Thank you for the videos you've given us. I only found this channel recently, so I don't know which videos used to be here, but I've never seen 03 in the series, which I don't need but was looking forward to watching. The effort that goes into making these videos is likely underappreciated by most viewers (myself included), but I can imagine the time and effort that goes into the planning, the recording, the editing, the clear explanations, not to mention the knowledge you've accumulated to even be able to make such videos. As a constant language dabbler, I know that what you're providing is better than what is put out by most language companies and learning institutions -- and of course they're making a lot of money, while you're making pennies with RUclips. Might I suggest that you keep a full set of videos, something akin to Yiddish 1's worth of material, to whet people's appetite towards Yiddish and to promote your private lessons. I also recommend you package your videos for Udemy's platform, where people pay for courses. I think the benefit of your private lessons must be in the interaction with you and classmates, not just strictly you giving these lectures live, which of couse few would pay for when they have a happy substitute in these videos. As for responding to emails, I would advise against it should you return to making videos. As someone who has wasted a great deal of time online explaining to people how wrong they are philosophically, I know firsthand how unappreciative people can be even when presented with veritable gold in clarity and profundity, which comes at great cost even to someone as astute and eloquent as I am. Screw them, I said to myself, and stopped participating in philosophy online forums, a gabfest of fops and fools, so I know your pain. Thanks again. You've inspired me to give Yiddish another try.
Why keep them up? I grew tired of the fact that much bigger organisations and university courses use my materials without even asking me. And it’s sad that people email me with a question and I spend hours creating grammar explanation and exercises to that specific question (for free!) and then I don’t even get a thank you in return. I’m not doing it anymore.
@@ikhlernzikhyiddish you did the right thing. You shouldn't waste your talent. Leave some videos up with your contact info and start charging for this quality teaching. You taught me a lot bro. I wish for you the best. אַ שיינעמ דאַנק
"Why keep them up?" May I suggest two reasons? 1. All the videos you've taken down are already available elsewhere on the web, e.g., on the Bilibili site, and are easy to find. But you are not getting any credit for them. Leaving them up here will mean that at least there'll be one place on the web where you do get credit for your work. 2. If your plan is to go into private teaching, then leaving the videos up will make for good marketing. You'll be demonstrating to everyone your skill as a teacher. However, I wish you all the best whatever you decide to do and would like to express my gratitude and appreciation for your work. זאָל זייַנ מיט מאַזל!
Thank you for giving me insight into this interesting laguage. It is sad to see you gone and most videos deleted now, but I understand it. I wish you and your soon to be students a great time, farewell! :)
Why keep them up? You know what a ‘shanda' is? The fact that much bigger organisations and university courses use my materials without even asking me. A ‘shanda’ is that people email me with a question and I spend hours creating a grammar explanation and exercises to that specific question (for free!) and then I don’t even get a thank you in return. That’s a ‘shanda’ and I’m not doing it anymore.
@@ikhlernzikhyiddishWhy not put a disclaimer saying not to use the videos for any purpose? and you dont have to reply to any email that strangers send you.
@@ikhlernzikhyiddish Greed greed has ruined every good initiative. How much did you earn now by destroying your course? Here on RUclips there are a lot of free courses in Spanish, English and other languages. Learn from them how they make money.
@ikhlernzikhyiddish given that Yiddish is an endangered language, yes, it really is a shame that you abandoned this project. If you built the channel, not only would you get paid by RUclips but you would be doing all Ashkenazi, all Jews and the world an honorable service. Is it your duty? No. But surely you realize that because yiddish is preserved almost entirely within the most insular Hasidic communities - always the MOST misunderstood Jews amongst outsiders - someone who has the ability to speak and teach the language through videos online would be helping many people in many ways - particularly people who wish to reconnect with their Jewish heritage, students who don't have access to Yiddish courses (which are rare) and interested outsiders who simply want to understand Ashkenazi culture better. Yes this is a פאַרפאַלן געלעגנהייט
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
You are one of the only Yiddish teachers on RUclips. Sad to see you go.
Thank you for the videos you've given us. I only found this channel recently, so I don't know which videos used to be here, but I've never seen 03 in the series, which I don't need but was looking forward to watching.
The effort that goes into making these videos is likely underappreciated by most viewers (myself included), but I can imagine the time and effort that goes into the planning, the recording, the editing, the clear explanations, not to mention the knowledge you've accumulated to even be able to make such videos. As a constant language dabbler, I know that what you're providing is better than what is put out by most language companies and learning institutions -- and of course they're making a lot of money, while you're making pennies with RUclips.
Might I suggest that you keep a full set of videos, something akin to Yiddish 1's worth of material, to whet people's appetite towards Yiddish and to promote your private lessons. I also recommend you package your videos for Udemy's platform, where people pay for courses. I think the benefit of your private lessons must be in the interaction with you and classmates, not just strictly you giving these lectures live, which of couse few would pay for when they have a happy substitute in these videos.
As for responding to emails, I would advise against it should you return to making videos. As someone who has wasted a great deal of time online explaining to people how wrong they are philosophically, I know firsthand how unappreciative people can be even when presented with veritable gold in clarity and profundity, which comes at great cost even to someone as astute and eloquent as I am. Screw them, I said to myself, and stopped participating in philosophy online forums, a gabfest of fops and fools, so I know your pain.
Thanks again. You've inspired me to give Yiddish another try.
Nooo :( why delete the videos???
Why keep them up?
I grew tired of the fact that much bigger organisations and university courses use my materials without even asking me. And it’s sad that people email me with a question and I spend hours creating grammar explanation and exercises to that specific question (for free!) and then I don’t even get a thank you in return. I’m not doing it anymore.
@@ikhlernzikhyiddish you did the right thing. You shouldn't waste your talent. Leave some videos up with your contact info and start charging for this quality teaching. You taught me a lot bro. I wish for you the best. אַ שיינעמ דאַנק
"Why keep them up?"
May I suggest two reasons?
1. All the videos you've taken down are already available elsewhere on the web, e.g., on the Bilibili site, and are easy to find. But you are not getting any credit for them. Leaving them up here will mean that at least there'll be one place on the web where you do get credit for your work.
2. If your plan is to go into private teaching, then leaving the videos up will make for good marketing. You'll be demonstrating to everyone your skill as a teacher.
However, I wish you all the best whatever you decide to do and would like to express my gratitude and appreciation for your work.
זאָל זייַנ מיט מאַזל!
Aw man, I just discovered you. you were the best resource I could find. :( I hope you do well.
Noooo!I have enjoyed your lessons so much
I just came on here for the first time! It’s so important to continue this language
I agree.
Thank you for giving me insight into this interesting laguage. It is sad to see you gone and most videos deleted now, but I understand it.
I wish you and your soon to be students a great time, farewell! :)
So sad to see you go. I've really enjoyed your videos as a walk through of the things I've learned in my uni course some time ago.
I just started to learn Yiddish and found your videos very useful. Sad to see you stop.
All the best to you and God bless you.
Sunny
Why delete your vids? That's such a Shanda.
Why keep them up?
You know what a ‘shanda' is? The fact that much bigger organisations and university courses use my materials without even asking me. A ‘shanda’ is that people email me with a question and I spend hours creating a grammar explanation and exercises to that specific question (for free!) and then I don’t even get a thank you in return. That’s a ‘shanda’ and I’m not doing it anymore.
@@ikhlernzikhyiddishWhy not put a disclaimer saying not to use the videos for any purpose? and you dont have to reply to any email that strangers send you.
@@ikhlernzikhyiddish Greed greed has ruined every good initiative.
How much did you earn now by destroying your course? Here on RUclips there are a lot of free courses in Spanish, English and other languages. Learn from them how they make money.
@ikhlernzikhyiddish given that Yiddish is an endangered language, yes, it really is a shame that you abandoned this project.
If you built the channel, not only would you get paid by RUclips but you would be doing all Ashkenazi, all Jews and the world an honorable service.
Is it your duty? No. But surely you realize that because yiddish is preserved almost entirely within the most insular Hasidic communities - always the MOST misunderstood Jews amongst outsiders - someone who has the ability to speak and teach the language through videos online would be helping many people in many ways - particularly people who wish to reconnect with their Jewish heritage, students who don't have access to Yiddish courses (which are rare) and interested outsiders who simply want to understand Ashkenazi culture better.
Yes this is a פאַרפאַלן געלעגנהייט
Its sad way to know yidish is very popular,with universities commiting acts of piracy,depressing indeed....
Plz reconsider deleting your videos. Still, I wish you the best.
Bruh
?