Joel Klatt breaks down the spring transfer portal window & how to fix it | Joel Klatt Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 апр 2024
- Joel Klatt broke down the spring transfer portal opening on April 16th. He explained how this upcoming transfer portal window is different from other years. Joel analyzed how NIL has affected the transfer window, how players are utilizing this to their advantage and how coaches are reacting to the upcoming window. Then, he explained how he would fix the spring transfer portal window.
#TheJoelKlattShow #CFB #TransferPortal
SUBSCRIBE to get the latest Joel Klatt Show content:
rb.gy/7sbi9
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4uouolb
►The Joel Klatt Show RUclips Channel: bit.ly/joelklattshow_yt
►PBC ON FOX’s RUclips Channel: foxs.pt/SubscribePBCONFOX
►WWE ON FOX RUclips channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeWWEONFOX
►FOX Soccer’s RUclips channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeFOXSOCCER
►NASCAR ON FOX RUclips channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeNASCARonFOX
►CFB ON FOX RUclips channel: foxs.pt/SubscribeCFBonFOX
See more from The Joel Klatt Show: www.foxsports.com/shows/the-j...
Like The Joel Klatt Show on Facebook: / joelklattshow
Follow The Joel Klatt Show on Twitter: / joelklattshow
Follow The Joel Klatt Show on Instagram: / joelklattshow
Joel Klatt breaks down the spring transfer portal window & how to fix it | Joel Klatt Show
• Joel Klatt breaks down... 
Спорт
![[FREE] 2024 HARD BOOM BAP TYPE BEAT - SWEET AND SOUND](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jo940rirygw/mqdefault.jpg)
Joel has his thinking cap on. lol. I think this is a great idea. Collective bargaining is a scary word. But I think it is needed in this case.
Wish I knew how to follow Joel Klatt. I think he has a wonderful football mind. I do believe he would make a great coach,but he's awesome just with his knowledge. He's one of those things we sometimes call goats at what they do for a living. He really is!!!
NCAA, coaches & athletic directors refused to compensate players fairly for 50 years! It finally caught up with them.
I don't think the athletes were being fairly compensated even in 1974.
Really? A free education and free room and board seems like very fair compensation to me.
@@turdferguson12 I'm sure it does. The school makes millions and the kid gets his "free education and free room and board" taken away when he gets hurt. Then he gets to pay for his medical bills for the rest of his life and he has to get a job with no education. I have no doubt you think that is a fair deal.
Would like to see the Big 10 And the SEC make out for lost times
You can bet your sweet bippy he does.
teams in the south are gonna have "spring" football before northern teams for most part due to WEATHER cant expect them to have them at the same time smdh
Big schools have indoor practice fields
@@joshuagarner1654indoors don’t seat 70,000
The Joel Klatt Show: A College Football Podcast, I liked this video because it's awesome!
Collectively bargain and turn scholarships into contracts, as independent contractors. The elephant in the room is the conferences only care about themselves, and not college football in general. All this revenue distribution needs to include change to three divisions, instead of P5 and G5. CFB is almost there with the consolidation of the $EC and B1G.
Joel...entering the transfer portal, the student athlete still has to be picked up by a new program correct? You can enter the portal and not get picked up and just sit there possible thru the next season.? So they take a chance of not getting an offer and then be in Limbo. Choices!!!
Exactly!!!
I understand limiting the transfer portal, but don't confuse or mix up lack of opportunity to play with lack of ability to endure adversity. At your Ala, GA or OH St. they have a line of QBs who are just as talented as the next guy who just will never play simply due to timing, not talent or lack of work ethic. Look at Justin Fields and Jalen Hurts. Had they stayed at their original school, they probably don't get drafted.
Fantastic points!
I like the two transfers but need to give them eligibility increased by a year like 5 year eligibility. However college and college benefits need to be guaranteed so if someone says 200k but you get injured career over they need to lock in those funds by the school for all eligible years. That’s includes housing, meal plans etc… if your going for o out limits on transferring need to increase commitments from the schools.
So when Saban for example, took 2nd year players scholarships and made them transfer, was that enabling them to reach their potential or enabling him to bring in what he perceived as a better player?
Portal will make college a more leveled playing field. Those SEC and Big 10 backups will be starters at other places which is a good thing. Eventually if coaches want to win they will have to develop those 3s into useful 2s..
No it won't. The same teams will keep winning the titles, and they will get a lot of the best players in the portal.
Allowed to enter portal once without any penalties. Second time entering portal will cause you to sit out one year. That's it.....
This what the sport wants, so they get what they deserve.
Will they fix coaches being able to release players just because they signed someone else?
No
That comes with being employees. Any other pro league has cuts. Nature of the beast.
@@valantheflame0193 So coaches can release players but the players can't release the school/coach? That is as un-American as you can get.
@@BigMilt8 Then tell that to the NFL.
@@valantheflame0193 Exactly my point. NFL is a professional league where contracts are involved (Side Note: The NFL has the worse CBA of all the major sports. It is atrocious, but that is a different discussion). If a player is released, there are monetary issues that must be handled. Not the same in CFB. Coaches can release a player at will without any repercussions (ex., paying out scholarship). If a coach/school had to payout a kids scholarship then that would definitely alter the landscape. Truthfully, players should be treated like regular students. The Fine Arts major that is composing a symphony or painting has more power then the athletes. They have the freedom to move to whatever school whenever they wish.
How do you find the middle of you don’t swing it back to the other side. Now you can find the middle, which I agree needs and will happen
I get that things are chaos, but man I can’t help but laugh at how so many people are coming up with really well thought out ideas for changes… once the power has shifted, and a big name coach complains.
I also like the fear of making the workers employees. You sound like Uber. It would be so chaotic if we had to follow state employment laws! Jeez, how does nearly every business in America pull it off? It’s crazy that so many businesses can manage to follow labor laws.
I also love how coaches have buyout clauses, but then Saban is saying it isn’t good for kids not to be committed. If that is the case, I guess all of these coaches just aren’t willing to grow as a person. If coaches can have buyouts, players should get them too.
If this is going to be fair, hold coaches to the same standards. Either they give up their buyout clauses, and they really show us how committed they are, or the players also get them.
Ha! Fantastic but the coaches are his friends. So it would be ok for them to "be their best" somewhere else.
They need to do the super league. Bring aome stability to the sport.
Two transfers with no penalty wouldn’t make kids more committed. It also still allows smaller programs to be drained of all talent.
asking fsu and colorado to have the same spring football schedule would be flat out wrong
Why is that even a little bit wrong? Let alone “flat out wrong?”
@brandonl2555 because a southern team is going to have early ish spring training before weather gets too hot...northern teams are generally going to look for a warmer time to get out of sub freezing temps
@@seanmanahan477 on a scale of 1 to “flat out wrong”…at worst that barely registers as mildly inconvenient. 🙄
Or are you going to try and claim that it’s flat out wrong for the packers and dolphins to be on the same offseason schedule within a day or 2? It is such a minor issue when compared to the transfer portal issues.
@brandonl2555 in nfl they don't have the outside practices in march..not same as college schedules
@@seanmanahan477 …yeah that’s just not true. Several nfl teams hold camps at outdoor practice facilities, and a significant portion of div 1 schools have both outdoor and indoor practice facilities. It’s a non issue
Im on board with the graduate transfer but that is it. Also the kids should get a monthly stipend of about $500 across the board. Every player, every sport, every school. That’s it! They are already getting a free education and free room and board. These are students, not professional athletes!!!
Exactly! The head football coach of the college deserves and in my opinion NEEDS to be the highest paid employee in the entire state. That shows respect. But you can't pay him that much if you pay the inmates to run the asylum.
JK is right, unfortunately the genie is out the lamp and it doesn't want to go back in. Fan interest in CFB will be dead inside of 20 years imo.
This NIL stuff is getting so exhausting and boring. Find a solution asap! Need contracts in place!
Scholarships have always only been 1 year contracts
@@joshuagarner1654 lmfaooo yea whatever you say. Schools are paying more than other schools. Joe literally just said thats the biggest reason.Has nothing to do with scholarships its all about money.Put 1-2 year contracts in place or even 3 depending on how much the NIL deal is worth.
Contracts wouldn't stop nil. No union is going agree to a contract that prevents them from making money off their own name , image and likeness
Just have one transfer portal
Shouldn't the kids be able to transfer if the coach quits, gets fired, or takes a new job. Shouldn't the kid also be able to transfer if he has a family crisis?
wrong klatt. get rid of the other two windows, and have one windown DURING spring practice. I think times when your not practicing, your mind tens to wonder more(what re the other possibilities) vs when your live practicing your more focused on the team. then, at the end of spring, have a legit scrimmage against your biggest or one of your rivals. like, wouldnt it be sweet, having a bunch of new players, and then having ala vs aub. or mich vs ohio st. during the spring? it would also addd strategy for coaches. get these analysts up off the sidelines
They need to only allow one transfer per four years of eligibility
Why?
Open gambling and TV profits have ruined College Football. Excellent plan to fix it! But Head coaches can't just jump schools as well.
The coaches are his friends, of course they can leave whenever they want. It's their job, you can't make someone stay at their job.
Transfer portal shouldn't happen until May 15.
TV revenue is so imbalanced, tour revenue sharing makes the player-rich teams even better. The rich get richer. 👎
SKIP
Horrible, the athletes would need to unionize to do anything he says. He also doesn't mention his "friends" the coaches honoring their contracts.
Not a soul is beating OSU’s NIL fund rn
The Charmin’s have no Soul , just cash no Class ! Big Black & Blue be coming yes 👍 they be coming!
I'm all for the players getting paid. But at this rate, college football's not gonna be worth watching. For the reasons we used to like it. Also the NFL operates in multiple states
You guys petition for players to get paid, cool, you guys championed players being able to call the shots, cool…….🗣️LITERALLY EVERYONE ELSE WAS TELLING YOU THIS WOULD BECOME A PROBLEM!!!…….now you think you’re going to back track and tell some kids who are making more than coaches, and some kids who can come and go as they please that they can’t do it anymore?????😂😂😂😂……this was a stupid idea from jump, no one in media had the balls to say it though, now we’re here, deal with it, deal with the 19 year old diva QB making low 7 figures telling you he doesn’t feel like playing a rivalry game because it doesn’t benefit him so he can “load manage” now
The schools currently have no motivation to change. This is best case scenario for them. They get to take in all the booster revenue and TV revenue and dont have to pay the players. They became the biggest benefactor of this so its going to be hard to knock them off this gravy train.
To me you allow people to transfer 1 time during career that is it. Now if you want to transfer more then you loose eligibility...meaning you can transfer to get degree but not to play sports. It is silly as now a person could transfer every year....this is insane. Let them do it once...maybe they are struggling in classes, or move closer to home, or maybe to get more playing time. They get 1 time to change their minds on a school to play sports. Now if you want to transfer like a non athlete...go ahead!! But to play sports is a privilege not a right.
There can't be tampering?! Hahahaha!!! There is nothing but tampering. UW was talking to wsu players after the apple cup. Multiple players that left the previous season were contacted before they were in the portal.
I like the system. Power to the players ! A lot of these kids come from nothing and won't play in the NFL . Let's start putting rules and salary caps on the coaches and see how that goes .
Great idea let’s wait another 50 years like they waited the first time.
Its killing HS football!!🤦♂️
College football has now become which boosters can afford the most players. These players are KIDS!! They haven't even learned how to use & balance this money! It's unreal. Nurses, doctors & other essential workers need money like this & actually save lives. This is asinine and teaching greed to kids
This guy's the regulator of the ncaa and nil? HA! What a clown.
It's pro ball....NFL minus. If you want to watch real college football, you just watch the Service Academies and some Ivy League.
There still is a developmental aspect to college football.
Yeah... I wasn't really into the spring game stuff... Please label what you're going to outline besides saying "more." I want to give you my view count.
College football is broken. Nick Saban retired because of it. There is no fixing it.
Lol he retired because he couldn't get every single great player, sorry other colleges have a chance now. No sympathy for saban he dominated for long enough.
@@PunkyBoyGWiz Nick Saban said he was to meet a highschool recruit in his office, and only the players agent showed up. Not the player. That was it for him.
@@cleroyster2610 of course he's gonna say that, that doesn't mean it's true. He also complained about other coaches like deion sanders and Jimbo Fisher recruiting players.
@@PunkyBoyGWiz must be an Auburn fan. Lol
Slick Nick retired because he didn’t want to share the power (money) with the kids. Its ok for the coach to go from school to school without repercussions but its a problem when the players get to do it. Revenue share is the next step in the NEW EVOLUTION of College athletics. Get on board or RETIRE!
Get rid of it! It is ludicrous to have to recruit the same players over and over again
What's wrong with 'free agency' as you put it? Ever heard of capitalism, ever heard of freedom? Is anyone stupid enough to think that if they put in any 'guardrails' on the portal, that those rules will be written to benefit players? I say, let the system alone. Let players and school negotiate freely, and sign contracts that are mutually beneficial. I blows my mind that anyone could be against this idea.
As it collapses
Allowing a player to sign a multi-year, no portal access contract would collapse college football? They wheeled out the same lame arguments against free agency for pro sports, and the opposite happened. A CBA might work, but how will this happen with so many State schools with their own laws to follow? What if Alabama law forbids a certain clause? 50 different CBAa?
They need multi year contracts to give the smaller schools a chance at retaining talent. We are on track to turn 70% of the schools, including some in the B1G and SEC, into farms.
Agreed - if the player and the school want that. Soon, the schools will realize that giving a player money with no contract or portal limits is stupid. The situation will sort it self out - that's my point. Pay the kids who have leverage. The rest will go on as usual. I don't see the downside - except if you are a school that wants to keep their money. I promise you that any rules will be written by the schools to benefit themselves.
Unregulated capitalism is never fair to anyone.