The saddest thing is if you follow him, he runs all the way to Saint Denis, where the law recognizes him and guns him down. Further drives the point that they (Mark, John, Arthur) will never outrun the outlaw life.
I think he just turns into a random wanted NPC probably, because they probably didn't spend a ton of time programming this considering the dogshit consoles this was originally intended to run on. I like your story though. Maybe you're right and this was actually the tragic end. We'll never know!
3:26: “a man who thought he could just leave his outlaw past behind him and become a rancher and a family man. Well, the law don’t work that way Mr. marst….I mean Mr. Johnson.”
It's a masterpiece, Rockstar really knocked it out of the park. It really set an insanely high bar for GTA 6 that I'm not sure they'll be able to reach.
@@squirrelsinjacket1804mostly we should be skeptical because they made 90% of their money on online gameplay they may put less resources into the single player story and design and focus on online stuff only, which will really suck if they do
@@VergilTheLegendaryDarkSlayerthat’s what happened to mine. I saved one guy right as the rope dropped and tried to ride away but they shot my horse and it ran off and then I got gunned down. And when I reloaded it I never saw another character hang.
This is friggin' unbelievable. I have spent countless hours playing this game - too much than I want to admit - and I have NEVER seen any part of this other than the basic bounty scenario. It didn't even occur to me to kill his wife. It's insane how this game keeps surprising you after all these years. I almost think they're adding stuff to the game, but considering how they've done RDO dirty, I'm sure it was all in there from the beginning. RD2 is like a never-ending labyrinth.
@@rick3461i’d say it’s highly unlikely given the time and the supposed $2 BILLION budget it’s taking to make VI. And from what we’ve seen so far from the leaks and trailer. It’s safe to say this game will be detailed up the ASS!
The fact that a simple bounty can lead the player down such a deep and niche scenario that nearly no one knew about is crazy. It's insane how passionate the devs were when making this game.
Arthur: "You take care of that boy now. Go on!" Children of the deputies at the execution: "Ma, when is papa coming home?" Arthur: "Feelin like I forgot somethin... oh well."
This is why I keep coming back to this game. Even after so long and sooo many playthroughs. the game STILL surprises me with things that I've missed and the sheer number of outcomes that the developers thought of that I never knew could happen.. It's why this game is just on another level given the staggering attention to detail. Anyway, thanks for sharing.. thumbs up!
It's what separated it from pretty much all other games. I've never played a game as realistic as red dead 2. Usually NPCs are dumb as rocks and robotic. Starfield comes to mind lol.
@squirrelsinjacket1804 Totally. Starfield was a mile wide and a half inch deep. I would have preferred a smaller, more handcrafted and focused game to "ooo look we just procgenned the galaxy" The only places worth visiting and quests worth doing were the ones that were actually handcrafted by the dev team. Its so blindingly obvious the difference between the handcrafting and procgen that exploring outside of the handcreated areas gets real boring real fast.
@@childofcascadia Yup, I didn't even finish the game. Multiple times while playing I was wondering what they were thinking when giving you this awesome ship but it's just window dressing instead of a core part of the gameplay.
In my playthrough I just let him say goodbye to his family and surrender himself. You know a game is on another level when you feel actual guilt towards NPCs. I can only imagine what GTA 6 will be like.
by the way, if you kill his wife and son (using the mod) he will say in prison that you killed them both and that is crazy because you couldn't do it in the base game without mods and they put a special encounter for the occasion anyway
I tried leaving without collecting the bounty, to try and show mercy, and the mission just failed and I was forced to restart. It made me deeply disappointed.
No, you fool--Dan Houser and his key team ARE THE BEST. ROckstar is just the cashcow company they used to work to--and now that they left, Rockstar CANNOT make a game as good as this. You need talent, not a "Rockstar" name to make this kind of game. And now the talents have left.
Rockstar isn't what they used to was, just empty shell. Now they are greedy company who only enjoys corporate greed. Funny how they made RDR2 and had great plans for it and online and then abandoned it. Lets not forget this month when they banned innocent people with no reason and rolled back all those bans. Not even sorry. To hell Rockstar and what ever their next greedy game is. And as did Slavemi told, none of their great talented developers are left around anymore.
I am amazed by the fact that when Mr Johnson is going to be hanged, you can only antagonize him. Also, the simple fact that you shoot the rope make your honor lower because the game under stand that you are making this man free. So little details that I'm still amazed of after 5 years.
the amount of despair that was put on this man by killing his wife right in front of him, to serving jail time, and wanting to die but escaping death itself is next level
reactivity and dynamic narrative are underappreciated in RDR2 or mostly in games, how developers are lazy hiring writers. IE: BG3 how it's considers as an immersive sim respecting players freedom, since games is a form of escapism all along.
@@blakbear6528is the Witcher 3 really actually a game worth putting in the time like red dead 2 is? I’m on the 100% grind rn at 85% but I’ve always thought about the Witcher
@@wm2990 The sad thing is you are probably being overly optimistic here. It will drop in 2040 but the game will literally have as many outcomes as real life.
@@webcamrandomness14if there is a RDR3 it will come within 10 years. Remember the developers are getting old too, Rockstar aren’t immortal, they humans just like us and probably want to do one more for trilogy. So I think before 2030, hell even 2027 is probably the best year for RDR3 release
I know this shit is just a game but I have never once thought about doing that, and the fact that the devs knew that people would try that and let you do that really proves to me how much effort rockstar made to create this masterpiece.
Did not know there were multiple outcomes to side quests like this. Side quests in this game are basically RPG's. Wish you could manipulate the main story at this level too lol
Mark Johnson could have been a good character for influencing Arthur to change his ways, or at least making him think about it. Listening to Johnson trying to prepare his son was definitely difficult.
Interesting! It wouldn't have occurred to me to kill his wife, but it never ceases to amaze me how the devs thought of just about every possibility, and actually accounted for them 👍
I came across this hanging scene and I'm fairly sure I never collected his bounty because I don't remember him, but once i heard he was just trying to be a rancher, I saved him.
I really really wished there was an option to let Mark Johnson go when I first played it. I remembered being disappointed that you don’t get a prompt to just like, turn away and ignore what happens and to let him get away, the way Arthur later absolves the debt of that one woman and so on. I’m pretty sure you can do this bounty with John as well, right? So with John especially I feel like it should have been an option. You know, other than freeing him from being hanged
It should have been like the Mr Black and White mission were you can turn them in or let them go then they could still have this random encounter if you turn him in.
You guys are always cynical. People were cynical before Red Dead 2 dropped too and look how it turned out. Stop it. This is Rockstar. They know what they're doing
I doubt npc interactions will be so detailed. Gta is about doing crimes for more successful criminals in a city. If it does become like red dead in npc interactions and side quests, it will most likely feel bland and uninspired. Like, a random guy can just say "hey" and you can either greet him back or be an ass. This wont feel meaningful as there most likely wont be an honor system. And it seems that each new GTA only adds better ai, more interactions between that ai, more world content, and more graphical detail. The jiggle physics look amazing. Usually it's modders that do that. Anyways, I'm sure GTA6 will be great, but have low expectations for it to be more atmospheric in a meaningful and fluid way like Red dead.
Looks like you're playing this on quite a reasonable rig - good performance. And of course, RDR2 and it's detail and immersiveness is almost unparalleled. There were a bunch of moments when the game world felt 'real'.
É absurdamente incrível pensar q os desenvolvedores realmente pensaram nisso tudo. E é mais incrível ainda alguém fazer isso tudo sem q o jogo te indusa a fazer. Belo trabalho Mr 7
If you run into lemoyne raiders and follow them around u get some interesting dialogue and eventually they lead u to a camp or a fight with braithwates. All kinds of cool encounters
Only rockstar can make open world games that feel like an open world. You want to ride here ok, you want to kill this guy ok, you want to shoot birds fine, you want to catch fish go for it. Whatever you can imagine is already there in these games... every time rockstar has to show other devs how it's done.
thats something so many games are afraid to do because they'll lose sponsors and partnerships etc.: Allowing the player to embrace their villain fantasy. meanwhile Rockstar takes it a step further and gives you the option to let your victims suffer a greater hell than dialogue boxes.
Unreal! Can’t believe they anticipated, recorded and programmed all this dialogue. I mean how far do some of these goes. It’s been 5 years and we’re just now seeing this. Makes me wonder how many other scenarios are covered if you mess with the “normal” sequence of events.
Exactly. Sandbox games really are a reflection of the self - what would one do to everyone else if there were no consequences? GTA & RDR are great mirrors which reveal the answer.
i am gonna be honest, the voice actor for this specific character is pretty bad, especially for rockstar standards. I personally couldn't feel sorry for the character because he didn't convey any emotion.
It's amazing how in so many situations the NPC's say "They", showing how the game originally was meant for you to travel with your gang or at a few members of it all the time.
It's insane how this NPC's life is literally similar to John's life. The attention to detail is absurd, it makes you wonder how much detail will be in GTA 6, given how much longer it had to develop.
Imagine how unhinged Arthur must seem if you're an NPC in this game. Dood just shows up and deletes your wife for no reason, then shows up to rescue you from the gallows just because.
The fact that Arthur can compensate for killing a mother and a wife just by wishing 3 strangers a good morning in saint denis.
“Hey there mister” is just too powerful of a line
“You know what, I’m feeling good today”
Maybe those strangers are husbands and fathers
@@Sebastian62608 and "Hey fellers"
I did that for 3 hours honnor still not go up again to be full honnor . So The saying hello is not that good annymore
Mark Johnson is an analogy of John Marston.
A former outlaw turned family man who turned his life around but his past caught up with him
Anagram?
There’s no K in John Marston
@@JacobEnglander Imagine "Mart Johnson"
Wow nothing gets past you does it?
@@oofowie8882 wow you're like a black woman in hindsight
The saddest thing is if you follow him, he runs all the way to Saint Denis, where the law recognizes him and guns him down. Further drives the point that they (Mark, John, Arthur) will never outrun the outlaw life.
you followed him?
@@Original-Phantom yeah in a few play thrus. This happens each time. Kinda wanted to see if he made it back to his family but he doesnt.
@@reginaangelica751But what if you kill the laws in Saint Denis?
@@UserHey He keeps running until he gets killed.
I think he just turns into a random wanted NPC probably, because they probably didn't spend a ton of time programming this considering the dogshit consoles this was originally intended to run on. I like your story though. Maybe you're right and this was actually the tragic end. We'll never know!
I love how after he shoots his wife in front of him he just casually says “just tisnt your day is it” like it’s another day in the office
he's a smooth operator.
For Mr. Johnson it was a tragedy.
For Arthur it was just Tuesday.
Well back in their day. That WAS the office!
Thats some Walking Dead Negan crap
That’s like some Jack Walker shit
3:26: “a man who thought he could just leave his outlaw past behind him and become a rancher and a family man. Well, the law don’t work that way Mr. marst….I mean Mr. Johnson.”
yeah Mark Johnson, John Marston...
I did this mission as John so it was very fitting.
@@GeneralUlyssesGrant See I’ve always had it with Arthur. I didn’t even know it was possible to do with John!
Names Jarston,
Mohn Jarston
John would probably be sweating if he did that bounty
The fact that they hang the bounties you bring in a couple days later is so cool. Man I love this game
It's a masterpiece, Rockstar really knocked it out of the park. It really set an insanely high bar for GTA 6 that I'm not sure they'll be able to reach.
@@squirrelsinjacket1804mostly we should be skeptical because they made 90% of their money on online gameplay they may put less resources into the single player story and design and focus on online stuff only, which will really suck if they do
Sometimes the bounties remain in the cell even after the epilogue
@@VergilTheLegendaryDarkSlayerthat’s what happened to mine. I saved one guy right as the rope dropped and tried to ride away but they shot my horse and it ran off and then I got gunned down. And when I reloaded it I never saw another character hang.
Reactivity is underappreciated as dynamic narrative
This is friggin' unbelievable. I have spent countless hours playing this game - too much than I want to admit - and I have NEVER seen any part of this other than the basic bounty scenario. It didn't even occur to me to kill his wife. It's insane how this game keeps surprising you after all these years. I almost think they're adding stuff to the game, but considering how they've done RDO dirty, I'm sure it was all in there from the beginning. RD2 is like a never-ending labyrinth.
This game is truly one of those "once in lifetime" masterpieces.
@@aominetaiga343That's why I'm afraid GTA6 will be a huge letdown.
@@rick3461i’d say it’s highly unlikely given the time and the supposed $2 BILLION budget it’s taking to make VI. And from what we’ve seen so far from the leaks and trailer. It’s safe to say this game will be detailed up the ASS!
I wouldn't worry if anything Rockstar has proven they always go bigger and badder @@rick3461
@@rick3461let down? It’s being built specifically for PS5. Red dead was made on the ps4. We are gonna see some crazy stuff in gta 6
That hanging dialogue is an exact foreshadow/analogy to John Marston at the end of RDR1…crazy
“The law don’t work that way”
💔
The fact that a simple bounty can lead the player down such a deep and niche scenario that nearly no one knew about is crazy. It's insane how passionate the devs were when making this game.
John Marston = Mark Johnson
“John Mar” Something I noticed is their names are similar.
winkler
@@heymrmiyagivan
rip@@JosukeReal
No shit Sherlock
Well, aren't you just the smartest cookie in the jar
Arthur: "You take care of that boy now. Go on!"
Children of the deputies at the execution: "Ma, when is papa coming home?"
Arthur: "Feelin like I forgot somethin... oh well."
This is why I keep coming back to this game. Even after so long and sooo many playthroughs. the game STILL surprises me with things that I've missed and the sheer number of outcomes that the developers thought of that I never knew could happen.. It's why this game is just on another level given the staggering attention to detail. Anyway, thanks for sharing.. thumbs up!
It's what separated it from pretty much all other games. I've never played a game as realistic as red dead 2. Usually NPCs are dumb as rocks and robotic. Starfield comes to mind lol.
@@squirrelsinjacket1804Starfield 😂
Starfield is definitely a game of all time.
@squirrelsinjacket1804
Totally. Starfield was a mile wide and a half inch deep.
I would have preferred a smaller, more handcrafted and focused game to "ooo look we just procgenned the galaxy"
The only places worth visiting and quests worth doing were the ones that were actually handcrafted by the dev team. Its so blindingly obvious the difference between the handcrafting and procgen that exploring outside of the handcreated areas gets real boring real fast.
@@childofcascadia Yup, I didn't even finish the game. Multiple times while playing I was wondering what they were thinking when giving you this awesome ship but it's just window dressing instead of a core part of the gameplay.
@@squirrelsinjacket1804 Did you pay $100 to get early access? I did and now I willl never trust bethesda again. 😢
The speech before he’s hung is exactly what happens to John in rdr1
Killing his wife was ruthless, omg
You're a good man Arthur Morgan.
its a game you will be alright lol
Wow. What a variety of choices. The developers have provided all possible scenarios that can only come to the player's mind. Bravo
you don’t have to kill his wife to save him for those wondering
In my playthrough I just let him say goodbye to his family and surrender himself. You know a game is on another level when you feel actual guilt towards NPCs. I can only imagine what GTA 6 will be like.
@squirrelsinjacket1804 Probably not as good as you're hoping, since all the main guys at Rockstar left after this game.
Yea it's odd after freeing him and his fine w/ that, thought it's going to be a lot questioning after, I guess writers didn expect thay. 😅
@@squirrelsinjacket1804To be continued in 2-4 years…
@@R3TR0J4N Yeah if you're going to straight up Joker playthrough, I think you're going to hit the limits of what any dev can account for.
The line "we are what we've done" goes hard.
This game has so much to offer.
The amount of detail in this game really is amazing lol this is ridiculous
by the way, if you kill his wife and son (using the mod) he will say in prison that you killed them both and that is crazy because you couldn't do it in the base game without mods and they put a special encounter for the occasion anyway
What happens if you kill them both in the base game? Or just kill the son?
@@deathsbane0 children are invincible in the base game, so it's not possible without a mod.
@@kahashikunnot all are the kid at Catfish jacksons and the street gang kids. But a few are most games will not let you kill kids.
@@deathsbane0sorry for late response
@@deathsbane0 as this kind man said you aint really allowed to to kill children in the base game
I tried leaving without collecting the bounty, to try and show mercy, and the mission just failed and I was forced to restart.
It made me deeply disappointed.
I didn’t even know you can free him. Even after all these years, I’m still finding new things about this game.
And that's why, Rockstar is THE Best.
Nice videos mate, Keep it up 🙌👌
No, you fool--Dan Houser and his key team ARE THE BEST. ROckstar is just the cashcow company they used to work to--and now that they left, Rockstar CANNOT make a game as good as this. You need talent, not a "Rockstar" name to make this kind of game. And now the talents have left.
Rockstar isn't what they used to was, just empty shell. Now they are greedy company who only enjoys corporate greed. Funny how they made RDR2 and had great plans for it and online and then abandoned it. Lets not forget this month when they banned innocent people with no reason and rolled back all those bans. Not even sorry. To hell Rockstar and what ever their next greedy game is. And as did Slavemi told, none of their great talented developers are left around anymore.
smiping for a company...
you all deserve the dystopia.
Its nothing new , game is 5years old we saw this stuff already several of times
Blud what? How does free fire youtuber watches rdr 2 videos it's rare because rdr2 is underrated 😂😂
You really do learn a new rdr2 detail everyday 😂
I am amazed by the fact that when Mr Johnson is going to be hanged, you can only antagonize him. Also, the simple fact that you shoot the rope make your honor lower because the game under stand that you are making this man free. So little details that I'm still amazed of after 5 years.
the amount of despair that was put on this man by killing his wife right in front of him, to serving jail time, and wanting to die but escaping death itself is next level
This is basically John's story, except instead of getting hung he got blasted
Rdr2 is the most detailed game in history
RDR 2, The witcher 3, and Fallout new vegas are the only games I can think of that have little details like this
reactivity and dynamic narrative are underappreciated in RDR2 or mostly in games, how developers are lazy hiring writers. IE: BG3 how it's considers as an immersive sim respecting players freedom, since games is a form of escapism all along.
Mass Effect managed to carry a story across three games, now that's attention to detail
@@blakbear6528is the Witcher 3 really actually a game worth putting in the time like red dead 2 is? I’m on the 100% grind rn at 85% but I’ve always thought about the Witcher
MIND = BLOWN. Can't even imagine how legendary RDR3 will be.
Can’t wait until 2031 when they release the trailer
@@wm2990 The sad thing is you are probably being overly optimistic here.
It will drop in 2040 but the game will literally have as many outcomes as real life.
@@webcamrandomness14if there is a RDR3 it will come within 10 years. Remember the developers are getting old too, Rockstar aren’t immortal, they humans just like us and probably want to do one more for trilogy. So I think before 2030, hell even 2027 is probably the best year for RDR3 release
@@cjc4426 2-5 years after GTA6 release? Never
mind what D:
I know this shit is just a game but I have never once thought about doing that, and the fact that the devs knew that people would try that and let you do that really proves to me how much effort rockstar made to create this masterpiece.
Did not know there were multiple outcomes to side quests like this. Side quests in this game are basically RPG's. Wish you could manipulate the main story at this level too lol
Everyone would just kill micah 😂
Arthur: You take care of that boy now. Go on!
Man: **GPS Located, running towards his son in straight line**
Mark Johnson could have been a good character for influencing Arthur to change his ways, or at least making him think about it. Listening to Johnson trying to prepare his son was definitely difficult.
Interesting! It wouldn't have occurred to me to kill his wife, but it never ceases to amaze me how the devs thought of just about every possibility, and actually accounted for them 👍
I should hope not
@@juliandavidhoffer2022🤓
@@juliandavidhoffer2022for real lol
I’m a sicko and it did occur to me long before this vid lol
I came across this hanging scene and I'm fairly sure I never collected his bounty because I don't remember him, but once i heard he was just trying to be a rancher, I saved him.
I followed him around to see if he goes back to his family. All he does is circle around Lemoyne
Like anybody saved))
I really really wished there was an option to let Mark Johnson go when I first played it. I remembered being disappointed that you don’t get a prompt to just like, turn away and ignore what happens and to let him get away, the way Arthur later absolves the debt of that one woman and so on. I’m pretty sure you can do this bounty with John as well, right? So with John especially I feel like it should have been an option.
You know, other than freeing him from being hanged
It should have been like the Mr Black and White mission were you can turn them in or let them go then they could still have this random encounter if you turn him in.
I'm afraid to die before learning everything about this game.
I felt the same with Tibia since I started playing it and now I feel the same with RDR2
Can't wait to see how this kind of attention to detail will translate to modern day Vice City
There gonna focus on online more then story mode unfortunately
You guys are always cynical. People were cynical before Red Dead 2 dropped too and look how it turned out. Stop it. This is Rockstar. They know what they're doing
once they did with Leslie and Dan but it’s a whole new beast now, especially after the ‘success’ of GtaO
I doubt npc interactions will be so detailed. Gta is about doing crimes for more successful criminals in a city. If it does become like red dead in npc interactions and side quests, it will most likely feel bland and uninspired. Like, a random guy can just say "hey" and you can either greet him back or be an ass. This wont feel meaningful as there most likely wont be an honor system. And it seems that each new GTA only adds better ai, more interactions between that ai, more world content, and more graphical detail. The jiggle physics look amazing. Usually it's modders that do that. Anyways, I'm sure GTA6 will be great, but have low expectations for it to be more atmospheric in a meaningful and fluid way like Red dead.
@@kennaneanderson8137 this comment makes absolutely no sense
That was kool, no hearted Arthur is really a bad mfker. I'm gna do my third playthrough as him✊🏽😂
Oh wow third playthru nice
Same here. I'm gonna be as bad as possible.
Grammar?
That’s going to be fun! I will say this, though… greet/greet/antagonize with no honor John is hilarious!
@@louismazzei5862 omg they are funny af
Looks like you're playing this on quite a reasonable rig - good performance. And of course, RDR2 and it's detail and immersiveness is almost unparalleled. There were a bunch of moments when the game world felt 'real'.
É absurdamente incrível pensar q os desenvolvedores realmente pensaram nisso tudo. E é mais incrível ainda alguém fazer isso tudo sem q o jogo te indusa a fazer. Belo trabalho Mr 7
If you run into lemoyne raiders and follow them around u get some interesting dialogue and eventually they lead u to a camp or a fight with braithwates. All kinds of cool encounters
someone made a lore for a random npc 😵😭
That kid gonna turn into a protagonist for a revenge based plot for a movie
His last name is even JOHNson, they knew what they were doing.
And here I expected the kid to turn in a blood thirsty murderer out for vengeance raking in the largest bounty of the west
And people hate Rockstar? God, this game is such a perfection!
Who hates rockstar..?
@@oofowie8882
Probs cuz GTA VI ain't out yet 😭
noone hates Rockstar
People hate Rockstar because they abandoned Red Dead Online and have been making GTAO worse for profit.
Two things can be true: RDR2 is great, and the remastered trilogy is cashgrab dogshit.
The speech at the gallows was basically a synopsis of the first red dead. Lol
Devs can think of alot of things. It takes skill to actually do it. With no skill you end up with starfield and diablo 4
That was about the best western cinematic short I’ve seen in years 😅
Only rockstar can make open world games that feel like an open world. You want to ride here ok, you want to kill this guy ok, you want to shoot birds fine, you want to catch fish go for it. Whatever you can imagine is already there in these games... every time rockstar has to show other devs how it's done.
I wanted to find a spot I could build my own cabin but that’s not possible
@@sas_soldier8884😂😂😂😂
The soundtrack from this mission is my favorite!
thats something so many games are afraid to do because they'll lose sponsors and partnerships etc.: Allowing the player to embrace their villain fantasy.
meanwhile Rockstar takes it a step further and gives you the option to let your victims suffer a greater hell than dialogue boxes.
The atention to details like this is just insane
This is actually fucking insane.
right??
3:10 The subtle foreshadowing of John’s fate
but why would u have to kill his wife to rescue him? or is it for the dialouge?
For the dialogue.
"you're a good man arthur"
This is a great example that separates a rockstar game from the rest of the industry.
This is exactly what years later john would try to do, escape the past, become a rancher.
3:26 John uh I mean Mark
I mean damn, can you maybe free him without having to kill his wife for no reason? Thats pretty fucked up.
you don't have to kill his wife to do so.
"your a good man author morgan"
Yeah GTA 6 ain't touching this game
You gonna eat your words
Unreal!
Can’t believe they anticipated, recorded and programmed all this dialogue. I mean how far do some of these goes. It’s been 5 years and we’re just now seeing this. Makes me wonder how many other scenarios are covered if you mess with the “normal” sequence of events.
tf u killed his wife for
Being evil and cruel
showing how detailed the game is, with unique dialogue for each action you may take
Thats the thing, nobody in their right mind would do so, but R* actually took it into account.
This is the best example of attention to detail Ive ever seen in this game, this is a whole different level.
This is pretty good never knew this
the way his hands go up whenever arthur points the gun at him
2:14 lol Israeli proverb
free israel
"You're a good man arthur morgan"
Ok, but what on earth is the point in killing his wife?
Exactly. Sandbox games really are a reflection of the self - what would one do to everyone else if there were no consequences? GTA & RDR are great mirrors which reveal the answer.
To show how detailed the game's dialogue is
Bro understood the assignment
What if you kill the boy instead the wife ?
You can't lol
You Can't because Its BOI
Boi?
@@tomelliott90 gow boi
@@tomelliott90”boi” is something r.e.t.a.r.d.e.d. ninth graders say to sound cool.
He sent him on his villain arc
i am gonna be honest, the voice actor for this specific character is pretty bad, especially for rockstar standards. I personally couldn't feel sorry for the character because he didn't convey any emotion.
1:31 that comment from Arthur.. bruuhhh
Love your videos ❤❤❤❤
Can you get this without killing the wife? Like as far as I can tell the woman did not need to be murdered.
Take the guy to jail then free him.
I can take this😢😢😢 why did you kill his wife ?
To check the secret outcomes
I like the subtle nod to RDR1 towards the end. Being a changed man doesn't change the crimes you've committed.
Developers when they have to think about every possibility to every situation
It's amazing how in so many situations the NPC's say "They", showing how the game originally was meant for you to travel with your gang or at a few members of it all the time.
3:16 Sounds familiar 😂
The absolutely chaotic nature of these events is so baffling to watch
I could never do this even on my most dishonorable playthrough. When I do renegade runs in games I can only go so far lol.
It's insane how this NPC's life is literally similar to John's life.
The attention to detail is absurd, it makes you wonder how much detail will be in GTA 6, given how much longer it had to develop.
the fact that the devs let arthur kill an innocent wife
The fact that didn’t win Goty that year is still criminal
I don’t remember killing his wife when I played it
wow that messed up. killing her like that and then setting him free of all things... just wow
"I shall spare you death Mr. Johnson. On one condition... Life for a life..."
“Just isn’t your day, is it?”
The parallels to john marston is kinda crazy.
Imagine how unhinged Arthur must seem if you're an NPC in this game. Dood just shows up and deletes your wife for no reason, then shows up to rescue you from the gallows just because.
The only time losing honor can feel right
ngl this was intersting but mark johnson is a hell of a sprinter
Bro gave that kid his origin story
Broke my heart when the kid said momma
Spooky sense of irony what the hangman was saying like it was directed right at John Marston.