Hang on, you might be right! The next high note is A flat, and it sounds as if the pianist went up only one tone to play the A flat. So she did play a G flat! Weird... Anyway, thanks for your comment (and I apologise for replying rather rudely to your previous comment!)
Maybe the performer didn't want to bother to change from an E to a G and so just played the E as a G...? Or maybe her sheet music was a different edition to the one shown here (this is the Klindworth Edition (Bote & Bock issue), Vol. 2). Oh well...
I don't know... It sounds different compared all the other versions I can find on youtube. And on my sheet music, the note in the 49th measure is the same b flat as in the 1st, 5th, 9th, 13th, and 53rd.
Ok, the piano doesn't have a good sound, and there's the issue of the edition (I've been told Mikulik's one is the best). But the clear, articulated execution seems exactly fit for this study, far from grandiloquent others.
@fwcraigslist Sadly, she is playing a pleyel from Chopins time. I find this a disgrace, being that she tries to "reproduce" the sound chopin had during his time. But I think she fails to understand that a 200 year old instrument wont sound the way it sounded 200 years ago.
Haha, I definitely don't have perfect pitch. But I've been listening to the piece so many times by know that I thought I recognised a note that seemed to be completely wrong. You don't agree?
I really enjoyed this. Especially like the last 20 seconds/last page, sounds beautiful and not of this world
Hang on, you might be right!
The next high note is A flat, and it sounds as if the pianist went up only one tone to play the A flat. So she did play a G flat! Weird...
Anyway, thanks for your comment (and I apologise for replying rather rudely to your previous comment!)
1:40 I think the ending should not be a diminuendo
Whats the sound before start?? Weak sound of black keys..
There is a white key at 1:20!!! I thought this piece was called black key. And i believe that’s the only white key in this piece
i believe i saw many natural accidental markings throughout the piece tho
if it wasn't for this sheet I was sure the tempo revolved around 240 bpm (or more precisely relying on the sheet 232bpm)
+plazasta I saw your other comment.
ManticTac which other one? The one where I got called an idiot for not knowing this?
spectacular rendition!
and this is even one of the slowest out there
Is there a wrong note around 1:00?
Mandy W yes
Yes
Op. 25 no 5?
Who cares
Music college recitals be like: *"OoOOo, wrong note! You are now banished from society for your horrendous performance on stage!"*
That song sounds really fast! My brother played that piece before!
i mean if you really think about it it's just eighth notes on the left hand sixteenth notes on the right
Maybe the performer didn't want to bother to change from an E to a G and so just played the E as a G...? Or maybe her sheet music was a different edition to the one shown here (this is the Klindworth Edition (Bote & Bock issue), Vol. 2). Oh well...
I don't know... It sounds different compared all the other versions I can find on youtube. And on my sheet music, the note in the 49th measure is the same b flat as in the 1st, 5th, 9th, 13th, and 53rd.
Ok, the piano doesn't have a good sound, and there's the issue of the edition (I've been told Mikulik's one is the best). But the clear, articulated execution seems exactly fit for this study, far from grandiloquent others.
actually its how its supposed to be played, i compared the note to the notes on the sheet music. its right =D
It's actuall an E-FLAT, not an E! Yes, and it's not a G; I don't know why it's meant to be a G (flat!) anyway.
Better name for Gb Major is F# Major!!!!
@fwcraigslist Sadly, she is playing a pleyel from Chopins time. I find this a disgrace, being that she tries to "reproduce" the sound chopin had during his time. But I think she fails to understand that a 200 year old instrument wont sound the way it sounded 200 years ago.
Mistake at 1:00?
I love this piece, though.
Terrific playing, but why does the treble sound so shallow?
Haha, I definitely don't have perfect pitch. But I've been listening to the piece so many times by know that I thought I recognised a note that seemed to be completely wrong. You don't agree?
@tomekkobialka maybe chopin didnt have e's on his piano
what brand of piano is she playing? I will not buy it! hahahaha
lol
Honkey tonk
😂
Wow u commented that when I was three years old
@@zmusic897 POGGERS
@dragonfly3895 its called 'black keys' eetude wat do u think
The piano... it clicked at me.
The high pitched notes sound not right-
@tomekkobialka where is the link?
ugh i need more practice.. its endless lol
OMG FREAKING ENDLESS
Ooh elden ring I win
Your edition is incorrect, it is in fact a Gb instead of the Eb shown in your edition. Performer plays it correctly.
The piano is not good in playing high notes it sounds like a harp:)
it's a bit too slow
honeybee naaah
bullshit
lol
Either you're high on speed, or you're joking
@@ForeverFall Shes right though. Not that it matters much but the marked tempo is 116bpm while this is around 100-105 (measures with metronom)