I discovered your channel last Friday and I just watched more than 5 long documentaries and this last video. I believe that your craft is better in long videos, but it is not appealing to young generations and therefore I agree that mixing between the two formats will benefit you (and us in the long run) better. You are truly amazing and inspiring. I have watched history and travel content for years on RUclips and other platforms and I think that the way you mix between on-site filming, storytelling and history is a revolutionary concept. You are taking the greatness from both worlds: the uniqueness of your personalized, routine and authentic point of view to the insane research, study and knowledge about historical facts. I know there are so many stories that the western world has missed about the Far East. I am excited to see your future projects and thankful for what you have done so far. Keep it up man!
i am young aged 30 years old and i strongly prefer long videos because they clarify things in depth .. i advise the youtubers to continue producing long videos but slightely less than 1 hour
I am amazed that there is such an excellent documentary channel on the YT, and it’s even more impressive that it’s all done by a single person! I hope your channel will become more and more successful.
This was an interesting video. I live on the Sea of Japan coast of Japan, and the region I live in used to be dependent on trade in the sea. Today the entire Japanese region has been declining for at least 50 years. I think, at least in part, this decline has started from the Russian far east being an afterthought and North Korea being closed off to Sea of Japan trade. Perhaps if China had more commerce on the Sea of Japan, this region of Japan wouldn't be experiencing such economic stagnation.
Vladivostok has a cargo port and there are certainly trains connecting Chinese cities with that port. I'm not convinced that a bridge, that is much taller than the river bed beneath it is deep, is the issue here. When you look at the river closely you can tell that China would have to dig out the river bed for at least 20 Kilometers to enable even smaller container vessels to reach Chinese territory by faring up the Tumen river.
Digging out the river bed is the least of the issue for China, there are way more sophisticated project than this that China had done. Therefore it is the issue of the bridge height that block acess.@@Ryan_Winter
Keep the video long. It's unique way and make it your own way. Those long videos are the reason I started following you. There are plenty of short style videos but long style like yours are very few so please let it be long
I love your "The Russian Chinese" series. And your series on the Mongols and Tibetans. Good work climbing to the heavenly lake and trying to swim to North Korea too. Finally, watching Uyghurs dance is very charming. As for this one, I'm sure China Russia and Korea will talk this one out. The threesome is getting more solid ever day. Don't stop making films !
I have pondered this issue a moment or two. It boils down to a tiny foothold there for China would be extremely vulnerable militarily from ground forces by either North Korea or Russia. The big enchilada in the area is Vladivostok which is now firmly in Russian control.
Historically, Russia was very cruel to the Chinese. After the Russians occupied Outer Manchuria, they killed most of the Chinese, Manchus and Koreans living there. There are still remains of mass graves in Vladivostok.
First of all the vedio is not even related to any war so ? and Chinese were" nice" to Russians. I would like to ask u to provide any info about them killings because killing people who are capable of working such land and bringing people who never worker such land sounds like bullshit most of Manchuria is Han Chinese so if u don't see Manchu people u can blaim Han
WRONG! According to historical facts, Outer Manchuria was a forbidden area for the Qing Dynasty royal family. Apart from the Manchu people, the Qing government mostly prohibited other Chinese citizens from entering both Outer and Inner Manchuria. Outer Manchuria, in particular, was sparsely populated. It was only after Russia occupied Outer Manchuria that the Qing government allowed Chinese citizens to enter the region, an event known as the "Rush into the Northeast."闯关东 At the same time, Koreans were also permitted to enter.
By the way, it wasn't until the late Qing Dynasty that the government allowed all Chinese citizens to enter Manchuria. Prior to that, Manchuria was sparsely populated and largely undeveloped, which made it rich in natural resources, as it had been a forbidden area belonging to the imperial court for two hundred years.
Hi JingWu, im a fan of your content, and watched most of it. I love your long form content, as this is where your talent really shines, but i also understand the need for short form content. As i get older and more busy with life and work, there's a pressure in myself in whatever i am doing, to get to the point right away and save precious time, including...shorter length videos.. Many times i have to defer watching longer videos in youtube to some other time. So there needs to be a balance i believe... one suggestion i can make is to release short length videos as series, that can later be collated as one massive long form videos. Many other history related channels do that like kings and generals to name one. they have several short length videos released about various topics such as Napoleonic Wars, Roman Empire, World War 2 in the Pacific, etc.. and at the end of the series, they issue a full length compilation video that can run up to 3 hours, with the added benefit that you can do additional editing on the videos or issue corrections based on feedbacks. Please consider Jing Wu! More power !
14:55 The bridge looks to be of the same height as both banks of the river that it connects, which is quite convenient so there was zero reason for them to make this bridge higher back when it was built increasing the costs, yet alone rebuilding it now. And if they were to make it higher they would have to make this bridge WAY WAY longer too in order to support the railroad because trains usually go on slopes of only 2 degrees or less.
The comment I wrote here does not appear in my history and apparently it can't be seen, I can't look at it myself. I'm puzzled, I don't understand what was so controversial about that comment that it had to be hidden away. Not confidence inspiring.
As a Vietnamese girl 🇻🇳, i hope the host, Jing Wu, can do a video on the Delta estuaries in my country, Vietnam 🇻🇳 Thank you for this wonderful video, learnt more than my history books in the university 😅
The regime in North Korea was propped up by the Soviet Union. In the conflict between China and the Soviet Union, North Korea always supported the Soviet Union against China.
I LOVE your documentaries to be as long as possible! I'm from South America and from here is kinda difficult to know about Eastern Asia and Central Asia or The most famous figures as Genghis Khan or Bogd Khan or The chamans and Lamas, i never could learn it if it wasnt because of your amazing work. Please keep helping us to know, You are relevant
I’m sure China can build a new canal parallel to the Yalu river estuary to solve the accessibility problems. I don’t think they saw great values in it as you’ve said. Upsetting both the North Korea and Russian isn’t in their interests. Your concerns are most intriguing. However, In my humble opinion, a canal from Changchun thru shenyang to Yingkou will be better served and economical. The flat land there, is a much better option. The Yalu and Turmen side are too mountainous to be much use.
@@Jingwushowkeep the video long. It's unique way and make it your own way. Those long videos are the reason I started following you. There are plenty of short style videos but long style like yours are very few so please let it be long
You’ve done it again man… amazing content, very well presented. As a fellow creator, I really admire the amount of work and time you put into your content. Incredible how using one bridge effectively blocked the Chinese and is probably why the Chinese cities on that side of the border are much less developed. Incredible stuff, can’t wait to see your next video. Stay blessed 🙏🏽
Documentário espetacular!!!. Nem nas universidades encontraria tal conteúdo com tantas informações históricas e geopolíticas!!!. Entendo que as pessoas necessitem de produções áudio visuais curtas, por causa do pouco tempo disponível, nos tempos atuais!!!; Contudo, trazer-nos toda uma história de quase 200 anos , de forma didática e bem elaborada, meu amigo, eu tiro o chapéu para Jingwu!!!. Que youtuber sensacional!!!.
To be honest, i dont mind short videos but long vidoes are also prefectly fine. I always watch your show while i am doing something. The thing that attracts me most is the topics themselves and your point of view. So keep going
A BIG THUMBS UP for another great video. Always looking forward to your documentary videos and appreciates the amount of thoughts and work behind it in presenting all your videos and in some ways, I see myself in you. Anyway, I see no better opportunity than now for China to pressure both Russia and North Korea to open up the waterways. Don't allow them to dictate but be bold to apply the strongest pressure on them. After all, Russia has stolen all the surrounding land from China.
No, they won't. I haven't seen China successfully pressuring anyone. Chinese diplomacy is rather soft and usually gives up more to solve border disputes. I also wouldn't say its a stolen land by the russian. China did sign off those land to russia under pressure, but also in exchange for russian protection against the Japanese and the west. When a country is weak, it will lose land and currently the best way for China not to lose anymore land is not to agitate the russian and the north korean, but to fight against the west and their vassal states. China might lose the yalu or the tumen, but its nothing compared to losing taiwan, south china sea and tech war to the west.
I'm not tired or thought that your documentaries are long. I love its thoroughness, well, and cogent explanation. I learn a lot from them. Keep them going.
From outside, China, Russia and NK appears to be very close to each other and get along very well, but their relationship is complicated as they do not trust each other.
Any plans on a future video exploring the lasting impact of the Mongol empire in China and Korea? I feel like the Mongolian Empire is obviously well known but not many know the lasting cultural and ethnic impact the Mongols left in their former domain. A video on the Nomadic Conquerers who were absorbed into the Han Chinese ethnicity would be interesting as well. People like the Xiongnu and the Xianbei.
I’m also curious about the Manchu people history, especially during 20th century. Not so much information about this period and tragedy of their people
Excelente video. Es increíble la manera como lo explicas. Siempre veía esa parte del mapa de China y me preguntaba ¿Por qué China no tenia acceso al mar de Japón?. Al ver tu video, ya tengo las respuestas a mis preguntas. Minuto 21:15 me hizo recordar el control que tiene EEUU sobre sus aliados de Europa. Hay que considerar que los 3 países poseen armas nucleares, así que la única manera de convencerlos, tendrá que ser a la buena 😅.
why is the duration of your content so short, I like the previous content, it is very clear and detailed, that is the characteristic of your content, and a neutral perspective perspective for the interests of saints, not for politics, very good in my opinion, keep up the enthusiasm bro making content, about history, geography of China and its neighboring countries!.
Love your channel! I always try to finish my homework early to have time to watch your videos when a new one comes out. Really such an amazing channel. Probably the only channel who’s videos I will watch for hours on end without feeling bored. Please keep up what you are doing and definitely make more series on new things about China! Love your content wish you success. Definitely my favorite channel on RUclips!!
I once wrote an article about NE China and shared my theory about why it is declining - it is mainly because of North Korea and its isolation from the rich and the industrialized countries in the region like SK and Japan and even furthermore extended to cross-pacific couterpart, which made manchuria landlocked. Now you show me the details and proved my speculation correct. Bravo!
Yes!! Thank you bro for making these shorter form videos covering single topics; this could serve as a companion video to your longer ones and you could cram your (no doubt many) cut materials into it! Cheers and here is a hoping for greater success to Jingwu channel!!
I really manifested a video about this subject and here it is. Honestly, I would have loved the longer, more detailed version of this video but it's okay. Good luck.
I still didn't understand why estuaries are so important after you have explained them in the beginning, but fully appreciated the gravity of losing it at the end. Russia and NK really screwed NE China and also NE Asia with one bloody bridge!
With the recent visit of Putin to North Korea, there is talk of building a a road bridge across the Tumen river between the two countries. Is there a likelihood that this railway bridge will be dismantled or rebuild higher to allow Chinese ships to pass through?
According to historical facts, Outer Manchuria was a forbidden area for the Qing Dynasty royal family. Apart from the Manchu people, the Qing government mostly prohibited other Chinese citizens from entering both Outer and Inner Manchuria. Outer Manchuria, in particular, was sparsely populated. It was only after Russia occupied Outer Manchuria that the Qing government allowed Chinese citizens to enter the region, an event known as the "Rush into the Northeast."闯关东 At the same time, Koreans were also permitted to enter.
Any plans to do a video about the Heihe/Blagoveshchensk border region? I studied both Russian and Chinese as a part of my grad school, and had dreams about living in that area and immersing myself in both languages at the same time.
![KSI - Thick Of It (feat. Trippie Redd) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/At8v_Yc044Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Don't want shorter. Your long videos are amazing.
优质的视频博主，特别是没有团队的情况下，一个人完成了这些艰难的工作。你太棒了，我已经成为你的死忠粉。请保持更新，并且注意安全。😊😘
Keep the videos long. They are worth golden informations. Awesome content.
Why can't he do both?
@@dunnowy123?
I discovered your channel last Friday and I just watched more than 5 long documentaries and this last video. I believe that your craft is better in long videos, but it is not appealing to young generations and therefore I agree that mixing between the two formats will benefit you (and us in the long run) better.
You are truly amazing and inspiring. I have watched history and travel content for years on RUclips and other platforms and I think that the way you mix between on-site filming, storytelling and history is a revolutionary concept. You are taking the greatness from both worlds: the uniqueness of your personalized, routine and authentic point of view to the insane research, study and knowledge about historical facts.
I know there are so many stories that the western world has missed about the Far East. I am excited to see your future projects and thankful for what you have done so far. Keep it up man!
i am young aged 30 years old and i strongly prefer long videos because they clarify things in depth .. i advise the youtubers to continue producing long videos but slightely less than 1 hour
I am also 30! I was thinking more of current teenagers and people in their early 20s, not our generation@@ziedyacoub8488
It's been the exact same for me (just 2 months later) :)
I have been waiting for next....!!!
I am amazed that there is such an excellent documentary channel on the YT, and it’s even more impressive that it’s all done by a single person! I hope your channel will become more and more successful.
This was great but i like the long and in depth videos the most from you. Keep up the good work.
Great insight here and all the best in your work. Please if you would do a section about korean chinese.
Thank you for the video. I always enjoy your informative and fun documentaries.
Jingwu真的太厉害了！！支持你，超级爱看你的节目，非常专业
I love your videos, also wow uploaded 2 minutes ago!
definetly one of my favorite youtubers
This was an interesting video. I live on the Sea of Japan coast of Japan, and the region I live in used to be dependent on trade in the sea. Today the entire Japanese region has been declining for at least 50 years. I think, at least in part, this decline has started from the Russian far east being an afterthought and North Korea being closed off to Sea of Japan trade. Perhaps if China had more commerce on the Sea of Japan, this region of Japan wouldn't be experiencing such economic stagnation.
Vladivostok has a cargo port and there are certainly trains connecting Chinese cities with that port.
I'm not convinced that a bridge, that is much taller than the river bed beneath it is deep, is the issue here.
When you look at the river closely you can tell that China would have to dig out the river bed for at least 20 Kilometers to enable even smaller container vessels to reach Chinese territory by faring up the Tumen river.
Digging out the river bed is the least of the issue for China, there are way more sophisticated project than this that China had done. Therefore it is the issue of the bridge height that block acess.@@Ryan_Winter
被俄罗斯殖民者封锁控制有关，至少阻碍了亚洲100年发展
你仔细想中国就是日本海没有大的港口不然日本和中国东北经济谋会提升很多，俄罗斯本来在远东就没多少人，朝鲜更是讨厌中国日本俄罗斯，毕竟还是世袭制😮😮😮😮😮
Bro I like your 1hour long docus. Never change
Love your long docos :)
Amazing doco!
Come on Jingwu!!! It’s the length always about the length & girth
his videos has always been very girthy...this time around is just lacking in length tho..
I can tell you we absolutely don't want shorter videos. I love the documentary style videos, strike while the iron is hot my friend.
dude this vid is too short imo...
@@lyhthegreat yeah that's what I said. I love the 1hr+ videos
Keep the video long. It's unique way and make it your own way. Those long videos are the reason I started following you. There are plenty of short style videos but long style like yours are very few so please let it be long
But we love the distant past and the forgotten wars explained. Love your work.
很高兴看到您讲述了我家乡的故事，你讲的非常对。
I love your "The Russian Chinese" series. And your series on the Mongols and Tibetans. Good work climbing to the heavenly lake and trying to swim to North Korea too. Finally, watching Uyghurs dance is very charming. As for this one, I'm sure China Russia and Korea will talk this one out. The threesome is getting more solid ever day. Don't stop making films !
I have pondered this issue a moment or two. It boils down to a tiny foothold there for China would be extremely vulnerable militarily from ground forces by either North Korea or Russia. The big enchilada in the area is Vladivostok which is now firmly in Russian control.
@@LyuChen94 外满州变成他们的领土，他们帮中国东北守国门挡住美日韩，也没坏处。谁想入侵中国东北就先死在俄罗斯人和朝鲜人的领土上。
Russia and PRC have become natural ally to one another .
Both are suffering from U$-led undeclared War .
俄罗斯人不会发展经济占领了世界这么大土地😮😮😮😮😮
Another fantastic video, learned so much from your videos.
中朝邊界是最憋屈的邊界，比白龍尾島、藏南還憋屈，真不知道當年毛澤東是怎麼想的...界河，一般都是是主航道來劃分的，而鴨綠江圖們江簡直就是一種羞辱...嘿嘿...數十萬將士的犧牲，換來了整個東北的半死不活，跟這兩個河口有著直接的關係...點讚...訂閱
当年是资料缺失，很多资料都被国民党带到台湾了，60年代划分边境肯定吃亏，另外60年代中苏交恶，为了拉拢朝鲜别选边肯定是牺牲的，你不能以现在视角看待当时，毛泽东咋想的我不知道，至少保住了西藏和新疆，西藏在国民党执政事实上独立
1.间岛在勘界的时候没这么大，而且在鸭绿江航道偏朝鲜一方，自然按照就近原则属于朝鲜。沧海桑田几十年，一座岛屿就长大了，而且是此消彼长，‘长’到中国丹东这边来了
2.外东北是满清和沙俄订约割让的，已经一百多年了。图们江法理上中国是有出海权的，一直都有。
3东北的崛起是日满打下的基础，新中国一五计划腾飞的，衰落则是抓大放小的国企改革【也就是贱卖国有资产】和分税制改革导致的大下岗先后两拨冲击带来的，东北回到了以前的位置罢了
@@令和第一男枪山上徹也看來小粉紅不知道90年共產黨確認外東北是俄羅斯土地
確認不平等條約
對著俄爹就沒有“自古以來”，拿土地孝敬俄爹了
知足吧 免费拿了那么多非中国领土 还不知足 长白山到底啥时候成了 中国领土
@@hiouggdj517 去学学历史吧，长白山是满族圣山，清代以来都是中国领土，除满族其他人禁止入内，直到建国后被送出去一半
Great new historical release! Love it!
Historically, Russia was very cruel to the Chinese. After the Russians occupied Outer Manchuria, they killed most of the Chinese, Manchus and Koreans living there. There are still remains of mass graves in Vladivostok.
Russians despise Chinese and still want Manchuria.
First of all the vedio is not even related to any war so ? and Chinese were" nice" to Russians. I would like to ask u to provide any info about them killings because killing people who are capable of working such land and bringing people who never worker such land sounds like bullshit most of Manchuria is Han Chinese so if u don't see Manchu people u can blaim Han
WRONG! According to historical facts, Outer Manchuria was a forbidden area for the Qing Dynasty royal family. Apart from the Manchu people, the Qing government mostly prohibited other Chinese citizens from entering both Outer and Inner Manchuria. Outer Manchuria, in particular, was sparsely populated. It was only after Russia occupied Outer Manchuria that the Qing government allowed Chinese citizens to enter the region, an event known as the "Rush into the Northeast."闯关东 At the same time, Koreans were also permitted to enter.
By the way, it wasn't until the late Qing Dynasty that the government allowed all Chinese citizens to enter Manchuria. Prior to that, Manchuria was sparsely populated and largely undeveloped, which made it rich in natural resources, as it had been a forbidden area belonging to the imperial court for two hundred years.
@@michaelhuang7842作为一个中国人 我可以明确告诉你，他说的是真的
Hi JingWu, im a fan of your content, and watched most of it. I love your long form content, as this is where your talent really shines, but i also understand the need for short form content. As i get older and more busy with life and work, there's a pressure in myself in whatever i am doing, to get to the point right away and save precious time, including...shorter length videos..
Many times i have to defer watching longer videos in youtube to some other time.
So there needs to be a balance i believe... one suggestion i can make is to release short length videos as series, that can later be collated as one massive long form videos. Many other history related channels do that like kings and generals to name one.
they have several short length videos released about various topics such as Napoleonic Wars, Roman Empire, World War 2 in the Pacific, etc.. and at the end of the series, they issue a full length compilation video that can run up to 3 hours, with the added benefit that you can do additional editing on the videos or issue corrections based on feedbacks. Please consider Jing Wu! More power !
14:55 The bridge looks to be of the same height as both banks of the river that it connects, which is quite convenient so there was zero reason for them to make this bridge higher back when it was built increasing the costs, yet alone rebuilding it now. And if they were to make it higher they would have to make this bridge WAY WAY longer too in order to support the railroad because trains usually go on slopes of only 2 degrees or less.
The comment I wrote here does not appear in my history and apparently it can't be seen, I can't look at it myself.
I'm puzzled, I don't understand what was so controversial about that comment that it had to be hidden away.
Not confidence inspiring.
I’m sure if Russia and North Korea agree, China will be more than happy to build such long bridge for them even for free.
China will built it for free
As a Vietnamese girl 🇻🇳, i hope the host, Jing Wu, can do a video on the Delta estuaries in my country, Vietnam 🇻🇳 Thank you for this wonderful video, learnt more than my history books in the university 😅
vietnam has endless amounts of beaches, i doubt they actually needed anymore...
한국인이라 압록강 하구의 신도의 존재와 두만강이 중국의 동해로의 접근을 막는 것은 알고 있었지만
북한과 러시아 사이의 철교가 의도적으로 낮게 만들어진 건 또 처음 안 사실이네요
The regime in North Korea was propped up by the Soviet Union. In the conflict between China and the Soviet Union, North Korea always supported the Soviet Union against China.
@@chenNick-ph6qo朝鲜是唯一一个在中越冲突中支持中国的社会主义国家
@@chenNick-ph6qo North korea is used as a pawn by both russia and china...
中国与朝鲜和苏联的关系一直都是很微妙的
但是毫无疑问，中国的利益优先
中国必须接着向俄罗斯以及朝鲜施压
俄乌冲突对于中国来说是一个绝佳的机会
普京已经做了很多他平时都不会做的让步了
他需要做更多
如果可能，我甚至希望乌军拥有中国军火
如果扔给乌克兰200亿人民币的武器可以让俄罗斯对中国妥协的话，我认为没有中国人会在乎200亿人民币
I LOVE your documentaries to be as long as possible! I'm from South America and from here is kinda difficult to know about Eastern Asia and Central Asia or The most famous figures as Genghis Khan or Bogd Khan or The chamans and Lamas, i never could learn it if it wasnt because of your amazing work. Please keep helping us to know, You are relevant
I’m sure China can build a new canal parallel to the Yalu river estuary to solve the accessibility problems. I don’t think they saw great values in it as you’ve said. Upsetting both the North Korea and Russian isn’t in their interests. Your concerns are most intriguing. However, In my humble opinion, a canal from Changchun thru shenyang to Yingkou will be better served and economical. The flat land there, is a much better option. The Yalu and Turmen side are too mountainous to be much use.
Not sure about the geography here, my question is would not building a canal be more disastrous for China than as things as well
@@KailamiMwiinga
Jingwu is spreading anti-China/Russia/NK propaganda .
Russia and NKorea aren't blocking PRC's access to the sea .
@@KailamiMwiinga不会，这个运河不会大过三峡大坝的开支
事实上中国有将近四个省份修建运河
中国中部省份河南省的运河长度甚至是上百公里
一旦这条运河修成，河南省的经济将会出现巨量增长
广西省的平陆运河将会为广西建立一个大港口
一条运河，可以让中央政府发国债来支持
东北已经衰落很久了
东北急需一个港口重振经济，中国中央政府一定也肯定会为东北向俄罗斯和朝鲜继续施压
普京在俄乌现场的失利使他向中国做了不少妥协
中国需要他们更大的妥协
I honestly don’t know how you can do these videos alone
Obviously he has people helping/financing him.
@@HS-hx8ti obviously they are professional. the NGOs.
lol, i work alone man.@@HS-hx8ti
I believe a strong will can outsmart a team of talents. :D Thanks for watching, friend!
@@Jingwushowkeep the video long. It's unique way and make it your own way. Those long videos are the reason I started following you. There are plenty of short style videos but long style like yours are very few so please let it be long
You’ve done it again man… amazing content, very well presented. As a fellow creator, I really admire the amount of work and time you put into your content. Incredible how using one bridge effectively blocked the Chinese and is probably why the Chinese cities on that side of the border are much less developed. Incredible stuff, can’t wait to see your next video. Stay blessed 🙏🏽
Documentário espetacular!!!. Nem nas universidades encontraria tal conteúdo com tantas informações históricas e geopolíticas!!!. Entendo que as pessoas necessitem de produções áudio visuais curtas, por causa do pouco tempo disponível, nos tempos atuais!!!; Contudo, trazer-nos toda uma história de quase 200 anos , de forma didática e bem elaborada, meu amigo, eu tiro o chapéu para Jingwu!!!. Que youtuber sensacional!!!.
Waiting for your updates !
Now this is what i called the QUALITY CONTENT.
To be honest, i dont mind short videos but long vidoes are also prefectly fine. I always watch your show while i am doing something. The thing that attracts me most is the topics themselves and your point of view. So keep going
A BIG THUMBS UP for another great video. Always looking forward to your documentary videos and appreciates the amount of thoughts and work behind it in presenting all your videos and in some ways, I see myself in you. Anyway, I see no better opportunity than now for China to pressure both Russia and North Korea to open up the waterways. Don't allow them to dictate but be bold to apply the strongest pressure on them. After all, Russia has stolen all the surrounding land from China.
No, they won't. I haven't seen China successfully pressuring anyone. Chinese diplomacy is rather soft and usually gives up more to solve border disputes. I also wouldn't say its a stolen land by the russian. China did sign off those land to russia under pressure, but also in exchange for russian protection against the Japanese and the west. When a country is weak, it will lose land and currently the best way for China not to lose anymore land is not to agitate the russian and the north korean, but to fight against the west and their vassal states. China might lose the yalu or the tumen, but its nothing compared to losing taiwan, south china sea and tech war to the west.
Good point. There is a bigger problem to resolve.@@turtlesoup8134
Thank you for the awesome content. Love you show!
amazing on grounds content. subd!
I'm not tired or thought that your documentaries are long. I love its thoroughness, well, and cogent explanation. I learn a lot from them. Keep them going.
I'm still not used to these kinds of short documents, the longer your videos are, the better they are!
From outside, China, Russia and NK appears to be very close to each other and get along very well, but their relationship is complicated as they do not trust each other.
How many relationships are not 'complicated' in geopolitics?
因为没有统一的价值观
@@Jkl62200USA🇺🇸 , Canada 🇨🇦 , UK 🇬🇧 , France 🇫🇷 , are very firm and staunch allies . No complications .
@@bobfaam5215lol, the US just stole 600billions sub deal from France. you call that no complications?
keep your friends close and your enemies closer?
以前看地圖時就常常好奇這三角地究竟是甚麼一回事 這地理實在是與政治緊密相勾
love your videos❤
Thanke you so much for your political, economy, and geographic lesson, 🇨🇳❤️👈🫰👏👏👏 Jaio Ciungo !
Any plans on a future video exploring the lasting impact of the Mongol empire in China and Korea? I feel like the Mongolian Empire is obviously well known but not many know the lasting cultural and ethnic impact the Mongols left in their former domain.
A video on the Nomadic Conquerers who were absorbed into the Han Chinese ethnicity would be interesting as well. People like the Xiongnu and the Xianbei.
I’m also curious about the Manchu people history, especially during 20th century. Not so much information about this period and tragedy of their people
@@eugenic12
Man-chu were the aggressors .
They maltreated the Han and any ethnicities that rebelled against them .
蒙古人给中国留下的最大影响，就是它们那个让人讨厌的专制制度，元朝彻底颠覆以往唐宋两朝的相权制约皇权的政策，将皇权置于全部之上，导致元朝以后的中国越来越专制。再加上被全民统治的恐惧，中国人越来越排外。这些就是蒙古人留给我们的影响，你觉得他会有积极的吗？
Another interesting video about Northeast Asia! Appreciate your efforts and keep up the good work! Looking forward to your next video already! 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
辛苦了，你做的内容很棒❤
Excelente video.
Es increíble la manera como lo explicas.
Siempre veía esa parte del mapa de China y me preguntaba ¿Por qué China no tenia acceso al mar de Japón?. Al ver tu video, ya tengo las respuestas a mis preguntas.
Minuto 21:15 me hizo recordar el control que tiene EEUU sobre sus aliados de Europa.
Hay que considerar que los 3 países poseen armas nucleares, así que la única manera de convencerlos, tendrá que ser a la buena 😅.
It shows how geopolitics sometimes as pertinent as it reflects.
why is the duration of your content so short, I like the previous content, it is very clear and detailed, that is the characteristic of your content, and a neutral perspective perspective for the interests of saints, not for politics, very good in my opinion, keep up the enthusiasm bro making content, about history, geography of China and its neighboring countries!.
Love your channel! I always try to finish my homework early to have time to watch your videos when a new one comes out. Really such an amazing channel. Probably the only channel who’s videos I will watch for hours on end without feeling bored. Please keep up what you are doing and definitely make more series on new things about China! Love your content wish you success. Definitely my favorite channel on RUclips!!
一个非常有意思的点：薪岛在中国的高德地图上是不存在的，那里显示是一片海。而在谷歌地图上会显示是一个岛
我也发现了这个问题，但不知道为什么。
Great content. I can understand blocking the direct access to the Sea of Japan tho, knowing how much of the sea access China already has
非常非常期待中亚系列，能了解的信息不多，去实地拍摄的就更少了
I once wrote an article about NE China and shared my theory about why it is declining - it is mainly because of North Korea and its isolation from the rich and the industrialized countries in the region like SK and Japan and even furthermore extended to cross-pacific couterpart, which made manchuria landlocked. Now you show me the details and proved my speculation correct. Bravo!
Magnífico video como siempre, y desde mi punto de vista cuanto más largo y más datos históricos mucho mejor.
Yes!! Thank you bro for making these shorter form videos covering single topics; this could serve as a companion video to your longer ones and you could cram your (no doubt many) cut materials into it! Cheers and here is a hoping for greater success to Jingwu channel!!
Saya sangat menyukai vidio anda, tolong jaga durasinya tetap panjang tapi padat pengetahuan sejarah.
흥미로운 주제입니다. 감사합니다.
Jingwu is an anti-China tool .
NKorea and Russia aren't blocking PRC's access to the sea .
I really manifested a video about this subject and here it is. Honestly, I would have loved the longer, more detailed version of this video but it's okay. Good luck.
喜歡這集內容。辛苦了。非常棒👍
I like your deep thinking. Please don't let the algorithm control you. Thank you
Really well done, thank you!
太厉害了，一个人完成了这么高质量的作品
나는 대한민국 사람이다.
당신의 영상은 매우 가치가 있고, 흥미롭게 느껴진다.
고맙게 생각한다.
러시아와 중국의 관계가 나빠지길 원하는 마음에서 고맙게 생각되지?
@@MyFaceTime 무슨소리야?
@@zLkTRyJHVfnBSdqqd
나 한국에 살고있어
Thank you for your hard work. I visited Hunchun a few months ago and I had the same feeling and thought.
Can you make a video about Manchurian history after the Qing Empire collapse? what’s happened to Manchu ethnic enclaves across China
老套的剧情，汉人报复满人屠杀他们，如同满人征服汉人一样
ruclips.net/video/j5MehGeLy08/видео.html
I still didn't understand why estuaries are so important after you have explained them in the beginning, but fully appreciated the gravity of losing it at the end. Russia and NK really screwed NE China and also NE Asia with one bloody bridge!
excellent video sir
啥时候更新啊
作者太有诚意了，我已经对现状有所了解。
Jingwu出品，必属精品，先赞后看。
=============================
观后感：
1、本集的长度果然简短了不少，质量仍然在线，但是就这个主题而言，我认为应该提一下1938年的图们江口之战，毕竟此战对现状的影响是决定性的；
2、或许也应当提一下被中共割让的长白山东麓；
I don't know who said "make your videos shorter". I am reporting them for violating my ability to enjoy your videos fully
GIVE US LONG VIDEOS
期待更新
日本人として見ると、露朝間の(露骨に低く作られた)橋は、日中貿易を阻害する代わりに日本や韓国東部を中国の海軍力から守っていたんですね。目から鱗の面白い話でした。
私はいずれロシアと北朝鮮は中国の要求を呑むように思えましたが、どうなるでしょうか... 中国にとっては2国を同時に説得する必要があり難題だろうとは想像できます。
しかし、将来中国はロシアを説得し、ロシアを通じて北朝鮮を説得するだろう！この動画には言っていないのは、現在のロシアとウクライナの戦争のため、ロシアは経済的にも政治的にも深刻な被害を受けているからだ！だから中国の支持を得るために、ロシアはウラジオストクの港のほとんどを中国に与え、これらの港を中国の税関基準で運営させている（つまり「内港化」）。
また、これまでロシアはさまざまな方法で中国が建設しようとしていたインフラ建設プロジェクトを遅らせてきたが、今回のロシアとウクライナ戦争が始まってからは順調にスタートし、建設を加速させている。ロシア（あるいはプーチン）にとって、今のロシアはもう選択肢がないからだ！彼は中国しか選べない。ロシアが中国がロシアの「盟主」になっているのを非常に見たくないとしても、将来の傾向はそうであり、ロシアの国力はますます衰えていくだけで、中国の国力はますます強くなるだけで、欧米諸国はほとんどロシアを「封殺」しているので、ロシアの未来はますます中国に頼るだけで、頼りたくなくてもできないからだ！
俄罗斯不希望中国的军事力量出现在日本海，朝鲜不希望中国和日本太过友好！俄罗斯和朝鲜都有自己的小算盘！
@@itvbnews 然而俄罗斯未来已经不可能阻挡中国进入日本海了！因为俄乌战争已经把俄罗斯的国力又削弱了很多！
@@itvbnews 现在中国海军是世界第二，美军第一。俄罗斯军力以陆军空军为主，俄罗斯怎么阻止中国进入日本海？你是民逗吗？
感谢 学习了❤
J'adore ta réflexion profonde, s'il te plaît ne laisse pas l'algorithme te contrôler, merci
nice,the video is just long enough for me to finish my dinner.
Nice work bro.
Your show is always great!
With the recent visit of Putin to North Korea, there is talk of building a a road bridge across the Tumen river between the two countries. Is there a likelihood that this railway bridge will be dismantled or rebuild higher to allow Chinese ships to pass through?
有可能，俄罗斯正在比世界上任何时期都需要中国
Great job!
my favorite youtube of the whole internet
I am Russian, and I was VERY interested in your material about inner and outer Mongolia. Do as you want!
According to historical facts, Outer Manchuria was a forbidden area for the Qing Dynasty royal family. Apart from the Manchu people, the Qing government mostly prohibited other Chinese citizens from entering both Outer and Inner Manchuria. Outer Manchuria, in particular, was sparsely populated. It was only after Russia occupied Outer Manchuria that the Qing government allowed Chinese citizens to enter the region, an event known as the "Rush into the Northeast."闯关东 At the same time, Koreans were also permitted to enter.
据史实记载，满族皇室属于明朝臣民
东北从一开始就属于汉族，直到满族到来之后，东北经历过一次大屠杀
讲的很好！制作精良！受益良多！
厉害👍
what happened to the "unlimited friendship" between russia and china tho?
普京之前是一个大欧洲主义者
直到这次俄乌冲突之前他都是一个大欧洲主义者
中国所有人都清楚普京在俄罗斯的定位
普京不能复兴俄罗斯
作为中国的盟国，与中国相临的国家
经济贸易额每年两千亿美元
中国人都清楚，俄罗斯在害怕中国，俄罗斯怕中国将俄罗斯变成加拿大
Long videos are good, even if I need to dedicate time to watch them. Not enough long content nowadays.
Any plans to do a video about the Heihe/Blagoveshchensk border region? I studied both Russian and Chinese as a part of my grad school, and had dreams about living in that area and immersing myself in both languages at the same time.
我猜这个槽点是你在实地考察朝鲜族的时候发现的，尤其是朝俄友谊桥和鸭绿江出海口。
Extreme condition - a kid pounding your camera with a water bottle. XD
What if china dam the river… killing its flow? Or how does the rivers flow
high quality，thx share
老哥值得百万订阅👍
I prefer long videos.