You can definitely hear Tobias gain more control with his voice and become more comfortable with his sound throughout the years. Some people would disagree, but I think that their newest album and performances are the best. They just keep getting better and better.
I could "disagree" since I don't love the more nasal approach that he has now, but I sill like it. Anyway, he still a great singer, although I think he's a better songwriter than a singer.
Agreeed. Theres not one song on prequelle i don’t like. Usually i always have 2-3 i skip even on metallica records and megadeth records whos my faves but ghosts prequelle i never skipped a song i think thats a masterpiece from start to finish
you can really start to notice the progress of Tobias' voice around Ritual, 2013 12:43 also, I just noticed, he started playing younger characters as he got older.
@@spicy_meatball862 its a really good concert (except the crowd). when i watch it i open the version with the hd video in a tab and this one in another tab. its really good but u have to get it to sync.
Its crazy to look at from then to today. How they began so small, and look at them now, its absolutely amazing. Luckily, the lineup still stands{2017-2022} with even a couple more members that have joined today as of their current shows for 2022 and i really hope it doesnt change, they are all so amazing and talented. From a small stage they began, to the biggest stage and audience, luv ghost
I dont wanna burst you bubble, but every member except for Tobias has changed since the start. The biggest change was in 2016, when all the current members was changed.
@@labbern i was and have been aware of 2016. So you arent potentially bursting my bubble lol. Ive been aware of it. The lineup was was talking about was the 2017-2022
@@labbern why focus on the negative tho tbh. Its ghost, gotta enjoy them at their best. Im not gonna get into a band and not educate myself on it so, Obviously i will, have been, and gonna educate myself on a band i find potential in.
@@delibat I wasnt trying to be negative. sorry. I was just reading your comment and telling you what I knew. I love all of Ghosts lineups. They are great!
It's amazing how far they've come. I know the ghouls changed over the years. But still, it's so cool watching them grow. Tobias Voice control is improving every time, amazing to listen to live. Thanks for the compilation 🖤🤘
it always made me emotional to watch Copia's development after watching the "chapters". not only that, though. Tobia's development as an artist is a delight to watch. He's awesome. thanks for the compilation, can't wait for the next one in a few years :))
22:30 Liseberg, I Remember this show 🥲🥲My dad and i Stood up against the Fence at the stage. and when he was dragged off we were so confused what was happening
Seeing a few people really hate their new stuff, and I guess it's because it deviates so much from their old work. Meanwhile I'm just here appreciating all of the eras, because there's a constant with the band from the beginning to now, and that's that their melodic progressions are very much of the same caliber. The change in sound, tone and mood from doom metal to a more glam-rock/metal kinda sound, follow suit with the new iterations of Papa Emeritus, but it's still Ghost. It makes sense to me. I will always be a fan of the Infestissumam era, but their newer stuff is so SO good too.
I was at the the show with Ben and Chris playing the guitars....it was like a Sisters of mercy show without Andrew singing...i still miss Martin and Simon though
Great video! Very well put together! I'm loving this new chapter in Ghost's journey. I saw them for the first time in February, on the Pre-Imperatour with Volbeat. I can't wait to see them again in September! Tobias Forge is really a genius. Watching this band grow and change is really neat!
Whomever create this video.... Excellent work. To my ear, the musicians who wrote and recorded their parts on Meliora were above and beyond the best players Tobias has had for songwriting. They added the most to Tobias's music. If the information here at 14:04 is correct, then that is the lineup that took them Mainstream. Linton Rubino and Mauro Rubino's parts are absolute perfection. Bring em back. Give them a small percentage of publishing. Well deserved. Guitars and solos are perfect.
This is pretty cool thanks for putting this together. Do you have links to the original videos? Specially the Elizabeth one. Also Martin Persner quit in July 2016. So he is still the one playing in the "From the Pinnacle to the pit" show you have there from the Carolina rebellion show you need to fix the line up in your titles.
You can definitely hear Tobias gain more control with his voice and become more comfortable with his sound throughout the years. Some people would disagree, but I think that their newest album and performances are the best. They just keep getting better and better.
I could "disagree" since I don't love the more nasal approach that he has now, but I sill like it. Anyway, he still a great singer, although I think he's a better songwriter than a singer.
1. Impera 2. Prequelle 3. Meliora 4. Opus Eponymous 5. Infestissumam at the moment
Agreeed. Theres not one song on prequelle i don’t like. Usually i always have 2-3 i skip even on metallica records and megadeth records whos my faves but ghosts prequelle i never skipped a song i think thats a masterpiece from start to finish
you can really start to notice the progress of Tobias' voice around Ritual, 2013 12:43
also, I just noticed, he started playing younger characters as he got older.
the audio is from ceremony and devotion. its overlayed. the real audio is here ruclips.net/video/HA_hBb2sKYE/видео.html
@@matmatmatamatvsjdjfh oh, thanks
@@spicy_meatball862 its a really good concert (except the crowd). when i watch it i open the version with the hd video in a tab and this one in another tab. its really good but u have to get it to sync.
@@matmatmatamatvsjdjfh Ok, I'll try that
Its crazy to look at from then to today. How they began so small, and look at them now, its absolutely amazing. Luckily, the lineup still stands{2017-2022} with even a couple more members that have joined today as of their current shows for 2022 and i really hope it doesnt change, they are all so amazing and talented. From a small stage they began, to the biggest stage and audience, luv ghost
I dont wanna burst you bubble, but every member except for Tobias has changed since the start. The biggest change was in 2016, when all the current members was changed.
@@labbern i was and have been aware of 2016. So you arent potentially bursting my bubble lol. Ive been aware of it. The lineup was was talking about was the 2017-2022
@@labbern why focus on the negative tho tbh. Its ghost, gotta enjoy them at their best. Im not gonna get into a band and not educate myself on it so, Obviously i will, have been, and gonna educate myself on a band i find potential in.
@@delibat I wasnt trying to be negative. sorry. I was just reading your comment and telling you what I knew. I love all of Ghosts lineups. They are great!
Same thing with Slipknot, performing in small theatre's to on a huge stage with probably the best stage setup I've ever seen, look it up.
respect to the creator finding all these memorial videos
Thank you, I appreciate it immensely
I forgot how AWESOME he belts out Elizabeth in the Papa III era
It's amazing how far they've come. I know the ghouls changed over the years. But still, it's so cool watching them grow.
Tobias Voice control is improving every time, amazing to listen to live. Thanks for the compilation 🖤🤘
Jokes on you, Papa Nihil plays the sax solo after his death as well :D
Martin, Simon, Mauro, (Henke and Martin H too) I miss you
it always made me emotional to watch Copia's development after watching the "chapters".
not only that, though. Tobia's development as an artist is a delight to watch. He's awesome.
thanks for the compilation, can't wait for the next one in a few years :))
Excellent compilation. Now only one is missing adding the Impera era💯
22:30 Liseberg, I Remember this show 🥲🥲My dad and i Stood up against the Fence at the stage. and when he was dragged off we were so confused what was happening
Seeing a few people really hate their new stuff, and I guess it's because it deviates so much from their old work. Meanwhile I'm just here appreciating all of the eras, because there's a constant with the band from the beginning to now, and that's that their melodic progressions are very much of the same caliber. The change in sound, tone and mood from doom metal to a more glam-rock/metal kinda sound, follow suit with the new iterations of Papa Emeritus, but it's still Ghost. It makes sense to me.
I will always be a fan of the Infestissumam era, but their newer stuff is so SO good too.
Same
I was at the the show with Ben and Chris playing the guitars....it was like a Sisters of mercy show without Andrew singing...i still miss Martin and Simon though
Great video! Very well put together! I'm loving this new chapter in Ghost's journey. I saw them for the first time in February, on the Pre-Imperatour with Volbeat. I can't wait to see them again in September! Tobias Forge is really a genius. Watching this band grow and change is really neat!
They were in my country ten years ago in Rock in Rio. I hope they appear again here!!
Whomever create this video.... Excellent work. To my ear, the musicians who wrote and recorded their parts on Meliora were above and beyond the best players Tobias has had for songwriting. They added the most to Tobias's music. If the information here at 14:04 is correct, then that is the lineup that took them Mainstream. Linton Rubino and Mauro Rubino's parts are absolute perfection. Bring em back. Give them a small percentage of publishing. Well deserved. Guitars and solos are perfect.
I really enjoyed this!!! Great to see how they evolved but they were always a great live band. Tobias is no dummy!!
Wow thank you so much for this! It was perfect 🤩
I miss Papa Emeritus I to perform again.
Same! He's my favourite papa along with my favourite Ghost era
Papa Emeritus III , the best !
Tobias, brilliant, I love you so much!
I wish they still played Genesis
Great video! Thank you for your work :)
Brilliant video...thanks !!
great video, now update to 2022 shows
Maybe in a few years more
Great video.
This is pretty cool thanks for putting this together. Do you have links to the original videos? Specially the Elizabeth one. Also Martin Persner quit in July 2016. So he is still the one playing in the "From the Pinnacle to the pit" show you have there from the Carolina rebellion show you need to fix the line up in your titles.
ruclips.net/video/0TJzUI7QDXI/видео.html That's the Elizabeth video from Hellfest 2011
Thanks for pointing that out, I didn't notice that ;
Muito bom
Alpha & Omega the best guitarrist
Aksel was an amazing drummer too! Loved the open handed style he had
28:13 "NO MANCHES" lmao
My father was Papa , and his father was Papa and his father and his father's father and his father's father, father ...
Father.
2013 show rock in rio no Brasil ,abriu pro Metallica amei a banda des da primeira vez.
Linton Rubino wasnt in the band in 2015. He quit after Infestissumam and Henrik Palm joined in 2015 with Meliora.
The first Namelles Ghouls are Nazguls! 😂😂
Their best look imo, just after Meliora era
Papa II still the best!
do you have the link for copias first full show?
Sadly the footage I used seems to he deleted from YT :(
Has uno de Rammstein
I now a lot of this content came from phones, but they have become a plague on live music
Not a plague at all.
24 mins in was faith not monstrance clock
It's actually Spirit haha
wir denken nach :) 6 .. plus minus null