Laura plays exceptionally well, but Tina's playing always seems so effortless and otherworldly. She's hitting in all supercharged cylinders. Flawless performances time and again. Her cover of Altitudes is proof of that.
Absolutely stunning from both ladies. I was so absorbed with listening and enjoying their playing I never actually thought about trying to compare the two. Well done to both of them. Truly inspirational.
@@F1rstWorldNomaD - I don't know about that.....Laura's picking was super clean and precise. Tina's sounded like her synchronization was like a bag of bees and mosquitos at war. Laura wins this round.....hands down.
@@F1rstWorldNomaD - Yeah sure thing. And I'm sure there's people out there that think C.C. DeVille is a better guitarist that Eddie Van Halen. Or that a Flock of Seagulls blows away Led Zeppelin. And those people can agree to disagree. Tina's note separation and feel was traded off for the shear ability to just simply hit the notes.....tone is out the window and on par with watching somebody impressively smoke on a typewriter. BORING! This comparison is real similar to (lets say) comparing Chris Impellitteri to Yngwie. One picks notes cleanly and the other buzz saws 'em to get the job done.......you decide which is which. Tina's great......but I'm sure she too wishes she could hit those notes and not sound so lifeless. Michael Angelo Baito is a monster shredder.....and lifeless too. He sounds like a computer. Works for him, but I'd never want to play like that.....trade off feel for speed. And, if given the choice, I wouldn't trade my skill set for Tina's......she don't scare me none Yo-Yo is a way better guitarist than Tina S. And (likely) the best guitar player alive is a Russian kid named Max Ostro. He has it all. He don't learn tunes.....he digests people's complete styles, burps, and says "...what's next?" Plays Yngwie so perfect you cannot hear any difference....not even the slightest. If I was Stevie Vai.....I would be scared of this kid.....he's on another planet completely.
Both extremely terrific, of course! Tina S displays more impressive technique and speed. I enjoy listening to Laura's more (disagreeing with many here). The pace and phrasing I think are truer to Vivaldi's intent (if anyone can say that). That such a complex orchestral piece with point-counterpoint combined with percussion can be played by a single musician on a guitar says a lot about the artists' skill and musicianship! Win-win. May they both have extremely successful and satisfying careers!
I enjoyed listening both of them. Well done! No need for compression - different style, different attitude... finally, the joy listening excellent performances is important.
I have been playing guitar since 1978, and the next time someone asks me if I play I will simply say no......... Laura is a great player no doubt but, Tina is just completely on a different level.
Indeed. Her command of the guitar is far above the 1st girl. Lauren is great, don't get me wrong... but it's like comparing me to David Gilmour. I am a weak copy.
Alizee, just a separate note to say thank you for bringing all these phenomenal talents to YT. I jumped to a page that says you have 639 uploads so far. Probably more by now. That in itself is phenomenal. Thank you for putting all this superb talent up before the world. You are doing good work. Best from Canada.
Thank you for your sincere comment. It's been my objective since day ONE to put the emphasis on the artist first. I also love and welcome controversy, as it creates chatter..sometimes , not always good. I am impressed , however on the comments this video got. Very positive and constructive, with very little DWEEB FACTOR That's great! Whenever you put 2 amazing guitarists together, you are always going to get who is better, who is fastest, who is cleaner, who is your personal favorite. In my mind, they are are both great. Tina has the slight edge with the Metal flavor of the song and Laura has more classical feel to her rendition of the song. There is no LOSER or WINNER , as both gals have 2 totally different styles. I enjoy listening to both of them, as the contrast is what makes them so unique. Thanks for your support and remember to support the ladies!
You don't support the ladies by USING THEIR WONG NAME IN THE VIDEO TITLE, and "forget" to make links to their channels in the description. Laura 6100 has even requested this herself in a comment here, with no responses. At least ask for their permission before posting! You are a disgrace.
"put the emphasis on the artist first" (spells their names wrong, copies their footage without consent, and doesn't include any link to their channels)
Tina S, mainly because she actually turned it into a song of her own. She performed it with creativity and adjusted it to her own style and liking, while still keeping the spirit of the piece intact and therefore respecting it. And she did so in an amazing way.
Tina S is the winner in my opinion but I am truly amazed by the god-given feel & talent that both of these amazing young ladies have for the guitar--to say nothing of the countless hours of practice that goes into refining their skills for such flawless exhibitions such as these.
Lauren is the winner here. She plays true to Antonios’ beautiful composition and her tapping skills exhibits he versatility. A fantastic piece interpreted by a youth 👏
ok wow, I feel like a perv now, thanks, I can't effing tell how old people are anymore, omg I have had "face-blindness" this whole time, no wonder all white people look the same to me
I think they're both great. Their styles are different and their setups and backing tracks are way different so I think it's a hard comparison to make. Without the backing tracks it might sound a little different. Also as the listener we have our own bias to styles. Some like a softer tone and then Laura has the edge. Some like a heavier tone and the Tina has it. I think we should applaud both for a lot of hard work and REAL talent.
Ha...It's the term (in the same meaning) that Steve Ouimette used when he first heard Tina. "That's just *ridiculous*!"...meaning, "ridiculously awesome", "off the charts"...
Tina S. hands and fingers down. No comparison. Tina had the clarity, articulation, and power and confidence in other words as said below....Tina S. owned it!
She is just so damn fast on those picks and she never slows down. She simply plays on another level. Can't wait to see her new work. Yeah she's 24 now fixing to be 25 I think her Bday is in April and she was born in 99 what a prodigy.
When watching these two MASTERS of their instrument, Debating which one is better tis pointless. I just enjoy watching Incredible , Badass guitarists shred and make it look effortless. Gooddamn Brilliance!
Wow that was awesome. Laura and Tina you both are very talented. I look forward to seeing you both down the road. It's almost scary to think you'll both improve as the future unfolds. Thank you both for sharing your talent, I enjoyed the performance.
Both of these girls blow the doors off of anything I've ever done in my life. I'm not going to embarrass myself by pretending I'm in any position to judge either of them. They are both incredibly talented and light years ahead of me. Tina has always been a guitar God to me, that magic will never change. Never seen this other girl before, but clearly super talented. Anyone that can be put side by side with Tina S in a comparison automatically claims the title best of the best, so there's that. One song is hardly enough to go by as well, but seriously, why even bother doing a comparison. Let's just call them both Gods and be done with it. People work crazy hard to get to this level, even prodigies. Why disparage their hard work by calling one the best and one second best. I'm tired of people getting trophies just for showing up as much as the next guy, but these two definitely both deserve one.
This is comparing apples to oranges. You cannot expect two entirely different styles to have a winner. Miss Lauren was hard and edgy, while Miss Tina was classical all the way. Both are amazingly talented musicians, and both my awe and respect. Pair the two of them up and see what THAT sounds like!
Tina S and Laura Lace are both great in their own way. Everyone has their own unique style on playing the guitar. Tina S and Laura Lace have different styles because everyone won't have the same shape of fingers. Everyone has different shape of fingers. They both did awesome but....with Tina S I felt more of a good vibe with her then Laura Lace. But don't underestimate them they both are awesome at it.
The fact that she plays power chords with her middle and ring finger is a huge deal. When playing classical music (or rock based on classical) this is a huge advantage. Much props for Tina.
Both are amazing! I dont really know much of the 1st girl but Tina S has amazed me a hundred times with her multiple covers. Her cover of Jason Becker, it was either Altitudes or Perpetual Burn, im not sure, but it was perfect! I got my 9 year old a very nice Ibanez mini, very nice guitar, i just wish she would take interest like these girls have. Again, AMAZING!
No. Only a non-guitarist would think this. Tina's command of the guitar is far above Lauren's. If you listen to things like pinch harmonics and the control of the distortion that she wields, you would see that Tina is on another level when compared to Lauren. I understand non-players would think they're both godly... but there is a clear difference in talent here. Raw memorization and practice only get you so far.
Laurens probably got a cleaner style, a bit more precision, but oh boy are Tinas fingers fast. These two kids are going to be epic guitarists when they get older.
I find this an interesting topic, let's discuss. Lauren Lace has a very polished sound. I have seen her play on stage (In a video) and she did a fine job. Specifically, I think Lace has a more established feel for rhythm and has demonstrated her stage presence. Like Eric Clapton she is crystal clear and deliberate with her phrasing. She is a polished and proficient technician. Tina S. is an artist, I believe her sound is still evolving and I have seen no videos of her playing in front of an audience. Her best playing is done in the classical guitar posture, the body between the legs. I do not feel her rhythm like I do Lace. Regardless, Tina S plays with more soul and I am excited to hear her, she is more like Stevie Ray Vaughn, not as much of a tight ass like Clapton. My preference is Tina S. On a positive note. These two performers need to unite across the Atlantic and form the next version of Iron Maiden or Judas Priest. RUclips's next job is finding a Singer Drummer and Bassist.
I've spent most of my life among musicians on and off stage, and these young women are amazing.... but I do have to choose. Of course, they both have a lot of work to do on their stage-presence... and Laura is a beautiful and amazingly talented guitarist... but Tina is simply a goddess.
they both have their whole lives ahead of them, I wouldn't wanna choose between them ,infact,that wouldn't be very nice,,they both play to a very hi-calibre ,,class act xoxoxo
I rate them both as excellent and I have been a musician over 50 years. I have seen many fantastic musicians but these two ladies take the cake. Excellence on display.....
😊 with years of practice and a promising career (if pursued) in music 🎵 or whatever 😅 both of these girls can get to the level of orianthi The 🦘 Australian Shredder 🤌👍
It is amazing to watch and to listen to such heavenly talented young musicians of different styles and techniques working on the same theme and finding their own ways of Interpretations. My thanks for showing them both together. But the question of who is best is not the best one to find an answer for whom and why this music originally was Made for. The question is taking away the sende and deviating the thoughts of the viewers into critics which better should belong to a meaning everyone shall have on his own by feeling touched by the waves of sympathies and personal preferences. We all should be thankful that both artists were showing us something of things which can be just possible if you love whatever you do without any question in mind but only feeling the spirit and being one with the composition of grandmasters in the past. So it's really the best to see them all alive while the beat goes on. ....naa nana nana....click
Alizee Defan, in the future please be more discreet on who you put side by side. Both Guitarists are good in their own right but it's like putting REO's Lead Guitarist Kevin Cronin against Yngwie Malmsteen. Discretion Madame.
Exactly! Cronin Vs. Malmsteen... Hilarious, but oh so true! I'm sure Lauren is a nice young lady and all, and she's a quite good guitarist, but she took all kinds of shortcuts in this song. Not even playing the lead part every other measure! Tina played it (as she does on all sons she covers) note for note. 1:1. Exactly as played by the original artist. No shortcuts, no dropping out to the rhythm part every other measure, nada. Flat out blazing!
REO's current Lead Guitarist is Dave Amato (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REO_Speedwagon) Kevin Cronin plays Rhythm Guitar only. I would put former REO Guitarist Gary Richrath (1970 - 1989) up against Yngwie though. But I actually prefer Lauren, she captures the essence of the material much better.
Ysee what I don't see is the point. Why would anyone want to do a note for note 1:1 copy of anything? The original's already out there. Either add something new to it or do something original.
What's the point? Why does a classical pianist or orchestra play everything note for note 1:1? Why does sheet music even exist? Think about that for a second. ;) But more seriously, training enough to be able to play a variety of difficult music 1:1 hones your skills, and Tina S proves her insane skill over and over again.
Niklas - You're absolutely correct. It's getting the detail correct when playing other's music. Once you've mastered that - THEN you can consider writing and playing your own music. VERY seldom do you find great composers who have NOT done the hard graft of studying their predecessor's works. (Even Mozart studied master-works from those who went before him)
What to compare in these? Laura played the electric guitar cover version of Vivaldi Summer Presto, while Tina played a metal version of it. Comparing the two is like comparing the Knockin' on heavens door from Bob Dylan with the Guns N' Roses version of the song.
I have the feeling that Tina is the more accomplished artist but, I liked Lauren's rendition better. Perhaps if the production quality of Tina's video was equivalent to Lauren's it might tip the scale in Tina's favor.
You should definitely choose Tina. Don't worry about the tone, listen to the melody and try watching other of Tina's videos. She's played more than just melodic shred, she's also done flat-picking and blues playing too.
Nick Waters Oh yeah Nick. I have viewed several other videos featuring Tina. She is phenomenal. To me, she had the best interpretation of Comfortably Numb I have seen on the internet. But Tina often allows her virtuosity to prevail over the music leaving the listener amazed at the potential of the human body rather than moved by the music. At least that is my take on having listened to a number of her performances on RUclips. In this video here, I didn't think Tina did that but, I still like Lauren's performance better.
dnsmithnc Lauren is great, but she stares at her fretboard. In fact, Tina even plays songs on the guitar without looking at her fingers or the fretboard a lot. In classical music, not only the classical music about melody or rhythm, it was about musical talent, skill, and technique. Do you only care about music and not talent? I care most likely about both music and skill. Music is music where it's good or not. Many listeners don't pay attention much to the melody because they think the notes that she plays an be too fast for them, but she does use musical soul by using melody and if the listeners would've payed close attention, then they would understand and they would be amazed by the melodies and skills she used. Tina wins and that's final.
Nick Waters But my point is in your response. I am not concerned about her technique but, the music she produces. I have no doubt in the world that technically, Tina is far better generally. But, the quality of the sound, to my ears, is better with Lauren on this song. Your final summation is sheer arrogance. Tina wins and that is final? Bullshit.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Bigger In Texas [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxTkZTLWdo4/mqdefault.jpg)
After playing guitar for forty years,...I have decided to get a job.
L.O.L.
👌😎🤣
after 5 years i made millions and come here to read you misfortunes!
I totally agree with you
Wow chicks sher can play guitar
Lauren is a great guitar player, but Tina IS the guitar
simon clemence Imho Lauren tells the musical story much better... Tina’s speed and perfectness are impressive, but to me a bit soulless.
During my music training I as told “you must not play every piece as fast as you can. You need time to think, plus author set tempo for a reason”😸
Grigory Buteyko a very good point ı agree 👏
Grigory Buteyko
Couldn’t put it better 👍
Tina is Carnegie Hall Material. Every note, pitch amplitude and cadence, not one error. May be one error in 10 Exp012 notes.
Laura is a magnificent, highly skilled guitar player. Tina S. is a GODDESS OF ROCK.
Laura plays exceptionally well, but Tina's playing always seems so effortless and otherworldly. She's hitting in all supercharged cylinders. Flawless performances time and again. Her cover of Altitudes is proof of that.
That's what technique does my friend classical guitar
Remember the great composer's wrote for entire ensemble of instruments. Here you have 1 instrument and 1 musician doing all.
Why have we got to compare? Can't we just enjoy what they have both given us?
Not everyone gets a trophy
@Horus Skywalker (o-o)==m==# i can =E
We can. Should we?
Agree 100%
Agree! Both are great, This isn't a competition.
Absolutely stunning from both ladies. I was so absorbed with listening and enjoying their playing I never actually thought about trying to compare the two. Well done to both of them. Truly inspirational.
Both of these young ladies are absolutely amazing guitar players but Tina S. is on another level.
If there was a Universal Guitar Hero tournament, Earth would send Tina to represent us.
No we wouldnt.
Best comment ever...
Marcin, Alexandr Misko, Guthrie Govan, ichika Nito or Prime Jason Becker instead of Tina.
One is good the other is phenomenal. I don’t even have to say who, we all know .
Nah, one is phenomenal the other *inhuman,*
Calling Laura "good" is not fair. She is exceptional... But Tina is league's beyond her.
Tina is a goddess
@@F1rstWorldNomaD - I don't know about that.....Laura's picking was super clean and precise. Tina's sounded like her synchronization was like a bag of bees and mosquitos at war. Laura wins this round.....hands down.
@@ubatooba8467 Agree to disagree, I guess.
I think we can agree theyre both exceptional either way.
@@F1rstWorldNomaD - Yeah sure thing. And I'm sure there's people out there that think C.C. DeVille is a better guitarist that Eddie Van Halen. Or that a Flock of Seagulls blows away Led Zeppelin. And those people can agree to disagree. Tina's note separation and feel was traded off for the shear ability to just simply hit the notes.....tone is out the window and on par with watching somebody impressively smoke on a typewriter. BORING! This comparison is real similar to (lets say) comparing Chris Impellitteri to Yngwie. One picks notes cleanly and the other buzz saws 'em to get the job done.......you decide which is which. Tina's great......but I'm sure she too wishes she could hit those notes and not sound so lifeless. Michael Angelo Baito is a monster shredder.....and lifeless too. He sounds like a computer. Works for him, but I'd never want to play like that.....trade off feel for speed. And, if given the choice, I wouldn't trade my skill set for Tina's......she don't scare me none Yo-Yo is a way better guitarist than Tina S. And (likely) the best guitar player alive is a Russian kid named Max Ostro. He has it all. He don't learn tunes.....he digests people's complete styles, burps, and says "...what's next?" Plays Yngwie so perfect you cannot hear any difference....not even the slightest. If I was Stevie Vai.....I would be scared of this kid.....he's on another planet completely.
Both extremely terrific, of course! Tina S displays more impressive technique and speed.
I enjoy listening to Laura's more (disagreeing with many here). The pace and phrasing I think are truer to Vivaldi's intent (if anyone can say that).
That such a complex orchestral piece with point-counterpoint combined with percussion can be played by a single musician on a guitar says a lot about the artists' skill and musicianship! Win-win. May they both have extremely successful and satisfying careers!
Mitch Bogart
Agreed.
There is a second guitar overlay though
Tina plays at the exact same speed than the violons of Vivaldi.
Both are very good, and as you said Mitch I wish them both successful careers.
I enjoyed listening both of them. Well done! No need for compression - different style, different attitude... finally, the joy listening excellent performances is important.
Here here!!
Tina S is so silky fluid with her shreds. Her classical training adds to her impeccable technique.
Lauren sounds great... then Tina plugs in -- Holy &uck! This girl is in another dimension.
Agreed
Yes ... in another dimension all of her own ... she definitely rates in the top 1% of all guitarists.
I have been playing guitar since 1978, and the next time someone asks me if I play I will simply say no......... Laura is a great player no doubt but, Tina is just completely on a different level.
Tina S is light-years ahead.
Very little comparison here... Tina is on a different level.
Have to agree. It wasn't really worth the video.
Ys, but Laura is cuter... soooo... uhhhm.... stuff?
@@interdimensionalsteve8172 They're both cute but that would be a different topic
Indeed. Her command of the guitar is far above the 1st girl. Lauren is great, don't get me wrong... but it's like comparing me to David Gilmour. I am a weak copy.
@@basedbear1605 Well said!!
Lauren is good,But not in the same league as Tina
Alizee, just a separate note to say thank you for bringing all these phenomenal talents to YT. I jumped to a page that says you have 639 uploads so far. Probably more by now. That in itself is phenomenal.
Thank you for putting all this superb talent up before the world. You are doing good work.
Best from Canada.
Thank you for your sincere comment. It's been my objective since day ONE to put the emphasis on the artist first. I also love and welcome controversy, as it creates chatter..sometimes , not always good. I am impressed , however on the comments this video got. Very positive and constructive, with very little DWEEB FACTOR That's great! Whenever you put 2 amazing guitarists together, you are always going to get who is better, who is fastest, who is cleaner, who is your personal favorite.
In my mind, they are are both great. Tina has the slight edge with the Metal flavor of the song and Laura has more classical feel to her rendition of the song. There is no LOSER or WINNER , as both gals have 2 totally different styles. I enjoy listening to both of them, as the contrast is what makes them so unique. Thanks for your support and remember to support the ladies!
Do you actually have their permission to upload their videos or do you just steal them? Just curious.
You don't support the ladies by USING THEIR WONG NAME IN THE VIDEO TITLE, and "forget" to make links to their channels in the description. Laura 6100 has even requested this herself in a comment here, with no responses. At least ask for their permission before posting! You are a disgrace.
"put the emphasis on the artist first" (spells their names wrong, copies their footage without consent, and doesn't include any link to their channels)
Wow, both super talented young girls!! However, I`m going with Tina S. I think Tina has a better feel, and is more of a natural.
I could never choose between these two artists, they're both Amazing & Wonderful!
yes
And after the 7th day God looked down on his creations and became aware that his wonders would only be complete with Tina S.
Probably not that far from the truth..... :)
A genius!
Amen! She is amazing.
that is so!!
They should do a project together! Call it 'Tina loves Lauren (but Lauren feels weird about it)'.
These are both extremely talented young ladies, I don't see either one of them being better than the other. Amazing !
Tina S, mainly because she actually turned it into a song of her own. She performed it with creativity and adjusted it to her own style and liking, while still keeping the spirit of the piece intact and therefore respecting it. And she did so in an amazing way.
***** I checked what you said and you are sadly correct. Thanks for the correction :)
Agreed
Tina S is the winner in my opinion but I am truly amazed by the god-given feel & talent that both of these amazing young ladies have for the guitar--to say nothing of the countless hours of practice that goes into refining their skills for such flawless exhibitions such as these.
Lauren is the winner here.
She plays true to Antonios’ beautiful composition and her tapping skills exhibits he versatility.
A fantastic piece interpreted by a youth 👏
Tina was 14 when she did this one ...... FOURTEEN !!!!!
Old enough for me 😋
I was eating sand at 14 ffs
@@markxv2267 xD fuck
ok wow, I feel like a perv now, thanks, I can't effing tell how old people are anymore, omg I have had "face-blindness" this whole time, no wonder all white people look the same to me
@Vasile Lipcan, aren't we all, still just chowing down on fantastic sand castles
Lauren, good guitarist. Tina S. prodigy. BIG DIFFERENCE !!!!
Believe it or not, Tina S
Yup. She owned that song and didn't take any shortcuts
Seriously you said believe it or not ? Tina da beast 🤘🏻
Laura's got chops but Tina's playing is sublime.
I think they're both great. Their styles are different and their setups and backing tracks are way different so I think it's a hard comparison to make. Without the backing tracks it might sound a little different. Also as the listener we have our own bias to styles. Some like a softer tone and then Laura has the edge. Some like a heavier tone and the Tina has it. I think we should applaud both for a lot of hard work and REAL talent.
That wasn't fair for Lauren. While she is a very good player, Tina is just ridiculous. She is just on a different level.
What do you mean ridiculous?
Ridiculous= Awesome
I totally agree. Tina makes everyone want to throw their axes into a wood chipper - even Lauren, I imagine.
LOL
Ha...It's the term (in the same meaning) that Steve Ouimette used when he first heard Tina. "That's just *ridiculous*!"...meaning, "ridiculously awesome", "off the charts"...
Tina S. hands and fingers down. No comparison. Tina had the clarity, articulation, and power and confidence in other words as said below....Tina S. owned it!
She is just so damn fast on those picks and she never slows down. She simply plays on another level. Can't wait to see her new work. Yeah she's 24 now fixing to be 25 I think her Bday is in April and she was born in 99 what a prodigy.
Laura plays like a mathematician, without emotions. Tina feels ... Well done Tina!
When watching these two MASTERS of their instrument, Debating which one is better tis pointless. I just enjoy watching Incredible , Badass guitarists shred and make it look effortless. Gooddamn Brilliance!
Hahaha, Tina S hands down. Also her rendition of Beethovens "Moonlight", part 3 is fantastic.
Tina S makes it look effortless. Strong and quick hands
Tina's technique and style are sublime
The only real matchup that would make sorta sense is TINA S vs TINA S. Why bother with anyone else.
Wow that was awesome. Laura and Tina you both are very talented. I look forward to seeing you both down the road. It's almost scary to think you'll both improve as the future unfolds. Thank you both for sharing your talent, I enjoyed the performance.
Both of these girls blow the doors off of anything I've ever done in my life. I'm not going to embarrass myself by pretending I'm in any position to judge either of them. They are both incredibly talented and light years ahead of me. Tina has always been a guitar God to me, that magic will never change. Never seen this other girl before, but clearly super talented. Anyone that can be put side by side with Tina S in a comparison automatically claims the title best of the best, so there's that. One song is hardly enough to go by as well, but seriously, why even bother doing a comparison. Let's just call them both Gods and be done with it. People work crazy hard to get to this level, even prodigies. Why disparage their hard work by calling one the best and one second best. I'm tired of people getting trophies just for showing up as much as the next guy, but these two definitely both deserve one.
both great but gotta give it to Tina S!
This is comparing apples to oranges. You cannot expect two entirely different styles to have a winner. Miss Lauren was hard and edgy, while Miss Tina was classical all the way. Both are amazingly talented musicians, and both my awe and respect. Pair the two of them up and see what THAT sounds like!
You're right! Just choose both !
Soy fan de Vivaldi y la verdad Laura lace lo hace de forma impresionantemente impecable
Tina s is better, Because she have feel. And she was 14🤩😍🤩😍🤩
Laura is performing Vivaldi, Tina performs more herself. That's why I like Laura more.
Laura was Vivaldi
Tina S and Laura Lace are both great in their own way. Everyone has their own unique style on playing the guitar. Tina S and Laura Lace have different styles because everyone won't have the same shape of fingers. Everyone has different shape of fingers. They both did awesome but....with Tina S I felt more of a good vibe with her then Laura Lace. But don't underestimate them they both are awesome at it.
Whilst both are amazing and worlds better than I'll ever be, there is no comparison, Tina S is just far more practiced and technical
Tina S is the best
Best at what? dadadadada, dadadadada, dadadadadad0dink dink da. lol
The tempo changes and the use of overdrive/distortion are so different. Tina's style is more metal which doesn't suit the piece as well IMO.
love em both, wish I was 50 years younger,
Both are awesome 🤘 but Tina S is more better... Her finger style is pro GG legend... Love you tina S #Fan😘
The fact that she plays power chords with her middle and ring finger is a huge deal. When playing classical music (or rock based on classical) this is a huge advantage. Much props for Tina.
No contest Tina S.
Both are amazing! I dont really know much of the 1st girl but Tina S has amazed me a hundred times with her multiple covers. Her cover of Jason Becker, it was either Altitudes or Perpetual Burn, im not sure, but it was perfect! I got my 9 year old a very nice Ibanez mini, very nice guitar, i just wish she would take interest like these girls have. Again, AMAZING!
No winner here.... Both, totally amazing!!!
Both fantastic, however, I think Tina has the edge with this piece.
Both are at God level. So it doesn't matter. They can mop the floor with every one of the 920 commenters here (except me, of course).
No. Only a non-guitarist would think this. Tina's command of the guitar is far above Lauren's. If you listen to things like pinch harmonics and the control of the distortion that she wields, you would see that Tina is on another level when compared to Lauren.
I understand non-players would think they're both godly... but there is a clear difference in talent here. Raw memorization and practice only get you so far.
Laurens probably got a cleaner style, a bit more precision, but oh boy are Tinas fingers fast. These two kids are going to be epic guitarists when they get older.
+Shayne O'Neill You probably didn't notice, like so many other things in life, but they already are!
Pretty epic now I would say. Why wait.
Sorry, Tina S all the way. Much more polished.
No comparision is needed ! Both Tina's and Laura's guitar playing takes my breath away ! 👍
Both are extremely talented, best in the field, artists. Love the pair!
I find this an interesting topic, let's discuss.
Lauren Lace has a very polished sound. I have seen her play on stage (In a video) and she did a fine job. Specifically, I think Lace has a more established feel for rhythm and has demonstrated her stage presence. Like Eric Clapton she is crystal clear and deliberate with her phrasing. She is a polished and proficient technician.
Tina S. is an artist, I believe her sound is still evolving and I have seen no videos of her playing in front of an audience. Her best playing is done in the classical guitar posture, the body between the legs. I do not feel her rhythm like I do Lace. Regardless, Tina S plays with more soul and I am excited to hear her, she is more like Stevie Ray Vaughn, not as much of a tight ass like Clapton.
My preference is Tina S.
On a positive note. These two performers need to unite across the Atlantic and form the next version of Iron Maiden or Judas Priest. RUclips's next job is finding a Singer Drummer and Bassist.
Can either compose original music?
Tina S for the win, lauren's good, but, tina's better
The emotions that Tina gives are phenomenal
Man that was a treat. Amazing talent.
Both players are absolutely astonishing!!
Why this duel i like Tina and Laura both is awesome respect for all.
Because, as with anything.... there can be only one Best. And clearly Tina S is the best up and coming guitarist I've ever seen.
Tina S - no contest. Absolute mastery 😎🇫🇷
Laura has a cleaner sound as Tina uses more distortion.
Different styles. They're both superb and I could listen to them all day long.
Both have their own style - and in full perfection. They both studied the guitar and understood it...
They BOTH have immense talent!!!
Laura lace forever..❤
Tina S ... My God!! That's perfect.
I've spent most of my life among musicians on and off stage, and these young women are amazing.... but I do have to choose.
Of course, they both have a lot of work to do on their stage-presence... and Laura is a beautiful and amazingly talented guitarist... but Tina is simply a goddess.
what is better Honda or Yamaha ... Ferrari or Lamborgini ... F-16 or SU-28 ... ?
Both are wonderful musicians! One has more "feeling", the other one more "technique". Which is which? I don't know 8•)
they both have their whole lives ahead of them, I wouldn't wanna choose between them ,infact,that wouldn't be very nice,,they both play to a very hi-calibre ,,class act xoxoxo
But Tina S is much better is not an opinion it's a fact
Это божественно! Словами это не описать! Теперь я знаю что такое слуховой оргазм
Lauren is so smooth!!!
They are playing Antonio Vivaldi's Summer-Presto. It's from his 4 Seasons Suite.
I love them both and happy to be able to watch,listen and learn from both...May your fingers take you beyond your wildest dreams....
2 winners!
А мне они обе понравились! Молодцы девчонки!!! Возможно благодаря вашему исполнению, я хочу слушать классику!!!
Ванессу Мэй слушай. Не порть себе слух ширпотребом. Особенно вторая исполнительница, просто позор..
@@PaagriolRUoffClassic- Не испорчу! В детстве, мне сказали, что его то, у меня и не наблюдается;)
Both are great. Tina is better.
I rate them both as excellent and I have been a musician over 50 years. I have seen many fantastic musicians but these two ladies take the cake.
Excellence on display.....
😊 with years of practice and a promising career (if pursued) in music 🎵 or whatever 😅 both of these girls can get to the level of orianthi The 🦘 Australian Shredder 🤌👍
Thank you 👍 for the ❤️
me as a guitarist myself really do think that Tina S is better she has a much better tone than Lauren and also has better arpeggios
Rename this video to "Tina makes Laura look like a beginner!" Seriously!
And you look like a sniveling asshole.
@@rickromski4618 Nope.. only you look like the ahole troll here. Get a life.
team Tina S the Greatest!!
Yes indeed two pearls of electronic music
It is amazing to watch and to listen to such heavenly talented young musicians of different styles and techniques working on the same theme and finding their own ways of Interpretations. My thanks for showing them both together. But the question of who is best is not the best one to find an answer for whom and why this music originally was Made for. The question is taking away the sende and deviating the thoughts of the viewers into critics which better should belong to a meaning everyone shall have on his own by feeling touched by the waves of sympathies and personal preferences.
We all should be thankful that both artists were showing us something of things which can be just possible if you love whatever you do without any question in mind but only feeling the spirit and being one with the composition of grandmasters in the past.
So it's really the best to see them all alive while the beat goes on.
....naa nana nana....click
Alizee Defan, in the future please be more discreet on who you put side by side. Both Guitarists are good in their own right but it's like putting REO's Lead Guitarist Kevin Cronin against Yngwie Malmsteen. Discretion Madame.
Exactly! Cronin Vs. Malmsteen... Hilarious, but oh so true! I'm sure Lauren is a nice young lady and all, and she's a quite good guitarist, but she took all kinds of shortcuts in this song. Not even playing the lead part every other measure! Tina played it (as she does on all sons she covers) note for note. 1:1. Exactly as played by the original artist. No shortcuts, no dropping out to the rhythm part every other measure, nada. Flat out blazing!
REO's current Lead Guitarist is Dave Amato (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REO_Speedwagon) Kevin Cronin plays Rhythm Guitar only. I would put former REO Guitarist Gary Richrath (1970 - 1989) up against Yngwie though. But I actually prefer Lauren, she captures the essence of the material much better.
Ysee what I don't see is the point. Why would anyone want to do a note for note 1:1 copy of anything? The original's already out there. Either add something new to it or do something original.
What's the point? Why does a classical pianist or orchestra play everything note for note 1:1? Why does sheet music even exist? Think about that for a second. ;) But more seriously, training enough to be able to play a variety of difficult music 1:1 hones your skills, and Tina S proves her insane skill over and over again.
Niklas - You're absolutely correct. It's getting the detail correct when playing other's music. Once you've mastered that - THEN you can consider writing and playing your own music. VERY seldom do you find great composers who have NOT done the hard graft of studying their predecessor's works. (Even Mozart studied master-works from those who went before him)
Umnichka! Мой любимый Вивальди!!!
Классные гитаристки и красавицы!Не сравнивайте!
Such wonderful talent. Keep enjoying your art. We love it.
What to compare in these? Laura played the electric guitar cover version of Vivaldi Summer Presto, while Tina played a metal version of it. Comparing the two is like comparing the Knockin' on heavens door from Bob Dylan with the Guns N' Roses version of the song.
I have the feeling that Tina is the more accomplished artist but, I liked Lauren's rendition better. Perhaps if the production quality of Tina's video was equivalent to Lauren's it might tip the scale in Tina's favor.
You should definitely choose Tina. Don't worry about the tone, listen to the melody and try watching other of Tina's videos. She's played more than just melodic shred, she's also done flat-picking and blues playing too.
Nick Waters Oh yeah Nick. I have viewed several other videos featuring Tina. She is phenomenal. To me, she had the best interpretation of Comfortably Numb I have seen on the internet. But Tina often allows her virtuosity to prevail over the music leaving the listener amazed at the potential of the human body rather than moved by the music. At least that is my take on having listened to a number of her performances on RUclips. In this video here, I didn't think Tina did that but, I still like Lauren's performance better.
sorry but Tina S is light years above and beyond Lauren and no chance of catching up
dnsmithnc Lauren is great, but she stares at her fretboard. In fact, Tina even plays songs on the guitar without looking at her fingers or the fretboard a lot. In classical music, not only the classical music about melody or rhythm, it was about musical talent, skill, and technique. Do you only care about music and not talent? I care most likely about both music and skill. Music is music where it's good or not. Many listeners don't pay attention much to the melody because they think the notes that she plays an be too fast for them, but she does use musical soul by using melody and if the listeners would've payed close attention, then they would understand and they would be amazed by the melodies and skills she used. Tina wins and that's final.
Nick Waters But my point is in your response. I am not concerned about her technique but, the music she produces. I have no doubt in the world that technically, Tina is far better generally. But, the quality of the sound, to my ears, is better with Lauren on this song. Your final summation is sheer arrogance. Tina wins and that is final? Bullshit.
Awesome and Awesomer, this is a win/win for me.
Tina wins IMO, but they are both very good
Amazing !!! Two winners!
You both did an excellent job in different ways.