REACTION | DOCTOR WHO | 4x6 | The Doctor's Daughter
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- SPOILER NOTICE: As of the time this episode is being released on RUclips, the most recent full reaction released on Patreon is the 2020 Festive Special; Revolution of the Daleks.
I am also reacting to Classic Who, and have reacted to all of Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures over on Patreon. The most recent full reactions for those are listed below.
- Classic Who: Episode 8x20; Colony in Space: Part 6
- Torchwood: Series 1-4
- The Sarah Jane Adventures: Series 1-5
NO SPOILERS (or any hints or details) past those episodes unless you see later episodes have been released.
*****
Doctor Who Playlist: • REACTION | DOCTOR WHO ...
*****
Support me on Patreon to get access to:
- FULL REACTIONS (You will need your own copy of the episode to watch alongside my video)
- BONUS/EXCLUSIVE REACTIONS
- EARLY RELEASES
- AD-FREE VERSIONS OF THE SHORTENED RUclips VIDEOS
- DISCORD SERVER
- MONTHLY ZOOM CALLS
- POLLS FOR FUTURE REACTIONS
Become a Patron Here: / britanybinges
*****
If you want to see what's coming up on Patreon or RUclips, use the link below and select the appropriate spreadsheet. The link also includes a list of the movies and I've pilots I've reacted to on Patreon.
airtable.com/s...
*****
I do not own the rights to the Doctor Who footage. It is being used under the Fair Use Act and has been shortened significantly, is taking up only 25% of the screen, and has been altered (cut, blacked out, blurred, and/or silenced) in order to honor the Fair Use Guidelines. All rights go to BBC Studios.
Credit: BBC Studios
Original Network: BBC One
Viewed on: HBO Max
Website: www.bbc.co.uk/...
#doctorwho #reaction #drwho #davidtennant #catherinetate
What are the odds that a Doctor Who would marry the daughter of another Doctor Who, whom also portrayed that Doctor Who's child, and she is also the child of the Doctor Who's favorite Doctor Who?
Yeah, it was odd watching this back while editing it knowing they ended up getting married. lol
And you do know she is the daughter of Peter Davison, who played the Doctor (number 5) in the classic series?@@BritanyBinges
Davidson was at a Comic-Con with McCoy, the emcee asked what the weirdest thing a fan ever game them, an audience member yelled out "A GRANDDAUGHTER!" ruclips.net/video/qkQop3yDGGM/видео.html
She's the most dangerous woman in all of time and space - she's the Doctor's Daughter twice over, while also being the Doctor's wife and the mother of the Doctor's children. That's a hair's width away from being her own mother and destroying the universe in a massive paradox...
Georgia Tennant also went to school with Lucy Baker, daughter of Colin Baker, the Sixth Doctor, so she thought it was a far more common thing to be the daughter of Doctor Who growing up.
There are audiobooks voiced by Georgia Tennant on Big Finish that follow Jenny's story.
Jenny - The Doctor's Daughter Series
Great to know, thank you! I'll add that to my BF list. :)
Georgia tenant said in an interview that when she read the script she told her father (Peter Davison aka the 5th doctor) that the first lines she says is "Hello Dad" so they knew it was the right role for her, and thats where she met her future husband
I appreciate you sharing this story, but please refrain from sharing any details about Classic Who as I am reacting to that as well. I knew who her father is, but not which number doctor he was and that's information I prefer not to know.
@@BritanyBingesok, good to know, i was avoiding details about besides him being the 5th doctor, there is a short that has 5 and 10 together before the titanic Christmas episode, i think i mentioned it previously, 10 calls 5 the doctor's doctor, and 5 was when i start watching doctor who, so he's my favorite of classic, and 10 is my favorite new who, so they both have a special place for me
I've seen people rare this episode lower and I don't understand why. I think it's great. Good use of both Martha and Donna, an interesting concept, and a wonderful new character. I was chuckling when you kept saying you wanted to "keep" her. I was thinking, "Yeah, apparently DT felt the same." lol.
I don't really understand why either. I really enjoyed several aspects of it.
I was kinda hoping for a spin off. It was almost like a back door pilot for Jenny.
That girl in real life is the actual daughter of the 5th Doctor, and having met here, she married David Tennent. So she's the Doctor's daughter and the Doctor's wife.
Every time someone mentions that the song “I am my own grandpa” plays somewhere.
I think when this originally aired there was a prevailing sigh of disappointment when everyone realised that it wasnt in any 'important' way a literal title.
I could see how Jenny flying off into unknown space time without really knowing anything about who she is, could result in her being used in the future to explain something the fans really didn't like about Chibnal's choices as show runner - those 'timeless' choices he made in particular.
She def gives me Caroline vibes didn't think of that. It's kinda heartbreaking that the doctor had to watch another child of his die. Fun observation his daughter was blonde :)
Her names Martha, she's not collateral damage for anyone. ❤❤❤❤❤ Donna
Well - until the Stolen Earth.
Her. It's Her.
@@tl1110 yeah , sorry typo 👍
would be cool in the future if she came back, but at this point i doubt it, its sad cause i could see a whole season with Jenny and the Docter, running and saving the day tho she has appeared in Big Finish, so the audio books from doctor who
Yeah, it would've been nice to have her come back. I think they could've done a lot more with her character.
This episode always depressed me in a way, especially after watching the rest of the series. There was so much potential in Jenny returning again during the course of the show.
I agree about the potential of the character. I would have loved to have her pop back up again and play a more significant role.
@@BritanyBinges I think I read somewhere, that they made some sort of spin-off media with her, but it never really took off. Also the woman who plays Jenny is now married to David Tennant.
@@petrusjnaude7279 And that might be the reason why Jenny never came back. Georgia was busy giving birth to four more children of the Doctor.
She was busy raising babies....
Honestly, I thought that the best time she could have come back was in Peter capaldi's last season. Peter capaldi always showed that his doctor was more of a father figure to his companions. Man, I wish that happened, but no, we had to have the diversity hire.
You're in for a treat herein, an amazing run of episodes coming up
The next two parter is a still a favorite of mine. I'm excited to get to it next week! :)
Jenny's story does actually get continued in Big Finish, but I guess it's not that surprising, there is a lot of it. I always loved this episode, so emotional!
After this episode I rushed out and bought the "Jenny: The Doctor's Daughter" CD box set, audio drama adventures {basically radio style plays} by Big Finish Productions. So, I only knew about those first 4 episodes from 2018. Then I just discovered that there is a "Series 2", from 2021 with 4 more adventures. She also appeared in one with her actual earlier generation dad, Peter Davison {Peter Malcolm Gordon Moffett} in "Doctor Who: Once and Future: The Artist at the End of Time" in 2023. She also appeared in a comic book series "The Lost Dimension" issues 1, 6, 7, and maybe 8, and "Prisoners of Time" issue 11 story "The Choice".
Yeah, I didn't know she had Big Finish stories until some others mentioned it here in the comments. I have a few 9th Doctor stories and one for Jamie (I was bummed after he left in Classic Who), and I'll be getting some Rose stories next so I can find out what happened on Pete's world, but I'm definitely adding Jenny's stories to the list. :)
The late actor who played Cobb was also Arthur from the 1980s Excaliber movie.
Oh, interesting. I've never seen it.
@@BritanyBinges Yeah. One of the few adaptations that starts at the actual beginning, with Arthur's terrible dad, Othar.
And this episode had two actors from 2008s "Merlin" in it: Georgia Tennant and Joe Dempsie (Cline). And given that Merlin himself, Colin Morgan, will soon be sitting in a train on Midnight and Michelle Ryan play a very important role in one of the specials, season 4 has to be the most Arthurian...
Would have LOVED a spin-off with Jenny, but just never panned out. Not sure why, it just never happened.
And by now, you know the story - Georgia Moffat is Doctor Number 4 Peter Davison’s daughter and there was chemistry between Georgia and David on the set. My favorite story is a fan got a picture of Davison, Moffat and Tennant and got it signed by Davison and later got to meet Tennant and get the picture signed. David saw the photo, saw the signature, just looked up, smiled and said “Been hanging out with the in laws, have we?”
Actually, I’ve heard since RTD and Tennant have been friends for a while, RTD was actually trying to cast actresses who were David’s type when he could, see if sparks flew. Rennete in The Girl in the Fireplace was the first time and Tennant and her did date for a time. The second attempt worked out.
OK, enough Who gossip - isn’t this fun? I actually REALLY love the moment where you think “God, Doctor might actually kill this guy.” when he has the gun on him. Tennant is REALLY good at giving the Doctor a bit of a dark edge. Love the progression on Donna’s character too, how she both compliments and challenges the Doctor.
Can’t wait for the next video!
Please, feel free to share all the gossip! (So long as it doesn't include any spoilers for NuWho or Classic Who, of course.) These stories were fun to hear about.
we all love jenny. esp David Tennant. - Married her.
I love the scenes at 10:50 and 16:56
They perfectly highlight one consistent way to make me tear up, just play This Is Gallifrey in the background.
I adore this episode so much!
I really enjoyed it as well. It's a highlight of series 4 for me.
For some reason, some people don't like this episode much, maybe because Series 4 is so good. Glad you liked it.
Yeah, I remember being surprised when I put the full version out over on Patreon how many people weren't fans of this episode.
Really, I am surprised I really like it myself, one of my go to episodes....
Same. Such a fantastic moment with Donna and The Doctor, so small yet he mentions family which is rare. Lots of great character moments and great characters.@@chriscowey7464
Hearing Georgia Tennant say "Hello daddy" to David Tennant feels so wrong.
I was really affected by Martha's Hath dying in the goop.
Same. I got Neverending Story flashbacks, it wasn't a good time lmao
“And knowing is Hath the battle.”
I'm sure people on Patreon have told you about her Big Finish stuff! Enjoy!!!
They have. :) Unfortunately, I've listened to a few 9th Doctor BF stories so far and I've got a Jamie one lined up next. But, I definitely want to check out hers, Rose's, River's, Missy's and Christina's stories as well. I've been toying around with the idea of doing some BF reactions on Patreon to keep Doctor Who content going after the upcoming season/series wraps up.
The "I never would" scene often gets flack from Classic Who fans/after some have made progress with Classic, due to the Doctor using guns/killing in classic. But (may be biased cause this would have been while i was early in my classic who watching) like the Eccleston (unless up against Daleks) & even more so Tennant Doctor & beyond is the man who never would as opposed to the Doctor in general being who never would. Like there was a (couple, including the expanded universe) Time War(s) between Classic & Revival Who, & regeneration being a fresh start, wanting to be a pacifist/not wanting to use guns in any way if he can help it, with said fresh start makes sense.
19:29 the Doctor is Toucan Sam 😂
She's seen up to Revolution of the Daleks, so I can ponder this: It's interesting how future episodes would unintentionally add to why Jenny couldn't regenerate. I always assumed from details given in other episodes that the vortex grants the power of regeneration to Time Lords, but then you have all "The Timeless Child" stuff which implies that it's something artificially given as opposed to it being at all natural.
Don't get me started on that Timeless Child nonsense I love Jodie as the Doctor but that Timeless Child storyline was absolute crap.
@@joshuajoshua2732 Honestly, as a concept, I didn't mind it, it defiantly could've been executed better. But I personally find the Hybrid to be a way more infuriating storyline.
I think Jenny will end up being the timeless child - the Doctor creates himself
Oooh Tenant's wife!
Jenny has a few audio book dramas
There are some great Big Finish stories about Jenny.
I'll have to check them out! Thanks! :)
run jenny!make daddy proud of you!! ❤❤
There was a spinoff but it never was picked up. Maybe one day she will make an appearance.
Still hoping for a return because the 4th season was RTD's last full season and maybe .... just maybe we get lucky.
I didn't know that! Was there an actual pilot shot for it that can be watched somewhere?
@@BritanyBinges no it was more of like an audio story of a few of her adventures it was never picked up for a show. 4 audio Episodes in all.
@@loganhemin4818 There are 8 Big Finish Doctor's Daughter audio stories.Two series. Plus Jenny appears in a couple others with different Doctors.
If you want more Jenny then you need to check out the big finish radio dramas where there are over 8 jenny featured episodes
Thanks! It's on my list! :) I've a got a story with Jamie lined up next because I want to know what happened to him when he left the Doctor, and then I'll probably do The Dimension Canon with Rose after that. But, I want to check out pretty much all of 9 (the ones narrated by Christopher), Rose, River, Missy, Jenny, and Christina's stories eventually.
I've been talking with some Patrons about possibly doing some reactions to them after this upcoming season/series wraps up since it will be a while before I'll have any more new Doctor Who episodes to react to. Just not quite sure what audio reactions would like or if they would be worth the amount of time and effort that would have to go into them. We'll see.
unfortunately she can't regenerate, the terraforming sphere brought her back, might be able to do bring her back from death a few times but who knows
Jenny's adventures continue in the comics!
I'm not really a comic book person, but I do know she's in some Big Finish stories and I'm definitely interesting in checking those out ... eventually. lol
Martha is a completely different character to what she was as a regular from Series 3 she was abit of a damsel in distress in this episode which I thought was a major disappointment after her bravery at the end of Series 3 but I also didn't really see the point of her being in this episode there was no real purpose to it I feel she was just there for the sake of fan service if she wasn't in this i still think the episode would not be a loss.
The saddest part for me out of this whole episode was the Hath drowning into the swamp that was so dark and sadly I blame Martha for it.
Jenny was originally meant to stay dead but Steven Moffat (future showrunner) insisted on keeping the character alive for a potential spin-off that never happened or planned something that didn't lead anywhere as a story and apparently Moffat forgotten all about it and 15 years later the character is still nowhere to be seen.
The actress that plays Jenny is also married to David Tennant in real life and is the daughter of a Classic Doctor (Peter Davison) so you have the father-in-law and the son-in-law playing the same character and Peter Davison was also David Tennant's favourite Doctor growing up.
For me, Martha is in this to show more of the Hath. Without her being taken by them, we wouldn't have any reason to see them again until the end of the episode. We also wouldn't have realized they can actually be gentle and caring (unlike most of the humans shown). So, I'm okay with her being in this.
Unfortunately, I do agree that the Hath's death was her fault. It tried to warn her about going outside. She dismissed it and then she basically shamed it into going with her.
I would've loved to see more of Jenny in the show, but some others have said they did do some Big Finish stories with her so, at least that's something. I'll have to check them out eventually.
Unless I am mistaken, I believe next up is my favorite two parter EVER!
We've got one more to go. The Unicorn and the Wasp is next and then we get into Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead.
I won't compare her with Caroline at all, since I grow to dislike Caroline over the years, while I don't hate anything about 10th Doctor
I think Jenny will end up being the timeless child - the Doctor creates himself
+10pts if you spot Gendry from Game of Thrones
I've only seen the first one or two episodes of Game of Thrones.
@@BritanyBinges Jealous. You have some excellent TV ahead of you.
I really disliked this episode when it first aired and have never re-visited it since. So I couldn’t remember half of it when I watched your reaction. I still think it looks low budget and the story feels contrived. Also: what a waste of a comeback for Martha.
Well, I appreciate you watching the reaction anyway even though you don't like this episode!
Pretty much Martha's fault for the Hath dying. It warned her not to go out and then had to rescue her from the swamp.
I definitely don't disagree. 😬