Sweeping rage after Kolkata rape-murder could be pushing us towards judicial lynching, not justice
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Since the 2012 Delhi rape-murder, politicians have been promising fast, effective action against perpetrators. But, lacking proper training and equipped with overstretched forensic resources, investigators often take shortcuts. That’s led to a disturbing rise in cases where there are doubts if it is the perpetrators who are in jail.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
What sets this Bengal rape-murder apart is, the police calling this as suicide, govt protecting the principal, and police shamelessly, silencing protestors. It is not just another rape case.
And I have never seen such naked vandalism of the evidence scene, in front of everyone. More like Laloo era jungle raaj.
Why blame Bihar, which has improved over the last two decades, albeit slowly and sporadically. The state with the worst law and order situation in the country now is, without any doubt, West Bengal. The paranoid schizophrenic who is the Chief Minister presides over the mayhem quite gleefully. Really sympathize with the poor citizens of West Bengal!
Stop bringing up Bihar in everything, dude. WB is moving to the bottom position pretty swiftly. We're still holding on to ego because of our past glory. Bangali hoyei bolchi. Be respectful to everybody else, and lets work on improving ourselves.
@@hkumar7340I trust you, when you say Bihar has improved. But past Bihar was jungle raj, and present Bengal is competing with that ! Edited comment.
Perfectly Said. Snipper Dogs Brought by Police After 3 Day Just Unimaginable 😮
@@rajx7120Bengal is Now Bihar
Policing in India has to change, we are still living with british raj way. We have to redo the system completely, not just in rape case but throughout.
What was the police system we were having before the British or are you saying we are immune to change - in police and other systems - just curious to know - I used to work in government hospital before I left India - i used to feel the same - we need to change
we should not keep blaming the british for our laziness, and more importantly our endemic corruption. our society is riddled with political power-crime nexus
I agree but the people in power (BJP,TMC,Congress etc) don't give a f*ck till people start protesting. Especially when their kin or rich people are culprit.
See the hathras 2020 case same operating system where BJP Services Limited rules. In the midnight🕛 Body burn🔥 (Main Evidence) BJPee Or TMChee both are same in respect of women safety. Only #BIG word from Modi ji... Every one #playing with #public #emotions. Govt sucking blood🩸 (Tax) for making 🌉bridge/Road because its very easy to take cut money and convert to party fund...We need #adequate #manpower and #sophisticated equipment for #CAG and #CBI. Request to public understand politics of Companies Those who win contract to #Run #government.
3 main weakness
1. Image 🖼of leader.
2. Public sentiment centralized for a single issue (Companies those are winning for run government they diverting public mind/Dividing rule)
3. Public have a option (We have to create it)
Understand that this is #weakness of #Govt so they #delay justice (Time kill theory)
Now #Kapil #Sibal fighting in favor of #West #Bengal #govt.
Total #Racket running by #powerful #political #party
We need more accountability from state governments, especially in healthcare, education, and law and order. Unlike the central government, where a significant portion of spending goes to defense, railways, and transport ministries and is overseen by the CAG, state governments often show low productivity and accountability. For instance, despite healthcare, education, and law and order being state subjects, their quality remains poor across the country, no matter which state you live in.
The title is very misleading. The Kolkata case is not simply a rape case. The murder part is more important. And the Mamata is trying to destroy the evidence. Please say this is a political murder. Gory, like other cases of rape and violence, but the motives and contexts are different.
Can’t agree more!
Police and judicial reforms are long overdue - unfortunately most politicians and judges want to talk of bandaids or distracting placebos
We may make stricter laws or a criminal Justice system that is more efficient, but it won't work in reducing crimes against women or violence against anyone, until we change the society as a whole.
When the administration is not doing anything, the public is _bound_ to take matters into its own hands. Hence the dire need for police reforms making the police service independent of the state government.
Indian law doesn’t exist for poor and middle class Hindu people.
Why is The Print working overtime on "Whataboutery" for Mamta Benerji?
This should be the case we all talk about, and WB govt.'s LACK of empathy on this case only!
Do we really need to change policing and justice for women ? We should be satisfied with better highways , highest bridge on the Chenab river , great textiles , great restaurants , terrible Bollywood movies etc etc . Justice for women is not a priority , nor better education or healthcare. As long as every politician gets elected , including Modi , that should satisfy the public. They give us crumbs and we hail them.Modi is great , Indira was India , Rahul and his cohorts are saviors of democracy. They all work for themselves and we the people have always been dumb.
True Sir. The CJI must see and consider these points. Thanks for SC's intervention. Though the HC Kolkata was very firm with his orders.
But for the intervention of SC. Lawyers team headed by Kapil browbeat the judge started browbeat the judge though he was firm on his judgment at one point of time Kapil gangs almost succeeded in doing so. But he gathered his wits back and did what he wanted.
SC further took it next level.
Police should form a separate wing to handle such heinous crime with technical background to avoid major errors in mishandling the evidence by constables and ASIs while presenting to the court. Tx.
If concrete step to improve this comedy judicial system are not Taken India is bound to collapse
The trouble is, that we have destroyed our institutions and taken pleasure in it.
What else do we expect ?
Media and politics are pushing us towards collapse
Thanks!
Dear Arko,
Thank you again for supporting us.
Some times I wonder is this a RUclips channel from my mother country? Great presentation in a subtle way with layered facts uncommon to see on RUclips now a days
Excellent analysis.
Another BS episode!
that's why judges need to be replaced or be allowed to pass orders using highly efficient LLMs such as Claude 3.5
Playing the Women Card " Modern Indian Police ( Men & Women 😮 ) Ignore Violance Against Women By Men "
Wow! We were so proud to hear that our country stands fifth in the world. Now I know that India is standing last in the world.
This video is a masterclass on how suave, english speaking, room ridden intellectuals have no idea of whats happening on ground. Completely detached from they live in their own land of esoteric ideas.
Hon SC should first change rotten law of this country.Why is police given authority to burn the body of victim, why can't case of criminal negligence filed if body disposed of without no objection from parents,forensics and prosecution ,why Post mortem is allowed to be done in same hospital ,why Post mortem.not done by third party forensics,why forensic team along with prosecutor is not there when police does their panchnama like in other countries
Another Mamta Stooge here.
India is shining from the a**
Rightly said
In Hinduism, rape is not considered a sin, even gods have indulged in this practice. Shiva who indulged in love with mohini, because he could not control himself. In hinduism women have always seen as objects that can be distributed and used as sex objects. For rape to stop, we must abondon hindu and accept humanity.
Mr. Praveen Swami , I was waiting for your explanation
Report is incomplete without showing destroying of evidence and if rape was a message to worse crimes that include the government police and officials at the hospital plus if the systems were in place like safe facilities in the first place in hospitals decades ago plus the lack of action in enforcing laws already there.
Agreed but what can the public do? Even you have made this because of the so called judicial lynching.
Jago mataye jago.🕉️🇮🇳🏵️
Wow Swamy 👏 what a brilliant cover fire to save Mamta di ! While the facts he brought out are interesting , it is a clear cover fire to save bengal police and Mamta in the current case where they are clearly seen tampering evidence and trying to protect the guilty at all costs . Now Pravin Swamy brings in old cases of wrong convictions to add doubt here too…
Please also report the rape threats given to women online for not "protesting enough" by some who claim to be outraged by this case.
Also please report on the woman who was dragged out from her home in Midnapur and stripped and paraded naked for 3 kms by BJP supporters because she refused to participate in a midnight protest and said she will.do so only in the morning.
Every state has its owns story
The Kolkata case is overhyped.
It's easy to dismiss the Kolkata case as overhyped when you're not directly affected, but imagine if the victim were your own sister, girlfriend, wife, nephew, cousin, or anyone else you care about. Would you still think it's overhyped, or would you demand justice and accountability? When it comes to the safety and dignity of our loved ones, politics should never take precedence over basic human decency and justice. Trivializing such a serious issue not only disrespects the victim but also sets a dangerous precedent where empathy is overshadowed by political biases
@@Boruto_Is_OP bro don't talk to this guy. He's an incel. They celebrate the brutalisation of women.
RATTU POPAT!
Mamta pro print
Lodha Trail 👍 All The Print Women 💕 Group will be ❤ ❤ ❤ For Police Ignoring Women vs Men Criminal Cases
😮
Thanks!
Dear Kiran,
Thank you for supporting ThePrint.