Hyderabad & Integration of India || Deccan Dialogues 06 || Parakala Prabhakar & Mohan Guruswamy ||

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
  • Hyderabad posed a difficult challenge in India's integration process. Most of the princely states joined India without much difficulty. But the process was not merely territorial. It is administrative, political, and economic as well. The episode discusses the process and challenges posed by bringing the erstwhile princely states into India Union and forging a modern Republic.

Комментарии • 85

  • @merabharatmahan1374
    @merabharatmahan1374 Год назад +8

    We are terribly missing your Midweek Matters. Please continue your wonderful insights on issues of the country @Mr. Prabhakar

  • @pc611
    @pc611 2 года назад +8

    I can't imagine such critical public debate on any mass media platform ,sadly most people care less ,about what is really happening to the freedom our freedom fighters gave us..

  • @manmadhareddy7164
    @manmadhareddy7164 Год назад +6

    Parakala garu ... You are one among the leading intellectuals of the country ... Your talks ,besides being intellectual , thought provoking , meaningful , enlightening ... Why don't you resume your RUclips talks ..!

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @saineerajkalizham341
    @saineerajkalizham341 5 месяцев назад +1

    Prabhakar sir is very wise man. He has great intellect and outstanding depth of knowledge in social, economic concepts. Great watch for me.

  • @hopefulindia8533
    @hopefulindia8533 Год назад +4

    How I miss midweek matters!!

  • @Anon999-qk3ue
    @Anon999-qk3ue Год назад +2

    Sir we miss you very much, please come back to do Midweek Matters again your analysis is second to none

  • @muditjain8784
    @muditjain8784 2 года назад +4

    Hyderabad is great place for market research on test marketing of products which means it captures the centrality of India

  • @subramaniiyer3801
    @subramaniiyer3801 6 месяцев назад +1

    Simple beautiful intelligent speaking looking and presentation by both speaker's.

  • @subramaniiyer3801
    @subramaniiyer3801 6 месяцев назад +1

    Superb speeches and presentation.

  • @jagdeeshah5543
    @jagdeeshah5543 5 месяцев назад +1

    Sir, you are close to Mother earth than Madame...👍👍👍👌

  • @devanshutrivedi7577
    @devanshutrivedi7577 Год назад +1

    Indians especially the youth MUST watch this and such debates...

  • @kiranraavi4240
    @kiranraavi4240 Год назад +1

    Sir we miss you dearly. You were a voice of reason and honesty. Because of you we could see real analysis beyond only narrative

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @tiglathpileser3329
    @tiglathpileser3329 Год назад +3

    Good afternoon sir,
    I am reading your book ' The crooked timber of new india' . It's a magnificent book.
    We are living in dark times. Wish there were more people like you around, to light a beacon of hope.
    I honestly wonder about the spiritual effects of all this toxicity, hatred, anger and other negative emotions we are exposed to 24*7 through the media.

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @sambasivaraoanne8609
    @sambasivaraoanne8609 Месяц назад

    Your comments are very educative and very informative. I got all documents and books on integrations of states india. Opinion polu orginal book..who saved integrations of india not patel nor nehru. Vp menon saved the entire india

  • @yesbhadra6696
    @yesbhadra6696 Год назад +5

    Hey Tamil bro settler of Hyderabad, Mohan Guruswamy, it is Liberation of Hyderabad, whether you agree or not, reason being, people were liberated by the Communists and later by the Govt of India, and then it was integrated into India. It was first liberated, and then it was integrated. Junagadh was not liberated, it was just integrated. Kalvakuntla had once said India forcefully occupied Hyderabad. Telangana Rebellion is for what, was it for liberation or integration, it was for liberation. Occupation by India was for liberation and integration. Dont believe this TRS falthu chemcha Mohan Guruswamy.

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @krpa_chandrukrishnaswamy5020
    @krpa_chandrukrishnaswamy5020 2 месяца назад

    Mysore was far more advanced than all other princely states in terms of democracy, income, advancement of science and technology.
    The privy purse given to the Mysore Maharaja was the highest.

  • @tspscgeek
    @tspscgeek Год назад +2

    I don't understand why these people are called intellectuals.
    They carry certain agenda and present some kind of narrative distorting the actuals.
    The people who laid their lifes struggling would be ashamed of these people.
    Dasarathi Rangacharya wrote about this in 1960s,1970s that certain people are creating new narrative painting nizam as ideal and erstwhile Hyderabad state as the best.
    Nizams rule was despotic religiously oppressive, with no freedom, the kind of oppression from which still Telangana people didn't come out

  • @krpa_chandrukrishnaswamy5020
    @krpa_chandrukrishnaswamy5020 Месяц назад

    There is an interesting photo in the Bardoli Sathyagrah centre. In the photo, all the chief ministers are all sitting and the Central ministers are standing behind.
    It is clear from the picture that state chief ministers are calling the shots

  • @surendrabarsode8959
    @surendrabarsode8959 2 года назад +1

    Good discussion. In next 25 years, south is going to drift away from north and we have ensure that it does not lead to fissiparous tendencies. So decentralization is going to be a big challenge for the country. On one hand, with GST, banking, finance, various welfare measures, common markets etc., we are integrating but politically, we are observing the opposite trend. So either BJP or Congress as one national party dominates or we have autonomy for the states. Going to be quite tough for us.

    • @rakadus
      @rakadus Год назад

      Seeds of divisive thoughts sown in one person's mind. Let's talk of futuristic solution instead of wallowing in the past. Technology led governance

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @sunderrajanklikar2613
    @sunderrajanklikar2613 5 месяцев назад

    Articulating of Indian independence movement started decisively after crushing of 1857 revolt, which was articulation of princely states Kingdom association to throw out British. So British officer A O Hume articulated to build socio-political oligarchic structured corporate society's diaspora to spread accross the world by enslaved princely states beurocratic structure by implementing colonial sociology on them. Thus 1885 Congress was created.

  • @promilakarpal6609
    @promilakarpal6609 2 года назад +1

    Decentralization of power is very important in a country like ours otherwise it would lose all democratic values if at all we have some of them still left

  • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
    @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 5 месяцев назад

    Unique Country or Unique State

  • @lokeshkamblesfi9440
    @lokeshkamblesfi9440 2 года назад +1

    good information

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
    @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 7 месяцев назад

    TODAY IN TAMILNADU
    RULLING PARTY PRAISE YOU
    ON HIS OFFICIAL PAPER

  • @Dog_Car_2468
    @Dog_Car_2468 4 месяца назад +1

    I agree Parakala is a dangerous man ! A traitor actually!

  • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
    @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 5 месяцев назад

    North India Population 110 கோடி
    South India Population. 30 கோடி
    வட இந்தியா மக்கள்தொகை 110 Cros
    தென்னிந்தியா மக்கள்தொகை 30 Cros
    ஒட்டுமொத்த INDIA POPULATION 140 கோடி

  • @tspscgeek
    @tspscgeek Год назад +1

    In the pursuit of political and personal ambitions these people lose common sense.
    Don't take them seriously

  • @ricardoafonso7563
    @ricardoafonso7563 2 года назад +1

    .
    So the Empire was 40 percent of the SubContinent47
    ..

  • @jrcr4004
    @jrcr4004 10 месяцев назад

    No videos?

  • @peacelover5984
    @peacelover5984 Год назад

    Why are you not making videos anymore 😢, did you got told off by your better half 😢😢

  • @mallika96p
    @mallika96p Год назад

    Missing your take on the jee-20 . Please come back. Also your literary channel

    • @chinthapublishersofficial
      @chinthapublishersofficial 10 месяцев назад

      Speech Of Parakala Prabhakal @ KLIBF in KERALA ruclips.net/video/_hP3kPZwDpc/видео.html

  • @jrcr4004
    @jrcr4004 Год назад

    Where are you.

  • @MysteriesDiamond
    @MysteriesDiamond Год назад

    Where are you Sir......

  • @yesbhadra6696
    @yesbhadra6696 Год назад

    A feudal lord Dora became CM and his son is dreaming about becoming the PM of India

  • @jas6806
    @jas6806 2 года назад

    why are names of comments are being changed?

  • @mchandrahasa1362
    @mchandrahasa1362 Год назад +2

    Why you have stopped wid week matter Sir?. To prevent embarrassment to union minister and Government

  • @ratnakumari9872
    @ratnakumari9872 Год назад

    Happy birthday Sir 💐🙏

    • @parakalaprabhakar
      @parakalaprabhakar  Год назад

      Thank you 🙏🏽

    • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
      @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 7 месяцев назад

      ​@@parakalaprabhakar
      Yesterday and TODAY IN TAMILNADU
      RULLING PARTY PRAISE YOU
      ON HIS OFFICIAL PAPER
      Save india From Your Wife
      Tamilnadu Hugely affected
      By your wife
      YOUR WIFE SPEAK LOT OF
      VERY BUDGET LIES
      IN ALL BUDGET

    • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
      @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@parakalaprabhakar
      இன்னும் இரண்டாயிரம்
      வருஷம் ஆனாலும்
      INDIAN UNIONல்ல
      ஓற்றை உணவு
      ஓற்றை உடை
      ஓற்றை மொழி
      ஓற்றை இனம்
      ஓற்றை கலாச்சாரம்
      ஒற்றை CLIMATE
      ஓற்றை தன்மை
      ஓற்றை Landscape
      ஓற்றை வளர்ச்சி
      என்பது INDIAN UNIONல்ல
      சாத்தியம் இல்லை.

    • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
      @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@parakalaprabhakar
      North India Population 110 கோடி
      South India Population. 30 கோடி
      வட இந்தியா மக்கள்தொகை 110 Cros
      தென்னிந்தியா மக்கள்தொகை 30 Cros
      ஒட்டுமொத்த INDIA POPULATION 140 கோடி

  • @jayabharathibl
    @jayabharathibl 7 месяцев назад

    Why don't you resume your RUclips talks ..!

  • @dhindsadhindsa3612
    @dhindsadhindsa3612 11 месяцев назад

    I just wonder how you guys managed to live together with strong opposite mindset.

  • @jas6806
    @jas6806 2 года назад +1

    indian states will dump GST and cut of the oxygen to the center .delhi will have to rely on income tax thus will have incentive to create jobs not consumption.

  • @satyapampana4641
    @satyapampana4641 4 месяца назад +4

    It's my humble request to all , Don't listen Parakala talks. He dumped so many parties and good people. His wife works for BJP and he talks completely against all developments done by current government. His narratives and thoughts are ver y dangerous to Country.

    • @kevinraj1277
      @kevinraj1277 4 месяца назад

      😂😂😂

    • @inzi27
      @inzi27 4 месяца назад +2

      counter his points logically rather than proclaiming to cancel him.

    • @krishnaraocolluru5333
      @krishnaraocolluru5333 4 месяца назад

      An intelligent, analytical, different opinion from that of the Establishment is always a dire necessity in a democracy. Don’t brush it aside simply because it is a ‘husband’s’ opinion. Prabhakar’s opinions are that way, very relevant. If you perceive ‘dissent’ as ‘dangerous’, that, I would say is the beginning of dictatorial trends.

    • @pushparajshetty6754
      @pushparajshetty6754 3 месяца назад

      It's not new to us, it's our Hindu culture ,we saw Haisiyat film hero Jitendra was the union leader and Jaya Prada was employer. 😂😂😂

    • @irascibleinfant3509
      @irascibleinfant3509 3 месяца назад

      Then ask Nirmala to Divorce him and put him behind bars.. is your government so incapable that it can't even such a terrible person who is speaking "lies"(according to you) about them???

  • @madhankorapati
    @madhankorapati Год назад

    Sir metho okkasari matladali please sir
    Chala urgent help kavali sir

  • @radhakrishnamuli3356
    @radhakrishnamuli3356 2 года назад

    I was rather disappointed. History of the movement lead by Swami Ramanand Teerth was not mentioned. Discussion was less about the Hyderabad state ruled by the Nizam & was more about the ideas....call it liberation or integration , it was consequence of the popular & secular movement ( keeping it secular was a big challenge ) & police action...

  • @Suryaa427
    @Suryaa427 Год назад +1

    Parakala prabhaker oka visha vruksham

    • @yesbhadra6696
      @yesbhadra6696 Год назад +1

      endhuku, nee yammani pandabettada pakkalo velama dora lekka leka nizam dora lekka leka razakar dora lekka

  • @AnilNagisetti
    @AnilNagisetti Год назад

    Parkala prabhakar inka nu సచ్చిపోలేదా

  • @vimalk78
    @vimalk78 2 года назад

    360p :(

  • @venomcr7874
    @venomcr7874 3 месяца назад

    Don't know what to say for this guy..
    See I agree BJP is not the best etc but do you atleast imagine where India will go with Congress regime. What we can do is choose the better among the options. Its clearly your hatred for BJP which makes you say this because I don't find as many improvements or achievements done in so many years of their power as much as BJP did.
    So be realistic.

  • @subramaniiyer3801
    @subramaniiyer3801 6 месяцев назад

    Myself requesting bjp RSS ministers Modi and Amit stop your dhamki rowdism tapori giri dadagiri goondagiri against truth speaking or writing people's of print and electronic media's in India immediately bandh Karo.

  • @ykuo3303
    @ykuo3303 8 месяцев назад

    sir your wife totally waste carbage for this country

  • @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724
    @rainbowmanfromoriginalid8724 7 месяцев назад

    YOUR WIFE SPEAK LOT OF
    VERY BUDGET LIES
    IN ALL BUDGET