Because they have nothing in their brains to suggest anything concrete for the benefit of the country except to say things like wearing shorts is haram and corruptions by certain people is halal.
Wow! This video is damn owesome, which is only 7 minutes long, it states all my dissatisfaction with these extremists and what they have done again and again to fool their supporters for many decades. I hope that more people will see this video, especially PAS supporters. Thank you very much Victor Tan
Ha ha, it’s been something I’ve been thinking about for a while! Thank you so much, and it’s an honor to have your kind words! In a small way, I hope that they will see it as well, but really it is up to the algorithm and it is also up to them to change as people! Thank you so much for the support, and look forward to seeing you in my next video!
D problem is tun is d advisor of pas d so call muslim party...we msian ignored those chrismas activities joy...but tun d saka 99 is d main problem.. WHY..??????
Hey thank you Joshua! I recall that you suggested it btw xD It was interesting to think about, and to also think about the broader concept of Amar Makruf Nahi Mungkar - something I’ve always been thinking about and that I keep thinking is hypocritical just cause it keeps getting used for the most inane reasons 😭 No idea if they’re going to comment on this, but what I can see is that since they’re siding with DS Najib (I might make a video about that), that might mean a chilling of the relationship between the PAS goons and Tun M 🤣 Thank you for watching!
Why ???? Bcos atok saka tua is pas advisor...advised on what ???? How to sakau d govt money & push anwar down to grieve....when is this atok going to.....
In her case, it was not about "Christmas extremists", celebrated Christmas is HARAM (forbidden) in Islam & there is no problem if Muslims send a Christmas greets to Christians community. But at same, PAS is HYPOCRITED! They blamed Anwar Ibrahim as "liberal" but at same time Mahathir family are more liberal & secularist than Anwar Ibrahim who are mostly weared a hijab than Mahathir family. PAS never criticized Mahathir family.
That’s part of it! I think they also just want to get clout and bring down famous people so that their own stars can rise 😭 Generally, I have very little faith in these people, and I do not think that they have good intentions - if they would, then they would be using their ability to criticize for better causes 😭
of course she is but educated doesnt mean their IQ is high these days. i mean you have doctors like Akmal Bebop, PhD holder Siti Mastura, The doctor Rahmah cancer. Just to name a few domestic ones. on international level, university students and professor cant explain explain what a woman is..
privacy?? nah.. she is a M people. although we are not Muslims, it is our duty to remind her of what her tok guru said. even her atok is now tok guru close pal.
I watched your video till the end and everything you said is the absolute truth. Today I was having roti canai breakfast with my son at our favourite stall.I was recently widowed and suddenly a lady in veil approached me and blah.....blah away.😮 Why cant she respect other people privacy🙄?
Thanks for watching and I’m sorry to hear that! I hope the culture can change! I guess it starts with choosing to mind your own business, although for a lot of these people they’ve always believed that it was the right thing for them to do to go out and speak to people and tell them that what they’re doing is wrong. I think it takeseffort to realign all of that and some people might just think that it’s completely wrong and refuse to do it after all 😭
To be somewhat fair, I think that the Anwar administration tries to control what it can control, and does not control what it thinks it cannot control - it’s not that this makes his administration look good in any way, especially since it displays such an appalling lack of ability when it comes to managing perceptions or messaging, but at least it is understandable. I believe the challenge now is to create a civil society where it is not only acceptable but also expected and pushed on by all members of the rakyat, whether Malay, Chinese, or Indian, that the government should take action against PAS as we begin to influence PDRM, the military, and every other entity to move in that direction and therefore to begin to locate the people who are selling out extremism in our society. We know after all that Madani allegedly wants to govern in a way that is fair and inclusive, which as we have seen basically means that they will never take action in a meaningful way on things unless it becomes clear that their hand is being forced and the universe is on their side, that something has to be done. How will we get to the point where it becomes decisively normal and our government will just casually and happily claim credit once it finally calls for a probe and an operation? That is a step-by-step process that Malaysia should walk towards every single day 😭
@VictorTan Exactly! but we humans are all short term creatures.. can be justify as most of us can only think rationally up to 70-80 yrs of age! But n years down the road, with increasing speed+change in technology, the feudal system is kaput! as all humans wanted to be equal and fair share of the piece of economical and power cake.
@danielyee9159 However currently there's no other better Pm! Who would u suggest anyway? Btw in the future it'll be even more worrisome and bleak! Only Rafizi .. At least he's seen to be clean & less corrupt! Khairul & A$$min all hopeless, so is $yed $addiq.. & definitely not those Dumbno, Ber$atu & PAS racist youth leaders!
It's not fair, all the nons are enjoying various festivals with colours, lights, new fashionable clothing, drinks and food. The nons work hard and celebrating happily.
Please commed.. kenapa tidak ada pihak yang menganjur perhimpunan bantah pendatang / pekerja tanpa izin... ?. mereka yang rampas peluang raktya dan kewangan malaysia ( berbillion ke negara merekan setiap tahun) dengan masala sosial.... sebaliknya pas bantah lain isu
This is a common thread, but in my opinion it accomplishes nothing except allow you to maintain an illusion in your head. Encourage you not to look at what you call the ‘good old days’ and instead focus your mind on the present and ask what specific and small thing you can do to make Malaysia closer to what you envision as its ideal state. 👍
Hey Victor! Do you know what??! I really enjoy watching your videos. Your contents are not just simply spitting out FACTS. But, what really entertained me was your head, hand and finger movement when you talk (Especially when you pointing your finger at *cough PAS *cough, I mean the camera) Just like an Orchestral Conductor… 😂😂😂
LOLLLL thank you for the kind sharing! All the better to entertain, educate, and hang out, chill, brainw… I MEAN share messages that I think are important with the world! That aside, I think making videos and being able to influence thousands of people is fun - it helps to develop your personality, and also to learn how to articulate yourself in better ways. I could not do this without all of you, and I look forward to following the path of truth in the days ahead as well - thank you for following my strange dances and fun facts, and I look forward to seeing you again! 🤩
Controlling other people's behaviour is wrong no matter what excuses you use.Using fear, threat to make people to conform is counter productive, because you cannot control what people think.More productive to inspire people to change through our love ,respect and honour.When authorities uses force , what makes them diffrent from fascist, authoritarian, communist and repressive regimes that everybody hates
Here I might push back a bit by saying that firstly most people would find it uncontroversial to restrict someone who attacks people or creates discomfort for them or violates the rights of children or otherwise. What this means is that there is always going to be some justification for some control over people's behaviour but the question is merely how much. It's also worthwhile to note that the people here in this context aren't actually authorities. They are random civilians who have come out thinking that they should be able to criticise anyone and under any circumstances. They are not authorities. They are random people who want to bring down authority which is the real problem at the end of the day. It's true that authorities shouldn't have a complete control over people and citizens should hold them to that but it is also unreasonable for citizens to insist that they can bring down authority at any given moment simply because they see what they perceive to be failing and then try to bring down the house without actually checking becoming popular and then bringing mob rule into play rather than actually fair adjudication.
I'm not against Christmas as it is a celebration for the Christians. For your information Muslims among themselves cannot celebrate X'mas or even wish other Muslims "A Merry Christmas" but they can wish the Christians that. No problem. Among themselves NO WAY!
Christmas is for everyone.People cannot condemn people who celebrate christmas.If you condemn then muslims cannot visit and eat with peoples of other faiths during chinese new year or deepavali or other faiths celebrations.
Islam is very respectful of other religions and their followers, including their beliefs about Christmas. However, as Muslims, we believe in the concept of absolute monotheism, which is that God is One, begets and is not begotten. Christmas, although it appears as a cultural celebration, is actually closely related to the Christian belief in the divinity of Jesus (the Prophet Jesus), which is contrary to the Islamic creed. Therefore, we do not celebrate Christmas because it can give our faith and affect the Islamic identity, but at the same time we still respect those who celebrate it
Ah, thanks! I appreciate the heart emoji as well but just know that I don’t swing that way if that’s the message, and I might make a post about this at a later time. Thank you for watching and see you in my next videos!
Some thoughts on Amar Makruf Nahi Mungkar! Thanks for watching as always, sepupus! 🤩 Link: ruclips.net/user/postUgkxIbAxnRLcYD1sIMyyl3A004FaoYUVptar?si=KoB6pnuzb-9o8jXf
Isaiah 9:6 : For unto us a child is born, unto us a Son is given: and the government shall be upon his shoulder: and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The Almighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace. This is Christmas, the Son of God come to taken away sins of the World, John 1:29.
Surah Maryam (19:30-35): "[Jesus] said, 'Indeed, I am the servant of Allah. He has given me the Scripture and made me a prophet. And He has made me blessed wherever I am and has enjoined upon me prayer and zakah as long as I remain alive. And [made me] dutiful to my mother, and He has not made me a wretched tyrant. And peace is on me the day I was born and the day I will die and the day I am raised alive.' That is Jesus, the son of Mary-the word of truth about which they are in dispute. It is not [befitting] for Allah to take a son; exalted is He! When He decrees an affair, He only says to it, 'Be,' and it is."
i once had a malay muslim friend , told me about "boomoh believer you should beware of in Malay community" , because seeing me do something innocent to something, looks like it might be, lah. this people who play boomoh (Malay's voodoo) usually will gift it to the next generation, someone should keep it as pet (worst than animal pet dog that quran refers to , because this demon is pure from satan , these angels of God won't enter house). this people who play boomoh usually will not die , the lived very long age, because the owner unable to cursed the other generation, basically need new owner to passed on, then only you can die like regular human does. so , this guy come to my mind, and i mentioned his name. My friend laughed out loud , "maybe ?...his children and later on his granddaughter had trust issues with him, who knows ?.... ahh betul cakap awak, got something"
My who worked in a Japanese firm was given a higher post with lucrative salary but you know what his malay friends did to him they were so jealous and made him become mad until his job was given to a malay this what are true Malays
I highly recommend that you add Chinese subtitles to your future videos. I'll ask my brothers and sisters to support you for sure... A civilized and rational society needs outstanding people like you who dare to express anger and speak out our right.
Thank you so much! That’s very kind of you! Actually, in response to your request, I just put in Chinese and Malay subtitles for this video as well! Just started thinking about how I need to start reaching more people at scale and I think that this is going to help with that a bit - thank you for the suggestion!
Guys Dont lah criticize the innocents kids Merry Christmas Happy New Year or Maybe Atok Sakau Birthday loh.The Pemimipin frm Pas Ulama Supreme and his Ustaz222 and henchmen wont say anything maybe thier Kids does the same in thier Homes Privately that God Knows or maybe dont Mah.
That’s interesting to think about. Shouldn’t PAS supporters have the right to know about the private lives of their leaders and the children of their leaders since people like drawing attention to even Tun M’s children?
He is hypocirte.Is he perfect himself.Is he GOD to judge others.When is he going to stop his bloody nonsense.Pls someone stop him causing disunity in the country.He is a real pain in the neck.
Here is a catch: Almost EVEYBODY knows what Mahathir did that cause problem to Malaysia. The question should how do people Hadi be ANYMORE different than the musang tua himself by doing the fitnah this and there no matter what? I don't EVER recall any religions telling people to do mob justice?
was and still wondering about :. 1. why so many issues are on religion issue..?. 2. why so issues to improve muslim livellihood / welfare/economy..etc..?..... 3. Why always through political platform to voice out?...4. what has other religious ngo, persatuan, organisation has to commend.?. 5. who fight for further reform... not only to expose corruptors...BUT must fight for reform in the government admin controlling system ( govt should change)... Please commend to enlighten me..hope this is a good
@StLieDetecterFoo-n9v The verse tells women to cover their chests and lower their gazes. Most adult Muslim women cover their hairs(head) and show their faces. 🤲🕌
Bro, If you have time commenting the battle of Xmass than Malaysia is fine. Its first world problems. Here in Poland we had a dude who runs with fire extingusher beacause he dislikes hanooka candels. Cheer up, enjoy the great Malay whether
Oh wow! You’re commenting all the way from Poland?! That’s super cool! I think I might have seen that somewhere, but I don’t immediately remember - I will look it up! Thank you for the wish, and enjoy your dumplings (amongst other things - but wait what do you eat LOL) and your own variant of awesome weather as well!
Is not fine. What is brewing is a “cold community conflict” that haven’t reach the social unrest level. And is regrettable minorities in Malaysia can’t have civil right movement and neither can atheist/agnostic congregate nor organize.
Actually it has to be all of us. The Malays alone are not enough. There needs to be a genuine unity that comes from transcending differences and not being too calculative about what is different between us, although realistically it would just be an understanding that look, we want the future to be better than the past in several specific areas such as economy, diversity, national reputation, and strength, and we need to be clear that political manipulation and religious manipulation cannot be on the table. The fears that the Malays have need to be better assuaged and managed, and people have to become genuinely better friends with their Malay brothers and sisters. That is the pathway going forward - we cannot be caught constantly in this I FIGHT YOU YOU FIGHT ME nonsense.
@@VictorTantoo idealistic VT. Something has got to give. Only solution is to remove race and religion from government and all public institutions, reintroduce meritocracy from school right to retirement, fine-tune social security and allow economy to flourish.
Hmmmm. I hear you but suggesting that 15 year old, personalities with bad record shouldn't say anything might also be a form of gaslighting? It's 2025 and now anyone can say anything. And maybe we just have to live with that. What we should do is engage these influencers and their supporters on their turf. Let's pursue truth and believe it will ultimately win.
Ah yes, thanks Adrian - you caught upon the nuance that I observed, which is that perhaps the authorities shouldn't do anything and that, at the end of the day, it is only civil society and ‘the marketplace of ideas’ that should do anything. (But is that certain?) In a way, we are then in alignment. I do think that people in our society should develop a requisite awareness of the deceptions that people want to bring upon them and that they perpetuate over and over again. Just because these narratives are popular, the emotions of supporters compel them to do so; they do not read, they do not check, they do not decide upon what may actually be the better options - measures of expression of emotion (number of likes and shares) become barometers of truth. You could say that people know themselves best certainly and always, but anyone who has ever graded exams would know that such a statement is only of limited truth and that if we look at any number of objective metrics, there we can see that the students of our world and in Malaysia, and by extension the adults who had risen amongst them, may not be able to evaluate matters correctly even as the resonance of emotional truth calls out amidst the corroborating evidence that many Malaysians barely read anything except the headlines of articles, and there we are, standing in the eventuality of things only as evidence of plausibility and not objective truth. It's true that anyone can say anything, Adrian, but what does it mean when the people have such a low level of critical thinking on average, that inevitably, because of the random accidental collisions of ideas and discussions, only the narratives that come from the lowest common denominator of our society and those that are most plausible, should win out? This is a call for that which reflects reasoning to become more popular. But also to consider that our authorities should look at evaluating speech that is nearly emotive or targeted at playing upon emotions, sifting it from what we deem as true in the interim (understand this is a potential problematic point but we can talk about it), and while people are still developing an inchoate awareness of how to become good participants in a democratic society. In other words, while I understand the spirit of what you are saying, reality is a different matter; less abstractly, it is definitively untrue that ‘anyone can say anything they want’ in 2025 - which in any case is untrue already restricted because of restrictions on incitement, defamation, true threats and otherwise, aimed at preventing danger at large. It is well that the U.S. even now has realised that freedom for the wolves has often meant death to the sheep, and wisely pays lip service to that freedom in respect of genuine democratic discourse in the public sphere and even healthily defends it at critical junctures through entities like the ACLU in the context of speech on public figures, but also regulates it as is expected in the context of capitalist enterprise and also on platforms for the equally valid purpose of maintaining societal harmony and order. Laws such as the Sedition Act aim to restrict danger and harmful speech (which I concede carries an overly broad meaning and can be abused, yes; that is why criticism has been meted against PH for not repealing it) and can be criticized for what people see as their authoritarian nature, yes, but already in Malaysia, we are seeing the dangers of allowing free speech to run wild, and how it allows dangerous individuals who facilitate slander and to question the Royal Institution maliciously to go wild. I think we can agree that questioning institutions purely on the basis of one's own morality or emotions in a fashion that can destroy them without any evidential basis is certainly something that this country should more narrowly prescribe, defining better conditions and a clear punishment and deterrence regime to ensure it is clear to society what can or cannot be done and what direction gravity acts in, and if people do not follow those rules, it is well that gravity should act.
If anybody is wondering why Muslims cannot celebrate other religion's celebrations, please go to the rightful authority and listen to their explaination. It will clear all the doubts.
What wrong with Christmas celebrations that there just have a great time during Christmas. Where is satu Malaysia?? It's all fake satu Malaysia! Malaya is too proud of there own, but not to others!!
Islam is very respectful of other religions and their followers, including their beliefs about Christmas. However, as Muslims, we believe in the concept of absolute monotheism, which is that God is One, begets and is not begotten. Christmas, although it appears as a cultural celebration, is actually closely related to the Christian belief in the divinity of Jesus (the Prophet Jesus), which is contrary to the Islamic creed. Therefore, we do not celebrate Christmas because it can give our faith and affect the Islamic identity, but at the same time we still respect those who celebrate it
Wait, she is Mahathir's granddaughter? This is something. I have to be honest: No matter what wrong things Mahathir did in his past that to Malaysia's current situation, though the ONLY thing he did right in his life was making sure even the monarchy play the rules, some people like her granddaughter shouldn't even baring her grandfather's sins. Folks such as the ever infamous Agamaku Zealots (PAS) are the LAST folks to ever talk about morals because of their obsession about "agama ialah moral" thing is NEVER sihat for a country.
Yup! People shouldn’t be going after his granddaughter for a Christmas celebration and frankly neither should ANYONE else. This kind of tegur culture is seriously sickening and I know for a fact that it’s something that A LOT of Malaysians and friends have been sick of for years now and consider a legit reason to actually leave Malaysia. And I don’t mean Chinese or anyone else - this is specifically Malay friends… But it doesn’t mean I don’t see it or that I can’t understand it 😔
Malaysia was a truly great multi culture country people of all walk of life coexist until mathatir came along destroy unity separate them into non bumi Putra instigating hatred among the people of malaysia hopping they would fight among themselves for more than 22 years, even at the age of 95 he still would not drop his snake tongue like the chopsticks and patriotism vernacular schools and if you think PAS and our race base politicians are racist it's because they learn from mathatir, do your homework the root cause of why malaysia politicians are unbecoming of their appointment, these politicians are using race and religion cards to gain voters and support for them to have a seat in the parliament, once they secure their seat it's easy for them to play with the cookie jar know that the more they steal the more hand kisses and respect they gets
@@ChuanTeh I feel like Tun hangs on to this world and has lived to this age specifically because he wants to see the Malays succeed at scale and that is why he is hanging on to the world, and that is a reason as to why he remains in this world. When we spoke, he sounded pensive, regretful almost because he knew that his goal had not come true even though his family became very rich in the course of time. I might not be able to comment on that, but I can certainly comment on the fact that he very likely does believe what he said about the Malays being lazy even though he denied those ideas later on. That much I can definitely say for sure. Whatever it is, it is certainly also Tun M who wrote the famous Tunku Abdul Rahman poison pen letter and circulated it - A regrettable thing to do but I definitely think, based on every single thing that he said and everything I could read from actually interacting with him, that he genuinely feels that the Malays are weak and have to be protected and that he did what he did with that in mind. 😔
Pada dasarnya Islam tidak mengharamkan hiburan selagi tidak bertentangan dengan hukum syarak dan tidak mengandungi unsur keagamaan agama lain. Oleh itu, hukum menyertai Christmas Carolling adalah haram kerana lirik lagu-lagunya yang mengandungi unsur agama Kristian dan bercanggah dengan syarak. Umat Islam hendaklah menjauhi upacara-upacara keagamaan agama lain sama ada dalam bentuk nyanyian atau lainnya.
Well in their mind it’s not a minor issue, either that or they really didn’t think it over and they think genuinely IF TAK TEGUR THEN CANNOT DO WELL IN AKHIRAT or I MUST LOVE MY FELLOW BROTHERS AND SISTERS. How many % genuine? I estimate less than 5%, and most people saja fire bullets only 😭
PAS is afraid of cross , bible , xmas trees n songs.
Sounds a bit like vampires tbh 🤦🏻♂️🧛♂️
But they're never shy of the berjalan sambil belajar at Petaling street to catch the delicious whiff of smoking bak Kua smell.😅😊
And books
Because they have nothing in their brains to suggest anything concrete for the benefit of the country except to say things like wearing shorts is haram and corruptions by certain people is halal.
What they are most afraid is the truth !not the season or celebration. That is why they are ao naive and weak . And .....
Wow! This video is damn owesome, which is only 7 minutes long, it states all my dissatisfaction with these extremists and what they have done again and again to fool their supporters for many decades.
I hope that more people will see this video, especially PAS supporters. Thank you very much Victor Tan
Ha ha, it’s been something I’ve been thinking about for a while! Thank you so much, and it’s an honor to have your kind words! In a small way, I hope that they will see it as well, but really it is up to the algorithm and it is also up to them to change as people! Thank you so much for the support, and look forward to seeing you in my next video!
U think too highly of those PA$ $upporter$.. eg Dr. $iti Ma$tool.lah of the Lim GuavJew fame!😅
D problem is tun is d advisor of pas d so call muslim party...we msian ignored those chrismas activities joy...but tun d saka 99 is d main problem..
WHY..??????
God bless you brother we need people like you
Thank you so much! That’s very kind of you, and I look forward to seeing you and everyone else in my next videos! Thank you so much for the support!
Awesome video 💪🏻bro...so far i never see any PAS goons making any comment on this cucu atok...😃😆
Hey thank you Joshua! I recall that you suggested it btw xD
It was interesting to think about, and to also think about the broader concept of Amar Makruf Nahi Mungkar - something I’ve always been thinking about and that I keep thinking is hypocritical just cause it keeps getting used for the most inane reasons 😭
No idea if they’re going to comment on this, but what I can see is that since they’re siding with DS Najib (I might make a video about that), that might mean a chilling of the relationship between the PAS goons and Tun M 🤣
Thank you for watching!
@@VictorTanyeah they will keep their mouth shut for awhile...😃...keep it up bro...
@@VictorTanThey wouldn't leave comments here as they know they are not your match when it comes to debating the truth.
Why ???? Bcos atok saka tua is pas advisor...advised on what ???? How to sakau d govt money & push anwar down to grieve....when is this atok going to.....
They just enjoy their fresh young life and celebrate their fellow Malaysians big day.. Nothing wrong with that,
Amen.
Malaysia should NOT be busybodies in this kind of thing when there are FAR MORE IMPORTANT THINGS that people are not speaking up about. 😔
In her case, it was not about "Christmas extremists", celebrated Christmas is HARAM (forbidden) in Islam & there is no problem if Muslims send a Christmas greets to Christians community. But at same, PAS is HYPOCRITED! They blamed Anwar Ibrahim as "liberal" but at same time Mahathir family are more liberal & secularist than Anwar Ibrahim who are mostly weared a hijab than Mahathir family. PAS never criticized Mahathir family.
@@emierdanish2002 And this adding a fact Christmas should NEVER a problem to Malaysia once upon a time here.
Sebab pas rapat dengan tun m. Orang pas kedah suka tun m sebab cara dia bawa diri adalah cara orang kampung.
Bullies only attack the weak.
They are jelouse that people are having fun
That’s part of it! I think they also just want to get clout and bring down famous people so that their own stars can rise 😭
Generally, I have very little faith in these people, and I do not think that they have good intentions - if they would, then they would be using their ability to criticize for better causes 😭
@@oliverlazaroo346 AMEN 🙏🏻
She knows what she doing because she is educated
of course she is but educated doesnt mean their IQ is high these days. i mean you have doctors like Akmal Bebop, PhD holder Siti Mastura, The doctor Rahmah cancer. Just to name a few domestic ones. on international level, university students and professor cant explain explain what a woman is..
Sensible argument Victor!! 👍👍
Thank you for the kind words, Boon! 👍 Appreciate it, glad that made sense, and look forward to seeing you in my next videos!
Leave her alone. She's not causing a public nuisance. Respect her privacy please!
privacy?? nah.. she is a M people. although we are not Muslims, it is our duty to remind her of what her tok guru said. even her atok is now tok guru close pal.
I am Your Fan ! Fantastic Contents in ALL your podcasts Sir!❤
Thank you for watching and see you in the next ones! 👍
@@VictorTan ❤️
I watched your video till the end and everything you said is the absolute truth. Today I was having roti canai breakfast with my son at our favourite stall.I was recently widowed and suddenly a lady in veil approached me and blah.....blah away.😮 Why cant she respect other people privacy🙄?
Thanks for watching and I’m sorry to hear that! I hope the culture can change! I guess it starts with choosing to mind your own business, although for a lot of these people they’ve always believed that it was the right thing for them to do to go out and speak to people and tell them that what they’re doing is wrong. I think it takeseffort to realign all of that and some people might just think that it’s completely wrong and refuse to do it after all 😭
Anwar is really weak! Bar council peaceful memorandum walk is stopped by police.. Yet this bigotry perhimpunan is allowed?😢🎉
To be somewhat fair, I think that the Anwar administration tries to control what it can control, and does not control what it thinks it cannot control - it’s not that this makes his administration look good in any way, especially since it displays such an appalling lack of ability when it comes to managing perceptions or messaging, but at least it is understandable.
I believe the challenge now is to create a civil society where it is not only acceptable but also expected and pushed on by all members of the rakyat, whether Malay, Chinese, or Indian, that the government should take action against PAS as we begin to influence PDRM, the military, and every other entity to move in that direction and therefore to begin to locate the people who are selling out extremism in our society.
We know after all that Madani allegedly wants to govern in a way that is fair and inclusive, which as we have seen basically means that they will never take action in a meaningful way on things unless it becomes clear that their hand is being forced and the universe is on their side, that something has to be done.
How will we get to the point where it becomes decisively normal and our government will just casually and happily claim credit once it finally calls for a probe and an operation? That is a step-by-step process that Malaysia should walk towards every single day 😭
@VictorTan Exactly! but we humans are all short term creatures.. can be justify as most of us can only think rationally up to 70-80 yrs of age! But n years down the road, with increasing speed+change in technology, the feudal system is kaput! as all humans wanted to be equal and fair share of the piece of economical and power cake.
This is what happen if Anwar still the PM. He is a very weak leader and have no vision at all.
@danielyee9159 However currently there's no other better Pm! Who would u suggest anyway?
Btw in the future it'll be even more worrisome and bleak! Only Rafizi .. At least he's seen to be clean & less corrupt! Khairul & A$$min all hopeless, so is $yed $addiq.. & definitely not those Dumbno, Ber$atu & PAS racist youth leaders!
It's not fair, all the nons are enjoying various festivals with colours, lights, new fashionable clothing, drinks and food. The nons work hard and celebrating happily.
Please commed.. kenapa tidak ada pihak yang menganjur perhimpunan bantah pendatang / pekerja tanpa izin... ?. mereka yang rampas peluang raktya dan kewangan malaysia ( berbillion ke negara merekan setiap tahun) dengan masala sosial.... sebaliknya pas bantah lain isu
Malaysian are no longer Malaysian we know in the 60s and 70s
This is a common thread, but in my opinion it accomplishes nothing except allow you to maintain an illusion in your head.
Encourage you not to look at what you call the ‘good old days’ and instead focus your mind on the present and ask what specific and small thing you can do to make Malaysia closer to what you envision as its ideal state. 👍
But they keep saying satu Malaysia, bullshit all along the way😂😂 liar until die😂😂🤣
@@johngorden2601"Satu Malaysia" was Najib's motto.
PAS' motto is, "No secularism"!
Hey Victor!
Do you know what??!
I really enjoy watching your videos. Your contents are not just simply spitting out FACTS. But, what really entertained me was your head, hand and finger movement when you talk (Especially when you pointing your finger at *cough PAS *cough, I mean the camera) Just like an Orchestral Conductor… 😂😂😂
LOLLLL thank you for the kind sharing! All the better to entertain, educate, and hang out, chill, brainw… I MEAN share messages that I think are important with the world!
That aside, I think making videos and being able to influence thousands of people is fun - it helps to develop your personality, and also to learn how to articulate yourself in better ways. I could not do this without all of you, and I look forward to following the path of truth in the days ahead as well - thank you for following my strange dances and fun facts, and I look forward to seeing you again! 🤩
Controlling other people's behaviour is wrong no matter what excuses you use.Using fear, threat to make people to conform is counter productive, because you cannot control what people think.More productive to inspire people to change through our love ,respect and
honour.When authorities uses force , what makes them diffrent from fascist, authoritarian, communist and repressive regimes that everybody hates
Here I might push back a bit by saying that firstly most people would find it uncontroversial to restrict someone who attacks people or creates discomfort for them or violates the rights of children or otherwise.
What this means is that there is always going to be some justification for some control over people's behaviour but the question is merely how much.
It's also worthwhile to note that the people here in this context aren't actually authorities.
They are random civilians who have come out thinking that they should be able to criticise anyone and under any circumstances. They are not authorities. They are random people who want to bring down authority which is the real problem at the end of the day. It's true that authorities shouldn't have a complete control over people and citizens should hold them to that but it is also unreasonable for citizens to insist that they can bring down authority at any given moment simply because they see what they perceive to be failing and then try to bring down the house without actually checking becoming popular and then bringing mob rule into play rather than actually fair adjudication.
Extremist party like PAS is like that. Only they are right in every thing but others are wrong. Thats why people siad PAS are PARTI SESAT
Malaysians need content creator like yourself. Keep on going! 👍🏽
Appreciate it! Thank you for the kind words bro! 🙏
I'm not against Christmas as it is a celebration for the Christians. For your information Muslims among themselves cannot celebrate X'mas or even wish other Muslims "A Merry Christmas" but they can wish the Christians that. No problem. Among themselves NO WAY!
Thanks for the sharing of your perspective!
Christmas is for everyone.People cannot condemn people who celebrate christmas.If you condemn then muslims cannot visit and eat with peoples of other faiths during chinese new year or deepavali or other faiths celebrations.
CNY ang pao also haram for them 😂😂😂
Islam is very respectful of other religions and their followers, including their beliefs about Christmas. However, as Muslims, we believe in the concept of absolute monotheism, which is that God is One, begets and is not begotten. Christmas, although it appears as a cultural celebration, is actually closely related to the Christian belief in the divinity of Jesus (the Prophet Jesus), which is contrary to the Islamic creed. Therefore, we do not celebrate Christmas because it can give our faith and affect the Islamic identity, but at the same time we still respect those who celebrate it
Well as ex CCP and Kuomintang supporter I agree to this behavior as I already had huge Social Credit
True or not that Mahathir very very rich becoming PM over the yrs?
MAN OF ACTION.👍❤️
Ah, thanks! I appreciate the heart emoji as well but just know that I don’t swing that way if that’s the message, and I might make a post about this at a later time.
Thank you for watching and see you in my next videos!
V TAN WELCOME,👍❤️
Some thoughts on Amar Makruf Nahi Mungkar!
Thanks for watching as always, sepupus! 🤩
Link: ruclips.net/user/postUgkxIbAxnRLcYD1sIMyyl3A004FaoYUVptar?si=KoB6pnuzb-9o8jXf
Isaiah 9:6 : For unto us a child is born, unto us a Son is given: and the government shall be upon his shoulder: and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The Almighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace. This is Christmas, the Son of God come to taken away sins of the World, John 1:29.
Surah Maryam (19:30-35):
"[Jesus] said, 'Indeed, I am the servant of Allah. He has given me the Scripture and made me a prophet. And He has made me blessed wherever I am and has enjoined upon me prayer and zakah as long as I remain alive. And [made me] dutiful to my mother, and He has not made me a wretched tyrant. And peace is on me the day I was born and the day I will die and the day I am raised alive.' That is Jesus, the son of Mary-the word of truth about which they are in dispute. It is not [befitting] for Allah to take a son; exalted is He! When He decrees an affair, He only says to it, 'Be,' and it is."
i once had a malay muslim friend , told me about "boomoh believer you should beware of in Malay community" , because seeing me do something innocent to something, looks like it might be, lah.
this people who play boomoh (Malay's voodoo) usually will gift it to the next generation, someone should keep it as pet (worst than animal pet dog that quran refers to , because this demon is pure from satan , these angels of God won't enter house).
this people who play boomoh usually will not die , the lived very long age, because the owner unable to cursed the other generation, basically need new owner to passed on, then only you can die like regular human does.
so ,
this guy come to my mind, and i mentioned his name.
My friend laughed out loud , "maybe ?...his children and later on his granddaughter had trust issues with him, who knows ?.... ahh betul cakap awak, got something"
My who worked in a Japanese firm was given a higher post with lucrative salary but you know what his malay friends did to him they were so jealous and made him become mad until his job was given to a malay this what are true Malays
I highly recommend that you add Chinese subtitles to your future videos. I'll ask my brothers and sisters to support you for sure...
A civilized and rational society needs outstanding people like you who dare to express anger and speak out our right.
Thank you so much! That’s very kind of you! Actually, in response to your request, I just put in Chinese and Malay subtitles for this video as well!
Just started thinking about how I need to start reaching more people at scale and I think that this is going to help with that a bit - thank you for the suggestion!
@@VictorTanyeah.. U need to add more other languages..
Guys Dont lah criticize the innocents kids Merry Christmas Happy New Year or Maybe Atok Sakau Birthday loh.The Pemimipin frm Pas Ulama Supreme and his Ustaz222 and henchmen wont say anything maybe thier Kids does the same in thier Homes Privately that God Knows or maybe dont Mah.
That’s interesting to think about. Shouldn’t PAS supporters have the right to know about the private lives of their leaders and the children of their leaders since people like drawing attention to even Tun M’s children?
love each people s very important than this isu.
He is hypocirte.Is he perfect himself.Is he GOD to judge others.When is he going to stop his bloody nonsense.Pls someone stop him causing disunity in the country.He is a real pain in the neck.
Here is a catch: Almost EVEYBODY knows what Mahathir did that cause problem to Malaysia. The question should how do people Hadi be ANYMORE different than the musang tua himself by doing the fitnah this and there no matter what?
I don't EVER recall any religions telling people to do mob justice?
was and still wondering about :. 1. why so many issues are on religion issue..?. 2. why so issues to improve muslim livellihood / welfare/economy..etc..?..... 3. Why always through political platform to voice out?...4. what has other religious ngo, persatuan, organisation has to commend.?. 5. who fight for further reform... not only to expose corruptors...BUT must fight for reform in the government admin controlling system ( govt should change)... Please commend to enlighten me..hope this is a good
OMG zero discipline on themselves. Perhaps the upbringing and the premier leadership is the main cause.
Why? They have the right to celebrate whatever they want.
It’s not really your business or the business of any Malaysians, yes? 😔
Many also blamed that Atok's family women don't wear the hijab!
Atok's wife wears a wig, as she doesn't have natural hair. A doctor told me! 😂🇲🇾
There is no cover head for women but cover face. Quran 24:31. Young girls cover face is very important.
@StLieDetecterFoo-n9v The verse tells women to cover their chests and lower their gazes.
Most adult Muslim women cover their hairs(head) and show their faces. 🤲🕌
@@StLieDetecterFoo-n9v😊 and it Not even from allah 😊😊 or Muhammad but rather Umar Ibn kattap😊😊😊
Fools seldom differ!
Bro, If you have time commenting the battle of Xmass than Malaysia is fine. Its first world problems. Here in Poland we had a dude who runs with fire extingusher beacause he dislikes hanooka candels. Cheer up, enjoy the great Malay whether
Oh wow! You’re commenting all the way from Poland?! That’s super cool! I think I might have seen that somewhere, but I don’t immediately remember - I will look it up! Thank you for the wish, and enjoy your dumplings (amongst other things - but wait what do you eat LOL) and your own variant of awesome weather as well!
Is not fine. What is brewing is a “cold community conflict” that haven’t reach the social unrest level. And is regrettable minorities in Malaysia can’t have civil right movement and neither can atheist/agnostic congregate nor organize.
Poland have a GREATEST Prime Minister
No matter what n how much we say...its now ONLY THE MALAYS can STOP these EXTREMIST NONSENSE
Actually it has to be all of us.
The Malays alone are not enough.
There needs to be a genuine unity that comes from transcending differences and not being too calculative about what is different between us, although realistically it would just be an understanding that look, we want the future to be better than the past in several specific areas such as economy, diversity, national reputation, and strength, and we need to be clear that political manipulation and religious manipulation cannot be on the table.
The fears that the Malays have need to be better assuaged and managed, and people have to become genuinely better friends with their Malay brothers and sisters. That is the pathway going forward - we cannot be caught constantly in this I FIGHT YOU YOU FIGHT ME nonsense.
@@VictorTantoo idealistic VT. Something has got to give.
Only solution is to remove race and religion from government and all public institutions, reintroduce meritocracy from school right to retirement, fine-tune social security and allow economy to flourish.
Hmmmm. I hear you but suggesting that 15 year old, personalities with bad record shouldn't say anything might also be a form of gaslighting?
It's 2025 and now anyone can say anything. And maybe we just have to live with that. What we should do is engage these influencers and their supporters on their turf. Let's pursue truth and believe it will ultimately win.
Ah yes, thanks Adrian - you caught upon the nuance that I observed, which is that perhaps the authorities shouldn't do anything and that, at the end of the day, it is only civil society and ‘the marketplace of ideas’ that should do anything. (But is that certain?)
In a way, we are then in alignment.
I do think that people in our society should develop a requisite awareness of the deceptions that people want to bring upon them and that they perpetuate over and over again.
Just because these narratives are popular, the emotions of supporters compel them to do so; they do not read, they do not check, they do not decide upon what may actually be the better options - measures of expression of emotion (number of likes and shares) become barometers of truth.
You could say that people know themselves best certainly and always, but anyone who has ever graded exams would know that such a statement is only of limited truth and that if we look at any number of objective metrics, there we can see that the students of our world and in Malaysia, and by extension the adults who had risen amongst them, may not be able to evaluate matters correctly even as the resonance of emotional truth calls out amidst the corroborating evidence that many Malaysians barely read anything except the headlines of articles, and there we are, standing in the eventuality of things only as evidence of plausibility and not objective truth.
It's true that anyone can say anything, Adrian, but what does it mean when the people have such a low level of critical thinking on average, that inevitably, because of the random accidental collisions of ideas and discussions, only the narratives that come from the lowest common denominator of our society and those that are most plausible, should win out?
This is a call for that which reflects reasoning to become more popular. But also to consider that our authorities should look at evaluating speech that is nearly emotive or targeted at playing upon emotions, sifting it from what we deem as true in the interim (understand this is a potential problematic point but we can talk about it), and while people are still developing an inchoate awareness of how to become good participants in a democratic society.
In other words, while I understand the spirit of what you are saying, reality is a different matter; less abstractly, it is definitively untrue that ‘anyone can say anything they want’ in 2025 - which in any case is untrue already restricted because of restrictions on incitement, defamation, true threats and otherwise, aimed at preventing danger at large.
It is well that the U.S. even now has realised that freedom for the wolves has often meant death to the sheep, and wisely pays lip service to that freedom in respect of genuine democratic discourse in the public sphere and even healthily defends it at critical junctures through entities like the ACLU in the context of speech on public figures, but also regulates it as is expected in the context of capitalist enterprise and also on platforms for the equally valid purpose of maintaining societal harmony and order.
Laws such as the Sedition Act aim to restrict danger and harmful speech (which I concede carries an overly broad meaning and can be abused, yes; that is why criticism has been meted against PH for not repealing it) and can be criticized for what people see as their authoritarian nature, yes, but already in Malaysia, we are seeing the dangers of allowing free speech to run wild, and how it allows dangerous individuals who facilitate slander and to question the Royal Institution maliciously to go wild.
I think we can agree that questioning institutions purely on the basis of one's own morality or emotions in a fashion that can destroy them without any evidential basis is certainly something that this country should more narrowly prescribe, defining better conditions and a clear punishment and deterrence regime to ensure it is clear to society what can or cannot be done and what direction gravity acts in, and if people do not follow those rules, it is well that gravity should act.
Holier than thou ..
My head hurts
If anybody is wondering why Muslims cannot celebrate other religion's celebrations, please go to the rightful authority and listen to their explaination.
It will clear all the doubts.
What wrong with Christmas celebrations that there just have a great time during Christmas. Where is satu Malaysia?? It's all fake satu Malaysia! Malaya is too proud of there own, but not to others!!
Islam is very respectful of other religions and their followers, including their beliefs about Christmas. However, as Muslims, we believe in the concept of absolute monotheism, which is that God is One, begets and is not begotten. Christmas, although it appears as a cultural celebration, is actually closely related to the Christian belief in the divinity of Jesus (the Prophet Jesus), which is contrary to the Islamic creed. Therefore, we do not celebrate Christmas because it can give our faith and affect the Islamic identity, but at the same time we still respect those who celebrate it
50% of the malays just follow. Join the crowd for what???
Wait, she is Mahathir's granddaughter? This is something.
I have to be honest: No matter what wrong things Mahathir did in his past that to Malaysia's current situation, though the ONLY thing he did right in his life was making sure even the monarchy play the rules, some people like her granddaughter shouldn't even baring her grandfather's sins.
Folks such as the ever infamous Agamaku Zealots (PAS) are the LAST folks to ever talk about morals because of their obsession about "agama ialah moral" thing is NEVER sihat for a country.
Yup! People shouldn’t be going after his granddaughter for a Christmas celebration and frankly neither should ANYONE else.
This kind of tegur culture is seriously sickening and I know for a fact that it’s something that A LOT of Malaysians and friends have been sick of for years now and consider a legit reason to actually leave Malaysia.
And I don’t mean Chinese or anyone else - this is specifically Malay friends… But it doesn’t mean I don’t see it or that I can’t understand it 😔
Malaysia was a truly great multi culture country people of all walk of life coexist until mathatir came along destroy unity separate them into non bumi Putra instigating hatred among the people of malaysia hopping they would fight among themselves for more than 22 years, even at the age of 95 he still would not drop his snake tongue like the chopsticks and patriotism vernacular schools and if you think PAS and our race base politicians are racist it's because they learn from mathatir, do your homework the root cause of why malaysia politicians are unbecoming of their appointment, these politicians are using race and religion cards to gain voters and support for them to have a seat in the parliament, once they secure their seat it's easy for them to play with the cookie jar know that the more they steal the more hand kisses and respect they gets
@@ChuanTeh
I feel like Tun hangs on to this world and has lived to this age specifically because he wants to see the Malays succeed at scale and that is why he is hanging on to the world, and that is a reason as to why he remains in this world.
When we spoke, he sounded pensive, regretful almost because he knew that his goal had not come true even though his family became very rich in the course of time.
I might not be able to comment on that, but I can certainly comment on the fact that he very likely does believe what he said about the Malays being lazy even though he denied those ideas later on. That much I can definitely say for sure.
Whatever it is, it is certainly also Tun M who wrote the famous Tunku Abdul Rahman poison pen letter and circulated it - A regrettable thing to do but I definitely think, based on every single thing that he said and everything I could read from actually interacting with him, that he genuinely feels that the Malays are weak and have to be protected and that he did what he did with that in mind. 😔
Dude, I watch your videos to learn how to speak better English😊
Oh, I’m glad that you do! Hopefully I didn’t mislead you or anything! Good luck on your English language journey!
STUPID PEOPLE JUST DOING THINGS WITHOUT THINKING ....
This 🌍 Alwz safe 4 GD Samaritan....
you dance better than them .
LOLLLL Thank you! For all you know, I have been practicing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Pada dasarnya Islam tidak mengharamkan hiburan selagi tidak bertentangan dengan hukum syarak dan tidak mengandungi unsur keagamaan agama lain. Oleh itu, hukum menyertai Christmas Carolling adalah haram kerana lirik lagu-lagunya yang mengandungi unsur agama Kristian dan bercanggah dengan syarak. Umat Islam hendaklah menjauhi upacara-upacara keagamaan agama lain sama ada dalam bentuk nyanyian atau lainnya.
Very well said… the World of Hypocrisies … just like the grandfather .. King of Hyppo Malaysia …😂😂😂😂
1:15
Ｍａｍａｋ ｔｕａ ｌｕｄａｈ ｌａｎｇｉｔ
Tipu Melayu.
Why those peoples complainted minor issue didn!t they know that Mohamat and Jesus R messanger of God?
Well in their mind it’s not a minor issue, either that or they really didn’t think it over and they think genuinely IF TAK TEGUR THEN CANNOT DO WELL IN AKHIRAT or I MUST LOVE MY FELLOW BROTHERS AND SISTERS.
How many % genuine? I estimate less than 5%, and most people saja fire bullets only 😭