I have the same reaction. He's not only a much better pianist than me, he has a far better understanding of the structure of the music; I just read the notes and try to hit them.
Barenboim ignores the rhythm in the score and makes up his own. Horrible.That may be why his Clair de Lune sounds different than yours. He doesn't count!
I never realized the first sentence is actually of syncopation since my first time playing clair de lune twenty years ago. What a revelation! Time to revisit this masterpiece.
Please be sure to place 9 beats in a measure, as indicated in the score, and certainly NOT reflected in Barenboim's playing, whose rhythm here is disgraceful.
I dont get how anyone can dislike this video. the master is teaching people how to appreciate the music in its rightful form, its construct. Not to only indulge ourselves in this pieces' nice melody and atmosphere but he teaches us to understand the logic behind it which authenticates its mastery.
Nicht von dieser Welt 😳how very weird you chose a German You Tube name, and you don’t even speak German. Just like you are a snob about art I think you are trying to appear very sophisticated....alas...gotcha😂🤣!!!!!
As someone who's not musically trained, listening to Maestro Barenboim's exposition of this piece makes me feel both humbled and blessed that I am part of this creation called humanity capable of such simple beauty.
Five minutes for these videos is just too short, wish it were fifty, or more. It's like having the privilege of Leonardo da Vinci teaching you to paint, but only for five minutes.
Monsieur Barenboim, vos enregistrements des concertos complets de Mozart avec l'orchestre de chambre du Wiener furent les morceaux favoris dans toute la musique pour mon père, défunt aujourd'hui, pour qui vous étiez avec Rubinstein l'un des très grands interprètes du vingtième siècle. Quant à moi, votre enregistrement des nocturnes de Chopin a bercé toutes mes années d'université, et je mesure toutes les autres interprétations par rapport aux vôtres. Merci d'avoir rendu nos vies plus belles et nos plaisirs musicaux plus grands.
Barenboim et Debussy! un Homme de Paix, sait mieux que quiconque sentir et dire la musique, et donner l'élévation qui fait vibrer notre âme! Thanks, and LovexxxEsther et Etienne Kervyn
Wow! The Master himself!. I was completely mesmerised by this your Video. A veritable Masterclass on this beautiful piece of music. I will be following all your Presentations. I cant believe I have been so lucky to see a quality Presentation from a talented Pianist. Thank you Maestro.
Mondieur Baremboin 100 fois je vous ecoute avec le second mouvement du klavierkonzert 5 de Beethoven et 100 fois je pleure de joie et de gratitude. Ma gratitude je vous l exprime pour votre Amour de la paix entre les peuples A travers votre OstWest Divan orquester associant de jeunes Palestiniens et de jeunes Israeliens dans une meme communion dans la musique. Vous etes un homme de coeur, Vous etes un homme de paix. Vous etes un ange a l Oeuvre sur cetteTerre. Merci de ce cadeau. Et longue vie a vous !
After a day of work on Sunday, on a place where there's no subtillities and lot of consumerism, it is just so kind that I came up to this video with Daniel Barenboim explaining details on Claire de Lune. Now I'm filled with love. Thank you maestro for always having thie will to transmit your love for Music.
Thank you sir, for bringing a bit of culture and beauty to RUclips. This music reminds us of the best of humanity. In this world of war, hatred, oppression, and destruction, if only we could all focus on the good, the beautiful, the sublime.
I very much appreciate that Barenboim is one of the few performers (another is Lang Lang) who draw attention to the gentle dissonances in the piece rather than trying to make them just softly dissolve into the harmony. It enhances the overall wistful effect of the piece dramatically.
Admirable. Il demultiplie le sens de l'oeuvre. Sa sensibilite est a la mesure de sa virtuosite et de so analyse. On progresse plus avec lui en 5 minutes qu'en annees quand on reste seul. Cette musique evoque les paysages calmes et un peu frais de la Sein et de l'yonne.
i learned it about a year and a half ago, still trying to master each step at a time. I hope I'm able to finish this in time for my grannies to listen.
Seeing this makes me realize that learning what is written on the sheet music is merely the first step- the beauty and magic comes long after (and sometimes not at all).
Saying that the first phrase begins, "in the air" as opposed to the second time with a more elaborate left hand being, "on the ground" is such a simple but beautiful metaphor. It's perfect. I'll never hear it the same way.
great idea - training the listeners' ears - it makes the musical piece more tantalizing - the listener is no longer being dragged along - but more alert - and eager - i wish this had been available to me decades ago
I just watched a video of the recording of Debussy playing Clair de Lune. This has all the wonderful feeling of the composer's own performance. Mr. Barenbolim obviously knows his music. Lovely!
Thank you so much Maestro Barenboim, never stop believe in, only music is our salvation and you are doing a great job indeed, supporters are always here to backup you.. that's what fans are for
i now understand why debussy was once titled as the 'monet of piano', his pieces are phrased so beautifully yet still robust and firm, it is beautiful how he can shape it using odd chords or phrasing/rhythms in his pieces which can complement other phrases in unimaginable ways. He is an impressionist of music.
As someone that listens to heavy rock (AC/DC , Zepplin and the likes) but produces dance music ..... this is actually my fave piece of music, anytime I hear it I sit back and sigh at the feeling it gives me ❤️
Absolut amazing! Fanastic Master bouth.! Thank you Mister Barenboim. Your super beautiful sound! Your super soft, delicat just perfect timing and phrasering. What A beautiful Debyssi dreaming, moonlight
Clair de Lune. Most amazing piece of music. It touches the deepest depths of my soul. Debussy played and teached on the hands of the master. Thanks for your sensibility and love for the music Mr. Barenboim
Daniel Barenboim has already left a legacy in ways I do not even know - but as an exponent of Beethoven, conductor of the best orchestras... He is also known for being married to Jacqueline du Pre who passed away far too soon (MS).
@@kitbeethoven no. he's saying this is what *I* notice about it - Debussy would be the first to agree that no piece of music is a formula that must be precisely followed - also I find myself appreciating the piece even more after this little insight into the chord progression: mission accomplished
He is a gem and master. So grateful for you, Maestro Barenboim. Thank you for putting words to what our ears and hearts always knew and sharing with others.
I still smile when I remember how young and funny you were while rehearsing in London 1969 for that once in a lifetime chance performance of the Trout Quintet with those other 4 great talents. I was only 2 years old then, I wish I could have been in the audience.
What a privilege it is to listen to a masterful musician like Daniel Barenboim interpret and speak through this exquisite piece by Debussy. Brilliant! Heartfelt thanks for your insights.
SALUDOS DESDE ARGENTINA PARA EL MAESTRO BARENBOIM , QUE NOS REPRESENTA TAN MARAVILLOSAMENTE EN EL UNIVERSO DE LA MUSICA .- EL CLARO DE LUNA DE DEBUSSY ES UNA GENIALIDAD MUSICAL DE MI PREFERENCIA . UN GRAN ABRAZO Y LO ESPERAMOS SIEMPRE EN BUENOS AIRES -
![5 Minutes On... Beethoven - The Moonlight Sonata (C# minor) | Daniel Barenboim [subtitulado]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EZsBi50VbXw/mqdefault.jpg)
![5 Minutes On... Beethoven - The Moonlight Sonata (C# minor) | Daniel Barenboim [subtitulado]](/img/tr.png)
![5 Minutes On... Mozart - Piano Concerto No. 23 | Daniel Barenboim [subtitulado]](/img/1.gif)
"Put your ear on my left hand".
I love that phrasing.
Daniel Barenboim in a previous video (a masterclass with Yang Yang) stated that music can never be a profession; it is a way of life.
All I can hear after he said that is what his left hand is playing...simply astounding
and you did....
I tried but it was too hairy for my liking warts and all
laire de lune barenboim
My god the bass of that Steinway 🤯
Alejandro Sosa a very musically advanced dick.
@@tonytonychopper999 lol, throbbingly correct.
Tony Z Lolll
What is up with this replies xd
its a hundred thousan dollar bass
When I compare his way of playing Clair de Lune and mine, I have the feeling that we don't play the same piece at all aha.. he's amazing!
I have the same reaction. He's not only a much better pianist than me, he has a far better understanding of the structure of the music; I just read the notes and try to hit them.
@@soaringvulture Now,when i'm playing this piece,I hear different things,thanks to this video!
So me
Barenboim ignores the rhythm in the score and makes up his own. Horrible.That may be why his Clair de Lune sounds different than yours. He doesn't count!
@@kitbeethoven I didn't think of that!!!You're right!!!
I never realized the first sentence is actually of syncopation since my first time playing clair de lune twenty years ago. What a revelation! Time to revisit this masterpiece.
I always say it as an anacrusis, so the second chord was on beat 1
Means you weren’t really counting! Lol
I've always called it "playing after the downbeat".
Still learning what really is special in music at 87 and pleased as punch in doing so!!
Please be sure to place 9 beats in a measure, as indicated in the score, and certainly NOT reflected in Barenboim's playing, whose rhythm here is disgraceful.
My God, is that not the most beautiful piece of music.
I would probably say “Chicken on the rocks
is number one, but this a close second for sure.
I think so too yes.. 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Your "god" had nothing to do with it, I can promise you. 😉
Zaine Ridling Oh Mr. Ridling, must we be so dismissive of fellow music-lovers?
And God won't hold your promise against you, Zaine.
I dont get how anyone can dislike this video. the master is teaching people how to appreciate the music in its rightful form, its construct. Not to only indulge ourselves in this pieces' nice melody and atmosphere but he teaches us to understand the logic behind it which authenticates its mastery.
It's RUclips. Some people have a pathological need to denigrate the work of others, it seems to inflate their flaccid ego.
Nicht von dieser Welt Du klingst genau wie die Menschen die du hier beschreibst: snob, wanbabee, Lästerer!
Nicht von dieser Welt 😳how very weird you chose a German You Tube name, and you don’t even speak German. Just like you are a snob about art
I think you are trying to appear very sophisticated....alas...gotcha😂🤣!!!!!
@Nicht von dieser Welt Out of curiosity, what music do you enjoy?
Fruit boots, Nicht?
As someone who's not musically trained, listening to Maestro Barenboim's exposition of this piece makes me feel both humbled and blessed that I am part of this creation called humanity capable of such simple beauty.
Five minutes for these videos is just too short, wish it were fifty, or more.
It's like having the privilege of Leonardo da Vinci teaching you to paint, but only for five minutes.
Thank you for expressing this so beautifully and aptly!
Agreed. what a musical genius. he understands pieces to the point where very very few people can
Five minutes you will never forget.
Barenboim is an interpret not a composer.
So if you talk about da Vinci, Daniel would be a man who shows you some paintings of Leonardo ;)
or Paul Gauguin teaching you to paint 5 minutes or Johann Sebastian Bach teaching you to play and composed
Gracias Daniel !!!! Saludos desde tu querida Argentina.
Monsieur Barenboim, vos enregistrements des concertos complets de Mozart avec l'orchestre de chambre du Wiener furent les morceaux favoris dans toute la musique pour mon père, défunt aujourd'hui, pour qui vous étiez avec Rubinstein l'un des très grands interprètes du vingtième siècle. Quant à moi, votre enregistrement des nocturnes de Chopin a bercé toutes mes années d'université, et je mesure toutes les autres interprétations par rapport aux vôtres. Merci d'avoir rendu nos vies plus belles et nos plaisirs musicaux plus grands.
Merci monsieur ,quelle fraîcheur c est magnifique
Muchas gracias maestro Daniel, sus excelentes cometarios me han dado una mayor visión que ayuda a mejorar la interpretación. Muchas bendiciones.
Thank you Sir. Listening from the Philippines and sharing with everyone I know. ❤
Barenboim et Debussy! un Homme de Paix, sait mieux que quiconque sentir et dire la musique, et donner l'élévation qui fait vibrer notre âme! Thanks, and LovexxxEsther et Etienne Kervyn
Gracias por su tiempo y por compartir oro.
Wow!
The Master himself!.
I was completely mesmerised by this your Video.
A veritable Masterclass on this beautiful piece of music.
I will be following all your Presentations.
I cant believe I have been so lucky to see a quality Presentation from a talented Pianist.
Thank you Maestro.
Genial gracias emosionante
Quiero más 👏👏👏
Prachtig, voor mij zeer emotioneel❤️
The sound becomes texture under his fingers: deep, lush, silky velvet. Entrancing.
Grande Barenboim, thanks to you to share with us your wisdom!
Mondieur Baremboin 100 fois je vous ecoute avec le second mouvement du klavierkonzert 5 de Beethoven et 100 fois je pleure de joie et de gratitude. Ma gratitude je vous l exprime pour votre
Amour de la paix entre les peuples
A travers votre OstWest Divan orquester associant de jeunes Palestiniens et de jeunes Israeliens dans une meme communion dans la musique. Vous etes un homme de coeur, Vous etes un homme de paix. Vous etes un ange a l Oeuvre sur cetteTerre. Merci de ce cadeau. Et longue vie a vous !
"...on the ground....in the air ". Great visual. thanks maestro!
Thank you so much Maestro for uploading this video.
Definitely ONE of the most beautiful pieces of music ever written...
Thank you that was beautiful. I loved it all the way from Africa.🐘.
His playing is so heavenly. It's like taking a few minutes walk in space, far away from this painful planet
Maestro Barenboim ❤️
Grazie maestro, perle per ascoltare meglio, per capire di più. Non ho parole...Saluti da Atene.
Please post more sir ! You have no idea how much we love and respect you !
Oh, my goodness, you opened it right up for me. It's about loneliness and longing. Of course. Thank you so much.
So this little video made me cry. What a beautiful powerful example of the good that platforms like RUclips can bring....
100%
Thank YOU! Maestro!
Les mains s’éloignent et reviennent. Les différentes intensités du toucher de chaque main révèlent nombre de mélodie, je pense et
J’adore!
After a day of work on Sunday, on a place where there's no subtillities and lot of consumerism, it is just so kind that I came up to this video with Daniel Barenboim explaining details on Claire de Lune. Now I'm filled with love. Thank you maestro for always having thie will to transmit your love for Music.
Thank you sir, for bringing a bit of culture and beauty to RUclips. This music reminds us of the best of humanity. In this world of war, hatred, oppression, and destruction, if only we could all focus on the good, the beautiful, the sublime.
Amen
Every now and then someone comes along and writes a piece of music that is nearly perfect. And this is one of those pieces.
Love love such music....drift away...simply lovely...👍👍🎵🎵🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵
I very much appreciate that Barenboim is one of the few performers (another is Lang Lang) who draw attention to the gentle dissonances in the piece rather than trying to make them just softly dissolve into the harmony. It enhances the overall wistful effect of the piece dramatically.
The art of listening...thank you very much
Barenboim has made the world a better place for those with little or more knowledge of classical music. Brilliant, effortless musical gift.
you say brilliant effortless and i say brilliantless effort.
Oh, there's effort behind that, don't you doubt. Years and years and years of sweat and toil make it =Look= effortless.
Thank you, Maestro.
Thank you Mr. Barenboim
It's a joy to see you thinking and feeling about music
Thank you very much
My jaw dropped when I heard you play the beginning of the song. Great
Thank´s YOU
desde la luna de Buenos Aires le mando mis mejores deseos para estos tiempos BRAVO
So much passion in such subtlety.
Great Barenboim. It's my favorite piece of piano solo.
At 80 You inspire me to learn more! Thank You!
Admirable. Il demultiplie le sens de l'oeuvre. Sa sensibilite est a la mesure de sa virtuosite et de so analyse. On progresse plus avec lui en 5 minutes qu'en annees quand on reste seul. Cette musique evoque les paysages calmes et un peu frais de la Sein et de l'yonne.
Bravoooo....Maestro
Thank you Daniel. We love you.
I can't wait to finish this piece it's so beautiful
you will never finish it hopefully, hopefully it will be with you forever, always changing......
i learned it about a year and a half ago, still trying to master each step at a time. I hope I'm able to finish this in time for my grannies to listen.
And? How is it 2 years later :)
Yes! How it's going?
@@ricky_lian YO
herr barenboim-sie sind ein grossartiger künstler
Exquisite… the most beautiful sound and composition in the world
Just realized this year is the century of Debussy's death.
sad, innit?
Yeah it's in the description also
Seeing this makes me realize that learning what is written on the sheet music is merely the first step- the beauty and magic comes long after (and sometimes not at all).
We said. Bravo !
Thank you for sharing your great knowledge for viewers like me. Clair de Lune is also my favorite one.
Saying that the first phrase begins, "in the air" as opposed to the second time with a more elaborate left hand being, "on the ground" is such a simple but beautiful metaphor. It's perfect. I'll never hear it the same way.
Bravo MAESTRO!
great idea - training the listeners' ears - it makes the musical piece more tantalizing - the listener is no longer being dragged along - but more alert - and eager - i wish this had been available to me decades ago
Thank you Very much. ❤
I love how Daniel breaks down the piece on an emotional level. I'd love to study under him. Such valuable information!
You made me want to play the piece. It sounded so sublime.
Toccata by EJ MOERAN
And it actually is managable, so even for people that aren't the greatest pianists, give it a shot, you might succeed.
Claudio Arrau's version of this is so romantic!
With 2 years of daily practice you can play it
@@juanquiroga8933 I doubt you'll need that long. I got the first 25 bars down in a week.l
I just watched a video of the recording of Debussy playing Clair de Lune. This has all the wonderful feeling of the composer's own performance. Mr. Barenbolim obviously knows his music. Lovely!
A rare gift to humanity.
J'adore et j'admire depuis toujours Daniel Barenboim et se leçons de musique sont vraiment réussies.Merci,Maestro!
oh bullshit!
Thank you so much Maestro Barenboim, never stop believe in, only music is our salvation and you are doing a great job indeed, supporters are always here to backup you.. that's what fans are for
i now understand why debussy was once titled as the 'monet of piano', his pieces are phrased so beautifully yet still robust and firm, it is beautiful how he can shape it using odd chords or phrasing/rhythms in his pieces which can complement other phrases in unimaginable ways. He is an impressionist of music.
Beautiful, so relaxing
This piece of music brings tears of joy to me EVERY time I hear it.
It has a profound effect on me.
Daniel, you are a miracle of God on earth. Your music has done so much good for the world. Thank you.
What a beautiful man...you will listen in your own way
Me reitero, el Sr. Baremboim es uno de esos seres que tienen el Don, perfeccionado luego con exigente y continuo trabajo. Viva luengos anos.
Its a tease....thankyou mr. Daniel - absolutely beautiful play.
And thank you Maestro.
4:19 comparing the different parts was really mind blowing to me and also really amazing
There is a reason this is one of the greatest compositions of all time....its like floating down a river
A hero for our time. Pure light, in a time of darkness.
As someone that listens to heavy rock (AC/DC , Zepplin and the likes) but produces dance music ..... this is actually my fave piece of music, anytime I hear it I sit back and sigh at the feeling it gives me ❤️
Hey. I am the same. Led Zep and I create dance. Can you send me a link where I can hear your music please?
Maestro gentile, la tua garbata sapienza illumina il mondo…non solo nella musica. 🎼✨
This piece is so romantic at the beginning but becomes whimsical and magical later on.
I've listened to so many renditions of this masterpiece,.....but Barenboim to my ear takes the prize,..... bravissimo.
Absolut amazing! Fanastic Master bouth.! Thank you Mister Barenboim. Your super beautiful sound! Your super soft, delicat just perfect timing and phrasering. What A beautiful Debyssi dreaming, moonlight
GRACIAS MAESTRO!!!
💖💖🙏🙏 Thank you very much Maestro Baremboin, Excellent Interpretation e Divina Spiegazione 👍👌👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 Cordiali saluti, Anna e Luigi
How are you doing today my name is Eric
Clair de Lune. Most amazing piece of music. It touches the deepest depths of my soul. Debussy played and teached on the hands of the master. Thanks for your sensibility and love for the music Mr. Barenboim
My god! So beautiful!!
Continue with these insightful and inspiring mini clinics! The music world needs you! You are leaving a legacy.
Daniel Barenboim has already left a legacy in ways I do not even know - but as an exponent of Beethoven, conductor of the best orchestras... He is also known for being married to Jacqueline du Pre who passed away far too soon (MS).
I’m at a loss: HOW could ANYONE find fault with a master playing and explaining a masterpiece?!
Morrons surely....
Because they are familiar with Debussy's score and recognize that Barenboim 's rhythm here is incorrect, and what's more, disgracefully so.
@@kitbeethoven no. he's saying this is what *I* notice about it - Debussy would be the first to agree that no piece of music is a formula that must be precisely followed - also I find myself appreciating the piece even more after this little insight into the chord progression: mission accomplished
@@kitbeethoven welp, that version has pretty much been overwrited by the new version :v
beautiful sound he has, and pedaling. that takes decades to perfect
Except his rhythm is deplorable. Inaccurate, incorrect, embarrassing.l
@@kitbeethoven yes, maybe someday Daniel will be a good as you
@@kitbeethoven wdym lol
Pedaling,I find it very difficult
to adjust as it varies from one piano to another.
I just love the sensitivity, I feel at home
Daniel Barenboim is a good man.
Que Maestro!
Wonderful Thank you !
formidable Daniel barenboim , génie modeste et cœur généreux
We need more of these videos from the masters of our time talking about the masterpieces of the past.
He is a gem and master. So grateful for you, Maestro Barenboim. Thank you for putting words to what our ears and hearts always knew and sharing with others.
I still smile when I remember how young and funny you were while rehearsing in London 1969 for that once in a lifetime chance performance of the Trout Quintet with those other 4 great talents. I was only 2 years old then, I wish I could have been in the audience.
Only five minutes. Ah! But what a wonderful, priceless five minutes. Thank you.
What a privilege it is to listen to a masterful musician like Daniel Barenboim interpret and speak through this exquisite piece by Debussy. Brilliant! Heartfelt thanks for your insights.
SALUDOS DESDE ARGENTINA PARA EL MAESTRO BARENBOIM , QUE NOS REPRESENTA TAN MARAVILLOSAMENTE EN EL UNIVERSO DE LA MUSICA .- EL CLARO DE LUNA DE DEBUSSY ES UNA GENIALIDAD MUSICAL DE MI PREFERENCIA . UN GRAN ABRAZO Y LO ESPERAMOS SIEMPRE EN BUENOS AIRES -