Quran prohibits any compulsion in religion (2:256). The Prophet was specifically directed by God "You are not there to compel them to believe" Quran 50:39. And none can change God's words (6:115). President of Islamic Information Center, confirms "No death Penalty" for apostates.
@@themurtad821 how is that my fault and if u dont then you'll regret it. Tell me why did u leave maybe I can get rid of tour doubts. Also the death penalty is applicable after the person is given 3 days to repent and if they have been captured by the authority
@@nightblades6239 because your religion is a Cult of a pedophile suicide bomber? You have no Right to force me to accept your primitive beliefs like flying on a donkey for example. And then killing me as if I’m your slave. Maybe that’s why I will never return
@@nightblades6239 your not following the Quran or the prophet end of discussion your a "false muslim" anyone who wants the death of another simply for leaving the faith is a "falls Muslim"
This video is incomplete. There are more hadiths. What if a person leaves Islam & does no harm to Islam, does not brag about it?? As far as I know, shariah law has nothing to do with him/her except letting him/her go.
but how can we reconcile this with verse 89 and 90 of Sura Nisa. and when Allah mentioned in the quran about those who change their religion every now and then that Allah won't accept their repentance. so if it is mentioned that they change their religion back and forth how does this show that they were killed the first time they changed their faith JAZAKALLAHU KHAIRAN
It is referring to a specific type of ppl who take advantage of the religion and mess with it. U know the ppl who say “when u convert, all of ur sins are wiped away”? Some sleazy munafiqs took advantage but Allah clearly says that u can’t do this. As the sheikh mentioned, u can’t be executed for simply converting out of Islam. The authorities can decide if u have taken it to an extent where u are the enemy of Allah and his messenger. But authorities have studied sharia for their whole lives, I’m sure they’ll justly take care of the situation
So let me explain better: A person who leaves islam wants to do suicide and by no means doesn't want to return to islam. because he would kill himself either way. You are telling us that YOU ARE GOING TO HELP HIM GET DEAD?
Narrated 'Ikrima: Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to 'Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn 'Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Apostle forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Apostle, 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
I don’t trust this narration seeing that burning anybody is one of the gravest sins you can do and I don’t think that one of the best followers of Islam Ali RA would’ve done it.
Thats why all bukhari hadeeths are not sahih...we should only accept hadeeths that dont contradict religion...if the bible of isa as can be corrupted and the torah of moses then surely bukhari could have been too.
The reason they are sahih are because they are in line with the Quran. Scholars of much greater caliber than you have decided the hadiths are in agreement with the quran thats why they graded those hadiths sahih.
Its reported in Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Sunan Ibn Majah, Sunan an-Nasa'i, Jami` at-Tirmidhi, Sunan Abu Dawood. First 2 authentic by themselves independently, but we have 4 more corroborating reports that the prophet actually said it. Its undoubtedly true.
I dont follow his views I follow Dr Shabbir Allys views on this and basically most rulings in Islamic law. Dr Shabbir Ally explains why apostates should not be punished, adulterers should not be stoned, and homosexuals should not be punished
Quran prohibits any compulsion in religion (2:256). The Prophet was specifically directed by God "You are not there to compel them to believe" Quran 50:39. And none can change God's words (6:115). President of Islamic Information Center, confirms "No death Penalty" for apostates.
There is a death penalty
@@nightblades6239 That’s why I’m never returning to Islam thanks to you Brother 😂😆🤦♂️
@@themurtad821 how is that my fault and if u dont then you'll regret it. Tell me why did u leave maybe I can get rid of tour doubts. Also the death penalty is applicable after the person is given 3 days to repent and if they have been captured by the authority
@@nightblades6239 because your religion is a Cult of a pedophile suicide bomber? You have no Right to force me to accept your primitive beliefs like flying on a donkey for example. And then killing me as if I’m your slave. Maybe that’s why I will never return
@@nightblades6239 your not following the Quran or the prophet end of discussion your a "false muslim" anyone who wants the death of another simply for leaving the faith is a "falls Muslim"
This video is incomplete. There are more hadiths. What if a person leaves Islam & does no harm to Islam, does not brag about it?? As far as I know, shariah law has nothing to do with him/her except letting him/her go.
It has never been that way in practice throughout history.
@@lvsoad22 Surah 2 ayat 79. They always just fumble around and pretend it's not there. They will be rejected janah
Yeah and that makes it ok
but how can we reconcile this with verse 89 and 90 of Sura Nisa. and when Allah mentioned in the quran about those who change their religion every now and then that Allah won't accept their repentance.
so if it is mentioned that they change their religion back and forth how does this show that they were killed the first time they changed their faith
JAZAKALLAHU KHAIRAN
It is referring to a specific type of ppl who take advantage of the religion and mess with it. U know the ppl who say “when u convert, all of ur sins are wiped away”? Some sleazy munafiqs took advantage but Allah clearly says that u can’t do this. As the sheikh mentioned, u can’t be executed for simply converting out of Islam. The authorities can decide if u have taken it to an extent where u are the enemy of Allah and his messenger. But authorities have studied sharia for their whole lives, I’m sure they’ll justly take care of the situation
@@2shotmj921 thank u so much for the clarification
May Allah bless u and grant u an excellent end
@@amiramz7869 jazakallahu khair, ameen. May Allah continue to grant u more knowledge
@@2shotmj921 ameen
@Simpsons LOL XD Ik, but if u want to be closer to Allah, I’d recommend it
So let me explain better:
A person who leaves islam wants to do suicide and by no means doesn't want to return to islam.
because he would kill himself either way. You are telling us that YOU ARE GOING TO HELP HIM GET DEAD?
Jazakallahu Khaira.
Narrated 'Ikrima:
Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to 'Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn 'Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Apostle forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Apostle, 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
I don’t trust you
that was a specific situation
I don’t trust this narration seeing that burning anybody is one of the gravest sins you can do and I don’t think that one of the best followers of Islam Ali RA would’ve done it.
at the time of war
Not at the time of peace
Thats why all bukhari hadeeths are not sahih...we should only accept hadeeths that dont contradict religion...if the bible of isa as can be corrupted and the torah of moses then surely bukhari could have been too.
The reason they are sahih are because they are in line with the Quran. Scholars of much greater caliber than you have decided the hadiths are in agreement with the quran thats why they graded those hadiths sahih.
@@KaauhurKSo naive. Who appointed these scholars and which verse does this nonsense go in line with?
No human work can be completely free from error or mistakes . Same with hadeeth. Only Quran which is 100 % correct
Its reported in Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Sunan Ibn Majah, Sunan an-Nasa'i, Jami` at-Tirmidhi, Sunan Abu Dawood. First 2 authentic by themselves independently, but we have 4 more corroborating reports that the prophet actually said it. Its undoubtedly true.
But can an apostat be forgiven if he returned to islam
Yes
Yes until person dies
YES BUT MAKE TAWBAH AND RETAKE THE SHAHADAH SEARCH UP ON RUclips HOW TO MAKE TAWBAH
ruclips.net/video/69jZH9ohNCI/видео.html
why not. do repentance before your death.
In summary;
👳♀️'I've thought about it and tbh, Islam is a little too much for me to swallow.'
⚔
💀
This guy's views are extreme, he does not represent mainstream view
@Lol Rofl Or because Islam demands judicial murder for rejecting supposed truth.
I dont follow his views I follow Dr Shabbir Allys views on this and basically most rulings in Islamic law. Dr Shabbir Ally explains why apostates should not be punished, adulterers should not be stoned, and homosexuals should not be punished
ruclips.net/video/69jZH9ohNCI/видео.html
@@nj5587 Lol. That's the correct form of Islam based on hadiths.