wow, i LOVE the way you did this comparison video.. you get to point, which a lot of girls don't do, you show close ups for the tips, side by side, close ups of the application on eye.. this is exactly what i look for when i'm trying to see a review video. love it, keep it up
I have watched A LOT of makeup review videos today, and I have to tell you that this is BY FAR the most no-nonsense ,concise ,and informative way of presenting and comparing products! Not to say that it lacks entertainment value because it does, but it you don't get caught up in a cult of personality like many youtubers today, and I appreciate that!
This was such a thorough and super helpful review. I've been torn between the two and this review helped me make my decision. I'm going with the Stila because of the felt pen and the color choices (even though I'm not a fan of the color bleeding lol).
Kat von d tattoo liner is my all time favorite eyeliner! The Stila one is almost just as good but i feel like felt tip eyeliner never really got along with my eyelids since i have hooded eyes. The brush tip for Kat von d's tattoo liner is amazing in the way that its fine point creates that perfect sharp end looking wing for me :)
Stila is the best!! It's so lightweight and applys flawless I love it so much more than kvd and it last forever I don't have to go in and apply touch ups
I personally love Stila's eyeliner so much! I refuse to use any other liner but stila's and i HATE felt tip. But Stila's apply super nicely, its waterproof, and it is ITENSE black how i like it. it makes my wings super sharp too! whereas kat von d's liner is super well too. i like brush tips normally BUT problem is that its not as dark as how i want it to be. so ppl who love doing intense wing looks...go for stila!
+jillojello Wow PF liquid eyeliner looks identical to both of these products. I don't own it but I thinks it's a great dupe with an amazing starting price!
I feel so biased, I've been using the stila eyeliner for as long as I can remember and it's my holy grail in my makeup bag I'm scared to try out Kat Von D 😧 but it's animal cruelty free so I'm making the switch
Actually, both companies are cruelty free! Stila recently made the switch and has changed their animal testing policy (: Both eyeliners are not tested on animals
The fact that they have the same ingredients doesn't mean they have the same formula! They probably have different amounts of each ingredient, and that's why they perform different with the bleeding and such.
I've been trying to give the kat Von d one a chance so many times but it fails in comparison to the stila liner in my opinon. When using the kat Von d liner, it is very hard to get a a consistency going on my eye lid and it results in me trying to get more product out which is very frustrating for me.
I love your comparison video. I am currently using Stila Liquid eyeliner in the shade Alloy. I have blue eyes and I find wearing black liquid eyeliner too intense. I wish the Kat Von D tattoo liquid eyeliner would come in a grey blue shade.
this review was exactly what i was looking for. very detailed and thorough. stila's product getting 'veiny', as you put it, was the dealbreaker for me. KVD looks wayyy smoother and more like what i need. thank you so much!
I haven't been using the stila for very long but I've found I absolutely love it. When I went to go and find a good eyeliner at Ulta I looked over it at first, but when I compared it to other brands it was so much better. Like I said I haven't been using it for long, but it is definitely a holy grail for me.
save the bunnies and go with kat von d! stila unfortunately tests on animals and that was the deal breaker for me even though i used to love their eyeliner :(
What?? Are you kidding me?? Dammit, it was labeled as cruelty free on beauty bay and that's why I bought it :c Well, next time I'm going with Kat von D...
Great video! I would love to know how the Too Faced Sketch Marker and the Ardency Inn liners compare to these as well. Could you review those in the future? Thanks, new sub!
I saw a video on facebook where they coloured a piece of paper, the Stila outlasted the Kat Von D significantly. I'm unsure if it dried out faster or what but I was hoping to see that in this video as well. Unless of course you haven't done an updated comparison video yet. Maybe I missed it? Thoughts about that?
I’ve had the kat von d eyeliner and I decided to try the stila eyeliner but the liquid doesn’t even get to the tip so idk if I got a bad batch, I still prefer the kat von d better
After trying Kat von D eyeliner, which I loved and it never dried out! A friend recommended the stila eyeliner I bought it and it is not worth it! It fades to gray over any eyeshadow I wear! After only a couple of hours btw! Returning it asap.
which one is more long lasting and dont smudge? I have oily eyes so I never able to put a pencil eyeliner, and all waterproof eyeliner always get smudge in my eyes :') I've tried so many brands and type...
Is the Kat Von D water proof? I haven’t tried either of these brands before. I’d like to test one of them out, since it’s summer now and I need a good waterproof eyeliner!
ONE thing you failed to compare which should've been included is running water over both applications on your skin to see just how waterproof they are. They both state they're waterproof.
Can you please tell me what you used or how did you clean your eyeliner brushes in the clip where you're talking about eyeshadow transferring? I use Stila and my eyeshadow transfers onto the brush so bad to the point where I cant even use the liner cause it won't show up :/ I didnt even know washing the eyeliner brush was a thing lol?? Sorry im kind of a noob and just started wearing eyeshadow and stuff this year 😅
I also don't like the shiny finish on eyeliners and was disappointed when I bought the KvD. I still liked it and used it, but I prefer a non-shiny finish. There's another liner by KvD that's not shiny, but idk the name. I think it's the "ink liner".
Thanks for the great video comparison! Sad to see they both use parabens & phenoxyethanol! PLEASE peeps- do your research on these 2 ingredients. This is near your sensitive, thin skinned eye area so it matters!! Personally, I don't know why those 2 ingredients have not been banned yet! If your pregnant- please research phenoxyethanol! Thank you again! Ash!
Thank you for this vid! I have been using Stila for 2 years & then found out they test on animals, so I've been trying to find a cruelty free dupe. thanks!
Can you review the AOM Extreme Art Liner Pen? I can't find one negative complaint on the product which makes me question if it's biased or paid reviews. I just want to know if the product is truly worth buying from an unbiased perspective
Stila was not opaque for me and it dried out pretty weird. I have no eyelashes and it made it really obvious. It also moved A LOT throughout the day. A really cheap one that is not waterproof is more opaque and didn't bulge as much as stila. I'm really disappointed tbh.
Stila is wayyy better .... Kay von D would always melt on me while the stila stayed on the whole day even on hot days which is what is not important the reviewing the package price
wow, i LOVE the way you did this comparison video.. you get to point, which a lot of girls don't do, you show close ups for the tips, side by side, close ups of the application on eye.. this is exactly what i look for when i'm trying to see a review video. love it, keep it up
dope great review
Thanks!
Thanks!
I agree! It's nice not to have all the chatter.
agreed! this is the first review that answers all my questions about the eyeliners. thank you ash!!
I have watched A LOT of makeup review videos today, and I have to tell you that this is BY FAR the most no-nonsense ,concise ,and informative way of presenting and comparing products! Not to say that it lacks entertainment value because it does, but it you don't get caught up in a cult of personality like many youtubers today, and I appreciate that!
Yay! Thank you!
She honestly makes the best reviews on RUclips. Her reviews actually affect what I'm gonna buy. 10/10 reviews.
+Danielle Now i'm nervous. Thanks hun!
This was such a thorough and super helpful review. I've been torn between the two and this review helped me make my decision. I'm going with the Stila because of the felt pen and the color choices (even though I'm not a fan of the color bleeding lol).
+cosmetica529 Yes Stila does have great shade options!
I've never had a problem with the Stila liner and I'd always choose that one over the kat von d!
+LovelyAngie Thanks for sharing!
This was THE best product review I have ever watched. Thank you for being so thorough, it really helped me
Your welcome!
Kat von d tattoo liner is my all time favorite eyeliner! The Stila one is almost just as good but i feel like felt tip eyeliner never really got along with my eyelids since i have hooded eyes. The brush tip for Kat von d's tattoo liner is amazing in the way that its fine point creates that perfect sharp end looking wing for me :)
YES! You've got all the points to why I love the KVD!
Have you experienced the KvD liner drying out after about 1 month?
Yep...I know it's so sad.
Cerise store it upside down
aditi dixit gautam it still dries out
Kōmori Music.Modelling yes!!!
I THOGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE
Stila is the best!! It's so lightweight and applys flawless I love it so much more than kvd and it last forever I don't have to go in and apply touch ups
Yes, it does last longer than KVD!
And how many months it can last v
Without drying out
Good to know
omg, i never post on makeup vids. but thank you! this review is freaking fantastic! reminds me of why I intially started watching makeup vids
Thanks for the awesome comment, I'm glad you loved my review!
Thank you for the very thorough video! Keep making this kind of review!
Thanks Debby!
Thorough, clear and quick.
You've done an awesome job, loved it!!!!
Thanks!
Minute 2:51 made the decision easy for me - My eyelids tend to crepe and this info was EXACTLY what I was looking for. Thanks so much!
Great to hear!
I personally love Stila's eyeliner so much! I refuse to use any other liner but stila's and i HATE felt tip. But Stila's apply super nicely, its waterproof, and it is ITENSE black how i like it. it makes my wings super sharp too! whereas kat von d's liner is super well too. i like brush tips normally BUT problem is that its not as dark as how i want it to be. so ppl who love doing intense wing looks...go for stila!
I wish my tattoo eye liner was super wet like that. I've gotten two at two different Sephora locations and both are dry AF!
Yeah it dries out quickly but I find swiping it with a water cotton pad helps.
What a great review and demo. I like the brush type the best, I love the physicians formula liner for that reason.
+jillojello Wow PF liquid eyeliner looks identical to both of these products. I don't own it but I thinks it's a great dupe with an amazing starting price!
I feel so biased, I've been using the stila eyeliner for as long as I can remember and it's my holy grail in my makeup bag I'm scared to try out Kat Von D 😧 but it's animal cruelty free so I'm making the switch
Actually, both companies are cruelty free! Stila recently made the switch and has changed their animal testing policy (:
Both eyeliners are not tested on animals
Such a thorough and well-made video. You covered everything I was looking for and more. I'm going to try out the Kat Von D liner today!
Thanks, glad you enjoyed my video!
You have the best comparison videos I love how you get straight to point. Thank you again.
Thanks!
Wow, this is the best review I have seen for a product. Good work
Thanks! Glad to hear you enjoyed it.
Very thorough yet short! Great video, I was trying to decide and you helped me make my final choice!
Thanks, glad I could help!
The fact that they have the same ingredients doesn't mean they have the same formula! They probably have different amounts of each ingredient, and that's why they perform different with the bleeding and such.
Thanks Naciunbarco...your correct!
Best comparison video I've ever seen you got me subscribed.
Thanks Jesslyn!
I love how thorough this comparison was! Concise and informative, thank's for the help!!
This video is really thorough and helpful! Thanks for including so much information!
Thanks!
I've been trying to give the kat Von d one a chance so many times but it fails in comparison to the stila liner in my opinon. When using the kat Von d liner, it is very hard to get a a consistency going on my eye lid and it results in me trying to get more product out which is very frustrating for me.
+hina475 Thanks for sharing, I'm glad to hear at least the Stila liner works for you!
BEST PRODUCT REVIEW EVER!
Thank you Sassy Jassy!
I love your comparison video. I am currently using Stila Liquid eyeliner in the shade Alloy. I have blue eyes and I find wearing black liquid eyeliner too intense. I wish the Kat Von D tattoo liquid eyeliner would come in a grey blue shade.
Thanks for sharing.
this review was exactly what i was looking for. very detailed and thorough. stila's product getting 'veiny', as you put it, was the dealbreaker for me. KVD looks wayyy smoother and more like what i need. thank you so much!
Best review of eyeliner ever
Thank you!
Kat was all I ever wore and yesterday I bought Stila for the very first time. I'm so happy to see this
That's awesome!
Wish every comparison vid was like this one
!
Thanks!
You do the BEST reviews!! ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
+Abrar SE Thanks for the love!
I haven't been using the stila for very long but I've found I absolutely love it. When I went to go and find a good eyeliner at Ulta I looked over it at first, but when I compared it to other brands it was so much better. Like I said I haven't been using it for long, but it is definitely a holy grail for me.
Thanks for sharing!
I use the kat Von d liner, I love it, it makes it very easy to do my winged eyeliner 😌
Love your reviews as always!
+PingWing Thanks!
Yay...I absolutely enjoy your reviews!
+rocknlulu Thanks!
I have hooded eyes and Stila's felt tip is kinda firm and a bit difficult to control. Makes my eyeliners both uneven. Might try trooper.
Yes, the felt tip is not as flexible. You will definitely love the Tattoo liner or any liner with a brush applicator.
this helped me decide between the two, thank you so much! such a professional and thorough review. I think I've decided on the Kat von d!
Thanks! Glad I could help.
KVD girl here. Enjoy your reviews. Can't wait for the next one. 🤗
+Virlene Guzman Thanks!
Yay I suggested that you did this in a previous video!! I'm so happy
+makayla oh Yes, it's finally here. Thanks for your request!
Good review, thanks!
Thanks for watching!
I have both liners and I prefer the kat Von d. It's my wholly grail product
This was a class review !!!!
Thanks!
save the bunnies and go with kat von d! stila unfortunately tests on animals and that was the deal breaker for me even though i used to love their eyeliner :(
What?? Are you kidding me?? Dammit, it was labeled as cruelty free on beauty bay and that's why I bought it :c Well, next time I'm going with Kat von D...
sia hannah great news! Stila went cruelty free last week I believe and PETA has confirmed it!
Stila is cf now!!
They are cruelty free now and kat von d is anti vaxx! Go with STILA
awsome review!
Thanks!
WOWWW amazing review. Instantly sub'ed! Please do more of such reviews.
Great demonstration!
Love the review! You should review more liquid eyeliners 😊
Thanks!
Great review video!
Thanks Jazmine!
love this i hope u can do one with the stila pot gel eyeliner and the inglot and bobbie brown gel eyeliner ! it would be awesome!!
The Kat Von D one transferred on the crease of my lid SO bad all day long... i'm really sad it didn't work out for me :(
Sorry to hear that! Hopefully you'll have a better experience with the Stila liner.
Mariane Pellerin do you have hooded eyes? I've heard it go better for hooded eyes
Great video ❤
Thank you!!
Great review!!!!
Thanks!
Amazing video, thanks so much x
Thanks Rachel!
Great eyeliner review!
Thanks!
Thanks for ur review, Ash❤️
+ida culun Your Welcome!
Great video! I would love to know how the Too Faced Sketch Marker and the Ardency Inn liners compare to these as well. Could you review those in the future? Thanks, new sub!
Thanks for the request Sabrina, I'll add it to my list!
Extremely helpful !
Thanks!
Very deep，thorough review！
Thanks!
My Tattoo eyeliner gets barley any product out of it. PLEASE tell me how to fix it.
Shake it, then use a wet towel, wipe the bristles on it and see if more product comes out.
Wow best review ever! Ty.
Thanks!
Best reviews!
+Luiza Ituassú Thanks!
I saw a video on facebook where they coloured a piece of paper, the Stila outlasted the Kat Von D significantly. I'm unsure if it dried out faster or what but I was hoping to see that in this video as well. Unless of course you haven't done an updated comparison video yet. Maybe I missed it? Thoughts about that?
I've never seen it on Facebook but the Stila liner does last longer. I don't know if they dry out, but the KVD liner did run out of product quickly.
thank you i was 'bout to buy the stila one but this helped me a lot👏❤❤
Thank you, I'm glad I could help!
have you noticed the Kat von d liner drying out pretty fast? I've heard this a few times and would like to hear another side before purchasing
I've had mine for over 1 month, I haven't experienced any drying but the product does run out fast.
Mariam Karimi store it upside down
I’ve had the kat von d eyeliner and I decided to try the stila eyeliner but the liquid doesn’t even get to the tip so idk if I got a bad batch, I still prefer the kat von d better
Thanks for sharing.
After trying Kat von D eyeliner, which I loved and it never dried out! A friend recommended the stila eyeliner I bought it and it is not worth it! It fades to gray over any eyeshadow I wear! After only a couple of hours btw! Returning it asap.
Thanks for sharing.
You should check if they're waterproof
I just posted my application/wear video on both products and I'm happy to report that they both are waterproof!
which one is more long lasting and dont smudge? I have oily eyes so I never able to put a pencil eyeliner, and all waterproof eyeliner always get smudge in my eyes :') I've tried so many brands and type...
After lots of use, I think the Stila liner performs better!
angela van Kat von d fades on my eyelids throughout the day. I have hooded eyes
I have hooded eyes too! Maybe I shld use stila first. And I'm a noob when comes to makeup.
Is the Kat Von D water proof? I haven’t tried either of these brands before. I’d like to test one of them out, since it’s summer now and I need a good waterproof eyeliner!
ONE thing you failed to compare which should've been included is running water over both applications on your skin to see just how waterproof they are. They both state they're waterproof.
Thanks! I did compare them in my demo video.
Thanks for the info ...
Thanks!
the vein thing didn't happen to me with Stila when I tried it today.
Thanks for sharing.
Can you please tell me what you used or how did you clean your eyeliner brushes in the clip where you're talking about eyeshadow transferring? I use Stila and my eyeshadow transfers onto the brush so bad to the point where I cant even use the liner cause it won't show up :/ I didnt even know washing the eyeliner brush was a thing lol?? Sorry im kind of a noob and just started wearing eyeshadow and stuff this year 😅
Wow, you are the first to ask about this! It's been a while but I think I used Micellar Water and a cotton round.
I also don't like the shiny finish on eyeliners and was disappointed when I bought the KvD. I still liked it and used it, but I prefer a non-shiny finish. There's another liner by KvD that's not shiny, but idk the name. I think it's the "ink liner".
Thanks for sharing. I agree with you!
Kat Van D now sells an ink liner with more colors and a felt tip
Thanks for sharing Pamela!
My eyes are watery, what eyeliner is best Kat Von D or LA cosmetics eyeliner? needing one that stays put. Thanks
Which one lasts longer cause my eyeliner always runs
For me now the Stila Liner performs better and last longer.
Which one is more waterproof?
For me, Stila was more waterproof.
Thank you so much for this video, it was really helpful!
Thanks Eva!
I hate the stila every time I try to put more on it takes it off and doesn't really want to come off the tip for wings but I haven't tried Kat von d
Thanks for sharing. Do you wait for it to dry before you apply more? Or does it still take off the product if it's dry?
So they only come in one shade?
They come with a few other shades, the Stila liner does have more options though.
is the kvd waterproof?
No it's not waterproof.
I personally love the Kat von d but it dried up within 2 months. in trying to find one that will last it's pigmentation.
Thanks for the great video comparison!
Sad to see they both use parabens & phenoxyethanol! PLEASE peeps- do your research on these 2 ingredients. This is near your sensitive, thin skinned eye area so it matters!! Personally, I don't know why those 2 ingredients have not been banned yet! If your pregnant- please research phenoxyethanol!
Thank you again! Ash!
Thanks for sharing.
very well done video!!
Thanks!
Thank you for this vid! I have been using Stila for 2 years & then found out they test on animals, so I've been trying to find a cruelty free dupe. thanks!
Glad I can help!
I have found the perfect eye liner! (stila)
Thanks!
This whole video was you bashing on the Stila eyeliner ??
Sorry if it seemed that way. My first impression of it, I didn't like it but after several months I actually love it now.
Can you review the AOM Extreme Art Liner Pen? I can't find one negative complaint on the product which makes me question if it's biased or paid reviews. I just want to know if the product is truly worth buying from an unbiased perspective
Hi Daniella. Honestly I'm not familiar with this brand but I will add this item to my list! Thanks for the request!
KAT VON D FTW!
Why waste so much cardboard or material ? For the packaging ?
Well packaging has to be included, to list ingredients and info about the product. Some packaging it recyclable so it's not a complete waste.
Love Love Love your videos. They're all about the products not about you. Although I think you're adorable.
Thanks Terry!
Stila was not opaque for me and it dried out pretty weird. I have no eyelashes and it made it really obvious. It also moved A LOT throughout the day. A really cheap one that is not waterproof is more opaque and didn't bulge as much as stila.
I'm really disappointed tbh.
Thanks for sharing!
all you had to say was shiny finish and I was out for both of them lmao
💖
Stila is wayyy better .... Kay von D would always melt on me while the stila stayed on the whole day even on hot days which is what is not important the reviewing the package price
Thanks for sharing.
definitely stila.. kat von d's liner is so easily smudged and can't last through the day if you have watery eyes.
Thanks for sharing!
Kat von d ftw
Thanks for sharing.