Check out my new video, in an arrangement for two guitars of a piece by one of the most famous American composers, which is .... ruclips.net/video/wdMVW1MDlNg/видео.html&ab_channel=RoxaneElfasci
Well. I'd left a post here about how there are many ways of learning a song, tbs, by sound by watching etc. But I guess it verged, completely unintentionally, on creepy and it got excised -(that's just as well, I'd intended to edit it anyway)
I am very excited to tell you all that I am now in the process of recording my debut solo album for release later this year. To start with I will be releasing my live performance of Clair de Lune on all music platforms worldwide on May 7th. You can enjoy it here: lnk.to/RECDL Best !
thank you so much for you music. After 8 years of coming up with plenty of excuses to not get a new guitar after my old one broke, watching this video inspired me to get a new one. I can not wait to learn this score and look forward to hearing more from you.
Congratulations! I have wanted to own a recording of your interpretation of Clair de Lune for a long time and I'm equally excited to hear anything else you record for the album!
This was one of my Mom's favorite piano pieces. She would have loved this guitar rendition, but I'm a bit too late as she passed away 4 months ago. So I thought of her throughout this video. Thank you for the creative, delicate, and emotional care you gave it!
Hi Craig. Very sorry about your Mom's passing. Hoping the Lord will bless you with His peace and comfort, and this composition will help with that. God Bless...
@@kenwbrenner Thank you for your well wishes. Very, very few strangers would take the time to do that. So, I'm most definitely compelled to acknowledge your kindness and giving nature!
As a classical pianist, I am absolutely floored. Not only did you play this difficult piece with a lovely, emotional, masterful interpretation, you played it on guitar!
On the lower neck, her fingers have the most amazing stretch into five and occasionally six frets…. And the pauses…. Seemed perfect w/ just the correct amount of timing to move to the next position
I don't want to undermine this guitarist as she is very talented with beautiful technique. But I wanted to say this piece isn't as complex as it seems and something you can very much work your way up to with an intelligent practice routine.
@@alexhoward1884 Like all beautiful masterpieces.....there are parts that are easy....then there are parts of complexity. Putting it all together is what seperates the masters and the rest of us. Good luck on your journey .....I hope to maybe one day capture the beauty this artist holds.
That's because guitar and piano have a lot of things in common with how they produce sound, so of course the notes timbre will be largely similar, as opposed to how it would be with a violin or trumpet.
@@Leonhart_93 you should listen the Oistrakh version, breathtaking. Of course the piano remains the best, Kocsis version of course 🤗 this is nice but I wish she didn't have to jump octavs, it breaks the melody line, maybe in another tonality ?
It's also the fact that she's intentionally playing close to the middle of the string, which is where the harp is plucked (while the guitar normally gets plucked around 1/3rd from the bridge)
it never crossed my mind that a guitar would be able to do justice to this composition. you trully are a virtuoso in perfect control of the instrument yet so effortless and smooth in your execution.
@@olliebear9256 Yes! But he had more than one version. My favorite is from the "Music for Lovers" LP. However, I believe that version is him playing an overdubbed track; essentially two guitars.
The technique displayed here is perfect. The subtlety of whole notes and quick single notes is wonderful and that’s so hard to do. Plus mixing in harmonics in between all those quick changes is just such amazing talent
French orchestral composer Berlioz was a guitar player, so it is not beyond possibility that Debussy may also have had a small guitar propped up by the piano.
Absolutely.There is such meticulous silence and delicate fingerwork there that even the very few, light frizzes there are should weigh more than gold ! Beautiful execution. Masterfully accomplished.
I actually love coming back to listen to this. As much as I enjoy the original piece on piano, this rendition is played so beautifully and somehow feels more fitting...magnificent.
To me, it doesn't feel more fitting, just different. Love it on a piano, as well as listening to her play it. Sounds great on harp, too ruclips.net/video/vVTPbLhlbfI/видео.html
Years ago, I was driving home from an airport run, on a moonlit night... the only radio station that has reception on the M6 through the hills of the Lake District was Classic FM ... so, begrudgingly, I turned it on... oh hell, Debussy, how over-sentimental... or so I thought at the time. Then the radio announcer told a story, about how someone had requested they play it, with a letter (paraphrasing) "In 1942, I flew in a WWII bomber crew, we used to fly to Germany and back, each night, with a realization that we had a 1/10 chance of not coming back... on one perfectly clear moonlit night (the most dangerous time to fly, you are easily spotted)...." I don't have the words to describe what he said in his letter, their communal sense of relief, and thankfulness just to be alive, to be returning home - when others were not so lucky - their elation of having survived was cruelly tempered by the knowledge that so many people would have died, and on their return, they would learn who had been lost that night. So, the navigator had set up a small gramophone, and, as seemed fitting for a moonlit night, played Claire De Lune to the crew across the intercom, as they flew home, safe. And there I was, driving home, alone, a full moon, not a cloud in the sky, realizing how lucky I was not to have had to live through that, and it showed me how these young men must have found hope in such beautiful music - it made me understand that writing music is a timeless way to celebrate the innate beauty of life. So, wonderful stuff +Roxanne Elfasci that's a stunning arrangement, love the way the harmonic undertones ring through - and, in recording, it's so hard to capture the "chime" and voice of a guitar, but the (mic? def not a U87 always) does a great job... nice recording of a beautiful arrangement... I love it and must work on some of that!
Wonderful story. What a way to grasp the power, importance, and beauty of music in peoples' lives. Also makes me grateful for my fortunate circumstances, and for the way that many people in drastically different situations can still have a common appreciation for things, like Debussy's beautiful piano compositions. Thanks for sharing.
Those who know how to play this on a piano will know how hellishly difficult this would be on a guitar. I hope you have a million likes on this video. I’ve replayed this many times.
Claire De Lune may sound difficult to play on piano, but it's a piece of intermediate difficulty. Of course, that does not take anything away from its timeless beauty. However, arranged for guitar, this piece becomes an extremely difficult one to play and especially with the proficiency that Roxan Elfsasci so beautifully does in this recording. I could go on and on about how fluent, seamless and fluid everything is played together.
I've heard so many versions of Clair De lune, both guitar and piano, this is by far my most favorite. Can't put my finger on why I keep coming back to this. Just hits me on such a deep level. I get very pensive and philosophical when I hear this version.
She's doing the impossible. And doing it in a such marvellous way that I almost can't believe. Clair de Lune is a so pianistic piece that making it sound in the guitar the way she gets is almost a miracle.
esojbar that’s what I was thinking! Over and over I kept doing double-takes at how she treated each section so masterfully, conquering parts with such beauty. When Love comes alive in a musician, the heart can inspire the brain and body to achieve whole new levels of mastery and creativity, and this woman has illuminated that truth with her own example.
Sitting here on a cold, dreary rainy afternoon, trying to fight depression from a recent diagnosis I just received. Just happened to hit this post and I was totally mesmerized by her beauty combined with magnificent artistry. What a rendition of one of my favorite Debussy songs. I wish I could articulate my emotions better. I feel calm and at peace. Peace and calmness to one and all of you!
Beautiful. makes you stop and realise how amazing humans actually are. The playing, the instrument itself, the technology to record and visualise it, the composition, and the elegance of the performance.
Yes.....the creation of the instruments. So many types that may be played alone or all types at once in the same key. Producing sounds that stir the soul and spirits of the listener. Yes indeed......amazing!
“Beautiful. makes you stop and realise how amazing humans actually are” Amazing in the one direction and appalling in the other. The upside of humans is indeed very high. Unfortunately the downside is very low.
@@keithsmith4780 that's why it is foolish to look towards mankind for answers to life's problems. A mere mortal, in my opinion, does not have the answer.
@@zain4019 i mean no offense, but i didn't say i have no idea what guitar position this is. I was stating the realistic fact that this position helps the player BE ABLE to strecth their fingers to play like that. It's like you decided to "correct" me when no correction was needed. For example, say if this video was someone eating a bowl of soup and i commented "holding the bowl helps to eat it." Then you reply to me "that's the classical soup eating position." You get it? Maybe I'm looking too much into your comment, like you did mine.
Indeed. I got a guitar and can't lie, it's confusing. I also had quite a hard time holding strings on the fretboard, the tone would go off. You had to be precise, just to get a note sounding as it should
In my opinion, i mean yeah it is harder to play on guitar, but it is also not easy to play on piano too. I think people like the piano better because clair de lune has been known with a piano and its also nice to hear on piano. But the guiitar man, masterpiece.
@@jerome4385 She is to guitar what Ben Webster is to sax. There are instrumentalists and vocalists (I won't mention names) who are very clinical and cerebral in their approach to playing; no emotion attached to it at all. That, by necessity, is the way it is when you're learning a new piece. But once you have it in your pocket, you own it. Your performance of the piece doesn't come from the brain but from somewhere deep inside. And that's what we're hearing here. This lady didn't play a single note that didn't have a piece of her soul attached to it. And that is guitartistry in its purest form.
Wow! Not only is Claire de Lune my favorite piece but your flawless rendition moved me to thank my Creator for allowing me to be alive to hear such precious and beautiful music. I know your talent didn't come easy and required many years of dedication and sacrifice but I thank you from the bottom of my heart for producing such a lasting impression on my psyche forever!
It's a guitar. The instument of the lazy. Trillions of hours have been wasted by lazy wortless people taking good people's money by operating such a dreadful device. I would rather hear a lawnmower
I think she has transposed from the original Db, to D for the guitar. Still sounds wonderful. :-) EDIT: After listening side by side with piano rendition, they are in the same key, so the guitarist must have detuned by a half-step. :-)
Breath taken away at the first note for this very reason. I've tried it too and failed hard. People who only listen may have their breath taken away for one reason. People who play may be astounded for another. Wow.
If I work VERY hard, I MAY learn the notes and MAYBE I can technically perform the piece. But it is the rare person that can bring this level of feeling and emotion. Ms Elfasci is truly a brilliant artist! Bravo.
There is a certain humbleness about this song. Like a speck of dust floating around inside a drop of water that slowly slides down the leaf of a tree on a rainy afternoon. It says to me "Calm down, not everything is on your shoulders. You're like that speck of dust.. relax"
to me the intro feels like sadness and pain, and then with the faster parts it comes trouble and panic, and after it's over the intro tries to come back but it's different, more melancholic, like the notes are carefully trying to be what the intro was but the first notes comes out different in an even sadder way but with a tone of overcoming . to me this song feels more like the stages of grief after losing someone, and not "romantic" like people say.
Just exquisite. There are few things in this world which justify human existence more undeniably than this sublime melody. Thank you, Roxane for a flawless performance.
I lost count how many times I've come back to this, and I do so when the world and everything around me start my anxieties. Right now the world is in a collective grief, and one could only hope for normalcy to return. This video is a pocket of peace amdist the crisis.
No such thing as normal. Embrace the chaos and pursue your joys. At the end of the day nobody is getting out alive anyhow :) have fun. And peace be with you
1. She plays 9/8 on guitar 2. She plays a piano piece 3. She plays it up to tempo 4. No accidental muted sounds 5. PLAYS THE HARD PART THAT I CAN'T FRICKEN DO ON PIANO... Kill me
Ha ha Sam... love your sense of humor, "kill me" is perfect..I feel the same way every time I listen to Bill Evans, Paul Desmond or Julian Bream playing this: ruclips.net/video/Ua4x1UEvm3s/видео.html
Yes" seria raro " casi siempre lo hago es x civer espacio osea tras el vidrio ho espejo dd ti mismo alli " ho forma visual de estar made " individualmente asiendo ho percisionando un sonido ho voz " de forma de interpretar un sonido" pero si " estando tu. Ho que "??? Saber es" yes ho no "??? 😢 jo tin 😂❤???
Segovia once said..."The guitar maintains its natural beauty at the hands of the novice." Embrace the level of skill you have today. Its all about the journey....enjoy !
I once had a thought when I heard a piece of music, "I could never, ever, not in a MILLION BILLION YEARS play like that". Then I realized that I had absolutely nothing to lose by trying and went to buy a guitar. The first piece of music I ever tried to learn on the guitar was the Koyunbaba Suite... Not exactly beginner fare. It took a few years, but the love of the one piece kept drawing me forward to learn more and more and while I'm certainly no concert master, I can now play 20-30 minutes of reasonably engaging repertoire. I can even play the first 3 movements of the Koyunbaba Suite. I had a setback a few years ago when I played the piece for my grandmother on hear deathbed from the other side of the world. I didn't have much else of value to share with her as she was reaching out to her loved ones to make her feel like she had lived a good life. She stopped me as the emotional climax was building in the third movement and said it was too sad. We talked briefly after that and that was the last time we spoke. The piece is interpretative and can change flavor depending on the mood of the person playing. I was in a dark place at that time in my life and I think it came through. I have had a lot of trouble studying past that point because of it and the piece brought me to tears several times since then until I had to let it go. Even now, it takes tremendous effort to practice it and my eyes well up just writing this brief account. But in the end, I suppose that means that I was able to play it meaningfully, even if it was reflecting too much sadness. But this story wouldn't have happened if I hadn't tried. It would have simply been an awkward phone call where she asked me if I had any girlfriends or had thought about maybe making a family some day, while several of my cousins had delighted her with their small children and fresh life. Instead, I have something bittersweet, that is a reminder of what is important in life from a person who was and is still extremely important to me, in a way that I will never forget.
@@eschelar Thank you for sharing your story. Mine is quite different, but when I feel depressed somehow I end practicing with my guitar just to fill the void. I began with Asturias, by Albeniz. I'm still not capable of playing at the right speed and I haven't learned half of the piece yet, but even if I learn to play another 4 or 5 notes, I feel better. However, that piece alone kept me trying and I have learned a few other (easy) pieces that make me fell like I'm making progress.
That was beyond the limits of guitar - absolutely beautiful. One of the most stunningly beautiful performances I’ve ever seen on guitar. Bravissima !! Senza fiato.
Extremely well played. There is lot of feeling and emotion conveyed through the guitar technique, and interpretation. Very much enjoyed listening, thank you.
Of all the wonderful things I have seen in my 68 years...seeing and hearing this rendition is truly a marvelous moment. Thank you for your hours of practice and your diligence in coming to an understanding of the aura of this great music. From the bottom of my heart.
Honestly, I've always thought that pieces written by certain kinds of composers such as Debussy and Chopin are not really for guitars (Although I'm a big fan of guitar music as well as I am of piano music), but she changed my mind within 90 seconds. Please let me know if anyone knows other beautiful exceptions like this performance.
ruclips.net/video/Zq3rSwX4QHM/видео.html (and in this version, you don't get lost in so many interpretation subtilities, so don't have to know the original piano version to appreciate, in my humble opinion........... :).
Never in my life have I ever heard such a beautiful rendition of Clair de lune. My Mother played this on the piano perfectly . Growing up I often would request her to play this for me over and over again. Roxane you have captured my heart with your display and admiration for of this master piece. Bravo, your playing is excellent. What a gift you have. Much appreciated ! My Mom would have loved it. Bless you.
The technical virtuosity necessary for this performance is off the charts. Every note so clean. Lots of nuance. Very minimal string squeak. Truly inspired. Thank you for sharing.
She plays so delicate, soft, intense and tender at the same time. She embraces her guitar, Debussy must be grateful. Beautiful artist. I am grateful for the gift of listening her guitar.
This is the most beautiful Clair de Lune I have ever heard... Her technique is delicate but her mood and rhythm change is what I appreciate most its really beautiful...
In my 75 years on this earth I've heard countless guitar pieces of all genres and I can say truthfully that this is the most beautiful piece ever, played with skill and feeling.
Played the video twice. The first time I was totally mesmerised by her technique, the second time I closed my eyes and let the music take me to a wonderful place.
To re-arrange - what is common for guitar music - the third movement from Debussy's Suite bergamasque kind of a challenge. To transform the music from piano to guitar is a retelling. I think you succeeded. And you are telling a wonderfull story worth listening to. Your sound is great, your way of changing sound is wonderfull and you perform great. 5 Hearts from me. Great work.
classical music is so intense to my untrained ear, its hard to imagine a lot of people on piano being able to recreate a work 1:1. or the other side of the coin, masters of guitar being able to perfectly nail a solo from an original is just insane to me. I figured even the original artists just have to improv a bit but I dunno
I listen to a lot of guitar covers and arrangements of all sorts of classical pieces; And romantic era composers are my most favorite people ever, and I do not believe I will ever get tired of that genre of music. With that being said, this has to be the most beautiful arrangement on guitar that I have ever heard being played. So fluent, touching and eloquent.
This is stunning. I've played for years, and I can tell you I will never attempt to learn even the first mesure. I still can't believe what I've seen and heard. As close as perfection as it gets, great job. The amount of work behind this must be insane.
@@petermuller161 This exact vid is the reason I feel in love with classical guitar and I tried the first week to do this and tried again twice but every time I just realize that ill take years before I can get even close to how beautifully this was played
Extremely well played! As a former classical guitarist (the nerves of my hands and feet were damaged due to chemotherapy treatment), I can vouch for what Kyle Cravens said: this is CRAZY difficult. Of course, purists will point out her incorrect posture, the sound of the nails of the right hand, etc. but this is an excellent performance.
I am sorry to hear about the damage. It must be terribly painful not to be able to play anymore. Even with the unusually high guitar position, I find her technique impeccable; as for the nail sound, perhaps that was intentional, a part of her expression, given the dream-like mood of the piece?
bubka42 - I have always played (difficult) guitar pieces in my head throughout the day. I used to be able to come home and work those pieces out on my guitars. I can't do that anymore. As for Roxane's performance, you may be right. She may have allowed the nail soundings in order to add a mood to the piece. If that's true, she sure succeeded. So many guitarists have come out with different ways of approaching the instrument, like fanning, tapping, etc. I am just blown away by her playing. And you're right - impeccable.
And purists usually wind up sounding too pure, too machine-like; purists lack personality, in their playing and in their -- um -- personality. An instrument can be held many ways, as suits the player and the needs of the composition. As she does here. And personally, I like the chime effect of fingernails on the plectrum hand. PURISTS: it's what comes out of the instrument and through the air; that's why music is being played.
Russel - couldn't agree more. Some of those players sound like machines. Sometimes you like to hear the musician, things like the sound of nails, the "scrape" sound of the string when moving from one position to another, heavy breathing and so on. And I like your description of the right hand nails, sounds just like a chime. Good description.
"Purists" are the bane of creativity and excellence in every sphere of the arts. People whose enjoyment comes from talking a better performance than the actual artist. People who claim to speak for others who never gave them permission. Purists are detestable people who suck the joy from every atom of the world.
Roxane, I've seen many people attempt to play Clair de Lune on guitar... And I've been told by much better guitarist than me that it is one of the more difficult pieces to play on guitar, and have the impact that it does on piano... But YOU, my dear, when you look up "Magic in her Fingers" in the dictionary, it's got a picture of YOU!.. Bless You, for giving us mere mortals, something to Strive for!.. ❤
She is wonderful, very talented, Bravo. I wish her the moon in her career. For any guitarists who want to play this piece but doubt themselves, it is not impossible. If you are at a pretty good level already, you have paid your dues for some years, then 100 hours of work would make a big dent in this arrangement. You can find the James Edwards arrangement online, even free if you look hard. If after 100 hours of work you don't sound like her but only 62% of her level, well, you will still have the pleasure of playing this and it will sound beautiful, your friends and family will enjoy it. Some of the difficult stretches and passages can be modified. A lot of the painful stretches are just to make the bass notes sound through a measure of the melody, which is pretty subtle or actually does not happen much without a very expensive instrument. That is nice if you can do it, but almost no one will notice if you simplify the fingering. It does not have to hurt to play beautiful music for your own pleasure. Music is for everyone, the fantastically gifted, the somewhat less fantastically gifted, and the normally gifted who are willing to work hard out of love for music. Any determined intermediate guitarist can play at least some part of this arrangement.
Agreed, this is possible. Also having the neck so close to vertical really helps with those stretches. Her performance is beautiful, not trying to put it down with this comment.
If I didn’t see it done, I would have said it was impossible- this is the best classical guitar playing I’ve ever heard in my life. When you were at the end I said to myself “she’s not going to go for the ultra high octave harmonic, is she? That’s got to be so precise to come out that it’s ridiculous!” And then sure enough you did it. As far as the m concerned, you’re the new Segovia, bravo!!!
@@DidipanI'm right around the same point in my journey. Sending this to remind you to give it a try again! I've come across this like once a year to try and learn. Getting close to the ability level
My dad’s favourite piece of classical music before he passed away. It was rendered here in such a beautiful way. It was beautiful before, but here, you can feel every note so vividly. Absolutely masterful
Oh ... {speechless} .... I've played since 4th grade and worshiped guitar since even before that ... but I've *never* heard anything like this. What an incredibly gifted, emotive player: she is so 'gone' into this piece and her playing that you can FEEL it. I am so glad I was privileged enough to be able to watch. Like watching an angel play a harp. Thank you, talented player, for bringing this to us.
Hi Yes bbst "????claro fue culpa del señor DIOS ji.ji.ji tuvo la culpa EL piensa " the chaly" y claro tiene las merjores arpas del mundo y galacias" mas sonidos de angeles ha nivel world on of the's world ho sea disposicion de sonido interplanetario y esterno planetario"??? Es mas como sonaria la flauta majica de DIOS ???
What a gift to have and a joy to share. Thank you for an amazing five minutes of music, and guitar playing, that I have ever heard in my 66 year lifetime.
If you don't have some acquaintance with the guitar, you have no way of knowing how good this is. Wonderfully emotional. I need a cigarette and I don't even smoke!
well said. I agree in part, but the thing is, I actually smoke. So for me, this could be useful in listening to every time I feel like smoking? lol either way, the first part of your statement is sooooo accurate. Exciting to find others who feel the same way about certain songs and the guitar.
I never liked the piano rendition. But this just gives me goosebumps all over. Nylon strings in a classical style just works so well with this song. Then there's the emotion from Roxane. Such a fine touch on the strings.
Whoa, the fingers of your left hand look like they're made of liquid, always pouring on the fretboard. Impressive playing and lovely rendition of the piece. I loved watching and listening to that. Thank you!
My dearest sister died on 29/07/2022. This rendition on a guitar evoked my father playing the same song. I am doubled grief by this song. Thank you Roxanne..
Check out my new video, in an arrangement for two guitars of a piece by one of the most famous American composers, which is .... ruclips.net/video/wdMVW1MDlNg/видео.html&ab_channel=RoxaneElfasci
Beautifully played and sounding.
just watched. amazing. thank you
clair de lune....thanks.
One of my favourite pieces and you played it beautifully. The performance was as gorgeous to my eyes as it was in my ears.
Thank you for sharing this masterpiece ❤️ greetings from the Netherlands ❤️❤️🙏
It is magical how the next note is always the one that you want to hear - and it never dissapoints
A different note ... and there would be ... diminishment.
sometimes you don’t even know you want it until it plays
wow... I love your comment so much.
I wouldn't be able to think of a better way to put it
agreed, even the minor notes are the one that i want imagine to hear it!👌
Got the tabs? I just learned smoke on the water.
LMAO
Learn how to identify a joke
Hahaha
BRO LMAO
Well. I'd left a post here about how there are many ways of learning a song, tbs, by sound by watching etc. But I guess it verged, completely unintentionally, on creepy and it got excised -(that's just as well, I'd intended to edit it anyway)
I am very excited to tell you all that I am now in the process of recording my debut solo album for release later this year. To start with I will be releasing my live performance of Clair de Lune on all music platforms worldwide on May 7th. You can enjoy it here: lnk.to/RECDL
Best !
Pin this to be at the top so everyone can see it right away..... ❤️❤️❤️
Nice
thank you so much for you music. After 8 years of coming up with plenty of excuses to not get a new guitar after my old one broke, watching this video inspired me to get a new one. I can not wait to learn this score and look forward to hearing more from you.
You are awesome
Congratulations! I have wanted to own a recording of your interpretation of Clair de Lune for a long time and I'm equally excited to hear anything else you record for the album!
This was one of my Mom's favorite piano pieces. She would have loved this guitar rendition, but I'm a bit too late as she passed away 4 months ago. So I thought of her throughout this video. Thank you for the creative, delicate, and emotional care you gave it!
Hi Craig. Very sorry about your Mom's passing.
Hoping the Lord will bless you with His peace and comfort, and this composition will help with that.
God Bless...
@@kenwbrenner Thank you for your well wishes. Very, very few strangers would take the time to do that. So, I'm most definitely compelled to acknowledge your kindness and giving nature!
@@craigjohnson4302 It is my blessing to do so, hoping you will be blessed...
Im with Ken. Sorry for your loss ,Craig.
@@papaw2937 Thank you!
As a classical pianist, I am absolutely floored. Not only did you play this difficult piece with a lovely, emotional, masterful interpretation, you played it on guitar!
...and look at those finger positions... clearly not easy to do.
@@mattimaranda9638 no shit!
On the lower neck, her fingers have the most amazing stretch into five and occasionally six frets…. And the pauses…. Seemed perfect w/ just the correct amount of timing to move to the next position
She's probably more accurate at gang signs than the actual gangsters.
It's the casual and perfect use of harmonics that gets me. I don't play guitar but I appreciate it!
I see an infinite number of hours of practice in this video.
Pandas really can see the future!
Ling ling oh i gonna practice...
I don't want to undermine this guitarist as she is very talented with beautiful technique. But I wanted to say this piece isn't as complex as it seems and something you can very much work your way up to with an intelligent practice routine.
@@alexhoward1884 Like all beautiful masterpieces.....there are parts that are easy....then there are parts of complexity. Putting it all together is what seperates the masters and the rest of us. Good luck on your journey .....I hope to maybe one day capture the beauty this artist holds.
Do you mean a lot, or infinite? Just asking becauseonly one makes sense.
she makes it sound like this piece was made for guitar
Truly. I am shocked by this rendering. Incredible arrangement too.
Yes, she does! And what a gorgeous, captivating arrangement. Some really transcendent moments.
That's because guitar and piano have a lot of things in common with how they produce sound, so of course the notes timbre will be largely similar, as opposed to how it would be with a violin or trumpet.
foreal. it's crazy.
@@Leonhart_93 you should listen the Oistrakh version, breathtaking. Of course the piano remains the best, Kocsis version of course 🤗 this is nice but I wish she didn't have to jump octavs, it breaks the melody line, maybe in another tonality ?
My parents favorite.
May they both rest in peace.
Thank you.
Beautiful.
That was to be played when my mother died.
Sounds almost as a harp. Crazy stuff. Dynamic is phenomenal.
Alex Peter exactly!
I think it's with all the harmonics, those are way softer than the usual fingerpicked notes, and notes on the harp are softer than on guitar
It's also the fact that she's intentionally playing close to the middle of the string, which is where the harp is plucked (while the guitar normally gets plucked around 1/3rd from the bridge)
it never crossed my mind that a guitar would be able to do justice to this composition. you trully are a virtuoso in perfect control of the instrument yet so effortless and smooth in your execution.
Badiuzzaman Mohamed
Laurindo Almeida also transposed and played a wonderful version, but I believe hers is even better, which is my highest praise.
Big dookie how do you notice that tf
Does anyone know how she tuned her guitar ? it sounds different on mine
@@ouafmannlitchfield5448 Is tuned half step down on each string :)
@@olliebear9256 Yes! But he had more than one version. My favorite is from the "Music for Lovers" LP. However, I believe that version is him playing an overdubbed track; essentially two guitars.
My fingers ache just looking at the stretch she's having to use to play this piece. Crazy difficult yet beautifully executed. Wonderous.
She has long skinny fingers. Always an advantage.
What impresses me the most is how every note rings perfectly at the right volume, despite the insane fingerings
Equal Sql grow up shit fingers
Oh come on she just stretched 6 frets
That's why she's holding the guitar like a cello.
The technique displayed here is perfect. The subtlety of whole notes and quick single notes is wonderful and that’s so hard to do. Plus mixing in harmonics in between all those quick changes is just such amazing talent
I've watched many classical guitar interpretations of this song. This is the first time I could be convinced it was composed for that instrument.
French orchestral composer Berlioz was a guitar player, so it is not beyond possibility that Debussy may also have had a small guitar propped up by the piano.
Absolutely. I totally agree. 👌🏻
Totally agree.... Somehow she made it divine.....
try playing it on the Guitar.... so... .no
The warmth of it is so wonderfully delicious. Makes me feel hugged.
I,m 71 yrs and that the most beautiful thing I've ever heard. Thank you. :)
ลุงนี่ไม่ค่อยได้ฟังเพลง
@@TheFullmetalj ? :)
67 checking in, ditto!
Damn... I'm only 13, and this blows my mind how there are people watching RUclips above the age of 50...
I'm 57 and this is third most beautiful thing I've ever heard. The top two...
Good lord, that is some MONSTER technique. Absolutely magnificent.
And monster of sensitivity
Absolutely.There is such meticulous silence and delicate fingerwork there that even the very few, light frizzes there are should weigh more than gold ! Beautiful execution. Masterfully accomplished.
That chord at 1:23 !!
Thank you. I’m no master of guitar but she’s doing some crazy twisted hand positions here. And smoothly and deftly. Very nice.
I actually love coming back to listen to this. As much as I enjoy the original piece on piano, this rendition is played so beautifully and somehow feels more fitting...magnificent.
To me, it doesn't feel more fitting, just different. Love it on a piano, as well as listening to her play it. Sounds great on harp, too ruclips.net/video/vVTPbLhlbfI/видео.html
Years ago, I was driving home from an airport run, on a moonlit night... the only radio station that has reception on the M6 through the hills of the Lake District was Classic FM ... so, begrudgingly, I turned it on... oh hell, Debussy, how over-sentimental... or so I thought at the time. Then the radio announcer told a story, about how someone had requested they play it, with a letter (paraphrasing) "In 1942, I flew in a WWII bomber crew, we used to fly to Germany and back, each night, with a realization that we had a 1/10 chance of not coming back... on one perfectly clear moonlit night (the most dangerous time to fly, you are easily spotted)...." I don't have the words to describe what he said in his letter, their communal sense of relief, and thankfulness just to be alive, to be returning home - when others were not so lucky - their elation of having survived was cruelly tempered by the knowledge that so many people would have died, and on their return, they would learn who had been lost that night. So, the navigator had set up a small gramophone, and, as seemed fitting for a moonlit night, played Claire De Lune to the crew across the intercom, as they flew home, safe. And there I was, driving home, alone, a full moon, not a cloud in the sky, realizing how lucky I was not to have had to live through that, and it showed me how these young men must have found hope in such beautiful music - it made me understand that writing music is a timeless way to celebrate the innate beauty of life. So, wonderful stuff +Roxanne Elfasci that's a stunning arrangement, love the way the harmonic undertones ring through - and, in recording, it's so hard to capture the "chime" and voice of a guitar, but the (mic? def not a U87 always) does a great job... nice recording of a beautiful arrangement... I love it and must work on some of that!
Wonderful story. What a way to grasp the power, importance, and beauty of music in peoples' lives. Also makes me grateful for my fortunate circumstances, and for the way that many people in drastically different situations can still have a common appreciation for things, like Debussy's beautiful piano compositions. Thanks for sharing.
That's a beautiful comment. Thanks for sharing.
Thank you for that Ken.
Ken McCormack i always troll comments no matter what but this... this is different.
wow.....this gave me goosebumps
my mother's favorite. you have resurrected her and brought her into my view again smiling and we both have tears of joy. what a wonderful performance
What a beautiful comment, you made me feel sad but joyful for what it represents for you, thanks for sharing.
Aww I love that. Music is such an amazing bridge to our memories ☺️
@@jessicapreston9808 it can heal and sooth tragedy . i appreciate your comment
Why the frick am i crying
Those who know how to play this on a piano will know how hellishly difficult this would be on a guitar. I hope you have a million likes on this video. I’ve replayed this many times.
Hmm. Piano and guitar are not very similar. It may not be what you think
Claire De Lune may sound difficult to play on piano, but it's a piece of intermediate difficulty. Of course, that does not take anything away from its timeless beauty. However, arranged for guitar, this piece becomes an extremely difficult one to play and especially with the proficiency that Roxan Elfsasci so beautifully does in this recording. I could go on and on about how fluent, seamless and fluid everything is played together.
@@Insomnia_tic
Do you often come to the internet to discount the achievements of artists?
@@Insomnia_tic Exactly? That's why its alot harder on guitar. Piano makes large chords and arpeggios relatively easy to play compared to piano.
That's exactly what he said.
I've heard so many versions of Clair De lune, both guitar and piano, this is by far my most favorite. Can't put my finger on why I keep coming back to this. Just hits me on such a deep level. I get very pensive and philosophical when I hear this version.
ok, cool!
She's doing the impossible. And doing it in a such marvellous way that I almost can't believe. Clair de Lune is a so pianistic piece that making it sound in the guitar the way she gets is almost a miracle.
esojbar that’s what I was thinking! Over and over I kept doing double-takes at how she treated each section so masterfully, conquering parts with such beauty. When Love comes alive in a musician, the heart can inspire the brain and body to achieve whole new levels of mastery and creativity, and this woman has illuminated that truth with her own example.
Check it out performed on the harp. Your mind will be blown. I listen to the harp version so much it doesnt even sound right on a piano anymore lol
🍇😱💝
You'd be surprised how many piano songs translate surprisingly well to guitar
@@daltont3878 In fact, most by Spanish composer Isaac Albéniz :)
someone should make a piano arrangement of this!!
Lol.
Lol
Lol.
Lol.
Lol.
She definitely does not skip her 40 hours of practice each day...
The power of ling ling
LING LING FORTY HOURSSS
Ling ling 40 hours.
Ling Ling's proud
i come here to watch this video every now and then, did not expect ling ling gang
Master piece, is not only the technique, but your memory for every single note.
Sitting here on a cold, dreary rainy afternoon, trying to fight depression from a recent diagnosis I just received. Just happened to hit this post and I was totally mesmerized by her beauty combined with magnificent artistry. What a rendition of one of my favorite Debussy songs. I wish I could articulate my emotions better. I feel calm and at peace. Peace and calmness to one and all of you!
Find meaning in life and don't follow this promoted materialistic way of life! Perhaps music can be your meaning if it makes you that happy:)
Stay strong Robert you're more capable than you would believe :D
Hanging in with you, I hope you feel better soon, bud!
Hope you're doing well my friend. I think its amazing the effect a simple piece of music can have on a person.
I wish You a good health ! 🌲
Beautiful. makes you stop and realise how amazing humans actually are. The playing, the instrument itself, the technology to record and visualise it, the composition, and the elegance of the performance.
Yes. And now go listen to Valerí Milot on orchestral harp playing solo… equal spirits….
Debussy has brought tears to my eyes. So beautiful.
Yes.....the creation of the instruments. So many types that may be played alone or all types at once in the same key. Producing sounds that stir the soul and spirits of the listener. Yes indeed......amazing!
“Beautiful. makes you stop and realise how amazing humans actually are”
Amazing in the one direction and appalling in the other. The upside of humans is indeed very high. Unfortunately the downside is very low.
@@keithsmith4780 that's why it is foolish to look towards mankind for answers to life's problems.
A mere mortal, in my opinion, does not have the answer.
Perhaps the most incredible feat I've seen performed on a guitar, ever.
shes amazing. go check out Mike Dawes One cover (metallica).
This remains one of my most favorite renditions of this magical piece of music. If casts an absolute SPELL on me every time I watch it. Beautiful!!
Me too. Amazing
The dexterity of her fingers is incredible ! My goodness !
JohnBindon little spider fingers! Im no longer afraid of spiders after seeing her hands work that fretboard
music is not about fingers.....
Holding the guitar tilted like she is, definitely helps stretching your fingers like that.
nightmarethief712
That’s the classical guitar playin position.
@@zain4019 i mean no offense, but i didn't say i have no idea what guitar position this is. I was stating the realistic fact that this position helps the player BE ABLE to strecth their fingers to play like that. It's like you decided to "correct" me when no correction was needed. For example, say if this video was someone eating a bowl of soup and i commented "holding the bowl helps to eat it." Then you reply to me "that's the classical soup eating position." You get it? Maybe I'm looking too much into your comment, like you did mine.
If people only knew how much harder this is to play on guitar than piano there would be like a trillion more likes on this video.
It really isnt that difficult to play on piano anyway though, it just sounds like it because of all the arpeggios
Springboob Squirepin Yes, that always helps, too.
Indeed. I got a guitar and can't lie, it's confusing. I also had quite a hard time holding strings on the fretboard, the tone would go off. You had to be precise, just to get a note sounding as it should
Lazy Yandere Yeah, this is a highly underrated performance.
In my opinion, i mean yeah it is harder to play on guitar, but it is also not easy to play on piano too. I think people like the piano better because clair de lune has been known with a piano and its also nice to hear on piano. But the guiitar man, masterpiece.
I get the impression that she is baring her soul. She must be emotionally exhausted after a concert. Just beautiful in every respect.
what does that mean bob? baring her soul?
@@jerome4385 She is to guitar what Ben Webster is to sax. There are instrumentalists and vocalists (I won't mention names) who are very clinical and cerebral in their approach to playing; no emotion attached to it at all. That, by necessity, is the way it is when you're learning a new piece. But once you have it in your pocket, you own it. Your performance of the piece doesn't come from the brain but from somewhere deep inside. And that's what we're hearing here. This lady didn't play a single note that didn't have a piece of her soul attached to it. And that is guitartistry in its purest form.
@@bobburford Well said! :D
@@bobburford why does it always have to be about sax bob?
Go back stuffin your face with turkey Bob
Wow! Not only is Claire de Lune my favorite piece but your flawless rendition moved me to thank my Creator for allowing me to be alive to hear such precious and beautiful music. I know your talent didn't come easy and required many years of dedication and sacrifice but I thank you from the bottom of my heart for producing such a lasting impression on my psyche forever!
Praise Bob!
I never could have said it beter.
A true master of her instrument. In a world where beauty is sorely needed, this performance is gorgeous.
It's a guitar. The instument of the lazy. Trillions of hours have been wasted by lazy wortless people taking good people's money by operating such a dreadful device. I would rather hear a lawnmower
@@totallysmooth1203 I think I've figured out which part of you is totally smooth
@@totallysmooth1203 snobbery rather than an intelligent argument against the guitar
The performance was 👍🏼. Master of her instrument? Not quite. You need to hear more guitarists.
@@totallysmooth1203 Keep Practicing little fella , you'll get it ..... Don't Get Mad !!
' Pop Goes The Weasel ' Takes Time To Master !! 😉👍🏻
I didn't think it would be possible to do this song justice on a guitar. Absolutely nailed it!
I was thinking the same. Incredible!
Prefer this to the piano version.
A five year old could do this song justice. It’s trash.
@@sitarnut Both guitar & piano versions are worthy. A 5 year old child can sing pure song to life and loving life living!
Very unreasonable. You must be those people who hates on everything that popular. @@solorollo9756
I didn't even think this was possible on a guitar.
It is almost impossible. I'm trying.
So much is, this music so good
I think she has transposed from the original Db, to D for the guitar. Still sounds wonderful. :-)
EDIT: After listening side by side with piano rendition, they are in the same key, so the guitarist must have detuned by a half-step. :-)
I didn't either, that was impeccable, and of course, sublime. Bravissima!
Breath taken away at the first note for this very reason. I've tried it too and failed hard.
People who only listen may have their breath taken away for one reason. People who play may be astounded for another. Wow.
8 years ago you posted this video, it's your first video, and now I see it on RUclips...truly beautifully done.
If I work VERY hard, I MAY learn the notes and MAYBE I can technically perform the piece. But it is the rare person that can bring this level of feeling and emotion. Ms Elfasci is truly a brilliant artist! Bravo.
Is it a competition? Even if youre never able to come anywhere close to playing on this level does it matter?
@@0pct-Zscrop2-bcue7im9a.4space relax!
Mr. Anderson, welcome back, we missed you.
@@efraingbj I plugged into the Matrix and I can play this perfectly now!😃
@@tomanderson848 Mr. Anderson.
There is a certain humbleness about this song. Like a speck of dust floating around inside a drop of water that slowly slides down the leaf of a tree on a rainy afternoon. It says to me "Calm down, not everything is on your shoulders. You're like that speck of dust.. relax"
Well said.
Wow..☺️...can I have some of what your having😊
Even the comments are artful up in here!
to me the intro feels like sadness and pain, and then with the faster parts it comes trouble and panic, and after it's over the intro tries to come back but it's different, more melancholic, like the notes are carefully trying to be what the intro was but the first notes comes out different in an even sadder way but with a tone of overcoming . to me this song feels more like the stages of grief after losing someone, and not "romantic" like people say.
@l tonos: Your words are as touching as this music. I hope you are an author
There's something with the sound of the guitar that magnifies the original piece. An inner warmth.
Its still better on piano because the piece was composed for that
Oh,Shut Up...
It's called Spanish guitar. That's the feeling.
Such talent fantastic achievement .
Nothing better than the sound of Debussy.
proto-jazz is what DeBussy sounds like. He's my favorite.
queef
Always finish on Debussy, never finish on the Bach
this is what good debussy sounds like.
In Debussy*
This is spectacular. Beautiful doesn't even come close to describing it.
Perfect!
This is the definition of someone who has mastered their instrument. Perfect arrangement and perfectly played.
Just exquisite. There are few things in this world which justify human existence more undeniably than this sublime melody. Thank you, Roxane for a flawless performance.
Well said.
I lost count how many times I've come back to this, and I do so when the world and everything around me start my anxieties. Right now the world is in a collective grief, and one could only hope for normalcy to return. This video is a pocket of peace amdist the crisis.
No such thing as normal. Embrace the chaos and pursue your joys. At the end of the day nobody is getting out alive anyhow :) have fun. And peace be with you
reading this was satisfying
ruclips.net/video/WWw54h2S_2c/видео.html
you're welcome
Calma. Todo pasa.
I hear you culota. I am here beside you.
1. She plays 9/8 on guitar
2. She plays a piano piece
3. She plays it up to tempo
4. No accidental muted sounds
5. PLAYS THE HARD PART THAT I CAN'T FRICKEN DO ON PIANO...
Kill me
Samuel Yang "she plays 9/8 on guitar" so what lol
Nossi cuz for drums you purposely to play to feel the beat again, on a guitar it's not that simple
Ha ha Sam... love your sense of humor, "kill me" is perfect..I feel the same way every time I listen to Bill Evans, Paul Desmond or Julian Bream playing this: ruclips.net/video/Ua4x1UEvm3s/видео.html
About the piano thingy...
It's not that hard once you've mastered those hand-wrenching arpeggios on your left hand
6. She is very beautiful
Beautiful! Didn't expect it to sound so soothing and complete on a guitar. Master artistry.
ruclips.net/video/MJRsMCmWwpU/видео.html it would be amazing if you could listen to my cover of Capricho Arabe 🌱💫💕🐬🧜🏻♀️💃🦅🎶🌎
Makes me want to study her biography….
I didn't either! I was expecting something loud and kind of clanky.
@@joelvaldez8688 Haha why
Your music brought tears to these old eyes
is that good?
Imagine sitting in the same room and being able to experience this live. Truly a wonderful guitarist!
Yes" seria raro " casi siempre lo hago es x civer espacio osea tras el vidrio ho espejo dd ti mismo alli " ho forma visual de estar made " individualmente asiendo ho percisionando un sonido ho voz " de forma de interpretar un sonido" pero si " estando tu. Ho que "??? Saber es" yes ho no "??? 😢 jo tin 😂❤???
Bravo
I just looked at my guitar. I swear it's laughing at me.
Segovia once said..."The guitar maintains its natural beauty at the hands of the novice." Embrace the level of skill you have today. Its all about the journey....enjoy !
Guitar:
Do this to me!!
I dare you
yours too...? I thot it was just all of mine....
fkers!
I once had a thought when I heard a piece of music, "I could never, ever, not in a MILLION BILLION YEARS play like that".
Then I realized that I had absolutely nothing to lose by trying and went to buy a guitar.
The first piece of music I ever tried to learn on the guitar was the Koyunbaba Suite... Not exactly beginner fare.
It took a few years, but the love of the one piece kept drawing me forward to learn more and more and while I'm certainly no concert master, I can now play 20-30 minutes of reasonably engaging repertoire.
I can even play the first 3 movements of the Koyunbaba Suite.
I had a setback a few years ago when I played the piece for my grandmother on hear deathbed from the other side of the world. I didn't have much else of value to share with her as she was reaching out to her loved ones to make her feel like she had lived a good life. She stopped me as the emotional climax was building in the third movement and said it was too sad. We talked briefly after that and that was the last time we spoke.
The piece is interpretative and can change flavor depending on the mood of the person playing. I was in a dark place at that time in my life and I think it came through. I have had a lot of trouble studying past that point because of it and the piece brought me to tears several times since then until I had to let it go. Even now, it takes tremendous effort to practice it and my eyes well up just writing this brief account. But in the end, I suppose that means that I was able to play it meaningfully, even if it was reflecting too much sadness.
But this story wouldn't have happened if I hadn't tried. It would have simply been an awkward phone call where she asked me if I had any girlfriends or had thought about maybe making a family some day, while several of my cousins had delighted her with their small children and fresh life. Instead, I have something bittersweet, that is a reminder of what is important in life from a person who was and is still extremely important to me, in a way that I will never forget.
@@eschelar Thank you for sharing your story. Mine is quite different, but when I feel depressed somehow I end practicing with my guitar just to fill the void. I began with Asturias, by Albeniz. I'm still not capable of playing at the right speed and I haven't learned half of the piece yet, but even if I learn to play another 4 or 5 notes, I feel better. However, that piece alone kept me trying and I have learned a few other (easy) pieces that make me fell like I'm making progress.
When a musical performance is so beautiful it brings tears to your eyes.
It's just... I don't know. Sad? Happy? Grief? Regret? I'm confused as much as I am enthralled.
Anas Azhari it's all of those things :)
It never occurred to me that this piece could be played on the guitar, but this is a wonderful arrangement and performance. Congratulations!!
Wow! What a gift. This is a side of humanity that we need to cultivate. Thank you for sharing your mastery.
this is no gift, this is passion
I know your intentions were good but calling all the hard work and passion needed to be a good musician a ''gift'' is not a huge compliment
Loved observing Roxane demonstrate her love of the guitar. You can command the heavens. Bravo!
robertparkerpiano - - You are 100% spot on.
@@oatenn could be
That was beyond the limits of guitar - absolutely beautiful. One of the most stunningly beautiful performances I’ve ever seen on guitar. Bravissima !! Senza fiato.
Vero
Guitar is more versatile than we normally think
Extremely well played. There is lot of feeling and emotion conveyed through the guitar technique, and interpretation. Very much enjoyed listening, thank you.
So good, so deep, so enjoyable. Thank you.
Of all the wonderful things I have seen in my 68 years...seeing and hearing this rendition is truly a marvelous moment. Thank you for your hours of practice and your diligence in coming to an understanding of the aura of this great music. From the bottom of my heart.
I’m 5’ 7” and I like it too.
Honestly, I've always thought that pieces written by certain kinds of composers such as Debussy and Chopin are not really for guitars (Although I'm a big fan of guitar music as well as I am of piano music), but she changed my mind within 90 seconds.
Please let me know if anyone knows other beautiful exceptions like this performance.
ruclips.net/video/5ZcL_DNVp0k/видео.html
Canon
ruclips.net/video/XZgiNnGB8m4/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/4UVbt3IWS2o/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/NVitgDEh_tw/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Zq3rSwX4QHM/видео.html (and in this version, you don't get lost in so many interpretation subtilities, so don't have to know the original piano version to appreciate, in my humble opinion........... :).
Beautiful song. My mom used to play it on the piano when I was young, and it still holds a special place in my heart.
debussy guitarussy
Excellent interpretation! Thank you for a few minutes of peace in my busy day.
The dexterity and reach of her fingers is amazing. This takes years and years of practice. Masterpiece.
Never in my life have I ever heard such a beautiful rendition of Clair de lune. My Mother played this on the piano perfectly . Growing up I often would request her to play this for me over and over again. Roxane you have captured my heart with your display and admiration for of this master piece. Bravo, your playing is excellent. What a gift you have. Much appreciated ! My Mom would have loved it. Bless you.
The technical virtuosity necessary for this performance is off the charts. Every note so clean. Lots of nuance. Very minimal string squeak. Truly inspired. Thank you for sharing.
Right on!
This was magnificent, you are amazing
She plays so delicate, soft, intense and tender at the same time. She embraces her guitar, Debussy must be grateful. Beautiful artist. I am grateful for the gift of listening her guitar.
Technical mastery and artistic expression combined into something otherworldly. This one is special.
very well said.
let me tell you. this piece has never been and will never be played like this. perfection is what you achieved.
I just made a better rendition but my battery went down and just lost the recording.Sorry
@@franckdebank same
franckdebank yeah me too
@@laura8700 wtf, just happend to me too.
I agree
Music for the soul... Thanks for this beautiful interpretation.
This is the most beautiful Clair de Lune I have ever heard...
Her technique is delicate
but her mood and rhythm change is what I appreciate most
its really beautiful...
The second harmonic... Breathtaking. Impossibly beautiful.
It's an artificial harmonic, very difficult at first, but so very beautiful in the right places
The use of harmonics was amazing. Chills all around. Very nice performance.
Very dedicated and clean played. ❤.
In my 75 years on this earth I've heard countless guitar pieces of all genres and I can say truthfully that this is the most beautiful piece ever, played with skill and feeling.
Played the video twice. The first time I was totally mesmerised by her technique, the second time I closed my eyes and let the music take me to a wonderful place.
Where did it take you to?
To re-arrange - what is common for guitar music - the third movement from Debussy's Suite bergamasque kind of a challenge. To transform the music from piano to guitar is a retelling. I think you succeeded. And you are telling a wonderfull story worth listening to. Your sound is great, your way of changing sound is wonderfull and you perform great. 5 Hearts from me. Great work.
classical music is so intense to my untrained ear, its hard to imagine a lot of people on piano being able to recreate a work 1:1. or the other side of the coin, masters of guitar being able to perfectly nail a solo from an original is just insane to me. I figured even the original artists just have to improv a bit but I dunno
Just FYI it's not her arrangement
I listen to a lot of guitar covers and arrangements of all sorts of classical pieces; And romantic era composers are my most favorite people ever, and I do not believe I will ever get tired of that genre of music. With that being said, this has to be the most beautiful arrangement on guitar that I have ever heard being played. So fluent, touching and eloquent.
Yes, the transcription is beyond amazing and her performance is astounding. Those fingerings and voicing are unbelievable.
I'm speechless. This is virtuoso level guitar here. What a wonderful piece, my god
Classical guitar is criminally underrated
ruclips.net/video/MJRsMCmWwpU/видео.html it would be amazing if you could listen to my cover of Capricho Arabe 🌱💫💕🐬🧜🏻♀️💃🦅🎶🌎
Absolutely jaw dropping performance. I feel like a better person and musician simply for having listened to this.
LOL ahahahahh I hate genius too. I hate Marissa Elene Nadieja. I hate genius.
@@agnethnao8247 wtf?
I will play this hundreds of times and someday ditch my pick habit of 45 yrs - nothing like all 8 fingers working hard at once
The harmonic notes alone are amazing. What a pleasure! Beautiful beyond expectation.
This is stunning. I've played for years, and I can tell you I will never attempt to learn even the first mesure. I still can't believe what I've seen and heard. As close as perfection as it gets, great job. The amount of work behind this must be insane.
I think you should try.
"I still can't believe what I've seen and heard" = ditto - with bells on
@@petermuller161 This exact vid is the reason I feel in love with classical guitar and I tried the first week to do this and tried again twice but every time I just realize that ill take years before I can get even close to how beautifully this was played
@@petermuller161 ive now been playing for 1 year and a half and can play most “ advanced” songs but this one is just something else
We know...
Extremely well played! As a former classical guitarist (the nerves of my hands and feet were damaged due to chemotherapy treatment), I can vouch for what Kyle Cravens said: this is CRAZY difficult. Of course, purists will point out her incorrect posture, the sound of the nails of the right hand, etc. but this is an excellent performance.
I am sorry to hear about the damage. It must be terribly painful not to be able to play anymore. Even with the unusually high guitar position, I find her technique impeccable; as for the nail sound, perhaps that was intentional, a part of her expression, given the dream-like mood of the piece?
bubka42 - I have always played (difficult) guitar pieces in my head throughout the day. I used to be able to come home and work those pieces out on my guitars. I can't do that anymore.
As for Roxane's performance, you may be right. She may have allowed the nail soundings in order to add a mood to the piece. If that's true, she sure succeeded. So many guitarists have come out with different ways of approaching the instrument, like fanning, tapping, etc. I am just blown away by her playing. And you're right - impeccable.
And purists usually wind up sounding too pure, too machine-like; purists lack personality, in their playing and in their -- um -- personality. An instrument can be held many ways, as suits the player and the needs of the composition. As she does here. And personally, I like the chime effect of fingernails on the plectrum hand. PURISTS: it's what comes out of the instrument and through the air; that's why music is being played.
Russel - couldn't agree more. Some of those players sound like machines. Sometimes you like to hear the musician, things like the sound of nails, the "scrape" sound of the string when moving from one position to another, heavy breathing and so on. And I like your description of the right hand nails, sounds just like a chime. Good description.
"Purists" are the bane of creativity and excellence in every sphere of the arts. People whose enjoyment comes from talking a better performance than the actual artist. People who claim to speak for others who never gave them permission.
Purists are detestable people who suck the joy from every atom of the world.
They haven't invented a word yet to define how great this is.
Closest we can get is "hentai"
@@vollmond9342 Y E S
I agree entirely!
i laughed
Tadow
Roxane, I've seen many people attempt to play Clair de Lune on guitar... And I've been told by much better guitarist than me that it is one of the more difficult pieces to play on guitar, and have the impact that it does on piano... But YOU, my dear, when you look up "Magic in her Fingers" in the dictionary, it's got a picture of YOU!.. Bless You, for giving us mere mortals, something to Strive for!.. ❤
I can die knowing I've heard the most beautiful rendition of this piece ever recorded. How great is it we live at this time?
She is wonderful, very talented, Bravo. I wish her the moon in her career. For any guitarists who want to play this piece but doubt themselves, it is not impossible. If you are at a pretty good level already, you have paid your dues for some years, then 100 hours of work would make a big dent in this arrangement. You can find the James Edwards arrangement online, even free if you look hard. If after 100 hours of work you don't sound like her but only 62% of her level, well, you will still have the pleasure of playing this and it will sound beautiful, your friends and family will enjoy it. Some of the difficult stretches and passages can be modified. A lot of the painful stretches are just to make the bass notes sound through a measure of the melody, which is pretty subtle or actually does not happen much without a very expensive instrument. That is nice if you can do it, but almost no one will notice if you simplify the fingering. It does not have to hurt to play beautiful music for your own pleasure. Music is for everyone, the fantastically gifted, the somewhat less fantastically gifted, and the normally gifted who are willing to work hard out of love for music. Any determined intermediate guitarist can play at least some part of this arrangement.
Agreed, this is possible. Also having the neck so close to vertical really helps with those stretches. Her performance is beautiful, not trying to put it down with this comment.
If I didn’t see it done, I would have said it was impossible- this is the best classical guitar playing I’ve ever heard in my life. When you were at the end I said to myself “she’s not going to go for the ultra high octave harmonic, is she? That’s got to be so precise to come out that it’s ridiculous!” And then sure enough you did it. As far as the m concerned, you’re the new Segovia, bravo!!!
Douglas R Perkins certainly a close second if not tied. But let’s hear her doing Bach.
Ha! Was about to say ‘someone show this to Segovia! (Rip)
Truth
The most beautiful version I have ever heard. Played with such emotion .
If you've never heard Debussy's Clair de Lune played on a Piano you can't possibly understand how technically wonderful this is!
I've been playing classical guitar for 7 years and I still have a long way to have that level! Just wonderful!
Pretty sure everyone has heard Clair de Lune on piano, considering that was the instrument Debussy originally composed it with.
@@jackstack2136 maybe not guitarists
You're an idiot Timothy
@@DidipanI'm right around the same point in my journey. Sending this to remind you to give it a try again! I've come across this like once a year to try and learn. Getting close to the ability level
My dad’s favourite piece of classical music before he passed away.
It was rendered here in such a beautiful way. It was beautiful before, but here, you can feel every note so vividly.
Absolutely masterful
Oh ... {speechless} .... I've played since 4th grade and worshiped guitar since even before that ... but I've *never* heard anything like this. What an incredibly gifted, emotive player: she is so 'gone' into this piece and her playing that you can FEEL it. I am so glad I was privileged enough to be able to watch. Like watching an angel play a harp. Thank you, talented player, for bringing this to us.
Brava..."Like watching an angel playing the harp"..absolute bullseye remark...you should be a music critic!
This angel can't be bothered with a reply...
νικος γιώργος well she’s French so.....
Hi Yes bbst "????claro fue culpa del señor DIOS ji.ji.ji tuvo la culpa EL piensa " the chaly" y claro tiene las merjores arpas del mundo y galacias" mas sonidos de angeles ha nivel world on of the's world ho sea disposicion de sonido interplanetario y esterno planetario"??? Es mas como sonaria la flauta majica de DIOS ???
What a gift to have and a joy to share. Thank you for an amazing five minutes of music, and guitar playing, that I have ever heard in my 66 year lifetime.
If you don't have some acquaintance with the guitar, you have no way of knowing how good this is. Wonderfully emotional. I need a cigarette and I don't even smoke!
well said. I agree in part, but the thing is, I actually smoke. So for me, this could be useful in listening to every time I feel like smoking? lol either way, the first part of your statement is sooooo accurate. Exciting to find others who feel the same way about certain songs and the guitar.
don't have to smoke to enjoy good shit but I got you dude. this is a masterpiece.
It's a beautiful piece of music, and she made it sound as enchanting as played on piano. Bravo 😍
Agreed. The strokes and timing are so nuanced, it's tough to emulate
I never liked the piano rendition. But this just gives me goosebumps all over. Nylon strings in a classical style just works so well with this song. Then there's the emotion from Roxane. Such a fine touch on the strings.
Superhuman performance of a stunning arrangement of a piano work to the guitar.
When life gets difficult and rough, I will come back to this wonderful lady with the magical guitar
Bravissima-stupenda interpretazione
Whoa, the fingers of your left hand look like they're made of liquid, always pouring on the fretboard. Impressive playing and lovely rendition of the piece. I loved watching and listening to that. Thank you!
well we are made of mostly di hydrogen monoxide so yeah
My dearest sister died on 29/07/2022. This rendition on a guitar evoked my father playing the same song. I am doubled grief by this song. Thank you Roxanne..
Beautiful. This was my dad’s favorite piece of music, and he loved the guitar (he taught me to play.). Fantastic job.
Mike Clark I would always play this for my son when he was an infant and crying so much... sounds like I get your dad hah, or music just transcends.