was a pleasure collaborating with you. I've been interested in covering rogue planets for a while and this was the perfect opportunity to do so btw here is the playlist of my astronomy videos for those of you who are interested: ruclips.net/p/PLZsYI0SZIhPBFZ5V-ROjP4MJ2l3WfcqlR
I think because there is a real chance that one of them can be really near us, somewhere in Oort cloud we secretly want to find some new stuff somewhere near us to explore it, and since everything that emits light was already found, those dark objects is the last chance sort of same with small black holes, having one stable and nearby can give such an advantage to science
Probably because they're so hard to study, and finding one is basically stumbling on it by pure luck since you can't really reproduce a lensing event several thousands of light years away.
To me they feel as sad as they are mysterious. Doomed to aimlessly wander the great cosmic dark heading who knows where. Alone. Forever. If that doesn't make anybody feel humbled by or have gratitude for our circumstances here on Earth I don't know what will.
that part that makes me really curious is imagine there's tons of rogue planets out there that hypothetically could've been perfect earths, but because they're not orbiting a star they never will be
@@HearMeLearnEven after billions of years, deep below the frozen surfaces of their oceans, there may still be enough geothermal warmth for life to survive
@@Soviet_Hivemind Let me clarify. By non-existent," I meant how people think the planet is because of how misinformation was spread. Not necessarily the existence itself but how people think the planet is.
In Dune 2, a videogame from the early 90s, Giedi Prime was depicted as a black sphere, making me think it was not lit by any sun. That was my first introduction to the idea of a planet orbiting a dead star or being rogue.
This is thus far the first high-yield astronomy channel that I have discovered. Thank you so much, this was a very educational and interesting video. I presume J1407b is the running joke within your community???
In effect, yeah. With how sensational the idea of a ring system as large as J1407b's was purported to be, it's become one of the most commonly peddled pieces of misinfo by astroslop channels.
The concept of a rogue planet appeared decades ago in the comic "Flash Gordon" with the planet Mongo. A lot less was known about the attributes of such a planet back then.
I've been considering writing about something like this some time, but yeah, imagine if aliens grew in pitch black, with the only light in the sky being bright stars to guide them since thanks to the lack of close-light, light pollution would be non-existant except for bioluminescent life perhaps. It'd be very pretty to see the night sky as it was intended, and then just a black sphere blocking out the sky of which would the the orbited star/giant.
Heres a spooky thought. There are many stars that exist in the space between galaxies, many in the supervoids. Imagine living on a planet orbiting one of these, where the nearest other star is millions of light years away, and indeed you'd have no way of knowing a universe outside your sun even exists
Rogue planets are awesome, and the binaries found in the Orion Nebula are particularly fascinating! However, “sub-brown dwarf” is a stupid name. If a celestial object doesn’t have enough mass to undergo any nuclear fusion, it’s not a star or brown dwarf. It doesn’t matter if it formed _like_ a star if it doesn’t have any stellar properties. Those are gas giant planets.
I knew about rogue planets, but I definitely didn't know how prevalent they are. I thought most of not almost all planets formed in star systems and that they only occasionally got ejected, so I thought they would only make up single digit percentage of planets. In reality, they're way way more common.
one thing I've often wondered is how likely is it for a rogue planet to find it's way into another solar system and what might it take to figure that out. I guess retrograde orbits/rotation might be a possible clue.
I always wondered about J1407b for a long time when i found out about it, and you've been the only reason i know it isnt a very ringed planet (i also dont think a planet could have that many rings in the first place like how would its roche limit be so large?🤔🤨) Amazing video like always 😌
Realistically there probably was only Five giants/ If the Fifth Giant ever was a thing it is either our Planet 9 we are looking for or is long gone probably somewhere outside of the Galaxy or somewhere else.
However there has been Six Gas Giants found around G-Type Stars before but realistically our system is super odd with the fact that there is oddly newer rocky planets with a composition of Gas Giants almost 50 MYO then the pair. I'm a heavy believer in the Grand Tack and / Other Planets that didn't make it theories.
@@HomewaveA its possible that rocky planets aren't that rare but its just our limited sample size combined with the fact that its harder to detect smaller planets.
In your images of these really hot new planets their heat is red I’m curious if a planet is hot enough can it show a blue or white heat idk if that’s possible but it would be cool?
@@Kyplanet893 Yea sorry I didn't get that far into it b4 I made my comment but at the same time, I think the specifics and models should be taken with a gain of salt. Like how do we know it's gas planet or w/e if the only date we have is a slight light deflection.
@@titan-1802 To be completely honest I don't think there was Six giants, The Fifth Giant is either beyond the Kuiper belt or long gone somewhere outside of our galaxy or on the other side of it.
@@HomewaveA thats my take too,either its long gone and we won't ever identify it,cause it can be literally anywhere,or its the planet 9 we are searching for
Does anyone know if any of them have gotten too close to our black hole, yet? Imagine watching it eat other planets, now that would be amazing and terrifying to see.
They would still lack the mass to explain dark Matter, since this would have to be more then all visible mass combined, while planets (even if they outnumber stars) have only a fraction of the stars mass (the sun has way more then 90% of all matter in the solar system)
Per Definition a Planet must have cleared its Orbit from other Objecte. But rogue Planets dont have any Orbit to clear. So i guess we have to redefine Planet, again. And all just because someone had to demote Pluto
Where could the planets that are theorized to have been thrown out of our solar system when or before Neptune and Uranus orbits were changed by Jupiter and Saturn?
so if there 10 times more rogue planets than stars and also 10 times more rogue moons - So around us in 4 lightyear shere there should be 100 rouge moons and some even in the solarsystem passing through
part of me thinks it might be a reference to the hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy, wherein 42 is the meaning of life, as determined by a 7.5 million-year-old supercomputer
If it's in orbit it will be seen regularly and can be studied over time potentially. If it is a rogue, it is, I understand, a one-off. So we know small rocky rogues exist but at the moment they can not be studied well because we see them and then they vanish into the darkness of space.
Planet may not be a suitable term for these objects. A planet by definition orbits a star, if it orbits another planet, it is a moon. If such objects not gravitationally bound to any star prove to be incredibly common in the universe, they should have their own unique term seperate from planet or moon
@@JamestonBoi it’s not true; a lot of stars don’t have planets orbiting them. In fact, we have no idea whether most stars have planets or not since we aren’t capable of knowing, yet. It’s safe to say that rogue planets don’t outnumber stars. Edit: rogue planets
@ayaan9646 it is not safe to say that at all best we can tell most stars have several planets, and the ones that don’t also happen to be the rarest types of stars the “lots of stars probably don’t have planets” idea is outdated and from when we only knew of a handful of exoplanets instead of thousands modern estimates suggest there are anywhere from 8-40 rogue planets per every star
Rogueplanets are SADLY LONELY planets without a star! Is it possible to a Rogueplanet to come here in our Solar System and what it's effect to a Solar System would be? 🌌☀🌏🌍🌎🌑🪐🌠
Go watch trolligi www.youtube.com/@Trolligi
Already subscribed to this channel, it's underrated.
i know trolligi! !
trolligi? The one from Celestia forum? No wonder they seems familiar.
@@redkino that would be me
also my comments here keep getting deleted
Oh boy, finnaly a video on rouge planeta
was a pleasure collaborating with you. I've been interested in covering rogue planets for a while and this was the perfect opportunity to do so
btw here is the playlist of my astronomy videos for those of you who are interested: ruclips.net/p/PLZsYI0SZIhPBFZ5V-ROjP4MJ2l3WfcqlR
Well done👍
Here i am watching this for the 2nd time, well done!
@ thats crazy
Idk why but rogue planets are one of the most interesting kinds of planet because it’s just have that mysterious vibe to it
It's like they have massive rogue guilds on them. You would be have your pocket picked before you even landed.
I think because there is a real chance that one of them can be really near us, somewhere in Oort cloud
we secretly want to find some new stuff somewhere near us to explore it, and since everything that emits light was already found, those dark objects is the last chance sort of
same with small black holes, having one stable and nearby can give such an advantage to science
Probably because they're so hard to study, and finding one is basically stumbling on it by pure luck since you can't really reproduce a lensing event several thousands of light years away.
I love rogue planets. They are the planetary enigma.
To me they feel as sad as they are mysterious.
Doomed to aimlessly wander the great cosmic dark heading who knows where. Alone. Forever.
If that doesn't make anybody feel humbled by or have gratitude for our circumstances here on Earth I don't know what will.
7:37 J1407b jumpscare
man will take any opportunity he can to mention this cursed world
Saw this comment right before it popped up and cackled lmao
Haha
in fairness, it DOES fit the sub-brown dwarf topic
@@Trolligi This cursed NON-world you mean because it isn't even that lol.
The algorithm doesn't like this type of videos if there isn't any misinformation. So sad. But don't worry, you still are the best astronomy channel.
This usually happens because misinformation is most of the times absurd or "eye-catching" if you will, and gets most of the views.
any else feel shivers that theres PLANETS just floating through space with no light, unbound from solar systems? eerie
that part that makes me really curious is imagine there's tons of rogue planets out there that hypothetically could've been perfect earths, but because they're not orbiting a star they never will be
They’re lurking… watching you…
@@HearMeLearnJust another reason to hold onto and cherish how lucky we are to be here on our pale blue dot. The only home we've ever known.🌏
@@HearMeLearnEven after billions of years, deep below the frozen surfaces of their oceans, there may still be enough geothermal warmth for life to survive
@@Phosfit 😂
this is a nice halloween gift, this is themed like a halloween special (even though its not)
maybe it is just a little bit
I'm glad I'm not the only who felt this way!
Kyplanet is the first person who has beefed with a non-existent Planet. J1407b
It's a rogue planet
@@Soviet_Hivemind Let me clarify. By non-existent," I meant how people think the planet is because of how misinformation was spread. Not necessarily the existence itself but how people think the planet is.
@@JamestonBoiit’s not really confirmed
@@Soviet_Hivemindtestimony says brown dwarf
@@Soviet_Hivemind it's a brown dwarf
In Dune 2, a videogame from the early 90s, Giedi Prime was depicted as a black sphere, making me think it was not lit by any sun. That was my first introduction to the idea of a planet orbiting a dead star or being rogue.
I heard these Rouges have a special sneak attack that destabilizes orbits with intimidation just with their mere presence.
The term planet means wanderer, making rogue planets more worthy of the name than what we normally consider planets, arguably.
This is thus far the first high-yield astronomy channel that I have discovered. Thank you so much, this was a very educational and interesting video.
I presume J1407b is the running joke within your community???
In effect, yeah. With how sensational the idea of a ring system as large as J1407b's was purported to be, it's become one of the most commonly peddled pieces of misinfo by astroslop channels.
Rouge planets are super underrated
Nah, they are uninteresting. They get the attention they deserve.
@@ayaan9646If something appears uninteresting, you’re not looking hard enough
@@oberonpanopticon not everything has to be forcibly made to be interesting. There are uninteresting things in space and that’s okay.
@@ayaan9646 I don’t believe anything is uninteresting. There’s only willful ignorance.
The concept of a rogue planet appeared decades ago in the comic "Flash Gordon" with the planet Mongo. A lot less was known about the attributes of such a planet back then.
This video scared tf outta me. I had to turn on the lights just to finish it.
Name a better rivalry than J1407b VS Kyplanet 💀
Babe wake up new ky video just dropped
I like your voice. I’m glad you are in the space video industry.
is this how nerds flirt
@@sepsysmurf6982 😭😭😭
This man does so high quality videos it's crazy that you only have about 52k subs
imagine life in one of these, forever stuck in a perpetual night
perpetual night at 51°F, perfect environment tbh
I've been considering writing about something like this some time, but yeah, imagine if aliens grew in pitch black, with the only light in the sky being bright stars to guide them since thanks to the lack of close-light, light pollution would be non-existant except for bioluminescent life perhaps. It'd be very pretty to see the night sky as it was intended, and then just a black sphere blocking out the sky of which would the the orbited star/giant.
No days, no years, and no light. Just the stars circling above
Heres a spooky thought. There are many stars that exist in the space between galaxies, many in the supervoids. Imagine living on a planet orbiting one of these, where the nearest other star is millions of light years away, and indeed you'd have no way of knowing a universe outside your sun even exists
@@thesenate1844 well you still would know, youd still see galaxies as little dots in the night sky
Gonna watch you J-107B playlist today.
*insert Nibiru joke here:*
Rogue planets are awesome, and the binaries found in the Orion Nebula are particularly fascinating! However, “sub-brown dwarf” is a stupid name. If a celestial object doesn’t have enough mass to undergo any nuclear fusion, it’s not a star or brown dwarf. It doesn’t matter if it formed _like_ a star if it doesn’t have any stellar properties. Those are gas giant planets.
Great analysis of the jumbos 🙂
Gorgeous thumbnail 😮
I knew about rogue planets, but I definitely didn't know how prevalent they are. I thought most of not almost all planets formed in star systems and that they only occasionally got ejected, so I thought they would only make up single digit percentage of planets. In reality, they're way way more common.
Man, I can't wait for you to collaborate with Sea Space. Also, I love your content. It's nice to watch real astronomy videos for once.
one thing I've often wondered is how likely is it for a rogue planet to find it's way into another solar system and what might it take to figure that out. I guess retrograde orbits/rotation might be a possible clue.
my favourite space youtuber cooking again
Cool video this is something I also wondered! With so much space there much be some that are just flying out there
I always wondered about J1407b for a long time when i found out about it, and you've been the only reason i know it isnt a very ringed planet (i also dont think a planet could have that many rings in the first place like how would its roche limit be so large?🤔🤨)
Amazing video like always 😌
This one got recommended for me so I’m guessing it will be recommended to other people
nice video like always
Imagine if there was life on a super earth sized rogue planet. How good will it do for some billion years
thanks for the content
5th Giant is a rouge planet from the Solar System. It was ejected by Jupiter and Saturn during the migrations of Uranus, Neptune & Planet 9.
Realistically there probably was only Five giants/ If the Fifth Giant ever was a thing it is either our Planet 9 we are looking for or is long gone probably somewhere outside of the Galaxy or somewhere else.
However there has been Six Gas Giants found around G-Type Stars before but realistically our system is super odd with the fact that there is oddly newer rocky planets with a composition of Gas Giants almost 50 MYO then the pair. I'm a heavy believer in the Grand Tack and / Other Planets that didn't make it theories.
@@HomewaveA its possible that rocky planets aren't that rare but its just our limited sample size combined with the fact that its harder to detect smaller planets.
They're just out there... 0:25 , minding their own business...
In your images of these really hot new planets their heat is red I’m curious if a planet is hot enough can it show a blue or white heat idk if that’s possible but it would be cool?
Theres probably a rogue planet named Billy
whaat
I am a rogue planet named Billy, hi
what
There’s probably a rogue planet named Jeremy Elbertson
trve
If this sub-brown dwarf is room temperature it’s possible it has life.
no
life needs WAY more things to work than just temperature
I don't think so. Sorry.
You deserve way more subscribers
you know who else deserves more subscribers? 😊😊😊
@Trolligi who 😏
JUMBOS are such a cute name omfg😭 makes me want to cuddle those giant burning newly formed masses of gas😩
I love your videos! ❤️
How do they detect them if they aren't visible and they don't exert measurable gravitational forces?
Inferred I guess?
microlensing
@@Kyplanet893 Yea sorry I didn't get that far into it b4 I made my comment but at the same time, I think the specifics and models should be taken with a gain of salt. Like how do we know it's gas planet or w/e if the only date we have is a slight light deflection.
Great video!
I wonder if a moon of these rogues could for a short while have liquid water because of the heart of the rogue planet.
Or tidal heating
Have you heard of the theory around Jupiter ejecting an ice giant from our solar system? The fifth planet nice model is what its called I think
If it exsists it wasnt ejected it was just sent to kaiper belt sence scientest observed sole strange lnlike objects being efected by somthings gravity
@@Freakykuna.8 Depending if you interpret the Fifth Giant and Planet Nine as one of the same or completely separate things.
@@titan-1802 To be completely honest I don't think there was Six giants, The Fifth Giant is either beyond the Kuiper belt or long gone somewhere outside of our galaxy or on the other side of it.
@@HomewaveA thats my take too,either its long gone and we won't ever identify it,cause it can be literally anywhere,or its the planet 9 we are searching for
@@HomewaveA I have to agree with that too.
NO WAY I Appeared 10:52 (masonhunter)
Does anyone know if any of them have gotten too close to our black hole, yet? Imagine watching it eat other planets, now that would be amazing and terrifying to see.
This is a good video
10:51 Discord DM leak jumpscare
9:28 Unicron jumpscare
Is there anything about tidal heating on rogue planet's moons?
I thought J1407b had a circumplanetary disk instead of a protoplanetary disk.
Maybe dumb question but if there are as many rogue planets as the high estimate implies there could be could that explain the "dark matter" issue?
They would still lack the mass to explain dark Matter, since this would have to be more then all visible mass combined, while planets (even if they outnumber stars) have only a fraction of the stars mass (the sun has way more then 90% of all matter in the solar system)
@comentedonakeyboard okay then I will go back to being highly skeptical of dark matter as a mathematics downfall then lol
Rogue planet: I’m an IN👏DAH👏PEN👏DENT👏 planet, and I don’t need 👏NO 👏SUN!👏
Everybody gangsta until they start approaching another rogue planet
Everybody gangsta until they start approaching another rogue planet
less than one rogue planet per cubic light year would be enough to account for the total mass of dark matter
Will you ever talk about europa clipper?
bruv why you leaking your discord dms? 10:51 🤣
shhhhh 🤫
@@Trolligi 🤨
@@yazovgaming ok dmitry yazov gaming
Per Definition a Planet must have cleared its Orbit from other Objecte. But rogue Planets dont have any Orbit to clear. So i guess we have to redefine Planet, again.
And all just because someone had to demote Pluto
Discord jump scare 10:51
Where could the planets that are theorized to have been thrown out of our solar system when or before Neptune and Uranus orbits were changed by Jupiter and Saturn?
The fifth giant theory?
I've got a question: what is ganymede's crust made of and why is it that thick
ur discord popped up for a frame at 10:51 😭
I don't have sound on, i really wish I could know what you meant by rogue planets right now
Rouge 💄 planets
Can you talk about nebulae next?
But assain j21b is bigger than J1407b 8:20
Love from j1407b
How do we take pictures of it if it's completely dark?
the hottest ones glow
so if there 10 times more rogue planets than stars and also 10 times more rogue moons - So around us in 4 lightyear shere there should be 100 rouge moons and some even in the solarsystem passing through
Zombie Planets video when?
WUT? More rogue planets than regular planets? HOW?
5:55 isn't everything in space a coincidence? I don't really understand this line
part of me thinks it might be a reference to the hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy, wherein 42 is the meaning of life, as determined by a 7.5 million-year-old supercomputer
How can you tell by micro lensing that the planet is not in orbit and is in fact rogue?
If it's in orbit it will be seen regularly and can be studied over time potentially. If it is a rogue, it is, I understand, a one-off. So we know small rocky rogues exist but at the moment they can not be studied well because we see them and then they vanish into the darkness of space.
@paulohagan3309 ok thanks for telling me!
@@kaedz3055 Welcome.
5:28 *click*
Is Law By Mike click bait?
👍🏻🌑
Planet may not be a suitable term for these objects. A planet by definition orbits a star, if it orbits another planet, it is a moon. If such objects not gravitationally bound to any star prove to be incredibly common in the universe, they should have their own unique term seperate from planet or moon
Pluto got Avenged
Nope, it's just definition NASA gave to planets sucks.
@@marks.7211 POV: Its the IAU, not NASA.
HI
4 minutes yay
rogue planets1
Lol discord screenshot 10:52
Rogue planets don’t outnumber stars lol
according to recent evidence they almost certainly do
You are aware there are a lot more planets than stars, right?
And more moons then planets
@@JamestonBoi it’s not true; a lot of stars don’t have planets orbiting them. In fact, we have no idea whether most stars have planets or not since we aren’t capable of knowing, yet. It’s safe to say that rogue planets don’t outnumber stars.
Edit: rogue planets
@ayaan9646 it is not safe to say that at all
best we can tell most stars have several planets, and the ones that don’t also happen to be the rarest types of stars
the “lots of stars probably don’t have planets” idea is outdated and from when we only knew of a handful of exoplanets instead of thousands
modern estimates suggest there are anywhere from 8-40 rogue planets per every star
2/10 no Zonama Sekot reference
Replace Oumuamua with a Jupiter size rogue, alter it's trajectory a bit and you get... ruclips.net/video/KcLaMyc4ecE/видео.html
10:52 ;]
Pondo
85th to comment.
Would love to watch your videos on Nebula instead of RUclips
Can someone give me tips on how to avoid ai videos 😢
Sadly, the only way you can get rid of them is by pressing "Don't recommend channel". But unfortunately, they'll keep popping up. :(
@titan-1802 the sheer amount of them is staggering 😢
@@sajidansari911 Yeah, its really unfortunate...
Rogueplanets are SADLY LONELY planets without a star! Is it possible to a Rogueplanet to come here in our Solar System and what it's effect to a Solar System would be? 🌌☀🌏🌍🌎🌑🪐🌠