Who is responsible for the Amazon deforestation fires in Brazil? | DW Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Deforestation fires are surging in the Amazon, eliminating more square kilometers of rainforest this year than they have since 2009. In the Brazilian Amazon, fires are a common means of clearing the land -- land that is worth five times more without the forest than with the forest -- for cattle and soy fields. Brazil is the world’s leading exporter of beef and soy, but there’s also a high demand for these goods domestically.
There are preservation laws still on the books in Brazil, but Bolsonaro’s cut funding for their enforcement. Spending on forest inspection in 2020 is less than a third of what it was in 2019. Part of the Amazon can be reforested but time is critical: scientists estimate that once more than 20% of the rainforest is gone, recovery won't be possible and the Amazon will go into a process of savanization.
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: www.youtube.co...
#Amazon #Brazil #Rainforest
2:37 this is misinformation, Is false that deforestation is growing because of Cattle in Brazil. The technology involved in our agriculture made it possible to reduce the cattle area by 12% without affecting our productivity.
The area of native forests well preserved in Brazil is equivalent to 43 countries in Europe.
I'm sick of these European and American environmentalists Talking about the preservation Amazon Rainforest. They don't have almost anything of natural resources preserved and think that they can teach Brazil how to take care of our territory.
They don't even know how many Biomes we have here.
Stop telling lies about us!
Brazil is a Giant 🇧🇷 🇧🇷
Exactly, it is growing because of rising meat consumption. We turn a blind eye. We do exactly the same here in Europe for cheap furniture. We are living on environmental credit. We'll pay the bill later. Thank's for the trust.
@@ZWD2011 you are believing in lies! All cattle production is concentrate all most in Mid-West, and in the south-east, not in North, where the Amazon florest is
👏👏👏
@@thiagomoreira5287 liea
“the technology involved in our agriculture …” 😂 you mean mass production slaughterhouses?
Why is it Brazil's responsibility to be the lungs of the world? The rest of the world has trashed the environment and Brazil is expected to clean up the mess. If you all want to protect the rainforest, than lease it for 99 years or find some other way to make it economically advantages for all concerned stack holders. Just saying, get your house in order!
So what practical solution do you have to offer? I believe in ecotourism. I believe in conservation. By the way, I live in a desert.
What happened to and is happening in Australia is a shame.
I'm from and live in the U.S. and do niether support Trump nor Bolsonaro.
@@abelardogreen The Amazon is from Brazil, there is a lot of international interest in what is under it .. Gold, water, and other precious minerals .. This is the only interest that moves other nations.
First world countries have already destroyed their forests, if they want to help .. Ok .. It may be with money, but it must be inspected. Building a wall to isolate that area is an option.
But AMAZONIA IS FROM BRAZIL
@@ricardotyhssen735 I understand. I wish the best for your country and the people that live in it. I assume you're from Brazil?
If you want to help, you may eat Brazil nut. It isn't farmed, it is harvest from the forest, and makes the forest valuable for the people who lives there.
Yes! Açaí berries are also a good alternative!
As much as i want to help the rainforest, Brazil nuts are literally the worst type of nut
It's true , in the moment brazilian nuts trees are being extinguished due to intensive fire deforestation to produce ..... cattle meat (?!) as commodity and for internal consuming , killing indigenous people on the way . Bolivia is now the number one producer .
@@asafvirin2181 why ?
@@liegesaboya8265 Brazil is the number one producer.
"A third of the earth was burned up, a third of the trees were burned up, and all the green grass was burned up. a third of the living creatures in the sea died, and a third of the ships were destroyed. ... Woe to the inhabitants of the earth, because of the trumpet blasts about to be sounded ..."
Who is responsible? Europe has only 0,3% of it original forests remaining. 500 years ago, Europeans, who had fully destroyed their territories, started destroying others locations, like Brazil, in the name of evolution. Now, you expect Brazil to save the world? Why don't you ask Europeans and Americans about their rain forests?
Brazil has the world's largest rain forest, it is absolutely worth protecting.
Are you trying to say that the Amazon rain forest should be completely cut down for the sake of capitalism and industry?
If you guys want to destroy the Amazon forest then you are no different then Europeans and the west
Bolsonaro is destroying the Amazon and killing the natives
lol two wrongs make a right how smart
@@angelsbackgroundsounds right, but less smart people who think they have smart answers are free to comment on youtube.
Cuidem de suas florestas.
Se vocês tivessem cuidado de suas florestas não precisava se preocupar com as florestas dos outros.
Os caras não vão sossegar enquanto não sugarem até última pepita de ouro. Têm que explulsar essas ongs.
A floresta Amazônica ela é 20% do oxigênio do MUNDO, se ela queima ela solta o nitrogênio que pode elevar a grandes catástrofes ao planeta o aquecimento global por exemplo.
E infelizmente os próprios Brasileiros não estão nem aí.
A floresta é tua por acaso? Isso dá o direito de queimar tudo? Podemos nós mesmos nos beneficiar da floresta de maneira sustentável e você aí apoiando desmatamento. Poderíamos fazer remédios, explorar mais recursos abundantes que não são essenciais para a floresta. Mas você vem com essa de que a floresta é nossa, a gente não paga por ela, então pare de reivindicar a natureza como se fosse sua.
@@luydriannsouza9347 Estude biologia. Às algas marinhas produzem oxigênio. Florestas produzem oxigênio sob a luz do sol e consomem praticamente tudo à noite.
Fora que nitrogênio já é a substância mais abundante na atmosfera. Ele não provoca dano nenhum.
I guess the rest of the world better start growing some tree's.
Scale matter!
The huge area of rain forest keep itself going, seeding rain on itself and nearby areas.
6:52 Scientist think we're close to the breaking point where the whole rain forest will be unable to sustain itself.
I've got space for a bonsai in my room.
India has started initiatives on urban forestry. Though still we have a net negative figures but in coming years our target is to make it positive we can do.
Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
sanction brazil
If the world want to keep Amazon rainforest, it should not be based on keeping Brazilians poor.
The only way to protect The rainforest, is to find a way to make Brazilians as wealthy as the Europeans, without destroying the rainforest. Currently no such plan is available or proposed. All the world, especially the Western Nations, is turning blind eyes to the poverty in Brazil while accusing their people of destroying the rainforest for money. Proposals like paying countries that own large forests for forest maintenance could be a very good start. Help, don’t just stand by and accuse.
What you're basically saying is, we should pay Brazil who lives in the same Aparatment as us, who is poor, So he doesnt burn the apparment down.
Stop acting like the only way a counrty can be rich is by burning down forests.
Do you think poor communities are improving their lives through wildfires and deforestation? The lion share of the money is going - as always - to just a few very rich persons, and many of them don't even live in the Amazon. Ilegal gold mining is one of the issues in the forest, and each mining machine costs at least 100k USD. I can assure you it is not the poor people who is buying them.
@@Zuaquim1 I agree. They even said in the video that only 2% of farmers are responsible for 62% of fires. Prolly henchmen of some capitalist entity. Why would 2% own so much land? This stinks of big business, not of poor locals.
@@ToneyCrimson Why do you think that anyone wins burning a forest?
1. If you are burning a land that is protected by law, to put cattle, you gonna be in jail soon. Will take time, but you will. And your cattle won't be safe. Ask yourself, why have an illegal cattle farm? is a bet?
2. Burning forest to extract wood is counterproductive, that way you'll only extract wood charcoal ...
There are lot's of things about Amazon that is not addressed by this video or anyone on internet that NEVER have put their foot on Brazil or some south American country...
Things here are very different from what you see on TV or hear from CNN. Stop watching TV and come here.
The right way to stop illegal wood extraction is stopping the foreigners from buying wood from the North of Brazil. Is that easy. But, forest fires can't be 100% controlled, as in the dry season everywhere has a burn.
The problem is, *very few of this fires are actually caused by poor people.* That's because costs _a lot_ in equipment to cut those enormous trees. What happen is like the _tragedy of the commons:_ some *farmers* would love to make space for more cattle, since the loss of on climate stability is shared globally, while the profit of the cattle is not. And any farmer whom doesn't go along out of his consciousness is surpassed by his competitors.
To prevent that, we create severe laws and fines. For one, any seized equipment (like tractor, or excavator) is destroyed, causing a loss of thousands of dollars. So, they have to evaluate the risk/reward of being caught. But, since Bolsonaro raise to power, *the risk has never been so low.* He reduced the investments on fiscalization, reduced the value of the fines, and prohibited the destruction of seized equipment.
So, the economic plan isn't actually to save poor people, but to give farmers an incentive to keep the florest up. Like, if is more profitable to keep the forest than turn it on pasture, they would keep the forest.
The Amazon is from Brazil, there is a lot of international interest in what is under it .. Gold, water, and other precious minerals .. This is the only interest that moves other nations.
First world countries have already destroyed their forests, if they want to help .. Ok .. It may be with money, but it must be inspected. Building a wall to isolate that area is an option.
But AMAZONIA IS FROM BRAZIL
Kkkkk. Good luck building a wall on the Amazon.
But serious, though, not everyone is interested on extract the Amazon's resources. There's also genuine interest in to mantain the forest because of its contribuition for the global climate.
_"Yeah, but they destroyed _*_their_*_ forests for economic growth..."_ That's one more motive for we let them help us not to do the same with ours. I mean, if someone drives carelessly and crashes, and them advice you *not* to do the same, would you ignore it?
When an international leader or anyone expresses concern over the Amazon forest, it doesn't mean they want to steal it from Brazil (which by the way doesn't own the whole forest, I hope you know that). Just because it's in Brazilian territory, it doesn't mean it can be destroyed. And giving money to the country won't help if its leader isn't a bit interested in taking care of it. Give money, but demand actions!
@@wowlily1245
I have said that our 1988 constitution is a lot of paper made to protect bandits and punish those who work. The biggest problem in Brazil was the fall of the Military Regime, where there were problems. YEA
Only now we don’t have an efficient health, we have to take care when leaving home. We live in endless fear, our health if you don’t have a health plan you can die in a row, our “free” health service often cannot meet needs ..
When I went to Europe I observed my tranquility of walking the streets without being afraid of being mugged ..Try to walk the streets in Rio de Janeiro ..
Brazil should be administered either by the military or by foreigners. Our democracy here does not work, we live in an eternal purgatory where Bolsonaro is the "best" because the others are mostly Left parties with Chinese connections.
Understood ??
@@ricardotyhssen735 interesting. You want a military regime. Are you high??? Anyways, good luck.
@@wowlily1245 You don't live in Brazil, come here and you will see all the problems that I mentioned above ..
Democracy with the politicians we have will never improve
Now the German and French people have to make make their own Forest. Die Deutschen haben gar keine Wälder mehr.
Europe should not meddle in the affairs of Brazil, we Brazilians know their interests and the United States should not say anything
@@jonasmarcelobaptistinifran8663 Por isso devemos fortalecer nossas relações com a China e Rússia, eles nos respeitam e não querem roubar nossas riquezas. Estados Unidos e união européia uma hora ou outra roubará nossos recursos naturais
O mais engraçado é ver americanos e europeus que já destruíram suas florestas e querendo dar lição de moral para o Brasil.
O brasip e o país que mais preserva o meio ambiente no mundo.
Não, não é.
Só na sua imaginação .
Vá se informar fora da sua bolha.
@@wowlily1245 tá vendo e e por conta de mentalidades como esse de achar que tudo de fora e verdade que muito provavelmente em um futuro não tão distante o Brasil vai se tornar o novo "Iran seremos um país cercado e ameaçado cheio de sanções e isso na melhor das hipóteses porque na pior esses "bondosos" países que querem "defender" o meio ambiente mais não reflorestam a Europa vai invadir é desmembrar o Brasil é criar um protetorado internacional como a Antártida na Amazônia e muito provavelmente oque sobrar do Brasil vai ser como a china durante o século xix quando foi invadida e desmembrar a pelas "bondozas" potências europeias e a China foi saqueada e escravizada por mais de 1seculo e milhões e milhões de pessoas inocentes morreram.
E infelismente e assim que vai acontecer e nosso futuro como nação independente e soberana pode não ser assim tão certo, e tu crítica tanto o agro negócio não é? Mais você deve ser só uma menininha rica falando no conforto do seu ar-condicionado e com a sua geladeira abarrotada de comida enfim a hipocrisia, se não fosse o agro o Brasil já teria falido a décadas.
@@liegesaboya8265 amigona sabe quanto uma propriedade rural deve preservar de vegetação nativa em sua propriedade? 80% é para outros biomas e 30% de vegetação nativa coisa que não existe em nenhum país do mundo, o Brasil possui quase 20% de seu imenso território demarcado como reservas e áreas indígenas enquanto em outros países europeus não chega a 2%, eu acho incrível a necessidade do brasileiro querer se rebaixar ao que outros países falam como se tudo no Brasil fosse uma merda, enfim como disse para a moça de suma podemos estar nos aproximando do fim do brasil como nação independente e tudo isso por culpa nossa.
Os europeus não quer o bem da Amazônia eles querem os bens da Amazônia e querem frear a produção agrícola brasileira que é a mais produtiva do mundo e tirar a bilhões de dólares e levará milhares de fazendeiros europeus a falência.
@@dcfenixii4926 você está totalmente por fora do assunto .
Absolutamente equivocado .
Brazil have the right to ues its natural resources and develop its economy and no one should interfere in there internal matters.
BS !!!
Too late for that. The 2016 coup served the interests of international players. The obvious ones are the oil companies. But the list is much longer. Don't forget that bozo was elected only because the frontrunner was arrested just months before the polls. And the judge who arrested him was made justice minister by the winner. It can't be more corrupt than that!
The only natures that European countries want to preserve in the Amazon are gold, niobium, manganese, oil and various minerals and natural products to become expensive medicines and cosmetics. They are not really concerned with preservation. Or their forest cover would be much larger. Brazilian natural coverage is approximately 66% of the entire Brazilian territory. Which country has the moral capacity to accuse Brazil?
Our agricultural production this year will be around 246.7 million tons. This considering that Brazilian farmers cultivate only 7.6% of the Brazilian territory, with a lot of technology. Most countries use between 20% and 30% of the territory for agriculture. Those in the European Union use between 45% and 65%. The United States, 18.3%; China, 17.7%; and India, 60.5%. These data are confirmed by NASA.
humans fully deserve their fate
Lol you goes killed all of your rain forest...... Now you're worry about our rain forest... Let it burn.....
I don't understand the criticism of Brazil, Venezuela and Argentina exploit their forests and no one criticizes them, clearly it's not for the good of the Amazon but for economic and political interest
They get their fair share of it, what are you talking about?? Do you know geography? Brazil holds 60% of the Amazonian rain forest, so yeah you should probably lead by example when the other ones hold like 10%.
I wonder why DW doesn't make a documentary blaming Putin for the destruction of the tundra
What are you going to do threaten all the rest of the world there’s only so many nukes man
A treeless, cold, largely bare, rocky place supporting hardly any life?
Why don't you take care of your territory and stop saying that Brazil doesn't take care of the Amazon? Let me know if you were taking care of your territories you wouldn't like it, would you?
Meat consumption in USA is the double as in Brazil per capita ! your narrative is wrong and misleading ! (3:06). Top beef eaters are surely not Brazillians, the mayority cannot afford it. Shame on you DW . Lost respect to your publications.
Maybe you shoul re-watch the video... It says "making them *_one of the top_* beef features in the world"...
@@j3t538, maybe because they already have a picture on screen. Maybe because if you are talking about the impact of cattle on the Amazon, the important information is "how much?" not "where you is ranked?". Maybe because they already have put the source on the bottom right corner and know people have internet to look it up if they wanted to...
@@j3t538, my point was not about fact-check the entire interview. But if they say "Brazil produces X amount of meat (show graph) *and* is one of the top producers", if you are in doubt about the secondary information (or just curious about who's on top) you can check that easily.
As I said, on this context, the quantity is more important.
If you look at a forest map...Brazil has too much. They should have as much forest like Europe or U.S.
you aren't looking at population denisity whic is a big factor because the majority of the brazilian population is on the coast whic is alredy quite deforested
@Drakoshi England did not have basic sanitation in their 1st industrial Revolution.
@Drakoshi No, we do have. 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷😎😎😎😎😎
@Drakoshi the worst comment in the world I have ever seen !! ridiculous, xenophobic, everyone knows that the United States is not just "Miami Beach" "Manhattan" and "Hollywood Sing
I agree, it should be taken away from Brazil and the other countries and designated as its own country, Amazonia.
These numbers are not right. Brazil has 80% of its forests preserved, more then any other place... specially where they exterminate everything. Tons of “material “ biased like this one has many porpoises: Brazil is #1 food producer in the planet but some “European “ countries don’t like the idea.
80% so na sua cabeça, e o Brasil esta devastando a amazonia por cousa dos comodities e da exportação ilegal de madeira, BOLSONARISTA é burro e idiota.
@@MrKtrend Mostre OS números em fontes confiáveis por a muito tempo a Amazônia e desmatada eu não estou vendo essa declaração toda que ESTÃO falando ! Boa parte da floresta está preservada sim .
A responsabilidade são das ações criminosas do grupo que sempre entregaram as riquezas para grupos internacionais. Ou seja, os antipatriotas!!
@Talecia P fale em português, caramba. O vídeo é sobre o Brasil não sobre o seu país, ou seja, fale em português.
At 0:39 the darker grey area is larger than the Amazon area actually is, part of this area is Cerrado (a savanna vegetation area). The deforestation and fires compared to last year decresead inside brazilian amazon according to NASA reports. Amazon is an area with the worst soil for agriculture in Brazil, it is too poor on minerals and it remains in large areas flooded most of the year. There's no budget for rangers since Dilma was in office back in 2015 when most of law enforcement budgets were cut.
Right. Tell the Brazilians what to do with their own land, and tell the rest of the world not to eat meat. Really? Impossible foods peddling alert.
There is a good reason for President Bolsonaro's decision in cutting funding, the budget simply didn't allow more extensive funding... a consequence of the overspending of the previous government, the Labor Party, that ran the nation for 16 years, leaving it with nearly 'empty pockets'. Bolsonaro is often blamed for everything that goes wrong in Brazil... unfairly so!
He is allowing the company to do the job of deforestation.
Bolsonaro is destroying the Amazon and killing the natives
Forest on fire, iceberg melting 😢. Human, we are the most failure of all creation.
@ᏟᎪᏁᎪᏞ ᎠᎾ ᎠᎬsᎬᏁhᎾ Should I specify, Forest on fire in Brazil, iceberg melting in Antartic and other parts of the world where icebergs are. My point is, we, humans are the ones causing these disasters.
And thousands of ignorants not caring about all other countries like USA, FRANCE, CHINA, JAPAN, etc polluting the oceans, where is the REAL problem. You can plant trees easily, but you can not solve the oceans ecosystem as fast. Learn the REAL truth about our "planet's eco issues". So much hypocrisy.
@@WadeWilson- actually no, the amazon makes mostly its own water through transpiration. We can't just replant the forest. at most we would get a woodland, not the rainforest that the amazon used to be. since the amazon was created millions of years ago when the climate was wetter, it no longer has that wet climate and when you cut the forest down you cant simply restore it.
@@kairon5249 yes that is the point as mentioned in the video it may lose that unique ability if the deforestation reaches 20% (currently 18%) so I guess it´s over. The forest will lose it´s microclimate and will transfer into a regular forest not a rainforest anymore ... al lthe forests in Europe are dry .. they don´= t produce anything no matter how much trees they have but still better than nothing and still better in keeping some humidity, cooling theland , providing space for animals etc.
@@skifisk the 18% statistic is a bit misleading. it also includes former forest territory(not rainforest) that was cut down.
ONGS are responsable.
This is lie! Lula, Dilma, Temer, Bolsonaro, corporations and even peaple are responsable!
@@ericpinhais ONGS also. Because they pay the corruption.Remember it . For every corrupt person there is a corruptor, who is equally guilty.
You are so funny , hahahaha !!
'Madness, madness and stupidity' - Tywin Lannister
at this point the forest is down by 20% .. non-reversable changes are happening .. maybe within 50 years the whole area will be a dead desert and noone will produce any profit ... catch your money quick quick ...ever tried to grow anything in 50+ with water 50km away and 2-3 months no rain? Good luck...
Amazon has a dry period from May to September. Every year wild fires occur and man can do almost nothing. I live here and can assure you this fact.
Deforestation in the Amazon is already in an irreversible process. The deforested areas will be transformed into pastures for livestock, after the pasture they will be transformed into soybean and cotton plantations.
Wrong
soon to become a dry desert .. no rain no soybean and so on ... the water will evaporate quickly... temperatures rise and the whole area will generate 0 profit and people will need to leave .. this may only take a few yeas once the forest is dead
@@skifisk this is true
@@skifisk they are also killing the biodiversity that is supposed to live in that specific climate.
RIGHT
first of all,the Europeans ended their florests etc,now they want to find excuses to take the forests of the others,Brazil is rising,we are looking at our country with different eyes,with patriotic eyes,this is a sovereign country,and who has to decide on the issues about environment are the Brazilian people,we dont get involved in any country`s internal affairs,and of course we have to protect our forest,rivers,etc...and we will take care,we know that Europeans,Chinese etc,are not interesting the survival of forests,they interests what have in the soil,the richest of soil,we are not so innocent and much less stupids to believe in this sudden kindness.
We have been compartmentalized
If you cut the Amazon . Earth is RIP
@@TheAleksandros who is cut?if the international thieves come here to stole our forest,of course we go rip
@@DgurlSunshine sure
@@andersonsantucci9325 And then.... *Water became a COMMODITY*
Solution: Worldwide boycott of food from Brazil! Boycott to beef, grains, and other crops from deforestation areas!
Façam isso, aí vocês morrem de fome , a comida que vocês não comprarem a gente vende pra China, Índia, Rússia e etc
these fires are criminal, not only criminal people from Brazil act in this action, people from foreign countries are also burning.
Tell me lies, tell me sweet little lies
No more Amazon, just grasslands
good
Shame on you, DW! Aren't you ashamed of spreading such lies??
@Klauss Bmann Thank you for asking, shows that you are sincerely interested. So let me tell you. The truth is that foreign countries have been stealing riches from the Amazon (minerals, precious gems, wood, bio-piracy, etc) for decades, in agreement with previous leftist governments that have been bribed by them to turn a blind eye. Now, Bolsonaro is stopping this. There is now a very strong military operation going on in the Amazon catching all the misdeeds in the area, informing us of all the robbery that has been going on for decades, much of which perpetrated by European NGOs and their Brazilian marionettes. The people who had been stealing are not happy about this. The truth is that the Amazon is more than 80% preserved and that Brazil has the largest index in the world for native vegetation preservation, as well as for clean energy matrix. The rainforest does not catch fire, it is too humid for that. Fires occur in the surroundings, in areas that had already been deforested, according to the law. They occur every year during the dry season and it is a natural occurrence. The same areas burn over and over again every hear. The truth is that the Amazon rainforest is NOT the lungs of the world; the oceans are. All the oxygen generated by the rainforest is also absorbed by it; this is a scientific fact. Therefore, we resent very much foreigners who keep on referring to the Amazon as "our house", "our planet", etc. There are huge financial interests and massive international greed behind every video such as this, shamefully presented by DW.
It is also important to mention that, although Brazil has a very successful agricultural business that feeds 1/3 of the world population, none of it is done anywhere near the Amazon. It is done in the central and southern parts of the country and only 27% of the Brazilian territory is used in agriculture (crops + cattle raising). Therefore, we have a lot of space to expand our agriculture before going around destroying rainforests. There, again, there are huge financial and commercial interests involved: competitor food exporting countries try to convince the world that Brazilian food production destroys the Amazon, which is not true. These are the facts, very easy to check.
I have an interview with a freind in the timber industry that can explain how the forests of the Pacific Northwest have been totally ROBBED smuggled out of the continental US.
UN is doing all the smuggling
@@appudai WRONG! Obviously you dont know it all!
@2:15 “Forest 🌳 land is worth only a fifth of what cleared land is worth” ????? He spoke that like a fallen angel, not a man. A real man loves the forest.
If you grow crops or raise cattle on the land, you can make more money than just harvesting things from the forest. He is speaking economically, not philosophically or whatever logic you are using
YOU DO KNOW THAT IN PRECOLOMBIAN TIMES THERE WERE HUGE CITIES IN THE AMAZON, THERE WAS UPWARD OF 2,000,000( TWO MILLION) PEOPLE LIVING IN THE AMAZON...
Living sustainably.
Civilization is a fool's errand. Nothing really changed. As civilization grows, a few percentage of people take all and 99% live off scraps. Everything gets out of balance
@Freedom & Liberty Bot never before in history there was a system that forced me to sacrifice my whole life just to buy a place to live in. This BS started when Industrial Revolution came around. It is no big deal to build a house. We have done that for thousands of years. Right now I have to pay off mortgage for 40 years just to survive. It is a sick system that robs everybody of life's energy.
Today 30 million live there... Yet who are destroying most of it are farmers and oligarchs
Precolombian People were Hunters qnd getheres. But, people of this time até producers and consumers. The behavior changed so much.
Who's burning the Amazon Forrest? That's just about most silly question ever with a trumpet like leader at the wheel, denier of climate emergency, covid19 or any other science or fact
What you expect out of human selfishness, unreasonable behaviour. Not just forest we are destroying millions of species.
I wouldn't call it selfishness, instead, I would call it ignorance. The reason people aren't changing things faster is because not enough people are aware of what is going on.
@@pjc7729 no most people are aware. We live in the age of information, the actual problem is that people just decide not to do anythin about it since it doesn’t inconvenience them in any way.
@@diorsavage7811 Thats a good point but I wouldn't say most people that are aware aren't doing anything on purpose. Most likely they just don't know what to do about it. In fact, I would say it is a combination of both statements. There are many that are not aware fully and many that just don't know what to do and or want to do something to change things.
@@diorsavage7811 in the great corporation of the United States half the country is a check from broke struggling to feed their family. Of course they are concerned about a rainforest thousands of miles away.
PRIVATE PROPERTY IS BS.. !!
FLOODS AND SEVERE DROUGHT WILL INCREASE. GOOD LUCK
Never knew the comments section would be so based.
beware of the words they say there is a people here in Brazil willing to fight with the same vetinamite ferocity for their land
Happiness in Brazil is not found, our justice does not work .. It only works to release the bandits, the Brazilian Constitution of 1988 is delayed and delayed .. We have the most expensive Judiciary in the world ..
Can someone help us
Happiness for a gremista does not exist.
The trulys guilty, is the ongs, Mr. Bolsonaro is inocent, bigest and best president of the brazilian peoples.
@dwnews Great summary of the situation. It would be great to have Portuguese subtitles to share it with my non-English speaking Brazilian friends.
Ignorance is the fire, Greed is the flame and soon humanity will stand in the ashes 😒
It's not just money it's jobs. Like most of Brazil the Amazon regions are desperately poor and the removal of trees is jobs i.e., money for poor Brazilians. No government in Brazil Lula in Brazil will not risk creating unrest amongst the poor. Since being in office again has not had much success in stopping deforestation because of resistence not just from big farmers but the poor who see it as an attack on their livelyhood.
You stole the name from the amazon shops name
Parts of the video are showing Brazil SAVANNAH... not the Amazon. 🤔
Save Our Planet
Fix your room first.
Going with this pace, there wont be any Amazon after 20 to 30 years.
Somebody already said that 50 years ago, and It is still there.
@@SuperEdny who did
Blame greedy governments and idiocy. In general humanity. You dont see animals lighting up cooking their food .
This channel deletes legit comments they dont like. I quit this channel (said from wifes phone since my comments not allowed)
Buy Bananas, not Beef!
they don't want the good of the Amazon, they want the good of the Amazon says dr.Enéas.
This is why I felt the need to listen to diesel and dust.
It's capitalism, literally means to exploit.
to capitalize ..to exploit.
Ecocide
So incredibly short sighted. Human beings are doomed.
No, we're not.
@@Gustavo-lc5vk yes we are
How come forest are being allowed to be privatised?
It is not.
@@mariabrasileira3327 it is said on the report.
First you reduce surveillance, then someone invade and cut the trees, and when the dry season arrives they burn it and sell to someone naive (or maybe not) as if where legal land...
Also lobbying from the farmers...
Em vez de privatizar, exproprie fazendas no seu país e a transforme em florestas. Seria um ótimo exemplo.
Environmentalists are not talking about deforestation anymore since in Brazil there is now their friend Lula the communist, and even if Lula is still deforesting we will know nothing more.
Why German, France and other European Countries did not preserve Their Forest And wants impose deals to Brazil ? This is the question. Please look inside their own troubles and let Brazil take care with OWN AMAZON FOREST. If Amazonia was in Europe, only Exist SAND and SAND. That is the reallity.
Sorry, but most of the meat produced is to external market.
We can see that this government is the main responsible for this.
Countries that criticize Brazil are the same countries that buy illegal wood from Brazil
It's terrible that deforestation is continuing to happen on such a huge scale. It is linked to several problems throughout the world: global warming, flooding, soil erosion, animal extinction and so on. Their is no excuse whatsoever to deny the environmental impact of deforestation. Experts have been saying for years why it is so bad.
Is our demand for wooden products really so high? I certainly don't change my wooden furniture too frequently. Most of the wooden furniture in my home is over 30 years old. It's still in good condition and I have no plans to replace it anytime soon.
@@_koffee_9377 A lot of people deny the scale of deforestation and all the problems associated with it. Facts and figures are distorted to cover up the truth. If Brazil wants to continue doing business with the rest of the world, they should take better care of the Amazon. Too much has been destroyed already. It's got to stop. The rest of the world knows all about those cattle ranches and palm oil plantations that have sprung up over the years in Brazil. We are not going to be fooled into being told that their is no problem. We're past all that.
Today the gold mining is much bigger and with the support of the entire structure of the State. Nowadays Federal Delegates who face this mafia are removed;
environmental inspectors are prevented from inspecting. Legislation is rapidly changed to facilitate environmental crimes.
The fascist mafia that is occupying the Amazon has expertise in land grabbing and murder.
If the rest of the planet doesn't intervene, this mafia will consolidate, regardless of who the president is, and the process of devastation will never be stopped.!
stop carbon emissions first
Bolsonaro is one of those very narrow minded leaders that can't see beyond his immediate hungers. Or nose.
Esqueçam a Amazônia, a Amazônia é brasileira, é do Brasil ! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷👏
E nós vamos perder ela no futuro uauuuuuu
Esqueçam a Brasil, a Amazônia é Amazônian, é do Amazônia!🔥💩🇧🇷💩🔥🪶💪🌴🌳
3:01 3:11 ...
What?
Nem chamou, e eu já fui se der bom, vai dar ruim, cê não vai esquecer vou botar pra fuder foguete do tipo nasa saindo da atmosfera tem turbina nessa raba e agora ninguém me pega, aperta o cinto modo turbo que essa raba é de outro mundo aperta o cinto modo turbo senta senta sentaa
369
When we talk Abou environment, the center of the problem is not Amazonia, but até the oceans. Because the Amazonia represents 1% of the fresh Air and the 99% até from the oceans... And there is another enemy more dangerous: the virrus...
This is terribly frightening, the most militarily powerful nations should enter Brazil and save the Amazon.
@jp22168 Brazil's economy is fragile, a maritime blockade makes surrender easy, we meet with our troops, they sign treaties, and everything ends well.
@@columbia_gourmet3388EU ACABEI DE ENTREGAR TEU IP PARA AS FORCAS ARMADAS DO BRASIL AGORA. VOCE ESTÁ SENDO RASTREADO PELO GOVERNO DO BRASIL AGORA. VOCÊ NAO SOUBE DAS 15 OGIVAS NUCLEARES QUE O BRAS8L COMPROU DA RUSSIA E IRÃ EM 2023. ES AS NAÇÕES EUROPÉIAS E NORTE AMERICANAS TENTAR NOS BLOQUEAR NO MAR, NOS JOGAMOS NOSSOS MÍSSEIS HIPERSONICOS DE 16 MIL KILOMETROS POR HORA NO MAR LEVANDO 4 OGIVAS NUCLEARES DENTRO E ASSIM TODA A MARINHA MILITAR DE 34 NACOES RICAS QUE POSSUAM DE 15 MIL BARCOS CONTENDO MILHOES DE ARMAS DE GRANDES, MÉDIO E MICRO PORTES DENTRO E SER INCINERADOS E AFUNDADOS NO MAR.
@@columbia_gourmet3388bom, se isso ocorrer, perderemos, mas vocês perderam a Amazônia, ja que destruiriamos propositalmente. HAHAHAHA
Brazil would build nuclear weapons in 3 days and destroy the Amazon.
An aggression against a sovereign and democratic country would have serious consequences for you, we have recently been negotiating with India to purchase anti-aircraft systems and we have mastered half the conponents to make a nuclear warhead, anything you plan against Brazil we will not think twice before leaving of the NPT "treaty of non ploriferation of nuclear weapons" and producing nuclear warheads i bet the US would hate a Latin American neighbor with nuclear weapons.
We desire cheap meat and furniture. Who's to blame really? As always the true cost of the product is not reflected in the price.
fakenews.
I am vegan still feel bad about it.
1
Beef versus Forests?
Think about that when you next crave buying a Burger!
Replacing natural forests for Beef farming?
Very Sad for the Children of tomorrow!
Bring it on burn the whole forest
i agree
Ig we have to face the consequences our future is not bright at all
Germam liers
Portuguese liar
Dont buy beef from brazil...learn to hunt and fish :)
It is very frustrating to environmentalists and all the people who understand Importance of amazon.
Pretty frustrating for most Brazilians too. But debating is not and option. Actions should be taken.
@@wowlily1245 when elected government is not acting in interest of people, agitation is the only way to coerce them to do so.
@@wowlily1245 educate the children and Will not be necessary punish the Men (Pitagoras). That is the solution: education to get environmental awarennes.
@@ecossocioletramentonaamazo5594 Perfect
fish instead? Really? Is it so hard to not stick animals in your mouth? Please go vegan... if not for the animals, for all the generations of humans to come...
@Bartô N then ignore me and let reason be your guide. We don't need meat to thrive. Meat is harmful to animals and the environment and no one wants to harm animals or the environment needlessly. Therefore become vegan.
If you want to sell something, create the demand. Want a 'hero' to save you from catastrophe?
Amazonia is wet doesn't catch fire.
🇧🇷➡Língua portuguesa, a melhor língua de comunicação do mundo!
Easter Island 2.0
Eu queria muito que fosse deferente mais infelizmente o brasil não é perfeito nem os brasileiro l'm sorry
Traidora da pátria
Tks, but we need more.
We need global community to take action to stop this.
Dw could make a documentary about the destruction that Brazil is promoting, and it's impacts on local communities.
O que nós precisamos é começar a prender e punir traidores, isso sim. Especialmente os que clamam por intervenção estrangeira.
@@guilhermesilveira636 "Patriotismo é a virtude dos depravados"
O. Wilde
"Totalitarismo é o patriotismo institucionalizado"
A. Allen
Até parece que as entidades internacionais estão preocupados com a Amazônia e não os recursos não é ?
I AM BRAZILIAN, ACABEI DE ENTREGAR TEU NOME E IP PARA AS FORCAS ARMADAS DO BRASIL, VOCE ESTARA SENDO RASTREADA AGORA.
EU ACABEI DE ENTREGAR TEU IP PARA AS FORCAS ARMADAS DO BRASIL AGORA. VOCÊ ESTÁ SENDO RASTREADO PELO GOVERNO DO BRASIL AGORA.
The Amazon is done by the end of the 2020's. I know it!
NO IT WONT!!! We cant let it!
I actually agree, global demand is increasing extremely rapidly for resources and beef from the Amazon , the Amazon has suffered extreme droughts and dried up many times in recent years and gas dried out and turned into Savannah already in many areas, things are only only intensifying and I think within 2 years from now after another 2 years of extensive logging I think the Amazon tainforest will suddenly crack under the pressure and completely collapse
@@loganmalough2379 First, the Brazilians are in charge of the Brazilian territory, second you don't have to say anything unhappy American
Amazon forest = Brazil.
Brasil = we want beef.
DW please stop to lie..Tell the truth to the world.
So _you_ have the truth? Show us, then.
How much there is in your florest? Forget amazon rainforest its already has an owner and, bet, it is not europe so the sweet water, gold, mining so on it are all brazilian,but look I am not considering the trees and others sources which you guys had shipped to your land since 1500s, anyway, sorry for that might in mars europe would be an important place again because in this planet it is not.
I hope you guys get a nukes into glass
I'm vegan
Human will suffer for the revenge of nature!
Raytheon and their dieect energy weapons. All day.
6:19 exactly what does he mean
Stop. Get your Government together
Predictable outcome of having a fascist government
Sou brasileiro e moro em São Paulo. A impressão que tenho que uma parcela dos brasileiros, em especial os de baixa renda e com pouco estudo, tem pensamento deprimente justificando o desmatamento e queimadas no Brasil com situações extremas ou sem nexo de causa, do tipo:
__” É uma mentira desmatamentos e queimadas...”
__ “A Amazônia é nossa e fazemos o que quiser...”
__“Os estrangeiros estão querendo limitar a capacidade do agronegócio do Brasil...”
__”Os estrangeiros estão querendo roubar nossos metais preciosos e nossa biodiversidade... ”
__“Nós brasileiros temos o direito de desmatar nossas florestas já que vocês desmataram as suas...”
__”O trabalhador do campo precisa sobreviver, e geram riqueza para o país...”
Por mais que muitos brasileiros acham ruim desmatamento, acreditam que a floresta consegue se recompor naturalmente ou por intervenção humana, esquecem da extinção de várias espécies animais e vegetais.
A grande parte da população brasileira não vive do agronegócio nem do garimpo de ouro. As grandes empresas do agronegócio no Brasil são subsidiadas com crédito governamental, possuem processo mecanizado/automatizado gerando pouco emprego. Alguns defensores do desmatamento justificam vitimizando o trabalhador do campo, mas é difícil entender como um trabalhador sem recurso pode precisar de tantas terras para sobreviver.
É lamentável escutar de brasileiros justificativas para o desmatamento sem nexo de causa, em atividades econômicas extrativistas de recurso natural escasso que geram pouco retorno para o país, em que no final o custo-benefício para nação não compensa.
Mas isso não justifica ameaçar a soberania brasileira sobre a Amazônia e de outros países.
Não estamos Justificando o desmatando seu burro. Você não representa nem 1% dos brasileiros. Moro no litoral da Bahia, mais perto da Amazônia, e posso te dizer que a maioria das pessoas a minha volta, escolheriam preservar a floresta do que destroi-la
É obrigação do Brasil proteger a Amazônia, e não de outros países, porque ela está no nosso território, não no território francês e americano, que aliás, eles mesmo destruíram e não tem nem 60% do território deles com a floresta nativa preservada
Você deveria ser expulso do país por defender mentiras contra o povo brasileiro
Blame the big american corporations .