that story was…
Damn I never thought of it like that till now- its even more heartbreaking 😭 I love it. This actually makes a lot more sense.
Well not entirely true for Harry you know, i mean he casted a Cruciatus curse on Amycus Carrow (Against a death eater of course but he still count as a "fly") and you really need to have the intention for that to work ...
Yepp
Wrong take, that's not what he meant to say. What part made Severus think that Harry sees the good in people like his mother?
@@diegokucharsky7165 I mean, how do you tell Harry that the recently discovered Sectusempra almost finished Draco forever?
The moment when you realise that Severus was the biggest hero of HP movies...what an actor...❤
Yes
I disagree. The biggest hero to me is the Weasleys, Regulus Black and Harry himself. Snape's not even in the top 5. He bullied children just for fun.
@@ligma5042 So James bullied Snape, wa bout that??
@@androideditors When did I say that James is better? Both are assholes
@@androideditors James was a dumb teen when he did it. Snape was a grownass man. There is a difference. Snape chose to bully Neville Hermione and other students just for fun. Knowing damn well how it feels to be bullied. It makes it even worse
He was my favorite character since the first movie. It's not about being good or bad. He is the most human character in all the franchise. RIP.
same.. i loved him the moment i found out he didn’t jinx harry’s broom, he was “muttering his little counter-curse” as quirrell so gracefully put it, and all my friends judged me until we all watched the last one together and i dont think i have ever seen them apologize for anything so quickly..
I got chills when everyone clapped
Same
@@Lightfyre woah woah u don’t need to use the b word-
Theres alot of true harry potter fans there.
I cringed hard
Faaaaaaax
I was born too young to understand that part. The last movies were too dark for my young brain back then. But when i’ve saw them later, this is the most memorable scenes i’ve ever seen. Such a good written character.
i relate to you deeply on this, ever since i was a kid i still thought snape was the bad guy and good thing he died, watched in as an adult teen now that i realise how beautiful snape truly is and bawled my eyes out TT.
fax
@@reefa4773 frl
Same. Now that I’ve seen all the films with a real pair of eyes, and a solid set of emotions, I can gladly admit I’ve seen the “EXPECTO PATRONUM” scene about 30 times, because of its sheer beauty. But this scene was the biggest, most important twist of them all. I’m glad this scene was never spoiled for me.
@@UndertaleFan-cx2mc omg yesss
Imagine how Harry felt after seing those memories... The man he hated actually protected him
Edit: omg didn't expect all these likes
Or even before that when dying Snape tells him, he has his mother's eyes.. I think this is the real moment he understands that Snape never was an enemy. The look on Harrys face always hits me hard, well acted!
@@GloeckchenJas oh yea
who gives a shit how harry felt? imagine being a bullied introvert with the dickhead who bullies you taking your only true love and then you even have to risk your life to protect their arrogant kid who hates you.
@@knuckle-sandwichmma681 to be fair, Harry only hated Snape because Snape hated him first and was rly mean to him for what he thought was no reason. If Snape treated Harry better especially initially, Harry wouldn't have hated him
@@racheldarmawangsa9589 but then it's natural to have a little hate for our ex-lovers child! But then we'd also want to protect knowing they're parents has died
13 years later and this scene still hits! RIP Alan and Micheal you both will ALWAYS be missed 🙏🏾thank you for being a memorable part in my life!
Me at 3am: I need to sleep
RUclips: Wanna see the reactions of audience to Snape's memories?
Me: Sure
Literally 3.51am
02:54 here Hello my Friends xD
3:03. when I started the video it was probably 3:00 or 3:01
Lol it’s 323 am
When he said *”ALWAYS”* , I felt that deep in my heart.
Correct 😭😭
Me too
JK Rowling have Alan one piece of the puzzle that is shape. Which was the definition of the word always
This whole scene broke me so hard I felt so bad for snape he had almost everything taken away from him he did care about Harry he was just reminded of his father which triggered him
Bruiser Bunny he didn’t care about Harry! In this scene he was supposed to say (canonically) ‘for him?’, as in, 'not him' after Dumbledore said ‘don’t tell me you’ve grown to care for the boy’ and then show his patronus to show who he cared for: Lily. But not Harry. He was too bitter about James to care for Harry.
@@olgac.9636 here here, poisnous snake everywhere
@@olgac.9636 actually it's "for him?"
It's a movie 💩
@@coreywells6765 you sound like a boring person who hasn't read the books
Snape's character development and arc is one of the greatest! We can't deny how we tend to symphatize with him. ALWAYS.
This still makes me cry.
RIP Alan. RIP Professor Snape.
rip
Bruh hella no, this showed that Snape is just a overbearing man child. Yes your first love/ connection went to someone else. Guess what? EVERYONE goes through heartbreak. It take strength to push forward and live your life. Being a dick to the child of the woman who broke your heart is nothing but abusive. And Harry also losing his mom should of made it that Snape is nicer to Harry. They both lost the woman they loved. Theres plenty of threads and videos from women calling out Snape behavior.
@@malfaroangel3896 Nobody asked. Or cares for your opinion.
I was 12 years old when i watched deathly hollows part 2 in cinema, my childish brain never understood this scene due to hatred that built up since the first movie until this scene. I rewatched all movies at 17 and realised that snape was the good guy. I am now 21 and since the 2nd completion of series whenever i came across this scene, i cry
Yes!
Im 12 right now and i feel so bad for snape and malfoy.. They were so misunderstood
You just made me feel old. A lot. When this movie happend?
I hope you have read the books too. This scene, Snape story ark and so much more doesn’t even compare in the movie adaptations (although I enjoy the movies too)
@@Lamalamovska like 2011
(In thirty years)
Me: *Rereading Harry Potter for the 53552178th time*
My kids: Harry Potter, after all this time?
Me: Always
Always
Always
Always
Always
Always
"A villain is just a victim whose story hasn't been told
The fact that snape is a potions master and could brew a love potion to make lily fall in love but doesn’t is a testament to his good nature
@AyushGurung What a lot of people tend to ignore about the love potions is that, essentially, they're roofies. They override the drinker's judgement, making them consent to a relationship, however brief it is, that they probably wouldn't want under their own volition. Snape likely knew that Voldemort, himself, was conceived via a love potion, as well as the problems that this caused. He couldn't make himself do that to Lily, however much he might've been tempted. You're right about that decision, showing his true character. (10/24/2021)
not raping is really the lowest of the lowest of the lowest of the lowest bar
Idk if not roofying someone is a testament to anyone’s good nature man
And because, if you use a love potion in a relationship and then conceive a child, this child will never feel love.
@@frankenviews4069 lol, yes! The bare minimum he could do as a decent human.
I wish that i could erase my memory ang go back in time just to read the books and see the movies
Yeet or get yeeted I’ve never seen a single Harry Potter movie or even read a book for the matter
@@Ryujinn999 I definitely recommend reading the books. there are weak spots along the series, for me it was in book two and book four where I stopped reading for a while, but overall the series is fantastic in my opinion and worth reading until the end. Also watching the movies first might diminish your reading experience so although the movies range from decent to very good I would finish the books before considering watching the movies.
Obliviate /*
OBLIVIATE
The books had more content, the movies had the soundtrack going for them.
Notice how the lens is out of focus.
It’s crying too
I'm over here ugly crying and you made me bust out laughing 😭
idk when i wrote this but now im laugh crying thanks past self
@@Arxiuz2 it is so funny ahahah XD
I have never seen a Harry Potter movie in the cinema. But hearing the godly voice of Dumbledore and Severus is incredible. Their voices are so deep and powerful, also the acting and the story coming together in this particular scene is phenomenal.
Richard Harris was perfect for dumbledore.
Tell me I'm wrong - The character development of Snape is the best, not only in HP, but in any franchise. The fact that we, within one scene, went from hating the shit out of him, to love him almost more than Harry Potter... RIP Alan Rickman, you will never be forgotten.
Death Vader?🤷🏽♂️
I'm trying to develop my character.
Jaime Lannister theon greyjoy Sansa stark
Walter white jesse
Frodo Baggins
This scene deserves an Oscar in itself!!
Yes
Yesss!! 🔥
Oscar doesnt deserve them
You mean a pullitzer for J.K.
and hes dead..
Alan Rickman is actually dead.. im so sad :(
Now he is with Lily !
*He's alive in OUR HEART* ❤Remember, a true leyend, never die 👼
1946-"Always" 😭💔
No like the actor who plays snake is dead
@@jennifercampart xD
Mowinx .M Omg Lily is just fictional okay.. this man really died so no.. just no.. it’s cringy and annoys me
Snape is a perfect embodiment of "good guys never win"
That's so true..
That's the truth, right there. If you're a good guy you'll be forever alone. Girls don't appreciate it.
@@jcdenton6577 projecting much? Harry ends up with Ginny, Ron with Hermione. Neville also finds a woman. Mr. Weasley, Lupin and Hagrid all find love. They’re all bad guys then?
Snape isn’t the only “good guy”. He made poor life decisions unfortunately when he joined the Death Eaters which drove him away from Lily. He’s incredibly brave after that and he regrets not being able to save her, yes. But that doesn’t prove that good guys never win lol.
@@K100-b3e It's a movie... What did you expect? Not based on true events, you know.
@@jcdenton6577 You're right, it's not based on true events, it's actually based on a book series where Snape is infinitely more cruel and unpleasant than he's ever depicted in the films. Snape was a complex character, he was brave and he was clever, but he was by no means a "good guy". Snape was perfectly happy to serve the dark side until Lily, a childhood crush, was in danger. He then proceeded to terrorise her son, as well as the rest of the non-Slytherin students for years and years. Snape lavished at the idea of Sirius receiving the dementor's kiss. And even during this memeory sequence in the books, he scavenges through Sirius (now Harry's) house to find a letter and photo from Lily, including a photo of Lily, James, and Harry, and he tears off the part with Lily and the end of the letter where she states her love, and leaves the house in a mess. Snape is a creep; he was _obsessed_ with Lily. I feel sorry for anyone who thinks Snapes love, while genuine, is in anyway healthy.
The fact that snape has a patronus is proof of the goodness in his heart. Remember death eaters are allies with dementors so they do not need patronuses
Didn't save Crouch Jr
he spied on the most dangerous wizard of all time who was also one of the best legilimens ( wizard who can read people's mind) for dumboldore.
snape doesn't need a patronus to prove his goodness in his heart....
@@mahirfaisal8180 yes. But this was the absolute no turning back proof that snape was on the good side
Voldemort's patronus is a snake
Eh, not quite. It would be mighty odd for a defense against the dark arts teacher to conspicuously not be able to cast a patronus.
All those years wanting Snape to die and when he actually died EVERYONE CRIED.
i loved him the moment i found out he didn’t jinx harry’s broom, he was “muttering his little counter-curse” as quirrell so gracefully put it, and all my friends judged me until we all watched the last one together and i dont think i have ever seen them apologize for anything so quickly..
@@alexuswerntz99 ah i can imagine the look on their regretful faces lol
@@alexuswerntz99 Same. He was my favorite character long before the later books. I got into many an argument (all in good fun of course) after he killed Albus in book 6. We were still waiting for 7 to come out and I took my stand for Snape. I KNEW he was good. Of course, everyone else told me I was crazy, he is the most evil, we hate him, etc. There are little Easter eggs like the one you mentioned sprinkled throughout. Easy to miss. I know it's a fictional story, but it's one of the things I'm most proud of. It was fantastic when book 7 was finally released.
@@alexandraempie3842Dude take my heart and keep it safe w/ you. Coz you are the first person who liked Snape's Character after reading "The books", coz I thought I was the only one in who thought so!!!❤️🩹
I have no shame to admit that I cried for Snape. I hated him for so many years but this, just tore open my heart.
Rickman was a legend. RIP
Edit : Omg, thanks a lot you guys for the likes.
I will always hate snape cause of treatment of Lily son
@@charlenerafferty3534 what the fuck does that mean? Now get the fuck out of here Snape hater before I sectumsempra.
Couldn’t agree more. Little me thought he was part of “the AXIS of evil” lol. What amazes me is how well this image was maintained. From the troll attack, to the cursing of his broom, to the unbreakable vow, to the murder of dumbledore, there was never a moment where one would stop and think “wait, is there a higher motivation for all this?” Then you see this moment. And everything you’ve ever known about the character is wrong, and the missing piece is finally filled in.
Gay
The fact Alan made you hate his character shows just what a good job he did!
Me watching HP after 8 years and crying over this scene.
My mom: after all this time?
Me: always. /*
One of the most heartbreaking things i read a while ago that i never thought of was, snape died not knowing harry got to live. I havent stopped crying since reading it
Oh my God! I never thought about this! Now I feel even worse about Snape's death. And also, imagine, James died thinking Lily and Harry both lived.
After reading this, all I can feel is ✨pain✨
@@terabaap1775 I think james knew that they would probably end up dead because he failed to protect them from Voldemort himself and he was only in the next room
@@anitabonghit7606 yeah, that could've happened. But I think James must've thought that both Harry and Lily survived because he'd have thought that Lily would apparate along with Harry and would've saved both their lives.
@@terabaap1775 good point I guess in the end she didnt want to run
Dumbledore: After all this time?
Snape: *Always*
me: *cries Atlantic ocean*
Stop it
İ never watched harry potter in a cinema and its really weird to see it like this and to think people waited for this like we did for avengers
Kero kerem This may come as an even bigger shock, but I was (and still am) such a big fan of Harry Potter and have all the books and read each multiple times, but I looked towards this movie even more than I did for the Avengers. Endgame’s the second movie I ever cried at in a movie theater, too. That and Toy Story 3. I would’ve added this movie, but didn’t see it in a movie theater which I really regret.
Zach Pohlman no İ understand this Movie was really good but i dont see it that way because İ was too young
Even LOTR movies but i didn't watch them in theatres
I saw the Last three movies in a cinema
Dumbass this is a marathon
“Always” makes me tear up
“No, I am your father!”-Darth Vader
“Ride now! RIDE TO RUIN AND WORLDS ENDS DAY! DEATH!” -Theoden
“Pirates life”-Jack Sparrow
“ *Always* ” - Severus Snape
Four great sagas and each has a memorable quote.
Forgot one
YOU SHAALLL NOTTT PAASSSSS - Gandalf Brian Dumbledore
An Indian would like to add the last line of Bahubali: The Beginning.
“Hold on tight spider-monkey” - Edward Cullen
You forgot “Immortals? We’ll put their name to the test” - 300
@@mahaniyama its awuuu awuu
This is enough to make a grown man cry
insert meatball policeman
@Alicorn VK and you find yourself holding them back for some reason
Sounds like a manchild
Yup I’m crying 😢
Dumbledore : " Lily... After all this time "
Snape : " ALWAYS"😪
Snape did not see Harry as the son of a man he hated the most instead he went on seeing Harry as the son of the woman he loved ❤❤
എന്നാലും പിള്ളേ. ഹാരിയെ സ്കൂളിൽ നിന്നും പുറത്താക്കാൻ സ്നേപ്പ് നോക്കണണ്ണ്ണ്ഡിടല്ലോ
Damn... That's quite a comment you've made 👏🏼👌🏻
As I got to this comment
It started playing
Muy cierto, es muy cierto lo que dices y es increíble eso, cuanto la llegó a amar que incluso aún despues de su muerte la siguió amando y protegió lo mas importante para ella, Harry Potter
@@Ashwin-oq1xt to protect him from dark lord.
1:42 That quiet echoing howling 'Expecto Patronum' breaks my heart. Chills down my spine really
If Harry hadn't been there to collect Snape's tears, and if Snape never shared the tears Harry wouldn't have known the truth about Snape or even how to beat Voldemort...that's crazy
That's a haunting thought and there are no other witnesses to those facts either. All the marauders dead, dumbledore dead. Although perhaps the portrait of Phineas Nigellas Black in Dumbledores study or maybe Nearly Headless Nick ?
Its why when Snape was dying with Harry he was practically begging in desperation because he knew this was his last chance. Which is even more heartbreaking.
@@Blade9e7 In the books before Snape dies, Rowling mentions that in shrieking shack, Snape stared at the snake inside protective bubble while talking to Voldemort while voldemort was talking about the elder wand's inability to perform for him to the maximum. But snape repeatedly asked Voldemort to let him go find Harry and bring Harry to him.
Snape remembered Dumbledore advicing him to tell Harry that Harry had to die because of being a horcrux himself , when and only when there comes a time when Voldemort fears for nagini. Snape wanted to go find Harry and tell him so.
Then Voldemort mentioned elder wand and Snape killing Dumbledore and Snape understood what Voldemort was planning to do to master elder wand. Then only Snape knew that Voldemort intended to kill him , that he won't be able to find Harry and that Dumbledore was the previous master of elder wand and Dumbledore had other plans about elder wand's ownership when he asked Snape to kill him.
Dumbledore didn't thought Voldemort would find elder wand . He simply wanted the owner to die so as to prevent the succession of mastering the wand.
Snape realised that Dumbledore hid this piece of information from him before he was asked to make the promise about murdering Dumbledore.
Snape looked away from nagini only when he realised this. He was following Dumbledore's instructions to the dot .
Poor Severus.
@@Blade9e7 In the end Snape did fear he might never get a chance to tell Harry about Dumbledore's revalation of 'harry being a horcrux and should die ' .
Remember, a wizard should willingly give his memories . He should have chosen only to give his memories of conversations with Dumbledore. But he chose to give all of his memories connecting him, lilly , the Marauders , his childhood before Hogwarts and Dumbledore .
In the end he wanted Harry to realise that he have ALWAYS cared for harry and served Dumbledore for the sole purpose . And because no one can vouch for his because Dumbledore only knew this secret and he is dead.
@@thenerdfather5309 Phineas nigellus yes perhaps, being hung in Dumbledore's study. But not nearly headless Nick. He was a ghost , yes. But he didn't have a portrait of him in the headmaster's room. He would know the history, that's all.
Petition for making an *origin story* about *Severus Snape.*
_Who’s with me on this one?_
Yes please, I want one
No. It'll be ruined
No! Snape is my favourite character. And an origin story will ruin everything the books and movies have built. AND THE MOST IMPORTANT REASON:
Severus Snape = Alan Rickman
@@JuliaPloutarxou I could see Adam Driver playing Snape, but JK said that she only wants British actors playing Harry Potter characters
Adam Driver for the role of Snape
I know that most people think that this is Snape’s ”the moment” when we learn all of his motivations and etc. but I always saw this as “Dumbledore moment”. I mean Snape’s kinda right, Dumbledore kept Harry alive only so that he could die at the right moment (and most likely he didn’t even know that Harry could come back from the dead). And when Snape shocked (pretty appropriate reaction if you ask me) accuses Dumbledore of raising Harry like a pig to slaughter Dumbledore doesn’t show remorse. No, he looks at Snape and ironically asks ”Have you grown to care for the boy?”... For me that was the moment when we saw in Harry Potter the younger, manipulative side of Dumbledore that fascinates me so much. ‘Cause he was really ready to send Harry to death “FOR THE GREATER GOOD”
omg so truee. I really agree, but I think it's a little bit the moment of both of them
I don't think Dumbledore planned for him to die. I'm not sure if one realizes it, but Dumbledore set in motion for Harry Potter to become master of death. Harry had the stone sent to him by AD, he already had the cloak and became the master to the elder wand. Dumbledore didn't want Harry to die. He only wanted him to face death - to make him the master of death.
Yes. This vindicates Aberforth's point of view.
I'm pretty sure Dumbledore knew - or at least suspected - that Harry would not stay dead. He had a look of triumph when Harry said Voldemort used his blood to return.
I know he is manipulative. But to blame him for doing literally the only thing that would stop Voldemort is a bit hypocritical. Literally nothing else could have been done. If he did not do exactly this, Voldemort would have remained immortal. And literally billions would have been enslaved or slaughtered. Yes he is manipulative. But he needed to make that decision. And he could not tell a soul of it. Doom an innocent boy to death, and groom him into a self sacrificing reckless hero. So that he could do what must be done. So that he would. Dumbledore is not an evil person. He is manipulative and he likes power. He was the most powerful wizard alive, arguably. And for all that power and knowledge, the only thing he could do. Is destroy the life of another young person. Imagine that situation. Almost revered as a god. Powerless to do anything. It's easy to judge when you don't have to make the hard decisions.
The feeling knowing all of these was like having your heart ripped out of your chest while your still alive
I remember me watching this in a full cinema and right after this scene, the film turns completely silent and so did the audience. It felt like everybody was is shock, even forgetting to breath. Not a single noise. Nothing. That was one of the most striking moments I've ever experienced in a cinema.
Means nobody read the books...
@@sandeepfrancis3568 I read the books and I always knew he was good.
I was a kid I remember I didn't wanna get spoiler before seeing the movie but then I still read it cuz I couldn't help it and then I found out he was good lol
Even if u read the books, this scene is so alarmingly sad
This scene from a man who never laughed during entire series taught us the true meaning of love n care
ALWAYS
am i the only one who never hates Snape?
Abigail Tay I only started properly watching the movies this year when they came on ITV as they do every September, and I could never find myself hating him, no matter what he did or what he had appeared to have done (cough cough philosophers stone). been my favourite character from the very beginning
i’ve always loved him. there’s something so real about his character that i enjoy so much
nah I didnt, I kind of have the same traits as him
There were moments where you did hate him but then moments where you empathized with him, it was never easy for Snape to do all this stuff for Dumbledore yet he chose to do it anyway and my guess is he did it mainly for Lily because he loved her that much
Never hated him, I always thought he was severe but rightful, I had many teachers like him.. and every time they will be the ones will teach you the most in unique way
One of the best scenes in cinematography history!
When he said “always” and the audience started clapping I burst into tears. What a wonderful man Alan was, he played Snape absolutely on point. When I was younger, I asked my dad, “daddy, is the actor in real life mean just like Snape?” My dad went on to explain acting to me. And from then on, I loved Alan. I was heartbroken to hear about his death. I look up to him so much still and I know he will always be remembered.
Always. 😭🤍 he deserved more time here.
RIP the one and only Alan Rickman. I am better because of you.
Dumbledore believed that love is the greatest power of all. When he realised that Snape's love for Lilly exists after all this time, understood that he was totally right. Simultaneously he was so surprised because he understood that everything can change over the years, but love stays untouched, unconditional, unconventional and with the same power from the beginning till the end.
Thats yourbthoughts.. Not dumbledores😋... In books and science fiction love can be this much important... Not in real life
He didn’t fucking love her
You guys are watching too much Hollywood and reading too much Nicholas Sparks.
🔥
Dumbledore even used Snape’s love for Lilly to his own advantage. Lol he’s very clever.
Crushing my heart.... especially since Snape really had a pure heart at the end. I'm certain he knew the wand was faithful to Draco and not him. But prefered sacrificing his life not to endanger Draco's. A true hero, who never needed recognition to be loyal and brave🙏
Yes. I just realized this . Thank you. But remember , Snape made an unbreakable vow to protect Draco. In either way he should die.
Hes saving his student
Snape’s a true Hogwarts student and we didn’t realize it until it was too late. He’ll be sorely missed throughout the years of the wizarding world. He’s a Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw and Slytherin all in one.
He couldn't reveal it was Draco, since that would be putting him in danger. He made the unbreakable vow to protect him. Therefore Snape would've died regardless.
He may not have necessarily known. The legend behind the elder wand seemed to indicate that the allegiance changed with the murder of the previous master. Voldemort himself believed it. Snape was indeed very clever and a supremely good occlumens, but we do not know how versed he was in wandlore.
Avengers and Marvel has its own thing going.. But never will ever be like Harry Potter! 😭😭😭
That shit will never come close to this man.
And that says something to me because I’m a hardcore Marvel fan.. but this.. this is something else.. 😭🖤
probably cuz theyre not trying to go in a remotely similar direction as harry potter
Coz your childhood is filled with Harry Potter memories. Enough said.
Avengers is fucking gay