I'm not encouraging you to agree with what I say, but I urge you to listen to it. You should know as much as you can, and then you can decide for yourself. Cheers.
Yeah some have grown up with a lot fewer perspectives than the rest of us, and that’s ok. At the end of the day, people will see what they look for and hear what they listen for. “Vitriolic jingoism can be far more prevalent than sober analysis, and to those ideologically focused, every slope is slippery, and every gray area becomes another shade of black n white.” - Quotes from Rare Earth
As a Korean Chinese who lives in Germany, whose family originates from Yanbian and lived in Jilin and SK, whom the Yanbian University graduated a bechelor degree decade ago, I can totally tell that you put tons of effort to this even more than those historical students. I enjoyed every second of your video which hits hard also is thoroughly smooth. Keep up at good content !
@@jae-hyoungkim7538 Yeah... The Universe creators from S Korea never twisted any history. A Korean writer just claimed that ancient Korean people called Dongyi people created Chinese characters, but it's ok since Koreans created the Universe in 7 days, they can claim anything in it as their creations. 😂😂😂
As a Korean, this video is a very high-quality video. Don't get hurt by the comments of some extreme groups, and I look forward to posting great videos in the future.
@@panacea26947As a Joseonjok, all people who I know will not and never pretend to be Korean 😂, ok, in objectively speaking, South Korea may have not bad reputation abroad, But! in China it is second only to Japan in terms of notoriety such as Culture thieves. So u know, it's sooo unnecessary to pretend as a Joker Korean tbh❤ Or maybe You r just gettin' fooling around by ur own people 🤷🏻♂️ C'mon like, who knows? bro
Absolutely phenomenal documentary series again! I really love the time you take to discuss the lesser known aspect of China and its frontiers, done with various perspectives, experiences and expertise! 你太棒了!
Jingwu, thank you so much for this great narrative of the history of Yanbian Korean Chinese ! I can't believe I finished watching this whole 1hour15min episode without a single pause. All materials are well organized, and you've done a terrific job in bringing history and all the untold stories together. As a HAN Chinese I was always curious about the life and culture of the ethnic Koreans in China, and all other ethnic groups as well, including Mongolians, Uigurs, Tibetans. Although we're of different ethnicities, at the end of the day we're all Chinese, living in the same great country we call home. I love my ethnic Korean/Uygur/Tibetan/Mongolian/Hui/Uzbeck/Tajik/Kygiz brothers. I hope all of us will live happily together now and in the future. All the best wishes to you also. THANK YOU!!
As a Korean Chinese who grew up in Heilongjiang and Yanbian, worked in Beijing and South Korea, This video just pulls at heartstrings of mine. I had always been thinking about my idendity since my childhood, Complex emotions towards North Korean,South Korean and Chinese people(different yet connected), My grandparents immigrated from Koera in the early 20th century, went through hard times(japanese occupation, Chinese CivIl War, Korean war, Cultural Revolution). One of my uncle went to North Korea in the 1970's and never came back. as for me, car smuggling and refugees from North Korea,immigrant boom, K-pop, ethnic assimilation, all theses became my 1990's memorial symbols. Also recognize all the movie clips in this video, need to mention unfamous one, 두만강(Tumen River,directed by a Korean Chinese, 장률). great work, so much appreciated.
조선족 동포에게 많은 도움을 받아서 해외에서 무사히 지냈던 한국 사람입니다. 현재 한국에서 일부 정치인들과 그들의 추종자들이 조선족에 대한 이미지를 나쁘게 말하나, 저에게는 언제나 하나의 형제이고 같은 민족이라 생각했습니다. 언제나 같은 민족이라고 챙겨준 조선족들에게 저는 반가움이 매우 깊습니다. 조선족은 국적은 중국이지만, 같은 역사와 문화를 공유한 단군의 자손이라 생각합니다. 조선족들에게 국적이 한국이냐 물어보는건 정말 어리석다고 생각합니다. 같은 단군의 후손으로서 나중에 꼭 같은 민족으로서의 삶을 공유하고 활발히 교류하였으면 합니다 :-)
@@jae-hyoungkim7538 솔직히 중국정부 통치하에 강압적으로 중국인이 되기를 강요받으며 살아온 조선족들이 자신의 조국을 중국이라고 하는 것에 대해 어느정도 어쩔 수 없다고 생각함. 위에 일본제국치하 조선인 아이가 반자이를 눈물흘리며 외치는 장면이 조성족들의 상황과 오버랩되는듯. 미안하지만 우리가 그들을 구해주기에는 너무 늦은듯. 언젠가 우리가 대륙으로 가는 날이 오면 그제서야 동포들을 구할 수 있겠지. 늦지 않고 그날이 빨리와서 흩어진 우리 민족들이 살아갈 좋은 터전을 일궈야할텐데… 우리가 통일신라를 반쪽짜리 통일에 신라에 대한 인식이 안좋은것처럼 만약 우리가 남한만 잘살면되지하는 생각을 가진다면 후대인들도 우리를 손가락질 할듯
I am blown away by the high quality and objectivity of this documentary. I’m speaking from the perspective of a South Korean educated in the US. I applaud you for the extraordinary effort that you’ve put into this work!
As a hwagyo/huaqiao (Chinese who live in Korea), this was really illuminating to see the experience of our Korean Chinese counterparts. Thanks for covering this transnational topic often glossed over in the west.
Another gem in documentary video! After spending 6 years at Yanbian as an "educated youth" from Shanghai, I regard Yanbian as my second hometown, and my love for it is no less than that of the Yanbian Koreans. Your work is well researched, very informative and deserves much more subscription.
Fantastic documentary. I have stayed in China for over 20 years and this is one of the best objective documentary I have seen regarding Chinese history. If only mainstream media can pick this up and show it to more people....
I watched the first part and the second part. Thanks for your video. I always thought that not many people cared about the history of Koreans in China. I saw our history in your video, and more importantly, I saw your hard work and enthusiasm. Thank you again, I am an uncle in my thirties from the Korean ethnic group in China😁
That was some splendid 1st tier documentary! My grandparents used to reside in Wangqing county, Yanbian in the 1970s. Have heard a lot of stories about the life, wild wolves and ethinic Korean neighbours there. Keep up the good work Jingwu!
Another banger video! Just asking, but do you have any intensions of doing a series about the South East Asian Chinese diaspora? (e.g Singaporeans, Malaysian-Chinese, Thai-Chinese, Fillipino-Chinese, Indonesian-Chinese, etc)
Awesome documentary! I very admire your neutral point of view about history. As a korean, I only see the korean version of the story. But your work has greatly extended and diversify my understanding. Thank you for your great work and interest. I hope to see more of your films soon.
What incredible documentary you made over the two part series. As a ethnic Korean, I learned a ton. Thank you for your sharing. I'm not sure about your background and motivation behind these videos but as a historian, film maker and story teller, you had me captivated. I subscribed. May you find success and happiness in your journeys.
As someone who researching both my southern roots in Guangdong and my Korean Chinese roots in Liaoning, this is valuable viewing. Thank you so much. Subscribed
Great job as always man... Your ability to tell stories is something else, you shed so much light on the Kim II Sung story and North Korean situation ... just incredible. I really hope you get to see the Holy Mountain from the North Korean side at some point and get to share that on this channel. Both part 1 and 2 deserve 1 million views (particularly part 2). RUclips needs more content like this, what an underrated channel.
very well done and very extensive. I was wondering if you will cover about the "Koryo" people who were sent to Kazahkstan? These people lives in those same northern border between Russia, China and North Korea.
I would love to see China's Korea town with you if you ever decide guided tours of historic importance to so many Korean people! Thank you again for great work : )
Awesome video and a work of good historical research to back up your assertions! Your commentaries are supported by sound in-depth analysis and I thoroughly enjoy Part 2. Look forward to your future videos and I understand you will be taking us to Central Asia along the Ancient Silk Road. I was in Uzbekistan over 10 years ago and met some of the most generous, hospitable and kind people there. I cannot wait to go on another journey and look forward to your next video. Take care and keep the creative juice flowing!
This is a fascinating documentary-level video. Thank you for your effort making this series. As a Canadian-born Korean living in South Korea, I can't help but witness that South Korea was the most Japanese-influenced part of the Peninsula, but also becoming more Japan-ized for the past 2-3 years. Now observing the NE part of China in this video is a huge relief for me. So, absolutely one more time, thank you again.
another banger, just a question, what is the painting in 5:32? The art style kinda reminds me of the cover pages of Le Petit Journal. Edit: I just typed le petit journal korea on google and found it lol. Didn't expect it to be actually that
Greetings from China. I have traveled somewhat extensively through Yanbian and just finished watching both of your episodes on the topic. Both vids got a huge thumbs up and you got a new subscriber. The amount of time and effort you put into this, with such attention to detail, is honestly some of the best work I've seen on RUclips! Well done my friend! -A new American subscriber.
Your documentaries serve as a great bridge between those that know the complexities of East Asia & people like myself that may not hear much East Asia. No need to apologize on the views you have provided us. It’s important to hear various perspectives & not be completely ignorant towards one view. I thought otherwise, you’ve provided a neutral view on the 3 Koreas & shed a light on a region and its peoples that I never really considered. All that to say, loved the watch from a Jordanian-Canadian!
The eating and drinking while documenting is very handful, it feels like a break, How people (korea,china) get through troubles represents human history really accurate.
Great storytelling, i learned a lot from you. Even my chinese wife doesn't know the story of Yanbian. As a Chinese American, i hope to visit Yanbian one day.
There used to be a North Korean restaurant in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. It closed down back in 2017, a few months after the assassination of Kim Jong-nam. Your speech about North Korean refugees reminded me of the Rohingyan refugees issue in Malaysia and other SEA nations.
North Koreans had quite good life during the 1960s-1980s, which was also China's toughest times, even some Chinese who are not Korean ethnicity defected to North Korea then.
25:33 "I've heard the waitresses at this restaurant are exceptionally beautiful" gotta respect that dedication to research Joke aside, as a Vietnamese majoring in East Asia relations (mainly with Japanese), i learned a lot, thank you very much!
정말 훌륭한 영상입니다. 한국인으로서 최대한 객관적인 시각에서 영상을 만들기 위한 당신의 노력에 경의와 감사를 표하고 싶습니다. 평생을 남한에서 교육받은 저에게 외국인의 객관적 시각으로 본 압록강, 백두산, 두만강과 그 곳에 사는 조선족의 역사를 다룬 두 편의 영상은 신선한 충격이었습니다.
You rock, Jingwu. Been looking forward to part 2. I have learned much Asian history from watching your channel. What are some other topics you're planning to tackle?
I'm not encouraging you to agree with what I say, but I urge you to listen to it. You should know as much as you can, and then you can decide for yourself. Cheers.
透过不同成长经历的“哈哈镜” 每个人都有不同意识形态。正常
Yeah some have grown up with a lot fewer perspectives than the rest of us, and that’s ok. At the end of the day, people will see what they look for and hear what they listen for. “Vitriolic jingoism can be far more prevalent than sober analysis, and to those ideologically focused, every slope is slippery, and every gray area becomes another shade of black n white.” - Quotes from Rare Earth
@@commonsense_centrist Wise words.
Happy Chinese and Korean New Year, the years 4722 and 4357 of the wood dragon
WOWOWOW such long history for these ppl!!!!!
催更
As a Korean Chinese who lives in Germany, whose family originates from Yanbian and lived in Jilin and SK, whom the Yanbian University graduated a bechelor degree decade ago, I can totally tell that you put tons of effort to this even more than those historical students. I enjoyed every second of your video which hits hard also is thoroughly smooth. Keep up at good content !
Will do, friend! Thanks for sending regards from Germany. Hope everything is well on your side. :D
정말 훌륭한 분이에요. 제발 중국말로도 좀 만들어 주세요. 더 이상 共产 中国이 历史歪曲을 하게 두면 안됩니다.
@@jae-hyoungkim7538 Yeah... The Universe creators from S Korea never twisted any history. A Korean writer just claimed that ancient Korean people called Dongyi people created Chinese characters, but it's ok since Koreans created the Universe in 7 days, they can claim anything in it as their creations. 😂😂😂
@@directxxxx71드디어 바퀴벌레 한마리 나타나셨군..그래 漢字가 東夷가 만들어낸건 아는구나..너희 漢族하곤 전혀 상관없어. 너흰 거의 千年동안 北方民族의 奴隶였지.
@@jae-hyoungkim7538古代东亚基本就是中国的历史，韩国日本这些边缘国家能决定什么？日本人虽然一直想摆脱边缘地位不断向大陆侵略，日本也没有达到编造历史来欺骗本国人民，塑造虚假的民族主义的地步
As a Korean, this video is a very high-quality video. Don't get hurt by the comments of some extreme groups, and I look forward to posting great videos in the future.
I’m thinking you’re just another josunjok or hwagyo 🪳 pretending to be Korean
Too many josunjok and hwagyo pretending to be Korean these days
@@panacea26947 that's correct. They are using it as a political tool to promote the Northeast Project on RUclips, which is just disgusting.
@@panacea26947As a Joseonjok, all people who I know will not and never pretend to be Korean 😂, ok, in objectively speaking, South Korea may have not bad reputation abroad, But! in China it is second only to Japan in terms of notoriety such as Culture thieves.
So u know, it's sooo unnecessary to pretend as a Joker Korean tbh❤
Or maybe
You r just gettin' fooling around by ur own people 🤷🏻♂️
C'mon like, who knows? bro
Absolutely phenomenal documentary series again! I really love the time you take to discuss the lesser known aspect of China and its frontiers, done with various perspectives, experiences and expertise! 你太棒了!
Such a well-made documentary, I watch every episode ❤
Thank you!!
Jingwu, thank you so much for this great narrative of the history of Yanbian Korean Chinese ! I can't believe I finished watching this whole 1hour15min episode without a single pause. All materials are well organized, and you've done a terrific job in bringing history and all the untold stories together. As a HAN Chinese I was always curious about the life and culture of the ethnic Koreans in China, and all other ethnic groups as well, including Mongolians, Uigurs, Tibetans. Although we're of different ethnicities, at the end of the day we're all Chinese, living in the same great country we call home. I love my ethnic Korean/Uygur/Tibetan/Mongolian/Hui/Uzbeck/Tajik/Kygiz brothers. I hope all of us will live happily together now and in the future. All the best wishes to you also. THANK YOU!!
honestly, Jingwu you produce amazing documentaries! your story telling skills are super engaging.
Glad you liked it! Trying to bring their stories to everyone.
@@Jingwushowyou are better than 99 percent of the so called English language content about the region
No need for rest, I started watching part 2 as soon as i finished part 1. Bro the work you are doing is amazing 🤯
Well said! Providing new independent views on some major issues, different from those big broadcast companies. More people should see your channel.
As a Korean Chinese who grew up in Heilongjiang and Yanbian, worked in Beijing and South Korea,
This video just pulls at heartstrings of mine.
I had always been thinking about my idendity since my childhood,
Complex emotions towards North Korean,South Korean and Chinese people(different yet connected),
My grandparents immigrated from Koera in the early 20th century,
went through hard times(japanese occupation, Chinese CivIl War, Korean war, Cultural Revolution).
One of my uncle went to North Korea in the 1970's and never came back.
as for me, car smuggling and refugees from North Korea,immigrant boom, K-pop, ethnic assimilation,
all theses became my 1990's memorial symbols.
Also recognize all the movie clips in this video, need to mention unfamous one,
두만강(Tumen River,directed by a Korean Chinese, 장률).
great work, so much appreciated.
조선족 동포에게 많은 도움을 받아서 해외에서 무사히 지냈던 한국 사람입니다. 현재 한국에서 일부 정치인들과 그들의 추종자들이 조선족에 대한 이미지를 나쁘게 말하나, 저에게는 언제나 하나의 형제이고 같은 민족이라 생각했습니다. 언제나 같은 민족이라고 챙겨준 조선족들에게 저는 반가움이 매우 깊습니다. 조선족은 국적은 중국이지만, 같은 역사와 문화를 공유한 단군의 자손이라 생각합니다. 조선족들에게 국적이 한국이냐 물어보는건 정말 어리석다고 생각합니다. 같은 단군의 후손으로서 나중에 꼭 같은 민족으로서의 삶을 공유하고 활발히 교류하였으면 합니다 :-)
드 넓은 만주 벌판은, 한민족의 옛터전.
청나라 만주족은, 신라의 후예.
청나라 황제 건륭제의 명으로 쓰여진 만주족의 역사서 "흠정만주원류고" 에 다 나옴.
설마 중국을 祖国으로 생각하는건지?
@@jae-hyoungkim7538韩裔美国人会把欧洲白人当成自己的祖先吗？😅朝鲜族中国人是近两百年移民中国的，是不是可惜当初二战后，中国政府没像对待日本人一样强制驱逐朝鲜人离开中国？欢迎来到北朝鲜😮
@@jae-hyoungkim7538 솔직히 중국정부 통치하에 강압적으로 중국인이 되기를 강요받으며 살아온 조선족들이 자신의 조국을 중국이라고 하는 것에 대해 어느정도 어쩔 수 없다고 생각함. 위에 일본제국치하 조선인 아이가 반자이를 눈물흘리며 외치는 장면이 조성족들의 상황과 오버랩되는듯. 미안하지만 우리가 그들을 구해주기에는 너무 늦은듯. 언젠가 우리가 대륙으로 가는 날이 오면 그제서야 동포들을 구할 수 있겠지. 늦지 않고 그날이 빨리와서 흩어진 우리 민족들이 살아갈 좋은 터전을 일궈야할텐데… 우리가 통일신라를 반쪽짜리 통일에 신라에 대한 인식이 안좋은것처럼 만약 우리가 남한만 잘살면되지하는 생각을 가진다면 후대인들도 우리를 손가락질 할듯
I am blown away by the high quality and objectivity of this documentary. I’m speaking from the perspective of a South Korean educated in the US. I applaud you for the extraordinary effort that you’ve put into this work!
Glad you enjoyed it! Those words really warmed me.
Finally! Been waiting for p2.
Thanks for staying and waiting!!
these two videos were AMAZING sir
Superb. I watched both parts back to back. It's dense with information and a challenging delight to watch. Thank you for all your efforts.
As a hwagyo/huaqiao (Chinese who live in Korea), this was really illuminating to see the experience of our Korean Chinese counterparts. Thanks for covering this transnational topic often glossed over in the west.
And thank you for being awesome because Chinese people deserve more respect in the 21st century.
아주 좋은 교육영상이었습니다...
excellently good quality film .
you! the best!
매우 감사합니다.
목용의 4722년과 4357년, 행복한 중국과 한국의 설날
2nd time watching this, fascinating story
Another gem in documentary video! After spending 6 years at Yanbian as an "educated youth" from Shanghai, I regard Yanbian as my second hometown, and my love for it is no less than that of the Yanbian Koreans. Your work is well researched, very informative and deserves much more subscription.
Haha, thanks! Glad it brought back some fond memories for you!
Fantastic documentary. I have stayed in China for over 20 years and this is one of the best objective documentary I have seen regarding Chinese history. If only mainstream media can pick this up and show it to more people....
Thanks, friend! I don't really think mainstream media would pick this up though, lol.
Thank you. Jingwu, for this fantastic update. Always good to learn from your video's. ⛩🎥🏆
No problem, sir! Glad you enjoyed it.
I watched the first part and the second part. Thanks for your video. I always thought that not many people cared about the history of Koreans in China. I saw our history in your video, and more importantly, I saw your hard work and enthusiasm. Thank you again, I am an uncle in my thirties from the Korean ethnic group in China😁
Welcome back! Your comment is one of the most popular in the 1st part of the show! 😁
Glad to hear that, friend! Hope you are doing well!
还好66到76中国是56个民族都受到冲击你这样想就舒畅，刘少奇彭德怀那么多高层元帅都被处理啦😂😂😂😂
Thank you for your effort. Wonderful narrative, it will take me a long time to digest and think.🙏
That was some splendid 1st tier documentary! My grandparents used to reside in Wangqing county, Yanbian in the 1970s. Have heard a lot of stories about the life, wild wolves and ethinic Korean neighbours there. Keep up the good work Jingwu!
객관적으로 중국-남한-북한 관계를 아주 잘 정리한 영상입니다. 어지간한 다큐보다 더 잘 만들었네요. 구독자수 10만명 달성 기원합니다!
정말 고마워 친구 야! 재밌게 봐주시고 좋아해주셔서 다행입니다. 계속 지켜봐 주시기 바랍니다!
목용의 4722년과 4357년, 행복한 중국과 한국의 설날
남한?? 한국사람들은 남한이라고 안하는데? 이거 중공한족+조선족들이 짜고치는 각이네 ㅋㅋㅋ 번역기 돌리느라 수고가 많다야 ㅋㅋ nice try fabricating BS history. Another MADE IN CHINA
Another banger video! Just asking, but do you have any intensions of doing a series about the South East Asian Chinese diaspora?
(e.g Singaporeans, Malaysian-Chinese, Thai-Chinese, Fillipino-Chinese, Indonesian-Chinese, etc)
For sure! Their stories will be covered in detail, but maybe not this year. 2024 is already packed with plans.
太好了！等你的海外华人视频，我对这段历史非常感兴趣❤@@Jingwushow
A very good documentary, I like it very much! Thank you for your efforts!
Awesome documentary! I very admire your neutral point of view about history. As a korean, I only see the korean version of the story. But your work has greatly extended and diversify my understanding. Thank you for your great work and interest. I hope to see more of your films soon.
Thank you neighbor! Your words warmed me. Thank you.
从中国跑到北朝鲜的人现在继续忍受金正恩的艰苦生活😂😂😂😂😂
What incredible documentary you made over the two part series. As a ethnic Korean, I learned a ton. Thank you for your sharing. I'm not sure about your background and motivation behind these videos but as a historian, film maker and story teller, you had me captivated. I subscribed. May you find success and happiness in your journeys.
宝藏up！你关于蒙古的视频也很棒。旅行历史和地理三合一，精美的画面、文案和剪辑。期待你未来的视频！
Thanks for the documentaries, they were a very entertaining way to present a complex history.
It brought me many thoughts. History is so intriguing...
Superb stuff. Bravo!
Very impressive with your story telling skills and great English!
As someone who researching both my southern roots in Guangdong and my Korean Chinese roots in Liaoning, this is valuable viewing. Thank you so much. Subscribed
Finally! Great Video hope this video will be great
Great job as always man... Your ability to tell stories is something else, you shed so much light on the Kim II Sung story and North Korean situation ... just incredible. I really hope you get to see the Holy Mountain from the North Korean side at some point and get to share that on this channel. Both part 1 and 2 deserve 1 million views (particularly part 2). RUclips needs more content like this, what an underrated channel.
Will try my best to film from the other side, lol! Thanks for watching my show, friend!
Thanks for the work. It’s a really comprehensive documentary series i have ever seen.
You're welcome! Thanks for watching my show.
Amazing work, one of the top notch documentary. Thank you very much for your time and effort!
another in depth and impressive documentary 👍👍👍 good job Jingwu ! make one of Jeju Island 🫶
Noted!
Fantastic video, thanks for sharing this with us 🙏
잘 봤습니다. 좋은 영상 감사합니다.
물론이죠! 계속 지켜봐 주시기 바랍니다.
加油💪🏻，专业且中立真实，非常喜欢你的视频，比大部分专业纪录片都好，质量这么高的视频粉丝却这么少感觉非常难过，国内因为众所周知的缘故也很难看到，总之，感谢，希望您继续做下去🙏🏻
期待了好久，终于等到你的更新啦！今天晚上可以慢慢欣赏了🥳
辛苦了朋友！希望喜欢。
确实很好，这样角度的介绍历史的视频国内是没有的。
Thanks Jingwoo for your in depth reportage on several Asian countries including Russia. I look forward to more
國家地理頻道等級，水準真的高!下禮拜要從台灣去東北，順便到哈爾濱、瀋陽看看，祝福您一切安好
感恩！也祝您旅途顺利~
very well done and very extensive. I was wondering if you will cover about the "Koryo" people who were sent to Kazahkstan? These people lives in those same northern border between Russia, China and North Korea.
I would love to see China's Korea town with you if you ever decide guided tours of historic importance to so many Korean people! Thank you again for great work : )
That'd be cool, haha. Maybe when I retire, but for now I really don't have time for that.
there are many travel vlogs on YT that visit the Korean Autonomous Prefecture, but yeah it would be nice to see one focused on its historical aspect
Awesome video and a work of good historical research to back up your assertions! Your commentaries are supported by sound in-depth analysis and I thoroughly enjoy Part 2. Look forward to your future videos and I understand you will be taking us to Central Asia along the Ancient Silk Road. I was in Uzbekistan over 10 years ago and met some of the most generous, hospitable and kind people there. I cannot wait to go on another journey and look forward to your next video. Take care and keep the creative juice flowing!
wonderful history! and your storytelling skills are top tier man. Love it
Much appreciated!
我觉得我们还需要这部纪录片儿的第三部分。嘻嘻
这两部纪录片儿真是如虎添翼，内容特别丰富有趣！
Amazing Content, thank you for sharing .
Hello...I love your videos. Very educational!
This is a fascinating documentary-level video. Thank you for your effort making this series.
As a Canadian-born Korean living in South Korea, I can't help but witness that South Korea was the most Japanese-influenced part of the Peninsula, but also becoming more Japan-ized for the past 2-3 years. Now observing the NE part of China in this video is a huge relief for me. So, absolutely one more time, thank you again.
Why do you think South Korea has became more Japan-ized in the past 3 years?
Good job dude .... keep going ..a lot of insightful information
another banger, just a question, what is the painting in 5:32? The art style kinda reminds me of the cover pages of Le Petit Journal.
Edit: I just typed le petit journal korea on google and found it lol. Didn't expect it to be actually that
Le Petit Journal it is! Thanks for watching.
Greetings from China. I have traveled somewhat extensively through Yanbian and just finished watching both of your episodes on the topic. Both vids got a huge thumbs up and you got a new subscriber. The amount of time and effort you put into this, with such attention to detail, is honestly some of the best work I've seen on RUclips! Well done my friend! -A new American subscriber.
Glad you enjoyed it, friend!
太佩服博主了，实地考察讲述历史，很有趣。
Very educative content, and neutral perspective, good work, keep it up!!!!. 👍
这个博主制作的内容是我相当长的一段时间里，看过自制的关于亚洲民族历史纪录片里最客观最详细的，编排有趣不枯燥，非常感谢
Your documentaries serve as a great bridge between those that know the complexities of East Asia & people like myself that may not hear much East Asia.
No need to apologize on the views you have provided us. It’s important to hear various perspectives & not be completely ignorant towards one view. I thought otherwise, you’ve provided a neutral view on the 3 Koreas & shed a light on a region and its peoples that I never really considered.
All that to say, loved the watch from a Jordanian-Canadian!
很好的历史讲述视频，你应该有更多的观众，希望能继续看到优质的作品
From an Egyptian knowing little about the history of this corner of the world, this documentary is one of the highlights on all of RUclips. Thank you!
You're an amazing documentary filmmaker and I hope that someday these films will be shown on domestic platforms.
Thanks!! Maybe one day!
不敢想象你在这两集纪录片中投入了多少精力，向你致敬！期待更多作品
Always need to watch 2+ times of your amazing documentary
The eating and drinking while documenting is very handful, it feels like a break,
How people (korea,china) get through troubles represents human history really accurate.
Great storytelling, i learned a lot from you. Even my chinese wife doesn't know the story of Yanbian. As a Chinese American, i hope to visit Yanbian one day.
谢谢哥们，你是我为数不多能沉下心看完的长视频的博主，就是传播范围跟视频质量严重不对等，希望以后能越来越火。
别客气哥们，我这种更新速度应该火不了🤣，我也不特别想🔥倒是哈哈。
这种题材YT不会给流量的
@@Jingwushow你不火没天理啊！🔥
Jingwu preferred unexpected delight than others especially history stuff
很棒的制作， 1个多小时的视频，我甚至没有快进，全部看完。 了不起的UP主。
辛苦了朋友，愿意花时间在我的节目上。
我看他的视频不是快进，有些段落会看好多遍。或者暂停想一想理解一下地图和山脉河流的走势。那个蒙古的 西藏的视频看了好几遍
丰富的内容、严谨的逻辑、完整的故事线，每个故事都有实地讲解。制作非常精良，可以跟国际很多知名频道媲美了。
谢谢朋友！再接再厉，鞠躬了。
Yes. Your chapter two of your Korean narrative. I love your documentary!
“人权应该被保护，但不应该以牺牲其他人为代价”
这句话真的说的太好了😭人权问题背后无数的恩怨情仇与利益纠葛只能换来某些人权卫士在空调房里轻描淡写的一句“保护人权”“谴责XX”，实在是人类的悲哀啊😢
A very well documented video! Totally you fan from Indonesia (Chinese Diaspora).
Mantab - ada sodara di sini...
재밌게 잘 봤습니다! 시간 순식간에 사라졌네요
그 소식을 듣게되어서 행복하다! 제 다큐멘터리를 시청해 주셔서 감사합니다.
Awesome work.. can’t wait for the next episode
There used to be a North Korean restaurant in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. It closed down back in 2017, a few months after the assassination of Kim Jong-nam.
Your speech about North Korean refugees reminded me of the Rohingyan refugees issue in Malaysia and other SEA nations.
Excellent video. Thanks for sharing. Cheers.
Another awesome video, very informative, and fun to watch, thanks…
dude this is good stuff. keep at it!! i learn alot from ur videos
남한에 살며 배우고 이해한 동아시아와는 다른 관점, 다른 해석을 통해 더 다양하게
더 넓게 좀 더 객관적으로 세상을 생각하게 되었습니다. 고맙습니다.
i love that the description and the title is translated
非常精彩视频，博主辛苦啦！加油
谢谢你，为观众朋友们服务很快乐。
i really loved this documentary. i feel its objective and clear cut.
Worth the wait!! Down to every detail. ❤❤
Thinking about those Koreans escaped from China for ……North Korea😮
Many of them crossed back to China during the 1990s. They were the ones with relatives in China.
North Koreans had quite good life during the 1960s-1980s, which was also China's toughest times, even some Chinese who are not Korean ethnicity defected to North Korea then.
@@joeottoman6484历史，或者命运，很巧妙吧。。。
@@曾华琳 以上帝视角马后炮一下，朝鲜后来的光景在它的极盛时刻就能预料到，它南边的兄弟能发展起来靠的可远远不只是美国的援助（光靠超级大国援助就能发展起来那全世界都是发达国家了），相比之下，朝鲜的短暂繁荣完全是中国和苏联硬生生养起来的，工业血液石油完全靠苏联和罗马尼亚几乎白送，在经互会内部有东欧国家接盘完全不愁工业品卖不出去所以完全不上心产品质量一塌糊涂，更别说从中国薅的羊毛更是不计其数（50-80年代我们大部分时间基本都是在卖肾援朝），根本不是它自己奋斗出来的繁荣而是别人白送的，一旦别人不送了，等待朝鲜这种几乎没有任何现代资源的苦寒之地的只有毁灭
还有很多当年在日本居住的朝鲜人回到朝鲜 再也没出来
Fabulous ! Thanks Jingwu ! I watched at it in one breath . Will there ever be material about Vietnam?
Definitely! Too much drama with Vietnam, lol.
Absolutely crazy video your channel is so underrated
Glad you liked it, man! I like being underrated, haha.
Amazing. I love your posts. Jingwu you said you are Mongolian Chinese. can you explain it?
Watch his old videos
There are many ethnic groups in China, and Mongol is one of them. Thanks for watching!
Cool content, bro
This video is very well done. Keep up the good work. Thank you for your efforts.
谢谢分享 韩国 延边都去过 希望延边地区越来越好
🤝🤝🤝
What a beautiful documentary! Thanks for creating this masterpiece!
My pleasure!
25:33 "I've heard the waitresses at this restaurant are exceptionally beautiful"
gotta respect that dedication to research
Joke aside, as a Vietnamese majoring in East Asia relations (mainly with Japanese), i learned a lot, thank you very much!
You are welcome, neighbor! HAVE TO CHECK THEM OUT, lmao.
Your documentaries are getting better and better. Look forward to watching more....best wishes from Malaysia 🇲🇾
Glad you like them!
you are a great history teller❤❤❤
정말 훌륭한 영상입니다. 한국인으로서 최대한 객관적인 시각에서 영상을 만들기 위한 당신의 노력에 경의와 감사를 표하고 싶습니다. 평생을 남한에서 교육받은 저에게 외국인의 객관적 시각으로 본 압록강, 백두산, 두만강과 그 곳에 사는 조선족의 역사를 다룬 두 편의 영상은 신선한 충격이었습니다.
시청 해주셔서 감사합니다. 이 말은 정말 마음이 따뜻해졌습니다. 감사합니다.
really love this channel and these parts of history, greetings from Venezuela
第二集简直就是一部朝鲜民族血泪史，看得我一个中国汉人好几次几乎落泪。对于脱北者，站在人道主义角度，中国做的不近人情，虽然中国当时也才刚吃饱饭，对于大量脱北者可能难以承受，但可以呼吁国际社会进行人道主义救援，让欧美发达国家接受一些难民，就像他们现在接受中东难民一样。
这是个很苦难的话题，很苦很难。
这个有问题的。1、如果中国不遣返脱北者，你认为会有多少人从朝鲜过来？至少几百万吧。2、哪个国家可以接收几百万的难民？3、朝鲜崩溃了，朝鲜这个地方被韩国占领，美军压到鸭绿江边？这种中国肯定不愿意啊
需要顾及和朝鲜的关系明面上不能这么做，我们需要这个抗美先锋
将非法移民驱逐回本国是国际惯例。如果我们将他们送往第三国，他们可能会被朝鲜政府指控绑架其国民，并引发更多外交事件。这与我们无关。除非韩国人直接在边境给朝鲜非法移民发放韩国护照，那么中国就可以将这些人驱逐到韩国。韩国在没有采取必要行动的情况下就指责中国，这是荒谬的。
😂 身为中国的朝鲜族感谢你同情这段历史，但是你想法太单纯，这时的联合国是美国说了算，对中国实行制裁的美国会考虑人权而帮助中国？
You rock, Jingwu. Been looking forward to part 2. I have learned much Asian history from watching your channel.
What are some other topics you're planning to tackle?
Thanks for watching! Central Asia.
@@Jingwushow wow looking forward to see more of your work thanks for taking time to do this, I learn so much from u