Ex-federal official explains why she resigned over US approach to Gaza
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 май 2024
- Annelle Sheline, who served as a foreign affairs officer at the Office of Near Eastern Affairs in the Department of State's Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, explains her decision to resign from the Department based on the US response to the war in Gaza.
You’re still calling it the Israel-Hamas war. Come on, now.
Right. Lol how is it a war when one side has no military or state.
Follow the money. Who gains the most from selling military hardware.
@@mick947 America makes most of its money from controlling the petrol dollar hands while they go into countries for oil and selling weapons
100% right cnn is shameful
it should say "Israel-Children-War"
If Hamas is a terrorist organization, what then is the IDF?
IOF.... Pamper Army
@@BlueTeamRedTeam You mean the only pariah state in the Middle East?
@@BlueTeamRedTeam How can an Illegal squatters be democratic. Make each of them take a DNA test. Haha
@@Innocent_Plight no I’m not talking about Iran or Jordan or Turkey or Egypt. Keep trying you’ll figure it out soon
@@BlueTeamRedTeam All of those nations abide by international rules, unlike the pariah state, land thieves and war criminals you so vehemently defend.
Huge respect for her, it's extremely difficult to stand up as a normal person against powerful people like this.
Powerful people like who?
@@davidchin1828Israeli lobby...
She is not normal. She is a white educated rich woman in America. She is the rare exception.
Israel
If she were living under a brutal tyranny that executes its opponents, for example, in Hamas-ruled Gaza, then I'd agree. There, she'd be taking a huge risk speaking out in opposition to government policy, and it would be very brave. In the U.S., though? People post videos accusing Israel of genocide all the time and nothing happens to them. Why would this be so extremely difficult for her? What is likely to happen to her as a consequence of this, other than offers for paid speaking engagements? :-)
Not Israeli Hamas war but Israel vs women and children war
It’s west vs eastern women Israel can’t do anything now before not now not later Israel is just being used to push others plans
Yes "Israel's genocide on women and children"
That is the correct title.
Why do your friends in Hamas hide behind woman and children?
@@punchthem4582 same reason Israelis hide behind women and children? By your own logic, Israel has bases all throughout it's civilian population. So I guess they use human Shields as well 🤔
Provide evidence to support your claims!
Stop the genocide!
I agree
I agree ...what palastinians did to innocent Jewish women and children last October is disgusting!!!
The slaughter , rape and torture of over 1000 women and children by hamas was unacceptable!!!
And the kidnapping and murder of American Jews by hamas in Gaza must be STOPPED!!!
We must stop this 2nd genocide of jews💙🇺🇸✋🏿
The genocide hamass publicly declares against Israel, you mean?
FREE PALESTINE AND AMERICA 🇺🇸
Hamas is genocidal.
We can’t support genocide
Vote for Trump in November and also do anything you can to help Trump win, such as stay home, vote for JFKr, knock on doors on behalf of Trump, buy Trump's bible, and read the Book of two Corinthians.
LoL, where have you been the last 30 years US was in the middle east?
@@jasonlucas2328for what trump would of done worse with this war. And for what to have a nut like Kennedy not a real Kenny like his father etc even his family is against him. Trump want to be a ruler like Putin. No thanks.
noneshere,
That’s the point. It has gone on too long. Ceasefire now. I will never vote for Biden again. Never.
Life before party loyalty.
🇵🇸🙏🏿❤️
@@noneshereRussia was in Afghanistan and Syria.
Dr.Sheline, You are an example to all of us. Standing up for the rights of the oppressed against the silence and hypocrisy of the majority is an act of great courage.
She is standing up for the Hamas terrorist organization.
deserves her title of Doctor unlike others hiding behind a title
Israel.
@@blackrose7596honestly you need to hone up on your responses if you want to convince people your genocide is morally just.
A brave woman who speaks truth where there is much career and safety risk.
It would be braver of her if she stays to work out problematic issues instead of running away. Also this is another country what does she or others expect the United States to do?
@@Valerie-lp4xestop arming the terrorists to destroy innocent people duh
@@Valerie-lp4xe she’s clearly said her government doesn’t care about their concerns, as they’ve committed themselves on the darkest path. She expects the US to stop sending money and weapons to the oppressors.
@@Valerie-lp4xe a federal employee that she thinks she is important...1 of 76,000 US State employees
@@user-dp1bt9ql2m are u even aware of whats going on over there??
"The truth has come and falsehood has vanished. Indeed, falsehood is bound to vanish."
Lived in telaviv for more than 9years, the politicians can be dirty as fuck but the ordinary citizens are the best people I ever meet. And lived with
A verse from the Holy book (the Quran) God is in control. Remember that.
Ezekiel 23 ~20....
@@mahdiahmed8611I don’t read fiction.
@@johnward43how would you know?
the occupier can’t complain about the resistance
So rape is resistance? The slaughter of babies is resistance?
Good to know…
@@energytauq8710Still no evidence rape or beheaded babies. Would have been presented to UN if it were true.
Mia Schem [Israel hostage to Hamas] gets nose job b/c "Hamas wouldn't touch/rape her". "My therapist told me to get a nose job to boost my self esteem"
Which occupier? The muslim/Arab occupiers of Palestine?
@@nilnil8411so you obviously would also say that the British soldiers who murdered my parents as they walked home from the pub here in Belfast 🇮🇪 in 1979 , heroes, and because I fought back years later, im the terrorist, and obviously the Brits were here as far as you are concerned on bloody Sunday in Derry and 5 months before that in ballymurphy were they laughed at trial how they used one of the dead mens skulls as an ashtray and shot a priest as he gave the last rites to a fatally wounded young boy. You also agree that Israel were right to throw the 18 month old baby Ali Duwabsheh onto the fire and burn her alive and then mock the relatives by singing " were is Ali ??, Ali is on the grill . Any wonder we have no sympathy for any of the tramps that died on September 11 then .
Euro jew colonizers occupying Palestine
She speaks for this American citizen as well! 👏🏼
I never thought israelii army are the real terrorists
Let me guess you’re a single childless woman in your late thirties
She Is your wife 👏👏👏
She Is hot
She Is 🇺🇲 😮
Dr. Annelle Sheline resigned. She is being allowed to state her reason(s) on CNN for leaving the State Department. Thank you, CNN. As a Vietnam Vet, I appreciate Dr. Sheline's reasoning. Her public message should be respected.
She’s a virtue signaller , just like you are bringing up the irrelevant information that you’re a Vietnam vet.
@@dorianshadesofgray2981 GOOD FOR YOU!
Robot
@@dorianshadesofgray2981 🍼
As I always assert, certain positions may not be suitable for women. This also applies to the military, where individuals must make challenging decisions that not everyone can emotionally handle.
Ex Aaron Bushnell, may he rest in peace, was simply not suited for this particular role.
My brother ❣Aaron Bushnell's ❣last word was "Free Palestine".
My sister Catherine the Middleton ....
And why did you think it was important to share?
Israel is THE Palestinian state.
There are no Israeli slaves.
@@borisf2520 Relevant , not important
Palestine is being contained by the neighboring Arab countries. If you look at the robust border wall and entry points of these Arab countries that adjoining Palestine, you will quickly determine that these Arab countries believe that the Palestinians are the scourge of the area and must be kept contained.
A very brave and compassionate lady.
This concern for human rights should be the benchmark for all bureaucrats
A young atractive hot Western girl ! 😮👏👏👏🇺🇲
Respect👏👏🙏🙏🙏
Robot
Finally, Yankees with hearts stand up!
New York Nets '
As long as Netanyahu remains there is no solution. He wrecked the Oslo Accord by his bad faith. And instead used it as cover for his colonial project in Palestine.
@@mananimal3644
Opportunists coming out of the woodwork.
Netanyahu's government is dragging Israel into an economic and social catastrophe
Yair Lapid, Israeli opposition leader
متا
Netanyahu is leading Israel to dangerous international isolation... and the threat of the American administration indicates Netanyahu’s incompetence and loss of eligibility
Gilad Kariv Member of the Knesset from the Labor Party
كتا😊
IF THIS IS NOT GENOCIDE IN GAZA, THEN GERMANY WAS NOT GENOCIDE EITHER
@@mananimal3644 Biden gave aid to Palestinians. I don't think Palestinians are a distinct ethnicity either.
Now if we could get the entire government to quit
36.000 offiscialls
She made good points.
You mean a claim of genocide then refusal to back up her claims
@@dorianshadesofgray2981 She backed them up. Biden has not followed our laws she brought up. He's trying to handle this diplomatically without having to do that, but, at some point with more than 30k innocent Palestinians dead, and at least half of them children, no aid, starvation, and she has a point? Tell me there are 15k children in the Hamas organization? You cant. What Hamas did was horrifying. But so is what Israel is doing. And we are arming Israel. We need to help end this.
They will try to change the definition of “genocide” when they are the ones who are doing it 😂😂😅
You're absolutely right...What you did in Iraq was genocide and you committed massive war crimes...Now go sit down
Law is on your side, People are on your side, You are on the right side of histroy.
Be proud, good people need to do all we can to stop this carnage.
Bless her. She encompasses the strength and courage of women.
Dr . Sheline : Thank you for your ethical standards and calling out the truth when many in the American government is not seeing what the rest of the world is seeing . I applaud you . Thank you so very much 🙏🏼❤️🇨🇦
Thank you for Black socks
BLack Hawk
@@user-wj4yk8ly1d Hockey ? I don't read innuendo or euphemisms too well . 🤯 Could you spell it out for me ?
Why doesnt CNN hire ex msnbc Mehdi Hasan??? where is cnn muslim journalists?
AIPAC wouldn't allow such hiring
They've blacklisted him for telling the truth.
Hassan was a propagandist for Al Jazeera.
He's a propagandist and why does CNN need muslim journalists? Fareed Zakaria is muslim
Thruth can not hide forever
God bless you sister as you are able to differentiate right from wrong.stay strong like a lioness. Sadly US thought process is itself a big failure for the world and its far away from reality and practical issues.
Kushner is a piece of work.
No need to be polite. He's a money grubbing a$$hole.
A work that you scrape of your shoe after walking across the front lawn.
Thank god that piece of work doesn't live in my country😅
He Has not a dimes
He Is empty like Sahara desert
If US really cared it would stop funding And install a no fly zone immediately there.
F Russia
And support Hamas. The US and the EU already gave Iran billions.
So, you want the U.S. Navy to shoot down Israeli aircraft over Gaza. Am I getting that right?
da comrade
So, if the U.S. really cared, it would have the Navy shoot down any Israeli planes that flew over Gaza as part of their mission to remove Hamas from power. Am I understanding correctly? What would be the goal of that? Would it be to keep Hamas in power, or just to make Israel remove them without using aircraft?
Thank you for your bravery for standing up against the atrocities against the people of Gaza.
Thank you for speaking out
On truth sossial
Funny I don’t remember anyone questioning Israel on the definition of holocaust when they claimed that’s what Hamas committed Oct 7th? 🤔
The doctor that quit well spoken america dont follow their own laws what a shame and we talk about china Russia ect
Nothing but respect for anyone who takes a stands on principle. It takes a lot of courage to sacrifice based on conscience
Josh Paul too.
She quit her job after a year … we call that a quitter
*take a stand
@@dorianshadesofgray2981 we call it principled.
@@user-pf7tf3rf1u He still hasn't done his research.
I agree with her completely
And with Her Black socks too
@@user-wj4yk8ly1d why you bothered?
Good for you, Annelle.
You mean Annabelle
Anne Hathaway 🥰🥰😍😍😍😍😍😮👏👏👏🇺🇲🙂
"Anna and the King" ( Jodie Foster ) .
Thanks doctor you are a role model; standing for justice need to be prevailed. I really appreciate your courage.
Thank you Dr Sheline for taking the moral stance. Your truly a brave woman. Expect an onslaught of threats and abuse from immoral beings. When you do, just know that there are billions of us who support you and your conscious is clear
A great human being and a great Stateswoman. Hat's off to her.
Thank you for your integrity. We need more people like you in America.
When the oppressed become the oppressors
You really think anyone " looks to the U.S. as a leader"?
yeah they just look right over all the fools grovelling at a conman's feet and see real americans
There's so much you can do
Well, they’ve still got the military.
They lead in that.
Justice, freedom, democracy, politics… definitely not!
😂😂😂
Lander of Last Resort
Netanyahu wouldn't listen to president Biden.
But would listen to his instinct
Biden can stop the US aid, stop sending weapons, stop giving green light to Israel, stop blindly vetoing every UN resolution against Israel. It boggles my mind to see that we are giving weapons to unalive our fellow humans and children but withholding food so Israel can starve babies. We have lost our humanity and soul. Anyone supporting this is complicit in this gen-0-cide
No one in there rite mind would listen to Biden ,or Obama ,the Ukraine war was started by Obama and Biden ,and Biden is a muppet been run by Obama and the Deep State ,,
Thank you for coming and speaking the truth. This is humanity coming from people with HEARTS.
Heroine. Her CNN letter was one of the best I've ever read
Having been in
Gaza and theWestBank, I wish everyone could know what goes on
Yeah. A person with backbone
A conscientious human being.
These are true Americans with respect for constitution
Doctor Sheline is a very brave lady with integrity. So many governments should be totally ashamed with turning their backs on Gaza!
Former Israeli Chief of Staff Moshe Ya'alon admitted his country's responsibility for the killing of 100 people during the distribution of humanitarian aid in the northern Gaza Strip, according to statements reported by the Hebrew newspaper Maariv.
The newspaper quoted Ya’alon as saying, “Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu prefers to remain in power, and returning hostages is not a priority for him,” noting that “the threat to enter Rafah is a hoax. Ya’alon asked: “If we needed to enter, why did you not enter?” Why did we demobilize the reserve units?
The former Israeli chief of staff confirmed that officials within the government are demanding that hostages be sacrificed in exchange for occupying the Gaza Strip, expelling the Palestinians, and settling Jews there.
حتاا
Looks that way.
Did Hamas admit to anything?
Couldn't find any articles or quotes of moshe yaalon saying any of those things
Where is the source? Never heard of it
I only keep up with Haaretz and the Israel times. Did Haaretz do a story on this?
THIS BRINGS A TEAR TO MY EYE. THE AVERAGE AGE OVER IN GAZA IS 18 YEARS OF AGE. TO THE AMERICANS READING THIS POST JUST THINK ABOUT THAT 18-YEAR-OLDS ARE GETTING MURDERED BY RELIGION. SOME GOD
Well one day all of us will stand before almighty God like it or not.
This woman has seen way more information and evidence of Israel atrocities than any of us regular citizens.
Despicable questions by this so-called journalist, perpetuating the propaganda machine and being a war crime apologist.
He doesn’t want to anger his bosses
Behind every big news outlet journalist is a puppeteer’s string leading back to the politicians in charge. They’re nothing more than the propoganda wing of modern day globalists
1. Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Haifa Massacre 1938.
4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1939
6. Haifa Massacre 1947
7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
12. Tantura Massacre 1948
13. Jaffa Massacre 1948
14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
16. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
17. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990
18. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
19. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
20. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
21. Gaza Massacre 2012
22. Gaza Massacre 2014
23. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
24. Gaza Massacre 2021
25. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing
DONT LET ANYONE CONVINCE YOU THAT IT
STARTED ON OCTOBER 7th
PLEASE REPOST
نالا😊
@@Zman5146false there was no peace before the 7th October. Isreal committed aurestrike fews days before the 7th October
@@Zman5146 Did Netanyahu and Israeli intelligence know about the impending attack from Hamas in advance, and let it happen just to have an excuse to invade and destroy Gaza?
😂😂😂
@@Zman5146 Piece of advice, you and the plastianians will stand infront of God in the judgment day, you will be hold accountable for every single word you said or typed againest Plastainians, you will not be able to say nobody told me, you have been told.
How do you repost
We are witnessing the crumbling of the last tabernacle. Netanyahu has brought the disapproval of many nations and peoples upon its country. Biblical resonance is not a coincidence
Has brought callamitty ....
NicoLa Sturgeon : " .... Boris Johnson .... Have brought callamitty ...." .
Can you repeat that in English
@@qbconnect2883 That was perfect English. What English do you speak?
Former Israeli military chief: Dan Halutz has said, ”Israel has lost the war against Hamas”.
“The promise to eliminate Hamas is a lie. A ground invasion is doomed to failure. This Gov. can’t defeat Hamas.” Benzion Sanders- IDF, special forces. Fought in Gaza against Hamas in 2014
“The crisis shows the failure of Israeli policy towards Palestinians. Eventually, the oppressed will rise up against their oppressor”. IDF Commanding General Solomon Brom.(ret)
Ilan Pappe the Jewish Professor “We are witnessing the end of Zionism.”
“Zionism has created rivers of blood.”
Zionism is not compatible with Judaism. Judaism is 3,000 yrs. old, Zionism is 150 yrs old. The Jews lived in peace with Arab’s throughout the Middle East before Zionism. Rabbi Dovid Weiss
“The State of Israel doesn’t represent all Jews.” Rabbi Feldman
The occupation is totally illegitimate!
Yeah it's 100% illegitimate on many levels.
How long was the U.S. in Afghanistan militarily? Did the Taliban disappear?
A lot of people agree with Annelle, what is happening to Palestinians is a shame to Humanity
Peace Keepers, Foods, Healthcare is it US Human's RIGHTS ????
Is Dr. Sheline acquainted with Cassidy Hutchinson? Possibly they could form an organization that recognizes individuals of moral valor. Well done, Dr.Sheline!
Plastinians have the right to resist the occupation .
Plastinians are under occupation and oppression of Israel since 1948 .
I pray ✝️✝️✝️ for justice for plastinians
She speaks for most Americans.
Israel's president, Isaac Herzog said
"It's an entire nation out there that is responsible. This rhetoric about civilians not aware, not involved, it's absolutely not true. They could've risen up, they could have fought against that evil regime," 😊😊😊😊لتن
Iszaack
How about you look at the full quote?
@@FBerg5646 Iszaack he Is not aware of what he says , he Is out of his minde .....
@@FBerg5646 he doesn t feel Well , he Is ill , Iszaack ....
So I guess you didn't see the actual speech or read the full quote. You've just taken the snipped version south africa presented.
Thank you Dr. Shelina.
GOVERNMENT WORK IS BENEATH THE BEST PEOPLE A SOCIETY HAS TO OFFER.
I have much respect for this lady and she should be protected bc many ppl are being threatened that speak up against israel
An eye opener to what is really going on.
Well done ma'am
Medium
Respect, if only our military had such honor!
Salute to Aaron and dr Annelle
1:47 We’re still doing this? Really?
Truth are coming out brave lady
Women have become stronger than men. Thank you for standing for the truth and for the people of Palestine who face persecution from israel everyday since 1948.
Big Respect to this lady who's had enough of this GENOCIDE that's on going against these innocent people 🙏
Respect
H is not a terrorist org under international law. Terrorist nomenclature has been used as a code word for "People We Don't Like"
Facts
What the fuck ? This CNN interviewer has no conscience.
Strength, or rather compassion to power.
A brave woman in a time of a cowardness by AIPEC slaves.
She’s a part of the herd . Bravery is standing up to the “ from the river to the sea” chanting bullies
@@dorianshadesofgray2981 No she is very brave, she could have followed the herd of democrats.. Palestine from the river to the sea. I agree with that statement. It does not mean kill the jews though.
@@munbruk well tell me what happens to all the Jews in Israel which exists between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Will they still be there?
@@dorianshadesofgray2981 They go back to where they came from. Or live under indigenous people rules.
@@dorianshadesofgray2981
Yes when we say from the river to the sea we meant they must.live under indiginous ppl rule.
Shame on US and Israel the Apartheid regim
At least some politicians have integrity. Well done.
Real human cannot see Genocide 😢
THANK FOR YOUR COURAGE Dr ANNELLE
*Thanks for your courage, Dr. ....
Wow surprised that CNN makes some little changes to approach this issue!
Way to go!
is he asking or answering???
I am glad to see sane Americans.
I pray everyday that there is a "have it both ways" solution. They gotta get a new Yasser Arafat yesterday 🙏🙏
Maybe with Tareq Azize , my late father persenelly knew Tareque Azize From Irak
And , Aleksander Haigue , Also , he claimed , maybe , under dementia ....
*every day
Praying doesn't work. Decisions and actions work.
It's not much, but better than nothing I suppose. Doubtful you could change the state (war) dept. from within.
Undoubtedblly
🤔🤔🤔 ( Gibson 1995 ) 🤔🤔🤔
😐 Svetozar ! Such word does not exist
😂😂😂 Sorry
Dr Sheline did/does amazing work for the Middle East, especially Yemen. A great loss to the Biden administration.
God bless you for your convictions. History will remember you kindly for not being complicit
Very proud of her 😊
Thank you
Meanwhile 2 billion more has been approved.
CNN: crickets chirping
She can say what she likes even if true nothing she says will be followed up. What needs to be remembered is that she's another good person to respect for calling out to do the human/right thing.
Thank you so very much for doing the right things ❤
who is now the terrorists, before october 7th occupying plastine, Gaze en west bank. occupyning Iraq, afganistan, fietnam, african countries en india, japan ????????
I agree ☝️ with her statement. All the federal workers need to follow her example. the real question 🙋 is how she got the job to begin with 😮
These are the kind of people we need in office not to quit-we need people with a heart and compassion and humanity in positions of power. We need to get rid of the lobbyist and the greed and all the corruption ASAP.
Thanks alot. ❤❤
*a lot
how ridiculous for cnn host asking her if hamas is also responsible for tens of thousands of people died by israel bombing. did you ask if ukraine actions responsible for war as well?
To keep saying their hiding behind human shield after seeing the bombing of 4 unarmed civilian is ridiculous
Why would she go to cnn.... Th3y aint helping
How else is everyone going to find out how virtuous she is ?
Her interview on Democracy Now was excellent. Very powerful.
In order for US to see , hear
@@user-wj4yk8ly1d i'm just saying there are better outlets that wont deviate her message
True agree, even the type of questions and its well-known CNN is an IDF propaganda machine. Fact, CNN questioning and reporting runs through Israel 1st.
It's easy to criticize. It's harder to lead.
What would she do?
What would she say to bb?
Use what leverage?
Can you imagine the outrage if she tried her approach?
Clearly you didn’t listen. She was also on Democracy Now. Maybe check that interview out if you need clarification. Israel is currently blocking humanitarian aid. That’s in violation of US law concerning countries that we fund for “military assistance.” So, stop or no more military aid. That’s what you tell Bibi. That’s the leverage. The outrage where? The rest of the world is outraged that we’re still “unconditionally” supporting. Not to mention, that the majority of Democrats and a growing number of Republicans in this country are, to put it mildly, “unhappy” with our funding a “plausible gcide.”
She’s a typical single childless woman who is a product of a political science university education. It’s all about empathy for all people except her own and our allies.
@@dorianshadesofgray2981Thanks, typical male incel.
Our government truly is in a difficult situation. But, if we don't follow our own laws then what? How can we expect anyone to respect us if we don't respect ourselves.
@lorigreen3828 our president is in a difficult position. Dammed if you do and Dammed if you don't