2:21 in the English dub, i feel like Lumine's voice had a feeling of revenge and anger towards the God whereas Aether's voice is filled with sadness and grief.
Well in all other trailer it seems that the canon story is that Aether is the one who try to save Lumine, While Lumine herself is more focus to have revenge against the unknown God. You can actually see it in trailer "Teyfat story: Travail" where Dansleif explain the story of each current and future chapter, in that trailer it seems Dansleif is conversing with Aether rather than Lumine. Another example is in trailer called "We will be reunited" the one who ride the Ruin Guard and respected by the abyss mage is Lumine. So in other word we the player are suppose to choose Aether if you want to follow the canon storyline.
I thought it will start with Japanese dub and I was surprised by the English dub. I thought I'd have to play with English dub. The n saw the setting options. Now I switch between Japanese and English. I really like both
*And even then i still dont liek Zack's voice...* (I like dubs and all but i dont like Zacks voice but this is one is one of hsi better ones along with Genos)
It's because calling your siblings by "older/younger brother/sister" is pretty common in Asian countries specially China while in Europe or America you wouldn't really do that, you would just use their name.
Lumine's english voice is so full of emotion. When she shouted give my brother back. I felt a zap of electricity in my soul. Damn, I love her english voice.
@@japanesecurrency1486 If you want to hear more of Lumine's English VA, they actually voiced the Traveler's discussions with Paimon in the Character Menu in the 1.1 Update! I've been going through them since the update came out and it's so nice to hear the Traveler have actual conversations lmao
@@sketchy._.7595 actually for some people it's not bcz the kpop fans..it's bcz in his/her native language (Indonesian) oppa means grandpa,,,so it's kinda weird and just not used to it so....
English voice of Lumine just holds so much emotion in it. In the (small spoiler) Venti cutscene with La Signora, she sounds so worried and scared when she yells venti it just gives an unreal amount of emotion for a character that doesnt even talk
@@equalhealer8584 yeah also, Lumine refers to Aether as Nii-Chan/Ge (older brother) while Aether refers to Lumine as Imouto/Mei (younger sister) so it can be assumed Aether is the older twin
@@volphinaserafina yup. I know the meaning of the Japanese part, but not the chinese part. Just that i haven't noticed it by now, until you point it out.
@@CrAzYGAMINGWOLF same, but i think paimon might be the only iffy english VA funnily enough- everyone else is atleast decent, with some genuinely good ones in there too
Idk why, but their voices in the Chinese dub sound so much more calming compared to the other ones ( they're all amazing, i'm just talking about the vibe ), or is it just me?
Because in Chinese, the same pronunciation has four tones to express different meanings. In order to express the meaning accurately, the emotional expression of Chinese is weaker than that of Japanese
@@k423kaslana7 Oh! I am studying Chinese so I have heard how different emotions are expressed even with the tones. But you are certainly correct, sometimes the emotional expression iS a bit weaker, but I found it fitting in this case? Like, Aether/Lumine have just woken up from such a long time of being knocked out, them speaking with lots of emotion would be a bit draining so having a subdued emotion seemed to fit them? Maybe it's just because I've just been using the Chinese audio for my game tho >
@@k423kaslana7 As a Chinese I want to explain: when we Chinese want to express deep feelings like love, sincerity, tiredness, disappointed, loneliness, sadness, we tend to speak slowly and softly, the more you speak lower and softer, the more emotions you have, that's why some people think Chinese voices sounds calm, it's a culture thing.
@@jznn8218 Is that why the chinese salesmen I can see are usually shouting and/or talking in a loud voice? Because there's no deep feelings in selling things? (Genuinely curious now since you said that)
@@idontknowyet2875 Well, when it gets involved with business that will be another story. The reasons why people in service industry are rude to their customers probably are: 1.they're tired of their jobs. 2. their salaries are too low that they don't have the desire to treat their customers well. 3. they don't get any professional training about serving people. 4.they are in bad mood and they can't control their feelings.
_Okay, but, why is no one talking about Lumine and Aether’s Korean voice actors? They did a pretty great job, and I think their voices suits perfectly, it's so sad to know that this is the most underrated language._ ☹️
same, but only because I'm literally Chinese lol. Though my first language is still English, there's something comforting about characters speaking Chinese.
I really love the voice in japanese and Chinese.. I love to hear Aether and Paimon's conversation in the Profile in Chinese.. I'm sad that they didn't record them in Japanese too
Now I'm happy I chose to play female mc with Chinese voice acting from the start because I feel like it just suits her the most. (Probably because I'm so used to it now though)
And for some reason only if you are playing with chineese dub Traveler's "Voice over" is actully fully voiced... JUST WHY??? AND ALSO WHY THOSE VOICE LINES DON'T PLAY IN-GAME????
@@Sikee6338 it doesn't answer my question. In translated dubs they just left Traveler's dialogues with Pimon unvoiced when they were fully voiced in chineese dub
Fun fact: Chinese version "give my brother/sister back", the VAs said "把我的哥哥/妹妹...(还给我)" literally means "give my brother/sister...(back)", they don't even have enough time to finish their line, which is more sad to me.
it's similar to the Japanese version of "give my brother/sister back". they didn't have the time to finish their lines, so it hangs in "my brother/sister!!" 『よくも俺の妹！！/よくも私のお兄ちゃんは！！』But it's sadder in Lumine's part, because while Aether seems to be stopping at "What about my sister!", Lumine's words were cut off more like; "My brother is-" ((I really love miHoYo's grief portrayal here))
It's really interesting that even though they're twins, aether is called older brother and lumine younger sister (in Chinese, Japanese and Korean). I think it's because in those languages, they specify age in siblings. There isn't a direct translation for just "sister" or "brother".
At least in Chinese when there are different sex twins male one will always be called older and female will always be called younger it's about hierarchy not age really.
@@papkinn I'm not sure about that actually; I've seen many twins where the sister is older than the brother, she's called 姐姐 and the brother's called 弟弟, translating to older sis and younger brother. So no, not hierarchy, at least from the examples I've encountered.
What I found out through all these comparison videos is that all the Chinese VAs are SERIOUSLY underrated despite being the original voices and, in my opinion, the best voices for each character. Oh yeah and also a lot of people assume this was a Japanese game lol
in Chinese voice，Paimon's voice actor is 多多poi，who also gives voice to the Honkai Impact character Rozaliya·Olenyeva. And heroine's actor is 宴宁，who gives voice to Liliya·Olenyeva, the sister of Rozalita.
Different Version~ All English Timestamps: 1:10 1:42 2:22 4:26 All Japanese Timestamps: 1:11 1:52 2:53 5:36 All Chinese Timestamps: 1:13 2:02 3:27 4:49 All Korean Timestamps: 1:15 2:13 3:57 5:13
Interesting in the JPN version Lumine said "Oni-chan" and Aether said "Imouto" implying Aether is the older twin. Lumine also said "Oppa" in the Korean dub which is how females say older brother or address older males.
@@iamthethebeginningiamtheen9555 I think that's actually why they used the addresses in the first place. the original language was actually Chinese after all
Tbh it's a friggin' crime I don't hear more of the MC voice. Both male and female (I play in Chinese) sounds so pleasant to me -- they wasted these voice actors man. I play female mc and my gf plays male mc, and both of them I was like: sounds SO nice. Paimon's cute but I'd much rather listen to the MC.
yeah. Its kind of the rpg self insert thing where the writers don't know if they want the main character to be completely silent or give them a personality. Also if you want to hear the main character voice more just check their profile as they have conversation with paimon about thing which is kind of cool but it suck they only say like 5 words in every other chapter or so.
When lumine says "Don't go give my brother back" in EN her voice is breaking. You can feel her despair, sadness, fear in her voice. It's very beautiful 😍
These two characters have such good VAs in all languages...the game is so new, I hope we'll be hearing more of their voices as the story progresses. I'm super glad that the VAs from every country are really engaged with the community! I love hearing them sing song covers and interact with fans on livestreams.
I really like Lumine’s ENG voice line for, “Wait! Don’t go! Give my brother back!“ like that little choke at the end with her line makes it so emotional to me 😭 I also really like the performances of both CN voice actors for both of them (same line mentioned before) Aether sounds really panicked especially at the beginning and frustrated at the end, and Lumine sounds sad especially when her voices slightly fades out
I‘m choosing the Korean brother one even I don't know what they're saying, because I think that is suitable for music and RPG genre, also the brother sounds really like a ''young brother"(kinda cute). And other characters just sound "nature", Japanese voice just sounds kinda overexpression for me.
1:52-1:56! Aoi Yuuki!! I saw this before I knew who Lumine’s VA was, but I immediately recognized Aoi Yuuki there... That’s how she sounds as Tachibana Hibiki (Symphogear)! I really like hearing them in their different voices, although I really like all versions of them. It’s hard to pick a favorite!
well both of their va did an incredible job at giving the mc their characters aether's voice seems like he's still grieving and sad whilst lumine voice seems like she already pass most of the grieving part, and much more determine to find out what happen to her brother
''等等！别走！把我的妹妹-'' I resonate more with the Chinese.. Edit: im gonna wait until they add all language voice over for Aether and Paimon in the Voice over section..
Aether's Japanese VA sounds so good; actually sounds like it suits the character unlike the English one. I think both English and Japanese VA of Lumine sounds good too. UGH this game is marvelous!!!
I'm biased, but I absolutely love the Chinese. Their voices are softer, and more subdued making them less annoying to listen to for long periods of time. Especially in the "Give my Sibling Back!" scene, the chinese lines are just so good... It directly translates to something along the lines of "Wait, don't go! Take my sibling..." (more colloquial English - "Wait, don't go! Give me my sibling...") and tapering off as if they lost hope. It leaves us hanging, expecting the MC to finish the sentence with "Wait, don't go! Take my sibling and give them back to me!" (Wait, don't go! Give me my sibling back!). Instead of finishing, it tapers of and leaves you hanging. Hits right into the kokoro :') I also think that ENG Lumine and JPN Aether was good. The Korean VAs did a good job, but it felt a little rushed and the emotional beats didn't hit right (not used to listening to the language I guess). ENG Aether was a little too anime Shonen protag and JPN Lumine was a little shrill. Despite my personal opinions, all the VAs did a wonderful job and we should celebrate their hard work! (Still gonna say CN was the best, probably the "ideal"/"original" casting, eh. We all have differing opinions :D)
Many people saying that Chinese voice sounds way too calm, and that's true! In Chinese language, one wouldn't reveal too much emotion in their tones. You have to read context (or understand the sentence), to tell what emotion one is having right now. Normally all the emotions you can sound out of a Chinese sentence is like: calm calm calm, if you don't know the meaning. I think except for being happy, all other emotions are presented in calm tones in Chinese sentences. Normal sentence without emotion: sounds calm. Feeling sad: sounds calm. Feeling angry: sounds calm. (that's a disaster for those who can't realize) Feeling nervous: sounds calm. Feeling scared: sounds calm. I'll make an easy example: A Chinese person (calmly) says "I haven't had lunch yet." Normally: "I'm hungry." sadly: "I have no money to buy food." Angrily: "How dare you eat without me." Nervously: "I'm late for train." Scared: "Mom doesn't allow me to eat." So how on earth can you find out their emotion? Only with context. If you reveal an extreme obvious emotional tone (as a Chinese), people would think that you are pretending and performing, they in turns can't tell what your real emotion is when you are speaking this way. That's also why Chinese merchants in the street like to shout out loud about their product. When you are shouting that way, you do not have any specific emotion, and people automatically know that you are selling things. But nowadays people are getting more casual with their speaking method. As you have read, what I mentioned above is very tiring and stressful social ability. One could easily offend another when they are not trained enough to tell others' emotion. Instead of just changing your tone to express emotion, Chinese prefer to change their body language, or change grammar suddenly, to express their feeling. From my experince I can tell some difference when Chinese people speak: (but please figure out the context) If they are not looking at you when speaking: might feel sad. If their body become stiff: might feel angry. If they are not answering your question or give unralevant answer: might feel nervous. If they are looking at you when speaking: normal way / might feel scared. That's probably why you need to "look at them" when speaking to Chinese. If you don't do so, you are in danger of accidentally hurting someon's feeling or offending them.
I really like Aether's English dub. I don't why, I usually don't like English dubs all that much cuz they sound kinda weird but man Aether's is really good. Makes me wanna give him a warm hug
Now looking at this, going by the logic that the Mandarin is the most definite language, Aether's English VA sounds the closest to the original compared to the higher pitched voices in JP and KR
Is it just me, or does the VA for Aether sound kinda like Deku or Adrien from Miraculous? Edit: after the update they finally revealed his VA who's Zach Aguilar who also voices Koichi from JJBA and Genos from One Punch Man
okay, is it only me who liking korean dub? especially I like smooth voice from aether's. I already set it from the beginning I play genshin. Other character are have nice voice too. And I don't feels it was awkward at all…
everyone’s VA for the english ver is honestly so good, and i actually really love/prefer playing with the eng dub. but then there’s XINYAN’S VOICE. WHY DOES SHE HAVE A COUNTRY ACCENT?? WHAT
@@hahayouareking ah this comment was three months ago from when i wasn’t a xinyan main. now i am a xinyan main who can’t imagine her without any other accent or voice LMAO 😭 she’s one of my fave voices now
@@huangrenjunism YES YES YES AND SHE IS SCARED OF BUGS?? SHE ALWAYS DOES THIS CUTE SOUNDS AND LIFT UP ONE HER LEG LOOKING ARPUND OH GOD HOW CAN SOMEONE BE SO CUTE AND COOL AT THE SAME TIME (but she is more cool ofc!!!!!!!)
![Childe - All Languages [Genshin Impact]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sAmF-u8rkwY/mqdefault.jpg)
![Childe - All Languages [Genshin Impact]](/img/tr.png)
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Each voiced localization have a different version for main Character's names. You can check it all here: ruclips.net/video/kzXkQxRXn3I/видео.html
*It makes sense now*
Korean quality not good. I love Japanese.
i laughed so hard with "Give me back my sister"
Every other language beside korean: "Give me back my sister"
Korean literal translation "No."
EXACTLY LOL
LOL TRUE!!!! Idk if the brother’s part of this was cut off, but the sister says “wait for me! No!” And the brother only says “No!”
LMAO-
in chinese, it literally cuts off with “把我的哥哥-“ (Give my brother-)
In the Chinese version its: Wait! Don’t leave! My [older brother/little sister]!
English, Japanese, Chinese: Give back my brother/sister!
Korean: no
noㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Noㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
noㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
this😂
actually in chinese they dont actually fully say give my brother/sister back lol
The Twins:
Aether! Lumine!
Sora! Hotaru!
Kōng! Yíng!
Oppa! Hyeong-a!
Me: Coolman777
cool man B)😎😎😎
Oppa is not his name lol it means older brother
lol
XD
Same, I named my traveler Coolguy lmao
2:21 in the English dub, i feel like Lumine's voice had a feeling of revenge and anger towards the God whereas Aether's voice is filled with sadness and grief.
Well in all other trailer it seems that the canon story is that Aether is the one who try to save Lumine, While Lumine herself is more focus to have revenge against the unknown God. You can actually see it in trailer "Teyfat story: Travail" where Dansleif explain the story of each current and future chapter, in that trailer it seems Dansleif is conversing with Aether rather than Lumine. Another example is in trailer called "We will be reunited" the one who ride the Ruin Guard and respected by the abyss mage is Lumine. So in other word we the player are suppose to choose Aether if you want to follow the canon storyline.
@@ravenl.twilight3377 Or it could be an alternate timeline. I have a feeling that "We Will Be Reunited" is a future in-game cutscene.
@@albertrojas8585 well aether also appeared in the webtoon but hey lumine got the event part and aether got the story part
@@ravenl.twilight3377Lumine:" we will be reunited my brother But not yet,not now"
*Enter coop*
Aether: "Hello there"
@@Hatano_Rin Lumine:What the fuck?
I love how English voice of Lumine cracks when she gets trapped
it sounds like she is concerned or scared.
sounds more genuine
Holy gay 666 likes???
She sounds broken apart and it breaks my heart soooo much
Waitt whereee
Yes, I finally hear the intro in Japanese. The game automatically started in English for me so I never knew what that woman's voice sounded like.
exactly LMAOO
Same. It just sounded awkward hearing aether. His jp voice sounds more protagonist.
set the setting in japanese
@@yuurai, what surprised me is his english va voices tanjiro lol
I thought it will start with Japanese dub and I was surprised by the English dub. I thought I'd have to play with English dub. The n saw the setting options. Now I switch between Japanese and English. I really like both
*sigh* Even in Tanjiro’s next life he loses his sister to a God like figure
Wait Aether and Tanjiro to share the same VA ?
@@insignificantperson593 english va
Uh oh
*And even then i still dont liek Zack's voice...*
(I like dubs and all but i dont like Zacks voice but this is one is one of hsi better ones along with Genos)
:0
Chinese: older brother!
Japanese: older brother!
Korean: older brother!
English: Aether!
It's because calling your siblings by "older/younger brother/sister" is pretty common in Asian countries specially China while in Europe or America you wouldn't really do that, you would just use their name.
But that's how it works most of the time in non-Asian countries
I mean in English , most siblings call each other by names.
Thing is, they don't literally translate every single phrase and sentence. They have been localized to make more sense for each language.
America so unfilial!
Lumine's english voice is so full of emotion. When she shouted give my brother back. I felt a zap of electricity in my soul. Damn, I love her english voice.
underrated comment. lumine's english voice actor really helped me get invested in this game. such a strong opening.
Definitely
Agree, sadly the rest isn't as good. Now I'm playing in japanese, but that start with Lumine was awesome.
@@japanesecurrency1486 If you want to hear more of Lumine's English VA, they actually voiced the Traveler's discussions with Paimon in the Character Menu in the 1.1 Update! I've been going through them since the update came out and it's so nice to hear the Traveler have actual conversations lmao
I feel that way too! Her English voice is so pretty and also emotional
That "oppa" caught me off guard
@@sketchy._.7595 idk about the west, but oppa means grandpa in my language so yeah I'm just not used to it
It caught me off guard too. I thought they would change it a little or something but the “OPPA!”
@@Sangprabu2045 what
@@sketchy._.7595 actually for some people it's not bcz the kpop fans..it's bcz in his/her native language (Indonesian) oppa means grandpa,,,so it's kinda weird and just not used to it so....
Same lol😭😭😭😭
English voice of Lumine just holds so much emotion in it. In the (small spoiler) Venti cutscene with La Signora, she sounds so worried and scared when she yells venti it just gives an unreal amount of emotion for a character that doesnt even talk
Exactly, that’s why it really shows they care about each other, I kind of ship them 👉👈
@@diva5093 who do you ship?
@@Taesune lumine and venti
@@diva5093 Do you know people can care for each other and not want to be dating?
@@Sarawarawara- yeah but its not like shipping two people who care for each other is necessarily a bad thing
Well now I know that Aether is the older sibling (from my knowledge of Japanese and Chinese ways of calling an older brother or a younger sister)
No they are on the same age the Voice doesn't matter :,D
Well, i mean there's a thing like elder twin. Basically the oldest from the twins. So you're right.
@@equalhealer8584 yeah also, Lumine refers to Aether as Nii-Chan/Ge (older brother) while Aether refers to Lumine as Imouto/Mei (younger sister) so it can be assumed Aether is the older twin
@@volphinaserafina yup. I know the meaning of the Japanese part, but not the chinese part. Just that i haven't noticed it by now, until you point it out.
@@equalhealer8584 yeah I actually forgot they were twins when typing the original comment so thx for reminding me
Japanese & Chinese really suits the characters
Yeah, English sounds more mature.
@@kitty5625 im sorry but english just sounds cringe 😭😭😭
@@hahahe767 +
I actually like the english too and I normally prefer sub over dub :,)
@@mochi8990 Me too, I like the english one. But it's very weird that they dont add traveler voice in voice over section
Lumine’s Eng version is rlly good
I'm not much for the emergency roof's English voice.
@@CrAzYGAMINGWOLF same, but i think paimon might be the only iffy english VA funnily enough- everyone else is atleast decent, with some genuinely good ones in there too
@@cha0sd3v3l dont be shy just say childe and zhongli haha
*Sobs* yes
im sorry but i cry in disagreement english is bad and cringe
I don't know why but whenever I hear Chinese Aether says: "Give my sister back" , something broke inside me
Let me tell you something sadder, he couldn’t even get to say the last word. Literally.
Same with the Chinese Lumine
yeah, I died when they did not finish the sentence HAHAHA
Everyone: Give my sister/brother back!
Korean: 안돼
안돼!
기다려... 안 돼..!
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ???
엄마나깜짝이야ㅜ한국인
[Speak in circles]
Am I the only one who actually likes Aethers English VA?
Nope, i prefer the english voices as well as, especially Lumines
Yeah aether's voice is very calming.
I do. Well, personally I'll prefer japanese over English but for this,, i absolutely adore their English VAs
He literally almost sounds like tanjirou English dub
@@aloywong658 who's tanjirou? Also whats your point?
Honestly Lumines voice in english feels so much real than aether's
Disagree
To me aethers voice sounds kinda flat
@fish cocaine I don't think is fake, is more like Lumine's has a little more emotion
@fish cocaine we don't think it's fake, Aether's Voice is just Lacking some emotions While Lumine's Has it
aethers sounds real to me
한국판 절때 뒤쳐지지 않았다...ㄹㅇ
더빙 잘됬어....다른버전도 거의처음 듣는데
목소리가 좋은게 느껴짐...
Idk why, but their voices in the Chinese dub sound so much more calming compared to the other ones ( they're all amazing, i'm just talking about the vibe ), or is it just me?
Because in Chinese, the same pronunciation has four tones to express different meanings. In order to express the meaning accurately, the emotional expression of Chinese is weaker than that of Japanese
@@k423kaslana7 Oh! I am studying Chinese so I have heard how different emotions are expressed even with the tones. But you are certainly correct, sometimes the emotional expression iS a bit weaker, but I found it fitting in this case? Like, Aether/Lumine have just woken up from such a long time of being knocked out, them speaking with lots of emotion would be a bit draining so having a subdued emotion seemed to fit them?
Maybe it's just because I've just been using the Chinese audio for my game tho >
@@k423kaslana7 As a Chinese I want to explain: when we Chinese want to express deep feelings like love, sincerity, tiredness, disappointed, loneliness, sadness, we tend to speak slowly and softly, the more you speak lower and softer, the more emotions you have, that's why some people think Chinese voices sounds calm, it's a culture thing.
@@jznn8218 Is that why the chinese salesmen I can see are usually shouting and/or talking in a loud voice?
Because there's no deep feelings in selling things? (Genuinely curious now since you said that)
@@idontknowyet2875 Well, when it gets involved with business that will be another story. The reasons why people in service industry are rude to their customers probably are: 1.they're tired of their jobs. 2. their salaries are too low that they don't have the desire to treat their customers well. 3. they don't get any professional training about serving people. 4.they are in bad mood and they can't control their feelings.
Dude aether's en voice actor sounds like sykkuno
Then you should hear Kaeya's EN VA
Apparently every male character in Genshin sounds like sykkuno.
@@jzesu9889 Right? Same with Childe's voice from the trailer xD
LMFAO
Aether: Paimon sus
Chinese is so smooth to listen to, I love it.
Seeing Aether's face when he's getting captured is kinda heartbreaking.
나라마다 전부 다 잘 어울려서 좋다....
무슨 언어로 들어도 정말 성우분들이 노력하신게 들려서 너무 좋아요....
Aether's japanese and chinese voice🧎♀️🧎♀️🧎♀️
_Okay, but, why is no one talking about Lumine and Aether’s Korean voice actors? They did a pretty great job, and I think their voices suits perfectly, it's so sad to know that this is the most underrated language._ ☹️
Yes
I like the Chinese version the most tbh
I like all the languages, the voice actors did really good. But the Chinese version is also pretty good.
I switched from English to Japanese to Chinese for literal no reason 👁👄👁
I like it for the fact I can practice Chinese while playing genshin 🥵
well, it is the original lol
same, but only because I'm literally Chinese lol. Though my first language is still English, there's something comforting about characters speaking Chinese.
どの国も声のトーンが似てるから聞いてて違和感無くて良いね
天理の調停者が釘宮理恵だったということに驚いたわ。全く気づかなかった。声優すごい
I really love the voice in japanese and Chinese.. I love to hear Aether and Paimon's conversation in the Profile in Chinese.. I'm sad that they didn't record them in Japanese too
Same
They have them in japanese now u should check it out
Now I'm happy I chose to play female mc with Chinese voice acting from the start because I feel like it just suits her the most. (Probably because I'm so used to it now though)
And for some reason only if you are playing with chineese dub Traveler's "Voice over" is actully fully voiced... JUST WHY??? AND ALSO WHY THOSE VOICE LINES DON'T PLAY IN-GAME????
@@inkursion5868 well this game is made in china so yeah
@@Sikee6338 it doesn't answer my question. In translated dubs they just left Traveler's dialogues with Pimon unvoiced when they were fully voiced in chineese dub
@@inkursion5868 bc. Of covid, they didn't finish every plots for other languages
I’m pretty sure they are a Chinese Company so chinese would be prioritized more? I’m not sure
I don’t know why, but Chinese sounds oddly satisfying
English Lumine’s “Give my brother back” hit the hardest cuz you can hear the struggle in her voice as the... red things close around her
The Chinese dub make both lumine n aether sound so calm soothing but lonely. Its a voice that could lull me to sleep. Love it.
1:15 *"Oppa"*
That's freaking adorable
2:38 its SYKKUNO for sure
Nah sounds kinda like more Justin briner who voiced izuku from MHA (Dubbed)
@@lxncercrow4528 i was thinking about him the whole time i listened to the intro, it really sounds like him
@@lxncercrow4528 Sounds like Tanjiro as well
@@niantica1869 I believe the voice actor for Aether is Tanjiro's voice actor as well
the voice actor is Zach Aguilar who voice a bunch of character but your right about tanjiro.
The japanese voice for aether is really good
Every language except Korean:
No, not my sister/brother
Korean:
Aether: No!
Lumine: Wait! No!
English/Japanese Lumine and Chinese Aether best.
I find Chinese Aethers voice very calming
Sameer
and thats the last time i hear their voice besides fuujin
ffUUjinN
Kohsei
Kaze to tomo ni sare!
English Aether sounds like English dub Deku-
Tanjiro from Demon Slayer
I thought I was the only one xD
@@niantica1869 Yep Zach Aguilar
It sounds like a combo of the two to me
OMG I THOUGHT IT WAS JUSTIN BRINER TOO NGL
Fun fact: Chinese version "give my brother/sister back", the VAs said "把我的哥哥/妹妹...(还给我)" literally means "give my brother/sister...(back)", they don't even have enough time to finish their line, which is more sad to me.
At first I thought it sounded strange but in this context it makes sad
it's similar to the Japanese version of "give my brother/sister back".
they didn't have the time to finish their lines, so it hangs in "my brother/sister!!" 『よくも俺の妹！！/よくも私のお兄ちゃんは！！』But it's sadder in Lumine's part, because while Aether seems to be stopping at "What about my sister!", Lumine's words were cut off more like; "My brother is-"
((I really love miHoYo's grief portrayal here))
아ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 외국인들 형아!! 드립이랑 안돼!!드립치는 거 존1나웃김
다른나라:기다려 안돼! 내 형제를 다시돌려줘ㅓㅓ
한국:기다려 안돼!
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
IM SO SAD I DIDNT REALIZE LUMINE SOUNDED SO HEARTBROKEN CRYING OUT TO AETHER
It's really interesting that even though they're twins, aether is called older brother and lumine younger sister (in Chinese, Japanese and Korean). I think it's because in those languages, they specify age in siblings. There isn't a direct translation for just "sister" or "brother".
At least in Chinese when there are different sex twins male one will always be called older and female will always be called younger it's about hierarchy not age really.
I mean, there is a thing called the "elder twin" or something.
@@papkinn I dunno man seems like they’ll get elder or younger depending on who gets out first
@@papkinn I'm not sure about that actually; I've seen many twins where the sister is older than the brother, she's called 姐姐 and the brother's called 弟弟, translating to older sis and younger brother. So no, not hierarchy, at least from the examples I've encountered.
Pumpkin Not correct.
Chinese all the way, it sounds soothing and breeze.
its cute and wholesome all the way, i can confirm because i used it since day 1
but then if you like more emotion definitely go for japanese, english for maturity¿
@@chan9982
I think english and korean expresses more the maturity of the characters than Japanese tho
Mi ho yo is Chinese so the Chinese voices would be the backbone for the rest of the languages
No, Chinese always sound worse than jp / english. I'm chinese btw.
Lumine's English voice is full of emotions tbh and it's my favorite
1:08
At this scene, it sounds like they're trying to reach out for each other while something is pulling them apart and farther from each other.
What I found out through all these comparison videos is that all the Chinese VAs are SERIOUSLY underrated despite being the original voices and, in my opinion, the best voices for each character. Oh yeah and also a lot of people assume this was a Japanese game lol
Wait, this video got me wondering... what exactly was the traveler doing 2 months ago before they met Paimon?
in Chinese voice，Paimon's voice actor is 多多poi，who also gives voice to the Honkai Impact character Rozaliya·Olenyeva.
And heroine's actor is 宴宁，who gives voice to Liliya·Olenyeva, the sister of Rozalita.
So If you chose the heroine, it's not Genshi Impact, it will be VODKA Girls' journey.
Cutscene of selecting a twin :
0:00 - 1:09
Lumine and Aether
-English 1:10
-Japanese 1:11
-Chinese 1:13
-Korean 1:15
Twins gets separated
-English 1:42
-Japanese 1:52
-Chinese 2:02
-Korean 2:13
Twins talk about getting separated
-English 2:22
-Japanese 2:53
-Chinese 3:27
-Korean 3:57
Talks about meeting Paimon
-English 4:26
-Chinese 4:49
-Korean 5:13
-Japanese 5:36
Different Version~
All English Timestamps:
1:10
1:42
2:22
4:26
All Japanese Timestamps:
1:11
1:52
2:53
5:36
All Chinese Timestamps:
1:13
2:02
3:27
4:49
All Korean Timestamps:
1:15
2:13
3:57
5:13
Interesting in the JPN version Lumine said "Oni-chan" and Aether said "Imouto" implying Aether is the older twin.
Lumine also said "Oppa" in the Korean dub which is how females say older brother or address older males.
@@iamthethebeginningiamtheen9555 I think that's actually why they used the addresses in the first place. the original language was actually Chinese after all
Tbh it's a friggin' crime I don't hear more of the MC voice. Both male and female (I play in Chinese) sounds so pleasant to me -- they wasted these voice actors man. I play female mc and my gf plays male mc, and both of them I was like: sounds SO nice.
Paimon's cute but I'd much rather listen to the MC.
yeah. Its kind of the rpg self insert thing where the writers don't know if they want the main character to be completely silent or give them a personality. Also if you want to hear the main character voice more just check their profile as they have conversation with paimon about thing which is kind of cool but it suck they only say like 5 words in every other chapter or so.
You can at least finally listen to their voices in their profile. Paimon talks too as well!
When lumine says "Don't go give my brother back" in EN her voice is breaking. You can feel her despair, sadness, fear in her voice. It's very beautiful 😍
Lumine's english voice is really good tho, like, when she gets trapped her voice cracks a little it sounds so real-
Aether’s english voice is like the default male anime protagonist voice ever. Its not bad but its so default like.
Well he does voice Tanjiro as well, I like the voice personally
me too
Lumine english voice gets more desperate feelings at the end of prologue.. which is awesome!!
Chinese also great!
These two characters have such good VAs in all languages...the game is so new, I hope we'll be hearing more of their voices as the story progresses. I'm super glad that the VAs from every country are really engaged with the community! I love hearing them sing song covers and interact with fans on livestreams.
Big respect for lumine's eng va at that "give my brother back" part. It sounds so realistic im heartbroken-
wait aether’s korean voice is epic-
I really like Lumine’s ENG voice line for, “Wait! Don’t go! Give my brother back!“ like that little choke at the end with her line makes it so emotional to me 😭 I also really like the performances of both CN voice actors for both of them (same line mentioned before) Aether sounds really panicked especially at the beginning and frustrated at the end, and Lumine sounds sad especially when her voices slightly fades out
AETHER’S JAPANESE VOICE IS SOOOO GOOD
YEEEEEEEEEEE
Yesss!
he sounds so soft, love him sm
I‘m choosing the Korean brother one even I don't know what they're saying, because I think that is suitable for music and RPG genre, also the brother sounds really like a ''young brother"(kinda cute). And other characters just sound "nature", Japanese voice just sounds kinda overexpression for me.
2:02 I'VE BEEN ON CN DUB SINCE I STARTED PLAYING MONTHS AGO BUT I NEVER REALIZED HOW EMOTIONAL AETHER SOUNDED LIKE WHEN LUMINE WAS TAKEN AWAY !?!?!
lumine eng voice is so gooood like her voice shows the emotions
1:52-1:56! Aoi Yuuki!!
I saw this before I knew who Lumine’s VA was, but I immediately recognized Aoi Yuuki there... That’s how she sounds as Tachibana Hibiki (Symphogear)! I really like hearing them in their different voices, although I really like all versions of them. It’s hard to pick a favorite!
It's sad that most of the fanbase leans toward Lumine, Aether's voice is really good
well both of their va did an incredible job at giving the mc their characters
aether's voice seems like he's still grieving and sad
whilst lumine voice seems like she already pass most of the grieving part, and much more determine to find out what happen to her brother
Because most players are male and pick the waifu option, I personally chose Aether though and Zach does a great job as the English VA
Aether's voice was kinda Lacking some emotions, but his voice is still really good tho
Aether is canon character.
@@justanordinaryguy._.7399 what do you mean?? Aether is a character we all know that ;-;
5:08 He literally sounds like he's singing here. What a mellifluous silken voice, Kana.
Mami chan and Kazuya are siblings in another universe , lovely
Oh no
I am obsessed with lumine’s english “Wait, don’t go! Give my brother back!”
''等等！别走！把我的妹妹-''
I resonate more with the Chinese..
Edit: im gonna wait until they add all language voice over for Aether and Paimon in the Voice over section..
Aether's Japanese VA sounds so good; actually sounds like it suits the character unlike the English one. I think both English and Japanese VA of Lumine sounds good too. UGH this game is marvelous!!!
You know, after all this time, this never fails to make me tear up
I'm biased, but I absolutely love the Chinese. Their voices are softer, and more subdued making them less annoying to listen to for long periods of time.
Especially in the "Give my Sibling Back!" scene, the chinese lines are just so good...
It directly translates to something along the lines of "Wait, don't go! Take my sibling..." (more colloquial English - "Wait, don't go! Give me my sibling...") and tapering off as if they lost hope. It leaves us hanging, expecting the MC to finish the sentence with "Wait, don't go! Take my sibling and give them back to me!" (Wait, don't go! Give me my sibling back!). Instead of finishing, it tapers of and leaves you hanging.
Hits right into the kokoro :')
I also think that ENG Lumine and JPN Aether was good. The Korean VAs did a good job, but it felt a little rushed and the emotional beats didn't hit right (not used to listening to the language I guess). ENG Aether was a little too anime Shonen protag and JPN Lumine was a little shrill.
Despite my personal opinions, all the VAs did a wonderful job and we should celebrate their hard work!
(Still gonna say CN was the best, probably the "ideal"/"original" casting, eh. We all have differing opinions :D)
Yeah how CN Lumines voice tapered off when said 'give my brother' was really good
天理の調停者が釘宮理恵だったということに驚いたわ。全く気づかなかった。声優すごい
Lumine's eng voice actor was gold.
As someone who has a really shitty pc im grateful that i can see the cutscene in its full glory without the constant crashing or freeze frames
1:42 omg lumine english voice is so- i have no words
한국 남여행자 목소리 개좋쥬? ㅎㅅㅎ
아이고 그럼요 최고입니다..ㅜ
경태님...
아니근데왜 여자애이름이 형아야
ㅋㅋㅋ큐ㅡㅠㅡ
@@GG-qp5bz 그르게 사람들 오해할듯
아쉽게도 외국인들은 한국더빙을 안좋아하는 것 같네요..ㅠㅠ
Y'know you should update this because they now have voice lines when talking to Paimon in the character menu.
Many people saying that Chinese voice sounds way too calm, and that's true!
In Chinese language, one wouldn't reveal too much emotion in their tones. You have to read context (or understand the sentence), to tell what emotion one is having right now.
Normally all the emotions you can sound out of a Chinese sentence is like: calm calm calm, if you don't know the meaning.
I think except for being happy, all other emotions are presented in calm tones in Chinese sentences.
Normal sentence without emotion: sounds calm.
Feeling sad: sounds calm.
Feeling angry: sounds calm. (that's a disaster for those who can't realize)
Feeling nervous: sounds calm.
Feeling scared: sounds calm.
I'll make an easy example:
A Chinese person (calmly) says
"I haven't had lunch yet."
Normally: "I'm hungry."
sadly: "I have no money to buy food."
Angrily: "How dare you eat without me."
Nervously: "I'm late for train."
Scared: "Mom doesn't allow me to eat."
So how on earth can you find out their emotion? Only with context.
If you reveal an extreme obvious emotional tone (as a Chinese), people would think that you are pretending and performing, they in turns can't tell what your real emotion is when you are speaking this way. That's also why Chinese merchants in the street like to shout out loud about their product. When you are shouting that way, you do not have any specific emotion, and people automatically know that you are selling things.
But nowadays people are getting more casual with their speaking method. As you have read, what I mentioned above is very tiring and stressful social ability. One could easily offend another when they are not trained enough to tell others' emotion. Instead of just changing your tone to express emotion, Chinese prefer to change their body language, or change grammar suddenly, to express their feeling.
From my experince I can tell some difference when Chinese people speak:
(but please figure out the context)
If they are not looking at you when speaking: might feel sad.
If their body become stiff: might feel angry.
If they are not answering your question or give unralevant answer: might feel nervous.
If they are looking at you when speaking: normal way / might feel scared.
That's probably why you need to "look at them" when speaking to Chinese. If you don't do so, you are in danger of accidentally hurting someon's feeling or offending them.
I really don't this has to do with Chinese tones or culture. It has more to do with the way mandarin sounds as well as the vocal delivery.
The only scene that the MC spoke.
Oh, and also the senyora scene
I really like Aether's English dub. I don't why, I usually don't like English dubs all that much cuz they sound kinda weird but man Aether's is really good. Makes me wanna give him a warm hug
Every version is amazing
Now looking at this, going by the logic that the Mandarin is the most definite language, Aether's English VA sounds the closest to the original compared to the higher pitched voices in JP and KR
What? Not at all
Other languages: No Korea, you have to say Give my brother/sister back!
Korean: Hehe, translations go brrrrrr
Korean just says 'NO'
Is it just me, or does the VA for Aether sound kinda like Deku or Adrien from Miraculous?
Edit: after the update they finally revealed his VA who's Zach Aguilar who also voices Koichi from JJBA and Genos from One Punch Man
It's just you
Same here. I think it's the same voice actor who played Izuku.
@@lxncercrow4528 bro... they do
Also sounds like Sykkuno hahaha.
@@ashadyoutsider1195 who's Sykkuno
the english voices are so satisfying to listen to
It's kinda funny hearing them call out to each other in every language back to back
Now i want to hear the MC talk in the end of the new story for 1.1
1:15 어떻게 여자 이름이 형아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그러게요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
여캐는 형 이고 남캐는 공 이라고 합니다 :3
뭐야뭐야 형아라고 한거였어?
헤으응... 형아...
이름 향인줄ㅋㅋ 형이구낰ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Japanese and Korean for me
I shall ruin the 69 likes
i usually go with japanese voiceovers for anime/games but i love the eng dub of genshin so much
英語の男主人公声大人過ぎん？笑
okay, is it only me who liking korean dub? especially I like smooth voice from aether's. I already set it from the beginning I play genshin. Other character are have nice voice too. And I don't feels it was awkward at all…
yesssss. it's hard to find the emotion in it unlike others, but its there!
all are great ^^
I really like Korean dub.. Honestly so underrated
I love that in every language they sound pretty much alike, just like true twins
진짜 아이테르는 한국어가 찰떡인거 같음...
everyone’s VA for the english ver is honestly so good, and i actually really love/prefer playing with the eng dub. but then there’s XINYAN’S VOICE. WHY DOES SHE HAVE A COUNTRY ACCENT?? WHAT
Oh, um i adore her voice from the very beginnig as i heard her,,,,
@@hahayouareking ah this comment was three months ago from when i wasn’t a xinyan main. now i am a xinyan main who can’t imagine her without any other accent or voice LMAO 😭 she’s one of my fave voices now
@@huangrenjunism LMAO ASDHDHAHQHDJA
I MAIN HER TOO
I MEAN DID YOU SEE HER ULT????
@@hahayouareking YESSS I LOVE HER SO MUCH 😭 ALL HER ATTACKS ARE SO COOL AND HER IDLE ANIMATIONS ARE SO CUTE
@@huangrenjunism YES YES YES
AND SHE IS SCARED OF BUGS?? SHE ALWAYS DOES THIS CUTE SOUNDS AND LIFT UP ONE HER LEG LOOKING ARPUND OH GOD
HOW CAN SOMEONE BE SO CUTE AND COOL AT THE SAME TIME (but she is more cool ofc!!!!!!!)
Still waiting for Lumine to get a Precure Grace outfit.