The illusion of matter and why people get it so wrong

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 64

  • @birthing4blokes46
    @birthing4blokes46 2 месяца назад +5

    The explanation given at the beginning makes obvious sense. Thank you for this great video. 'Who is the one who makes the grass green'?

    • @theeastman9136
      @theeastman9136 2 месяца назад +1

      The one whose eyes can perceive "greenness" and no one else.

    • @meyerdude
      @meyerdude 2 месяца назад

      Green? Your grass is green?☯☯☯☯

    • @holgerjrgensen2166
      @holgerjrgensen2166 2 месяца назад

      @@theeastman9136 Yaeh, Short and Sharp,
      our Sensing-Organs is Motion, the Sensing
      is Motion, and the grass is Motion.
      wave-lenght, mirror-effect, and other,
      our Consciousness is 100% electric

    • @danielboomers
      @danielboomers Месяц назад

      has just one major problem:::rupert: there is only one reality. been proven wrong by 3 Nobel prize winner.

  • @leemysliwiec2803
    @leemysliwiec2803 2 месяца назад +1

    Yes... He put it so well...

  • @MaartendeJager
    @MaartendeJager 2 месяца назад +2

    All that matters is it only appears when observed.

    • @doriesse824
      @doriesse824 21 день назад +1

      How do people bump into things in the dark?

  • @rickmolchan3421
    @rickmolchan3421 2 месяца назад +1

    I was amazed to learn that humans can only perceive 1% of the light, sound and scent spectrum.

  • @prtauvers
    @prtauvers 2 месяца назад +1

    A photo of the pen shows what our senses sense…is the photo conscious too?

  • @artdadamo3501
    @artdadamo3501 2 месяца назад +2

    Related: 82 - Materialism and Some Alternatives ruclips.net/video/1mW3nrQEJ8A/видео.html

  • @alexdetrojan4534
    @alexdetrojan4534 2 месяца назад +1

    Samkhya philosophy posits both matter and Consciousness. Matter manifests when consciousness is applied to it. Neoplatonists, particularily Plotinus say there is the One and the apparent many. That 'what is' eminates from the One or the Good, emanating further and further from the immaterial One, until it reaches a stage where it is so far from the One, that it manifests into materiality. Parmenides(even before the the rishis in India) postulated that there was only the One and the apparent many, yet everything was a Unity contained in the One, including materiality. These examples for context.

    • @MikeWiest
      @MikeWiest 2 месяца назад +1

      That’s more useful than denying physical reality. Spinoza also has a similar view but also affirms physical reality and basically proves you can’t make mind out of matter or vice versa, which is what these idealists are trying to do

    • @MikeWiest
      @MikeWiest 2 месяца назад +1

      Giordano Bruno is another in that line who derive everything from the original unity. His book Cause, Principle, and Unity is really cool.

  • @dommccaffry3802
    @dommccaffry3802 2 месяца назад +1

    Sadly , having engaged in this nondual approach for several years, i have come to realise that it has made me less happy and more miserable; maybe its time to face up to that, and give up.

    • @IAmSimonMundie
      @IAmSimonMundie  2 месяца назад

      Sorry to hear that. In what way has it made you more unhappy?

    • @warriorpoet9629
      @warriorpoet9629 2 месяца назад

      I relate.

    • @valuemastery
      @valuemastery 2 месяца назад +1

      It's the contrary for me. Realizing that the world is not just particles bouncing around, but consciousness is ultimately real, lifts me up every time I am aware of it. The world feels more real to me.

    • @harvey1126
      @harvey1126 2 месяца назад

      Why are you seeking happiness?

    • @warriorpoet9629
      @warriorpoet9629 2 месяца назад +1

      @@harvey1126 because it beats sadness hands down.

  • @KeithNagel
    @KeithNagel Месяц назад +1

    Close your eyes: now with the aid of this large rock, I will introduce you to the concept of mass and kinetic energy... but keep your eyes closed, we want to prove that these things exist outside of your consciousness! If you lose consciousness briefly, don't panic, this is part of the initiation.

    • @IAmSimonMundie
      @IAmSimonMundie  Месяц назад

      When you fall unconscious at night, do you ever remain conscious, but only of your dreams?

    • @KeithNagel
      @KeithNagel Месяц назад

      @@IAmSimonMundie If by that you mean, have I ever had what's called a lucid dream? If so, yes. I did experiment with this some years ago. Why?

  • @kricketflyd111
    @kricketflyd111 Месяц назад

    I want to imagine crying 😂

  • @lowersaxon
    @lowersaxon 2 месяца назад +2

    Incredible statement. Pure Solipsism. He thinks that if all conscious beings are gone then Earth, Moon and Mars would equally be gone. Out.

    • @davidflahou3206
      @davidflahou3206 2 месяца назад +1

      Not at all, Rupert answered that 1000 times. If you’re really curious try not to jump onto conclusion instantly and do more research. Maybe there is more to it 😉

    • @JanSaevebek
      @JanSaevebek 2 месяца назад

      No, those things would still exist in infinite consciousness. That's how I understand it.

    • @Paul-vm9sz
      @Paul-vm9sz 2 месяца назад +3

      Well he is right. If there is no consciousness there is nothing to be conscious of. He’s in good company as well because these were the same points made by Albert Einstein and Max Planck so this is nothing new.

    • @valuemastery
      @valuemastery 2 месяца назад +1

      No, that's not at all what he's saying. The *appearance* of those things would ge gone, not the things themselves. They'd still be in universal consciousness, independent of any finite minds watching them.

    • @Paul-vm9sz
      @Paul-vm9sz 2 месяца назад +3

      @@valuemastery The things themselves are being “dreamed” into reality…. remove the dreamer and you remove the illusion of the “things”.

  • @Paulus_Brent
    @Paulus_Brent 2 месяца назад +1

    Kant's noumenon vs. phenomenon?

    • @MikeWiest
      @MikeWiest 2 месяца назад

      Yes. Ie nothing new

  • @esneliamunoz5082
    @esneliamunoz5082 2 месяца назад

    🕉🕉🕉

  • @holgerjrgensen2166
    @holgerjrgensen2166 2 месяца назад

    Life and our Over-Consciousness is Eternal,
    pictured in Rainbow, (the Cause-Less Cause)
    The Life-Desire is the First Force, in direct
    extension We have Will, Life-side, and Gravity
    Stuff-side.
    Our Day-Consciousness, stream of Thoughts,
    and physical reality, is Motion, part of the
    Motion-Ocean, Stuff-side of Life, so matter
    is not just an illusion, it is a Real Illusion,
    the Only way, the Eternal Life can Perform,
    Experience, Develop and Re-New its Eternal
    Consciousness.
    D. Hoffmann's main-focus is at the way We
    Sense and Perceive reality.
    Feeling (Yellow) is one of our Etenal Abilities,
    Contrast-Princip and Perspective-Princip,
    make Feeling into Sensing. All experiences
    is Feeling-Experience, First Hand.
    Intelligence (Green) means Logic and Order,
    Perspective-Princip means all relations relationship,
    Intelligence + Perspective-Princip = Mathematic.
    Walter Russell is the First physicist, as explain
    the Stuff-side in a Eternal Perspective.
    It is a very extensive study to explain the
    Eternal World Picture, in details, it need some
    basic experience, and not everyone is ready,
    but it exist.

    • @meyerdude
      @meyerdude 2 месяца назад

      Rainbows? R U high?

    • @holgerjrgensen2166
      @holgerjrgensen2166 2 месяца назад

      Rainbow picture our Eternal Over-Consciousness, Colors our Under-Consciousness = Day-Consciousness and Night-Consciousness.
      Red, Orange, Yellow, Green, Blue, Indigo
      Instinct, Gravity, Feeling, Intelligence, Intuition, Memory.
      We are Gravity-Beings, at Night We move
      our Day-Consciousness to the Night-
      Bodies Deep-Sleep, one by one via our
      Coupling-Body REM-sleep.
      Day/Night-Circuit is a Body-Circuit,
      our physical body, is a Organ-Circuit.
      'Colors' in the Body-Circuit correspond
      with the 'Colors' in our Organ-circuit,
      restoring, hormon-production and more.
      We find the same Eternal Abilities in this
      Device, in a technical composition.
      Automatic, Power, Sensors, Logic/Order
      (*), Harddisc, - *Intuition needs more text to
      explain.
      I had the un-expected experience of being Eternal 40 years ago, and studied the most complete knowledge about the Eternal Life
      and Consciousness, since then.
      At that time no body knew about how the
      smart devices would be a granted reality.

    • @woundedsoulhealer2652
      @woundedsoulhealer2652 2 месяца назад

      @@holgerjrgensen2166Smart devices being granted reality , humm 🤔 you got my intention…
      Care to elaborate ?🤷‍♀️

    • @holgerjrgensen2166
      @holgerjrgensen2166 2 месяца назад

      Even in the time of radio-waves,
      wire-less phones was unthinkable,
      but now adays the digital reality,
      is 'naturely', granted.
      The relatively few people who know
      that rainbow picture Consciousness,
      may not have recognized that it is the
      same Abilities, in technical composition
      as make the smart devices work so well.

  • @danielpaulson8838
    @danielpaulson8838 Месяц назад

    Rupert is super nice. But he teaches like Deepak Chopra.

  • @philipwaring6483
    @philipwaring6483 2 месяца назад

    But who created the 🖊️, and why can't we walk through walls?

  • @chiptowers1
    @chiptowers1 2 месяца назад

    If no one has never found how consciousness is generated from matter, then that alone would mean consciousness does not exist in matter, matter being solid, liquid and gas. Prior to matter itself there is no consciousness and following matter then matter to plasma, there is still no consciousness because matter into plasma is just a random reaction and random means " done without conscious decision," because random reactions do not require to survive ie the Universe does not require to survive, therefore their is no consciousness attached to the Universe nor does the Universe need to Evolve for a purpose, therefore the universe does not implement the consciousness tool. That would be impossible anyway because the Universe does not have a Host. Unlike the intelligent species who has its FORM source and it's BORN biology, both in a symbiotic relationship.
    Reality couldn't care less what someone perceives nor their state of consciousness.
    Matter cannot be an illusion because consciousness requires matter to implement the consciousness tool for consciousness to be aware that it was implemented by matter, in particular when required by a Formulae Form for survival and Evolving, not random events. Would you think thats a coincidence.

  • @karlwest437
    @karlwest437 2 месяца назад +1

    A lot of words to say very little

    • @MindVersusMisery
      @MindVersusMisery 2 месяца назад +3

      I disagree.
      What Rupert speaks of here dismantle all we ever thought was real, and opens up for the possibility of reality being other than physical.
      How can that be "very little"?

    • @LianaMarvel
      @LianaMarvel 2 месяца назад +2

      Yes, to those who can't grasp the meaning of what he says.

    • @karlwest437
      @karlwest437 2 месяца назад +1

      @@LianaMarvel he's saying that consciousness is primary and what we perceive as reality is actually an illusion created by consciousness, is that close enough?

    • @LianaMarvel
      @LianaMarvel 2 месяца назад +1

      @@karlwest437 perfectly logical to me since it's the model that best explains the world.
      Just my 2 cents.

    • @karlwest437
      @karlwest437 2 месяца назад +1

      @@LianaMarvel I'll stick with empirically testable quantum mechanics rather than piling on some mystical mumbo jumbo but you do you

  • @rodkeh
    @rodkeh 2 месяца назад

    I don't know when I've heard more idiotic nonsense! What drivel!

    • @valuemastery
      @valuemastery 2 месяца назад +1

      I understand it appears that way, especially when you're confronted with it for the first time. As a scientist and physicist I reacted the same way at first. But the more I study it and compare it with the findings of quantum field theory and relativity, the more I see the parallels and ultimately have to agree.

  • @danielboomers
    @danielboomers Месяц назад

    rupert: there is only one reality. ohh rupert try again...