I have been informed that the K-On clip is intentionally meant to be inaccurate. Kinda funny that it's still better than about half of the animated drumming scenes I've reviewed so far.
Just one random thing. I hate to be this guy. When you're talking into the mic, it's coming through really strong on the left side. It might just be me, but when I'm using headphones it really throws me off.
It actually made me really disappointed that one of my favourite shows got such a low rating just because of the performance choice Other scenes are animated with a lot of a lot of care, and accuracy Ritsu made me want to play drums!!!
Regarding that K-ON! section. They're not actually playing their instruments in that scene. They're pretending to play while that song is playing from a radio somewhere in that room. As much as I'm happy that this anime got featured here, I'm a bit disappointed that Eric chose this scene.
I don't blame him, it's pretty much the only scene you can find easily on RUclips. I suspect the other musical performances would get a copyright match right away.
I used to do motion capture! I can say that crossing your arms between a snare and hi hat would certainly cause some errors in a mocap system that wasn't set up specifically for drumming. Gotta get good coverage on all markers on your arms and body
The thing about most of these is that the animators may be told "there will be a music segment here, it will be at about this bpm, in this genre" without actually hearing the music, so they have no idea what they're animating to until it's too late to make any changes.
#1: WWAP should have been played with rulers for tonal difference. #2: Invisible bass drum pedal #3: Parts of this WWAP sounded better than original #4: Would have been easy to animate correctly #5: Would have been easy to animate correctly
What's fun about that clip from K-On is that none of them are actually playing what's sounding, just dramatically imitating a cassette of their club advisor's band
As someone who is in the msm community, seeing shugabush island just appear onscreen was a massive jumpscare. Been loving this series so glad to see you cover something so close to my heart
I was hoping you'd show the more stomp-y segments of Ain't got Rhythm, but I guess that's outside of the scope of this series. Props for pulling the Hitman scene, it's always hilarious how 47 has so many random talents and the accuracy (or mostly-accurate) of the scene really sells it.
3:35 i think this applies to musicians in general. like i saw incredibles 2 in theaters and seeing the trombonists in the end credits move the slide to do a crescendo hurt my soul
the k-on scene that you chose for this video was the least accurate in the series by a long shot and there's actually a good reason in-universe for this. i'm not sure if you watched the entire scene or just the performance but the punchline to that entire scene was that the performance shown was entirely fake and they were playing along to a track because they wanted to "change things up" and act as a much edgier band than they actually are, complete with squabbling over incredibly minor, petty things and talks about "breaking up the band over creative differences" (much to the audience's, and fifth member of the band's, initial horror). the rest of the show's drumming is a lot more accurate because, well, for the other scenes, the drummer's actually playing and not pretending to be an overly-flashy metal drummer with a bunch of unnecessary big hits; and quite possibly, to an astute drummer's eye, the amount of inaccuracy in this scene compared to the rest kinda foreshadows that something's off about the entire scene before their uncharacteristic fighting even starts and much before the fifth member finds the boombox that was actually playing the music. outside of that, great video! i love this series and i'm happy to see that k-on did make the cut; getting a c for their most stylistically inaccurate performance is still pretty darn good and seeing the waap and wissl were hilarious.
You should do "Gyro Drums" from Animusic 2. We know the animation will be right, but I would like to se you W.I.S.S.L. it just to see if you could replicate the Animusic kit.
Speaking of games, how accurate is the drummer in the Guitar Hero/Rock Band games? That might need a video of it's own because there's a lot of those games and I'm sure the animations became better as time went on.
@@jtheman6369 it's an Android app game (not sure if on iOS) where you unlock monsters, and each one has a short musical phrase they repeat. You then get to organize them in a way to create your own songs. It's all generic stuff, which is why all the vocals are various sounds instead of actual singing.
Here's a good contender for the next episode: Ika Musume Season 1 Episode 7 It comes in at the end of the episode where Squid Girl is shown playing the drums. She makes use of her tentacles as well, so it shows her playing like 10 different parts at the same time. Obviously it's not meant to be realistic, but I thought it would be interesting to see your reaction to it.
Hitman is stiff bc even though they used motion-capture that doesn't mean they used every frame (bc they still have to convert it to animation). They probably edited every couple frames and the rest got erased or replaced by copy paste. That's why it's so robotic.
Kind of surprised you haven't done Animal from the Muppets yet. I mean, he's one of the most famous fictional drummers out there. And before anyone says "He only does cartoons and video games," I'd like to remind you, Muppet Babies exists, and is a cartoon.
This video was great! If you do this again maybe you could try Shellbeat from MSM, I know you already did that game but it would be cool to see if they animated the drums correctly with that monster
Do Camp Lazlo, Sailor Moon, Shimmer and Shine, Hi Hi Puffy AmiYumi, Whatever Happened to Robot Jones and Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends for the next one
Can you react to Got Motion from Gothenburg, Sweden? They are a bunch of highschool kids (abt 16-18 years old), it includes a drumline, marimbas, vibraphones and a guitar. I want you to react to a video called "waves" because it's the version without mistakes. They won a regionals competition and came second in CGN championships with the song.
Doesn't take a drummer to recognize that it's not animated correctly in most cases. I've played piano for a long time and can easily tell when any instrument isn't animated correctly. Drums, flute, saxophone, etc. Squidward's clarinet is not even what a clarinet actually looks like, but they continue insisting that it's a clarinet all throughout the show.
I played My Singing Monsters, and pretty much every Drum Kit monster in that game are unusual compare to real Drum Kits. Either they are a living drum kit (T-Rox for example stomps its feet for a kickbeat and chomps for a snare), their drum kit is impossible to translate (Deedge and Furnoss), or they do have a Drum Kit, but it doesn't look like a traditional one (Shellbeat's drum kit doesn't have a kickbeat but it uses its shell as a kickbeat). Same with every instrumental monsters in general.
I wonder how disappointed Bill Burr was in the animating of the drums on F is for Family. He is a big jazz drum guy so you know that had to break his heart a little.
Could you do: "Denn wenn et Trömmelche jeht | TiRiLi - Kinderlieder zum Mitsingen" from the kids channel TiRiLi Kinderlieder? It has a German Locke and uses only the "Kleine Trommel" Greetings from Germany
I have been informed that the K-On clip is intentionally meant to be inaccurate.
Kinda funny that it's still better than about half of the animated drumming scenes I've reviewed so far.
They are just kids, cut them some slack
Just one random thing. I hate to be this guy. When you're talking into the mic, it's coming through really strong on the left side. It might just be me, but when I'm using headphones it really throws me off.
@@gamesaregood9904 just don’t 💪🏻😂
@@gamesaregood9904 It’s strong enough I’m noticing out of my phone speakers too
@@gamesaregood9904 Yeah even with speakers it's pretty obvious.
K-On definitely needs a redo with a different scene.
Yea, they were doing essentially lip syncing in that scene, they weren't actually playing
In that particular scene, they are miming the performance and not actually playing.
It actually made me really disappointed that one of my favourite shows got such a low rating just because of the performance choice
Other scenes are animated with a lot of a lot of care, and accuracy
Ritsu made me want to play drums!!!
Regarding that K-ON! section.
They're not actually playing their instruments in that scene. They're pretending to play while that song is playing from a radio somewhere in that room.
As much as I'm happy that this anime got featured here, I'm a bit disappointed that Eric chose this scene.
I don't blame him, it's pretty much the only scene you can find easily on RUclips. I suspect the other musical performances would get a copyright match right away.
@@jonessperandio Fair point. The only scene I could think of as an alternative is the last part of the season 1's first episode.
that’s soooo much more sense now
Exactly, I have the exact same thoughts on this
The fact that it's still fairly accurate is hilarious to me.
As others are pointing out the K-On clip was the girls miming to a tape of their teacher playing when she was in the same club.
you gotta love an animator who gets the animation at least pretty close. really puts live action movies/shows with obviously fake drummers to shame!!
and once you see it, cant be un-seen
I used to do motion capture! I can say that crossing your arms between a snare and hi hat would certainly cause some errors in a mocap system that wasn't set up specifically for drumming. Gotta get good coverage on all markers on your arms and body
The thing about most of these is that the animators may be told "there will be a music segment here, it will be at about this bpm, in this genre" without actually hearing the music, so they have no idea what they're animating to until it's too late to make any changes.
My left ear really loved that voice over.
#1: WWAP should have been played with rulers for tonal difference.
#2: Invisible bass drum pedal
#3: Parts of this WWAP sounded better than original
#4: Would have been easy to animate correctly
#5: Would have been easy to animate correctly
In #2 you can see the drum center (forgot what its called) responding so i dont think it matters
You should make a set of tenors out of different sized snare drums.
Id like to agree that seeing shugabush island was a bit of a jaw drop moment
I'd love to see Ringo drumming in Yellow Submarine rated in this series.
Just landed in Gulfport MS! Turned off airplane mode and got this announcement! Can't wait to watch it! 😜
I liked the Led Zeppelin part. Kind of genius how it sounded like lemonsong but far enough away to not get copyright problems
Band is called "Liffed Riffs" in the show. It's very tongue in cheek humor. The whole stage is, 70s x a million.
What's fun about that clip from K-On is that none of them are actually playing what's sounding, just dramatically imitating a cassette of their club advisor's band
As someone who is in the msm community, seeing shugabush island just appear onscreen was a massive jumpscare. Been loving this series so glad to see you cover something so close to my heart
Same
I was so scared that it was gonna be out of time. 😅 I love MSM as well!
I love the face of the kid with the shakers,in the American Dad video! & the pickle squeezing Led Zeppelin band 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I was hoping you'd show the more stomp-y segments of Ain't got Rhythm, but I guess that's outside of the scope of this series. Props for pulling the Hitman scene, it's always hilarious how 47 has so many random talents and the accuracy (or mostly-accurate) of the scene really sells it.
'We're engineering the perfect assassin. What do we need?' 'He needs to be able to rock on the drums' 'Perfect.'
forgot i even commented last time then saw my suggestion pop up on screen! very cool moment! thanks for including me :) good stuff as always!
Nice job on the metal WISLL!
3:35 i think this applies to musicians in general. like i saw incredibles 2 in theaters and seeing the trombonists in the end credits move the slide to do a crescendo hurt my soul
I’d love it if you could do “I Remember You” from the show Adventure Time!
To be fair, it was stated that he got his Rhythm back, not that he was good at drums
the k-on scene that you chose for this video was the least accurate in the series by a long shot and there's actually a good reason in-universe for this.
i'm not sure if you watched the entire scene or just the performance but the punchline to that entire scene was that the performance shown was entirely fake and they were playing along to a track because they wanted to "change things up" and act as a much edgier band than they actually are, complete with squabbling over incredibly minor, petty things and talks about "breaking up the band over creative differences" (much to the audience's, and fifth member of the band's, initial horror). the rest of the show's drumming is a lot more accurate because, well, for the other scenes, the drummer's actually playing and not pretending to be an overly-flashy metal drummer with a bunch of unnecessary big hits; and quite possibly, to an astute drummer's eye, the amount of inaccuracy in this scene compared to the rest kinda foreshadows that something's off about the entire scene before their uncharacteristic fighting even starts and much before the fifth member finds the boombox that was actually playing the music.
outside of that, great video! i love this series and i'm happy to see that k-on did make the cut; getting a c for their most stylistically inaccurate performance is still pretty darn good and seeing the waap and wissl were hilarious.
anime nerd booo
🤓
This needed to be said lol
🤓🤓🤓
🤓
Oh hey, your double bass is getting better.
We all love a good EMC Video
The real thing not only sounds cooler but it looks cooler as well!
My left ear enjoyed the video 👍
you should do the ice kings drumming in : I remember you, season 4 of adventure time.
You should do "Gyro Drums" from Animusic 2. We know the animation will be right, but I would like to se you W.I.S.S.L. it just to see if you could replicate the Animusic kit.
good idea
Uh oh, there's a bot in this house.
@@dudeonlygamingandotherstuf7791 and it's of mr hall
Speaking of games, how accurate is the drummer in the Guitar Hero/Rock Band games?
That might need a video of it's own because there's a lot of those games and I'm sure the animations became better as time went on.
That K-ON clip is a gag that they were air-playing along a track, not really playing.
I wanna see My Singing Monsters again. The other percussion monsters, especially Shellbeat and possibly Thumpies would be fun to analyze.
Mmmm good video
first comment! good job.
The one part you chose for K-On..... AND THEY'RE FAKING IT!!!!
I demand a recount!
This series is god tier content
I’m so glad you out f is for family in this episode
I love this eric guy who lays drumz
I could suggest you should look at some Scenes from Sonic Underground to see if the drums are animated?
Love your videos :)
Technically not a drum animation but how about analyzing the hambone dance in "Now That We're Men" from the first SpongeBob movie?
I am now a RUclips sensation. The fair show in part 2? American Dad - Jimmy crack corn
I haven't played My Singing Monsters in years. I'm rather surprised to find it on this list.
What song was that?
@@jtheman6369 it's an Android app game (not sure if on iOS) where you unlock monsters, and each one has a short musical phrase they repeat. You then get to organize them in a way to create your own songs. It's all generic stuff, which is why all the vocals are various sounds instead of actual singing.
@@Nareimooncatt oh ok, thanks for the replay!🙂
If My Singing Monsters is on the table, id love to see you check out Dwumrohl!
this
S A M E
or even Shellbeat
you have summoned all the MSM fans
You gotta look at Adam Neely's drum line challenge in his latest video
Disney's "Soul" has to be in the next video
loved that maracas part in American Dad xD
i love the K-On one cuz they were just doing random shit over a recording as a prank
Here's a good contender for the next episode: Ika Musume Season 1 Episode 7
It comes in at the end of the episode where Squid Girl is shown playing the drums. She makes use of her tentacles as well, so it shows her playing like 10 different parts at the same time. Obviously it's not meant to be realistic, but I thought it would be interesting to see your reaction to it.
in F is for Family there's also a layering error where the drumstick is in front of the singers arm for a few frames
CARS 3 The Bar Scene with Glory Days. That part looked interestingly accurate.
Drummer in Hitman looked stiff, because he's an assassin pretending to be a drummer to get closer to his target. It was on purpose.
Phineas and Ferb hit me in the nuts with nostalgia.
i'd pay money to see him do No Big Deal from Amphibia
Hitman is stiff bc even though they used motion-capture that doesn't mean they used every frame (bc they still have to convert it to animation). They probably edited every couple frames and the rest got erased or replaced by copy paste. That's why it's so robotic.
COD: Black Ops 2, where Avenged Sevenfold is featured playing Carry On
Kind of surprised you haven't done Animal from the Muppets yet. I mean, he's one of the most famous fictional drummers out there. And before anyone says "He only does cartoons and video games," I'd like to remind you, Muppet Babies exists, and is a cartoon.
Bruh that metal piece from K-On was POPPIN 😤😤😤
the lemon song parody is hilarious.
I always thought that reference to Lemon Song from F is for Family was hilarious
This video was great! If you do this again maybe you could try Shellbeat from MSM, I know you already did that game but it would be cool to see if they animated the drums correctly with that monster
Do Camp Lazlo, Sailor Moon, Shimmer and Shine, Hi Hi Puffy AmiYumi, Whatever Happened to Robot Jones and Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends for the next one
I’d be curious to see how accurate the Phil Collins concert from GTA Vice City Stories is in terms of drumming
well i gonna say they nailed it 😅
I love the WAPP treatment intro lol
You should do Tom and Jerry episode 155 Rock 'n' Rodent. where at night time, Jerry went and play drums in the bar and annoyed the heck out of Tom
In cars 3 during the bar scene there is a car playing a drum set… wanna give it a look?
My favorite series of yours! More please!
You should take a look at "God Knows" from the Haruhi anime.
I can imagine he’s hitting the rim with his left hand during the double-time thing at the end of Ain’t Got Rhythm
Hmm... I wonder if Jake and the Neverland Pirates animated the drums correctly? Could you do Jake and the Neverland Pirates please? Many thanks!
just found this playlist in my recommended and you gotta do bat metal
@Telegram 👉@EMCProductions
Hell yeah, we got some My Singing Monsters, glad to see one of my favorites getting some recognition.
What song was that?
@@jtheman6369 9 months late, but shugabush island.
We need more of these!
Gundam thunderbolt has a pretty nice jazz drumming scene.
You should do the end of CoD Black Ops II when they play Carry On
Can you react to Got Motion from Gothenburg, Sweden? They are a bunch of highschool kids (abt 16-18 years old), it includes a drumline, marimbas, vibraphones and a guitar. I want you to react to a video called "waves" because it's the version without mistakes. They won a regionals competition and came second in CGN championships with the song.
7:56 I had to take a LONG look at this to even comprehend what the set even is and...yeah I can't tell what some of these are
OH MY GOD MSM IS MY CHILDHOOD
Love the series don’t stop!
I was hoping hed play aint got rythem with rulers and a name tag
You should do the scenes in Diary of a Wimpy Kid any time Rodrick plays the drums
Doesn't take a drummer to recognize that it's not animated correctly in most cases. I've played piano for a long time and can easily tell when any instrument isn't animated correctly. Drums, flute, saxophone, etc. Squidward's clarinet is not even what a clarinet actually looks like, but they continue insisting that it's a clarinet all throughout the show.
You should do Blasphemian by Infant Annihilator. In it's entirety. With a WISLL.
I played My Singing Monsters, and pretty much every Drum Kit monster in that game are unusual compare to real Drum Kits. Either they are a living drum kit (T-Rox for example stomps its feet for a kickbeat and chomps for a snare), their drum kit is impossible to translate (Deedge and Furnoss), or they do have a Drum Kit, but it doesn't look like a traditional one (Shellbeat's drum kit doesn't have a kickbeat but it uses its shell as a kickbeat). Same with every instrumental monsters in general.
Siiiick!
You need to check out kids on the slope, the best drumming animation
for the next one of these you should review Cool Things from the homestar runner series
8:30 they were so focused on the drummer they clipped his arm through the lead singer's
I wonder how disappointed Bill Burr was in the animating of the drums on F is for Family. He is a big jazz drum guy so you know that had to break his heart a little.
Srill hoping to see you review Axel's drum solo from Alien by Your Favorite Martian.
Could you do: "Denn wenn et Trömmelche jeht | TiRiLi - Kinderlieder zum Mitsingen" from the kids channel TiRiLi Kinderlieder?
It has a German Locke and uses only the "Kleine Trommel"
Greetings from Germany
Can you make your next video with your voice in my right ear to compensate for this video where it is in my left? I need it to even out!
You should look at Kevin Temmer's animation called I've Had a Dream for Quite Some Time
Would still love to see the clip from Black Ops 2 with Woods and Avenged Sevenfold. It seems close, but not close enough for me.
2 more videos guys woooo!!!!
Or you do any Electric Mayhem song from the Muppet Show and see how good Animal is doing.
that was dope what the cartoon actually played HAHAHAHA
No Snot McDuckie?
disappointed
That was my favourite
TYSM FOR DOING K ON I LOVE THAT ANOME AMS
Suggestion: P-Bobby Brown from the Android Hell Blues, found on Harry101UK’s channel