Supergirl: ''Hank didn't Kill Astra, I did. ''

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 янв 2025

Комментарии • 153

  • @rileybennett7763
    @rileybennett7763 4 года назад +147

    what i find the most powerful is how Kara was about to walk out but instead she decided to forgive Alex. It’s so amazing.

    • @mdmmysocialmedia254
      @mdmmysocialmedia254 2 года назад +5

      In My Mind That's What's Makes A Superhero!

    • @EverythingDaltonmonias
      @EverythingDaltonmonias 2 года назад

      yea age was about ti bw mad but age decide to be tge bigger person

    • @Edward-nf4nc
      @Edward-nf4nc 4 месяца назад

      Alura used Kara, Hank let Alex use him, but then Alex showed how strong she is by telling Kara the truth and taking the risk of honesty. Kara realised this and forgave Alex for her honesty and bravery and loyalty to her friend.
      Kara showed she was a better sister than her mother since she could forgive her sister, but her mother could not.

  • @69davyd
    @69davyd 5 лет назад +271

    Their family like bond is beautiful when Kara hugged Alex and reached for J'onn I cried

    • @joelfinch2471
      @joelfinch2471 4 года назад +3

      You weren't alone...Alex, the badass, can make me cry buckets.

  • @leigracia3523
    @leigracia3523 5 лет назад +201

    This scene actually taught me to not get upset with people's action but to understand their intention and reason behind it. I had saved a lot of friendships that way. Which idk what that says about the decision making of a lot of my friends😂

    • @jasonmoukala8909
      @jasonmoukala8909 5 лет назад +4

      Lei Gracia I’m not gonna lie, I would be pissed if someone killed one of my family members even if that person is evil

    • @nichoudha
      @nichoudha 4 года назад +4

      @@jasonmoukala8909 Yeah, but the person who did it was another family member... so... uh...

    • @jasonmoukala8909
      @jasonmoukala8909 4 года назад

      Jarin Jove Wouldn’t you be mad?

    • @nichoudha
      @nichoudha 2 года назад +1

      @@jasonmoukala8909 Honestly, depends on what it is....

  • @lucasgray1492
    @lucasgray1492 5 лет назад +65

    She did what she had to do. Honestly this is one of the best scenes in the season. They are such amazing actors

  • @TheAwesomeJordy
    @TheAwesomeJordy 6 лет назад +232

    Absolutely heartbreaking scene. Brilliant acting performance!

  • @MrDCWood
    @MrDCWood 4 года назад +46

    To this day, still one of the most powerful moments in the whole show.
    And one of the moments that truly exemplifies what makes Kara Supergirl.

  • @ThePlanetPegasus
    @ThePlanetPegasus 5 лет назад +144

    I love J'onn he's so loyal to both of them.

  • @tttlllccctttlllccc4723
    @tttlllccctttlllccc4723 5 лет назад +68

    How I wish the show would return to having scenes like this.

    • @icaryu4058
      @icaryu4058 5 лет назад +2

      Maybe with Lena and Kara...

    • @saraalsheikhly6957
      @saraalsheikhly6957 5 лет назад +1

      Edouard Rivalland no more Danvers scenes need to happen supercorp is great and all but sg isn’t just about them

    • @disha6559
      @disha6559 4 года назад

      Ali Adler needs to get back in the exec seat for that.
      Not gonna happen with Queller & Rovner ruining the show left and right.

    • @MrDCWood
      @MrDCWood 4 года назад +2

      Disha · To be honest, I’m not sure how they’ve ruined the show. After all, they wrote Falling.
      Season 4 was certainly intense and covered so much politics, social and real-life issues...but ironically, that resulted in being the show’s best season. Highly-consistent writing, a fantastic arc, great new characters...and of course, Jon Cryer’s Lex Luthor.

    • @noabengal3739
      @noabengal3739 4 года назад +3

      @@icaryu4058 nooo the sisters are the heart of the show and thier bond is the only reason why I'm watching the show...not this lena and lax crap

  • @Smurshes
    @Smurshes 7 лет назад +272

    The sorrow and major regret in Alex's face, man. She was just doing what she thought was best for Kara. I don't think Astra would have done anything to stop myriad if she had lived. She was changing for the better, yes, but she wouldn't have stopped.

    • @Lava91point0
      @Lava91point0 6 лет назад +6

      If Alex hadn't suffered another episode of "she's my sister and you can't have her!" none of that shit with Myriad would have happened. Astra wasn't going to kill Jonn, you don't tell someone you're going to kill them, you just do it lol. Jeez, all that woman does is think with her vagina.

    • @agnikaineverdies7646
      @agnikaineverdies7646 6 лет назад +4

      Lord Papi Darkwing, lol Alex didn’t even need to kill her, just bringing kryptonite near astra would have weakened her

    • @agnikaineverdies7646
      @agnikaineverdies7646 6 лет назад +4

      Alex didn’t even need to kill astra, she could have simply incapacitated astra by stabbing her in the leg, or could have just hit her over the head and knocked her out.

    • @xiamariansupreme72
      @xiamariansupreme72 5 лет назад +1

      @@agnikaineverdies7646
      Didn't Astra have a kryptonite-invulnerable suit? Bringing it near her wouldn't have bothered her, but ramming it thru her alien flesh sure did.

    • @agnikaineverdies7646
      @agnikaineverdies7646 5 лет назад

      TheEmpressDominique, astra wasn’t wearing the suit otherwise the kryptonite wouldn’t have pierced her, she was completely vulnerable, bringing kryptonite near her would weaken her.
      Alex probably killed her on instinct because she didn’t have time to think

  • @kevsdigitalartsmore3743
    @kevsdigitalartsmore3743 5 лет назад +143

    2:26 you’re not going anywhere papa bear

    • @marina.-.9697
      @marina.-.9697 4 года назад +2

      Kev's Digital arts & more 😂

  • @alyssalam6556
    @alyssalam6556 4 года назад +35

    Chyler was amazing in this scene

  • @audreysegedin7803
    @audreysegedin7803 4 года назад +44

    J’onn had two girls of his own, but both of them were killed. Before Kara and Alex’s Father “died”, he asked J’onn to look after his girls for him. J’onn always felt like he failed his first family, so that’s why he was always so protective over Kara and Alex, because he didn’t want to lose two more daughters. I think that’s another reason he took the blame for Alex, because he knew that family splitting apart like he thought Kara and Alex would do is just as bad as losing them. He took the bad cop card so at least his girls could feel safe together. Another reason why Kara took his hand in the end. He had officially become their second Father (for Kara her third), and he was someone they could always trust and go to for advice. An amazing little family they have there. J’onn has two daughters again, and Kara and Alex have a Father again.

  • @beyondme9369
    @beyondme9369 5 лет назад +54

    My heart..i don't know or i personally haven't seen such a powerful and beautiful portrayal of sisters....

  • @ethanmitchell7479
    @ethanmitchell7479 4 года назад +42

    My friend:”damn that’s deep...”
    Me:”don’t cry, don’t cry, don’t cry, don’t cry, don’t cry.............”

  • @issymorley7702
    @issymorley7702 6 лет назад +116

    famous chyler leigh whimper returns

    • @gabriellethebard9339
      @gabriellethebard9339 5 лет назад +3

      What's that? 😂 she did it in grey's anatomy?

    • @alexreyes4159
      @alexreyes4159 5 лет назад

      Film Student Named Issy I know you know i8l love you 😘 one is ll

  • @hkaos
    @hkaos 5 лет назад +17

    I think this is still probably my favorite scene from the show.

  • @joeydurborow4106
    @joeydurborow4106 5 лет назад +49

    This is the best scene of the whole season

  • @kovidraj9380
    @kovidraj9380 4 года назад +16

    Chyler/Alex ❤ is such an awesome actress, from this moment i fell in love with Alex, she became my fav character in #Supergirl n the way Kara understands the situation n forgives Alex n hugs her was literally the best...

  • @hollywoodwerewolf
    @hollywoodwerewolf 5 лет назад +44

    He’s their Space Dad!

  • @someone929.
    @someone929. 4 года назад +9

    God I love this scene so much that I think I broke the replay button

  • @colingarcia5452
    @colingarcia5452 7 месяцев назад +2

    I felt so sorry alex when she broke down like that

  • @diegodreossi1458
    @diegodreossi1458 5 лет назад +47

    My favorite part is when Kara reaches J'onn

    • @NickyHelp
      @NickyHelp 2 года назад +2

      I’ll take that reach out as a sign of her apologizing to him.

  • @ferr5077
    @ferr5077 4 года назад +3

    Chyler's acting... chef kiss

  • @ForeverWinterandHope
    @ForeverWinterandHope 4 года назад +16

    Man, when Kara hugged Alex I cried! Anyone else?

  • @Fazzel
    @Fazzel 5 лет назад +13

    We should do a drinking game where every time Alex cries, we take a shot.

  • @KL-kt8tj
    @KL-kt8tj 5 лет назад +9

    1:46 Who else has had to hide a secret bc your too afraid of losing them, BUT actually do when you just can’t lie to the one you love.... wish this scene was real life with many in my family....
    Edit: 1:46

  • @taylorminx5449
    @taylorminx5449 5 лет назад +10

    2020 jan 2 . . still watching

  • @narayastarks
    @narayastarks 4 года назад +15

    I understand why she was upset, Astra was the only family she had left, even tho she was evil. Kara still cared about Astra

    • @NickyHelp
      @NickyHelp 2 года назад

      Yet, Astra hasn’t been family material anyway.

  • @stefanosgrapsas8816
    @stefanosgrapsas8816 3 года назад +4

    At 2:17 hes like aight my job is done here imma head out

  • @youareacoward8459
    @youareacoward8459 3 года назад +3

    when supergirl was something to watch.

  • @jamestolbert1856
    @jamestolbert1856 11 месяцев назад +1

    I’m glad that Kara decided not to hold it against her like she did to Jon, and forgave her

  • @shiniajones331
    @shiniajones331 5 лет назад +29

    This was the best scene ever in supergirl

  • @agentsasha2480
    @agentsasha2480 7 лет назад +69

    2:00
    What now ?!
    I told the truth !

  • @lukegamer4931
    @lukegamer4931 3 года назад +7

    I've started watching the whole arrowverse for the first time ever I know I'm late anyway I've become such a fan and nerd I'm watching the episodes in the order they came out and I'm loving every show and every character so far, tonight I watched a few more episodes and this scene was special, I'm loving Supergirl her story and character is so fascinating, but the sense of family, loving and forgiving them, whether by blood (or species), that's 1 of the big things I love about this show, I can't wait to see more and I'm going to be sad to see Supergirl end the truly had the perfect cast for this show

    • @SupermanForever1979
      @SupermanForever1979  3 года назад +4

      The first couple of seasons were pretty good! I'm glad you have a whole new set of stories and characters to enjoy!

    • @lukegamer4931
      @lukegamer4931 3 года назад +1

      Thank you, I remember watching smallville years ago I actually have all 10 seasons and loved the adventure and the characters, now I have Arrow, the Flash, Supergirl and DC Legends, and so far it's been emotional and amazing, and the the arrowverse is still going to date this is going to be great I can feel it

    • @SupermanForever1979
      @SupermanForever1979  3 года назад +1

      @@lukegamer4931 I continued to love The Flash up until season 6 which I am in the middle of watching for the first time now. Unfortunately, this season is actually incredibly boring and for the first time, I'm struggling to maintain interest. That seems to be the popular opinion for season 6. With regards to Supergirl, I was a massive fan in the beginning, but unfortunately it didn't take too long for the show to turn in to nothing but a sermon for preaching every single social justice campaign imaginable, as they jumped on every bandwagon and drew attention away from the fun superheroic storylines we watch these characters for. The cool stuff was there, but it often felt like it was in the background, offsetting daytime soap drama themes. Arrow is great and DC's Legends is a lot of fun too! But NOTHING compares to Smallville! Smallville was nothing but great stories with amazing characters and superb acting! I have the entire series on dvd/bluray too and think it's time to go back to the beginning!
      ''Always hold on to Smallvile''. :)

    • @kellharris2491
      @kellharris2491 2 года назад +1

      @@SupermanForever1979 That's the sad part about shows like Supergirl. They can't just be. Any time it's a woman or black or some other minority it's like they are pushed to show a message. Arrow and Flash could just be about the characters themselves. But one thing I will say, I love the Actors on Supergirl. I found myself watching some episodes just for the powerful Acting of Mellissa as Supergirl. And Katie as Lena Luthor. And Alex. I felt like even when the writting was trash there were times when they could pull real emotion from me and I am a cynic.

  • @AllyBubblesSpriggs
    @AllyBubblesSpriggs 5 лет назад +22

    I love this scene!!!! 😭😍😭😍😭😍

  • @baked_alaska
    @baked_alaska 3 года назад +11

    Given everything that happened in this story arc and everything that came to light, I honestly believe Kara only forgave Alex because she couldn't bear the thought of losing another loved one.
    Astra was killed, Kara's perfect memories of her parents were tarnished, her entire planet died because her own family couldn't agree on a solution to prevent the ecological collapse...
    What else could she do but forgive her only sister when the only alternative was more loss?

    • @AniWho268
      @AniWho268 Год назад +1

      That's an interesting perspective.

  • @murzkatze
    @murzkatze 5 лет назад +10

    And there my ladies and gentlemen and everyone in between you see true strengh.

  • @breahlanee4432
    @breahlanee4432 5 лет назад +15

    Sisterly love

  • @hername-jeneyce__coney2837
    @hername-jeneyce__coney2837 6 лет назад +29

    This gets me every time

  • @haiseee3566
    @haiseee3566 4 года назад +2

    gotta love how after all the bullshit jonn endured, he still didnt want alex to tell her

  • @JessicaLynn10
    @JessicaLynn10 5 лет назад +20

    Best scene ever in my opinion of supergirl.

  • @sanskrutipathak2000
    @sanskrutipathak2000 6 лет назад +12

    A strong moment...

  • @danielaespinosa8552
    @danielaespinosa8552 5 лет назад +3

    That was the first time I cried with this show 💔😭

  • @KingSadim
    @KingSadim 5 лет назад +4

    2:27 Every guy is like "Yessss, my fantasy"

  • @daeulorss
    @daeulorss 4 года назад +2

    Kara, you did it for Oliver

  • @ryanabate1981
    @ryanabate1981 Год назад +2

    We stopped getting scenes like this because CW took over. The writers they brought in were just not into these kinds of scenes. Arrowverse was emotional, but not on this level and I think the decision to make this an Arrowverse type show hurt the show

  • @agentsasha2480
    @agentsasha2480 7 лет назад +24

    2:28
    Well what you tryna do!?
    sec later..
    OH nvm, we coo!

  • @denisheabates7660
    @denisheabates7660 5 лет назад +4

    Alex you should have said something to her Kara doesn't hate you

  • @Bamaborn
    @Bamaborn 5 лет назад +2

    STRONGER TOGETHER

  • @darkreaper2981
    @darkreaper2981 4 года назад +3

    Damn this emotional

  • @lordwinton
    @lordwinton 5 лет назад +4

    Jonn was their surrogate papa bear

  • @FandeJay
    @FandeJay 5 лет назад +4

    2:43
    This image.
    Nuff said.

  • @matthewsteele6192
    @matthewsteele6192 5 лет назад +1

    God I love Kara I wish I had a sister like kara, she forgives Alex despite what she did because she knows she did what she had too their bond is so strong

  • @beginingoftheent6220
    @beginingoftheent6220 4 года назад

    1st scene to ever make me cry on a tv show.

  • @FERNANDALIMA-lp2qn
    @FERNANDALIMA-lp2qn 7 лет назад +6

    Que cena! Chy maravilhosa.

    • @melissabrienda
      @melissabrienda 7 лет назад

      Essa cena é muito linda, que atriz sensível!

  • @theirishhero81
    @theirishhero81 5 лет назад +14

    Why did he decide to lie? Why didn’t they just say that Astra was trying to kill them both? Kara was angry because she believed that Astra had changed, when she really hadn’t. If she had changed, she wouldn’t still be fighting them. Kara doesn’t seem to understand that Astra’s choices has consequences.

    • @d.n.c.greatness7735
      @d.n.c.greatness7735 5 лет назад +6

      Preach!!

    • @rlm140
      @rlm140 5 лет назад +5

      She said why she lied it was because she didn't want to loose her remember Kara always say we don't kill John took the blame to protect Alex at that moment we don't know how Kara would of acted towards Alex she thought he'd aunt was change but she would of kill Jon

    • @misspriss2482
      @misspriss2482 5 лет назад +4

      He lied because in some ways, Kara is a five year old. She always wants to believe the best in people and insists that given a choice, everyone will change. It's one of the few things that irritates me about Kara, to be honest. Some people are irredeemable and/or have no desire to be better.

    • @jasonmoukala8909
      @jasonmoukala8909 5 лет назад

      Miss Priss wouldn’t you be pissed if someone killed your family member, even if that family was evil.

    • @agnikaineverdies7646
      @agnikaineverdies7646 3 года назад

      Kara knew that astra was trying to kill them, she didn’t care, she was mad that jonn killed her

  • @kitt28
    @kitt28 5 лет назад +7

    supergirl has a heart of gold, makes me love the writers, now if they would have left her uniform alone.

    • @g2growcya
      @g2growcya 4 года назад +2

      KITT28 yeah. But pants/spandex pants/whatever are more practical than a skirt

  • @ChrisontopW
    @ChrisontopW 4 года назад +1

    Poor Alex I love you baby don't be said

  • @scottpowell5458
    @scottpowell5458 5 лет назад +7

    Go team super girl

  • @idaenaera_targaryen
    @idaenaera_targaryen 4 года назад +1

    oh i cried

  • @matilda517
    @matilda517 4 года назад +4

    So J'onn says he killed Astra, Kara gets cold and judgy. Alex says she kiled Astra and gets a hug like wtf?

    • @Feltkitty705gaming
      @Feltkitty705gaming 4 года назад +1

      At this point Kara hadn’t known J’onn long but Alex is her sister

    • @NickyHelp
      @NickyHelp 2 года назад +1

      Well, Kara apologizes to Martian Manhunter for that as she grabbed him by the arm.

  • @Frir10
    @Frir10 5 лет назад +5

    Wow, that skirt was really, really short. Glad they changed it (:

    • @Fazzel
      @Fazzel 5 лет назад +3

      I loved the skirt. Now she looks like a wanna be Captain Marvel.

    • @Feltkitty705gaming
      @Feltkitty705gaming 4 года назад

      Frir10 I’m sorry I know (or at least hope) this comment isn’t meant to be creep but the smiley face just makes it seem so weird

    • @Frir10
      @Frir10 4 года назад

      @@Feltkitty705gaming Oh sorry, I was not trying to be creepy. I'm just genuinely happy they decided to change it.

    • @Feltkitty705gaming
      @Feltkitty705gaming 4 года назад

      Frir10 that smiley face is creepy in any context idk why but it can make the most innocent comment seem creepy

  • @ritadecassia4699
    @ritadecassia4699 5 лет назад +2

    Tao lindas 💜💚👋

  • @mdmmysocialmedia254
    @mdmmysocialmedia254 2 года назад

    Posted: Saturday, February 19, 2022, PST, Commentary: It Is My Personal Opinion That Chyler Leigh Gave An Excellent Exceptional Believable Powerful Emotional Passionate Acting Performance With Total Conviction Of Purpose. Sincerely, FREE PRESS WITHOUT BORDERS. "We All Genuinely Act Out Our Real Life Experiences."

  • @chevyhargreaves9518
    @chevyhargreaves9518 Месяц назад

    it’d be so easy to walk away if someone betrayed me like that, i seriously don’t know why kara didn’t walk away

    • @daviddelara7158
      @daviddelara7158 Месяц назад +1

      Because Alex is her sister

    • @jomnix
      @jomnix 13 дней назад

      And Kara loves her sister and forgives her.

  • @rebeccafernandes3723
    @rebeccafernandes3723 5 лет назад +3

    Damn onioins

  • @vikram2423
    @vikram2423 5 лет назад +5

    0:01 I thought batman symbol was scary. LOL

    • @alexswan8597
      @alexswan8597 5 лет назад +1

      Out of the entire scene and that is literally the only thing you commented on? 🤣 (joking)

  • @aidanhelmstetter3650
    @aidanhelmstetter3650 3 года назад +1

    1:51

  • @ChrisontopW
    @ChrisontopW 4 года назад

    Poor Alex

  • @ChrisontopW
    @ChrisontopW 4 года назад

    I'm said 😭about you don't be said honey baby

  • @2013venjix
    @2013venjix 3 года назад +1

    You killed her aunt because of fearing the worst that might end up losing Kara *AND YOU'RE SORRY?!!* 😡

    • @Maddie-pn4mo
      @Maddie-pn4mo 3 года назад +2

      She killed astra bc she was about to kil J’onn/hank

    • @2013venjix
      @2013venjix 3 года назад

      @@Maddie-pn4mo She could've wounded her, not kill it.

    • @NickyHelp
      @NickyHelp 2 года назад

      There was no other choice. This was war. It was either Astra or Martian Manhunter.

    • @2013venjix
      @2013venjix 2 года назад

      @@NickyHelp There's always a choice.

    • @NickyHelp
      @NickyHelp 2 года назад +2

      @@2013venjix Wrong. Not if one is being controlled or brainwashed by a villain, there isn't a choice. Besides, in this case, there was no time for any choice to make. It's too late for any choice anyway. Martian Manhunter was about to be killed in a split second without anyone to make any choices. Again, like I pointed out this is war. You missed the entire point. Also, Astra bought it on herself anyway.

  • @alwaysalegend0018
    @alwaysalegend0018 5 лет назад +1

    😭😭💔💔

  • @vikram2423
    @vikram2423 5 лет назад +4

    Who is Hank?

    • @sophie23694
      @sophie23694 5 лет назад

      thiruvikraman sridharan the african-american man

    • @rapidecho5705
      @rapidecho5705 5 лет назад

      thiruvikraman sridharan Martian manhunter

    • @Fazzel
      @Fazzel 5 лет назад

      Cyborg Superman

    • @Feltkitty705gaming
      @Feltkitty705gaming 4 года назад

      Technically hank is the evil guy who works for Cadmus (not Jeremiah) but J’on was Impersonating hank Henshaw

  • @GigaDriggaDragon
    @GigaDriggaDragon 7 месяцев назад

    Powerful stuff, but regarding John and Kara never been a fan of non verbal apologies

  • @joelfinch2471
    @joelfinch2471 4 года назад +2

    Chyler Leigh could be a little more awesome....I'm just not sure how.

  • @kfiryegudayev733
    @kfiryegudayev733 5 лет назад +1

    its was alex that said it not supergirl supergirl:"hank didnt kill astra, i did." thats the title lol

    • @adrianna1465
      @adrianna1465 5 лет назад

      They put supergirl because that is the name of the show, they weren’t saying that Supergirl was the one to say it

    • @kfiryegudayev733
      @kfiryegudayev733 5 лет назад

      @@adrianna1465 kk

  • @hmiles650
    @hmiles650 5 лет назад +2

    It’s weird that they’re calling Jonn Hank

    • @Feltkitty705gaming
      @Feltkitty705gaming 4 года назад

      H Miles yeah in season 1 I just wish they would have made up their minds about what to call him finally they went with jonn

  • @Lava91point0
    @Lava91point0 6 лет назад +8

    What does it say when the human combatant with a kryptonite sword (very convenient plot armor btw, presumably the D.E.O is funded by Bruce fucking Wayne) is the one to save J'onn. There's a pattern in this series, where all the male characters are made less adequate even someone as powerful as J'onn J'onns, had to be saved by a woman. Another example, the fight with Non, who literally stood still and let supergirl beat the snot out of him, it's kid stuff, when you have to handicap one character to make the other look superior. Lol

    • @jeremiahthepisces5493
      @jeremiahthepisces5493 5 лет назад +2

      Right the man Hunter is so overpowered probably other then bat man and Superman man Hunter could take out the whole Justice league...in the show it's like he is weak

    • @Fazzel
      @Fazzel 5 лет назад +1

      @@jeremiahthepisces5493 -- He defeated red kryptonite Supergirl.

  • @ChrisontopW
    @ChrisontopW 4 года назад

    Gay Kara baby it's okay Lord alex