After Decades, Biden and Netanyahu Relationship at Inflection Point | The Mehdi Hasan Show

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
  • How can the U.S. maintain its relationship with Israel while Benjamin Natanyahu says the Israeli defense in Gaza will continue? Former U.S. Special Envoy for Israeli-Palestinian Negotiations Martin Indyk tells Mehdi Biden should reassure Netanyahu about the countries’ relationship, then push him toward a cease-fire.
    --------------------
    The Mehdi Hasan Show: Insightful reporting and probing interviews that examine the day's events and provide a deeper level of context for the politics of our interconnected society. Watch The Mehdi Hasan Show on The Choice channel on Peacock TV, weeknights, 7 p.m. ET. Subscribe to the channel for more interviews.
    peacocktv.com

Комментарии • 293

  • @allahuakbar3010
    @allahuakbar3010 3 года назад +114

    *"If I don't steal your house then someone else will"*
    Yaqub an Israeli settler from Brooklyn USA 2021

    • @Just_logic
      @Just_logic 3 года назад +2

      Pretty dangerous logic.

    • @farhanibrahim5925
      @farhanibrahim5925 3 года назад

      We must thanks yaqub for the quote of the year. His efforts cause worldwide attention of israel settler information

  • @TRE45ON.is.Bat5hit.Crazy.U.S.G
    @TRE45ON.is.Bat5hit.Crazy.U.S.G 3 года назад +118

    "If I don't steal your house, someone else will steal it." Israeli settler Jacob

    • @hatula1
      @hatula1 3 года назад

      just not true....i suggest you visit and see for yourself

    • @MichaelRoeterdink
      @MichaelRoeterdink 3 года назад +4

      @@hatula1 you missed that video?

    • @mofeedkharoufeh1186
      @mofeedkharoufeh1186 3 года назад +2

      Yes this is the exact reality of the suffering of Palestinian under occupation

    • @gypseeman
      @gypseeman 3 года назад +2

      @@hatula1 u must be in denial
      The reality video was posted
      Wake up man...

    • @osteomas4246
      @osteomas4246 3 года назад

      Vice reinterviewed him. He is from new york, he came to Isreal on January 2021. 🤦

  • @patrickx6940
    @patrickx6940 3 года назад +71

    "USA not an honest broker", thats a polite way to say it !

    • @zeenatevakhan9873
      @zeenatevakhan9873 3 года назад +8

      No politeness needed. Call a spade a spade. This out right war which kills children, journalists and noncombatants. Both countries need to hauled before the International Criminal Courts. Biden is a Catholic turn the other cheek. What if the Vatican city was bombed

    • @rosalinelowe972
      @rosalinelowe972 3 года назад +2

      I think Biden turned the other cheek because he has no
      choice. You can’t trust anyone in politics anymore not even Biden.

    • @wandaprock1015
      @wandaprock1015 3 года назад +4

      No , Trump and his son in law left Biden in one hell of a mess !

    • @faridakhajawall5504
      @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад +3

      @@wandaprock1015 yup that creep the son inlaw created all this mess in Aqsa mask.

    • @faridakhajawall5504
      @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад +2

      mean to say AQSA MOSQE

  • @deficrypto1234
    @deficrypto1234 3 года назад +11

    Isn't it a sad day when we can't even state that someone has a right to self defence???

  • @jimmcloughlin
    @jimmcloughlin 3 года назад +31

    Every time Netanyahu comes close to losing power some sort of incident like this happens to strengthen his power. He has engineered this over the past few weeks by his treatment of Arabs during Ramadan.

  • @Lala-me6no
    @Lala-me6no 3 года назад +10

    “IF I DON’T STEAL IT SOMEONE ELSE WILL “
    Jacob 2021

    • @felixrabe
      @felixrabe 3 года назад

      I start to wonder whether it is Unit 8200 posting half of the comments with this quote to steer the conversation.

  • @skb2359
    @skb2359 3 года назад +43

    Mehdi is so good at tackling tough issues fairly and on balance

  • @entityrocknrolla
    @entityrocknrolla 3 года назад +14

    You tell em Mehdi Sir....👍👍your voice echoes what many of us feel and resonate with!

  • @tornadofay
    @tornadofay 3 года назад +7

    the reason they can't say "Palestinian people have the right to self defend" because the sentence imply that Israel is the aggressor which is something a zionist will never admit even if it is the pure truth.

  • @eltigre7224
    @eltigre7224 3 года назад +45

    I hope Biden looks back at that with shame, to be a good friend with the devil itself - Netanyahu.

    • @tonymontana6550
      @tonymontana6550 3 года назад +2

      Wont happen

    • @blitzbees890
      @blitzbees890 3 года назад

      Like American is any better than Zionist lol . Remember they say birds of a feather flock together . You cant friend a satan unless you are satan yourself . After all USA is stand for United Satan of America .

    • @tonymontana6550
      @tonymontana6550 3 года назад

      @Ebola Extra the so card anti semitic card is defunct. People now understand that Zionism DOES NOT equal Semitism and Palestinians are semites also

  • @beshiryunus4279
    @beshiryunus4279 3 года назад +7

    Mahdi Hasan, again and again so honest. Keep up the good job.

  • @faridakhajawall5504
    @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад +10

    I love Your talk show.It is balanced and based on facts.Keep up the good work.

  • @ellenrosegaynor8063
    @ellenrosegaynor8063 3 года назад +26

    RESCUE GAZA with HOSPITAL SHIPS as well as AID, PROTECTION & INVESTMENT. USA please ❤️🧡💛💚

    • @luddity
      @luddity 3 года назад +1

      Neighboring countries should be required to offer them citizenship and safe passage to escape their prison.

    • @Deltanorth86
      @Deltanorth86 3 года назад

      Why??? So that they will come and use human bombs and knives to behead we Americans??? No shit, go to Egypt and Pakistan, they are your biggest supporters.

    • @user-je5cd8ys4t
      @user-je5cd8ys4t 3 года назад +4

      @@Deltanorth86 why the hell do you even have this age of Palestinians??..you have been well and truly brain washed...Palestinian pple were the only ones that welcomed these Israelis when no one else wanted them...they are alot nicer,.kinder and more humane than you..shame on you for your comment

    • @Deltanorth86
      @Deltanorth86 3 года назад

      @@user-je5cd8ys4t who gives a flying duck what you think?. I said what I said, America certainly do not need more terrorists.

    • @faridakhajawall5504
      @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад +3

      @@luddity western world should offer israel citizenship because they are living on a stolen and disputed land

  • @almird2260
    @almird2260 3 года назад +7

    According to Usa, Palestinans are allowed to selfdefense only when their both hands are cut off.

  • @remalim9471
    @remalim9471 3 года назад +7

    Shuldnt netanhayu be in jail for his crimes?

  • @nasman007
    @nasman007 3 года назад +11

    I thought Biden would be much better then donald but he's not better when it comes ro israelhell

  • @tap-unoreverseonyou
    @tap-unoreverseonyou 3 года назад +12

    He is right, why is everyone looking up to US, Uk, UN to meditate despite all these ? They only move in self interest.

    • @mohammadsiddiqui6221
      @mohammadsiddiqui6221 3 года назад +1

      Because US backs all agression Israel does. No US backing no atrocities.

  • @justinmiller1118
    @justinmiller1118 3 года назад +4

    Criticizing the actions of the ultranatiinalist Netanyahu administration is not at all equivalent to being anti-Israel.

  • @mukarji
    @mukarji 3 года назад +13

    “If I don’t steal your house, someone else will” Jewish men.

  • @wepromise6259
    @wepromise6259 3 года назад +18

    Dear sir, May Allah bless you, May Allah give you strength to put facts behind facts before the ignorant western world .I pray for you May Allah protect you.Aameen.
    Ikramuddin Akbar, from Karachi, Pakistan

    • @kristinkimberly3469
      @kristinkimberly3469 3 года назад

      Amen. It's such a complicated issue truly; all the parts and issues re Israel and Palestine. Because America does truly need Israel's help in the Middle East so badly, but I know many many Americans hate seeing what goes on in Palestine. They deserve their own land and peace already. And wth?! I thought Jared Kushner was "supposedly" going to make peace btwn ISRAEL and Palestine!!!? I was so mad when I saw that Palestine's needs were not even involved in the results!!!

  • @libanmohamed5503
    @libanmohamed5503 3 года назад +19

    Great show Mehdi 👍

  • @sammyking983
    @sammyking983 3 года назад +16

    Oh shucks I didn't know this about Biden !!!

    • @petefraser3013
      @petefraser3013 3 года назад +3

      Do some more research. He has been on the wrong side of history for most of his career. He pushed for the Iraq War, major supporter of the justice reform that locked up 100,000s of black and brown men, he voted to repeal Glass-Steagall (which was the precursor to the 2008 economic collapse) to name but a few. He comes across as a nice everyday guy, but he is rumored to have a red hot temper.

    • @faridakhajawall5504
      @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад

      yes he was always Pro Israeli that is same as being Pro Zionist.

  • @mirahsan2
    @mirahsan2 3 года назад +16

    American Taxpayer money could go to better places: like back to Americans for 1

  • @stephencopping9953
    @stephencopping9953 3 года назад +5

    Medhi wish you'd come back to the UK. We need you man!

    • @user-qn6yt3zx3w
      @user-qn6yt3zx3w 3 года назад

      In the land of the blind, the one eyed man is king.
      Mehdi has 2, so he’s staying!

  • @sammyking983
    @sammyking983 3 года назад +14

    He is BB's lapdog too

  • @rasat4829
    @rasat4829 3 года назад +3

    So, if you really think about the whole thing, the Palestinians are really fighting the Americans in Israel for their own land.

  • @tauriqabdullah6130
    @tauriqabdullah6130 3 года назад +8

    Why didn't you ask him about the human's rights watch report and the b'tselm report calling it an apartheid state.

  • @MJ-cl1dm
    @MJ-cl1dm 3 года назад +5

    It's very enjoyable to watch these seasoned politicians play with words to change Truth and colour it to one's own advantage. You can't really pin them down. The scoundrels are really good at it.

  • @visantparkash384
    @visantparkash384 3 года назад +3

    Deep down inside, democracy is more about balance than anything else. For peace and prosperity, we need a balanced policy in the Middle East.

  • @jasonblakes
    @jasonblakes 3 года назад +6

    Great video as always
    Thank you

  • @petefraser3013
    @petefraser3013 3 года назад +11

    This guest is a joke. It’s totally obvious where his allegiance lies.

    • @felixrabe
      @felixrabe 3 года назад

      I'd love to agree or disagree with you, but the audio is so bad I hardly understand a word he's saying.

    • @chakir348
      @chakir348 3 года назад +1

      Hes a monster he was one of the biggest Iraq war supporters hes a known Zionist

  • @nirmalsandhu693
    @nirmalsandhu693 3 года назад +3

    If Trump had said those same words there would have been a media backlash

  • @az..0N3
    @az..0N3 3 года назад +8

    Biden (at his age) needs to start preparing/thinking about the afterlife as God may be the most merciful but certainly ain't blind or forgetful!!

  • @khubza8999
    @khubza8999 3 года назад +3

    He said practically NOTHING--and Mehdi did NOT press him, either.

  • @mofeedkharoufeh1186
    @mofeedkharoufeh1186 3 года назад +1

    Good on you man , you have the decency and ability to confront the responses of your guests. Keep the good work and exploit this injustices on Palestinian.

  • @sohailmd123
    @sohailmd123 3 года назад +4

    This martin indyk guy was interviewed by mehdi on head to head al jazeera.....then he was super ignorant about isreal lmao see him now totally humbled

  • @nomadickhan6655
    @nomadickhan6655 3 года назад +3

    Good journalism sir
    God bless you 💐💐❤️❤️

  • @junaidbhatti5902
    @junaidbhatti5902 3 года назад +2

    Mehdi is marvelous

  • @jvola8523
    @jvola8523 3 года назад +14

    People like this are probably so amazing at word games & crossword puzzles.

  • @sony5713
    @sony5713 3 года назад +4

    Another 9/11-like tragedy that we are all observing but unable to prevent... What a pity.

  • @ghassansuleiman2221
    @ghassansuleiman2221 3 года назад +2

    What started in 1948 ends only in 1948 period

  • @hamzah3138
    @hamzah3138 3 года назад +2

    Well said Mehdi.

  • @stephencunningham6557
    @stephencunningham6557 3 года назад +4

    He couldn't say it because he doesn't believe it

  • @KhaletaniyaQueen
    @KhaletaniyaQueen 3 года назад +3

    He can even answer anything he just go around and around I don’t think Palestine 🇵🇸 the will get help from usa 🇺🇸

  • @allanlicudjacildo525
    @allanlicudjacildo525 3 года назад +2

    That's why I told my goverment to help me to transfer the money on my name. I already inform three sec
    Gov.ph how they initiate the budget

  • @lorrainehanson2868
    @lorrainehanson2868 3 года назад +5

    History is not going to be kind to Biden

    • @PinchHarmonic69
      @PinchHarmonic69 3 года назад

      Haha. Biden is doing a great job. Israel does have the right to defend itself, but should not be heavy handed or kill civilians unnecessarily. Both sides are wrong and right.

  • @mogamadgreyson143
    @mogamadgreyson143 3 года назад +9

    Sounds like a couple breaking up,i"t's not you it's me I still love you but can't we just be friends"

  • @kristinkimberly3469
    @kristinkimberly3469 3 года назад +2

    Excellent segment, dear Mehdi!! Love your questioning and being very fair. I feel so awful for the Palestinians. Again. It's so complicated, esp bcuz America does need Israel's help in the Middle East. So it's a very very hard position for the United States to be in. Although, it's just awful the humanitarian crisis happening in Palestine, from Israel! I don't see why some International group, maybe the UN or other, get in btwn those 2 countries and force peace!! Meaning they both get land, and if Israel starts the bombing again, they should lose some of their land each time they do that etc. Bcuz if it's always the U.S. involved, it's all around, too complicated.

  • @allanlicudjacildo525
    @allanlicudjacildo525 3 года назад +1

    I saw 1 man and 1woman sign initiating a there first move and suddenly they second move and third only now hacking activities.they already initiate this hacking activity.

  • @ajazizca
    @ajazizca 3 года назад +3

    Ambassador Indyk is totally out of touch. How long does Israel have to be in American embrace before they feel secure enough to move forward on peace deal.

    • @djh7087
      @djh7087 3 года назад

      No, he’s playing a role. Martin Indyk was AIPAC’s Research Director for a few years.

  • @naeemdin3606
    @naeemdin3606 3 года назад

    The questions are well put but I can't understand why no-one will answer it in a straight forward answer rather than saying one nation has the right and the other don't????

  • @zehrag3781
    @zehrag3781 3 года назад +3

    Just words

  • @ismailassenjee5914
    @ismailassenjee5914 3 года назад +6

    Benjamin Satanyahu

  • @allanlicudjacildo525
    @allanlicudjacildo525 3 года назад +2

    My desession is already done.i will withdraw now all my savings warnings and the balance of other investments..initiating a plan same strategy evry year.

  • @mtaqi7240
    @mtaqi7240 3 года назад +3

    'Do Palestinians have a right to self defense?'
    ' Well, I am not in a position to debate the legalities from up here'
    - Ned Price (State Spokesman)

  • @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
    @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings 3 года назад +2

    Mind Begs the Question:
    Those once expelled from their Homes
    If expell other from their Homes
    Human,Inhuman?

  • @Gabi-hv2xc
    @Gabi-hv2xc 3 года назад +1

    Was the West Bank occupied before 1967? Was Gaza Occupied before 67?

  • @WandererBrother
    @WandererBrother 3 года назад +1

    Why don't mehdi host Al Jazeera"s any show anymore?

    • @kenbrownfield6584
      @kenbrownfield6584 3 года назад

      Because Israel doesn't allow it.

    • @WandererBrother
      @WandererBrother 3 года назад

      @@kenbrownfield6584 who is Israel to boss on anything?Don't give me gibberish response

    • @8181k
      @8181k 3 года назад +1

      @@WandererBrother he changed jobs that's all. He first went to The Intercept. Then came to this Peacock/NBC network

    • @SM-nn6po
      @SM-nn6po 3 года назад

      He wants to open up the USA people’s eyes

  • @hopeafzali6777
    @hopeafzali6777 3 года назад

    US can stop the wars in Afghanistan, Palastine, Seria in a blink of an eye but there is something going on that they don’t do and let these people suffer.

  • @felixrabe
    @felixrabe 3 года назад

    Send the man a microphone.

  • @63Hash
    @63Hash 3 года назад

    .. So when can Gaza expect to get its Iron Dome? You know given that both have equal rights to security?

  • @mohommedyakub3114
    @mohommedyakub3114 3 года назад +2

    One side favoritism

  • @allanlicudjacildo525
    @allanlicudjacildo525 3 года назад +1

    I now us the 3rd day that I didn't sleep why. I watch there movements because someone traying to investigate how to shutdown my phone..because that's the only way and solution to steal the money.. look the money is on there hand.you know what I mean...
    They initiate a verbal words first second using the media to make ioyr name a trash second they will initiate a thief strategy and next hacking activity and next shut down the phone. They already win if they shutdown your phone

  • @realdemocracy11
    @realdemocracy11 3 года назад

    I loved it when Martin Indyke was ambushed by Norman Finkelstein on Democracy Now a few years ago.

  • @Viper-sg2ok
    @Viper-sg2ok 3 года назад +2

    One man political ambitions costing Palestinians their lives. Arm around israel? Pfff...

  • @natashabouran5019
    @natashabouran5019 3 года назад +3

    #savepalestine #savesheikhjarrah #gazaunderattack

  • @Lula2020
    @Lula2020 3 года назад +3

    I can't believe I voted for him wow?

  • @nikkster01
    @nikkster01 3 года назад

    deal with it by arresting war crim Bennie for a start

  • @bdtour7139
    @bdtour7139 3 года назад +2

    What can do world?

  • @hsbaden
    @hsbaden 3 года назад

    Your guest allegedly is an Australian Jew and has an Israeli passport as he fought with the Israeli forces in 1973 war . This draws doubt about his impartiality .

  • @zeenatevakhan9873
    @zeenatevakhan9873 3 года назад +1

    What a waste of USA taxpayer's money which could benefit to USA

  • @worldwatcher9671
    @worldwatcher9671 3 года назад

    Martin Indyk wants America to act like a stooge of Israel. Israel exists with American aid. The US President should not have to play games and excuses with Netanyahu to comply with POTUS request for immediate cease fire. Why should America first give assurance about country's relationship to an aggressive israel whio is committing human rights violations on a daily basis, before asking for ceasefire. I hate to see the mightiest nation in the world bending down to Israel, a nation of 7/8 million ! Laughable.

  • @pilfernandez
    @pilfernandez 3 года назад

    It is an unfair fight , always has been. It has been made more obvious 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

  • @desmondho9567
    @desmondho9567 3 года назад

    It is not who started this conflicts. All wars starts because of whose religion is greater and which location is their most sacred place.
    Another is whose idealogy or governmental system is better and Imperial Power forcefully enforce on to others.

  • @gadams47
    @gadams47 3 года назад

    Rhetorical double-speak. We’ve heard this before..... You push people to the brink they will inevitable respond. Stop invading under a “justification” of the “chosen”.

  • @kpthoo4231
    @kpthoo4231 3 года назад

    Jewish in the US is very very powerful. In the US 10% of Rich people owned 90 % of the wealth. Of this 90% Jewish owned 70% of the wealth

  • @junewebb-baptiste2409
    @junewebb-baptiste2409 3 года назад +2

    Poor Mike Pence. His brother didn't think he was worth defending and he has to continue to massage 45's rear .

  • @mrmarvellous5378
    @mrmarvellous5378 3 года назад

    Indyk couldn't bring himself to say the words that Palestinians have the right to defend themselves, I wonder why?

  • @chubnelson1231
    @chubnelson1231 3 года назад +1

    Arrest Ben.

  • @nirmalsandhu693
    @nirmalsandhu693 3 года назад

    Let’s reassure Netanyahu’s murderous offensive in Gaza which has been likened to shooting fish in a barrel

  • @teddyshunnarah4992
    @teddyshunnarah4992 3 года назад

    You have already invented this Israel, t started In 1897, and on. you did this with other nations from Europe, to protect your
    interests, what interests, you were so good at it the Christians had to leave. what a big mess.

  • @johngalt0096
    @johngalt0096 3 года назад

    Give us back our $25.735 billion. Warmongers.

  • @MrBlue8484
    @MrBlue8484 3 года назад

    I didn't know rokets from hamas can detect who's Jews or palastine in Israel wow

  • @ericsalinas7790
    @ericsalinas7790 3 года назад

    Another example of how there is no difference between Biden and Trump.

  • @johnlivanos5411
    @johnlivanos5411 3 года назад

    you invade their land , you kill their children , you oppress them in their own land , you are a apartheid state , you take their dignity :: what would you do ?

  • @mha4734
    @mha4734 3 года назад +1

    all americans live in cocosland.

  • @Bob.1973
    @Bob.1973 3 года назад +2

    How comes Biden was bald in his younger time....and now he got head covered with hair 😁 perhaps biotin 🤔

  • @zarathustra8200
    @zarathustra8200 3 года назад

    They do not have an equal right to defend themselves because of the power disparity between the groups if anything Palestinians have even more a right to defend themselves once the power disparity is reconciled then we can talk about equality

  • @bjuryshehu5268
    @bjuryshehu5268 3 года назад

    If u support a killer that means u are worst than him

  • @KhaletaniyaQueen
    @KhaletaniyaQueen 3 года назад +5

    😭😭😭✊✊🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

  • @beatpeace879
    @beatpeace879 3 года назад

    America was supposed to be world leader of peace it’s a joke

  • @trinamurray222
    @trinamurray222 3 года назад +1

    I think this guy needs to go back and read his Christian bible cause my understanding is God loved all people in their Christian bible also says Gods law you shall not kill and you shall not steal also being a Jew is not physical but is a matter of the heart if you love God yourself and others you are a Jew. ☮️

  • @realbadmanrealbadman2862
    @realbadmanrealbadman2862 3 года назад +1

    Israel. Da derrick chauvin of the middle east

  • @kensnape8075
    @kensnape8075 3 года назад

    Hurry up electric vehicles...it will really reduce the world's dependance on this area of the world.

    • @faridakhajawall5504
      @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад

      You are outdated.Electric vehicles are alreay in action.

  • @simayiya4421
    @simayiya4421 3 года назад

    An israeli settler attemting to justify forcibly taking the house of a palestinian family in tbe East jerusalem nighbourhood sheikh Jarrah.
    Palestinian women to yakub the israeli occupior: '' yakub,Youuuu aaare steaeeeling maaay houuuuse''.
    Yakub:' 'And if I dont steal it
    Someone else is going to steal it''.
    You cant argue with the logic of an israeli settler.
    I do steal your house
    Because if I dont do it
    Someone else will do it.
    That s what the drug dealers say when you asked them why you sell things that kill others.. If i dont sell to them someone else would sell it to them.
    Now I am going to rob a bank because if i dont rob it, then someone else wild rob it.

  • @faridakhajawall5504
    @faridakhajawall5504 3 года назад

    Biden is a wonderful human being.Like a beautiful rose has a thorn with it so has biden A thorn in the form of ISRAEL.

  • @beatpeace879
    @beatpeace879 3 года назад

    If you got a heart and you being human towards fellow humans and show your support for Palestine you are being labelled as lefty, why politicians and politics they ain’t got none of those certainly they ain’t got no heart

  • @sairaali1207
    @sairaali1207 3 года назад

    Had no idea this old gut was pro Israeli!! Come back trump all is forgiven.

  • @mofeedkharoufeh1186
    @mofeedkharoufeh1186 3 года назад

    God help us for the colourful American president

  • @soyouseethis
    @soyouseethis 3 года назад

    MEHDI HASAN should seriously quit being a media professional.
    Such blatant bias and lack of objectivity in every show he hosts.
    He is precisely what he accuses criticizes others of.
    Disgustingly one-sided coverage.