PAKISTANI WAY OF WAR : SALVAGING VICTORY FROM DEFEAT / LT GEN PR SHANKAR (R)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 июн 2024
- #GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
GUNNERS SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to +91 9384855773
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT RUclips CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot9829
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot9829
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot9829
Gunners Shot RUclips Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaEZ...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT
Excellent review of the psyche of Pakistan and it’s armed forces. The psyche of Mr Sethi seems to be the same as the public. Thanks Sir
More than the facts, thanks for enabling us to know abt the way to deal with things. Great insights Sir.
Amazing analyze sir ❤ jai hind
Superb introduction & analysis Sir!
You are the best sir!!! Your thorough understanding of military subjects and your continuous attempts to explain it to public audience is commendable.
Very good and informative series.
A rare insight of the concept of war! Thank you General, Sir, for this rich presentation. Jay jay siyaram! The ideological war with Hindu India is explicit within India. Will love to have your views on how to control it? जय जय सियाराम!
hmm
Its easy to win all wars when the public doesn't hold the politicians and the army accountable to their lies. Army losses every war, has countless citizen killed and then publicly hold parades to state they won the war. It is not a one sided equation. The army and the politicians are willing to lie and the citizenry is willing to accept their lies readily. The behavior and values of the politicians, Army and its people are the same. To the Pakistanis anything is fair when its against India.
VERY DEEP INFORMATION SIR MAIN TO SOCHTA THA KI MUJHE PAKISTAN KE BAARE ME BAHUT KUCH PATA HAI.
Sir , can you do a podcast on how the future of Gen Asim Munir is going vis a vis Imran Khan’s influence and Pak power dynamics ……who might be the next Pak Army Chief and if Munir will scuttle him or there might be a more Imran supporting Pak Army Corps Comdrs grouping that might change the politico - military dynamics going ahead in time ??!!
Finally the role of the judiciary in the interplay between the Pak Army - Politicians and Judiciary ?? 🎉
Will do
A very thoughtful episode...
Sir link up with maj Gaurav aarya and promote this wonderful channel
Hmm
You help me promote the channel.
This is the insight which only an ex service man can say who has faced the enemy
Bhaiji this is a big problem of Indian military at present. A small group took part in action in Kargil after 1971 means 28 yrs after. If any one got in military after 71 war he must hv become Gen Officer without seeing any real action. If any one who didn't participate in Kargil certainly he must retired without even witnessing the real action. Ist of all why Kargil intrusion happened at all when you have Air Force / as well as Army helicopters also? If happened why not cought soon after if not during by having regular observation flights or why not percived? This prrcievement n planning is only the task of Top brass not the patrols. That is why Musarraf is not wrong in narrative, listen to his interviews on it as neutral person.
Had it not been fiercest political intervention of Atalji by isolating Pak n forcing its Airforce n Army from supporting their intruders it could have been the case of POK. How much blood Soldiers sheded to recapture it even from the isolated/ stand alone intruders? Imagine if supplies n communication maintained, had it not been POK?
Why? Because failure of percievement abt thei vulnerability of Kargil like place and plan to avoiding it of then serving and a flood on MSM & You Tube Retd Gen. Col. Now.
Jaraa Map dekhana bhai Kargil ka fir sochana ki jungal se bhare adjacent abandoned plot se ek slant tree aapke courtyard me jhuka hai toh snakes rats cats aayenge ya nahi? Toh aap usaka kuchh intzam karenge ya nahi yaa saap aapake aage hi aayegaa peechhe nahi?
Theek hai izzat karo leki Bhavana me mat baho bhai socho
Root of the problem is that islam needs reform.
I'm sure such careful analysis of the enemy is done in military colleges and during war gaming scenarios. Which is why Bharat doesn't lose wars brought onto us. Great insights!
Interesting analysis of Pakistan vis a vis India. Although the 2 nation theory is the foundational principle of Pakistan, it seems that its conflict with India stems from the lack of clarity about its own identity. If the Pakistan state and its military see themselves as the sword-arm of Islam vs. India as the ‘inferior’ Hindu non believers, surely it would be ideologically conflicted with a China too, particularly since it (China) persecutes its own ethnic Muslim minority. By that same logic of a common ideology, it should be at peace with Afghanistan.
It seems like Pakistan’s real issue with India is historical; that the circumstances of history, which began with the rise of the Marathas that dealt a blow to Islamic rule in undivided India, the end of colonialism and undivided India’s emergence as an independent democratic nation, turned the tables on them, when Hindus became the ruling class. So every military conflict that Pakistan loses against India, is strangely viewed as a victory by its military, perhaps because it is seen as attempts at rectifying the historical reversal of roles.
It also seems to have geopolitical reasons, as envisaged in the classic Chanakya model, where it sees India as its enemy, which makes China a friend, since China and India are adversaries. As General Ravi Shankar rightly observes, it is India’s rapid economic advancement that will deliver that political defeat to Pakistan’s military.
Of India. How to encourage it is a big question which India to think about .
Think of the India ---your country
The good General is trying to demystify the Pakistan problem. It is not really that complicated if you understand Islam and what is written in their holy books😅, the one book I hope is covered is The Quranic concept of war by Brigadier SK Malik
Sir, we cannot fight an ideology that is fixed... we only waste our time hoping there is an evolution, alas............
Ghanna shot. What is the type of weapons being used at the beginning of each video ?
And what is the range ?
Why you are worried?
It looks like a brahmos missile, with a range of 290-500 KM.
You will know when it hits you
Worried?
@@gunnersshot9829 hopefuly you dont misfire into china. I cannot imagine the response🤣
Dear Sir
Excellent analysis. Following Topics are missing
Two nations theory
Theological and doctrinal basis of thinking.
Aided and abetted by the west and prompted by China.
Excess size at time of partition with respect to geography
We have to be preemptive, grow exponentially
hmm
एक घंटे में 19 भीव 46 लाइक । ai hai?
Kulbhushan Yadav must be freed
hmm
Haar ke jitne wale ko bazigar kehte hai😂
Ha ha
Sir,
There is a gentleman called Prof Ishtiyaque Ahmed. He is a Head Of Department in some University of Sweden. This man has written 4 or 5 authoritative books on Pakistan. He is in some ways a historian who has collected credible evidence of different important juncture in Pakistan. He is unbiased and has described how Pakistan has always been the aggressor and has always been defeated by India and what are the lies they propagate. You can do a scholarly and well-informed talk with him if you invite him. Lastly, he talks very well.
Hmm
This professor also has the same mindset mildly different from others.
Sir you sometimes says we should make #Pakistan #Army pay the price on loc because their behavior will not change and sometimes you say not giving them battles is the best #India can do so they will die their own death
What should be India's response ?
Hot and cold
Free Kashmir Free Khalistan
hmm
WHY YOU WANT TO HANDAL PAKISTAN? ITS THE SAME WHY NOT HANDAL INDIA?
Ha ha
Hindus are poor fighters. Sikhism developped as army of the Hindus. But, now Khalistan thought process is working against Hindus
hmm
Your intellect is as immature as a puberty hit youth.
Is it wrong to say that Pak army despite much smaller than Indian mammoth had always effective initiative except 1971. OK we ulrimately got Kargil back but at what cost? If they could observe the gap, why not like you Indian Gen n blocked those or kept watch so that theee incursion coul hv detected at the nascent level n thwarted?
So how many Indian army top brass accepted their unexcusable complacency n how many head rolled?
So they lie on outcome but good initiative n ours attribut their initiative failure to this & that n later boast on outcomes which couldn't have taken place if remained just alert. No?
I hv read probbly Major Gen. RS Verma himself took initistive to detect the Aksaichin Road in 60s or Air Mshl Barbora to operationalise DBO even by keeping cowardice UPA govt in dark.
So Ist boldly accept that Happening of Kargil was a gross failure of Indian military ss a whole n Indian Army in particular n Lt Gen. Budhwar precisely
No Sir?
FIXED IDEAS
@gunnersshot9829 Sir little deliberation it desrve not a Hikaarat to reality? No?
We Have to use resources for development work unlike Pak Army which runs the country.
Our is Democracy unlike Pak
We did not get easy money like Pak as they sold themselves to US interest
TM JASA COMPLECATED ANEMAL KASHMER MA NAHE RAH SAKTA.
Hmm
TM BAHRTE KHUD APNY DSMAN HO.
Hmm