Lynyrd Skynyrd was wrong. The South needed Neil Young and a portion of the South still needs him now to remind them to follow the good book, and not racist hate.
Am I the only one who tears up as SOON as they start singing? Man I almost have a religious experience when I watch them ,I have been that way EVER since I first heard them as a 4year old and I am 55 now and still feel that way about them ,I LOVE them TOGETHER or separate it doesn't MATTER to me 🙏😥😍✌👍😁❣🌹💜
The reality of this song, especially during this virus & many other signs of the times, shows just how history repeats itself, over & over!!! It can be so beautiful & harsh all in the same dimension! ❤ God Bless the music & words of many a generation!!! The best of the best!!! 💜💛💙❤CSN&Y....Rock on...
never wonder never ask why, just sit in amazement, cherish the the time spent together lay down your hatred and never say goodbye, live the day as they soon will be washed away.
Yes Yes I Too Grew Up Listening To There Music Back in The 70’s Being 59 Now Nothing There Has Changed!,,,, “I’m Still Listening “ ‼️🎹🎼🎹🎼🎹🎼🎹🎼‼️So Glad These Boy’s Got Together ‼️🎼🎹🎼‼️🎼🎹🎹🎼‼️
Are you THE John Lenihan who came from Santa Cruz to Marion Montana to Kalispell bartending? Could there be more than one? It's been 5 years since you posted BUT, on 8/20/20, I'm willing to chance reaching you! Would be a hella homecoming. Back in Cruz since 1986...Much love and blessings to you John...Meg Young email...megy796@gmail.com
I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU GUYS FOREVER!!!!! 🌅🎆🎆😘💖🌟💓💓👏!! I HEARD THAT NEIL YOUNG HAS A BRAIN ANOROISM IN HIS BRAIN 😭GOD BLESS YOU NEIL 🎆🌹I WANT TO GET THE ALBUMS IF CROSBY,STILLS,NASH AND YOUNG 💜 BUT MOST OF ALL NEIL,I WANT ALL OF YOUR MUSIC 🎶 SOLO 🎶🌟!!!!!! 🎆😲💓😊😃⭐😁👏🎆💜!!! THANKYOU FOR ALL THE GIFTS YOU'VE SENT ME, YOURSELF AND YOUR MUSIC 🎵!!(I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU FOREVER ☺️ YOUR ARE A SPECIAL GIFT FROM GOD🎆💗🌅🌟✨GOD BLESS YOU!!!!! I'M PRAYING FOR YOU TO GET WELL SOON😘! YOUR LOVING, GRATEFUL AND ALWAYS FRIEND 💓 RACH
I’m 64 years old and still listen to music 50- 60 years ago. We have 5 children and 12 grandchildren that love it! You can’t make it up, good music is just good music
He was a true talent . Even though he was a drunk and drug addict, his voice stayed ok. He found new hobbies after he cleaned up, but never gave up on sailing. Stills was always a closet-Conservative, Nash and Crosby had political positions on both sides and Neil Young was always sympathetic to the communist agenda. Despite all of the differences and difficulties, the always managed to create beautiful music.
🌹This is when music made sense.❤️🔥I was introduced to Neil Young first, my eldest of 5 Sisters received a 12-string for her 18th birthday and she taught me how to play. The first song I learned to play by Neil Young was "Sugar Mountain" and I still play it 40 years later. I was then introduced to "CSNY" and they stolen my heart. My Sister who taught me to play died of brain cancer, it took her within 9 months. I didn't want to cry today, but here I go again! I helplessly hope for a better tomorrow. 🇨🇦✌🏻🎶❤️🇺🇸✨🌎💫
She, like the music she introduced you to, is still alive and well inside Your Heart..... One Day You will join her, and side by side, Your energy will spread through all that You Both Touched. A Peaceful, Happy, and Healthy New Years to You and Your whole Family!!!!!
@@jgarcia1ful 🎄Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you as well Mr. Haley. I look forward to listening to the Angels Choir. 🌹Thank you for your kind reply.
An 18 year old sister could do no better than to teach a Neil young song, a present that lasts a life time. I wish you a better tomorrow - I wish us all a better tomorrow.
@@jeff2408 I am so saddened about the loss of💔David Crosby (19.01.2023) but know he suffers no longer, like my big🎸Sis. My big Sis was probably waiting at the gates for Croz and must've lead him to the🕊Angels Choir and is🎸jamming in the foreverafter as we reply. 🌹Thank you.
❤🎉❤For over 50 years I have loved this band! It was an absolute treat to see all 4 in concert one time at the United Center in Chicago - their harmony is absolutely beautiful ❤️❤️❤️❤️ Love you guys & miss you David! Your music will stay in our hearts 💕❤️ 💕
I was about that same age 14 or 15 years old. My first true love and I both sang Carry On together with such joy. We both loved Crosby,Stills and Nash so much ! Still together at age 67 years young.
As was I, 15 yo. From the first time I heard that 1st album, it was unbelievable. In 2023, this concert is giving me the same feeling. 😂 Thank you, all four of you.
Wow southern man i was played with friends ~~ i was 20. Neil young thank you to post it . (Just for me here) 😄. Long time i don't see you. Hope a next time. David Crosby missing a lot RIP🙏 💗CSN&Y💗 Greetings from France .
When I was struggling to quiet my mind this morning and listen, I heard "Long Time Gone" in my head, so I came to RUclips and listened to a 2009 concert track with my arms raised and tears running down my face at the changes in my country over the last 5 years and all the heartache in the world. Music expresses my/our deepest thoughts and emotions, better than I can.
I truly found CSN&Y when I was like 14yrs old in 1975 0r 6. Have listened ever since then to them separately and apart. They go their separate ways but come together every once in a while still. Some of these onld recordings on RUclips and stuff are amazing. Four charismatic beautiful dynamic people. Fully chronicalled.
While I agree that their music is absolutely fantastic, I love them and their music. Many bands have in fact helped a multitude of many millions of people across the world. One such band would be Linkin Park, their music helped me, and many millions with me, through many hard times. Sadly their music couldn't save Chester Bennington, Linkin Parks lead singer. May your 2024 be fantastic my fellow music lover :)
These guys really exemplify the 1960's for me. The music takes me back to the peace and freedom movement, the hippies, Free Press, free concerts and all of the incredible love and communion we shared as a generation devoted changing the world.🐯
Well, some of our generation...at least some of the time! I'm seeing the old divisions trying to tear us apart and destroy the dream of humanity overcoming our differences and celebrating the potential that our variety has to create "a more perfect union"!
So sad to lose a great one, David Crosby - you will be missed! My fondness for CSNY goes back to HS in the 60's - loved them then, love them still. Thankful that I had the chance to see them in concert and meet them. RIP. I can hear your sweet harmonies - 'lay your body down'...
I'm russian and so much love only SLAYER , but for me CSNY is real american music. And it's an awesome band - from the word "shock" with the vocal polyphony and wonderful harmony of three acoustic guitars that these guys have achieved. For some reason, this group is rarely mentioned by the music media, but these are truly legends of rock music who have not changed their worldview, despite the many musical trends that have arisen over 50 years. This band is not even a planet, it is a star whose rays have spread in all directions of rock! Great grandfathers!
I began as a CSN fan, having rated Graham Nash so high in the Hollies (sorry he left but understand why!) but Young did add that extra element. Now - what, almost 50 years later, still the greatest music!
Am I the only one who tears up as SOON as they start singing? Man I almost have a religious experience when I watch them ,I have been that way EVER since I first heard them as a 4year old and I am 55 now and still feel that way about them ,I LOVE them TOGETHER or separate it doesn't MATTER to me 🙏😥😍✌👍😁❣🌹💜
David Crosby was and still is a enormous human for me since i was eleven in 71.He knew about life and the music he made went straight into my heart.Great man.Full respect
Exceptional Talent, Love this FANTASTIC CONCERT of the 4 Most Talented Group with AMAZING HARMONIES sung with Joy and Love! God Bless them all for their 'Harmonic Wonders' of the songs they gave to us that will endure forever! RIP David Crosby, thanks for sharing your Musical Gifts from God. There will Never be another group like this one!!
RIP David....my earliest rock and roll concerts...sweet summer nights and always a peaceful blast of a great time w my 3 besties at Garden State Art Center. A gentler world, where things made sense. Thanks so much for the memories
I was very lucky to see them in concert 3 times. I was born at the right time. Music today is not in the same world as this. Im 66 and very very lucky. 8 dollar cncerts on every weekend in iowa. Car load of friends with me.
I thought I knew or had heard EVERY CSNY song but dang!…this amazing album proves me wrong! I’ve loved them since at least 1970 and here I am, at 70 years of age, discovering new-to-me gems and it’s almost like being back in 1970 again…what a gift music is and CSNY’s harmonies in particular.
THIS IS THE CSNY I FELL IN LOVE WITH AS A LITTLE HIPPIE CHICK CHILD who is now 55 and THIS is the BEST I have heard in a long time, THANKS for THIS ✌👍💜❣😁🙂😎
Woke up the other morning and "find The cost of freedom" randomly popped into my mind I couldn't believe it I don't know where it came from. These guys were one of kind and as a kid I grew up listening to their amazing harmonies, to this day I can't get over this band
My goodness I’m so happy to c this live show I can hardly believe it ? I’m so elated ! ♥️🐰🐇🌹☠️💀⚡️🕊️🪽😇😢😥😰💥🌟👽🪐🛸🚀⭐️✨🌙💫🔥💥🌟to all the fans out there with much love ! Music is what we all need all the time !
I am 69 and from the Bay Area, we had the most badass musical groups, Journey for one. Crosby,still, Nashville and Young are so awesome and still listen to them
I was at this show, it was wonderful! Encore was: CSN&Y, Bob Dylan, Jerry G. & Bob W, Nils Lofgren, Tom Petty, and Tracy Chapman, all doing a couple Dead tunes, wow!
@@tinamanukyan1742, yeah I hear ya, miss those days too and pray for their return. In the mean time we always have the good music to remind us, thank goodness.
one of the greatest rock groups ever put together i can listen to there music day and night i used to sing a bit and i love to harmonize with them any time they do a show any one of them i love to go but i have lots of cds to keep me going
Three acoustical guitars, four distinctive voices and their insight to communicate is deeply missed. My young son went to bed each night listening to these guys after me reading stories and singing Some Where Over the Rainbow.
The BEST that came out of the 20th century !!!! Always in my mind when asked who was the Best. Really who else could it be and stood the test of time. A time when the music and lyrics were from the heart and ACTUALLY MEANT REAL SITUATIONS and of the TIMES, AND STILL DOES !!!!!!!
I can't imagine the thought of losing one's home, livelihood & place where a family came together with the love of many year's for monies owed! This was when I was young & since found myself in just that situation! What a time to appreciate all that God had blessed me with throughout most of my lifetime! There are so many songs that reach each one of us written & sung by these masterful musicians of this time!!! God Bless "Farm Aid" & the Founding Father's of this lasting Endeavor!!! ❤❤❤❤!!!
You have such a profound impact on my career that even the biggest thank you text would fall shout to express my gratitude. Thanks for your support and the love shown stay safe ❤️❤️❤️
Crecí escuchando grupazos de los 60 y 70 como estos venerables Maestros, de mis favoritos entre todas las buenas corrientes del rock; CSN&Y, mis favoritos entre una cantidad increíble de excelentes bandas y solistas de aquella época irrepetible y de altísima calidad lírica y musical, el virtuosismos era la carta de presentación de la música en la Era de Acuario...!!
These geniuses, separately and together have sung me through the years. Unparalleled musical talent has accompanied those of us of a certain age and we have enjoyed an uncountable richness of blessings.
yes ! dont know about the blessings , still single , still not enough money, many years of productive satisfying work, animals are ok (dogs , 20 year old goose and his family, water and lights paid, house paid, winters coming (( corona virus )) Etc . Lifes not too bad . Trying to get this music to the new generation.
So many years of adoring this amazing union of incredible artists, I was 16 when Deja Vu was released, this was the first time I heard CSN, it was 1970 and for some dumb reason I wasn't aware of them when they started in 1968. The song Teach was my favorite song on the album but soon I just loved every song on it. That was a long time ago and the time has gone so fast, I'll listen to this band's amazing music until I pass. Just love these guys.
First heard CSN&Y in 1969, haven't been the same since, with music that stands the test of time. Thanks so very much to each and every one of them for enlightening me along the way!
Love the one youre with. Is my csny favorite song with a very nice lyrics i used to sing with my guitar thank god am still alive at 73. 2023. Still enjoying their lifetime music i am a filipino fan of CSNY.
Back in the late 1970s I used to target Stephen Stills as an old phogey but he's really an underrated guitarist and I'm sorry I was so arrogant but I was only 19.
Why can we not have more Artists today, who can execute music in the most "Simplest" forms as these guys did!! Appreciative of Great Vocals, Acoustics and Lyrics!♥️
@@loufitzsimmons914 We do, but there is such easy access to music that is promoted. There are so many talented people who sing in local groups and have great talent, but it is much harder to keep their music in front of live audiences. Audiences are important to an individual artist's or a group's development. It has become much harder to make a profit from selling new music, also. Technology can be a double edged sword.
C S and N and Young.....was a group I saw as a young hippie on acid in the 60's.....instantly they were my favorite ....and many decades later I'm a 71 yr old widow mother and grandmother and great grandmother and I love them even more.....RIP Crosby❤❤😊😊😇😇
I’m sitting here in the parking lot of my job. I’m off at midnight and I’m watching this as I’m smoking a joint and tearing up, then I’m going home. This was when music was beautiful and made sense. Rest in peace David Crosby and thank you for all of your beautiful talent and voice.
This is beautifully performed including Graham whose voice seems far far better than wembley in 1974. Very polished and great to see the 4 of them with some really nice new tunes by Graham, Neil and crosby.
Oh, all the memories this concert conjures up..... I grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area and as most of this group lived in the Bay Area, they played all the time. I consider myself very lucky to have been able to hear them play live so many times. Does anyone else remember the concerts in Golden Gate Park and the Bill Graham Days on the Green @ the Oakland Coliseum? Those were the days my friend ❣️❣️❣️❣️. The joy and heart the filled the stadium with was everything..... 👏❤️👍😘 Nobody did Harmony like Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young did.
@@CooManTunes No, thanks. My state is not safe. I have family and friends that use for medicinal reasons - they are still subject to getting busted. I gave up all that when I discovered the Mafia had taken over. Besides, there is so much great music from that time! This music can bring back a high any time I want it.
Mind Blown! I saw David Crosby and Graham Nash perform - I think it was Halloween 1988 - but it was a smaller venue in Oakland - the name escapes me. My daughter was conceived on that night!!
I love these music moments after moving from Boulder, CO and seeing David outside a restaurant who saw my baby who now is 30 and a great artist you stood up and sent your Heart to us, I didn't say just cruised by peacefully, Bless the whole Band. Peace and Love!!!
And 4 yes later and puzzled at what I was thinking 4 yeas ago. I have ALWAYS loved Neil Young. Love the music of the 4, but love Neil Young the music and musician.
R.I.P David Crosby, your part of the prefect voice harmony will be strongly missed.
voice of our generation
Rest in peace David Crosby
😢😢😢😢😭😭😭
it will.
🫧😇🫶
Stephen sounds freaking AWESOME ,his voice is STRONG too like it was in the BEGINNING with THE BUFFALO ,MAN I LOVE THIS
Oh, yeah!
Crosby Stills Nash & Young; Never gets old, I'm 72 years young, still loving it. RIP Croz
Me 65❤
Lynyrd Skynyrd was wrong. The South needed Neil Young and a portion of the South still needs him now to remind them to follow the good book, and not racist hate.
Same here, I'll be 72 in January & NEVER tire of these fine musician's tunes!
How fortunate we all were to live in an era with such awesome music!!!!
The very best...
So do I. I love them since elementary school.They tell the feeling.
Am I the only one who tears up as SOON as they start singing? Man I almost have a religious experience when I watch them ,I have been that way EVER since I first heard them as a 4year old and I am 55 now and still feel that way about them ,I LOVE them TOGETHER or separate it doesn't MATTER to me 🙏😥😍✌👍😁❣🌹💜
The reality of this song, especially during this virus & many other signs of the times, shows just how history repeats itself, over & over!!! It can be so beautiful & harsh all in the same dimension! ❤ God Bless the music & words of many a generation!!! The best of the best!!!
💜💛💙❤CSN&Y....Rock on...
Hello 👋 kathy
how're you doing
Thanks for your love and support, you're an amazing fan! it's nice meeting you here
never wonder never ask why, just sit in amazement, cherish the the time spent together lay down your hatred and never say goodbye, live the day as they soon will be washed away.
Absolutely great live performance--rock on! And a bonus with Tracy Chapman at the end.
Yes Yes I Too Grew Up Listening To There Music Back in The 70’s Being 59 Now Nothing There Has Changed!,,,, “I’m Still Listening “ ‼️🎹🎼🎹🎼🎹🎼🎹🎼‼️So Glad These Boy’s Got Together ‼️🎼🎹🎼‼️🎼🎹🎹🎼‼️
great stuff!!!
Are you THE John Lenihan who came from Santa Cruz to Marion Montana to Kalispell bartending? Could there be more than one? It's been 5 years since you posted BUT, on 8/20/20, I'm willing to chance reaching you! Would be a hella homecoming. Back in Cruz since 1986...Much love and blessings to you John...Meg Young email...megy796@gmail.com
😢Nostalgia di quei giorni 😊😊😢🎉
I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU GUYS FOREVER!!!!! 🌅🎆🎆😘💖🌟💓💓👏!! I HEARD THAT NEIL YOUNG HAS A BRAIN ANOROISM IN HIS BRAIN 😭GOD BLESS YOU NEIL 🎆🌹I WANT TO GET THE ALBUMS IF CROSBY,STILLS,NASH AND YOUNG 💜 BUT MOST OF ALL NEIL,I WANT ALL OF YOUR MUSIC 🎶 SOLO 🎶🌟!!!!!! 🎆😲💓😊😃⭐😁👏🎆💜!!! THANKYOU FOR ALL THE GIFTS YOU'VE SENT ME, YOURSELF AND YOUR MUSIC 🎵!!(I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU FOREVER ☺️ YOUR ARE A SPECIAL GIFT FROM GOD🎆💗🌅🌟✨GOD BLESS YOU!!!!! I'M PRAYING FOR YOU TO GET WELL SOON😘! YOUR LOVING, GRATEFUL AND ALWAYS FRIEND 💓 RACH
Tell me what has happened to music of today when just a few mates a few guitars and legends are born.
I loved the GN ballard because I felt he put himself out on a limb. Was there a reason he didn't play guitar anywhere (and that is GN, isn't it?)
Is that Tracy Chapman singing teach your children?
I’m 64 years old and still listen to music 50- 60 years ago. We have 5 children and 12 grandchildren that love it! You can’t make it up, good music is just good music
Až slza ukapne je mi 70 pamatuju to jako dnes
It's the best ❤🎉
Yeah 65 here. We have been blessed in our time with some legendary artists.
To ja o 5 lat dłużej Ich słucham razem i osobno 👍👋👋👋- wielki ból po Davidzie 🥲
66
Always my favorite band with or without Neil ❤️❤️
R. I. P DAVID 🙏🏻❤️THANK YOU FOR THE MEMORIES
And music! ❤❤❤ 😢🎉🎉😊
He was a true talent . Even though he was a drunk and drug addict, his voice stayed ok.
He found new hobbies after he cleaned up, but never gave up on sailing.
Stills was always a closet-Conservative, Nash and Crosby had political positions on both sides and Neil Young was always sympathetic to the communist agenda.
Despite all of the differences and difficulties, the always managed to create beautiful music.
🌹This is when music made sense.❤️🔥I was introduced to Neil Young first, my eldest of 5 Sisters received a 12-string for her 18th birthday and she taught me how to play. The first song I learned to play by Neil Young was
"Sugar Mountain" and I still play it 40 years later. I was then introduced to "CSNY" and they stolen my heart. My Sister who taught me to play died of brain cancer, it took her within 9 months. I didn't want to cry today, but here I go again! I helplessly hope for a better tomorrow.
🇨🇦✌🏻🎶❤️🇺🇸✨🌎💫
AMEN Girl Hang In There And BELIVE 😅g
She, like the music she introduced you to, is still alive and well inside Your Heart..... One Day You will join her, and side by side, Your energy will spread through all that You Both Touched. A Peaceful, Happy, and Healthy New Years to You and Your whole Family!!!!!
@@jgarcia1ful
🎄Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you as well Mr. Haley. I look forward to listening to the Angels Choir.
🌹Thank you for your kind reply.
An 18 year old sister could do no better than to teach a Neil young song, a present that lasts a life time. I wish you a better tomorrow - I wish us all a better tomorrow.
@@jeff2408
I am so saddened about the loss of💔David Crosby (19.01.2023) but know he suffers no longer, like my big🎸Sis.
My big Sis was probably waiting at the gates for Croz and must've lead him to the🕊Angels Choir and is🎸jamming in the foreverafter as we reply.
🌹Thank you.
cant believe Crosby is gone. The world was much better with him in it.
My God what an era of music. Lyrics for generations. ❤
songs for eternity....
They are the legend & scientest of music, they are my idol of folk country jazz,. Ever.!
I can live with these with coffee in the morning and whiskey by the afternoon.❤️👌
Oh yeah 🔥💗
Agreed!!
thank you for posting this, at 66 my heart is young again listening/watching
☮️☮️☮️☮️🕊️🤍
❤🎉❤For over 50 years I have loved this band! It was an absolute treat to see all 4 in concert one time at the United Center in Chicago - their harmony is absolutely beautiful ❤️❤️❤️❤️ Love you guys & miss you David! Your music will stay in our hearts 💕❤️ 💕
I was 15 when I first heard Crosby Stills and Nash. I loved them. When they added Young, I was infatuated. They remain my all time favorite band.
I was also 15 hanging out with older hippies cutting high school.. Best memories of my life.
I was about that same age 14 or 15 years old. My first true love and I both sang Carry On together with such joy. We both loved Crosby,Stills and Nash so much ! Still together at age 67 years young.
As was I, 15 yo. From the first time I heard that 1st album, it was unbelievable. In 2023, this concert is giving me the same feeling. 😂 Thank you, all four of you.
MINE TOO
Favorite guys ever
Wow southern man i was played with friends ~~ i was 20. Neil young thank you to post it . (Just for me here) 😄. Long time i don't see you. Hope a next time. David Crosby missing a lot RIP🙏 💗CSN&Y💗
Greetings from France .
Just catching this concert for the first time on 8/11/2023. WHAT A TRULY ENJOYABLE PERFORMANCE !!!
When I was struggling to quiet my mind this morning and listen, I heard "Long Time Gone" in my head, so I came to RUclips and listened to a 2009 concert track with my arms raised and tears running down my face at the changes in my country over the last 5 years and all the heartache in the world. Music expresses my/our deepest thoughts and emotions, better than I can.
Amen.🙏
I was trying to ease my mind too and that is why I came to this video. You are so right. Music is very emotional and touches our hearts. ☮️💜
Amen and amen
@@jeffreyurbach6544 Hey, your family name is the same as the small village I grew up in in Germany: Urbach.
Agreed. Lost my only son last year..I do not recognize this world. It's not my world
I truly found CSN&Y when I was like 14yrs old in 1975 0r 6. Have listened ever since then to them separately and apart. They go their separate ways but come together every once in a while still. Some of these onld recordings on RUclips and stuff are amazing. Four charismatic beautiful dynamic people. Fully chronicalled.
Without doubt. These men made a difference in music, mankind and society. None have done so, before or since.
While I agree that their music is absolutely fantastic, I love them and their music.
Many bands have in fact helped a multitude of many millions of people across the world.
One such band would be Linkin Park, their music helped me, and many millions with me, through many hard times.
Sadly their music couldn't save Chester Bennington, Linkin Parks lead singer.
May your 2024 be fantastic my fellow music lover :)
Love that era of music 🎶😍🎉❤
That's a steaming pile of horse pudding
😅 rock🎉
there were others
These guys really exemplify the 1960's for me. The music takes me back to the peace and freedom movement, the hippies, Free Press, free concerts and all of the incredible love and communion we shared as a generation devoted changing the world.🐯
Well, some of our generation...at least some of the time! I'm seeing the old divisions trying to tear us apart and destroy the dream of humanity overcoming our differences and celebrating the potential that our variety has to create "a more perfect union"!
Wow The Free Press
Only to f it up as adults......
So sad to lose a great one, David Crosby - you will be missed! My fondness for CSNY goes back to HS in the 60's - loved them then, love them still. Thankful that I had the chance to see them in concert and meet them. RIP. I can hear your sweet harmonies - 'lay your body down'...
I’m with ya. I turn age 69 this year.
And the times , during which CSN was formed and became popular.
We lived it!! We loved it.. We were blessed ♥️
I still think about David, Tom Petty, Glen Frey, Gregg Allman and Mac (Dr. John) Rebennack Jr. every day !
Me, too. ❤
I'm russian and so much love only SLAYER , but for me CSNY is real american music. And it's an awesome band - from the word "shock" with the vocal polyphony and wonderful harmony of three acoustic guitars that these guys have achieved. For some reason, this group is rarely mentioned by the music media, but these are truly legends of rock music who have not changed their worldview, despite the many musical trends that have arisen over 50 years. This band is not even a planet, it is a star whose rays have spread in all directions of rock! Great grandfathers!
Nicely put . ✌️
Liked ur comment 😀 well put😊😊😊😊❤🎉
They were truly blessed at their first stage appearance by all the open hearts at Woodstock - can't explain better...
So true so true
...peace
Amen to that.
Love hearing Stills and Young play together. Great songs and harmony.
Do you ever wonder who had to pass on to make room for someone like Stephen Stills or Neil Young in this world?
Wonderful collaboration between the two great musicians, but also between the four of them
I began as a CSN fan, having rated Graham Nash so high in the Hollies (sorry he left but understand why!) but Young did add that extra element. Now - what, almost 50 years later, still the greatest music!
Am I the only one who tears up as SOON as they start singing? Man I almost have a religious experience when I watch them ,I have been that way EVER since I first heard them as a 4year old and I am 55 now and still feel that way about them ,I LOVE them TOGETHER or separate it doesn't MATTER to me 🙏😥😍✌👍😁❣🌹💜
No From Pittsburgh, PA Rock on and Live Free and Die Hard !!!!
At the age of 69 fast approaching 70, this music is still the best!
AMEN!
Ya mean like right now.....
God yes...love them...those voices in harmony
I appreciate their music and musicianship more and more.
RIP
David Crosby,
we lost a beautiful soul!!!
My all-time favorite band.... the harmony between these 4 men is like no others.
Its always a special treat to hear them. ❤
David Crosby was and still is a enormous human for me since i was eleven in 71.He knew about life and the music he made went straight into my heart.Great man.Full respect
❤in 1971 I was 11 also. I would listen to music on my transiter radio.went to my 1st concert when I was 12.
Exceptional Talent, Love this FANTASTIC CONCERT of the 4 Most Talented Group with AMAZING HARMONIES sung with Joy and Love! God Bless them all for their 'Harmonic Wonders' of the songs they gave to us that will endure forever! RIP David Crosby, thanks for sharing your Musical Gifts from God. There will Never be another group like this one!!
RIP David....my earliest rock and roll concerts...sweet summer nights and always a peaceful blast of a great time w my 3 besties at Garden State Art Center. A gentler world, where things made sense. Thanks so much for the memories
It's such a shame they didn't get together one more time. Legends one of a kind bands
I was very lucky to see them in concert 3 times. I was born at the right time. Music today is not in the same world as this. Im 66 and very very lucky. 8 dollar cncerts on every weekend in iowa. Car load of friends with me.
RIP David Crosby. The world is a little darker without you.
and there's another star on the night sky.
A legend gone- Rest in Peace Croz
I thought I knew or had heard EVERY CSNY song but dang!…this amazing album proves me wrong! I’ve loved them since at least 1970 and here I am, at 70 years of age, discovering new-to-me gems and it’s almost like being back in 1970 again…what a gift music is and CSNY’s harmonies in particular.
I’m also 70. The music is timeless. Brings me back to more hopeful times. Young, maybe naive about what we could change.
Birds sing, and how much better would the world be, if we all did the same.
I'm also 70 ( in a month). Loved these guys, but always think of my brother who passed away in '94. His favorite group was CSN&Y.
THIS IS THE CSNY I FELL IN LOVE WITH AS A LITTLE HIPPIE CHICK CHILD who is now 55 and THIS is the BEST I have heard in a long time, THANKS for THIS ✌👍💜❣😁🙂😎
Magic times. We all look back in great form. Those were the best years. Legends. ♥️
Woke up the other morning and "find The cost of freedom" randomly popped into my mind I couldn't believe it I don't know where it came from. These guys were one of kind and as a kid I grew up listening to their amazing harmonies, to this day I can't get over this band
True AND the BAND AMERICA Too 😁GREAT HAPPY SOULFUL Human !!!Songs 😅😅😅😅😅😅g
We may be gone, but the music will never die. All generations please embrace it !
Never Gone! Just transferred energy!
From one Gen to another....
Hope this old rock keeps A Turn n!
@@helloworldRR 💯% CORRECT. I apologize. Must be slipping a bit with the years ? 😄
R.I.P David Crosby
My goodness I’m so happy to c this live show I can hardly believe it ? I’m so elated ! ♥️🐰🐇🌹☠️💀⚡️🕊️🪽😇😢😥😰💥🌟👽🪐🛸🚀⭐️✨🌙💫🔥💥🌟to all the fans out there with much love ! Music is what we all need all the time !
I am 69 and from the Bay Area, we had the most badass musical groups, Journey for one. Crosby,still, Nashville and Young are so awesome and still listen to them
I was at this show, it was wonderful!
Encore was:
CSN&Y, Bob Dylan, Jerry G. & Bob W, Nils Lofgren, Tom Petty, and Tracy Chapman, all doing a couple Dead tunes, wow!
Wow sounds like one awesome 👍😎 encore. Not to mention show. Miss those days when the world made sense.
@@tinamanukyan1742, yeah I hear ya, miss those days too and pray for their return. In the mean time we always have the good music to remind us, thank goodness.
A string of individual and collective brilliance 🔥
Hey David - a whole generation is missing you ❤
He his always missi.g😅philo
73 and still rockin to these guys like i was back in the day
Same at 76..what an era.
Yep...and I was there that night.
Absolutely. Real music from 50+ years. And still love them
one of the greatest rock groups ever put together i can listen to there music day and night i used to sing a bit and i love to harmonize with them any time they do a show any one of them i love to go but i have lots of cds to keep me going
Love this! Stephen Stills on guitar...wow, and Neil's voice...wow! The four of them were magical together!
This group, together and individually sang me through some rough parts of my life...a southern girl
Nothing but DITTO!❤️
Me to. They still are.
💛👏🏻👏🏻🎶🎶🎶
Amen, me too. 🙏❤️
....who better to give solace...
Three acoustical guitars, four distinctive voices and their insight to communicate is deeply missed. My young son went to bed each night listening to these guys after me reading stories and singing Some Where Over the Rainbow.
They are just magical together.
When Neil joins them it feels like the whole family made it home for the holidays!
Right on...
1/2/20 CSN&Y~ Always the finest throughout my MANY years of life, love and loss. Thanks for music like theirs!
i LIKE what David Crosby once said "I dont care if there were 99 of us in CS&N we get chance to add Neil Young we do it!"
+Walter Green Word!
Where you from Walter?
+Walter Green Thanks for responding! I know a Walter Green in Louisiana!
Variety Connections truth! So true! Although PS the quote was 25 of us 🙏🏻
I know I heard that I felt exactly the same way 😁❤️❤️
I got goose bumps and cried this morning as the harmony of my childhood filled my house this morning, absolutely awesome, thx
Special musicians, singing special music, from a very special time. This is special!
The BEST that came out of the 20th century !!!! Always in my mind when asked who was the Best. Really who else could it be and stood the test of time. A time when the music and lyrics were from the heart and ACTUALLY MEANT REAL SITUATIONS and of the TIMES, AND STILL DOES !!!!!!!
I can't imagine the thought of losing one's home, livelihood & place where a family came together with the love of many year's for monies owed! This was when I was young & since found myself in just that situation! What a time to appreciate all that God had blessed me with throughout most of my lifetime! There are so many songs that reach each one of us written & sung by these masterful musicians of this time!!! God Bless "Farm Aid" & the Founding Father's of this lasting Endeavor!!! ❤❤❤❤!!!
You have such a profound impact on my career that even the biggest thank you text would fall shout to express my gratitude. Thanks for your support and the love shown stay safe ❤️❤️❤️
Hello 👋 kathy
how're you doing
Thanks for your love and support, you're an amazing fan! it's nice meeting you here
Crecí escuchando grupazos de los 60 y 70 como estos venerables Maestros, de mis favoritos entre todas las buenas corrientes del rock; CSN&Y, mis favoritos entre una cantidad increíble de excelentes bandas y solistas de aquella época irrepetible y de altísima calidad lírica y musical, el virtuosismos era la carta de presentación de la música en la Era de Acuario...!!
Awesome performance! These four men have been my idols since 50 years ago. Thanks David, Stephen, Graham and Neil, long life for all of you.
LONG LIFE AND MANY MORE SONGS TO YOU ALL.
4 way street the best the 70,s were the best years❤️🥰👍
These geniuses, separately and together have sung me through the years. Unparalleled musical talent has accompanied those of us of a certain age and we have enjoyed an uncountable richness of blessings.
yes ! dont know about the blessings , still single , still not enough money, many years of productive satisfying work, animals are ok (dogs , 20 year old goose and his family, water and lights paid, house paid, winters coming (( corona virus )) Etc . Lifes not too bad . Trying to get this music to the new generation.
Truer words . . . , my dear ;o)
@@stephenbosch2208 teach your children well, my 12 year old (grand child is a lil songbird
They surely sound great together such great harmonies. 4 way street is great acoustic on one side electric on other.
Some of the JOYFUL NOISE the LORD enjoys too, think about that...
So many years of adoring this amazing union of incredible artists, I was 16 when Deja Vu was released, this was the first time I heard CSN, it was 1970 and for some dumb reason I wasn't aware of them when they started in 1968. The song Teach was my favorite song on the album but soon I just loved every song on it. That was a long time ago and the time has gone so fast, I'll listen to this band's amazing music until I pass. Just love these guys.
Outstanding ... in a word ..
This will never lose its place in great music
Wow, friggin amazing !!❤ saw Neil three times, CSN twice!❤❤❤
Graham Nash is English Neil is Canadian the others USA a truly great international band of earthly brothers.
Neil is now US citizen.
First heard CSN&Y in 1969, haven't been the same since, with music that stands the test of time. Thanks so very much to each and every one of them for enlightening me along the way!
Very well said. Simply the best music ever!
Love the one youre with. Is my csny favorite song with a very nice lyrics i used to sing with my guitar thank god am still alive at 73. 2023. Still enjoying their lifetime music i am a filipino fan of CSNY.
Back in the late 1970s I used to target Stephen Stills as an old phogey but he's really an underrated guitarist and I'm sorry I was so arrogant but I was only 19.
One of my top 5 bands for 40 years their harmonies are just stellar
SWEETIE I LOVE your comment they are my #1 FAVORITE band of ALL TIME ✌👍❣🌹💜
A mix of their previous bands... Buffalo Springfield, Hollies, and The Byrds...
You said it. Stellar indeed!!!
Just guitars, vocals, and a butt-load of talent...... sounds better now than I have ever heard them.... freaken awesome!!
Yeah, I just turned off the lights, laid back, closed my eyes and melted. They blew me away...no artificial enhancement needed.
Keith Kaufman I totally agree! They NEVER SOUNDED BETTER! ILOVE THEM
Why can we not have more Artists today, who can execute music in the most "Simplest" forms as these guys did!! Appreciative of Great Vocals, Acoustics and Lyrics!♥️
@@loufitzsimmons914 We do, but there is such easy access to music that is promoted. There are so many talented people who sing in local groups and have great talent, but it is much harder to keep their music in front of live audiences. Audiences are important to an individual artist's or a group's development. It has become much harder to make a profit from selling new music, also. Technology can be a double edged sword.
Music of my generation, can't stop listening to them, CSNY, SIMON and GARFUNKEL, PPM, JIM CROCE and other great musician of the 70's
weee! Dude! We could def hang out!
I hear ya buddy.
Cool the contiueum follows thru
Who's PPM?
@@MMLeatherCraft peter, paul & mary
Every time me, father and son, listens to Teach Your Children, I'm crying. Can't help it. This is IT
C S and N and Young.....was a group I saw as a young hippie on acid in the 60's.....instantly they were my favorite ....and many decades later I'm a 71 yr old widow mother and grandmother and great grandmother and I love them even more.....RIP Crosby❤❤😊😊😇😇
I’m sitting here in the parking lot of my job. I’m off at midnight and I’m watching this as I’m smoking a joint and tearing up, then I’m going home. This was when music was beautiful and made sense. Rest in peace David Crosby and thank you for all of your beautiful talent and voice.
This is beautifully performed including Graham whose voice seems far far better than wembley in 1974. Very polished and great to see the 4 of them with some really nice new tunes by Graham, Neil and crosby.
Its great to see Tracey join in.
Wooden Ships!! Neil and Crosby,Nash and Stills are all in a league of their own!! Timeless Songs and Musicianship!!!!
❤️
Can’t touch that
beyond pure
I’m 75
Oh, all the memories this concert conjures up..... I grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area and as most of this group lived in the Bay Area, they played all the time. I consider myself very lucky to have been able to hear them play live so many times. Does anyone else remember the concerts in Golden Gate Park and the Bill Graham Days on the Green @ the Oakland Coliseum? Those were the days my friend ❣️❣️❣️❣️. The joy and heart the filled the stadium with was everything..... 👏❤️👍😘
Nobody did Harmony like Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young did.
AMEN to That Brother I wish I Had SEEN them Live 😔g
I remember well.
Hope they all get together at least one more time before it's too late...
The only reason they will get back together is if they go broke. Too many egos.
This is music the way it was meant to be ❤
after 50 years, I still love and play CSN, CSNY and most their solo work. And I miss CROZ. RIP David
Christ...those harmonies on Southern Man. I reached for my stash but it has been empty for many years now.
Then get a new stash!
Redduke Teleman Bahahahahaha!
@@CooManTunes No, thanks. My state is not safe. I have family and friends that use for medicinal reasons - they are still subject to getting busted. I gave up all that when I discovered the Mafia had taken over. Besides, there is so much great music from that time! This music can bring back a high any time I want it.
Listened to them 35 years ago, still listen to them now. Real music and musicians.
Mind Blown! I saw David Crosby and Graham Nash perform - I think it was Halloween 1988 - but it was a smaller venue in Oakland - the name escapes me. My daughter was conceived on that night!!
Rest in peace Croz. Legend.
Adoro!!! Já tenho 70 anos e esta banda ainda mexe comigo ❤❤😢❤😮
I’m glad I still have my cds + albums by them to listen to ! ♥️🐰🐇🌹☠️💀⚡️🕊️🪽😘🥰😍👽🪐🛸🚀🔥💥🌟💫✨⭐️🌙⚡️
I love these music moments after moving from Boulder, CO and seeing David outside a restaurant who saw my baby who now is 30 and a great artist you stood up and sent your Heart to us, I didn't say just cruised by peacefully, Bless the whole Band. Peace and Love!!!
Neil's the man ...like him solo but also like the 4 of them. Harmonizing like NO OTHER.
Timeless.....
Stephen is also very talented to say the least. The great musician from Dallas.
They were all great but Neil is one of those rare people at the very top. He has written so many timeless classics.
And 4 yes later and puzzled at what I was thinking 4 yeas ago. I have ALWAYS loved Neil Young. Love the music of the 4, but love Neil Young the music and musician.
RIP David Crosby . Ive been listening to this music since I was 8 yrs old. Its magical.