the scariest thing is that so many Indians still support police doing encounters and shooting people. You know the corrupt and shameless police will shoot more innocent people than guilty just to close the case
Yes because, confessions in police custody are not considered in court. And hardly anyone accepts their crimes in court confession. Police is lazy to investigate and judiciary hesitate to give justice. System is always corrupt.
in most countries confession is not considered evidence as someone can be pressured into making a confession. its the protect the innocent people in those cases.
There is lot of simmering anger I felt post watching this film on the grave injustice faced by the parents. This movie has potential to re-open the Nithari case, just like what Talwar did with Arushi murder case.
@@TriedRefusedProductionsI hope these so called biwwigs do not do so, solely for VM. He is a phenomenal ACTOR. The bigwigs might just end up giving him stupid stuff with untalented nepo so called movie stars alongside him. No please bigwigs stay AWAY, UNLESS YOU HAVE GEMS LIKE THESE MOVIES.. PUHLEEEEZ STAY AWAY.
@@TriedRefusedProductions Exactly!! I hope this movie really does something for both Vikrant and Deepak . But I really do feel that for any outsider to get big projects , he/she really needs box office success . Damnn...I badly wanted this to come out in theatres and get that commercial success .
While I agree with you brother, I also want to say, I don't think we should be surprised. The man has been actively working in the industry for more than 15 years. Its about time we celebrate him than talk about his 'potential'
@@TriedRefusedProductions Agreed. And i loved your personal take on how the film was adapted. It did feel a bit unfaithful to the source material. Talvar being the standard set in this genre of films.
@@TriedRefusedProductions I must beg to differ, Amol. This was never intended to be a documentary, but rather a work of fiction inspired by real events. Filmmakers are not obliged to be purveyors of truth, nor is it within their purview. Our disappointment should be directed toward the police, the judiciary, the government, and the media-the institutions tasked with the preservation and dissemination of factual information.
@@TriedRefusedProductionsYeah. You people only see when the movie gets success. You were not seen when his black out was released. Pretty hypocrite ashos
I am excited for rajkumaar hirani first crime thriller film with vikrant Massey (pritam pedro) Imagine 😳 what kind of film that would be. Arshad warsi is also in that film as a side role.
fingers crossed if it does happen. Because Hirani has never strayed away from his genre of cinema. A step away from the Life lessons and coming of age films
@@Sarthaksingh32 Arshad Warsi is a legendary side actor as opposed to that joker Prabhas who is ageing 10 times faster than normal by eating samosa and burger! 😂
GARIBO KO JALDI INSAF NAHI MILTA..CHAHE WO VICTIM HO YA DOSHI...SACH KO INSAF NAHI MILTA...JHUT KO SACH MAN LIYA JATA HAI...SACH KO ANDHA KANOON DEKH NAHI SAKTA...LAW OF OUR COUNTRY.. L...LAZY...A... ARROGENT....W....UN WORTHY...
@@Sarthaksingh32you current generation jockers wont understand his value...He was a choreographer,,,, Amitabh Bachchan offerd him a roal of hero in Hero Hindustani movie...yes he is not a huge bankable star,but he has proved his presence in every role,,, comedy,serious,mental,he did the best,,,But still he is not a huge bankable hero...thats the only difference between a Actor and A star...
This is the best performance of Vikrant in his career. That interrogation scene gave me chills. He is the best actor we have today in this generation. Pankaj Tripathi, Nawaz, etc. all are gone. Time for Vikrant to shine.
@@crazyaboutnumbers315 please tell me the time stamp of that scene, I can't watch the whole movie, I wouldn't be able to sleep at night. so just the interrogation scene please
Yes Mera Bharat mahan, jai Hind, the very freedom you are enjoying today, if your safe and leading happy life is beca of our law and police, say what ever u want about our law and police imagine a day without police force , imagine a day without law. Imagine the crime. What you think injustice happens only in India? Every country goes through this , yes rice people gets privilegs more then poor it's fact but what stopping anyone from being rich ?? No one is born rice somewhere someone in their family worked their ass off to build empire, being rich and being in power entire world will respect not just in India.@@Gang14128
They didn't in reality both were caught and punished accordingly. I stand corrected I just read they got acquitted in 2023. Back in 2006 people were calling for their blood. 😡
It was so good to watch Deepak Dobriyal in such an engaging role. Sad that he has been typecasted as a comedy character or a side gig at the most, deserves something in line with his potential.
Deepak Dobriyal! What a performance, specially durimg the chase scene, the hospital scene where he is sitting outside and watching his daughter, the interrogation scene! Uff! 🔥🤌 Not to mention Vikrant is absolutely flawless!
Also came to know, that Porche driving kid who got 2 killed, also is out! So even the public outcry isn't enough to get justice here. As long as you have money, you can even bend laws.
I completely agree with you jammy. I felt that although the actors were out of this world but the story covered was not justified completely. Why is it that Indian movies and documentaries have hesitancy in showing what happened in its actuality?
@@TriedRefusedProductions and yet you seemed too critical. It’s a movie, not a documentary. As someone who hadn’t heard about this case before, the movie does a good enough job to pique interest in it so that one can research more accurate details from other sources. You just sound mad at the creators for taking creative liberties while overlooking multiple technical aspects of the movie.
No ....if u r making movie saying its inspired by true events then its their duty to present story as what happen in real life...detailng must be there .@@kickass2117
I don't understand how criminals get support from Human rights activists sometimes in Pakistan a guy killed over 100 kids got support of international human rights activists they said he's mentally ill and needs help, like wtf
So true I also don't understand remember delhi rape case so many human right lawyers r supporting the rapist. Where humanity going in this world 🌎. No one sympathy the victims n their families trauma whole life
@@pennyc8252 No lawyers do their job by representing case but they also know they are going to loose It's part of democracy everybody has right to having a lawyer
@@pennyc8252but there are people who support the prisoners giving second chance Just go and check prison life in Finland u will be shocked that they are living better life than Indian middle class families and people support them for giving them second chance That's sickening
The judiciary and police of this country to almost every institution of this country and the leaders are rotten to its core. It gets more depressing with each day. Jai Hind.
What about the POLITICIANS which WE elect ? WE are the CULPRITS for electing such criminal & racist politicians as they are the one's who decides the judiciary & police enforcement in our country. When WE as a country without any prejudices elect a leader then they should be OUR servants but sadly in INDIA it's the other way round WE are behaving like their servants.
Vikrant Massey acted really well but his character portrayal didn't have that darkness which this role required . Needed the vibe which Prasant Narayan left us with in Murder 2 . (IMO)
I think he did well with his role. If you see the real Suresh Koli who his character is based off of, he looks like a normal guy. There is nothing eerie or disturbing about him. Most predators are charismatic, manipulative, nice looking people hence they are the last people you would suspect. I feel Virat’s character not being too dark made it 20x scarier cause that could be your next door neighbour or some person you know who seems like a nice person.
Prasant was so good in murder 2. Because of his character portrayal I was not able to sleep for days. I have not watch 32 sector yet so I can't say anything about vikrant performance.
Agreed!, you can see sharp contrast in the interview sequence. Without speaking anything Deepak Dobriyal acted/said a lot more through his eyes than Vikrant's tirade about his doings.
Bro that interrogation scene just traumatized me for a day such a brilliant performance by Vikrant Massey. Like at once he acts like a very familiar person but then the words come out of his mouth just leaves you speechless
Found Vikrant Massey to be overacting a little, trying to be someone he is not. In my opinion, Vikrant Massey should have played inspector and Deepak to play Prem.
@@ProudIndian6450😂😂 I agree. Love him as an actor but the interrogation part his acting was lil bit cringe and sloppy. This is my personal opinion no hate towards the actor. I love him I have been rooting for him since his tv days “baba Aisa varr dhundo “.
This movie reminded me of another horrific film I saw called Silenced. The film got so much attention that it changed the South Korean Law! I hope this film can do something like that as well and it serves some justice to the parents who lost their kids. Hope they reopen the case or bring some change in our country's justice system!
The incharge of this case, Simarjit Kaur was dismissed by court for taking 3 lakhs bribe from the House Owner. After the verdict, she got back on duty and now is facing charges of taking 50k as bribe from an alleged r@pe victim.
भाई मेरे, इस (कल)युग में हर एक इंसान की सोच और वजूद ही इतना काला हो चुका है कि इससे और अधिक काला हम प्रेक्षक के रुप में भी बर्दाश्त नहीं कर पाते ! अब तो बस राह तक रहे हैं कि कब कल्कि अवतरित हो और कब हम इस युग से मुक्त हो ।
The frustrating thing about the acquital of these two is that the lapse was not on the side of judiciary but the investigative agencies who couldn't build a watertight case.
I think that because of Noida being under the jurisdiction of the UP govt, the makers adopted a safety driven choice of shifting the crime scenes to Delhi and portraying the case as being their fault mainly because of the current political environment in UP
Jammy i hear you, and im not diminishing the case by any means. But this movie is not about the nithari killings per se. It is "loosely" based on it. So the artistic liberty is understandable. Fair? No. But understandable.
The problem brother is, literally every finding of the case including those accused and their descriptions are identical to the Nithari case. Why take the creative liberty in other features when you're leaving no shadow of a doubt that this is that case
I agree with you brother sudden disconnection I felt with the movie after climax...I mean why you suddenly show that everything is okay and justice has been served...climax of this movie is very bad example of open end movie@@TriedRefusedProductions
@@shaolinAlexander ...on the contrary it shows the system allows corruption by showing the informant of the upper crust becoming the head of the police dept and implies things will go on as they did before. I cant see any served justice in it.
I was not able to sleep after watching this film. Hats off to vikrant massey and that interrogation scene. Deepak dobriyal no matter what he is doing in a movie, just never fails. Talking about the real events, for a person living outside UP and Delhi, this case signified the city of Noida to me. It was like a city of hell for me and friends who knew about the case through TV news. It brought back all the bad memories and discussions we used to have.
I really creeped out by the acting of vikrant in interrogation scene damn sad movie but awesome the release of the real culprit breaks my heart if u are wealthy u can do whatever u want sad reality man
Exactly felt the same. I was in class 7th when this incident happened. NGL I was legit scared back then. This was also the first time I got to know about cannibalism (The only other cannibalism incident that I could remember from back then was one from an episode from a show on sony tv where Makrand Deshpandey played a cannibal). So, I was actually bummed when the actual facts were not shown in this movie. It somewhere did not leave the impact it was intended to leave. Also it was quite responsible on the part of makers to not show the crime & even mute the part where Prem was narrating the horrors of the crimes he committed. I think this was done intentionally so that people don’t get inspired by the same. Also, I kinda prefer (acting wise) Raghav’s psychopath character from Kill more than Vikrant’s character in this film. May be the writing or something else but Vikrant did not look as evil as he should have been.
This is one of the best films this year. The social commentary was spot on. Vikrant nailed it. The film was never about the case..it clearly differentiates between the class of society and the treatment they deserve from the authorities. How they were the soft target.
This was not a documentary but a very powerful dark film with strong social commentary. The last scene , where the lack of change of the moral compass, if not becoming worse, within the police department hit me the most.
I never thought any other monologue of a psychopath unapologetically confessing his gruesome acts could be this disturbing and enraging after Delhi Crime season 1. VIKRANT MASSEY 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
The story started from a very rooted place and then in the very end it felt like a crime thriller drama. And what was the need of that post credit scene!!!
like wtf is the point of that CD now. The accused are acquitted aur yahan inka apna sequel ka plan chal raha hai. Hence my gripe with the creative route
Years have passed and nothing has changed. We see the same kind of incompetence from Indian Police with the Kolkata case. I have 0 trust on Indian Judiciary and Indian Police. We are getting nowhere in improving things our society. It's just sad.
I don't understand this. In one scene prem is shown to be scared shitless when Pandey almost catches him. He makes phone calls to bassi and the compounder because he feels there's a risk of his and his boss's secrets being exposed. In the other hand there's prem revealing everything during the interrogation with copious details. It just seemed too convenient. As if the makers of the film just made efforts to glorify the interrogation scene but not the build up to it. Like how do you show a killer scared to get caught in one scene and then just the opposite in other scene. A serial killer makes attempts to never get caught
He was not ashamed of his deeds as he was a psychopath. But, even they have fear of loosing their reputation, getting caught in kidnapping of policeman daughter is something that is wrong as per his learning , at the same time exploiting or killing poor kids, and the woman he liked is something that they deserved in his opinion. He wasn't ashamed of all his deeds,but still they have a fear of getting caught in an act. It's so f**ked up in their head, that normal people don't understand why and what. They can't think rationally, feel like normal people, but based on their learning they do things, and they justify their actions throughout and can do any sort of evil as long as it is not wrong in their head.
Indians respect power, money, fame. Its like we have in our genes to be submissive in front of authority and show power in front of weak. This is because of casteism
Completely agree with your review . I felt the same, they shouldn’t have gone down the who-dun-it thriller route on this subject as it’s based on true events and the music was so misplaced, tonally jarring ! Wish the filmmaker had been sensitive and honest regarding the screenplay ! Disappointing for sure
The confessing scene omg ..it was so horrific and i know the actual case and there was details given by that monster more cruel ..and knowing that , seeing the confession scene at the movie gave me more goosebumps 😨
I was hesitant when I heard Deepak Dobriyal is the protagonist because his silver screen persona is more of a comedic character. But he surprised me! Little did I know he is actually very well established in the theatre scene.
Jammyyyyy this is like the 45th time I'm asking you to check out this movie called *Ibbani tabbidha ileyali* please watch it Mann, it's one of the best movie from Sandalwood, And coming to this video, the intro was shocking, I swear to god I had never heard about this case, this was another thappad on our law and order...💔
Bruh where did vikrant land himself after 12th fail felt exactly the opposite emotion in this one. When the interrogation scene came up ijust told myself damn this guy is living the character🗿
Buddy, at the end of the day, that is a production and feeds many families. The director WILL have to make sure that it doesn't cause problems in today's Indian diaspora. On the other hand, I commend YOU for speaking about it and bringing your audience's attention towards the issue. Your decisions affect only you (assuming you work solo, apologies in advance if you don't) .
I liked that part of the interrogation scene where Vikrant's goes low and Deepak starts recollecting the names of those kids. Brilliantly, avoided Vikrant's actual explanation. That also elevated the scene to a new level.
I absolutely loved this movie until I saw this review...The points that you are highlighting around creative liberties is so valid and adds so much gravity to this review
My first intro the nithari murders was through the web series Abhay, whilst it was a fictional take also it did give me a reason to look forward to the movie to know the actual details. But the aside the perfomance and certain scenes, just knowing that facts have been changed takes away what would make the movie special
I started watching this movie and when the boy and vikrant came on screen I just couldn't continue watching, it was so real. Vikrant's acting is too real and the dialogues are too real.
Wealth is only with politicians, sportsmen, filmstars and business men in this country, rest are all doomed. Its always better to move to a country where human rights are taken seriously. Cant imagine the horror and trauma victims went through in these incidents
Thank you for such a truthful review - going beyond mere movie review and talking about the reality shown in the movie. My biggest gripe with movies made on real story is twisting the truth. I feel not telling the story as is is twisting the truth. How many people who watched the movie would go and find out what happened in real life?
I watched it yesterday's and omg what an acting by both the lead cast Deepak Dobriyal and Vikrant Massey......Vikrant with his psychopath demeanour chills down my spine especially in that interrogation scene ....he didn't take the larger than life villain approach and makes it more grounded which is applaudable 👏👏....... whereas Deepak Dobriyal as sub inspector pandey portrayed a very subtle performance.....he shines in emotional scenes ...his eyes speaks a lot about what's going in his mind ........one of the best movie i seen in recent times ......hope we get to see Deepak Dobriyal sir more and more
Justice is really expensive.. not everyone can afford it.. so a normal person can't trust the system.. all he can do is take matters in his own hand.. justice is a joke in this country.. this movie made me really disturbed
the principle that no one should be convicted based on conjecture or doubt. This is rooted in the idea that it's better for a guilty person to go free than for an innocent person to be wrongly convicted. While this principle can sometimes lead to the acquittal of individuals who may be guilty, it's a necessary safeguard to prevent the injustice of convicting the innocent. As you pointed out, there can be collateral consequences, but upholding this standard is essential to preserving fairness and the rule of law. It's a balance between individual rights and societal safety, often leaning towards protecting the former, even if it means some level of compromise on the lat
So awesome to see Deepak Dobriyal as one of the lead and Vikrant, as usual, raised the bar of his acting skills. My prayers to the victims' families and hoping them to receive justice and inner-peace.
Thank you for this video… these are my exact thoughts on this case, while the reality of it is something I am actively following, this film was harder to digest…
100% agree with this video. The performances and direction etc doesn't matter when you take a serious subject then it must be dealt with sincerity. You should not make a movie on real life incidents to use plight of people to make money if you don't intend to show the details. After watching the movie you will only feel disgust but you won't know anything about what happened in reality except for innocent children were abused and killed. Why ? Was there any organ racket involved ? Why there were let go free ? Etc thsi is doglapan.
I wonder why people still think that the courts and judicial system gives justice. One should realise , that courts look at evidences , statements and what arguments are made. Emptions , propaganda , etc have little to no bearing on the outcome of cases. Unless one reads the cases in detail , and what charges / arguments were put forth the courts by the prosecutor, such decisions while might feel unjust to common people like us , however, would be totally correct for those who understand the technicalities of law. This is sad , but true . Having said that , there is no denying that rich , powerful and influential people get away with a lot .
Just watched it, and imo Vikrant couldn't justify the role except for the confession scene, film does feel directed by a newbie, Deepak was good at his part though. Overall pretty mediocre good.
On the same adaptation, Prashant Narayan did the outstanding acting before ages. His character was something which gave that persona ki insan ko dekhkar ghinn ajaye.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but I did know about this Talwar's case through this national series of India Crime Patrol, so on a base of established viewers of that jig, i can say Patrol's screen play is way better then these high flying movies, sometimes it's so linear that you watch it in episode not in a single sitting, that drag that boring.
@@TriedRefusedProductions fair enough. Although I'd argue that with mobiles becoming more common place and internet moving from landline to broadband made the world a very different place but I'll go with it. Having said that, I like your content. Keep at it Cheers
I loved the film but it's really traumatizing!! 😭 Vikrant's character is so creepy and scary and literally gives chills!! His guilt-less confession and his past ahh everything is scary!! I can't believe he is the same guy who played Veer in BBB, he is so versatile ❤️ Also I have been Vikrant's fan like for the longest time, but this time I was just so much in awe of Deepak Dobriyal I mean wow from the start to the end, the way he portrayed the character so justly!!! Also, an observation: during the chase scene both Deepak and Vikrant's characters are in Ravana's get up signifying that both are (in diff ways obviously) unjust and evil. The interrogation scene and climax gave me chills, and ofcourse I saw it at night, haven't slept in 2 days 😭👍🏻
I came here after watching the movie and genuinely felt the movie didnt do justice to the real case. I was expecting a little more from the story. Maybe a series of this would have been better than a movie. Nonetheless, hats off to vikrant's acting. Thanks for your review. Love how you articulate things. 👍🏻
I heard this case during my school days. I used to go BBPS Noida until my 9th class later we moved to South delhi. All these stories mentioned actually happened during the 20s.
The movie probably had gotten vikrant messy another national award if it had been true to the facts of the case just like what talwar case did... An opportunity lost to showcase the truth for creating unnecessary thriller... It could have left and imp question for everybody seeking justice on why the case can not reopen in SC to bring justice...
Thank you for starting out this video the way you did. The Justice system in India has long become a joke. It is unbelievable that a case like this, so well publicised has acquitted its main perpetrators like this.
As an admirer and a regular spectator of your reviews I totally agree with your agree with your point of view but still in the movies' defence it is also going to be a testament to our very times hence i Justify the 'Tandav'.
I could not watch this movie for more than 15 mins. Brave of Vikrant Massey to take up this role, While his stock as an actor may have risen, his positive image from 12th fail would have taken a big beating. For general audience, this horrific character played by Vikranth will have a very bad recall value.
I get your frustration at the direction chosen but I also feel that there are very few films that portray a case as is for the fear of it turning into a docu-drama. Talvar & Madras Cafe are the ones I remember that tried to do so. But this movie did bring the plight of the poor & the gruesomeness of the crimes to the fore. I for one didn’t know where the case currently stands before the movie..
I remeber years ago crime petrol covered this case too and it still sends the chills ,I was a kid back then and though I knew the story but it literally sent chills down my spine ,performances were spot on and totally agree the real case was mere a part of the story but it still is most disturbing thing I've watched
@Anmol, it’s first time when I found you review heart felt! I can relate the pain as I stayed in Delhi NCR at that time and used to work in Noida. However, I feel with current political situation asking questions can reprimand the creators and it’s a fair ask from them not to indulge in showcasing bureaucratic complacency! It’s good that people have started to talk about the horrific events due to this movie. Being a parent, my heart goes out to those who are family members to these victims. Hope they find peace in this life after what they have been through🙏
Had the victims belong to privileged class, the verdict would have been different. Poor has no value in this country
they are called poor for a reason
That's not true.. Aayushi Talwars parents were doctors... Nd that Nepali guy was from lower class . Still we all kno what happened there....
so what ?? its survival of the fittest, its law of nature law of universe, the strong survive and weak perish. if u cant accept it, its ur own fault.
@@pralayaryan By that logic, the poor has the right to attack and take arbitrary action against the alleged criminals..... Do you agree with it?
Are india m mostly sab middle class h garibo logo ko bhaut Sare free ka seva milta h gov se
I don't understand why our police force is like this. It's frustrating and scary.
the british era training they get..people are others for them..
Corruption
two sides of coin one side criminal and other side criminals in uniform
the scariest thing is that so many Indians still support police doing encounters and shooting people. You know the corrupt and shameless police will shoot more innocent people than guilty just to close the case
say this when u r in police force. when u r not then u don't understand the hierarchy of power and position.
sad part is even after the confession, court said not enough evidence and gave them bail. hail our law and order
Yes because, confessions in police custody are not considered in court.
And hardly anyone accepts their crimes in court confession.
Police is lazy to investigate and judiciary hesitate to give justice. System is always corrupt.
in most countries confession is not considered evidence as someone can be pressured into making a confession. its the protect the innocent people in those cases.
abe lauded custodial confessions will be forced by police beating them so it will not be accepted
It is pathetic
Investigation should be tight where by in circumstantial evidence is undeniable.
Unfortunately when officers don't do their work this is the outcome.
There is lot of simmering anger I felt post watching this film on the grave injustice faced by the parents. This movie has potential to re-open the Nithari case, just like what Talwar did with Arushi murder case.
@@avneetkaur7554I believe it was the Servant , many indicator towards this theory
@@avneetkaur7554it's not parents
@@PS-ug7nm Yup bt on the command of her parents
@@avneetkaur7554you’ve said that all over the internet for years - and you still cannot substantiate why you feel that way.
@@avneetkaur7554why? For what reason?
The confession scene literally gave me chills .
10 mins of pure horror.
Imagining the scenario when the real killer had confessed to all his killings.
I hope Vikrant's versatility gets recognised by the big wigs post 12th fail and this stellar performance!
@@TriedRefusedProductionsI hope these so called biwwigs do not do so, solely for VM. He is a phenomenal ACTOR. The bigwigs might just end up giving him stupid stuff with untalented nepo so called movie stars alongside him. No please bigwigs stay AWAY, UNLESS YOU HAVE GEMS LIKE THESE MOVIES.. PUHLEEEEZ STAY AWAY.
@@TriedRefusedProductions Exactly!! I hope this movie really does something for both Vikrant and Deepak .
But I really do feel that for any outsider to get big projects , he/she really needs box office success .
Damnn...I badly wanted this to come out in theatres and get that commercial success .
He is also a bit arrogant and rude. At least that's what I have noticed from his interviews.
That interrogation scene is a testament to the potential in Bollywood. Vikrant Massey pulled off an amazing psycho killer.
While I agree with you brother, I also want to say, I don't think we should be surprised. The man has been actively working in the industry for more than 15 years. Its about time we celebrate him than talk about his 'potential'
@@TriedRefusedProductions Agreed. And i loved your personal take on how the film was adapted. It did feel a bit unfaithful to the source material. Talvar being the standard set in this genre of films.
spine chilling even its on OTT still they increase the sound to mute his action😢😢😢
@@TriedRefusedProductions
I must beg to differ, Amol. This was never intended to be a documentary, but rather a work of fiction inspired by real events. Filmmakers are not obliged to be purveyors of truth, nor is it within their purview. Our disappointment should be directed toward the police, the judiciary, the government, and the media-the institutions tasked with the preservation and dissemination of factual information.
@@TriedRefusedProductionsYeah. You people only see when the movie gets success. You were not seen when his black out was released. Pretty hypocrite ashos
I am excited for rajkumaar hirani first crime thriller film with vikrant Massey (pritam pedro)
Imagine 😳 what kind of film that would be. Arshad warsi is also in that film as a side role.
fingers crossed if it does happen. Because Hirani has never strayed away from his genre of cinema. A step away from the Life lessons and coming of age films
It is a webseries
@@Sarthaksingh32 Arshad Warsi is a legendary side actor as opposed to that joker Prabhas who is ageing 10 times faster than normal by eating samosa and burger! 😂
GARIBO KO JALDI INSAF NAHI MILTA..CHAHE WO VICTIM HO YA DOSHI...SACH KO INSAF NAHI MILTA...JHUT KO SACH MAN LIYA JATA HAI...SACH KO ANDHA KANOON DEKH NAHI SAKTA...LAW OF OUR COUNTRY.. L...LAZY...A... ARROGENT....W....UN WORTHY...
@@Sarthaksingh32you current generation jockers wont understand his value...He was a choreographer,,,, Amitabh Bachchan offerd him a roal of hero in Hero Hindustani movie...yes he is not a huge bankable star,but he has proved his presence in every role,,, comedy,serious,mental,he did the best,,,But still he is not a huge bankable hero...thats the only difference between a Actor and A star...
This is the best performance of Vikrant in his career. That interrogation scene gave me chills. He is the best actor we have today in this generation. Pankaj Tripathi, Nawaz, etc. all are gone. Time for Vikrant to shine.
I still consider his 12th fail to be just another level. He was however demonic in this film. Very chilling indeed
Oh man, I've watched that sequence 3 times just for the performance...
Phir bhi hero material nhi hai vo ..just actor ..
@@crazyaboutnumbers315 please tell me the time stamp of that scene, I can't watch the whole movie, I wouldn't be able to sleep at night. so just the interrogation scene please
Hero material ?
What is that
Explain @@VimalSingh-tt3vv
And the criminals got ACQUITTED ⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️⚠️
Ye hai humara justice system
aur bolo mera bharat mahan 🤣
Yes Mera Bharat mahan, jai Hind, the very freedom you are enjoying today, if your safe and leading happy life is beca of our law and police, say what ever u want about our law and police imagine a day without police force , imagine a day without law. Imagine the crime. What you think injustice happens only in India? Every country goes through this , yes rice people gets privilegs more then poor it's fact but what stopping anyone from being rich ?? No one is born rice somewhere someone in their family worked their ass off to build empire, being rich and being in power entire world will respect not just in India.@@Gang14128
They didn't in reality both were caught and punished accordingly.
I stand corrected I just read they got acquitted in 2023. Back in 2006 people were calling for their blood. 😡
It was so good to watch Deepak Dobriyal in such an engaging role. Sad that he has been typecasted as a comedy character or a side gig at the most, deserves something in line with his potential.
Deepak Dobriyal! What a performance, specially durimg the chase scene, the hospital scene where he is sitting outside and watching his daughter, the interrogation scene! Uff! 🔥🤌
Not to mention Vikrant is absolutely flawless!
I loved the scene where he just sends a flying kiss to her as she recovers. Beautifully done
@@TriedRefusedProductions and then his expression changes as he starts thinking of catching the guy.
Also came to know, that Porche driving kid who got 2 killed, also is out!
So even the public outcry isn't enough to get justice here.
As long as you have money, you can even bend laws.
its infuriating
I feel he should not be called as kid, Iam sorry to say this to him , but he is brat
Don't shy away from taking Vedant Agarwal's name
@@mssuryakumar1252not even brat.. he is a killer/murderer
He is planning to go abroad
I completely agree with you jammy. I felt that although the actors were out of this world but the story covered was not justified completely. Why is it that Indian movies and documentaries have hesitancy in showing what happened in its actuality?
I guess they fear legal liability so they just about do enough. Its quite frustrating. I think Delhi Crime got it spot on
@@TriedRefusedProductions and yet you seemed too critical. It’s a movie, not a documentary. As someone who hadn’t heard about this case before, the movie does a good enough job to pique interest in it so that one can research more accurate details from other sources. You just sound mad at the creators for taking creative liberties while overlooking multiple technical aspects of the movie.
then go watch a documentary. this is a movie. its like going to a five star and asking for vada pav
No ....if u r making movie saying its inspired by true events then its their duty to present story as what happen in real life...detailng must be there .@@kickass2117
@@kickass2117its not just a movie, which only for entertainment purposes. If it is in that case they can consider any masala movie rather than this
I don't understand how criminals get support from Human rights activists sometimes in Pakistan a guy killed over 100 kids got support of international human rights activists they said he's mentally ill and needs help, like wtf
So true I also don't understand remember delhi rape case so many human right lawyers r supporting the rapist. Where humanity going in this world 🌎. No one sympathy the victims n their families trauma whole life
@@pennyc8252 No lawyers do their job by representing case but they also know they are going to loose
It's part of democracy everybody has right to having a lawyer
@@pennyc8252but there are people who support the prisoners giving second chance
Just go and check prison life in Finland u will be shocked that they are living better life than Indian middle class families and people support them for giving them second chance
That's sickening
Nowadays mental health card is used to get leeway for worst criminals
@@pennyc8252 The lawyers were even speaking like a rapists. They were blaming nirbhay for the rape.
Spot on. I liked the fact that you didn't use the usual intro video of Tried & Refused Productions for this review :)
The judiciary and police of this country to almost every institution of this country and the leaders are rotten to its core. It gets more depressing with each day. Jai Hind.
What about the POLITICIANS which WE elect ? WE are the CULPRITS for electing such criminal & racist politicians as they are the one's who decides the judiciary & police enforcement in our country.
When WE as a country without any prejudices elect a leader then they should be OUR servants but sadly in INDIA it's the other way round WE are behaving like their servants.
His acting in haseen dilruba was also phenomenal. His characterization of phycho kind of roles is phenomenal.
its actually crazy to think that without nationwide protests,a victim can't seem to get their justice.
Vikrant Massey acted really well but his character portrayal didn't have that darkness which this role required . Needed the vibe which Prasant Narayan left us with in Murder 2 . (IMO)
Even though I agree with the same , he did a good job but it wasn't as nerve chilling or scary as it should be.
I agree.. The character was tooo dark, but he couldn't portray to that level.. It was average..
I feel the same
I think he did well with his role. If you see the real Suresh Koli who his character is based off of, he looks like a normal guy. There is nothing eerie or disturbing about him. Most predators are charismatic, manipulative, nice looking people hence they are the last people you would suspect. I feel Virat’s character not being too dark made it 20x scarier cause that could be your next door neighbour or some person you know who seems like a nice person.
Prasant was so good in murder 2. Because of his character portrayal I was not able to sleep for days. I have not watch 32 sector yet so I can't say anything about vikrant performance.
I liked Deepak's performance more than Vikrant's in this movie.
Agreed!, you can see sharp contrast in the interview sequence. Without speaking anything Deepak Dobriyal acted/said a lot more through his eyes than Vikrant's tirade about his doings.
Bro that interrogation scene just traumatized me for a day such a brilliant performance by Vikrant Massey. Like at once he acts like a very familiar person but then the words come out of his mouth just leaves you speechless
And the sheer cluelessness! Almost shocked that he will be punished for such a thing!
Found Vikrant Massey to be overacting a little, trying to be someone he is not. In my opinion, Vikrant Massey should have played inspector and Deepak to play Prem.
@@ProudIndian6450😂😂 I agree. Love him as an actor but the interrogation part his acting was lil bit cringe and sloppy. This is my personal opinion no hate towards the actor. I love him I have been rooting for him since his tv days “baba Aisa varr dhundo “.
This movie reminded me of another horrific film I saw called Silenced. The film got so much attention that it changed the South Korean Law! I hope this film can do something like that as well and it serves some justice to the parents who lost their kids. Hope they reopen the case or bring some change in our country's justice system!
Bro this is India. Ghanta ho ga kuch.
Exactly wo south korea tha yeh India hai @@dontlookatme9692
The incharge of this case, Simarjit Kaur was dismissed by court for taking 3 lakhs bribe from the House Owner. After the verdict, she got back on duty and now is facing charges of taking 50k as bribe from an alleged r@pe victim.
There is no hope for our country and the children. How do people close their eyes.
…nithari kaand ko copy kiya lekin dark movie banane ke guts nahi thi unme
yeh bilkul sahi pakde ho. Highlight kiya darkness aur casually chor diya
Dark toh lgi muje movie but the actual case is even more darker.
भाई मेरे, इस (कल)युग में हर एक इंसान की सोच और वजूद ही इतना काला हो चुका है कि इससे और अधिक काला हम प्रेक्षक के रुप में भी बर्दाश्त नहीं कर पाते ! अब तो बस राह तक रहे हैं कि कब कल्कि अवतरित हो और कब हम इस युग से मुक्त हो ।
The frustrating thing about the acquital of these two is that the lapse was not on the side of judiciary but the investigative agencies who couldn't build a watertight case.
I think that because of Noida being under the jurisdiction of the UP govt, the makers adopted a safety driven choice of shifting the crime scenes to Delhi and portraying the case as being their fault mainly because of the current political environment in UP
Yeah
Man I was just shocked the acting range this guy possess 12th fail now sector 36
Watch haseen dilruba
@@kritipant9041 well I have but honestly he went on a next level on this if you remember the starting scene
While Vikrant was great, i feel Deepak stole the show with his restrained and nuanced performance
Deepak Dobriyal death sean was just heartbreaking 💔
Jammy i hear you, and im not diminishing the case by any means.
But this movie is not about the nithari killings per se. It is "loosely" based on it. So the artistic liberty is understandable.
Fair? No. But understandable.
The problem brother is, literally every finding of the case including those accused and their descriptions are identical to the Nithari case. Why take the creative liberty in other features when you're leaving no shadow of a doubt that this is that case
I agree with you brother sudden disconnection I felt with the movie after climax...I mean why you suddenly show that everything is okay and justice has been served...climax of this movie is very bad example of open end movie@@TriedRefusedProductions
@@shaolinAlexander ...on the contrary it shows the system allows corruption by showing the informant of the upper crust becoming the head of the police dept and implies things will go on as they did before. I cant see any served justice in it.
Coz they wanna avoid potential lawsuits.
I was not able to sleep after watching this film. Hats off to vikrant massey and that interrogation scene. Deepak dobriyal no matter what he is doing in a movie, just never fails.
Talking about the real events, for a person living outside UP and Delhi, this case signified the city of Noida to me. It was like a city of hell for me and friends who knew about the case through TV news.
It brought back all the bad memories and discussions we used to have.
Bhai main to 10-15 min bhi nahi tik saka....aur violent movies to kaafi dekhe hain waise.
I really creeped out by the acting of vikrant in interrogation scene damn sad movie but awesome the release of the real culprit breaks my heart if u are wealthy u can do whatever u want sad reality man
Exactly felt the same. I was in class 7th when this incident happened. NGL I was legit scared back then. This was also the first time I got to know about cannibalism (The only other cannibalism incident that I could remember from back then was one from an episode from a show on sony tv where Makrand Deshpandey played a cannibal).
So, I was actually bummed when the actual facts were not shown in this movie. It somewhere did not leave the impact it was intended to leave.
Also it was quite responsible on the part of makers to not show the crime & even mute the part where Prem was narrating the horrors of the crimes he committed. I think this was done intentionally so that people don’t get inspired by the same.
Also, I kinda prefer (acting wise) Raghav’s psychopath character from Kill more than Vikrant’s character in this film. May be the writing or something else but Vikrant did not look as evil as he should have been.
This is one of the best films this year. The social commentary was spot on. Vikrant nailed it. The film was never about the case..it clearly differentiates between the class of society and the treatment they deserve from the authorities. How they were the soft target.
This was not a documentary but a very powerful dark film with strong social commentary. The last scene , where the lack of change of the moral compass, if not becoming worse, within the police department hit me the most.
I never thought any other monologue of a psychopath unapologetically confessing his gruesome acts could be this disturbing and enraging after Delhi Crime season 1.
VIKRANT MASSEY 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
that glaring stare. the adamant nature in believing he did something right. Haunting
Delhi crime*
I ever wondered how a serial killer or psychopath justify himself. Now I got the answer. They never find themselves as guilty
I cannot dare to watch this real life crime thriller but can you tellwhy he did all this@AryaAms
No to mention the thing that he kept doing to his hair during the interrogation
The story started from a very rooted place and then in the very end it felt like a crime thriller drama.
And what was the need of that post credit scene!!!
like wtf is the point of that CD now. The accused are acquitted aur yahan inka apna sequel ka plan chal raha hai. Hence my gripe with the creative route
That interrogation scene was the highlight of the film for me.
Both of 'em fkin' nailed it!!!
Years have passed and nothing has changed. We see the same kind of incompetence from Indian Police with the Kolkata case. I have 0 trust on Indian Judiciary and Indian Police. We are getting nowhere in improving things our society. It's just sad.
I don't understand this. In one scene prem is shown to be scared shitless when Pandey almost catches him. He makes phone calls to bassi and the compounder because he feels there's a risk of his and his boss's secrets being exposed. In the other hand there's prem revealing everything during the interrogation with copious details. It just seemed too convenient. As if the makers of the film just made efforts to glorify the interrogation scene but not the build up to it. Like how do you show a killer scared to get caught in one scene and then just the opposite in other scene. A serial killer makes attempts to never get caught
He was not ashamed of his deeds as he was a psychopath. But, even they have fear of loosing their reputation, getting caught in kidnapping of policeman daughter is something that is wrong as per his learning , at the same time exploiting or killing poor kids, and the woman he liked is something that they deserved in his opinion. He wasn't ashamed of all his deeds,but still they have a fear of getting caught in an act. It's so f**ked up in their head, that normal people don't understand why and what. They can't think rationally, feel like normal people, but based on their learning they do things, and they justify their actions throughout and can do any sort of evil as long as it is not wrong in their head.
@@SamJ-cs4ko agree 💯
Indians respect power, money, fame. Its like we have in our genes to be submissive in front of authority and show power in front of weak. This is because of casteism
9:55 MAN THAT SCENE
Completely agree with your review . I felt the same, they shouldn’t have gone down the who-dun-it thriller route on this subject as it’s based on true events and the music was so misplaced, tonally jarring ! Wish the filmmaker had been sensitive and honest regarding the screenplay ! Disappointing for sure
The confessing scene omg ..it was so horrific and i know the actual case and there was details given by that monster more cruel ..and knowing that , seeing the confession scene at the movie gave me more goosebumps 😨
I was hesitant when I heard Deepak Dobriyal is the protagonist because his silver screen persona is more of a comedic character. But he surprised me! Little did I know he is actually very well established in the theatre scene.
Getting justice in India is the most difficult thing...period!
Jammyyyyy this is like the 45th time I'm asking you to check out this movie called *Ibbani tabbidha ileyali* please watch it Mann, it's one of the best movie from Sandalwood,
And coming to this video, the intro was shocking, I swear to god I had never heard about this case, this was another thappad on our law and order...💔
woww first time i got the right time recommendation of the bell icon , soon within 1 min of upload
The movie is so good and the brutality of the pschyopath shown disturbed me. I couldn't watch beyond 40 minutes. World is so scary man😳
Being a baby girl mom, it pains me, gives me chills and I feel scared all the time as I don’t trust anyone with what is going on in this country.
Bruh where did vikrant land himself after 12th fail felt exactly the opposite emotion in this one. When the interrogation scene came up ijust told myself damn this guy is living the character🗿
Yes I completely agree with you. Bollywood is totally lost making movies on real events and that is why I hate watching Bollywood movies.
Buddy, at the end of the day, that is a production and feeds many families. The director WILL have to make sure that it doesn't cause problems in today's Indian diaspora. On the other hand, I commend YOU for speaking about it and bringing your audience's attention towards the issue. Your decisions affect only you (assuming you work solo, apologies in advance if you don't) .
I dont care about the plot, story or anything, all I SAW WAS THE VIKRANT MASSEY!!
OFF TOPIC
Films aside, one thing is quite evident and clear no matter where one resides. Justice is for those who can afford it. Simply put.
I liked that part of the interrogation scene where Vikrant's goes low and Deepak starts recollecting the names of those kids. Brilliantly, avoided Vikrant's actual explanation. That also elevated the scene to a new level.
I absolutely loved this movie until I saw this review...The points that you are highlighting around creative liberties is so valid and adds so much gravity to this review
My first intro the nithari murders was through the web series Abhay, whilst it was a fictional take also it did give me a reason to look forward to the movie to know the actual details. But the aside the perfomance and certain scenes, just knowing that facts have been changed takes away what would make the movie special
Well narrated. We could feel your pain and emotions! Very sad this is.
I am not going to watch this. This is not meant for me 😅
I started watching this movie and when the boy and vikrant came on screen I just couldn't continue watching, it was so real. Vikrant's acting is too real and the dialogues are too real.
Vikrant Massey was on Fire 😮😮
He literally "Killed" it ..both onscreen and Off screen in this Movie 👌👌 Brilliant Performance
Deepak Dobriyal's murder scene was just so heart breaking.😢😢
Wealth is only with politicians, sportsmen, filmstars and business men in this country, rest are all doomed. Its always better to move to a country where human rights are taken seriously. Cant imagine the horror and trauma victims went through in these incidents
Thank you for such a truthful review - going beyond mere movie review and talking about the reality shown in the movie. My biggest gripe with movies made on real story is twisting the truth. I feel not telling the story as is is twisting the truth. How many people who watched the movie would go and find out what happened in real life?
I watched it yesterday's and omg what an acting by both the lead cast Deepak Dobriyal and Vikrant Massey......Vikrant with his psychopath demeanour chills down my spine especially in that interrogation scene ....he didn't take the larger than life villain approach and makes it more grounded which is applaudable 👏👏....... whereas Deepak Dobriyal as sub inspector pandey portrayed a very subtle performance.....he shines in emotional scenes ...his eyes speaks a lot about what's going in his mind ........one of the best movie i seen in recent times ......hope we get to see Deepak Dobriyal sir more and more
Oh..our TRP host is rich and privileged 😅
Justice is really expensive.. not everyone can afford it.. so a normal person can't trust the system.. all he can do is take matters in his own hand.. justice is a joke in this country.. this movie made me really disturbed
the principle that no one should be convicted based on conjecture or doubt. This is rooted in the idea that it's better for a guilty person to go free than for an innocent person to be wrongly convicted. While this principle can sometimes lead to the acquittal of individuals who may be guilty, it's a necessary safeguard to prevent the injustice of convicting the innocent. As you pointed out, there can be collateral consequences, but upholding this standard is essential to preserving fairness and the rule of law. It's a balance between individual rights and societal safety, often leaning towards protecting the former, even if it means some level of compromise on the lat
So awesome to see Deepak Dobriyal as one of the lead and Vikrant, as usual, raised the bar of his acting skills. My prayers to the victims' families and hoping them to receive justice and inner-peace.
The judiciary is corrupt from top to bottom 😢😢😢 No money no justice
It is not high court's work to collect evidences
Totally agree with you Jammy. If someone is tackling such a sensitive incident they shouldn’t take the easy way out and make a regular thriller.
Thank you for this video… these are my exact thoughts on this case, while the reality of it is something I am actively following, this film was harder to digest…
100% agree with this video. The performances and direction etc doesn't matter when you take a serious subject then it must be dealt with sincerity.
You should not make a movie on real life incidents to use plight of people to make money if you don't intend to show the details.
After watching the movie you will only feel disgust but you won't know anything about what happened in reality except for innocent children were abused and killed. Why ? Was there any organ racket involved ? Why there were let go free ? Etc thsi is doglapan.
You could have recommended the documentary- “the karma killings “, gives gruesome insights and did justice to the narrative
I wonder why people still think that the courts and judicial system gives justice.
One should realise , that courts look at evidences , statements and what arguments are made.
Emptions , propaganda , etc have little to no bearing on the outcome of cases.
Unless one reads the cases in detail , and what charges / arguments were put forth the courts by the prosecutor, such decisions while might feel unjust to common people like us , however, would be totally correct for those who understand the technicalities of law.
This is sad , but true .
Having said that , there is no denying that rich , powerful and influential people get away with a lot .
Just watched it, and imo Vikrant couldn't justify the role except for the confession scene, film does feel directed by a newbie, Deepak was good at his part though. Overall pretty mediocre good.
The performance by Vikrant in the interrogation scene had my jaw on the floor. 😮
Loving how you're bringing yourself into the reviews more, but not letting it completely cloud your judgement.
On the same adaptation, Prashant Narayan did the outstanding acting before ages. His character was something which gave that persona ki insan ko dekhkar ghinn ajaye.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but I did know about this Talwar's case through this national series of India Crime Patrol, so on a base of established viewers of that jig, i can say Patrol's screen play is way better then these high flying movies, sometimes it's so linear that you watch it in episode not in a single sitting, that drag that boring.
Loved the sensitivity with which u opened this episode
Cmom dude
Monkey man was 2000 and the nithari case 2006. The world was a very different place in 5-6 years
I don't think its a stretch when you say the early 2000's and reference this man. It's not pre historic news compared to the nithari case
@@TriedRefusedProductions fair enough. Although I'd argue that with mobiles becoming more common place and internet moving from landline to broadband made the world a very different place but I'll go with it.
Having said that, I like your content. Keep at it
Cheers
Amazing acting by Vikraat,Dobriyal.Just amazing.Hoping to see more good movies from Bollywood
I loved the film but it's really traumatizing!! 😭
Vikrant's character is so creepy and scary and literally gives chills!! His guilt-less confession and his past ahh everything is scary!! I can't believe he is the same guy who played Veer in BBB, he is so versatile ❤️
Also I have been Vikrant's fan like for the longest time, but this time I was just so much in awe of Deepak Dobriyal I mean wow from the start to the end, the way he portrayed the character so justly!!!
Also, an observation: during the chase scene both Deepak and Vikrant's characters are in Ravana's get up signifying that both are (in diff ways obviously) unjust and evil.
The interrogation scene and climax gave me chills, and ofcourse I saw it at night, haven't slept in 2 days 😭👍🏻
I came here after watching the movie and genuinely felt the movie didnt do justice to the real case. I was expecting a little more from the story. Maybe a series of this would have been better than a movie. Nonetheless, hats off to vikrant's acting. Thanks for your review. Love how you articulate things. 👍🏻
I heard this case during my school days. I used to go BBPS Noida until my 9th class later we moved to South delhi. All these stories mentioned actually happened during the 20s.
The movie probably had gotten vikrant messy another national award if it had been true to the facts of the case just like what talwar case did... An opportunity lost to showcase the truth for creating unnecessary thriller... It could have left and imp question for everybody seeking justice on why the case can not reopen in SC to bring justice...
Honestly was waiting for this review. This was gut ranching
excellent review .. i support your opinions .. thank you for sharing
Thank you for starting out this video the way you did. The Justice system in India has long become a joke. It is unbelievable that a case like this, so well publicised has acquitted its main perpetrators like this.
Loved the film and performance but point made by you are more important and should have been considered by the maker.
As an admirer and a regular spectator of your reviews I totally agree with your agree with your point of view but still in the movies' defence it is also going to be a testament to our very times hence i Justify the 'Tandav'.
I am still in shock and awe how great this movie was. Simple screenplay but amazing amazing cast.
amazing movie and amazing acting by everyone. thrilling suspenseful. climax is very heart wrenching.
I could not watch this movie for more than 15 mins. Brave of Vikrant Massey to take up this role, While his stock as an actor may have risen, his positive image from 12th fail would have taken a big beating. For general audience, this horrific character played by Vikranth will have a very bad recall value.
I get your frustration at the direction chosen but I also feel that there are very few films that portray a case as is for the fear of it turning into a docu-drama. Talvar & Madras Cafe are the ones I remember that tried to do so.
But this movie did bring the plight of the poor & the gruesomeness of the crimes to the fore. I for one didn’t know where the case currently stands before the movie..
I remeber years ago crime petrol covered this case too and it still sends the chills ,I was a kid back then and though I knew the story but it literally sent chills down my spine ,performances were spot on and totally agree the real case was mere a part of the story but it still is most disturbing thing I've watched
@Anmol, it’s first time when I found you review heart felt! I can relate the pain as I stayed in Delhi NCR at that time and used to work in Noida. However, I feel with current political situation asking questions can reprimand the creators and it’s a fair ask from them not to indulge in showcasing bureaucratic complacency! It’s good that people have started to talk about the horrific events due to this movie. Being a parent, my heart goes out to those who are family members to these victims. Hope they find peace in this life after what they have been through🙏
I couldn’t even complete the film .. it’s just very sad..
I knew of the phrase 'nithari kand', didn't knew what it was. Googled it once and quit after reading one article. Had no courage to read deeper
@@swatisaini6447 Did you skip the film as well??
@@Ashwini-u2p yes. Too scary