What If You Explode a Blackhole?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 ноя 2017
- You can buy Universe Sandbox 2 game here: amzn.to/2yJqwU6
Hello and welcome to What Da Math!
In this video, we will talk about exploding blackholes.
Support this channel on Patreon to help me make this a full time job:
/ whatdamath
Space Engine is available for free here: spaceengine.org
Enjoy and please subscribe.
Twitter: / whatdamath
Facebook: / whatdamath
Twitch: / whatdamath
Bitcoins to spare? Donate them here to help this channel grow!
1GFiTKxWyEjAjZv4vsNtWTUmL53HgXBuvu 
Игры
Hello wonderful anton this is person here
I watched a physics video that said if you could make a black hole spin fast enough you could technically overpower the gravity and get the black hole to explode.
This is I want to know
But wouldn’t it need to spin faster than light for that?
@@theakiwar9118 unlogic thing about that is the black hole is actually just a dot. the black thing is the just the event horizon. so if you spin a dot, you cant make a angular momentum, because diameter of singularity is zero.
@@tonnymontana2027 that's what I'd think
Actually likely most black holes in the universe are likely ringularity which have crazy weird effects other than just absorbing matter but it's believed most black holes should be ringularitys because a lot of stars rotate an when stars implode into themselves they spin faster like a figure skater of hurricane thus making most black holes or singularities More ring like I recommended in a nutshell video on the topic.
I shoud be sleeping right now
But no space needs me
Awayyyyyyy
CriticleEcoKebab I don’t know what you mean
cringe
this lately I've fallen asleep to these videos
Knock knock... what happens if you explode Uranus :D
M. Fakhrurrazzaq Hadi he should be sleeping right now
BLACK HOLE SUN WON'T YOU COME
AND WASH AWAY THE RAIN
BLACK HOLE SUN WON'T YOU COME, WON'T YOU COME
In my eyes, indisposed
In disguises no one knows
Hides the face, lies the snake
The sun in my disgrace
Boiling heat, summer stench
Neath the black the sky looks dead
Call my name through the cream
And I'll hear you scream again...
Oh my goodness i love everyone in this comment chain
My thoughts exactly!
Thats my everyday struggle, watch Anton at 2 o'clock at night, and be dying in college the next day, or go to sleep. Somehow i always end up watching like 5videos
Word for word that's my life story right now. Get through my college classes, play games when i can, watch Anton while I calm down for sleep until 2 or 3am, wake up and be tired the next day. Rinse and repeat
i do the same exact think but instead of school its work 👎i usually pick a playlist of his usually KSP and try to go to sleep but i end up watching 10 episodes or so
I watch whenever I can, I watch this guy cause he knows his stuff, I’m a USAF pilot, only 21 years old, didn’t know of this guy since like 5 days when a video came up in recommended when I was showing my gf some rocket launch videos :P
always I got notifacations from you when im drunk!
The Low Armor ...
why even comment if you just put dots...seems like a waste of space and time.
Thats my secret Captain... I'm always drunk
Very fitting, he's high, you're drunk.
Black Hole Sun that is a Soundgarden song.
Great video as always, Anton. Space is so cool!
Wusaaaaaaaaaaap
Need more black hole vids. I’m genuinely into them.
Each of those fragments has a screaming visage of General Zod in it as well ...
114k, damn litterally yesterday I remember you being at 85k subs
Congratulations. You just created another universe!
If a civilization had the ability to detonate a black hole and the fragments of the hole went supernova themselves, that could be an insane way to destroy a galaxy.
Wouldnt have enough power by far
@@fiiral5870 but if they did
I have a space game called Weird Worlds: Return to Infinite Space, that has a device that "collapses space to a lower energy state" everything within 5 light years radius of activation. It's called a Limited Volume Collapser and everything- stars, planets, even black holes get sucked into it leaving empty space behind. It's very handy to defend the galaxy from baddies that can't be stopped in battle. It even has mods that emulate SF movies and TV shows.
Anton I love your videos so keep going!
I would assume that if you "exploded" a black hole, you would be converting all of the mass into energy. I will use units of Type 1a supernovae here because it is extremely hard to visualize some of these numbers if you don't.
A Type 1a supernova is a 1-2e+44 J explosion (for those of you who don't know whenever you see an "e" in a calculation, that means 10^[the following number]. For example 1e+44 means 10^44). That is equal to one trillion trillion Tsar Bomba, which is the largest nuclear weapon ever created at 100 megatons, or ~4.2e+17 J.
So I take the entire mass of the sun, convert it to energy via E = mc^2, and I get (hideous laughter) ~1.8e+47 J, which is ~1800 supernovae, or 180 hypernovae. Multiply this number by however many solar masses your black hole has. For example if you exploded Saggitarius A*, you get 774 million supernovae. That's a hell of a lot of energy! There really aren't any real world examples to compare that to. The only explosion that is larger than a hypernova is the Big Bang itself, and even these explosions I've made here come nowhere close to the Big Bang. After all, the Big Bang was an explosion of time and space, as well as all the energy that exists and ever will exist in the universe.
Excuse me, I commented on the comment of the idea explaining it is not possible, but you actually do a video. WOW
Please tell us your PC specs!
I've always wondered if at one time in previous rendition of our own universe, that the Primordial Atom that gave birth to the big bang and our universe. In the previous universe, most of the black holes came together to form that Primordial Atom. It became so massive that it could no longer contain all that energy within it, and of course exploded, which we call the Big Bang.
I am not a mathematician, but I have to believe that a black hole can only retain its own continuity to a certain point, at which time, something has to give. Super massive stars are like that, and go nova or supernova when the gravity/nuclear balance fails. Forgive me, to those who are experts on this subject. I am not an expert, but always felt that a black hole just cannot exist forever, continuing to gain mass, without something failing just like a super massive star.
I haven't a clue as to how long this process takes, but I am guessing that our own universes current lifetime is just a fraction of the time it takes for all those black holes to eventually COALESCE, and become critical.
I've always wished that someone who is a mathematical genius would take on this problem to see if this is possible. Maybe our vision of how things work, and of course, our mathematical models aren't correct, and a new set of rules needs to be worked. I do believe we know next to nothing of how our universe works. Many of our own previous mathematical models are no longer valid, based on new discoveries, or have had to be modified in order for things to work as we see them, and I feel things will change dramatically with each new discovery.
""when a black hole becomes big enough the stuff starts to clip inside each other, like in video games, and boooom""
Ends up looking like a nebula.
Good vid I sub and turn post notif you are the best universe sandbox RUclipsR EVER!!! And space engine
What happens when 2 relatively small black holes collide. Both moving at 99% speed of light but at opposite directions. Will the energy generated be enough to negate their immense gravities. And what would happen if this event happens to occur close to the solar system.
that a question no one can answer we need to see t irl to know what will follow
What are the minimum specs for this? I mean I have a Ryzen 7 1800X and a 1080Ti from Gigabyte so I’m not afraid of running anything, but just out of curiosity, looks like a fun thing to play around in
Such an awesome channel!
If you had a large body just shy of a black hole and it was moving 5% the speed of light and hit the small black hole dead on would it explode the black hole?
How did you edit there
A quick stupid question: When matter gets near a black hole, does it get sucked in an instant or does it take time?
By sucked in, I assume you mean falling below the event horizon, and assume the black hole is big enough that tidal forces don't play a huge role at the event horizon.
For something falling into the black hole, that could happen very quickly, or more slowly. It depends. If you started stationary, you'd pass that point very quickly. You'd be moving essentially at the speed of light past that point (though not through space, you are being carried along with space which is moving downward). You could theoretically thrust away from the black hole, and cross the event horizon quite slowly. Once you cross it, though, there's no getting out. Either way, you wouldn't really notice it when it does happen.
If you're watching an object falling into the event horizon, basically, it takes forever. The object never quite makes it. it'll slow down, eventually disappearing only because of the extreme red shift, but it will only cross the event horizon after infinite time, and any events below the horizon never happen.
That's a really good question, and to be honest, I'm not entirely sure of the answer.
However, there is a phrase my mind throws up whenever I ponder the question: the holographic principle. The solution sounds very similar to this potential solution to the information paradox.
According to the holographic principle, information falling into a black hole is not lost because it is encoded on the event horizon, and later carried away by hawking radiation. This sounds weird, because the object still falls in, so isn't that copying the information? Does this violate the no cloning theorem?
This is, once again, a matter of perspective. Remember, from our perspective outside the black hole, events within the event horizon will never happen, even after infinite time. This isn't just a visibility issue, it's a real phenomenon. A black hole is what you get when you delete entire events from the universe. Let it really sink in: from the outside, talking about events inside a black hole is purely theoretical, because they never happen.
But, black holes tend to be spherical, no matter how the matter falls in. If we threw a bunch of stuff into a black hole from one direction, we wouldn't expect a bulge in the event horizon on that side as the stuff piled up, frozen in time just before crossing.
What happens, according to the holographic principle, is that in addition to the red shift, an object from our perspective starts to smear out over the event horizon. It's weird, and complicated, more complicated than I can understand, but think of this like the time dilation: real, but also a matter of perspective. The object falling in doesn't experience this smear, but it is very, very real for outside observers.
That's how the event horizon would grow. Things falling in would get smeared out, and red shifted until they are emitting no light, and voila, you have a perfectly black, symmetrical event horizon. When hawking radiation occurs, the particle outside the event horizon sees this information smeared out, because it's outside the event horizon, and has the chance to carry it away.
Maybe the matter it grows is from Billions of billions years?
I can answer that in a very simple way. Not sure why Isobel wanted to take the longer route but at least he said he's not entirely sure which is a good thing.
The simple answer is, it doesn't take an infinite amount of time. Time is relative to whatever reference frame you are in. Outside of the singularity you would see an object crossing the event horizon freeze and just basically stay in the same position forever (from your reference frame). For the object's reference frame, YOU would freeze in place forever while it continues down to the singularity. The amount of time it takes can easily be calculated based on the velocity of the object after crossing the event horizon and the distance between the physical singularity and the event horizon. You need to remember.. that with relativity, just because something appears one way to you, doesn't mean that it's the same for what you're looking at.
But this is just all a moot point anyways seeing as anything that has mass or carries information cannot overcome causality and all matter is crushed beyond its basic atomic structure down to its schwarzschild radius before being added to the total mass of the black hole.
Edit: I'm purposely ignoring a few things like tidal forces etc.. just for the sake of argument and to play the devil's advocate. The general concept is still the same.
I think the objection was that, if it takes an infinite amount of time to cross the event horizon to an outside observer, how do we observe the event horizon grow? Sure, to the singularity and the object, the crossing and impact with the singularity occur, but to those outside, they do not, yet we can observe a black hole which has grown by accretion.
Do you have a guide on using universe sandbox?
It's like a crude facsimile of the big bang.
AWESOME!!
What would happen if you placed a white hole next to a black hole (both having same mass)? Would they merge or kick each other out? Annihilate or just stay there in equilibrium?
How can you explode something that light can't escape? Wouldn't the velocity of the explosion have to move faster than the speed of light otherwise its an implosion...
Yes, this makes no sense.
what game is that called?
That was beautiful!
Hmm, exploding a black hole would take out the entire galaxy, because if you were to crush a Boeing 747 into a tiny black hole, it would evaporate in a second and take out the entire earth. So if you were to explode a black hole with a mass of one sun, it should take out a big part of the galaxy
hi anton, what if, you explode the black hole sun, then let it expand a bit, then, halt all velocities, would you get the black hole sun again?
Can you explain different types of plasma and can it be used?
I tried to convert all fragments into full body on my own computer and the game crashes.
Use your graphics card for calculations, I think you can add this somewhere in the files
What happens when you explode a blachole ??
Intro comes in 0:12 ...
Now that's physics we are talking bout!
Unless there's a way to create infinite force, black holes cannot explode. Their mass is trapped. This might be eye-catching to watch, but it can't resemble anything that occurs in the real world.
What would Happen, if a Neutron Star was about to explode, and it Collided with our sun? How many Planets would it affect and how far would it stretch out too?
Immagining a Black Hole as something slowly (from outside the event orizon) imploding up to the plank limit and then exploding outward, what kind of matter would be formed in such an explosion?
This is One of the coolest thing I've seen! I think that If out Sun's core is radiation plasma(radiation are particles from crushed atoms), then a Black hole can only contain particles that ar crushed billions times harder and became billions times smaller than electrons or Maine even quarks and billions times deadlier due to pressure, so I Guess Those particles should vibrate billions Times faster.
how to create a beautiful adn unique nebua ...
nice video mate
Anton , invest in a powerful cpu . You can write it off for your taxes and create new content not many can witness.
What are your PC specs ?
the game in the description is universe sandbox not universe sandbox 2 (it shows)
Universe Sandbox
*2008*
*Explore In RUclips Gaming*
(I'm not talking about the link to amazon, also you can get it on STEEEEAM)
I think so small black hole will evaporate very fast // there must be a button size for these objects
how come we don't get dark matter, which is what happened in a different video of anton's?
Hey, I wanna see what happens if you make a silicate star (just like you've made a water one), or at least explain us better why a silicate-based gas giant is possible (why it works like a gas). Also why silicate will absorb all the carbon from the atmosphere in 1 billion years when the Sun is 10% brighter and make photosynthesis impossible.
An additional video idea is what happens if you add a Venus atmosphere worth of hydrogen to Venus, to Earth and to Mars. According to the Wikipedia article on terraforming Venus, on Venus it could, in real life, make the very hot, very pressurized carbon dioxide become graphite and water by the Bosch reaction (the same is not true for the carbon dioxide on Earth and Mars, thankfully). The Bosch reaction technically needs more heat than the one present in Venus, but it's easy to heat it up further in Universe Sandbox 2, and it might also prove easier with the planet's more dense atmosphere. It needs metals dispersed in the atmosphere as well, though. I doubt the game would simulate any of this but you might try demonstrating some, perhaps?
You'd need a lot of Ammonium Nitrate - about the size of 1000 suns ... and just to lite it off, toss in a sun.
A small black hole exploding would be one of the least harmful things on the universe
I'm guessing that you don't believe the singularity is some sort of super dense fluid that will become particle like projectiles upon "Exploding"? And that this is merely a computer game
so a black hole explosion is like a nova or a mini supernova but from a black hole
Version 15: Large = Gas planets flying from 3 to 12 millions the speed of light. Larger = some FTL stars.
Maybe really cpu intensive, but worth it. That is beautiful.
Will this happen to our blackholes in gazillion years, when our universe will blackout totally? Hard to imagine
I was thinking about the fact of black holes exploding because Hawking radiation.
I SUBSCRIBED AND LIKED
What's your specs?
best title ever
Should it not implode ? By the pull ?
what happens if there were two black holes on a collision course. Let's call it object A and Object B. Lets say there is an object C for reference that is stationary relative to the two black holes. Object A and B are each moving at half the speed of light relative to Object C. Object A, relative to Object B is moving at the speed of light and vis versa. What would result from such a collision?
There are at least 3 errors in this question.
1. A & B are moving rel to each other; yet you posit C stationary rel to both of them. This is, of course, impossible.
2. Right after saying that C is stationary rel to A & B, you now say they are both moving at ½c rel to C.
[I'm guessing you really meant that A & B are of equal mass, and that C is stationary rel to their center-of-momentum, so that they can both be going ½c rel to C, in opposite directions, toward each other.]
3. Finally, you say that A & B are moving at c rel to each other. Relativistic velocities don't add by simple addition. Instead,
v₁₂ = [v₁ + v₂]/[1 + v₁v₂/c²]
That is, taking β = v/c = the fraction of c that v is,
β₁₂ = [β₁ + β₂]/[1 + β₁β₂]
So when β₁= β₂= ½ , β₁₂= (½ + ½)/(1 + ¼) = ⅘
Which means that each black hole (BH) is moving at four-fifths the speed of light relative to the other.
And the result of such a collision would be a lot like the one announced in early 2016, from observations in Sep 2015 at LIGO. A boatload of gravitational radiation spreads out in all directions, and the collision product settles down as a BH of a bit less than the sum of the masses of A & B, because some of their total mass was radiated away.
Thank you... some actual coherent thought and real mathematics. Now.. if you could only teach Anton this =)
Black hole cannot explode but it can implode in my opinion...
How would one ever explode? Float a bunch of TNT in there?
Could be how part of our universe was created. (:
Big bang 😊
Better yet..what happens when two black holes collide?...future video idea possibly?
The result is a singular black hole with a mass just slightly smaller than the combined total of the 2 you started with. The missing mass is converted into energy that was released via gamma radiation and gravitational waves.
Cool bro i like it
Interestingly the simulator makes their speed even faster than speed of light.
ad a video that what happends when a two black holes collide
Of course, you can not explode a black hole. All the explosive energy of any explosion would be absorbed by the hole
Just throwing it out there that this may be the way the big bang happened. Imagine the universe is on an infinite cycle where big bang happens, things expand until eventually gravity pulls it all together into one big black hole which then explodes yet again.
Instead of energy particles, wouldnt the resultant of a BH explosion be millions of BHs?
Well, You don't get it.! Black holes are not more special than the sun except ammount of mass. It's about how aroma and subatomic particles work. A Black hole becomes a Black hole when the mass is enough to increase the gravity soo much that the light can't escape and we cannot see them. Any sort of matter can become a Black hole If You have enough so that Those aroma from above crush the arome from Bellow and all fall there getting shreded into lesser particles. For example, If You have a big stone chunk near the solar system IT can become a sun then a Black hole If You add more matter or mass!
WHAAAAA????? He doesn't tell us exactly HOW we could "explode" a black hole!!! It eats everything you throw at it....
What happens if a sun fragment hits a planet
My problems with watching Anton’s vids: I always fall asleep before it ends
Can you explode Ton 618?
it looks like nebula :)
I need some space says all the planets
the game representing its idea of "the big bang"? Maybe you just accidentally found the true origin of the known universe lol
SyD6_7 holy shit that might be it!
Actually, its a common idea. The idea origins in the universe expanding quicker than the speed of light and a black hole having an escape velocity of (more than, probably, no one knows) the speed of light would mean, that a black hole could be the origin of the universe.
Well, there is a theory that it is cyclic, that entropy eventually pulls everything into Black holes, and then all those Black Holes combines to create a mega Black Hole, which then explodes.
The downside to this is (a) it doesn't _really_ explain expansion as observed and (b) it _still_ doesn't answer the question of where all that mass came from in the first place.....
PRDibble, "it still doesn't answer the question of where all that mass came from in the first place". That's where the stupid shit from all of the religions comes from. :( There has to be another layer, something so big and important.. has to.. Something similar that we call dimensions, but yet somehow understood completely differently. In any case, time will tell. Always.
I always thought so. If a black hole is basicly a singularity, why not the singularity that emerged as the big bang should not be a black hole? Hell even black holes could be the source or the most homogenic face of whole existince.
Hello
Who would dislike this!
People who realize that 1. This program is not, by any means, a realistic representation of the physics involved with what Anton is trying to describe. 2. People who know that Anton really has almost no clue at all what he's talking about and absolutely has no formal education in relativistic physics. And 3. People who see most of his videos to be EXTREMELY misinformed and really don't like the idea of others going around spreading false information and creating a new generation of people ignorant of reality.
Has literally no one commented this yet?Black hole Sun Won't You Come And wash away the Rain.
It's a song.
Call it a strangelet planet
I am honestly scared to know what happens if a black hole actually does explode. If that much mass is released at once, God knows what will happen or how big the explosion could be.
AzurezEpic if it's a supermassive black hole, it might create some stars
But space is vast as shit, not much would happen to anything
Nothing happens. They can't explode. Just based on the physics involved with them, it is literally impossible for any outward explosive force of energy to have an escape velocity greater than causality.
The lifecycle (in years) has so many zeroes in it, only the AI robots would ever have to worry about such.
But they do explode after they bleed off the mass requirement to sustain the event horizon...contrary so some people’s proclamations.
As such it's currently only a theory and not substantiated by any evidence. For you to say "they do explode" is nothing more than a guess at multiple possible ends to the life of a black hole.
Drawing from a dry well on that comment. Physicists at IIT in Haifa created acoustic black holes and observed phonons radiating from the event horizon. This is experimental proof that follows the mathematical modeling.
And I don’t know if I like the tone of a theoretical scientist that has “researched relativistic physics for decades,” which deals with the THEORY OF RELATIVITY, and all the sudden becomes an experimental physicist when it becomes convenient in a RUclips battle.
You cannot win here. It is an exercise in futility to make the attempt.
Fun.
*What happens when a star explode next to a black hole?*
a lot of suck
*super succ*
Simon Senaviev a good long suck 😂
the fragments will be sucked in
Nom
Technically, you can't explode a black hole, because the laws of physics in there is not the same, and exploding it in our laws, may mean, something else in it's law
0:12 Am I the only one who sees a 3DS screen in the background?
I have seen on a old documentary that a black hole explosion could cause a new bang if it was not anymore star in the universe.
finally i can fully utilize my core i9 and titan Xp xDD JK
Stellar cores
Dark matter and energy.. solved.
Um 😐, that’s impossible!
Explode Ton
Try making sun planet liveible
Old Rusty Banana you can't it isn't a planet they're gases
Old Rusty Banana and also liveible isn't a word so you should have said "habitable"
Adolf Caillou The Great He managed to make the sun habitle so how come he couldn't do it with the gases
Or habitable sorry ;)
Mfw no hawking radiation
But how can a black hole explode?
It can't. There is nothing in the universe strong enough to rip apart a black hole.
When he said "Black Hole Sun," It reminded me that Chris Cornell is gone. :(