Partition, Citizenship and NRC - Clear-cut with J. Sai Deepak

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
  • We discuss the Citizenship Amendment Act and NRC separately and try to address the myths surrounding the recent steps by the government. We take the discussion deeper into the civilizational contours of this debate that has largely been ignored in the popular discourse.

Комментарии • 1,1 тыс.

  • @Upword
    @Upword  4 года назад +99

    Help us produce more such content. Support at www.upword.co/donate
    UPI: upword@upi

    • @honeymuker6676
      @honeymuker6676 4 года назад +6

      I really wish it can be in Hindi too.. would be so helpful to make ppl understand at ground level....
      But first, really appreciate ur work here...
      Thanks...!!

    • @FireFox-di5cz
      @FireFox-di5cz 4 года назад +1

      Google Pay as an option, is it possible?

    • @pulz1191
      @pulz1191 3 года назад

      About time to rouse hindu emotions as well.

    • @manasipatil2805
      @manasipatil2805 3 года назад

      You guys are really awesome, articulate and know exactly how to present the points with finesse which is so lacking in several discussions today. Looking forward to help upword in anyway I can.

    • @MS-kv8md
      @MS-kv8md 3 года назад

      Do you have a Paypal account? Keep up the great work!

  • @misspepsi6352
    @misspepsi6352 4 года назад +853

    This video should be telecasted all across Assam in Assamese language. Love to Sai Deepak 💙 From Dibrugarh, Assam.

    • @eddyed4713
      @eddyed4713 4 года назад +12

      Labh nai .. Kunuba sabo janu lengthy vdo buli ? Ulta ei duijon k e Bangladeshi buli kobo lastot goi, even though he explained our State's issue very well unlike other channels

    • @roccosins2916
      @roccosins2916 4 года назад +8

      if media cannot. do it urself. its also ur right and duty to make people aware of truth. share with u friends. from one to 2 to four to 8 to finally whole state

    • @himdude9637
      @himdude9637 4 года назад +13

      असम के हिंदू को कश्मीर से सीखना चाहिए था. धारा 370 को कश्मीर के हिंदू ने ही लगवाया था. उन कश्मीरी पंडित का क्या हाल हुआ और कैसे इन UP बिहार के हिंदू क्षेत्र ने ही इनको सहारा दिया जब भगाए गए. नहीं तो पहले कहते थे बिहार UP वाले के साथ नहीं रह सकते हैं इसलिए 370 लगवाया.
      ये याद रखना असम के हिंदू. तुम असम मे हिंदू नहीं बसने दे रहे और जेहादी जम्मू और हैदराबाद मे रोहइंगया को बसा लिया. फिर तुम जब बर्बाद होते हो तो रोते हो सुधरते नहीं

    • @NoThing-ec9km
      @NoThing-ec9km 4 года назад +4

      Ofcourse .and people like u supporting will definately help a lot..thanx for appreciation.

    • @flyingface
      @flyingface 4 года назад +2

      Wont CAA result in new waves of Bangladeshi migrants to Assam?

  • @jaiprem7413
    @jaiprem7413 4 года назад +356

    I am Indo-Guyanese. It’s always a pleasure listening to my brothers from India, discussing important issues 🙏🕉❤️🇮🇳

    • @BharatKumar-iv6qd
      @BharatKumar-iv6qd 4 года назад +4

      Let's not undermine what Singh Saab is attempting to caution us about..he is quite right in asking us to not being complacent.. Numbers do not guarantee one's influence..as our own history would testify it, which ensued in partion quite in contrast to majoritarian principle ..from a global standpoint we have examples of Syria which does not have a single native Syrian catholic today.. erstwhile Persia lost their native parsis.. Zoroastrian culture.. Our own Kashmir was rid off native kashmiri hindus..so we have enough instances to learn from.. but are we really learning, will be answered in the times to come..we should not always depend on political dispensation for everything as there are electoral compulsions which they may heed to. More importantly we should turn into a more informed society, stay united like others and negotiate well to serve our interest..once we have a common voice then political dispensation hardly matters as things can be turned to one's favour if sustained pressure are applied through a unified voice..so our willingness to bury our differences and unite, will only ensure our existence and of the generations ahead else we should be ready to become a forgotten chapter of history..

    • @anshuuu9708
      @anshuuu9708 4 года назад

      @abhishek sharma himachal me se khn se ho

    • @anshuuu9708
      @anshuuu9708 4 года назад

      @abhishek sharma Himchal se hindu khin nahi jare yhn par Situations yhn bhi thik nahi h

    • @porothashawarma2339
      @porothashawarma2339 3 года назад +1

      Please feel free to visit , we welcome you back home.

  • @devashishgusain4886
    @devashishgusain4886 4 года назад +287

    Still alot of people's after watching NDTV, Quint, The Wire , The print , etc saying that CAA is unconstitutional.

    • @riseabovehate9476
      @riseabovehate9476 4 года назад +12

      chutye haina

    • @ms-yq8cd
      @ms-yq8cd 4 года назад +38

      they Dont Want to know at all. they only want to Use whatever they can, to manipulate narratives. THEY R ESSENTIALLY ANTI HINDU AND ANTI INDIAN.

    • @siddarthshah1773
      @siddarthshah1773 4 года назад +15

      dey r paid medias by congress and aap

    • @navalnatrajannegi9291
      @navalnatrajannegi9291 4 года назад +2

      @@ms-yq8cd laser gun shoot 😎

    • @juhik3777
      @juhik3777 4 года назад +26

      Not to forget Dhruv Rathee and aakash banerjee

  • @madeachanneljusttocomment2632
    @madeachanneljusttocomment2632 4 года назад +248

    I attended his talk at Nagpur. Was blown away by his insane research, exceptional talent of simplifying complex issues and articulation.

  • @sandhyavij
    @sandhyavij 4 года назад +366

    This is a discussion that needs to be televised all across the country. 😁

    • @mithlesh6097
      @mithlesh6097 4 года назад +6

      NAA ...media KO toh need mirch masala
      Mirch masala SE hi they gonna sink our country

    • @indiamusically
      @indiamusically 4 года назад +1

      Simple question. Wasn't citizenship given before CAA? What stopped the state before from giving citizenship to anyone they want? Were Hindus, Christians, Sikhs not given citizenship before? What necessitates this then? Is it just because three countries have a state religion, India also should indirectly project to have a favouring religion?
      It's not about law. SC might restrain citing judicial overreach on the legislature. It's about what kind of India you believe in.

    • @sheikabdul3693
      @sheikabdul3693 4 года назад

      Yes but not alone with NRC , NRC +CAA !! But he will never discuss that together

    • @pandey47pradeep
      @pandey47pradeep 4 года назад +12

      @@sheikabdul3693 because NRC is in your dreams but CAA is reality😂😅😂
      Don't try to put your maulana's fear mongering plan here

    • @pandey47pradeep
      @pandey47pradeep 4 года назад +2

      @@indiamusically have you ever read this Act?

  • @janeshwerpurushothaman9510
    @janeshwerpurushothaman9510 4 года назад +256

    We are a global minority and don't resort to victimhood.
    We are more about providing a truly inclusive society.
    Thanks Deepak for putting out the historic backdrop behind the various Bills passed.

    • @ajay4i
      @ajay4i 4 года назад +10

      That's a nice perspective stating us as global minority 🙏👏

    • @surabhi86
      @surabhi86 4 года назад +5

      I agree! Globally we are being criticised for this CAA but the rest of the world doesn’t do anything or provide us any privilege. Rather we are flooded with missionaries to convert or Islamist terrorism.

  • @Thepatriotpodcast24
    @Thepatriotpodcast24 4 года назад +88

    Just like the deepak(lamp) illuminates the whole surrounding with its radiance... Sai deepak enlightens all of us with his intellect n wisdom
    May u always glow like deepak , you are the beacon of hope!
    🔥

    • @sunilbaluni5333
      @sunilbaluni5333 4 года назад

      Deepak yatha naam tatha gun. Fortuate to listen him.

  • @mansi0
    @mansi0 4 года назад +324

    This man is enlightened! Such clarity. This should go viral. Unfortunately, youth today watches Dhruv Rathee.
    Ps: I have been following his Rajya Sabha debates. But, heard him laughing for the first time today. This sounds music to my ears:)
    Love. Respect. Hail.🙏

    • @mithlesh6097
      @mithlesh6097 4 года назад +14

      I've shared this on social media ...
      Everyone should share this instead of sharing violence and misconceptions

    • @roserosarosen5637
      @roserosarosen5637 4 года назад +23

      Dhruv's channel has been spreading rumour like buses were set ablaze by police etc !

    • @mithlesh6097
      @mithlesh6097 4 года назад +3

      @@roserosarosen5637 reason why after that news ... problem increased more

    • @marong3717
      @marong3717 4 года назад +19

      People like dhruv rathe are Funded by break India forces along with main stream media. ...

    • @chandsingh342
      @chandsingh342 4 года назад +4

      I'm feeling relaxed some what after watching your views on this issue which is rather burning. Share it guys s much as you can. Thank You all of you.

  • @husainiacademy2049
    @husainiacademy2049 4 года назад +80

    In the age when debates are reduced to cacophony of nosies. This debate is comprehensive and encompasses cogent and substantial body of scholarship regarding cab and NRC. Endorsed depak sir standpoint is admirable and unparalleled. Good to be enlightened through this logical discourse

  • @Aby202
    @Aby202 4 года назад +92

    Minorities are always persecuted on the basis of their religion in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh. CAA will give healing touch to such people. Where will they go if India doesn't accept them.

    • @irwincrook567
      @irwincrook567 4 года назад +1

      And in India as well

    • @kamthangchangsan7039
      @kamthangchangsan7039 4 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/RooyXd5Ct7s/видео.html

    • @PranjalRajSingh
      @PranjalRajSingh 4 года назад +9

      @@irwincrook567 persecuted in India? Numbers and say otherwise. How many Indians to knocking to the neighbours for refuge?

    • @rahulagrawalagrawal48
      @rahulagrawalagrawal48 4 года назад +1

      Wat about healing touch to moblynching and kathua rape victim..

    • @roccosins2916
      @roccosins2916 4 года назад +4

      @@rahulagrawalagrawal48 yeah they got justice becoz they are muslim but what about the hindus that are being lynched by muslims????why media hiding them, or not saying their religion when covering the crimes?????????????????

  • @alopal3191
    @alopal3191 4 года назад +67

    You're just mind-blowing Sai Deepak!

  • @parishmitakalita1232
    @parishmitakalita1232 4 года назад +42

    Sir, this is something no one knows and everyone deserves to know. From childrens to senior citizens. I have seen nothing so enlightening in days.

    • @eddyed4713
      @eddyed4713 4 года назад +2

      Still CAA batil hobo lage ne ? But leaving this aside we need new NRC + uniform civil code+ population control bill + anti conversion bill ..aru eikeita ejon e dibo pare ..

  • @nukulchhillar8196
    @nukulchhillar8196 4 года назад +241

    Ravish(NDTV) or the other so called intellectuals will not stand a chance against this brilliant guy.

    • @siddarthshah1773
      @siddarthshah1773 4 года назад +33

      its nehru dyanasty television(ndtv)

    • @roserosarosen5637
      @roserosarosen5637 4 года назад +12

      Rabies Kumar he is !

    • @ms-yq8cd
      @ms-yq8cd 4 года назад +2

      budhdhoojeevis

    • @surabhi86
      @surabhi86 4 года назад +9

      PRAEMILA R SHIVAACHARYA good one! Now a days listening to rabies kumar boils me from inside. He is a undercover PA to congress. His chat shows sounds like Ekta Kapoor daily soaps full of sarcasms like grannies.

    • @roserosarosen5637
      @roserosarosen5637 4 года назад +3

      @@surabhi86
      Well, he's a compulsive liar to the core !

  • @venkateshkrishnarajpet3754
    @venkateshkrishnarajpet3754 4 года назад +47

    Wonderful,enlightening,
    We need more and more people like you
    We many of us Indian senior citizens bless you and your colleagues because you are promising a peaceful death to us
    We were desperate looking at the majority of youths not being responsible and serious about the happenings of our great country,
    You have fulfilled that want
    God bless you and your associates 👍😇✋

  • @aayushroy0609
    @aayushroy0609 4 года назад +16

    J. Sai Deepak, thank you for clearing the fog in my head. Forwarding this to all my friends and family.

  • @monikasethuraman6671
    @monikasethuraman6671 4 года назад +37

    34-36 , you so rightly pointed out the Journalists Academicians of Bangladesh openly propagating Greater bangla theory with Lebensraum theory as pretext to it. Sitting In a south Asian security seminar in pondicherry university i was agitated when Bangladeshi professors demanded inclusion of assam . I was ostracized for being vocal. May Bharat have many scholars like you two. Mera Bharat Mahan. JAI HIND.

    • @ruskinbond7617
      @ruskinbond7617 4 года назад +5

      Do share more details. Who are those Bangladeshi professors?

  • @anupamsharma1
    @anupamsharma1 4 года назад +235

    J sai Deepak is taking the legacy of K Parasaran ahead.

    • @siddharthabajpai7575
      @siddharthabajpai7575 4 года назад +8

      You are right. 😇

    • @vahanprasan
      @vahanprasan 4 года назад +5

      ANUPAM SHARMA I thought just the same..

    • @rai3086
      @rai3086 4 года назад +2

      Is he K Parasaran ‘s apprentice or has he been before ? I was impressed by some of his speech on Sabarimala issue but not much about his past and work I know. So just inquiring 🙂.

    • @anupamsharma1
      @anupamsharma1 4 года назад +7

      @@rai3086 yes he is working with Mr. K Parasaran sir on case of State control of Hindu temples.

    • @rai3086
      @rai3086 4 года назад

      ANUPAM SHARMA ok thanks

  • @raunakpoddar
    @raunakpoddar 4 года назад +24

    Very well said: "Perception is such an insurmountable barrier.. How do you wake up a man who is pretending to be asleep?"

  • @poetrification
    @poetrification 4 года назад +144

    DJ has got some mass following now. He is no less than a movie superstar for a lot us. 👍

    • @furyroad028
      @furyroad028 4 года назад +18

      Bro he is Telugu 😁. I saw him speaking Telugu ? Ask him to put a video in Telugu for our dumb Telugu people. Some dumbos in Andhra and telangana putting memes against caa and NRC . Sai Deepak needs to put a video in his mother tongue telugu. So that dumb telugus understand what is caa and NRC. One of my neighbour putting status going to miss my muslim friend because of caa and NRC in WhatsApp 😹😹😹. Anti caa protestors anni antinational kukkalu 😡

    • @ahuman6067
      @ahuman6067 4 года назад

      YOGENDRA YADAV is one of them who continuesly spreading these lies please burst all his lies......
      ruclips.net/video/XleYkvKBYKU/видео.html

    • @RaviKumar-ii6cb
      @RaviKumar-ii6cb 4 года назад +5

      @@furyroad028 In that Telugu program he himself said that he is Tamil Brahmin born and brought up in Hyderabad. So he can speak in Telugu and Tamil.

    • @furyroad028
      @furyroad028 4 года назад +2

      @@RaviKumar-ii6cb he is Telugu brahmin not Tamil . No where he told he is Tamil brahmin

    • @RaviKumar-ii6cb
      @RaviKumar-ii6cb 4 года назад

      @@furyroad028 Hello Sai. I must apologize. It is not in that video where he was speaking in Telugu and English it is in another video. I'm pasting the link. Just watch from Time stamp 3.39 onwords. You will know that he is a Tamil Brahmin.
      ruclips.net/video/-47gqvAlFXk/видео.html

  • @adarshsinghpathania
    @adarshsinghpathania 4 года назад +6

    Funny part of my stand in Support of CAA and NRC was called hypocrite by one of my friend in Canada .
    Just by seeing India media news.
    I really appreciate what you guys are doing.
    Jai Hind. Jai Bharat

  • @abir95571
    @abir95571 4 года назад +4

    The level intellect and research this man has done is exemplary ... we need more people like him

  • @dhanukishor5894
    @dhanukishor5894 4 года назад +8

    'Words of wisdom' 🙏for those frustrated with the level of ignorance portrayed by our so called community of intellectuals + 'Light of hope' for those who truely expect an inclusive and all embracing prosperity of our country. Salute and respect for Sai deepak.

  • @koushikgorre3281
    @koushikgorre3281 4 года назад +96

    India needs greater exposure to j sai deepak

  • @VaibhavSrivastava15
    @VaibhavSrivastava15 4 года назад +8

    For the first time I liked the host as well. He was intelligent and well read which made the discussion even more enlightening.

  • @sreenathganapathy5089
    @sreenathganapathy5089 4 года назад +78

    We support you. Truth will win one day.

    • @atul1024
      @atul1024 4 года назад

      Sreenath ganapathy
      ruclips.net/video/AvCsn-EDS5o/видео.html

    • @AnandRajappan
      @AnandRajappan 4 года назад +3

      @@atul1024 Dharma is not understood properly, it should always be applied keeping in context of the place, person and time factors.
      Poor not having enough in front of you and blaming karma is very hypothetical situation explained here and a good Dharmic person of india will never do it, and saying that as reason for our fall is very illogical and out of context. Cast system was actually a strength of indian society and helped good distribution of work within the society in general. The cause identified may be true to a small extent but actually life is not so straightforward and easy to make out what is dharma and adharma (people are confusing mortality, a pure western idea foreign to indic thoughts, with dharma and misleading them).

    • @atul1024
      @atul1024 4 года назад

      Anand Rajappan
      Full series
      ruclips.net/p/PL3232B4C151C161BB

  • @JasonLoganbourne
    @JasonLoganbourne 4 года назад +27

    A big salute to upword for bringing such enlightened debate

  • @saran1504
    @saran1504 4 года назад +16

    After listening this entire discussion I understand the real facts about caa and nrc, also understand it's importance. My suggestion to everyone those watch this video is that you must share this because it really shows the reality.

  • @jagadeeshkumar1491
    @jagadeeshkumar1491 4 года назад +256

    This has to be telecasted across the streets in all languages..... Normal public need this info.... Upword team.... Pls take time and include subtitles or dub it in all languages..... This will prevent violence......

    • @indiamusically
      @indiamusically 4 года назад +1

      Simple question. Wasn't citizenship given before CAA? What stopped the state before from giving citizenship to anyone they want? Were Hindus, Christians, Sikhs not given citizenship before? What necessitates this then? Is it just because three countries have a state religion, India also should indirectly project to have a favouring religion?
      It's not about law. SC might restrain citing judicial overreach on the legislature. It's about what kind of India you believe in.

    • @jagadeeshkumar1491
      @jagadeeshkumar1491 4 года назад +8

      @@indiamusically... These people were not Indian citizens... They are persecuted people in these 3 countries... Who are already in our country as refugees or as illegal immigrants.... This bill only concentrated on if persecution done then they can be naturalized...pls.. . Try to understand...

    • @raniramu735
      @raniramu735 4 года назад

      Why was this announcement made properly by the Govt? Assuming that v are all ignorant! All these happened coz the Govt using arrogance as usual....

    • @niteshagate474
      @niteshagate474 4 года назад +7

      @@raniramu735 Why was this announcement made properly by the Govt? Assuming that v are all ignorant! All these happened coz the Govt using arrogance as usual....
      1. You're asking "why the announcement was made properly by the government?" I assume you intended "why not?" and the answer is that it was done very much in accordance to the standard operating procedure, the bill was actually discussed in both the house, passed by them and then the president gave his assent post which the bill became an act and was published in 'The Gazette of India'. so this point that you raise is unfactual unless you were actually complaining why it was done properly🤣
      2. Buses are being burnt cause of govt's arrogance? public property is destroyed by miscreants and regardless of where you stand on the issue you should condemn the violence and destruction of public property, after all, it's our taxpayer's money that funds all of it.
      P.s. before you use labels and try to pigeon-hole me I would hope you realize I still haven't taken a stand on the issue but if you wish to discuss it in a civil manner based on facts I'll be more than willing to engage in such a debate or else good luck and goodbye.

    • @eddyed4713
      @eddyed4713 4 года назад +5

      n A hahah ya bro exactly.. instead of protesting daily and wasting 9-10 hours daily , if only people had just watched the Lok sabha and Rajya sabha sessions when the bills were passed , would’ve taken hardly 6 hours and would’ve done a huge favour to the whole country and spared us all this chaos that’s been going on in the name of caa protests

  • @pilotcyborg.gaming
    @pilotcyborg.gaming 4 года назад +28

    Free Hindu Temples
    We support CAA and NRC
    We support Bhajpa

  • @swarupdas8048
    @swarupdas8048 3 года назад +5

    I m from Bengal. Beautiful discussion. It really brings enlightenment to us.

  • @duckwalkerindian4689
    @duckwalkerindian4689 4 года назад +69

    for Islamists whatever your argument.....they will understand what they like to believe n reject d other....for them d sole issue is that both Modi and Amit Shah r Hindus living and working in Hindustan.....this is their problem

    • @Rtrpec
      @Rtrpec 4 года назад +1

      The same goes for u

    • @shivaputrabiradar6088
      @shivaputrabiradar6088 4 года назад +4

      @@Rtrpec what goes for him?

    • @shivaputrabiradar6088
      @shivaputrabiradar6088 4 года назад +4

      @@Rtrpec do you know Islamists?

    • @roccosins2916
      @roccosins2916 4 года назад +6

      Pakistan, Afghanistan, bangladesh and kashmir were all hindu countries and places, muslim came by force or by settlement, then today hindu are nearly extinct there. and lol, they say Muslim are suffering in world. u dont want peace u wanna make india islamic. full stop.histroy repeats. learn from history and dont ever repeat same mistake that ur forefathers did.

  • @HRHKamal
    @HRHKamal 4 года назад +22

    Very good follow up video.
    Essence - Everyone has the right to support or oppose the CAA but acquaint yourself with the facts first & be rational in your discussions.
    Irrationality, emotions, fears, your political ideology have no place in such discussions.
    And be courteous ; shun abuses & labels.

    • @Priya-cm3tr
      @Priya-cm3tr 3 года назад

      Put the correct map of India

  • @anishsingh3538
    @anishsingh3538 4 года назад +134

    We need this type of debate in public forum,,,,,

    • @akahummingbird
      @akahummingbird 4 года назад +6

      He regularly appear on Rajya Sabha TV debate

    • @oiitsmeraffic2407
      @oiitsmeraffic2407 4 года назад

      One person con't make Debate
      The second person joined
      Replay from your turn
      ruclips.net/video/xfS3y9-m6HM/видео.html

    • @ajitkumarsingh9076
      @ajitkumarsingh9076 4 года назад +3

      @@oiitsmeraffic2407 haha fake link

    • @kbmnair2182
      @kbmnair2182 4 года назад

      But you see the Kerala Assembly 139 out of 140 MLAs passed a resolution opposing the CAA without any Debate .

  • @VVV-wx3ui
    @VVV-wx3ui 4 года назад +26

    I have been waiting for such disclosure from Upword. They have the reach and must use to show the truth to All.
    Great to be part of the Upword subscriber list. I am very much impressed with Sai J Deepak on his views and mostly go all of it. Rather, I would put it this way, the cogitative views of Majority in Bharat, do not come forward due to the fact that their views are NOT encouraged. However, here, Sai J Deepak being from Legal Fraternity, would do best for the Justice of the Native of this Land and especially those who hold the cultural values in day-to-day life.
    I would not hesitate an iota to have Deepak represent a cause of this Land and he surely will come up with a Clause to defend it legally for the world to know its fundamental.
    Good work Upword.
    Namaskaram Sai Deepak..

  • @TheChromelover
    @TheChromelover 4 года назад +30

    I wish all lawyers were like this. Advocate J Sai Deepak’s arguments were very impressive in the Sabarimala case. He was allowed a time of just 10 mins but the court heard his arguments for 1.5 hours. It was so impressive.

    • @ritz6634
      @ritz6634 4 года назад

      Wow ! Which side was he on and what were the arguments? Is there anywhere I can access it ? Am for women entry , but even if he argued against it I'd like to listen because he seems so good .

    • @gurmeet926
      @gurmeet926 4 года назад +1

      @@ritz6634 against women entry but do listen his views

  • @sriharshanamuduri8694
    @sriharshanamuduri8694 4 года назад +15

    Thank you so much Upword and Sai Deepak for the efforts in educating Indians and world in general.Without these inputs, there is a lot of smog created by the intellectual mafia for us to understand what all of this fuss is about. Thanks again!!

    • @ms-yq8cd
      @ms-yq8cd 4 года назад

      yes . A Big Thanks to Upword.

  • @adityachalla89
    @adityachalla89 4 года назад +7

    J Sai Deepak's english is so amazing!! Beautiful explanation.

  • @thetrs1949
    @thetrs1949 4 года назад +2

    A Kashmiri and a Tamilian discussing how to protect their Motherland. This generation will take India to new heights.

  • @sachindivakar632
    @sachindivakar632 4 года назад +5

    I m Practicing Advait Vedanta being stock Analyst, while listening J. Sai Deepak i feel same Enlightenment .

  • @vrindaraman4029
    @vrindaraman4029 4 года назад +3

    Sai deepakji, you are putting your indepth knowledge of Indian Law to very good use. You are educating legal illiterates like me through your debates and talks. I am very grateful. May your courage never fail you to speak the truth and abide by the law

  • @deepikakumaravel
    @deepikakumaravel 4 года назад +34

    You can't get a clearer picture than this.

  • @vkuttus
    @vkuttus 4 года назад +40

    So true there has to be a public debate and it should be telecasted countrywide..

    • @indiamusically
      @indiamusically 4 года назад +1

      Simple questions.
      Wasn't citizenship given before CAA? What stopped the state before from giving citizenship to anyone they want? Were Hindus, Christians, Sikhs not given citizenship before? What necessitates this then? Is it just because three countries have a state religion, India also should indirectly project to have a favouring religion?
      Factual knowledge even if it's full without the understanding of the idea and philosophy behind is dangerous.
      It's not about law. SC might restrain citing judicial overreach on the legislature. Courts judge what is lawful and what is not. It doesn't just ideologies and philosophies.
      It's about what kind of India you believe in.

    • @vkuttus
      @vkuttus 4 года назад

      @@indiamusically according to our current citizenship law all these refugees have to go back once NRC is implemented. But they all can apply for a citizenship . This process is relaxed for a particular group of immigrants realizing that the threats that they face in their own Homeland is still very much at large which is their religious persicution in their homeland. The govt has realized that minority and this CAA has provided a little relaxation for such minorities. Hence it's an inclusion of minorities rather than the popular mislead ideas. And mind u the normal way to apply citizenship still persists for everyone this bill identifies the minorities among the immigrants who are still facing threats in their country

    • @vkuttus
      @vkuttus 4 года назад

      @@indiamusically to look at an issue where in ur decision is largely based on ideologies and philosophies will not work out in reality where a lot of practical issues have to be considered. A person thinking like that will be a subject of external influence where he can be easily persuaded to act according to someone else's agenda. That is a waste of ur education, people should question facts should comprehend things as it is rather being a subject to emotions. Study the things at hand try to know more about it reach a conclusion based on ur thinking and not the popular beliefs and then let's agree to disagree.

    • @indiamusically
      @indiamusically 4 года назад +1

      @@vkuttus ​ Whoever came before 2008(11 years back) is already given(or can be given) citizenship by naturalisation. So, for giving citizenship to people(fast track)who came between 2008 and 31 Dec 2014 this law is enacted? How much will be the number who came between 2008 and 2014?
      Why have a cutoff date then on 31 Dec 2014? Prosecuted religious minorities didn't come after that date, or will they not come now? Why don't fear of their extinction, who came after 31 Dec 2014, and want to come now? Why don't fast track them?
      India should give citizenship to them, that is out of the question. But this law is like firing bullets to others issues with guns on the shoulder(in name of) of persecuted migrants.
      Lastly, did I judge your education? Where do you learn to bring mudslinging in civil discussions? Your education, I suppose.
      I drop my case here and take your leave. Good Day.

  • @harshkumarsingh08
    @harshkumarsingh08 4 года назад +7

    CAA is justice, Period. Must needed for relieving those religiously persecuted people. He is so enlightening ♥️👌.

  • @bkachan1048
    @bkachan1048 4 года назад +73

    This should go viral. Share en masse.

  • @rakshithlokesh2810
    @rakshithlokesh2810 4 года назад +29

    I would pay u 2 lakh per hearing if u were my lawyer 😂...awesome sir

  • @suchita52
    @suchita52 3 года назад +2

    These kind of debates must happen across & this talk should be played out to give clarity to these issues....Sai Deepak you’ve made us also aware of the scary future of the intentions of Greater Bangla Desh!! Assam and North East MUST be well Protected with proper infrastructures to prevent ANY migration... NRC must be implemented by this government with discussions with people like Salve, Sai Deepak etc to craft a well structured law.

  • @pankajkhanaik5380
    @pankajkhanaik5380 4 года назад +6

    Crystal Clear
    This man is brilliant
    And great work done by #UPWORD

  • @pareshprajapati7916
    @pareshprajapati7916 4 года назад +3

    Salute Sir Deepak ji for freeing padmabhan temple from government.
    🇮🇳🙏🕉️

  • @dhruvgupta99
    @dhruvgupta99 4 года назад +39

    This guy is an encyclopedia of knowledge. Thankyou deepak sir :)

  • @sunilbhat7126
    @sunilbhat7126 Год назад +1

    Thanks to Ashish Dhar for putting forth such an enlightening debate on your channel. I wish you more power & God bless

  • @vishnunarayan8850
    @vishnunarayan8850 3 года назад +5

    Liberals after 5 minutes of watching " Hamari samajh ke kuch nahi aa raha but this guy is fascist. Now excuse me mujhe standup comedy dekhni which suits my brain" 😂😂😂

  • @prashantjohnmichael
    @prashantjohnmichael 4 года назад +8

    Here is the real explanation of the whole mess at last. Thank You Sir.

  • @vatsalasarwal7542
    @vatsalasarwal7542 4 года назад +12

    Excellent, comprehensive and accurate explanation of CAA which should be telecast widely, in different languages . Thank you Upword.

  • @bhargavkartik7476
    @bhargavkartik7476 4 года назад +2

    Not all heroes wear capes. Respect for our hero J Sai Deepak.

  • @pankajsawaliya8062
    @pankajsawaliya8062 4 года назад +4

    It was worth watching this debate..I wish each and every citizen of this country should know the fact...J Sai Deepak ji i really fell in love with you after watchig this debate..Love you sir

  • @JasonLoganbourne
    @JasonLoganbourne 4 года назад +69

    Plz make a Hindi version of this video... A broader reach is needed to remove fear mongering

    • @bangalorebadmintonderby2937
      @bangalorebadmintonderby2937 4 года назад +7

      Do it yourself bro...all of us have our responsibility to make this viral...I shall do in my mother tongue as well

  • @rational0
    @rational0 4 года назад +14

    This video is a very good unbiased analysis without holding back the real reasons and concerns for past events. But main stream media will never show this. Thank Goodness we have alt media like youtube today, so the truth is coming out for next generations too.

  • @arvindg553
    @arvindg553 4 года назад +1

    Now Jai Sai Deepak speech is my BINGE WATCH
    Is there any other debate at this level of intellectual and integrity and and going out of boundaries
    The best debate I ever saw in my life

  • @lajwantishahani1225
    @lajwantishahani1225 2 года назад +2

    Love these deep and enriching discussions. We need more people to talk about these issues, particularly on the CAA and NRC. Definitely more people to hear this with the right kind of takeaway. Thank you.
    Didn't realize that I was watching it again! After a year that too... and still learning.

  • @Danny-bbsrSingh
    @Danny-bbsrSingh 4 года назад +4

    Sir,J.Sai Deepak u r an ocean of Encyclopedic Knowledge! Just Wow!!!

  • @priyankas3812
    @priyankas3812 4 года назад +11

    J Sai Deepak Sir you are amazing👌👍
    Mass hysteria - 'From where is it coming?' is the real issue.
    Do you really think it is just because of CAA or NRC?

  • @akanksha9128
    @akanksha9128 4 года назад +9

    Sir, your videos made alot of people question themselves and they are now seeing the real picture and are changing their opinion. So please keep going. You are doing a great job. It was needed. Keep going. 💯❤

  • @julu8407
    @julu8407 4 года назад +32

    I hope NDTV is watching this.

    • @julu8407
      @julu8407 4 года назад +5

      @@alonzo_go Sometimes, they argue like childrens..

  • @susheelareddy24
    @susheelareddy24 4 года назад +4

    Mr.Deepak, Thanks for the earlier video and current video as well. I ve forwarded to my frens and will forward this too. We condemn ur colleagues' whispers. You are doing a job to give us actual truth coz u have the spine. You should also form a group or channel and place ur Blunt views. This is important for all Indians. We are proud of you. Respect from Rajahmundry. Andhra Pradesh.

  • @surabhi86
    @surabhi86 4 года назад +49

    I want Hindu Rashtra! secularism is a myth and and burden explained to us whereas all the abrahimic religions in itself is unsecular by doing evangelism considering that their own religion is the only true one. People who believe in such religions are unsecular themselves. Why is a pressure on us Hindus to enact as secular. Constitution needs another change. Making Bharat a Hindu Rashtra!
    Ban conversion in India!
    Ban rise in Abrahimic religion.
    Ban entry on people following Abrahimic religion and missionaries.
    Why there is no road rage and protest to save Hinduism from conversion.

  • @himanshubillorePeoplesoftHRMS
    @himanshubillorePeoplesoftHRMS 3 года назад +1

    One goes binge watching after seeing 1 video of J. Sai Deepak Sir... Most apt speaker !! Wow !!

  • @yushpi
    @yushpi 4 года назад +24

    Wow... The stats on Bangladesh is scary

    • @arjungupta4288
      @arjungupta4288 4 года назад +2

      Seriously...! Never thought of that.

  • @---------------------------...
    @---------------------------... 4 года назад +16

    Thanks for discussing so many facets. Thanks Ashish Dhar for mentioning Bangladesh crisis w.r.t. rising ocean levels.

  • @nimeshhendre7502
    @nimeshhendre7502 4 года назад +3

    What flair and finesse. Amazing hold on the legal and logical arguments. Cheers!

  • @malaashok173
    @malaashok173 3 года назад +1

    India needs more sai Deepaks. Many more. Hope he is able to influence younger generation to take up law and fight for what is right and not what will make them popular among leftists.
    God bless Sai Deepak with a long healthy and successful life

  • @chaithravarma782
    @chaithravarma782 4 года назад +4

    Well said! All those protesters against CAA and NRC out there, pls do watch.

  • @dharmeshnahar7788
    @dharmeshnahar7788 4 года назад +27

    Now liberandus will term u bhakts.
    I have shared your vdo on my Instagram handle. Thanks a lot for bringing so much clarity.

    • @indiamusically
      @indiamusically 4 года назад

      Simple questions.
      Wasn't citizenship given before CAA? What stopped the state before from giving citizenship to anyone they want? Were Hindus, Christians, Sikhs not given citizenship before? What necessitates this then? Is it just because three countries have a state religion, India also should indirectly project to have a favouring religion?
      Factual knowledge even if it's full without the understanding of the idea and philosophy behind is dangerous.
      It's not about law. SC might restrain citing judicial overreach on the legislature. Courts judge what is lawful and what is not. It doesn't just ideologies and philosophies.
      It's about what kind of India you believe in.

    • @Abhishekwolfonwall
      @Abhishekwolfonwall 4 года назад +5

      @@indiamusically u don't hold water here. Totally irrelevant argument. It seems like u r copying paste ur question.

    • @SH-yx6yl
      @SH-yx6yl 4 года назад

      @@indiamusically u have a very poor knowledge..

  • @kiransahni100
    @kiransahni100 4 года назад +5

    Very deeply and extensive analysis

  • @maheshnanadimath1234
    @maheshnanadimath1234 3 года назад +1

    Thanks Saideepak for such a detailed clarification and exposing these bigots 🙏

  • @Rocky-ip2tg
    @Rocky-ip2tg 4 года назад +2

    I want this guy to be the member of Parliament and BJP spokes person... Coz he is like AK 47...
    Who all agree with me... Pls hit the like button...👍

  • @bibekanandasur8054
    @bibekanandasur8054 4 года назад +51

    Please do a discussion about bengali hindus of india we're heading towards the same fate as kashmiri pandits.Our language is being hijacked culture altered and what not

    • @ramparmar3805
      @ramparmar3805 4 года назад +6

      What r u doing ? Why can't you fight your own fight ? Army couldn't protect kp they wili not be able to protect u . It is u who need to unite and fight.

    • @bibekanandasur8054
      @bibekanandasur8054 4 года назад +8

      @@ramparmar3805 I wrote what I wrote because this issue needs to be communicated before something bad happens.I just want people to be conscious about this.

    • @ramparmar3805
      @ramparmar3805 4 года назад

      @@bibekanandasur8054 let bad happen. Everybody knows assam is home illigel bangladeshi.

    • @shivanibhatt1768
      @shivanibhatt1768 4 года назад +4

      Tum khud hi doshi ho ,Jaise Maharashtra wale bhugtenge tum bhi bhugto aur do vote Mamta ko

    • @bibekanandasur8054
      @bibekanandasur8054 4 года назад +9

      @@shivanibhatt1768 I never voted for mamta nor does my family and not majority of bengali hindus.But goons of didi capture the poll booths during election

  • @naveensharma6882
    @naveensharma6882 4 года назад +49

    CAB is pro-minority
    I supporter of CAB
    where shall sikh, hindu, parsi, jain will go.
    Good explanation.
    Thanks

    • @siddarthshah1773
      @siddarthshah1773 4 года назад +3

      naveen sharma totally evn our whole jain community is with cab and nrc..in india minority means muslims..secularism is a weapon against hindus..dey wont ask us wt is our views..we want our santana dharama to be in the lead and throw dis abrahamic cunts out of our land..our religions r born here and we havent gone to conquer anybody thts wt our secularism have been bt today its been missused in such a way tht we r looking like a 3rd grade citizen in our own land

    • @rahulagrawalagrawal48
      @rahulagrawalagrawal48 4 года назад

      @@siddarthshah1773 jain community is d most opulent community overly represented in ias ..because u have jeeto foundation in which people live for years so dat dey can crack ..der is lot of jain temple building activity going on across d country everry polotocaian goes and touches feet of acharya sri vidyasagar ji..u r builders ,economist and wat not never has been jain community part of any riot ..people treat dem wid repect wat else do u need for becoming 1st class citizen ..rampant hatred and islamophobia

    • @rahulagrawalagrawal48
      @rahulagrawalagrawal48 4 года назад

      Cab is definitely pro minority nrc ia not

    • @naveensharma6882
      @naveensharma6882 4 года назад +1

      NRC must be conducted but taking minorties into confidence.
      If still donot agree than also it must b carried but after 2 to 3 years.
      More than 3 laks B,deshes went back within a week due to fear of detensions.
      Let them give time to return.
      UCC, Art370, NRC, CAB, Population control, conversion act etc r pending due to one community and appeasement policies of incumbent govts.
      This s bad for any nation.
      Certainly i will support thses measure.
      20 crore people r minority it s joke in itself.
      No other minority wants any thing and contibuted much more a country can give.
      I really respect Parsis, Jain, Sikhs etc what great flowers blessed to India.
      Indian muslim has to long way to go but India can not wait for whole centuries

    • @navalnatrajannegi9291
      @navalnatrajannegi9291 4 года назад

      @@karthika560 don't worry
      Till sanatanm dharam, no derived religion end...
      Hindus choose jainism by choice not by forced

  • @adarshdubey7295
    @adarshdubey7295 3 года назад +1

    Jai ho. Doing great work for Indic renaissance upword.

  • @sbs5408
    @sbs5408 4 года назад +5

    Brilliant discussion. Precise, sharp and erudite. Sai Deepak is very articulate and has "clear cut" views.

  • @santanuroy9101
    @santanuroy9101 4 года назад +10

    I watched the whole video and it cleared many of my misconceptions

    • @Sarcasticsanskar
      @Sarcasticsanskar 4 года назад

      Please spread the info and fight misinformation and unncessary chaos.

  • @deepakrajusiva
    @deepakrajusiva 4 года назад +22

    56:00 I am an Indian , from Coimbatore,TN

  • @ganeshrvs
    @ganeshrvs 4 года назад +3

    I can give 1000 likes to this video. Deepak you have explained it so clearly from the root. I wish people from every corner of India should see this video. Please translate to every language and show it to the public. People are so misguided with shameless politicians and so called activistis in this country. Thanks to UPWARD.

  • @savdutt
    @savdutt 4 года назад +6

    Share this video, people. He needs more exposure.

  • @steamingsilver
    @steamingsilver 4 года назад +21

    Sir, i m from the NE India and I really like and appreciate your deep views and analysis. I have been enlightened a lot.
    One request, can you please make a video related to the views of the NE people, Here, the reason for protest is not about exclusion of Muslims in CAA but people are apprehensive because by granting citizenship to anyone through CAA (any religion) the Indigenous People of the NE states will be affected because the area especially Assam has a good number of Illegal Immigrants in general. Thank you.

    • @ajayjadhav1174
      @ajayjadhav1174 4 года назад +9

      Hello brother there is different between illegal migrants & refugees. CAA is all about to giving citizen to minority refugee who persecuted on basis of religion from Pakistan Bangladesh & Afghanistan. According to assam accort who comes in assam illegally irrespective of their religion they will deported.

    • @ramparmar3805
      @ramparmar3805 4 года назад +5

      Brother most of NE is under ILP where this amendment will not apply.

    • @ramparmar3805
      @ramparmar3805 4 года назад

      @乙乇ᗪㄖ几Ꮆ爪卂ㄖ it has. But in few district as per my knowledge.

    • @jayaramanganapathi9385
      @jayaramanganapathi9385 4 года назад +1

      @@ajayjadhav1174 Hi, India needs CAA. I have stated logical aspects in below CAA supporting petition. Please read & sign the petition, forward to other groups.
      www.change.org/p/indian-citizens-caa-is-needed-for-india

  • @devintel113
    @devintel113 4 года назад +4

    After listening this clam and peace interview i subscribed this channel.
    Thanks you sir

  • @vj12343
    @vj12343 2 года назад +2

    This was eye opening and I learnt a lot. Thank you

  • @omp1335
    @omp1335 4 года назад +5

    Clarity thy name is Sai Deepak... Awesome.. thanks a lot.

  • @shankarschintalapati4783
    @shankarschintalapati4783 4 года назад +10

    Very informative , in depth study of burning issue

  • @worth_considering
    @worth_considering 4 года назад +12

    Can you run this on national television!?
    Please! It's the dire need of an hour..

  • @thisisanewusername4662
    @thisisanewusername4662 4 года назад +4

    Excellent, excellent, talk! Much needed.

  • @satyanandapatel
    @satyanandapatel 4 года назад +18

    Secularism and Liberal along with Nazism is loosely used in india.

    • @aaliyaaaliya
      @aaliyaaaliya 4 года назад +2

      Satyananda Patel Add Fascism to the list too

  • @liliesandtulips2000
    @liliesandtulips2000 4 года назад +4

    Brilliant as always! Kudos to the both of you, the gems of our country!
    I think, the demographic change that would certainly happen (even though miniscule) in india due to The CAA is what is bothering these effed up chrislamocommies.

  • @SubinAbrahamlove2808
    @SubinAbrahamlove2808 4 года назад +6

    Tremendous personality is this Man😍
    Became a fan of Sai Deepak after watching his explanation on why women of specific age are not allowed in Sabarimala.
    Everytime I watch his videos I get to learn new things on Indian constitution and Law😍😍

  • @vidyasagar8319
    @vidyasagar8319 4 года назад +3

    My dictionary gets strained after watching sai deepak's talks

  • @parakhp9498
    @parakhp9498 4 года назад +5

    Kudos to anchor also who conducted himself patienly

  • @123KCKS
    @123KCKS 4 года назад +5

    Thanks for showing me the clearer picture.

  • @adityashelke5473
    @adityashelke5473 4 года назад +4

    I really want to make an appeal from the bottom of my heart for people to share this as much as possible!!!
    People need to know
    Thank you Adv. Sai Deepak for the insights.
    Really helps when facts are used in arguments because it frames a much clearer picture

  • @prabhanshukumar1109
    @prabhanshukumar1109 4 года назад +1

    Many more such logical points must be shared with the public. Thanks to Deepak sir! 👍

  • @priyanshukhati3256
    @priyanshukhati3256 4 года назад +9

    He is a legend....