Well Roger Waters and Rick Wright sang a lot too, but David Gilmour and David’s guitar make 4. 😀 I actually felt bad that I left them out. 🙁 I read somewhere that Nick Mason the drummer never sang one note ever.
@@josephjohnson5056 If you count-in creating new music with Floyd. Yes both in the studio and live, which is also a part of songwriting. In the sense of lyrics, maybe but it's not registered as such.
I saw the Pulse concert live in 1994. Lots of people claim that Pink Floyd was at there peak during the Wall. They must have not seen Pulse! I didn’t miss Waters at all! If Richard Wright hadn’t got sick with cancer and passed away, there is no telling what we could have seen. To me, Pulse was Pink Floyd’s peak. So many good songs added to their catalog with early Waters songs. Songs we might have not had if Waters had stayed with the band. Sorrow, Coming Back To Life, On The Turning Away, Poles Apart, High Hopes and Learning To Fly just to name a few.
im kinda torn. this era of floyd was fantastic. I had seen them in 88 and 84 got to see roger in the 90's and the wall 2010's. Ive always wonderd what floyd would have truely sounded like had it not self destructed.. my childhood was floyd. i always wished i was born sooner than 74
@@sonus289: Don’t know what planet you are from, but Pink Floyd never self destructed. Roger Waters left the band. But the band kept on going without Waters and never really missed a beat. They released some very successful albums without Waters and sold out concert events everywhere they went. Arenas and stadiums. Pink Floyd disbanded upon Richard Wright’s death. Most of us real fans never missed Waters. I think ol Roger got an unpleasant surprise. He assumed that the band would die off at his departure. I think he grossly underestimated Dave, Richard and Nick. And the fans. Roger left on his own accord and got quite pissy after the band carried on without him. Kind of bruised his massive ego! Roger should have remembered that they also carried on with Syd. Who was at the time, the bands primary song writer, vocalist and guitarist. Yet the band flourished without Syd Barrett. Pink Floyd proved they could survive and be successful without Roger Waters.
@@jamesrice4158 Agreed, but having Gary Wallis as a 2nd percussionist I think was a mistake. He's nothing but an attention hound riding on the coattails of legends. Just my two cents.
It takes an entire band to create a masterpiece of music such as Sorrow, not just Gilmour, or Watters, or Wright, but all of them. I can never get enough of Pink Floyd!!!
When Floyd snobs make statements that they were finished because "Roger left" I know I don't have to listen to anything else they have to spout on about because THIS exists, and it's sublime.
Yes. And the song "On the Turning Away." Hands down two of the 3 most beautiful songs of the Gilmour era ("High Hopes") completing the troika. My fave era of the PF.
Их можно слушать вечно ! Это не группа , это - создание природы , их музыка за гранью , никогда нельзя прослушать в полном объёме , постоянно слушаешь что-то одно , то гитару , то голос , то сакс ... !!! Слушаю с 1975-го года , ничего подобного - НЕТ ! Гилмор - эпоха , его гитара - родник звуков !!!
Згідний , всі слова правильно , головне щоб одне падло у планеті не стер всесвіт з планети . Іця падла під іменем путлєр , бо воно не кчемна криса . Проти дітей та жінок вагітний і ще з інвалідами України воює .
@@motorcaster57 Right click > loop You can thank me later. I've been listening to most PF songs this way nowadays. No ads, no crazy autoplay to some weird videos that for some reason YT finds similar to Gilmour, no awkward silences. Just the soul within the notes of the greatest band ever.
Best band ever with such emotions coming through David Gilmour‘s guitar only one glitch which isthe old pink Floyd Roger thank goodness they made him leave the band.
@@williambaggett4445 Doesn't surprise me at all, to hear that. One line in a song he wrote, something to the effect of, "I'm angry, I'm always angry." I've always wondered why he said that..
It is a matter of taste....in my opinion that statement is a gross exaggeration. There were innovators in the '70, one extraordinary album (DSOM) , three or four BIG songs, but then...average musicians (except Gilmour), average compositions.
Watch some vids of Hank Marvin and The Shadows, the guy who in Gilmours own words, inspired him to learn to play. Another that could make a guitar truly sing
I introduced my neighbors tonight to the one and only Mr. David Gilmour. I hope they enjoyed it. I introduced him very loudly. Simply the greatest. Thank you sir for sharing, the absolutely greatest musican on the planet.
Гилмор родился с гитарой в руках!Талант от Бога.Уже почти 50 лет наслаждаюсь этой шедевральной музыкой.Спасибо Создателю,что могу быть свидетелем этого чуда!
@@alanmeasures8337 Sure, except that Jimmy didn't watch his health like David has been. Both Jimmy and David Create Music. Real Music with lots of meanings.
This song was in my “Most listened songs of 2018-2019” on spotify. I can’t get enough of this song. Everytime I hear “He talks to the river of lost love and dedication. Silent replies with swirl invitation” I get some good goosebumps. Best song of the Gilmour Era hands down!
David himself is very proud of this song, as he has mentioned over the years. Both the words and the music, came to him in what he admits was one of his more auspicious moments of inspiration.
Was für eine hervorragende band bin zwar 67 aber die Musik von Pink Floyd hält mich jung,seit den 60ern live in Pompei .War auch 1990 in Berlin dabei unvergessene Erlebnisse vergisst man nie
I saw Pink Floyd and 94 in Minneapolis best band and greatest light show I have ever seen in my life and I've been 232 concerts and I'm 70 years old so Pink Floyd David Gilmour I'm proud of you to be in this part of era of bands
I'm a drummer and just loved getting stoned and playing drums to this so loud you could feel it in your soul!! My ex-wife absolutely hated it at 1:00 AM and so did everyone with 11/2 miles from me!!😊
My nephew is a drummer as well,likes getting stoned as well. Just can't get him to listen to this kind of music. He used to be a rocker but not so much anymore. Can't quite figure it out. The times we live in who's to say. I wish he had been born the say time as me and his late father, my brother.
What a masterpiece! What a performance! What a band! What a music! What a solo!! But let me tell you that I am catched here by the lyrics.. seems that it talks about my sad story with my only real love that I have just lost.. I love a girl that was forced by some circumstances to leave me and marry an other dude who doesn't desearve her and even she doesn't want..Yes she's married by now and I can't get her out of my existance whatever I tried.. so like in the lyrics I am haunted by the memory of a lost paradise.. there is dust in my eyes that blinds my sight.. silence that speaks so much louder than words of promises broken.. I am chained forever to a word that's departed.. Sorry guys for bothering you with that story but trust me I am in a real deep grim since almost five months and I needed to talk.. Thanks for your patience and special thanks to the greatest, to the artist, to M. David Gilmour.. Greetings from Morocco
Я грузин. Сам музыкант и пою и слушаю разную музыку. Мне 36 лет. Я ничего лучше этого не слушал в жизни. Это какой то другой мир. Это космос какой то. ❤
Saw this live. Literally makes the hair stand up on the back of my neck. This was the most incredible thing I've witnessed in my life time. David Gilmour is so incredible its humbling. He is the greatest musician on earth. Hes in the books with Bach and Mozart.
Existira sim no futuro fazer não com essa magnitude pois eles são únicos nesse quesito.mas poderá existir sim dependerá do músico ser inteligente o suficiente para isso.
This is incredible. What a spiritual, transcendent experience it must have been for the audience. The greatness is shattering for me and I'm sad that my generation of contemporary musicians have overwhelmingly failed to create anything nearly as meaningful.
David's guitar speaks from my heart. My hurt and my pain comes out through his playing for decades now. If you can feel his solos live on comfortably numb, sorrow, and turning away then you can feel a glimpse into my own pain since I was little 💥😔
Практически 700 тысяч просмотров и ни одного лайка!!!!Такое чувство,что смотрели поклонники Ласкового Мая!Я прекрасно понимаю,что это видео,93-94 года,на не 2019!И тем не менее!!!Только один Гари Уоллис,заслуживает 700 тысяч Лайков,за его Непревзойдённую игру на ударных!А обо всем старом Трио от Пинк Флойда,вообще говорить нечего!Одни Лайки и наслаждение Самой Красивой Музыкой во Вселенной!
I don't know how someone I've never met could describe everything I've been through so eloquently. He's connected to the cosmic stream at a very deep level. A beautiful man. Comfortably Numb and Sorrow tell it completely and are my favorite songs . Long live the king.
A while back I heard his ex-wife Ginger recounting a story of how she was lying in bed with him one time, and he suddenly morphed into Jesus (he was asleep at the time) - ordinarily I'd be sceptical about a story like that, but where David Gilmour's concerned it seems completely plausible :-)
@@danielr3522 Back in the day he was a very gorgeous version of the J man! I can see it! I love him. I hope he's well. I'm grieving the loss of the black and red and white strats. Whose idea was that? Music is the way!
@@margaretlouiseable He was indeed, very handsome fella in his youth. Also very generous, what a lovely gesture to auction his guitars (the black strat went for almost $4m, my goodness!) even if it does feel like a crime against music :o
Когда Они были в Москве был два раза на концерте и видел в каком состоянии выходили люди, это была Фантастика! Супер! 👍 👏 💣🔥Таких больше не будет к сожалению!
I'm here in February 2025. Pink Floyd is the greatest live experience. There still has not been a band or concert to take their place. Thank goodness for you tube that we can keep experiencing them 31 years after the phenomenon.
David Gilmour's bendings are works of art, nobody can play like that absolute precision, outstanding guitarist. A mention also to Guy Pratt and his splendid bass line.
Oh yes Sorrow is a monumental song !! I deeply love this version, sound and bestial guitar solo !!! Gilmour Number One !!! Thanks my friend big Like for you !! Cheers !! 👍👍👍😉🎸🎸🎸🎸
@@thomasadam1330 Oh yes! Sure!! Comfortably Numb is an absolute masterpiece and in the Pulse version it is the apotheosis !! The most beautiful solo in history that together with Sorrow and High Hopes we can find a Gilmour in a state of grace! 👍😉🎸
David after a little prodding proves he really didn't need Roger. Both Roger and Syd are geniuses in their own right, but David, Rick, and Nick were the glue that made Pink Floyd the greatest Rock and Roll band ever! Great job HD once again!
Pink Floyd was , is and will be Syd, Roger, Richard, Nick and David in order of appearance, they are all the same essence, everyone learned of everyone ok?
@@Rebecca-pr4zp both Syd and Roger are a major part in the Pink Floyd story. However after both almost killing the Floyd, Rick, Nick, and David carried on and gave us many more years of the primes of their lives. Roger just sat and brooded and well Syd is a sad story and such a waste. Personally I will take the 20 plus extra years that the other three gave us. I saw Pink Floyd a half dozen times and I have to tell you they were so much better in the 80s and 90s than they ever were in the 70's. I respect your opinion though and you have a point. The Floyd would have never been without the contributions of all.
I,m from libya .. i have listened to pink Floyd more tha thirty years. David..amazing singer . All members they are professional..they are the best band all time ..... They are history.❤
Amazing at 65 I feel I've packed up but Gilmour keeps going. I thank him for the music guitar playing like no other and the incredible concerts I went to will never be another.
They don't make music like this anymore.
I don't think there's anyone out there capable of producing magic of that quality 🌹
@@eugenebuckley7657 your absolutely right its all samples and autotune
Heck no🤘
Damn right, today's bands are just flotsam compared to floyd.
@@eugenebuckley7657 Oh there are people who can, its just that most of those who can don't realize theyr'e capable of it.
The greatest show on planet Earth, how I wish I could be there to witness history. Amazing performance, out of this world!
Most underrated Gilmour's solo right here people. What a masterpiece.
100%
FUN WATCHING HIM
Agree with that !!
You 🙏 right on this one, this song is on top of all PF SONGS RECORDED ON PLASTIC than comes the rest ones
So true.. masterpiece!!
I’m still listening Pink Floyd after 50 years. Best music ever.
Always & forever !
🙏🏼
agree,36 years in now- :) first time I smoked Hasj... 16 years-- had to puke lol...music was so cool I almost came---
Since 38 years
I want Pink Floyd played at my funeral ❤
I will listen forever.
Pink Floyd is not the greatest band of the century… It is the greatest Band of the millennium.
The greatest band of universe 😂
Согласен с тобой, милый ты человек!
Ever
Yes is True !
Pink Floyd always had 2 lead singers. David Gilmour and David Gilmour’s guitar.💕
Right....
Well Roger Waters and Rick Wright sang a lot too, but David Gilmour and David’s guitar make 4. 😀 I actually felt bad that I left them out. 🙁 I read somewhere that Nick Mason the drummer never sang one note ever.
@@luciadelia5607 But his drum sang although, isn't it?
@@luciadelia5607 No but he did the spoken vocals to One Day I'll Cut you Into Little Peices from Careful With That Axe, Eugene.
@@luciadelia5607 He sang lead on Scream thy last scream
David Gilmour is the greatest and most humble guitarist ever. His guitar does the talking.
Bruce Springsteen one of the best. Gary Moore. Stevie Ray Vaughan. Slash to mention a few. Gilmorton was great Roger waters made him
BINGO...
@@neilsime3258 was ein Blödsinn. Waters konnte noch nichtmal seinen Bass alleine stimmen. Ohne Wright und Gilmoure wäre er nichts gewesen
Genius😍😍😍
@@neilsime3258slash one of the most? Omg…
bassist Guy Pratt never gets a mention so here it is, what a fantastic bassist he is, massive credit to him.
Estoy de acuerdo
That is why both Nick Mason and Gilmour still work with him! Legend.
Me encanta x q se recopa Guy muy buen bajista 💕💞🌹😁
Did he help with songwriting at all after waters left?
@@josephjohnson5056 If you count-in creating new music with Floyd. Yes both in the studio and live, which is also a part of songwriting.
In the sense of lyrics, maybe but it's not registered as such.
David Guilmour is my favorite guitar player of all time
He is a guitar god!
I saw the Pulse concert live in 1994. Lots of people claim that Pink Floyd was at there peak during the Wall. They must have not seen Pulse! I didn’t miss Waters at all! If Richard Wright hadn’t got sick with cancer and passed away, there is no telling what we could have seen. To me, Pulse was Pink Floyd’s peak. So many good songs added to their catalog with early Waters songs. Songs we might have not had if Waters had stayed with the band. Sorrow, Coming Back To Life, On The Turning Away, Poles Apart, High Hopes and Learning To Fly just to name a few.
You was sooo lucky to be there
im kinda torn. this era of floyd was fantastic. I had seen them in 88 and 84 got to see roger in the 90's and the wall 2010's. Ive always wonderd what floyd would have truely sounded like had it not self destructed.. my childhood was floyd. i always wished i was born sooner than 74
i was there too you are totally right
@@sonus289: Don’t know what planet you are from, but Pink Floyd never self destructed. Roger Waters left the band. But the band kept on going without Waters and never really missed a beat. They released some very successful albums without Waters and sold out concert events everywhere they went. Arenas and stadiums. Pink Floyd disbanded upon Richard Wright’s death. Most of us real fans never missed Waters. I think ol Roger got an unpleasant surprise. He assumed that the band would die off at his departure. I think he grossly underestimated Dave, Richard and Nick. And the fans. Roger left on his own accord and got quite pissy after the band carried on without him. Kind of bruised his massive ego! Roger should have remembered that they also carried on with Syd. Who was at the time, the bands primary song writer, vocalist and guitarist. Yet the band flourished without Syd Barrett. Pink Floyd proved they could survive and be successful without Roger Waters.
both n were good rogers was very important member david is too together was perfection
Most underrated Pink Floyd song ever.
One of the most underrated Gilmour solos ever.
Sorrow is my favorite song of all time.
I dont think so
@@MidnightLawyer. animals
Totally agree!
Nick Mason...what an incredable drummer...always been rock solid..
Well done Mr. Mason...you are truly a legend and you are amasing..
I believe David had said that the drum track was recorded from a track machine as you can see it take two percussion set to perform
Also underrated, GREAT drummer
@@jamesrice4158 Agreed, but having Gary Wallis as a 2nd percussionist I think was a mistake. He's nothing but an attention hound riding on the coattails of legends. Just my two cents.
It takes an entire band to create a masterpiece of music such as Sorrow, not just Gilmour, or Watters, or Wright, but all of them. I can never get enough of Pink Floyd!!!
Roger Waters had nothing to do with the studio or live version of this song. He was long gone my friend.
@@DeArtiztHayenga Good to know. I didn't realize this song was from A Momemtary Lapse of Reason, 1987.
@@timadams3656 Glad I could be of help. ✌
@@DeArtiztHayengaactually the last phrase of the song is dedicated to Waters.
And the silence can speak much lauder than words of promises broken
Sorry no waters on this one
I don’t care what people say about Momentary Lapse, it’s a masterpiece through and through
Damn straight!!!!
One my favorites on that album is "Dogs of War", which is ringing true these days.
@@davidmundy2906 - Rings true all the time...where have you been??😜😜
Personally I prefer it to the Waters-heavy albums. It's a return to what Pink Floyd was before Waters' ego took over.
@@TDMFAN - Totally agree!!
When Floyd snobs make statements that they were finished because "Roger left" I know I don't have to listen to anything else they have to spout on about because THIS exists, and it's sublime.
A momentary lapse of reason: the most underrated PF album. Sorrow: the most underrated PF song.
God bless Gilmour. Absolutely unique
Yes. And the song "On the Turning Away." Hands down two of the 3 most beautiful songs of the Gilmour era ("High Hopes") completing the troika. My fave era of the PF.
What he did to it on Pulse is beyond words. The original doesn’t do it justice like this does.
Guy Pratt's bass playing, out of this world.
Personally can't stick guy pratt as person but speak truth on guitar
Now that's how you play folks and all you young kids take note of the greatest of all time there will never be a another pink Floyd
I am addicted to this song ❤️
Me and you both! It is a total azz kicka!
Их можно слушать вечно ! Это не группа , это - создание природы , их музыка за гранью , никогда нельзя прослушать в полном объёме , постоянно слушаешь что-то одно , то гитару , то голос , то сакс ... !!! Слушаю с 1975-го года , ничего подобного - НЕТ ! Гилмор - эпоха , его гитара - родник звуков !!!
Мне 62 . Согласен с тобой. Шедеврально.
I enjoyed and appreciated your comment :-)
Это просто необьяснимо, словами не передать. Фантастика.!!!!! Музыка и группа как будто с другой планеты. Грандиозно!!!!! Вечный кайф!!!!!
Згідний , всі слова правильно , головне щоб одне падло у планеті не стер всесвіт з планети . Іця падла під іменем путлєр , бо воно не кчемна криса . Проти дітей та жінок вагітний і ще з інвалідами України воює .
Да, как он это делает?С первых струн нагревает гитару и трясет подбородкм! Дрожь!!!!!
The only negative I have to say about this, is that it ends.
A masterclass from a group of exceptionally gifted musicians.
I couldn't agree more... I was so lucky to see them in this configuration 4 times... Stunning shows and like you said MasterClass stuff...
@@motorcaster57
Right click > loop
You can thank me later. I've been listening to most PF songs this way nowadays. No ads, no crazy autoplay to some weird videos that for some reason YT finds similar to Gilmour, no awkward silences. Just the soul within the notes of the greatest band ever.
I hate endings to incredible things!
Other bands have fireworks, makeup, and outrageous costumes; Gilmour wears a T-shirt. I LOVE IT!
eso es genial en èl, que sencillez...
Best band ever with such emotions coming through David Gilmour‘s guitar only one glitch which isthe old pink Floyd Roger thank goodness they made him leave the band.
@@williambaggett4445 So true. Roger thought he was Pink Floyd. After he left, the others proved he wasn't. Bet he never expected that..
@@kathleengiross , also Roger had issues when he was growing up also
@@williambaggett4445 Doesn't surprise me at all, to hear that. One line in a song he wrote, something to the effect of, "I'm angry, I'm always angry." I've always wondered why he said that..
Greatest band the world ever had
Ever. 🤘
Gilmour is a God! His guitar speaks to us. It’s beautiful. He is pure energy. He’s absolutely amazing!!!
@KAT 1 and 2. No doubt.
It is a matter of taste....in my opinion that statement is a gross exaggeration. There were innovators in the '70, one extraordinary album (DSOM) , three or four BIG songs, but then...average musicians (except Gilmour), average compositions.
Sorry, Led Zeppelin for me. But Floyd is up there.
"And there is a silence that speaks much louder than words of promises broken". -That line get's me every time, I can't help but tear up.
The lyrics are truly powerful and sad.. the chasm between Waters and Gilmour.. ☹️
@@headpump Waters???
@@headpump all music and lyric of Sorrow were wrote by Gilmour. Waters did nothing with this song
Roger was pushed out in '85. In spite of the animosity, isn't David allowed to have some regret about it?
@@headpump Don't know where you're getting your history from but Roger chose to leave in 1985, he wasn't kicked out he could have stayed if he wanted
man, this is gilmour's best solo. I love comfortably numb, but this solo is something special.. especially the intro
David’s playing is just unmatchable. The little leading and trailing notes, the phrasing, tremolo..just so much going on. No one else plays like that.
Watch some vids of Hank Marvin and The Shadows, the guy who in Gilmours own words, inspired him to learn to play.
Another that could make a guitar truly sing
Jeff beck ?
Gilmours favourite guitarist and a friend
Gilmour blew away Jimi Hendrix so much that Jimi gave him his guitar strap.
I will never stop thanking God that I was born after the invention of the electric guitar.
I introduced my neighbors tonight to the one and only Mr. David Gilmour. I hope they enjoyed it. I introduced him very loudly. Simply the greatest. Thank you sir for sharing, the absolutely greatest musican on the planet.
I love the way how you "introduced" one of the best to him ;-)! May I add Mark Knopfler to your mail? As No. 2?
@@gioiaworldwide8157amen to that
every time i listen to this version i get goosebumps.. mind blowing.
Absolutely brilliant. Just so much respect for David Gilmour. And as you say, goosebumps, all over my old body.
Гилмор родился с гитарой в руках!Талант от Бога.Уже почти 50 лет наслаждаюсь этой шедевральной музыкой.Спасибо Создателю,что могу быть свидетелем этого чуда!
David is the best of all times. No one is even close to what he is.
Buckethead is Gilmouresce in some of his pikes!! IMO
@@josephliptak3183 Like I always say: Guitar is called David Gilmour .
There is god than after prophets
Love pink Floyd but don't forget Hendrix
@@alanmeasures8337 Sure, except that Jimmy didn't watch his health like David has been. Both Jimmy and David Create Music. Real Music with lots of meanings.
Я родился,а он уже играл,мне уже пора,а он все играет и играет.Дай ему бог жить вечно.
Не торопись.
@@ЮрийМешков-э2э я не в том смысле,он просто вечен.
Always mesmerizing to hear David Gilmour guitar. Incredible !!
Never ending. Continue vibrating my brain after 55 yrs…🦚🌏🍻🩷🩷🩷Floyd
Real music! Always loved Pink Floyd and their style of play! David is a master on the guitar!
Never die David, never die!
Je suis Pink Floyd depuis 1968 j'avais 15 ans maintenant j'en ai 70 et David Gilmour a chaque fois qu'il joue et chante il touche mon âme. Love u ❤❤❤
This song was in my “Most listened songs of 2018-2019” on spotify. I can’t get enough of this song. Everytime I hear “He talks to the river of lost love and dedication. Silent replies with swirl invitation” I get some good goosebumps.
Best song of the Gilmour Era hands down!
i agree, like it more than Numb....i can hear the Hendrix influence in some parts
Mine too. The Pulse version is my favourite song
O yes Iam no Enghis - Inglés si entiendo está excelente
David himself is very proud of this song, as he has mentioned over the years. Both the words and the music, came to him in what he admits was one of his more auspicious moments of inspiration.
The Pompeii version has an amazing section near the end, in the jam.
Gilmour at his best, just simply perfect in every way.
Pink Floyd has always been in touch with society and the world we live in.
If oneday you come across my comment , I am listening to this masterpiece and it reminds me of you
Haha really?
♾
Reminds me of you too ! Peace !
Kind words, peace be upon you friend.
Was für eine hervorragende band bin zwar 67 aber die Musik von Pink Floyd hält mich jung,seit den 60ern live in Pompei .War auch 1990 in Berlin dabei
unvergessene Erlebnisse vergisst man nie
Hamburg 89 fantastisch
If this is the last thing I hear as my soul soars away from my body, I’ll consider my life complete. Just keep that final solo going, David.
If only we could arrange that for our final breath...
Well said, exactly!
me too bro... me too... Aye . I am about ready to go and, I concur, this, this wil do.
I saw Pink Floyd and 94 in Minneapolis best band and greatest light show I have ever seen in my life and I've been 232 concerts and I'm 70 years old so Pink Floyd David Gilmour I'm proud of you to be in this part of era of bands
I'm a drummer and just loved getting stoned and playing drums to this so loud you could feel it in your soul!!
My ex-wife absolutely hated it at 1:00 AM and so did everyone with 11/2 miles from me!!😊
Cool anser Bud... like it Stone to 👍🇨🇦
My nephew is a drummer as well,likes getting stoned as well. Just can't get him to listen to this kind of music. He used to be a rocker but not so much anymore. Can't quite figure it out. The times we live in who's to say. I wish he had been born the say time as me and his late father, my brother.
What a masterpiece! What a performance! What a band! What a music! What a solo!! But let me tell you that I am catched here by the lyrics.. seems that it talks about my sad story with my only real love that I have just lost.. I love a girl that was forced by some circumstances to leave me and marry an other dude who doesn't desearve her and even she doesn't want..Yes she's married by now and I can't get her out of my existance whatever I tried.. so like in the lyrics I am haunted by the memory of a lost paradise.. there is dust in my eyes that blinds my sight.. silence that speaks so much louder than words of promises broken.. I am chained forever to a word that's departed..
Sorry guys for bothering you with that story but trust me I am in a real deep grim since almost five months and I needed to talk..
Thanks for your patience and special thanks to the greatest, to the artist, to M. David Gilmour..
Greetings from Morocco
Спасибо Вам! Вы вне времени. Вы и есть ВЕЧНОСТЬ. Вы сами наверное не осознаете, что Вы сделали.
ДА!!!Нет слов,одни эмоции!
Я грузин. Сам музыкант и пою и слушаю разную музыку. Мне 36 лет. Я ничего лучше этого не слушал в жизни. Это какой то другой мир. Это космос какой то. ❤
Saw this live. Literally makes the hair stand up on the back of my neck. This was the most incredible thing I've witnessed in my life time. David Gilmour is so incredible its humbling. He is the greatest musician on earth. Hes in the books with Bach and Mozart.
I am sure people will determine him as a genius like mozart or bethoveen in future the difference between us and them we already knew it before
False. Every Single Man Or Woman Who Performed There are massive LEGENDS.
Mozart and Bach are in the books with Gilmour
David Gilmour is a Master Guitarist!
He's not as bad as you say.
Diese Art von einzigartiger Musik wird es leider nie wieder geben!
Da stimm ich dir zu!
Existira sim no futuro fazer não com essa magnitude pois eles são únicos nesse quesito.mas poderá existir sim dependerá do músico ser inteligente o suficiente para isso.
Обалдеть можно. Это лучшее, что я слышала в рок-музыке.
ДА ЭТО В САМЫЕ ОТДАЛЁННЫЕ УГОЛКИ ДУШИ. НАВСЕГДА В СЕРДЦЕ И ДУШЕ. !!!!!
This is incredible. What a spiritual, transcendent experience it must have been for the audience. The greatness is shattering for me and I'm sad that my generation of contemporary musicians have overwhelmingly failed to create anything nearly as meaningful.
David's guitar speaks from my heart. My hurt and my pain comes out through his playing for decades now. If you can feel his solos live on comfortably numb, sorrow, and turning away then you can feel a glimpse into my own pain since I was little 💥😔
high hopes too
Grow a pair would you.
I know what you mean
@@luvwings yes ma'am
@@williamleckrone1628 Don t never give up. Wish you a lot of good things and lucke
This is what we call a great guitar solo!! Genius!!
Ребята. У меня нет слов. Это не музыка. Это что- то иное, потустороннее. А светоаранжеровка.
One of the, if not my favorite Pink Floyd tunes ever !!
Words can't explain how great this is. Thank you Mr. Gilmour
Практически 700 тысяч просмотров и ни одного лайка!!!!Такое чувство,что смотрели поклонники Ласкового Мая!Я прекрасно понимаю,что это видео,93-94 года,на не 2019!И тем не менее!!!Только один Гари Уоллис,заслуживает 700 тысяч Лайков,за его Непревзойдённую игру на ударных!А обо всем старом Трио от Пинк Флойда,вообще говорить нечего!Одни Лайки и наслаждение Самой Красивой Музыкой во Вселенной!
Это выше музыки,это космическая гармония,это счастье!!!
просто тот кто выложил это видео почему-то убрал просмотр лайков, их наверняка здесь тысячи
Пинк флойд ето гилмор и еще раз гилмор ,а потом все остальное ну ето мое мнение
За ударными Ник Мэйсон.
@@Status-1 А в клетке кто??????Посмотри внимательно
Love seeing Richard, though it's heartbreaking that he's gone.
Rick Wright, David Bowie, and Tom Petty have caused me the most sadness as we lose our rock and roll heros....
When we lost Richard Wright & Keith Emerson two of the all time greatest keyboardists were lost. 😦
@@garycraig6506 Do not forget Neil Peart, Lee Kerslake, Steve Priest, Ken Hensley, Eddie Van Halen among other musicians - 2020 sucks!
@@JuanIparraguirre OMG! This year, the fantastically ABYSMAL 2020, cannot get outta here FAST ENOUGH! 😩😱
@@garycraig6506 I would add Jon Lord, my favourite Hammond organ player EVER!
Probably the most beautiful song to me from Pink, next to coming back to life.
I don’t think Pink Floyd has a song that isn’t beautiful
Uma das Mais LINDAS já compostas pelos GÊNIOS!!! Me faz VIAJAR pelas nuvens!!! Curitiba/Brazil
Salve de Apucarana 🙌🏽
A true master of his instrument. Perfection.
Never in history has been such a band with such soul...heaven is with them!!!
The master at his craft!!!....I could watch Gilmour all day,,,,,
…это великое блаженство , слушать такие произведения…
Pink Floyd- forever. !!!
The best and the most perfect band ever!!!! No more words to express that.
I was about to say something but this show left me speechless.
The bass is so beatiful.
Guy Pratt (Richard Wright's son-in-law) live but David in thestudio.
Absolutely - using an "Octaver", just like you hear on "Sledgehammer"
Yes its amazing
Spector NS-2
Been a long time since I listened to this, and I'd forgotten how incredible that guitar sounds.
I just remembered this song, out of the blue, after almost 20 plus years..
It's awesome always....
A silence that speaks so much louder than words
Love pink floyd
My brain blew up as a 17 yo
Listening to this !
Listen to this today 28 years later
What a song
I don't know how someone I've never met could describe everything I've been through so eloquently. He's connected to the cosmic stream at a very deep level. A beautiful man. Comfortably Numb and Sorrow tell it completely and are my favorite songs . Long live the king.
A while back I heard his ex-wife Ginger recounting a story of how she was lying in bed with him one time, and he suddenly morphed into Jesus (he was asleep at the time) - ordinarily I'd be sceptical about a story like that, but where David Gilmour's concerned it seems completely plausible :-)
@@danielr3522 Back in the day he was a very gorgeous version of the J man! I can see it! I love him. I hope he's well. I'm grieving the loss of the black and red and white strats. Whose idea was that? Music is the way!
@@margaretlouiseable He was indeed, very handsome fella in his youth. Also very generous, what a lovely gesture to auction his guitars (the black strat went for almost $4m, my goodness!) even if it does feel like a crime against music :o
Когда Они были в Москве был два раза на концерте и видел в каком состоянии выходили люди, это была Фантастика! Супер! 👍 👏 💣🔥Таких больше не будет к сожалению!
Нуууу...практически всё переслушал ( из классики арта и харда.и.т.д.) но Гилмор вне конкуренции. Это просто достояние человечества!
@@zed9291 Согласен на 💯
@@АртурПирожков-ю7ба когда они были в путинской деревне
ДА БЫЛО КАК ВО СНЕ НЕКТО НЕВЕРИЛ ЧТО ГРУПА ПРЕЕЖАЕТ В СОВОК.СУ.
I'm here in February 2025. Pink Floyd is the greatest live experience. There still has not been a band or concert to take their place. Thank goodness for you tube that we can keep experiencing them 31 years after the phenomenon.
30 years old,
Still one of the best show and this music changed my life and thoughts forever ❤
So glad I attended this
🙏🏼
Love any Pink Floyd video with Gary Wallis. As a former drummer, I find him very entertaining to watch.
This song reflects my current mood so well it has me in tears.
This song reflects mood of any thinking and feeling person on this planet
Таких групп больше не будет они легенды на всегда Спасибо за музыку
Да. Времена великих свершений прошли. Началась деградация массовая.
And don't forget their stage guys what a job they do for the show!!!
David Gilmour's bendings are works of art, nobody can play like that absolute precision, outstanding guitarist.
A mention also to Guy Pratt and his splendid bass line.
unbelievable... one of the best... ever 🎧
Essa música e magnífica da vontade dançar e não parar mais é linda.
Which David is it? 😉 {deepest voice} 💜😎💜
This is the best song they ever done.
Oh yes Sorrow is a monumental song !! I deeply love this version, sound and bestial guitar solo !!! Gilmour Number One !!! Thanks my friend big Like for you !! Cheers !! 👍👍👍😉🎸🎸🎸🎸
Not forget Comfortably Numb!!!
@@thomasadam1330 Oh yes! Sure!! Comfortably Numb is an absolute masterpiece and in the Pulse version it is the apotheosis !! The most beautiful solo in history that together with Sorrow and High Hopes we can find a Gilmour in a state of grace! 👍😉🎸
I like this controlled feedback at the beginning and the end of this song. Last but not least the soloparts during the complete song
C est ma préférée sublime son et jeux de lumières ❤❤
My ears just broke. Think I will listen to it again....
Gilmour owns the title for heaviest guitar player in the world there is no one is even close
Только Пинк Флойд своей ,,Печалью'' способен разогнать все печали!🔥👍👏
Пинк Флойд - это музыка вечности. Под неё создавалась вселенная!
Pink Floyd the best. Pulse best concert. Кароче, я в восторге!!!
Вещь
Да. Музыка Pink Floyd вне времени. Она не может устареть или быть в рамках какого стиля , жанра , проекта.
Братуха, печаль
Великий Пинк Флойд!!! слушаю с молодости, восхищаюсь!!! 🙏🧎👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
David after a little prodding proves he really didn't need Roger. Both Roger and Syd are geniuses in their own right, but David, Rick, and Nick were the glue that made Pink Floyd the greatest Rock and Roll band ever! Great job HD once again!
Pink Floyd was , is and will be
Syd, Roger, Richard, Nick and David in order of appearance, they are all the same essence, everyone
learned of everyone ok?
@@jtlampsu2 Thank's 😊
@@Rebecca-pr4zp both Syd and Roger are a major part in the Pink Floyd story. However after both almost killing the Floyd, Rick, Nick, and David carried on and gave us many more years of the primes of their lives. Roger just sat and brooded and well Syd is a sad story and such a waste. Personally I will take the 20 plus extra years that the other three gave us. I saw Pink Floyd a half dozen times and I have to tell you they were so much better in the 80s and 90s than they ever were in the 70's. I respect your opinion though and you have a point. The Floyd would have never been without the contributions of all.
@@Rebecca-pr4zp well, absolutely correct , loving the floyd, nice to hear others appreciating their music.
Bill Gross You are so right my friend. They continued to make great music together. I was very relieved that they did.
Saw them do dark side of the moon in 1975 the year I graduated couldn't been better !
We will never get this again so thrilled to have witness this live on 3 different occasions
Absolutely Brilliant. Flawless
Could not ask for more. True Genious 🤘
This is one of my favorite songs to turn nice and loud!
Величайшая группа всех времён и народов!!!
FOREVER IN MY HEART AND SOUL.
💯👌
David Gilmour es un milagro de la vida, la guitarra se vuelve una parte de su cuerpo, es un virtuoso genial, lo adoro, simplemente.❤️❤️
Thanks from Ukraine.
Leyenda viva.
Gloria para Ucrania 🇪🇦🇺🇦🚀
@@marccosta7376ciao Marco! E vero... 🙋♀️😍😘💘🌅
I,m from libya .. i have listened to pink Floyd more tha thirty years.
David..amazing singer .
All members they are professional..they are the best band all time ..... They are history.❤
Le meilleur groupe de tout les temps....des moments de grand frissons....c'est trop bon d'écouter du pink floyd ! 😍😍😍😍
Another masterpiece by Pink Floyd. David Gilmour a legend and Godather of the electric guitar 🎸!
Спасибо что вы есть вырос с этой музыкой, очень благодарен от души
Ich hab Pink Floyd 1994 life in Berlin sehen dürfen,es war ein lang gehegter Wunsch der in Erfüllung ging,es war ein Fest unvergesslich!!!
Das glaub ich dir!
Ich hab sie im Juni 1989 in Köln sehen können, DSOT TOUR.
Ein Erlebnis für die Fans.. UNVERGESSLICH!!!
One of the best live tracks...EVER
You hear this guitar with your body, not the ears. I heard it live twice and it was out of this world!
Yup and Live you hear those opening notes reverberating through your whole body
Drives right into your soul
Amazing at 65 I feel I've packed up but Gilmour keeps going. I thank him for the music guitar playing like no other and the incredible concerts I went to will never be another.