Thanku so so much Ashrish bhai for the appreciation 🥰.... Your Work on Languages and Geography has always been Inspiration for me 🙌🏻 I have always been a big fanboy of IIP and getting Appreciation from the artist who keeps inspiring me is a biggest proud moment for me as well Thanku so much for everything you do :)
Pure Hindi is oldest language like Sais the pevar Hindi is similar like Sanskrit जिसमें लेकिन नहीं किंतु परंतु का उपयोग किया जाता है शुद्ध हिंदी कितनी पुरानी है यह हमें यह पता चलता है कि हिंदू कैलेंडर हिंदी में शुद्ध हिंदी की बात कर रहा हूं और तुम जिस हिंदी की बात कर रही हो उसमें 10 भाषण मिला दी जाती हैं।
I’m from Karnataka my wife from Andhra Pradesh my mother is from Tamil Nadu , I am proud to say I can speak all these beautiful languages and I respect all languages and we need to protect all our region languages and not to loose out your roots.
As a Maharashtrian Marathi, I can assure that most of Maharashtrians can speak hindi fluently but at the same point we love our mother tounge Marathi more than that ❤🔥🚩🙏
Hamari matrabhasha Sanskrit aur Tamil hain, baaki sab dialects hain. Aryan Sanskrit aur Dravidian Tamil hi Bharat ki matrabhasha hain aur baaki sab in bhashaon ki betiyan hain. Marathi se pyaar karo magar Sanskrit ko bhi yaad rakho.
@@ashesofhopesinabonfireofdr6341 if you're born speaking a different language then that's your mother tongue not something which you can not speak. It's a common misconception to call something your mother tongue which you can't even speak.
Same thing happening with bhojpuri 90% of new generation don't even speak bhojpuri wait for few more years most of the regional languages will be gone 😞
This is because of your attitude that you think people who speak local are illiterate. You are proud to speak English than any other language. You cannot say that Hindi destroyed everything. Hindi is very close to northern and mid India languages.
South indians are the one who are resisting the attack of foreign Aryan language and culture attack..rest of indians have already surrendered to this Aryan attack.
@@fruitful_thought wrong. South indian people should save their regional language and shouldn't submit to it. North indians are weak and submit to hindI. Hindi is forced on people everyone from rajasthan to odisa should reject it. Hindi/urdu is delhi, U.P, M.P langauge.
National religion ?? If state can have state language then why can not state religion ?? I am currently in wb but that does not mean that i have any less right as a hindi(bhojpuri) speaker and so india should also have state religion
सारे लोग अपने अपने भाषा में बात करें कोई अपने लोगों में परंतु यदि एक राज्य का व्यक्ति किसी दूसरे राज्य का व्यक्ति से बात करनी है, तो हिन्दी में बात करना श्रेयस्कर होगा I
@@ranjittyagi9354 yes. all this North Indians coming to Kolkata refusing to speak Bengali is an insult to Bengal's culture.... either speak Bengali or get out of Bengal
@@ranjittyagi9354s,....an egoistic war started by hindi-speakers, between Hindi entitled brats and natives standing up for themselves,...we will never come to Hindi speaking state and say speak my language,..so why should Hindi speakers have such entitlements?
I'm a Bengali and everyone loves their mother tounge. It's not just a language, it binds the culture as well. For me, any one language is fine to connect with people outside my community be it Bengali, Hindi, Gujrati, Tamil, English. 😊
In Himachal Pradesh there are 20 + dialects spoken but . Nowadays some parents are forcing their kids to speak Hindi , i personally belong from South Himachal and speak kangri which is a Punjabi dialect
Makes no sense. It's not hard to learn multiple languages at once. I grew up with English Punjabi and Hindi and am able to speak all of them just fine even though I live in an English dominated society
You shouldn't force your kids to speak in Hindi. English and mothertongue. Hindi should be banned here in Himachal and these dhoti U.P people need to speak in our pahadi language.
@@mayan5600 no just no. I don't live in India and I've never been to India but learning just regional language English and Hindi are necessary. V the more languages you know the more people you can talk to. If I didn't know Hindi I would be so much restricted in the people I can talk to or the media I can consume
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
I have been to southern state and never met someone who preferred english over hindi, most people speak hindi Or atleast understand it except in tamil nadu , english is limited to major cities except in Kerala. "Stop hindi imposition " is only an internet phenomenon.
Did u even watched the video? Hindi is a language which can be used for connectivity and i think so we should not use english for connectivity cause hindi is a indian langua
This is the fault of Indian finding father. Never choose the majority language/biggest language as lingua franca because it will cause jealousy and the sense of favoritism towards one language. Indonesia and Pakistan are the only successful countries to unite all the ethnics with one language because they chose small/minor language as lingua franca. Indonesia chose Malay instead of Javanese, Pakistan chose Urdu instead of Pashto
@@SudiptoSarkar-mh5vy you guys missed what was said in the video. Hindi wasnt made to impose on others. It was made just like any other language was made but as time went on it became the most spoken language. and thats why the government wanted to promote it over English because they wanted something indian to unite the people. But how they did it is definitely wrong, they imposed it instead of promoting it, even regional languages where im from arent spoken much ( pahadi languages ) and our takri script is even considered dead. But that doesnt mean we should hate on a language thats from our land. There is a difference between standing your ground so your culture doesnt die out and just hating on a language
That's why there is a reason why the 🇮🇳 Indian Govt. has declared Telugu, Tamil, Kannada & Malayalam (along with Odia and Sanskrit) as 'Classical Languages of India' over Hindi/ Urdu! 🇮🇳 తెలుగు 🇮🇳 தமிழ் 🇮🇳 ಕನ್ನಡ 🇮🇳 മലയാളം 🇮🇳 ଓଡିଆ 🇮🇳 संस्कृतम्
@@aravind270 Lol what Tamil is oldest what the hell only Tamil brainwashed niggas say that not even all other south India or regional states 😂😂😂😂 And with due respect at least rice bag converted haleluyaah products should not cry about heritage culture identity it seems like blatant hypocrisy
I'm a guy with Hindi as my Mother tongue but I respect all the languages there is no need to impose Hindi on other states. Since they have their own languages which have been preserved for more than a millennium,but hating on people just because they speak Hindi is not okay ! Jai Hind 💪
It is not hating hindi speakers, it is the fighting against, mistaken as hate, the people who wants to impose hindi on the rest of non-hindi citizens. Imposition is through making hindi compulsary in schools, changing railway station boards to hindi only etc,., Hindi speakers has a "sense" of entitlement because of the central government expecting people to know Hindi. This is what the regional governments and people are opposing. No imposition (.)
@@striker44 No they don't. Everyone where I live speaks Hindi and also other regional languages. Nobody has any "sense" of entitlement just because they speak Hindi. I am from Uttarakhand btw.
@@person1420yeah? You'd know the situation if you'd come to our state,.....what striker44 said 100% true,... They come to our states with a sense of entitlement that the natives themselves have to learn an alien language(Hindi).
you all stole from tamil. SANSKRIT plagiarized tamil and claim its 5000 years older. WTF. Why indians believe hindu myth? That too in 21st century? INDIA is in DARK country when it come spiritual stuff.
@@Amoghavarsha. actually kerala has many type of people. Different people have different identity. Most Christians in kerala are not recently converted like rest of India. The first converts were Brahmins who mixed with Syrian migrants around 100-300 AD. After that many Christians from Arabian peninsula migrated and settled in kerala before the begining of Islam. All these Christians consider them different from the Christians who converted during colonial period. The muslims of kerala are Arab traders who mixed with local population (Aryans and Dravidian) and settled in kerala. So they also have a different identity. Among the hindu population 30 percentage are Nairs. They are Aryans and they consider sanskrit and Malayalam as their language. The Brahmins and Nairs mixed sanskrit with local dravidian and Malayalam was formed. Ezhava community is about 50 percentage of Hindu population. We are not sure whether they are dravidian or Aryans but sanskrit is important for them as well. 15 percentage of Hindu population are Dalits and they are dravidians. Upper caste Christians and upper caste Hindus are mostly sanskrit supporters. Even bible is in highly sanskirtised malayalam
Nothing is wrong with Hindi, nor is with any other languages and many other dialects, including my Garhwali. Just remember one thing, if a language dies so does the history, culture and traditions. Thank you for this very interesting episode! Definitely subscribed for now.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
Without english, there would have been no India as it exists now. It is the British who occupied various princely territories and formed India. We inherited that in the early forties but had to part with some land for Muslims, hindu- muslim conflicts. Imposing of majority ethnic, religious, lingual force on non hindi speaking population will sure repeat 1947. Nobody wants that but the hindi zealots may make it happen. Remember the cause of creation of Bangla Desh and break up of USSR. Let wisdom rule over language fanaticism.
As a proud Marathi i don't get it why people have problem with us? They are try to impose their toxic hindutva and nationalism on us And it's also a myth that Marathis are fluent in hindi and we are comfortable with hindi imposition, stop putting us in North India group Many people are flexing that hindi people rule india but just remember that marathas occupied half of India but never imposed marathi on anyone
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
@@gamingstrong1686Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
ನಾನು ನೋಡಿದಂತ ಅದ್ಭುತವಾದ ಜ್ಞಾನ ತುಂಬಿದ ದೃಶ್ಯಾವಿದು. ನನ್ನೊಬ್ಬ ದ್ರಾವಿಡ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗನಾಗಿರುವೆ ಈ ಮಾಹಿತಿ ನೀಡಿದ ನಿಮಗೆ ಅಸಂಖ್ಯಾತ ನಮನಗಳು 🙏. 100% true words about Indian languages. I' m a Dravidian kannadiga Thank u For informative video.🙏. We Love All Languages. Please Respect Local language.👍❤
Only Movies (bollywood/khanwood ) and political leaders has divided North and South We don't want you to speak only Hindi, we all have been living together for thousands of years. When our ancestors had no problems then why would we? Only movies / political leaders For Impressions and views Be unite 💪
I'm from Tamilnadu. India is a country in diversity. We should cherish every language available here. We should give priority to our mother tongue first. If you can't read, write and excel in your mother tongue but you know third language means, It is really shame. Mother tongue is like mother, Giving food to others letting your mother to starve is a sin.
You are right brother , even I am not in favour of forcing Hindi on people who have different mother tongue but we need a connecting language that is not foriegn (like I am using English now 😅) , would you agree if that connecting language is Sanskrit ?
@@ayushbhardwaj7650 why we should? Why should we learn for immigrants? And for your information we people speak Tamil which is an independent language which doesn't come from Sanskrit so don't include us in other states. We learn English because it's a global language and it will be useful for work. Else we don't learn that too
There is nothing wrong with Hindi. I am born and brought up in Mumbai. I speak bhojpuri with my family members and relatives. I speak Hindi with my friends and Marathi with every government official or local bhajiwala, autowala etc. People are blaming Hindi when they should blame their parents for not inspiring them to speak in their own mother tongue. Hindi is very important to binding multilingual Indian society. If I have to work in 5 different states I can not learn 5 different languages. There has to be a common working indian language for whole nation.
I'm proud Indian Bengali & we won't let anyone force or impose Hindi or Urdu or any freaking language on us. Yeah we can treat Hindi as connecting language upto a certain level. I belong from a community in which peoples martyred their lives to stop foreign language (Urdu) imposition 😌❤️ Jai Bengal Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Urdu is not foreign language...it is our own language with just a touch of persian and arabivc...most of urdu words are derived from sanskrit...urdu was developed in delhi and up so how it can be foreign language??
@@r1a172 Urdu is a foreign language. urdu was developed in the brothels of Delhi, it's disgusting language, it symbolizes oppression and the worst of the periods in Indian history. Jai Hind Jai Bengal
Keep it up bro, Bengali as a language is more beautiful than Hindi, Bengali script may be a derivative of devanagiri but it definitely looks more beautiful and artistic with its sharp edges, also, our national anthem is in Bengali not in Hindi, don't let anyone force you to speak any language against your wishes, take it from a proud Tamilian who does not like to be forced to learn any language and yet is a polyglot blessed of the Lord Jesus Christ for His glory. ;)
Never let your mother tongue die.....just because maximum of the population speaks one language..... I am from land of Dawnlit mountain (Arunachal Pradesh) mother tongue - Nyishi Official language - English.. Around 90% of population can speak Hindi....as because of hindi we are losing our mother tongue 😢
Arunachal has 100+ subtribes and 100+ languages(dialects). So it is necessary to take one language as official. It would have been better if English was compulsory and not hindi as hindi too is a foreign language for us.
Fantastic video! 1) look at movies of Telugu, Tamil, Kannada and Malayalam cinema: songs feature native Dravidian words as well as 🚩Sanskrit ones like प्रेम, प्राण, हृदय, समय, भोजनम, धन्यवदाम 2) now, look at the 'Hindi' industry of Bollywood: songs feature 🇵🇰Urdu words like Ishq, Aashiqui, Mohabbat, Mehboob, Khuda, Rab, Waqt, Wajood, Izzat, Ijazat, Hifazat, Rishta, Zindagi... But still, BJP/ RSS want to make हिन्दी as National Language over 1000s year old తెలుగు, தமிழ், ಕನ್ನಡ, മലയാളം languages. 🤔
It's not about BJP. It is central government's policy overall. Never forget that it was congress which tried to make Hindi the only official language of India. They inserted a clause in the constitution which makes it the central goverment's liability to promote Hindi.
Every government is mandated to make Hindi as national language. Even if a PM from south is elected as in case of Devegowda or Narsimha Rao or anyone in future, he will promote Hindi. It has nothing to do with BJP, RSS. A central government will need a medium to connect to all as it can't publish every notification in 1600+ language. Even if anti-hindi DMK occupies center it will start promoting Hindi as it will need to communicate with northern/NE/Bengali/Gujarati people. Even they will have to bring a common language. You can't end the concept of link language. I do understood mother tounge is important and it's duty of its native speakers to protect it and pass on to next generation. But when you are living in a such a big country a link language will be needed. It might be anyone English, Hindi or anyone else. BTW, those chauvinist who thinks that only Hindi will destroy their mother tounge and not English should learn about English History and how many languages it has killed to become so big. The rise and fall of language is a natural phenomenon. It is bound to happen and nothing can stop it. We can only pass our mother tounge to next generation and hope that it goes on till it becomes more popular. No need to hate other languages. PS : I am not a native Hindi /English speaker but could connect to you all only because we all were watching a Hindi language video and commenting in English language while our mother tounge is different.
As a Tamilian, you know where we stand with our mother tongue and hindi. Just Tamil and English is good for local and international use. If one needs another language, they will learn due to necessity. No hindi imposition please.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
@@andyistphdhpc2726 That's Because Hindi has been imposed on You and Now You guys Speaks Hindi More Than Bhojpuri... So Definitely You will Understand Hindi More.... But if You See the Linguistics, Grammar, Pronounciation and all Bhojpuri Is More similar to Bengali and Odia than Hindi.... Bcz Bhojpuri is Originated from Magadhi Prakrit and Not from Sauraseni Prakrit Like Hindi....
@@andyistphdhpc2726 Dude, Bhojpuri, Maithili, Magahi, Bengali, Odia, Assamese All These Languages Originated from Magadhi Prakrit... They have More Similarities with Each other Than a Different Origine language Hindi Which is Originated from Sauraseni Prakrit.... You Might Not Know the Pure Version of Your own Language Bhojpuri bcz From Decades Bhojpuri is Getting Influence of Hindi.... Even i can Hear So much Similarities between Bhojpuri and Bengali just by Listening it....!
@@theunknown8528 dumbo!! Bhojpuri is a dialect and not a language...it does not hv any grammar, every Bhojpuri province speaks its own version! For example: Jaat baanti- Gorakhpur Jaa taani-Deoria Jaat haiin-Maharaganj Jaat baani- Gopalganj All of the above means "I am going" but said differently in adjacent districts.
Hindhi occupied the native language of the region and suppressed the growth of regional language, like Haryana's regional language hariyanvi replaced by Hindi, gujrati replaced by hindhi, Maithili, chandhili, replaced by hindhi in the state of Bihar, soon Marathi will be suppressed by hindhi in the name of national education policy...
A well-researched and comprehensive video that touched upon some of the very questions I have grappled with when thinking of the future of languages. As a Tuluva Mumbaikar, I am aware of the many layers of complexity involved in the whole language/ dialect debate and how language is as much (if not more) about cultural identity than mere communication.
You may understand, as you are from Mumbai. I'm a Khadi boli speaker from Delhi NCR (UP side). Delhites cast us as rural and inferior when we speak khadi. It's devastating for my language.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
Brother, make this video in English too, so that people in the southern regions of india could understand that not everyone in northern regions of India wants to impose any language on them.
I'm kannada and Marathi speaker from solapur Maharashtra . We speak nearly 70% kannada and nearly 30% Marathi in home . Both are like mother tounge for us . But we add Marathi as a mother tounge . Millions of peoples who's mother tounge is Kannada in solapur district but 95% peoples notes Marathi as a mother tounge in census . That's why government report shows that kannada speaker are very few in solapur district . But , 95% kannada speaker from solapur district can't read and write kannada . And our kannada is some different . when we speak kannada we use 30-35% Marathi words . But , we love to speak both Language . And we proudly say we are Maharashtraian we are indian . When we go in South Karnataka we speak Hindi . Because our Kannada is different From them and they laugh on us when they heard our kannada . We speak Marathi and Hindi in all over Maharashtra .
I have friends in solapur. Bangalore kannada and solapur kannada are kannada Only. No need to use hindi in south karnataka. North Karnataka and south karnataka kannada are same only. Only slang is different
@@Sachin-ln3lo but peoples laugh when we speak . North kannada and South kannada are some different . And our kannada is some different north kannada . Only youths who laugh on us . That's why we use Hindi . And we can't properly speaks Kannada Because we use nearly 30% Marathi word's . And if we try to speak pure kannada then we nearly speak 90% . But our 50% relatives who living in Karnataka they can easily speaks south kannada .
@@Ashishचव्हाण haa bhawa . Ignore karte Hai ham . But fir bhi jo youth hote Hai vo dekh dekhake haste Hai Apni Langauge par . So ham Marathi me baate karte Hai ghar Walon ke saath . Baher Kahi shop pe hotel pe gaye toh unn logon ke Saath Hindi me baat kartey Hain .
There is no country like India where so many languages, so many scripts, so many dialects, so many religions, sects castes, dress, look, food, festivals, rituals, weather, history, geograpy exist. In Europe, for every language, there is a separate nation.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
@@Abhishekkumar-sc6ji maithili is completely different from bhojpuri Also the bhojpuri i know is gorakhpuri bhojpuri which is quite different from bihari bhojpuri
I am a Bengali , I remember in collage hostel when I watched English movies on the common TV , Hindi students who were Bihar's (they were a gang actually) always used to take the remote and change the channel to Hindi channel. They were mostly Bihars living in West Bengal and it was clear they wanted to impose Hindi in the hostel. They never respected the local Bengalis,never spoke in Bengali although they understood it . Watching your video gave me some perspective and I can relate with imposing Hindi .
Lol what a nonsensical comment. Just because someone wants to watch a show or anything in Hindi, you will say they are imposing their language upon you!?!? Hahahahaha!!!!! They can also use the same logic against you that you were imposing English upon them. Learn to use some brain, weasel.
@@CactusClay99 don't worry we have Garga Chatterjee. It's just that more Bengalis are required to support Bangla Pokhho. Spread awareness among your friends about Hindi Imposition
There should be no imposition. Let's promote as many languages as possible through entertainment industry. (eg- many anime fans in India learns Japanese just to enjoy their favorite anime, many learns english for hollywood and korean for korean drama)
वो बंदे के उपर होना चाहिए के वो क्या पढ़े। Do you know bihari language is almost dead in city। बिहार में हमें अपनी मात्रीभाषा nhi padhai जाती है example ke लिये मैथिली जो कि मैथिली स्पिकिंग district me compalsary honi चाहिए हम पढ़ाया तक nhi jata hai. Kya ye nhi hai Hindi imposition.
For all of u I want to point out one more thing. Sub language, even after being a Bengali I can't understand local Bengali sub languages. Sub language are destined to die (atleast that happened throughout history ). Maybe these sub languages of Bengali were once a full fledged language,but today they r under one umbrella and eventually would be replaced by Kolkatan Bengali. Anyways I feel like it's unavoidable.
The reason many people in the south are ready to accept English as the bridge language when compared to Hindi are 2 reasons 1. It connects not only India but also the whole world and you increase your employability greatly. 2. It is not a native language of any major Indian communities, Maybe for some anglo indians it's their mother tounge, but it's not major, so all language speakers in India would need to learn a new language and native one won't have a default advantage when it comes to things like entrance exams. I don't mind if Hindi is used as a bridge language, but I feel the govt should always promote local languages.
North has more dialects than south mate 😂. South being less invaded had led to the survival of their literary works. A major chunk in north is burned under the regular invasion. Unlike south dialect changes every few 50 km in north.
I think Hindi will eventually break India. South Indians feel extremely proud about their native language which are much older than Hindi and any attempt to force Hindi to become the dominant language will lead to another partition. I'm sure the USA, UK and China wants this to happen. Every state signed up to be part of India, not Hindia.
China also has 6 southern dialects, but mandarin is universal in China, but if India wants a national language which has international influence, or even become 7th UN official language, India needs to increase the importance of Hindi inside India, Dravidians can ve proud of their local language, but to ensure the unity of Indian nation, they need to learn hard Hindi,
@@EmilechenWhy do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
I am from bihar...and my mother tongue is bhojpuri after bhojpuri we mostly speak hindi..we don't have any problem with hindi .we love hindi .and bhojpuri and we have our cultural songs and traditional songs in bhojpuri...even we have a huge number of bhojpuri speaking people so i think the government should add our bhojpuri language in the coutitution of india as a recognised languages like other 22 language of indian constitution..
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Bhojpuri is not most speaking language in bihar. It is only spoken in western bihar and eastern up. In central bihar you will see many different languages like 'magahi' in patna and patliputra, 'bajika' in muzaffarpur and vaishali, 'Maithili' in eastern bihar (like darbhanga) and angika in south east bihar (like bhagalpur).
@@aryan22100 Are Bihari languages similar to Bengali? I've heard that Bihari is sister language of Bengalis. Now i know so called Bihari doesn't exist because there are so many dialects.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Who said that?? standard hindi might not be but the older form of hindi is which is also known as Khadiboli. It's a native Language of hindi people. Still spoken in rural areas of Western UP and Delhi region. Also, khadiboli is the mother of Standard Hindi, both Hindi and Urdu were born in Meerut present day West UP and both the languages have derived from Khadiboli only. So it's a mother tongue of only the natives of West UP, Delhi region mainly but also covers very few parts of Haryana and plains of Uttarakhand
I’m Tamil speaker from Tamil Nadu, i respect all languages. I speak only Tamil it is enough and comfortable for me today. Also im ready to learn other languages in future only if it is needed.
@@aproudjagannathbhaktkaling6054 Tamil and Malayalam very similar, As a Tamil guy I can naturally understand kanada to certain level and also watching to many telegu and Hindi film i can understand both. But Tamil is the only language I'm fluent, read and write.
@@nithishkandasamy9073 Ya obviously no need to be such kind of fluent in other language than the mother tongue if no such emergency even I'm an Odia & naturally I can understand Bengali & Assamese to certain level but I can understand Hindi Sanskrit Gujurati & Marathi in small amount even I have started learning little bit Kannada & will get other southern languages too as it's my hobby to be more acquainted to all the Indic wings
Very informative video. Loved the way you traced the history of all Indian languages which clearly explained the reasons for the current situation of various Indian languages. Languages are an integral part of any culture. I hope all Indian cultures preserve their native language and do not blindly adopt Hindi or English. All the various languages are jewels of India's crown and should be preserved at any cost.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
As a Bengali I am proud. No need to Hindi agression to us. Only 40% Indian mother tongue hindi 60% non hindi. We Bengalis are freedom fighters so donot give teach us freedom fighting Netaji Subhash, vivekananda, Rabindra nath thakur, Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar Shyama Prasad Mukherjee maximum freedom fighters was Bengali. Jai Bangla jai Bharat 🙏🇮🇳
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Rajasthan, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Uttrakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh not only lost their language but also the culture. As an outsider, I see them as a Hindi speaker and the same culture throughout.
I am from odisha but i know 5 languages Fast language Odia Hindi Bengali Kannada English But my target all languages speaking ❤❤❤ i love my india 🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩🥰
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
A tamil with very little hindi knowledge here. You have summarised the issue very well with few mistakes. You should publish in English too, to reach wider audience. Very good content. Kudos 👍
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
यहाँ पर लगभग सारे लोग अपना लोकल भाषा से प्यार करते है ऐसा बोल रहे है । लेकिन ये बोलने के लिए जो भाषा का उपयोग कर रहे है वो है अंग्रेजी माध्यम 😂😂😂। हम भोजपुरी भाषी है और भोजपुरी मे बात करना अच्छा लगता है । लेकिन हम इतने संख्या मे होते हुवे भी कभी किसी भाषा का विरोध नही किये । एक भारतीय होने के नाते हिन्दी को अपनाये सबको एक साथ जोड़ने केलिए। सोच-विचार करी कि आज हिन्दी का प्रसार मे सबसे अधिक महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका कि भाषा ने निभाया है। कृप्या कर अपने देश की भाषा का उपयोग करे ना कि अंग्रेजी।🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sanskrit should be promoted more. South Indian protected their language for so many years. Kudos to them. Edit: People who are replying how north kings protected south and south remained untouched by islamic invaders, should go read proper history. Khilji did invaded south long before mughals. He took kohinoor after invasion in south. After khilji tughlaq had control of south but later vijaynagara empire was formed, which gave resistance to northern muslim empire for next 100 years. It was during that time sanskrit, kannada, telugu, tamil flourished. Kumar vyasa translated maharabharat to kannada during this time. So stop saying south never had to fight against islamic invaders. First go read proper history. In fact until formation of Maratha empire. Many maratha and rajputs worked for mughals and adil shah. Maharana pratap fought against Man singh who fought for mughals. Chhatrapati shivaji maharaj's father and half brother venkoji worked under adil shah. They defeated nayak of south. Thankfully Venkoji promoted sanskrit and south languages while ruling thanjavur.
@@mayurpatil7784 South too had adil shah, nizam, qutub shah. In fact Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj's father who was working for adil shah had control over bangalore and his another son ekoji had control of thanjavur. Later tipu sultan controlled mysore. In north now they are not under invaders. They can bring back their culture. Ram mandir is now building, hope sanskrit too gets enough recognition. In fact maratha also had sanskrit and Marathi as official language.
@@mein3324 but south india was under control of invaders for only 500 years but north India is whole uncontrolled of invaders for many times in history if we will add them up it will become about 1000 years
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
बहुत ही ज्ञानवर्धक वीडियो बनाया है। मैं बुंदेलखंड से हूं। यहां बुंदेली बस कुछ जगह ही बोली जाती है, हिंदी ने बुंदेली के बहुत हद तक प्रभावित किया है। वैसे अगर निरपेक्ष रूप से कहा जाए तो बुंदेली बोली से लोग स्वयं से खड़ी बोली की ओर अग्रसर हुए है क्योंकि भाषा में इतनी अशुद्धि , गंवारपन है कि अगर कोई ठेठ बुंदेली बोलता दिख जाता है तो बोलने वाला खुद शर्मा जाता है। पानी को पानू कहना और फिर उस अशुद्धि को हक जाता कर सत्य सिद्ध करना कहां तक बुद्धिमानी है।
I appreciate the tremendous effort you have put into creating the video, particularly in raising awareness about the state of Pahari languages in Himachal and Uttarakhand for the general public to comprehend. Thank you.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ *There are 22 official administrative languages in India* & the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"Foreign income"* & So we are using English in trade business and workplace. 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World. "English is the language of international communication" 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
The biggest problem with Hindi is that it thinks that bhojpuri , awadhi, rajasthani is its enemy and their recognition will harm their no. But the opposite of these languages is its strength , they are roots of Hindi and Hindi is cutting its roots on its own . Hindi was never introduced as a connecting language but it was forced into the name of Nationalism, as a mother tongue.
Really, hindi is cutting its roots, i don't think so . hindi was promoted only as a connecting language and many of our freedom fighters knew its potential in uniting india hindi was doing better but then some so called intellectuals with their hyper intelligence and political ambitions began calling promotion as imposition under the ego of their limited identity ( which led centuries of slavery ) .
@@Attitudezero884you are gonna ! Broh just wait ! Becuz we need a medium ! Of communication ! Becuz if go to Tamil Nadu and speak kannada no one will understand but if you come to gujrat and speak Hindi , everyone will understand and when you come to my northeast ! And you speak Hindi everyone will understand ! Even in Assam some people who doesn't know Assamese they communicate in hindi ! And I'm not saying you start reading everything in hindi ! But if you want an unity ! You have to know Hindi ! Becuz no language is at the state of comparison with Hindi ! So hindi is the main sole
I'm an Proud Odia, I'm also using Hindi for connecting with other State's Peoples but I strongly oppose Govt. Lable promotion for Hindi, English, Urdu like New born or Outer languages. We should promote Classic Language like Sanskrit, Odia and Tamil for Communicate with Our People 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
*Just shut up....Hindi is predominantly spoken language that's why it's duty of govt according to constitution....unlike your Odia which is spoken by few only*
We can have classical languages but the question is which one to make, for ex. If we make Tamil as common then other language people will ask to make their language as a common language, but Hindi is something they cooked for communication during independence movement period so i personally feel they should make Hindi more Indian by adding vocabs from Dravidian languages and other groups so every one will feel Hindi is common and union shld also ensure to protect regional languages....This my personal opinion from TN..
@@vetrivelv9391 Sanskrit is the only option. So forget Hindi as national or connecting language. Both so called Dravidian and so called aryan languages share the huge nos of Sanskrit words directly or indirectly. So do not force to accept Urdu / Hindi . This is extremely wrong steps by Indian government to promote hindi with huge resources . I am from odisha and my language is much older as well as huge vocabulary than Hindi . So it is not possible to accept Hindi in large contexts. So Sanskrit is the only option . As soon as accept by Hindi speakers is better for nation . ଜୟ ଜଗନ୍ନାଥ ।
@@meenaji4628 Bhasha aur boli me farq nhi pta kya bhai tumhe.??Rajasthani ki hi boliya h dhundhari ,marwari ,haudoti ,mewadi aadi .aur inke lagbhag 90% se jyada word same hi h
Aap ikdum glat ho, Apani bhasa bhulno matlab apane culture ko bhulno hot he. Tum apni aur apne purwajn ki pehchan ko bhulno he. Bhut so bundeli sahit bhi to he. Aaj kal budelkhand ke so called padhe likhe apni bhasa ko hi nhi janat he.
As a Assamese speaker i feel proud to speak assamese and i think everyone should love their mother tongue along with that we have to learn English for a better future or as a connecting language 😊
@@kanyakumari610 We are from North East, here Hindi and Sanskrit will not be there, only local languages like Assamese, Kabi, Nagmese, Mizo, meitei, dimasa, kuki, galo, kokborok Bodo and other local languages will be there........ And English our office language...but I hat hindi, Sanskrit, bengli and other meinland indian languages 🤢
@@violina1734 We Shouldn't Hate Languages,but to protect ours!! But Assamese is an Language Which Emerged from Sanskrit Itself !! And all the Languages of North ,Central , West India have Sanskrit Ancestors And In South 60 to 70% words have Sanskrit Roots and In Telugu and Malayalam it's 75 to 70% Even Tamil too But Tamilians Just Because of Politics hate Sanskrit but While Worshipping , Sanskrit Hymns are Only Used !! Tamil is Used for Devotional songs or Such like That !! That's why I said !! It may bound us !! As an Indian We need a Single Language To Unify!! It's English or Sanskrit or Hindi We have To Choose One ,I won't go With Hindi as it has no any History 😂 If I Go With English there's a problem that it's a Foreign language and Most of The Nation Today Preserve there Indegenous Language to Unify,just like Japan Japanese ,China Chinese,Korea Korean ,similarly India Too need it English is Good but a Language without Culture and A slavery History can't be Our Language !! Even I Am Typing in English although I don't want English
Kangri dialect is similar to punjabi still it is recognised as hindi dialect but pahari has its own writing system called tankri derived from shardah script of jammu kashmir
@@deependerkadian5524 I told it is similar I didn't told that it is dialect of Punjabi and Pahari should be different language and all sign board and shop boards of himachal should be in tankri script not in hindi
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
I'M BIHARI MY MOTHER LANGUAGE IS " BHOJPURI AND MAGDHI " I KNOW MEITHLI LANGUAGE ALSO 😌♥️ PROUD TO BE A BIHARI ( BHOJPURI 🤝 MAGDHI 🤝 MEITHLI ) = OUR BIHAR 🥺♥️🤝 JAI BIHARI ♥️🤝
We Bhojpuriyas are against Hindi imposition. Bhojpuri is an independent language from the Eastern Indo Aryan language group. But it is forcefully included under Hindi in the census which is a language of Central Indo Aryan group. We need recognition of Bhojpuri language. Official status of Bhojpuri and Bhojpuri as medium of education in Bhojpuri region.
Government can create a separate Bhojpuri state by combining western Bihar districts and Eastern UP districts in Purvanchal.. The new state with capital at Gorakhpur, can have Bhojpuri as official language..
You can still speak Bhojpuri. No one is stopping you. But we also need ONE national language so that we can all communicate effectively with each other!
पता नही भाई सरकार भोजपुरी को हिन्दी का एक उपभाषा क्यू कहती है जबकी हमारे भाषा का खुद का स्क्रिप्ट है जिसको "कैथी" बोला जाता है लेकिन फिर भी हमारे यहाँ सभी hordings हिन्दी मे ही है । हमारे किताबो को भी हिन्दी मे ही , schools मे भी हिन्दी मे बात करते हैं ।
Great Work!! This video is a gem. ❤ As a Bengali, I never suppot Hindi imposition. ❌ Yes I know Hindi and English because it's my choice. But government can't make it obligatory! That will result in huge protests for sure. Also, one thing I thought worth mentioning, Bengali and Punjabi was the most important language while our freedom struggle because most of the freedom fighters were from Bengal and Punjab. If you go to Cellular jail in Andaman (kala pani k uss paar) you will find that most of the freedom fighter prisoners were Bengali and Punjabi. Also, Indian National Anthem is in "Tatsama Bengali" language close to Sanskrit. Even, "Vande mataram" was written by a great Bengalee man Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay! The only Nobel Prize in literature in whole India is a Rabindranath Tagore. 🏆 Also, I know every other Indian languages including the beautiful south Indian languages have their own pride and rich history. So, imposing Hindi would serve as the last nail to the coffin ⚰️ of Indian Unity in Diversity. Never try to impose Hindi on someone.
Bro every state contributed towards independence movement. Maharashtra UP and Rajasthan too had their fair share. The first independence movement started in UP which was indigenous. FYI If there were no Marathas India would no longer exist as a Hindu country. In short many communities contributed towards Independence which include Bengalis and Punjabis. In the end NS role could have been bigger than others to attain independence.
Bengali Communist Bhadralok have Spoken. You should thank this nation for What narrow Strip of former Bengal which still Exist. It was Bengali-Bhadralok Communists who started Naxalism. You forgot About all Marathi and other Freedom fighters. Stop Crying nobody is imposing Sh*t. Bihar and UP are your neighbouring states. You wrote this in English. Just like that people are Learning Hindi. Almost 60%-70% people can understand Hindi all over India.
@@Trials_By_Errors I expect you read my comment again carefully. No, I didn't forget anything regarding other freedom fighters from other states. I just said that freedom fighters from Bengal and Punjab are large in number. And Bengali language had an important role in India's freedom too. That's it. And yes I already mentioned I understand Hindi because it is a choice. But you can't make it obligatory to learn Hindi in other language areas. Don't forget, all languages are local languages: Hindi is also a local language for non-hindi speakers.
As a maharashtrian there is a huge population who is living here from more than decades even bought homes and shifted but still say they dont understand marathi. They dont want to speak nor learn.
Mumbaikar honge people in pune can understand and speak Marathi I am in pune with in two years I started speaking Marathi . A person who speaks Hindi can speak Marathi easily
Great content. Unbiased, thoroughly researched and provides a clear picture of the history and current status of languages in India. Though I don't understand Hindi fluently, I could understand the content through images and data on screen. Ironically, I have a request. Please recreate this video in English or add English subtitles, this video must reach more viewers from entire India.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Being multilingual is assets not burden.. Multilingual kids can understand new thing more easily, it makes there Brains flexible & increases adaptability skill via environment..
@@theFastestSloth_001 no I didn’t. I said all Indians who don’t know Tamil will do well learning Tamil and understanding the Tamil way of life. It is a classical language and anyone who doesn’t know it and wants to impose their language on Tamiians can take the lead and learn a non-Hindi language and appreciate it. I want the Indian government to allocate resources to propagate Tamil to non-Tamil speaking people and support it.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
Brothers first of all learning a new language is extremely difficult. Many my friends from North India who are working in Bengaluru tried learning kannada and gave up. Even for us learning hindi is extremely difficult even though we had one subject in school it is extremely difficult for us too. Everyone must learn English even though it's hard because there is no hindi used in Engineering,medicine or any research paper,coding etc. Even hindi people can't survive in India in any good profession without knowing English. Many people associating hindi with patriotism. Kannada, Tamil, Malayalam,Telugu,Tulu,Marathi,Gujarathi people are as patriotic as hindi people . Hindi people are more in population doesn't make them more patriotic. Punishing south Indian because they consciously controlled population. Is it right thing. Why can't we communicate with the language we use for job and education purpose. Most of us use English to comment in RUclips or anywhere in social media. Why sould then the south Indian people should learn hindi and not English which can give them much better opportunity not only in India, but all over the world. However hard we criticize English but this is the language which connects India and which connect world.
kannada is hard for north people because they never learnt any south language in school. but we spent like 5 years learning hindi, as a south india. to me it feels like thier policy is responcible for all this. we spend so much time in high school leaning hindi.. why can't northies spend same amount of time in high schools learning any south language. it will make the new south languages much easier to learn. at least least they should try.. it's just unfair.
Anna what is going on Karnataka is not shameful? By destroying shops because they have written their business name in 3 languages targeting them for 60% kannada imposition. U can also do here write in 3 languages (kannada, English and Hindi) on ur business outlet we wouldn't have mind it, but kannada rakshana vedike 😂😂 went on rampage( showing ur literacy by doing such heinous things) it's not the way. Specifically targeting who have written their business name in Hindi by disrespecting it by kicking, breaking the name plates 😢 u r sending message that u hate north Indian so much and then talk about unity that we r indian and all stuff. We have not forced u to speak Hindi noway.
@@vikramshetty8334 I agree with you brother but I am telling to this Abdul Malik bcoz kannadiga,s are native people of kannada not who came from Iran or turkey
Thank you for mentioning Tulu ❤and for those who are not agreeing with it are those who want thier language to dominate 😊and according to me only Sanskrit as the legitimate right to be our national language
I think the non hindi states should make a rule that in schools there should be the regional language as 1st or 2nd language so that the migrant's children can understand the regional language from where he/she is getting food. Otherwise hindi will kill every regional languages with the help of central govt (whether its BJP or Congress).
@@arghyadipray5278speaking is different. Scoring is different. Some people may have good score in English. But they suck at speaking. It's the same case in most times. One of my friend used to score good marks in Hindi. But he suks when it comes to speaking in Hindi
Learning as many languages as possible is a positive thing. Learning many languages make the mind sharp as well. I think Hindi, English as well as regional languages all are taught in the schools.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
@@AnarchistDoc I know bro but I don't care what language the people around me speak. No matter how many new languages we learn or come across, my family and I will always support our mother tongue. :)
@@AnarchistDoc i am also a garhwali. It’s not Hindi imposition that killed native languages. Hindi is a unifying language that was destined to be unifying language for entire county with no iLL intention. Native speakers should have their duty to keep their native languages alive. It takes another level of understanding in accepting and popularizing Hindi and keeping your mother tongue alive as well. I am fluent in Garhwali and I have a very good knowledge of Hindi as well. Don’t make unnecessary enemies. Hindi is refined to be fit for all Indians. It’s phonetics and base verbs are taken from Sanskrit directly hence it’s suitable for all Indians who speak their native languages.
@@RavinderSNegi bheji tye barmand ma chaaru lagyu chi? gadwai ar kumaya hindi bana extinct whona ar tumu yakh yu chui laan ma kwe bat ni legni? shame on you.....
If Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand and Delhi government can recognise Urdu as official language for Muslim appeasement (even if No Hindu & even 50% Muslims also can't write urdu) then what's the problem in recognising other languages? Now Most Hindi hindi speaking states has BJP govt. they should recognise all these languages, promotion of Hindi is ok but not recognising local languages is absolute foolish thing to do. Please atleast recognise Rajasthani, Awadhi and Bhojpuri.
Jharkhand has 16 additional official languages apart from Hindi which includes all local languages spoken in the state. You can imagine how linguistically diverse the state is 😅
@@alhamdulillah826 tamilnadu and Kerala Muslims can't understand single word of Urdu .they can understand few words of Hindi which belongs to Sanskrit . And same Tamil malayalam have many Sanskrit words which same use in Hindi too . And nearly only 1/5th Muslims recognise themselves as a Urdu speakers . And only 1/6 muslims can read and write Urdu .
Why cant hindi people learn telugu and kannada as we learn hindi in our schools? It really helps us unifying And on the other hand tamils anyway doesnt try to learn hindi or other indian languages except english 😤😤😤
Official language status is also nominal. De facto many other languages are also officially used. eg. Marathi is the sole official language of Maharashtra. Not Hindi, not English. But in practice Govt. of Maharashtra and the various Municipal Corporations under it also utilise English, and to a lesser extent Hindi. In Ulhasnagar, all signboards are written in English and Sindhi (Persian script) because of the high Sindhi population there. Govt. also runs Kannada language schools in Kannada villages in Solapur and Kolhapur districts. It is the responsibility of the government to adapt to it citizens and provide services in their language. Only the central government has shown some level of pigheadedness when it comes to langauge.
Please, Maharashtra govt is worse. They are forcing private establishments to put up signboards in Marathi. If you want to make language adaptable, you need to let businesses decide for themselves - they will only succeed if they put the language used commonly by that locals in that area. So whatever language they choose without force is automatically the correct one. In Mumbai they used English for so long, so clearly that was not a problem. But govt forced Marathi. They pretend Mumbai is not multiethnic and impose Marathi and Marathi nationalism constantly, with inflammatory historical claims
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
I think govt and public sector companies should Hindi more than English but less than local language. Indian language should be focused on first then a foreign language like English.
@@akhileshkannan8421 English is not a foreign language anymore, it's not French. It is a binding language to our country and even and a native tongue to few Indians - but across geographical distribution, so it is a very fair language to use.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
I am from Jharkhand and i grew up speaking Santhali, Hindi and English and a little bit of Odia...and even though i can speak/understand all of these languages, only one gives me my identity and its the reason why i put it above rest even though Santhali, Hindi and English are all my mothertongue..and i would hate for anyone to impose Hindi as official language on me and my tribe becaus emy tribal language is already dying as it is and instead of saving it, it would essentially demolish learning the language by the newer generation
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)* 1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally" 2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language) 3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)* 4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace' 5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World 6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment. 7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Bhojpuri should be added to our 8th schedule of constitution. We feel proud in speaking Hindi but bhojpuri should get it's right and thus we can introduce our bhojpuri in educational forums ... Jai Bhojpuriya , Jai Bharat
Yes it should be.................even Bhojpuri poets like Mahendra misir had played a very special role in the Indian independence...........and was sent to buxor jail.....for almost 8 years...........and he has given most of the Bihari.....folk songs......like Bidesiya,chaita,thumri,kajri,sohar.............etc❤
Had the British just made both Devanagari and Nastaliq as official script for Hindustani. This Hindu Muslim Hindi Urdu problem wouldn't have occured . My mother tongue is Urdu but I learned Devanagari script with ease on my own . As Urdu and Hindi are technically recognised registers of hindustani and mutually intelligible, learning another script wasn't difficult
@@homelesslavie_vlogs9600 agreed. Infact to this day many people in Pakistan (both native and non native Urdu speakers) use this term to address native Urdu speakers
@@ellerosee मिर्जापुर भले ही अवध का हिस्सा ना हो,लेकिन यहां भी प्रयागराज जौनपुर की तरह ही अवधि ही बोली जाती है। भोजपुरी का क्षेत्र वाराणसी से शुरू होता है। बाहर बैठकर आप यहां की भाषा को नहीं जान सकते इसके लिए आपको मिर्जापुर आना होगा
Maine bhi apni local dialect or language bhul Chuka tha...kyuki main Bachpan se apni language sunta tha but bolta nanin tha... Ab kuch saalo se Maine bolna suru kar Diya hai... Now I am good in it. Nagpuri bhasa from jharkhand. Ye 3rd generation hai Hindi ka... Kyuki mere grandfather was a Hindi teacher. But mere father abhi bhi itne fluent nahin hai... Our president Dropadi murmu ka bhi accent AA jata hai.. Thanks for your response.
I am so proud to be alive at a time artists like you exist. Excellent work!
Thanku so so much Ashrish bhai for the appreciation 🥰....
Your Work on Languages and Geography has always been Inspiration for me 🙌🏻
I have always been a big fanboy of IIP and getting Appreciation from the artist who keeps inspiring me is a biggest proud moment for me as well
Thanku so much for everything you do :)
Glad you watched and enjoyed the video! I love both maps and languages and this video is the most beautiful mashup of both
You both inspires me
Whenever I go I see you arish 😅 you are everywhere
Pure Hindi is oldest language like Sais the pevar Hindi is similar like Sanskrit जिसमें लेकिन नहीं किंतु परंतु का उपयोग किया जाता है शुद्ध हिंदी कितनी पुरानी है यह हमें यह पता चलता है कि हिंदू कैलेंडर हिंदी में शुद्ध हिंदी की बात कर रहा हूं और तुम जिस हिंदी की बात कर रही हो उसमें 10 भाषण मिला दी जाती हैं।
I’m from Karnataka my wife from Andhra Pradesh my mother is from Tamil Nadu , I am proud to say I can speak all these beautiful languages and I respect all languages and we need to protect all our region languages and not to loose out your roots.
All india in one family
Kannada is not regional language it's also national language
men how many languages you speak 😂
My mother also Tamil Nadu
@@akshatsharma9246 How many you know?? And why that sarcastic smile
As a Maharashtrian Marathi, I can assure that most of Maharashtrians can speak hindi fluently but at the same point we love our mother tounge Marathi more than that ❤🔥🚩🙏
but most maharashtrians 90% cant speak hindi fluently
Hamari matrabhasha Sanskrit aur Tamil hain, baaki sab dialects hain.
Aryan Sanskrit aur Dravidian Tamil hi Bharat ki matrabhasha hain aur baaki sab in bhashaon ki betiyan hain.
Marathi se pyaar karo magar Sanskrit ko bhi yaad rakho.
@@ashesofhopesinabonfireofdr6341 if you're born speaking a different language then that's your mother tongue not something which you can not speak. It's a common misconception to call something your mother tongue which you can't even speak.
@@PATRICX2000 Don’t required fluent okay 👍
Yeah, mother tongue first
Hindi has killed my Mother tongue Marwari, Today city kids do not understand a single word of Marwari😢😢😢
Hindi ka chod English ki wajah se aadhe marwadi, gujarati log western jaise ban chuke hai aur pura culture hi bhul gaye hai humara
Same thing happening with bhojpuri 90% of new generation don't even speak bhojpuri wait for few more years most of the regional languages will be gone 😞
@@ayushyadav5611bhojpuri has became shame for new generations that is also a reason.
Ram ram bhaisa🙏
This is because of your attitude that you think people who speak local are illiterate. You are proud to speak English than any other language. You cannot say that Hindi destroyed everything. Hindi is very close to northern and mid India languages.
South indians are the one who are resisting the attack of foreign Aryan language and culture attack..rest of indians have already surrendered to this Aryan attack.
Attack.... you need to change your way of thinking and need to find if actual is coming from Islamic and Abrahmic world or from Hindi.
@@fruitful_thought wrong. South indian people should save their regional language and shouldn't submit to it. North indians are weak and submit to hindI. Hindi is forced on people everyone from rajasthan to odisa should reject it. Hindi/urdu is delhi, U.P, M.P langauge.
Foreign?
No Dravidian gene data exceeds Gujjar And Sindhi in IVC genes
They have more IVC genes
There is no need of national language but don't hate hindi. As a Bengali I love to speak bengali, hindi and english 🙏
National religion ??
If state can have state language then why can not state religion ??
I am currently in wb but that does not mean that i have any less right as a hindi(bhojpuri) speaker and so india should also have state religion
@@rohit-ru5nm hindi and bhojpuri are not same
State religion is hindu
सारे लोग अपने अपने भाषा में बात करें कोई अपने लोगों में परंतु यदि एक राज्य का व्यक्ति किसी दूसरे राज्य का व्यक्ति से बात करनी है, तो हिन्दी में बात करना श्रेयस्कर होगा I
@@rohit-ru5nm yes you have less rights .....you people can't influx other states only because you don't have food
We need hindi as national language
I am a Proud Indian from Bengal and I will never surrender to Hindi because I love my Bengali motherland
Surrender? Is there a war going on between Hindi and you?
@@ranjittyagi9354 yes. all this North Indians coming to Kolkata refusing to speak Bengali is an insult to Bengal's culture.... either speak Bengali or get out of Bengal
@@ranjittyagi9354s,....an egoistic war started by hindi-speakers, between Hindi entitled brats and natives standing up for themselves,...we will never come to Hindi speaking state and say speak my language,..so why should Hindi speakers have such entitlements?
@@creakyinertia872 not started by common people though. I guess, you'd agree on this. Yes, I mean politicians.
You got the video wrong, kiddo
I'm a Bengali and everyone loves their mother tounge. It's not just a language, it binds the culture as well. For me, any one language is fine to connect with people outside my community be it Bengali, Hindi, Gujrati, Tamil, English. 😊
Yes tui to fine hobi jodi Kal hindi national language hoye jai tateo😊
তাহলে ভারতের National language বাংলা করে দেওয়া হোক
@@Anonymous-sf4hw hobe na oto sohoje. Ar barite te toh banglai bolbo.
But a person can't know all the languages, so it's important to choose a barrier language (Local language).
Hindi is spreading like virus, if we don't realise this now, we are soon going to loose our identity.🥺
In Himachal Pradesh there are 20 + dialects spoken but . Nowadays some parents are forcing their kids to speak Hindi , i personally belong from South Himachal and speak kangri which is a Punjabi dialect
Makes no sense. It's not hard to learn multiple languages at once. I grew up with English Punjabi and Hindi and am able to speak all of them just fine even though I live in an English dominated society
You shouldn't force your kids to speak in Hindi. English and mothertongue.
Hindi should be banned here in Himachal and these dhoti U.P people need to speak in our pahadi language.
@@mayan5600 no just no. I don't live in India and I've never been to India but learning just regional language English and Hindi are necessary. V the more languages you know the more people you can talk to. If I didn't know Hindi I would be so much restricted in the people I can talk to or the media I can consume
As a Telugu South Indian, most of the south Indians Speak english and we love our mother tongue as well. But we don't want Hindi imposition.
Kon impose kar raha he lattu😂
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
@@gamingstrong1686 Northie tattus like you is the reason many think North Indians are cheap people.
I have been to southern state and never met someone who preferred english over hindi, most people speak hindi Or atleast understand it except in tamil nadu , english is limited to major cities except in Kerala. "Stop hindi imposition " is only an internet phenomenon.
@@daksh6388 Northies like you is exactly why "Stop hindi imposition" is required.
As a Bengali we never support Hindi.We are always use Bengali.It’s our mother tongue.
Did u even watched the video? Hindi is a language which can be used for connectivity and i think so we should not use english for connectivity cause hindi is a indian langua
@@shashankdixit8949Bengali is an Indian language.Then why don't we use it?Why not any south Indian language?
@@shashankdixit8949why only Hindi when half of the country doesn't know Hindi.
This is the fault of Indian finding father. Never choose the majority language/biggest language as lingua franca because it will cause jealousy and the sense of favoritism towards one language. Indonesia and Pakistan are the only successful countries to unite all the ethnics with one language because they chose small/minor language as lingua franca. Indonesia chose Malay instead of Javanese, Pakistan chose Urdu instead of Pashto
@@SudiptoSarkar-mh5vy you guys missed what was said in the video. Hindi wasnt made to impose on others. It was made just like any other language was made but as time went on it became the most spoken language. and thats why the government wanted to promote it over English because they wanted something indian to unite the people. But how they did it is definitely wrong, they imposed it instead of promoting it, even regional languages where im from arent spoken much ( pahadi languages ) and our takri script is even considered dead. But that doesnt mean we should hate on a language thats from our land. There is a difference between standing your ground so your culture doesnt die out and just hating on a language
That's why there is a reason why the 🇮🇳 Indian Govt. has declared Telugu, Tamil, Kannada & Malayalam (along with Odia and Sanskrit) as 'Classical Languages of India' over Hindi/ Urdu!
🇮🇳 తెలుగు
🇮🇳 தமிழ்
🇮🇳 ಕನ್ನಡ
🇮🇳 മലയാളം
🇮🇳 ଓଡିଆ
🇮🇳 संस्कृतम्
And what's the reason?
Bhai Odia ka spelling Odia me sahi nehi likha hai wo ଓଡ଼ିଆ hai ଓଡିଆ nehi
@@msr7373
There are 11 parameters for that
Bcz that is truth...Those language oldest than Hindi...Tamil is older than sanskrit but north indian mind never accept that truth
@@aravind270
Lol what Tamil is oldest what the hell only Tamil brainwashed niggas say that not even all other south India or regional states 😂😂😂😂
And with due respect at least rice bag converted haleluyaah products should not cry about heritage culture identity it seems like blatant hypocrisy
I'm a guy with Hindi as my Mother tongue but I respect all the languages there is no need to impose Hindi on other states. Since they have their own languages which have been preserved for more than a millennium,but hating on people just because they speak Hindi is not okay ! Jai Hind 💪
It is not hating hindi speakers, it is the fighting against, mistaken as hate, the people who wants to impose hindi on the rest of non-hindi citizens. Imposition is through making hindi compulsary in schools, changing railway station boards to hindi only etc,., Hindi speakers has a "sense" of entitlement because of the central government expecting people to know Hindi. This is what the regional governments and people are opposing. No imposition (.)
@@striker44 No they don't. Everyone where I live speaks Hindi and also other regional languages. Nobody has any "sense" of entitlement just because they speak Hindi. I am from Uttarakhand btw.
@@person1420yeah? You'd know the situation if you'd come to our state,.....what striker44 said 100% true,... They come to our states with a sense of entitlement that the natives themselves have to learn an alien language(Hindi).
@@creakyinertia872 What state are you from? No hate or anger for anyone here. We are all one big nation. 🫡
you all stole from tamil. SANSKRIT plagiarized tamil and claim its 5000 years older. WTF. Why indians believe hindu myth? That too in 21st century?
INDIA is in DARK country when it come spiritual stuff.
Is nobody going to talk about The Death of Vedic Sanskrit , expect some Brahims and A town of Karnataka 😢
Jai Maa Kāli 🕉
Kannads are dravidians they have got nothing to with sanskrit. Theie langauge is also dravidian.
Actually the karnataka kannada speaking village people are migrants from Kerala
@@pkmabcd8270 bhag katuwe
@@Sachin-ln3lowhy keralites have so much identity crisis
@@Amoghavarsha. actually kerala has many type of people. Different people have different identity. Most Christians in kerala are not recently converted like rest of India. The first converts were Brahmins who mixed with Syrian migrants around 100-300 AD. After that many Christians from Arabian peninsula migrated and settled in kerala before the begining of Islam. All these Christians consider them different from the Christians who converted during colonial period. The muslims of kerala are Arab traders who mixed with local population (Aryans and Dravidian) and settled in kerala. So they also have a different identity. Among the hindu population 30 percentage are Nairs. They are Aryans and they consider sanskrit and Malayalam as their language. The Brahmins and Nairs mixed sanskrit with local dravidian and Malayalam was formed. Ezhava community is about 50 percentage of Hindu population. We are not sure whether they are dravidian or Aryans but sanskrit is important for them as well. 15 percentage of Hindu population are Dalits and they are dravidians. Upper caste Christians and upper caste Hindus are mostly sanskrit supporters. Even bible is in highly sanskirtised malayalam
Nothing is wrong with Hindi, nor is with any other languages and many other dialects, including my Garhwali. Just remember one thing, if a language dies so does the history, culture and traditions. Thank you for this very interesting episode! Definitely subscribed for now.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
Is there any script for Garhwali?
Without english, there would have been no India as it exists now.
It is the British who occupied various princely territories and formed India.
We inherited that in the early forties but had to part with some land for Muslims, hindu- muslim conflicts.
Imposing of majority ethnic, religious, lingual force on non hindi speaking population will sure repeat 1947.
Nobody wants that but the hindi zealots may make it happen.
Remember the cause of creation of Bangla Desh and break up of USSR.
Let wisdom rule over language fanaticism.
bhai garhwali hindi nhi hai
@@leharyenduri6540yup
As a proud Marathi i don't get it why people have problem with us? They are try to impose their toxic hindutva and nationalism on us
And it's also a myth that Marathis are fluent in hindi and we are comfortable with hindi imposition, stop putting us in North India group
Many people are flexing that hindi people rule india but just remember that marathas occupied half of India but never imposed marathi on anyone
I'm from andhra pradesh, Speaking hindi is no problem for us but compulsory & forcefully in board exams is problem
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
@@gamingstrong1686Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
iam from south india Telangana and we dont have any problem
Bro You can Use your language education
if you accept speaking then they won't speak your language and will go against your language in your state itself
ನಾನು ನೋಡಿದಂತ ಅದ್ಭುತವಾದ ಜ್ಞಾನ ತುಂಬಿದ ದೃಶ್ಯಾವಿದು.
ನನ್ನೊಬ್ಬ ದ್ರಾವಿಡ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗನಾಗಿರುವೆ ಈ ಮಾಹಿತಿ ನೀಡಿದ ನಿಮಗೆ ಅಸಂಖ್ಯಾತ ನಮನಗಳು 🙏.
100% true words about Indian languages.
I' m a Dravidian kannadiga
Thank u For informative video.🙏.
We Love All Languages.
Please Respect Local language.👍❤
Dravidian yaake anna....Bharata annu...
Only Movies (bollywood/khanwood ) and political leaders has divided North and South
We don't want you to speak only Hindi, we all have been living together for thousands of years. When our ancestors had no problems then why would we?
Only movies / political leaders
For Impressions and views
Be unite 💪
*ಭಾರತೀಯ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ✅*
You can say only Kannadiga
Dravidian kannadiga yaako
I'm from Tamilnadu. India is a country in diversity. We should cherish every language available here. We should give priority to our mother tongue first. If you can't read, write and excel in your mother tongue but you know third language means, It is really shame. Mother tongue is like mother, Giving food to others letting your mother to starve is a sin.
You are right brother , even I am not in favour of forcing Hindi on people who have different mother tongue but we need a connecting language that is not foriegn (like I am using English now 😅) , would you agree if that connecting language is Sanskrit ?
@@ayushbhardwaj7650if you come to tamilnadu connect through tamil. If we come to Up/Bihar we will connect in Hindi. Ok?
@@striker44idk why this simple logic evades people. Learn your mother tongue and local language of the state you stay in, simple.
@@bodhijitbiswas6282 Agreed. Simple right?
@@ayushbhardwaj7650 why we should? Why should we learn for immigrants? And for your information we people speak Tamil which is an independent language which doesn't come from Sanskrit so don't include us in other states. We learn English because it's a global language and it will be useful for work. Else we don't learn that too
There is nothing wrong with Hindi. I am born and brought up in Mumbai. I speak bhojpuri with my family members and relatives. I speak Hindi with my friends and Marathi with every government official or local bhajiwala, autowala etc. People are blaming Hindi when they should blame their parents for not inspiring them to speak in their own mother tongue. Hindi is very important to binding multilingual Indian society. If I have to work in 5 different states I can not learn 5 different languages. There has to be a common working indian language for whole nation.
ha bhai pta nhi kaha kaha se aajate h ye gawar log
Destructive ideas & opinions are more popular than constructive ones always.
I'm proud Indian Bengali & we won't let anyone force or impose Hindi or Urdu or any freaking language on us. Yeah we can treat Hindi as connecting language upto a certain level. I belong from a community in which peoples martyred their lives to stop foreign language (Urdu) imposition 😌❤️ Jai Bengal Jai Hind 🇮🇳
BENGAL BACHALO!! r0hingy@ BHAGAO!!! AGAR NRC CAA NHI LAGA TOH BENGAL GYA! BE VOCAL!!! DESH KE LIYE ITNA TOH KRO!!
Urdu is not foreign language...it is our own language with just a touch of persian and arabivc...most of urdu words are derived from sanskrit...urdu was developed in delhi and up so how it can be foreign language??
@@r1a172it is foreign to native bengali speakers
@@r1a172 Urdu is a foreign language. urdu was developed in the brothels of Delhi, it's disgusting language, it symbolizes oppression and the worst of the periods in Indian history.
Jai Hind Jai Bengal
Keep it up bro, Bengali as a language is more beautiful than Hindi, Bengali script may be a derivative of devanagiri but it definitely looks more beautiful and artistic with its sharp edges, also, our national anthem is in Bengali not in Hindi, don't let anyone force you to speak any language against your wishes, take it from a proud Tamilian who does not like to be forced to learn any language and yet is a polyglot blessed of the Lord Jesus Christ for His glory. ;)
Never let your mother tongue die.....just because maximum of the population speaks one language.....
I am from land of Dawnlit mountain (Arunachal Pradesh) mother tongue - Nyishi
Official language - English.. Around 90% of population can speak Hindi....as because of hindi we are losing our mother tongue 😢
Same with Uttarakhand. Today's childs don't speak Kumauni.
No one is killing their own mother tongue.learning a common language is not a bad thing.
@@nayakpaswancorrect ye faltu ka drama kar rahe ha
Hindi is just uniting us its your family task to give native language
Arunachal has 100+ subtribes and 100+ languages(dialects).
So it is necessary to take one language as official. It would have been better if English was compulsory and not hindi as hindi too is a foreign language for us.
Fantastic video!
1) look at movies of Telugu, Tamil, Kannada and Malayalam cinema:
songs feature native Dravidian words as well as 🚩Sanskrit ones like प्रेम, प्राण, हृदय, समय, भोजनम, धन्यवदाम
2) now, look at the 'Hindi' industry of Bollywood:
songs feature 🇵🇰Urdu words like Ishq, Aashiqui, Mohabbat, Mehboob, Khuda, Rab, Waqt, Wajood, Izzat, Ijazat, Hifazat, Rishta, Zindagi...
But still, BJP/ RSS want to make हिन्दी as National Language over 1000s year old తెలుగు, தமிழ், ಕನ್ನಡ, മലയാളം languages. 🤔
हम पूर्णतः आपसे सहमत है भाई ।💯💖
Won't happen 😂😂😂 telengana and Tamil Nadu will never agrre
The problem with people like you is that you consider Urdu as Pakistani, despite the fact that URDU is an Indian language.
It's not about BJP. It is central government's policy overall. Never forget that it was congress which tried to make Hindi the only official language of India. They inserted a clause in the constitution which makes it the central goverment's liability to promote Hindi.
Every government is mandated to make Hindi as national language. Even if a PM from south is elected as in case of Devegowda or Narsimha Rao or anyone in future, he will promote Hindi. It has nothing to do with BJP, RSS.
A central government will need a medium to connect to all as it can't publish every notification in 1600+ language. Even if anti-hindi DMK occupies center it will start promoting Hindi as it will need to communicate with northern/NE/Bengali/Gujarati people. Even they will have to bring a common language. You can't end the concept of link language.
I do understood mother tounge is important and it's duty of its native speakers to protect it and pass on to next generation. But when you are living in a such a big country a link language will be needed. It might be anyone English, Hindi or anyone else.
BTW, those chauvinist who thinks that only Hindi will destroy their mother tounge and not English should learn about English History and how many languages it has killed to become so big.
The rise and fall of language is a natural phenomenon. It is bound to happen and nothing can stop it.
We can only pass our mother tounge to next generation and hope that it goes on till it becomes more popular. No need to hate other languages.
PS : I am not a native Hindi /English speaker but could connect to you all only because we all were watching a Hindi language video and commenting in English language while our mother tounge is different.
अरे भाई साहेब आपकी जानकारी को सलाम🎉
As a Tamilian, you know where we stand with our mother tongue and hindi. Just Tamil and English is good for local and international use. If one needs another language, they will learn due to necessity. No hindi imposition please.
I hate English, it's such a Protestant language. Can we speak Spanish?
Languages never should be forced. I say as a Northie.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Yes
@@gigologandhi4566 , Remove Hindi... Lol, you moron, who do you think I am? King in the North!
This is such a well researched video without any agenda or bias...congratulations brother🎉..full respect to this channel 😊❤
Thanks For Your Support ❤️
@@andyistphdhpc2726 That's Because Hindi has been imposed on You and Now You guys Speaks Hindi More Than Bhojpuri... So Definitely You will Understand Hindi More....
But if You See the Linguistics, Grammar, Pronounciation and all Bhojpuri Is More similar to Bengali and Odia than Hindi.... Bcz Bhojpuri is Originated from Magadhi Prakrit and Not from Sauraseni Prakrit Like Hindi....
@@andyistphdhpc2726 Dude, Bhojpuri, Maithili, Magahi, Bengali, Odia, Assamese All These Languages Originated from Magadhi Prakrit... They have More Similarities with Each other Than a Different Origine language Hindi Which is Originated from Sauraseni Prakrit....
You Might Not Know the Pure Version of Your own Language Bhojpuri bcz From Decades Bhojpuri is Getting Influence of Hindi....
Even i can Hear So much Similarities between Bhojpuri and Bengali just by Listening it....!
❤❤
@@theunknown8528 dumbo!! Bhojpuri is a dialect and not a language...it does not hv any grammar, every Bhojpuri province speaks its own version! For example:
Jaat baanti- Gorakhpur
Jaa taani-Deoria
Jaat haiin-Maharaganj
Jaat baani- Gopalganj
All of the above means "I am going" but said differently in adjacent districts.
Hindhi occupied the native language of the region and suppressed the growth of regional language, like Haryana's regional language hariyanvi replaced by Hindi, gujrati replaced by hindhi, Maithili, chandhili, replaced by hindhi in the state of Bihar, soon Marathi will be suppressed by hindhi in the name of national education policy...
Who said gujarati displaced by hin dude
A well-researched and comprehensive video that touched upon some of the very questions I have grappled with when thinking of the future of languages. As a Tuluva Mumbaikar, I am aware of the many layers of complexity involved in the whole language/ dialect debate and how language is as much (if not more) about cultural identity than mere communication.
I make sure I speak Tulu in Udupi-Mangalore-Kasargod (Tulu Nad) if not spoken by native or protected the whole culture will die along with it.
@@SaideepShetty It saddens me to see how difficult it is becoming to deal with officials in Tulunadu without speaking Kannada. 😐
Fight for Freedom of your state Tulu Nadu against Karnataka. Tulu people are more successful than Kannadigas outside Karnataka
You may understand, as you are from Mumbai. I'm a Khadi boli speaker from Delhi NCR (UP side). Delhites cast us as rural and inferior when we speak khadi. It's devastating for my language.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
Brother, make this video in English too, so that people in the southern regions of india could understand that not everyone in northern regions of India wants to impose any language on them.
Hhmm...
I will try to add English Subtitles in this Video....
I watching from Kerala.
Yes you're right but we didn't know that languages of North!
No he should make this video in at least 50 languages for more views.
He uses a lot of English words anyway, so maybe not that hard to dub.
I'm kannada and Marathi speaker from solapur Maharashtra .
We speak nearly 70% kannada and nearly 30% Marathi in home .
Both are like mother tounge for us .
But we add Marathi as a mother tounge .
Millions of peoples who's mother tounge is Kannada in solapur district but 95% peoples notes Marathi as a mother tounge in census .
That's why government report shows that kannada speaker are very few in solapur district .
But , 95% kannada speaker from solapur district can't read and write kannada .
And our kannada is some different . when we speak kannada we use 30-35% Marathi words .
But , we love to speak both Language .
And we proudly say we are Maharashtraian we are indian .
When we go in South Karnataka we speak Hindi .
Because our Kannada is different From them and they laugh on us when they heard our kannada .
We speak Marathi and Hindi in all over Maharashtra .
I have friends in solapur. Bangalore kannada and solapur kannada are kannada Only. No need to use hindi in south karnataka. North Karnataka and south karnataka kannada are same only. Only slang is different
ignore those people who laugh at you.
@@Sachin-ln3lo but peoples laugh when we speak .
North kannada and South kannada are some different .
And our kannada is some different north kannada .
Only youths who laugh on us .
That's why we use Hindi . And we can't properly speaks Kannada Because we use nearly 30% Marathi word's .
And if we try to speak pure kannada then we nearly speak 90% .
But our 50% relatives who living in Karnataka they can easily speaks south kannada .
@@Ashishचव्हाण haa bhawa .
Ignore karte Hai ham .
But fir bhi jo youth hote Hai vo dekh dekhake haste Hai Apni Langauge par .
So ham Marathi me baate karte Hai ghar Walon ke saath .
Baher Kahi shop pe hotel pe gaye toh unn logon ke Saath Hindi me baat kartey Hain .
@@Sachin-ln3lo by the way Which City u belongs to ?
Yelli dinda adirya nivu ?
There is no country like India where so many languages, so many scripts, so many dialects, so many religions, sects castes, dress, look, food, festivals, rituals, weather, history, geograpy exist.
In Europe, for every language, there is a separate nation.
As someone from rajasthan, don't ever let hindi overpass u .
U would regret it later as we are today.
Same in Uttarakhand.
Yes, Rajasthan and Bihar got their languages fkd up with Hindi.😅
😢@@AbhinavChauhan-nc8hj
@@AbhinavChauhan-nc8hjdon't forget about pahari
When Sikhs were fighting for Punjabi language, you called them terr*orist and Punjabi Hindus registered Hindi as their mother tongue..
On a different note! Maithili is a magnificent language! So very poetic and lyrical sounding
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
Bengali came out of Maithili and Brajabuli.
I cant understand maithili but i can understand bhojpuri (100%) Awadhi (100%) magahi(70%)
I am from Gorakhpur and my mother is from ayodhya.
@@sauryangupta4628you can understand Magahi but why you can't understand Maithili?? Because Magahi is Combination of Maithili and Bhojpuri...
@@Abhishekkumar-sc6ji maithili is completely different from bhojpuri
Also the bhojpuri i know is gorakhpuri bhojpuri which is quite different from bihari bhojpuri
I am a Bengali , I remember in collage hostel when I watched English movies on the common TV , Hindi students who were Bihar's (they were a gang actually) always used to take the remote and change the channel to Hindi channel. They were mostly Bihars living in West Bengal and it was clear they wanted to impose Hindi in the hostel. They never respected the local Bengalis,never spoke in Bengali although they understood it .
Watching your video gave me some perspective and I can relate with imposing Hindi .
just because few guys treated you like this, you can't generalize the entire hindi speaking population as well as the Indian government
@@greenweed3253 If you read carefully I never generalized the Hindi population
This is such a shame that modern biharis recognize own language below Hindi, despite Maithili having such a rich history and literature
Lol what a nonsensical comment. Just because someone wants to watch a show or anything in Hindi, you will say they are imposing their language upon you!?!? Hahahahaha!!!!!
They can also use the same logic against you that you were imposing English upon them.
Learn to use some brain, weasel.
@@CactusClay99 don't worry we have Garga Chatterjee. It's just that more Bengalis are required to support Bangla Pokhho. Spread awareness among your friends about Hindi Imposition
Hindi is only 200 years old language. When the British arrived there was no Hindi language. Let that sink in.
There should be no imposition. Let's promote as many languages as possible through entertainment industry. (eg- many anime fans in India learns Japanese just to enjoy their favorite anime, many learns english for hollywood and korean for korean drama)
This many are limited in 5 digit only of a country of 10 digit
10000 times at least
वो बंदे के उपर होना चाहिए के वो क्या पढ़े। Do you know bihari language is almost dead in city। बिहार में हमें अपनी मात्रीभाषा nhi padhai जाती है example ke लिये मैथिली जो कि मैथिली स्पिकिंग district me compalsary honi चाहिए हम पढ़ाया तक nhi jata hai. Kya ye nhi hai Hindi imposition.
@@hamsanoj. bro I am from madhubani. From where are you
Too much diversity is harmful
For all of u I want to point out one more thing. Sub language, even after being a Bengali I can't understand local Bengali sub languages. Sub language are destined to die (atleast that happened throughout history ). Maybe these sub languages of Bengali were once a full fledged language,but today they r under one umbrella and eventually would be replaced by Kolkatan Bengali. Anyways I feel like it's unavoidable.
The reason many people in the south are ready to accept English as the bridge language when compared to Hindi are 2 reasons
1. It connects not only India but also the whole world and you increase your employability greatly.
2. It is not a native language of any major Indian communities, Maybe for some anglo indians it's their mother tounge, but it's not major, so all language speakers in India would need to learn a new language and native one won't have a default advantage when it comes to things like entrance exams.
I don't mind if Hindi is used as a bridge language, but I feel the govt should always promote local languages.
North has more dialects than south mate 😂.
South being less invaded had led to the survival of their literary works.
A major chunk in north is burned under the regular invasion.
Unlike south dialect changes every few 50 km in north.
@BlãçKjãçk BãÑkEr what is your point?
China: hold my beer 😂
We want independence
@@blackjackbanker2359 you getting invade multiple times is a skill issue 😂
I think Hindi will eventually break India. South Indians feel extremely proud about their native language which are much older than Hindi and any attempt to force Hindi to become the dominant language will lead to another partition. I'm sure the USA, UK and China wants this to happen. Every state signed up to be part of India, not Hindia.
True
China also has 6 southern dialects, but mandarin is universal in China,
but if India wants a national language which has international influence, or even become 7th UN official language,
India needs to increase the importance of Hindi inside India,
Dravidians can ve proud of their local language, but to ensure the unity of Indian nation, they need to learn hard Hindi,
@@EmilechenWhy do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
Hindi is an artificial language created for Government Purposes
There were no 'language based states' when India got Independence.
State Act itself came in 1956 when Odia and Telugu people started this drama.
कौन कौन kk create की video देख कर इस चैनल पर आया है।👍
I am from bihar...and my mother tongue is bhojpuri after bhojpuri we mostly speak hindi..we don't have any problem with hindi .we love hindi .and bhojpuri and we have our cultural songs and traditional songs in bhojpuri...even we have a huge number of bhojpuri speaking people so i think the government should add our bhojpuri language in the coutitution of india as a recognised languages like other 22 language of indian constitution..
Hindi is swallowing Bhojpuri. Wake up!
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Bhojpuri is not most speaking language in bihar. It is only spoken in western bihar and eastern up. In central bihar you will see many different languages like 'magahi' in patna and patliputra, 'bajika' in muzaffarpur and vaishali, 'Maithili' in eastern bihar (like darbhanga) and angika in south east bihar (like bhagalpur).
@@aryan22100 Are Bihari languages similar to Bengali? I've heard that Bihari is sister language of Bengalis. Now i know so called Bihari doesn't exist because there are so many dialects.
@@DilAbadyiyes Bihari languages are closer to Bengali language just like Rajasthani languages are closer to Gujarati language.
As a punjabi, we do not speak hindi. Our mother tongue is punjabi
The fact is Hindi speaking people can understand little bit of Punjabi
Lasssi
@@alien4648bhai gurdware chala Jaa, bahut lassi milegi tujhe
Khush reh
@Seema_Rahmanikoi ni ji, tunhin sikh jayoge
Sat Sari Akal, Lehande Punjab tu❤️
You have improved the Editing So much! Its literally matching the level of foreign RUclipsrs!
Thank You...
That's What i was Trying to do From Past Few Months...😅 Finally Someone Noticed....
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
That means nobody's mother tongue is Hindi in india😅
Hindi is a foreign language
@@julkernyne8925😂😂😂😂
Yes it is, in some parts of Delhi region. Go and check on Wikipedia.
Who said that?? standard hindi might not be but the older form of hindi is which is also known as Khadiboli. It's a native Language of hindi people. Still spoken in rural areas of Western UP and Delhi region. Also, khadiboli is the mother of Standard Hindi, both Hindi and Urdu were born in Meerut present day West UP and both the languages have derived from Khadiboli only. So it's a mother tongue of only the natives of West UP, Delhi region mainly but also covers very few parts of Haryana and plains of Uttarakhand
I’m Tamil speaker from Tamil Nadu, i respect all languages. I speak only Tamil it is enough and comfortable for me today. Also im ready to learn other languages in future only if it is needed.
Based but I think Tamils can corelate to Malayalam at least if not Kannada or Telugu, isn't it?
@@aproudjagannathbhaktkaling6054 Tamil and Malayalam very similar, As a Tamil guy I can naturally understand kanada to certain level and also watching to many telegu and Hindi film i can understand both. But Tamil is the only language I'm fluent, read and write.
@@nithishkandasamy9073
Ya obviously no need to be such kind of fluent in other language than the mother tongue if no such emergency even I'm an Odia & naturally I can understand Bengali & Assamese to certain level but I can understand Hindi Sanskrit Gujurati & Marathi in small amount even I have started learning little bit Kannada & will get other southern languages too as it's my hobby to be more acquainted to all the Indic wings
I know tamil not understan hindi.
@@arjunbasumatary8779
Even no need to
Very informative video. Loved the way you traced the history of all Indian languages which clearly explained the reasons for the current situation of various Indian languages. Languages are an integral part of any culture. I hope all Indian cultures preserve their native language and do not blindly adopt Hindi or English. All the various languages are jewels of India's crown and should be preserved at any cost.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
As a Bengali I am proud. No need to Hindi agression to us. Only 40% Indian mother tongue hindi 60% non hindi.
We Bengalis are freedom fighters so donot give teach us freedom fighting Netaji Subhash, vivekananda, Rabindra nath thakur, Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar Shyama Prasad Mukherjee maximum freedom fighters was Bengali.
Jai Bangla jai Bharat 🙏🇮🇳
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
You also divided the country by created Bangladesh (ex-pak)
@@aks7084 মুসলিম লিগ এবং কংগ্রেস এবং তোমাদের হিন্দি, উর্দু নেতারা ভারত ভেঙে হিন্দুস্তান আর পাকিস্তান বানিয়েছে। বাঙালিরা কোনদিন দেশ ভাঙেনি
@@aks7084that's because of hindi urdu imposition
@@invisible9299
Bangladesh become independent because they want islamic nation
Rajasthan, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Uttrakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh not only lost their language but also the culture. As an outsider, I see them as a Hindi speaker and the same culture throughout.
I am from odisha but i know 5 languages Fast language Odia Hindi Bengali Kannada English
But my target all languages speaking ❤❤❤ i love my india 🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩🥰
Bhai ama loka hi khali aeia bhabi bhali nija mula hi chedi sarileni ete bhola bhala hele aau haba ki
Kannada hege kalitiri guru...
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
A tamil with very little hindi knowledge here. You have summarised the issue very well with few mistakes. You should publish in English too, to reach wider audience.
Very good content. Kudos 👍
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
INDIA's diversity is her beauty ❤
Love from Odisha ❤
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
यहाँ पर लगभग सारे लोग अपना लोकल भाषा से प्यार करते है ऐसा बोल रहे है । लेकिन ये बोलने के लिए जो भाषा का उपयोग कर रहे है वो है अंग्रेजी माध्यम 😂😂😂। हम भोजपुरी भाषी है और भोजपुरी मे बात करना अच्छा लगता है । लेकिन हम इतने संख्या मे होते हुवे भी कभी किसी भाषा का विरोध नही किये । एक भारतीय होने के नाते हिन्दी को अपनाये सबको एक साथ जोड़ने केलिए। सोच-विचार करी कि आज हिन्दी का प्रसार मे सबसे अधिक महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका कि भाषा ने निभाया है। कृप्या कर अपने देश की भाषा का उपयोग करे ना कि अंग्रेजी।🙏🙏🙏🙏
Hindi is also outsiders language.. Only used in north side
@@moorthit6964then how it is outsider language if it is spoken is north side
@@lordstar_999 consider south north east.. Still hindi is irrelevant .. English is offical language since 1744-46 war.. In NE 1870 ..
@@moorthit6964 Please learn something. Hindi is an indian language which is the mother tongue of some parts in Delhi[UP].
हमें ज्यादा से ज्यादा भाषाओं का ज्ञान रखना चाहिए ऐसे भाषाएं लुप्त भी नहीं होंगी और हम एक दुसरे से संबंध भी बनाएं रख पाएंगे ।
MAIN BENGALI HUN
Sanskrit should be promoted more. South Indian protected their language for so many years.
Kudos to them.
Edit: People who are replying how north kings protected south and south remained untouched by islamic invaders, should go read proper history.
Khilji did invaded south long before mughals. He took kohinoor after invasion in south.
After khilji tughlaq had control of south but later vijaynagara empire was formed, which gave resistance to northern muslim empire for next 100 years.
It was during that time sanskrit, kannada, telugu, tamil flourished. Kumar vyasa translated maharabharat to kannada during this time.
So stop saying south never had to fight against islamic invaders. First go read proper history.
In fact until formation of Maratha empire. Many maratha and rajputs worked for mughals and adil shah.
Maharana pratap fought against Man singh who fought for mughals.
Chhatrapati shivaji maharaj's father and half brother venkoji worked under adil shah. They defeated nayak of south.
Thankfully Venkoji promoted sanskrit and south languages while ruling thanjavur.
I am from odisha and I love my odia language ❤
@@mayurpatil7784 South too had adil shah, nizam, qutub shah.
In fact Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj's father who was working for adil shah had control over bangalore and his another son ekoji had control of thanjavur.
Later tipu sultan controlled mysore.
In north now they are not under invaders. They can bring back their culture. Ram mandir is now building, hope sanskrit too gets enough recognition.
In fact maratha also had sanskrit and Marathi as official language.
@@mein3324 yes you are right in that sense though hopefully we get make that happen
@@mein3324 but south india was under control of invaders for only 500 years but north India is whole uncontrolled of invaders for many times in history if we will add them up it will become about 1000 years
@@jhaG_ 😂😂😂 history kha se padhi ncert se kya
Sad to see Tulu still not part of the scheduled languages since it was one of the oldest Dravidian languages along with tamil
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
बहुत ही ज्ञानवर्धक वीडियो बनाया है। मैं बुंदेलखंड से हूं। यहां बुंदेली बस कुछ जगह ही बोली जाती है, हिंदी ने बुंदेली के बहुत हद तक प्रभावित किया है। वैसे अगर निरपेक्ष रूप से कहा जाए तो बुंदेली बोली से लोग स्वयं से खड़ी बोली की ओर अग्रसर हुए है क्योंकि भाषा में इतनी अशुद्धि , गंवारपन है कि अगर कोई ठेठ बुंदेली बोलता दिख जाता है तो बोलने वाला खुद शर्मा जाता है। पानी को पानू कहना और फिर उस अशुद्धि को हक जाता कर सत्य सिद्ध करना कहां तक बुद्धिमानी है।
I appreciate the tremendous effort you have put into creating the video, particularly in raising awareness about the state of Pahari languages in Himachal and Uttarakhand for the general public to comprehend. Thank you.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ *There are 22 official administrative languages in India* & the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"Foreign income"* & So we are using English in trade business and workplace.
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World. "English is the language of international communication"
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally
The biggest problem with Hindi is that it thinks that bhojpuri , awadhi, rajasthani is its enemy and their recognition will harm their no. But the opposite of these languages is its strength , they are roots of Hindi and Hindi is cutting its roots on its own . Hindi was never introduced as a connecting language but it was forced into the name of Nationalism, as a mother tongue.
Really, hindi is cutting its roots, i don't think so .
hindi was promoted only as a connecting language and many of our freedom fighters knew its potential in uniting india hindi was doing better but then some so called intellectuals with their hyper intelligence and political ambitions began calling promotion as imposition under the ego of their limited identity ( which led centuries of slavery ) .
@@arjunchaurasiya5150 cry man cry, but we will never accept your hindi.
@@Attitudezero884 no one is imposing on you brother
Hindi is not a person who will create enemies
@@Attitudezero884you are gonna ! Broh just wait ! Becuz we need a medium ! Of communication ! Becuz if go to Tamil Nadu and speak kannada no one will understand but if you come to gujrat and speak Hindi , everyone will understand and when you come to my northeast ! And you speak Hindi everyone will understand ! Even in Assam some people who doesn't know Assamese they communicate in hindi ! And I'm not saying you start reading everything in hindi ! But if you want an unity ! You have to know Hindi ! Becuz no language is at the state of comparison with Hindi ! So hindi is the main sole
I'm an Proud Odia, I'm also using Hindi for connecting with other State's Peoples but I strongly oppose Govt. Lable promotion for Hindi, English, Urdu like New born or Outer languages. We should promote Classic Language like Sanskrit, Odia and Tamil for Communicate with Our People 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
*Just shut up....Hindi is predominantly spoken language that's why it's duty of govt according to constitution....unlike your Odia which is spoken by few only*
We can have classical languages but the question is which one to make, for ex. If we make Tamil as common then other language people will ask to make their language as a common language, but Hindi is something they cooked for communication during independence movement period so i personally feel they should make Hindi more Indian by adding vocabs from Dravidian languages and other groups so every one will feel Hindi is common and union shld also ensure to protect regional languages....This my personal opinion from TN..
hindi is still older unlike english and urdu
@@vetrivelv9391 Sanskrit is the only option. So forget Hindi as national or connecting language.
Both so called Dravidian and so called aryan languages share the huge nos of Sanskrit words directly or indirectly.
So do not force to accept Urdu / Hindi .
This is extremely wrong steps by Indian government to promote hindi with huge resources .
I am from odisha and my language is much older as well as huge vocabulary than Hindi . So it is not possible to accept Hindi in large contexts.
So Sanskrit is the only option .
As soon as accept by Hindi speakers is better for nation .
ଜୟ ଜଗନ୍ନାଥ ।
@@vladimirputin6530 We are discussing abt living Indian languages.. ur text fis out of context ...
Love this commentary and lots of interesting facts that I did not know . The presenter raises so many interesting questions . Well presented .
Rajasthani is spoken in the state of Rajasthan and Hindi is a forcibly imposed language.
I support you. We should agitate against Hindi. Anyway work is going on against it.
Jai Rajasthan Jai Rajasthani .
Bhai me bhi Rajasthan se hun lekin hindi Bharat bhi apna he 😢
Bhai rajasthani name ki koi language nahi hai rajsthan 3,4 language boli jati hai mtpb pahle rajasthan language ke base pe divide karo
@@meenaji4628 Bhasha aur boli me farq nhi pta kya bhai tumhe.??Rajasthani ki hi boliya h dhundhari ,marwari ,haudoti ,mewadi aadi .aur inke lagbhag 90% se jyada word same hi h
@@Rajasthani10100 nahi samaj ati word to boht se hindi aur rajasthani ke bhi same per dialect na bolker alag language bta rahe ho
मेंं बुंदेली हूं, और हिंदी को अपनी भाषा के रूप में पूणतः स्विकार करता हूं।।
1000 भाषाओं से अच्छा एक भाषा का होना है।
What you mean?
@@Everything_12 read my comment again..
@RAW is WAR then how did you got my comment ?
Aap ikdum glat ho,
Apani bhasa bhulno matlab apane culture ko bhulno hot he.
Tum apni aur apne purwajn ki pehchan ko bhulno he.
Bhut so bundeli sahit bhi to he.
Aaj kal budelkhand ke so called padhe likhe apni bhasa ko hi nhi janat he.
@@smartbaba1321 translation
As a Assamese speaker i feel proud to speak assamese and i think everyone should love their mother tongue along with that we have to learn English for a better future or as a connecting language 😊
Not English,that should be Sanskrit and We should Promote this one of The ancient Language Internationally
@@kanyakumari610 I'm from assam, northeast support English and northeastern languages, but i hate hindi🤢
@@violina1734 I too hate Hindi !! Better to except Sanskrit 🙏
@@kanyakumari610 We are from North East, here Hindi and Sanskrit will not be there, only local languages like Assamese, Kabi, Nagmese, Mizo, meitei, dimasa, kuki, galo, kokborok Bodo and other local languages will be there........
And English our office language...but I hat hindi, Sanskrit, bengli and other meinland indian languages 🤢
@@violina1734 We Shouldn't Hate Languages,but to protect ours!!
But Assamese is an Language Which Emerged from Sanskrit Itself !! And all the Languages of North ,Central , West India have Sanskrit Ancestors
And In South 60 to 70% words have Sanskrit Roots and In Telugu and Malayalam it's 75 to 70%
Even Tamil too But Tamilians Just Because of Politics hate Sanskrit but While Worshipping , Sanskrit Hymns are Only Used !!
Tamil is Used for Devotional songs or Such like That !!
That's why I said !! It may bound us !!
As an Indian We need a Single Language To Unify!! It's English or Sanskrit or Hindi We have To Choose One ,I won't go With Hindi as it has no any History 😂
If I Go With English there's a problem that it's a Foreign language and Most of The Nation Today Preserve there Indegenous Language to Unify,just like Japan Japanese ,China Chinese,Korea Korean ,similarly India Too need it English is Good but a Language without Culture and A slavery History can't be Our Language !! Even I Am Typing in English although I don't want English
Sanskrit should be spoken instead of Hindi because as soon as you speak Sanskrit, you become capable of understanding other languages almost
I have no time to waste in understanding other languages
Kangri dialect is similar to punjabi still it is recognised as hindi dialect but pahari has its own writing system called tankri derived from shardah script of jammu kashmir
No pahari is not similar to Punjabi
@@deependerkadian5524 Kangri pahari is very similar to Punjabi language
@@theelegantfacts5073 no they are not
Stop punjabising everything
What's the difference then between you and hindi imposers
@@deependerkadian5524 I told it is similar I didn't told that it is dialect of Punjabi and Pahari should be different language and all sign board and shop boards of himachal should be in tankri script not in hindi
@@theelegantfacts5073 not in Punjabi or English too
I am Bengali from WB and I can easily understand and said Hindi
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
মোদের গরব, মোদের আশা, আ মরি বাংলা ভাষা!
তোমার কোলে, তোমার বোলে, কতই শান্তি ভালোবাসা!
জয় বাংলা ❤
জয় ভারত ❤️
❤❤❤
জয় বঙ্গভূমি 🙏🙏🙏
অবিরাম ভালোবাসা বাংলাদেশ থেকে ❤
আপনারা বাংলার উপর হিন্দি আধিপত্য বিস্তার করতে দিবেন না।
জয় বাংলা
❤
জয় বাংলা
জয় হিন্দ ❤️
I'M BIHARI MY MOTHER LANGUAGE IS " BHOJPURI AND MAGDHI " I KNOW MEITHLI LANGUAGE ALSO 😌♥️
PROUD TO BE A BIHARI
( BHOJPURI 🤝 MAGDHI 🤝 MEITHLI ) = OUR BIHAR 🥺♥️🤝
JAI BIHARI ♥️🤝
We Bhojpuriyas are against Hindi imposition. Bhojpuri is an independent language from the Eastern Indo Aryan language group. But it is forcefully included under Hindi in the census which is a language of Central Indo Aryan group. We need recognition of Bhojpuri language. Official status of Bhojpuri and Bhojpuri as medium of education in Bhojpuri region.
sahio baat karat bada bhai
Government can create a separate Bhojpuri state by combining western Bihar districts and Eastern UP districts in Purvanchal..
The new state with capital at Gorakhpur, can have Bhojpuri as official language..
Bhojpuri is
😂😂😂😂💀💀 Dank language kamraiya devarva bahut nek dil gane hote hai😂😂😂
You can still speak Bhojpuri. No one is stopping you. But we also need ONE national language so that we can all communicate effectively with each other!
@@jaykay304 bade pavitra gane bante hain
I am bhojpuri speaker from eastern uttar pradesh(Purvanchal). We have our own identity and culture different from Hindi.
ह भाई हम भी भोजपुरी भाषी बानी गोपालगंज बिहार से । हिन्दी के वजह से हमनी के भाषा अब लोकल से भी खत्म होत जात बा ।
पता नही भाई सरकार भोजपुरी को हिन्दी का एक उपभाषा क्यू कहती है जबकी हमारे भाषा का खुद का स्क्रिप्ट है जिसको "कैथी" बोला जाता है लेकिन फिर भी हमारे यहाँ सभी hordings हिन्दी मे ही है । हमारे किताबो को भी हिन्दी मे ही , schools मे भी हिन्दी मे बात करते हैं ।
@@dhruvadhanush9468 Magadhi waale kiya kare 🤐 hamare too nahi movie industry nahi music industry. Magahi more dangerous category
Exactly bhojpuri cultural songs are unique kamariya jawaniya devarva lollypop poojwa
😂😂😂😂
@@dhruvadhanush9468 bhojpuri cultural songs are unique
Great Work!! This video is a gem. ❤ As a Bengali, I never suppot Hindi imposition. ❌ Yes I know Hindi and English because it's my choice. But government can't make it obligatory! That will result in huge protests for sure. Also, one thing I thought worth mentioning, Bengali and Punjabi was the most important language while our freedom struggle because most of the freedom fighters were from Bengal and Punjab. If you go to Cellular jail in Andaman (kala pani k uss paar) you will find that most of the freedom fighter prisoners were Bengali and Punjabi. Also, Indian National Anthem is in "Tatsama Bengali" language close to Sanskrit. Even, "Vande mataram" was written by a great Bengalee man Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay! The only Nobel Prize in literature in whole India is a Rabindranath Tagore. 🏆 Also, I know every other Indian languages including the beautiful south Indian languages have their own pride and rich history. So, imposing Hindi would serve as the last nail to the coffin ⚰️ of Indian Unity in Diversity. Never try to impose Hindi on someone.
Bro every state contributed towards independence movement. Maharashtra UP and Rajasthan too had their fair share. The first independence movement started in UP which was indigenous.
FYI If there were no Marathas India would no longer exist as a Hindu country. In short many communities contributed towards Independence which include Bengalis and Punjabis. In the end NS role could have been bigger than others to attain independence.
@@vinaymaheshwari3074 Exactly
Bengali Communist Bhadralok have Spoken. You should thank this nation for What narrow Strip of former Bengal which still Exist. It was Bengali-Bhadralok Communists who started Naxalism. You forgot About all Marathi and other Freedom fighters. Stop Crying nobody is imposing Sh*t. Bihar and UP are your neighbouring states. You wrote this in English. Just like that people are Learning Hindi. Almost 60%-70% people can understand Hindi all over India.
@@Trials_By_Errors I expect you read my comment again carefully. No, I didn't forget anything regarding other freedom fighters from other states. I just said that freedom fighters from Bengal and Punjab are large in number. And Bengali language had an important role in India's freedom too. That's it. And yes I already mentioned I understand Hindi because it is a choice. But you can't make it obligatory to learn Hindi in other language areas. Don't forget, all languages are local languages: Hindi is also a local language for non-hindi speakers.
bro, Maharastra bengal and pujab were in the forefront. it is not a surprise that all 3 states are low on bhajpa
As a maharashtrian
there is a huge population who is living here from more than decades even bought homes and shifted but still say they dont understand marathi. They dont want to speak nor learn.
Mumbaikar honge people in pune can understand and speak Marathi I am in pune with in two years I started speaking Marathi . A person who speaks Hindi can speak Marathi easily
Great content. Unbiased, thoroughly researched and provides a clear picture of the history and current status of languages in India. Though I don't understand Hindi fluently, I could understand the content through images and data on screen.
Ironically, I have a request. Please recreate this video in English or add English subtitles, this video must reach more viewers from entire India.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
@@dontbeafraidimhere5421no the 3,5,6,7 are not true
Being multilingual is assets not burden..
Multilingual kids can understand new thing more easily, it makes there Brains flexible & increases adaptability skill via environment..
You are a Hindi fanatic.
@@lawrencerichards4073 so what kind of a fanatic you are ??? Just curious
That is why we need all Indians to learn Tamil and integrate the language in our lifestyles.
@@surudog4929 you just offended malyalis, kannadigas, telugus and the others !!
@@theFastestSloth_001 no I didn’t. I said all Indians who don’t know Tamil will do well learning Tamil and understanding the Tamil way of life. It is a classical language and anyone who doesn’t know it and wants to impose their language on Tamiians can take the lead and learn a non-Hindi language and appreciate it. I want the Indian government to allocate resources to propagate Tamil to non-Tamil speaking people and support it.
Great video!😊 I didn't skip even a second!! We expecting more such content from your channel❤
Love from Karnataka
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally 🙏
ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਮੇਰੀ ਮਾ ਬੋਲੀ, ਮੈਂ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦਾ ਪੁੱਤ
ਆਪਣੀ ਬੋਲੀ ਨੂੰ ਮੁੜ੍ਹ ਸੁਰਜੀਤ ਕਰੀਏ, ਪਿਆਰ ਕਰੀਏ, ਤੇ ਸਤਿਕਾਰ ਕਰੀਏ
ਜੀਵੇ ਮੇਰਾ ਰੰਗਲਾ ਪੰਜਾਬ
Punjabi boli Zindabad
I love Punjabi people a lot, lots of love from Tamilnadu :)
@@lingeshanr love from Panjab
Brothers first of all learning a new language is extremely difficult.
Many my friends from North India who are working in Bengaluru tried learning kannada and gave up.
Even for us learning hindi is extremely difficult even though we had one subject in school it is extremely difficult for us too.
Everyone must learn English even though it's hard because there is no hindi used in Engineering,medicine or any research paper,coding etc.
Even hindi people can't survive in India in any good profession without knowing English.
Many people associating hindi with patriotism. Kannada, Tamil, Malayalam,Telugu,Tulu,Marathi,Gujarathi people are as patriotic as hindi people . Hindi people are more in population doesn't make them more patriotic. Punishing south Indian because they consciously controlled population. Is it right thing.
Why can't we communicate with the language we use for job and education purpose.
Most of us use English to comment in RUclips or anywhere in social media.
Why sould then the south Indian people should learn hindi and not English which can give them much better opportunity not only in India, but
all over the world.
However hard we criticize English but this is the language which connects India and which connect world.
Spit On Hindi Language
Put Shit On Hindi Language
kannada is hard for north people because they never learnt any south language in school. but we spent like 5 years learning hindi, as a south india. to me it feels like thier policy is responcible for all this.
we spend so much time in high school leaning hindi.. why can't northies spend same amount of time in high schools learning any south language. it will make the new south languages much easier to learn.
at least least they should try.. it's just unfair.
Well said 👏
Anna what is going on Karnataka is not shameful? By destroying shops because they have written their business name in 3 languages targeting them for 60% kannada imposition. U can also do here write in 3 languages (kannada, English and Hindi) on ur business outlet we wouldn't have mind it, but kannada rakshana vedike 😂😂 went on rampage( showing ur literacy by doing such heinous things) it's not the way. Specifically targeting who have written their business name in Hindi by disrespecting it by kicking, breaking the name plates 😢 u r sending message that u hate north Indian so much and then talk about unity that we r indian and all stuff. We have not forced u to speak Hindi noway.
Well said
I am proud to be himanchali and we himanchali will promote our pahari language to save it from hindi
Bilkul bhai
@@ASHISHSHARMA-rk6ir thanks brother
@@knowledgetime3828 Jai Hind Jai Himachal
@@ASHISHSHARMA-rk6ir jai hind and jai himachal
konsi district se hai bhai
I love the Way you explain Everything .
I like This Indian Diversity.
watching From Bangladesh 🇧🇩
ಕನ್ನಡ ಪುರಾತನ ಶ್ರೀಮಂತ ಭಾಷೆ
ಹಿಂದಿಗಿಂತಲೂ ಶ್ರೀಮಂತ ಪರಂಪರೆ, ಇತಿಹಾಸ ಸಂಸ್ಕೃತಿ ಹೊಂದಿದೆ.
I Love kannad
JAI Kamada
I also like kannada and learning it ❤
जिलेबी भाषा 🤣
@@hakunamatata3265YES as sweet as Jilebi ❤
@@hakunamatata3265tu hai nallah 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@hakunamatata3265tu hai nallah 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I am kanadiga and since i studyed in Kannada i have strong hold in kannada so i am comfortable with kannada i opose implementation of Hindi on me
Bro you are not kanadiga
@@vikramshetty8334 I agree with you brother but I am telling to this Abdul Malik bcoz kannadiga,s are native people of kannada not who came from Iran or turkey
Your are not kanadiga you Just Bullas
Abdul no one is forcing Hindi on you stop being delusional 😂
@@dead-channel6842 my dear center is imposing hindi on is we don't need Hindi we need Kannada
Thank you for mentioning Tulu ❤and for those who are not agreeing with it are those who want thier language to dominate 😊and according to me only Sanskrit as the legitimate right to be our national language
❤️
@@TheGraphicEarth please make a video on most dominated castes in Indian states
Please 🥺
@@deependerkadian5524 Anything Related to Cast Should be Abolished...
And You are talking about Dominant Cast here 💀
😂😂😂 matlab hamari school toh english promote kartti hai auur constituion kheta hai hindi promote karo
@@theunknown8528 yes we should abolished all history like rajput history because they are from same caste
I think the non hindi states should make a rule that in schools there should be the regional language as 1st or 2nd language so that the migrant's children can understand the regional language from where he/she is getting food. Otherwise hindi will kill every regional languages with the help of central govt (whether its BJP or Congress).
In uttrar Pradesh childern should learn Marathi along with Hindi.
@@sharadpatil2248 i don't think they are capable to learn more than one language
Support 3 language formula in WB
@@arghyadipray5278 As a Malayali I got full marks in Hindi in school but cannot even speak a single sentence in Hindi.😂
@@arghyadipray5278speaking is different. Scoring is different. Some people may have good score in English. But they suck at speaking. It's the same case in most times.
One of my friend used to score good marks in Hindi. But he suks when it comes to speaking in Hindi
Main problem is who is imposing Hindi on non hindi speakers.
Answer is politician but people hate hindi speaker rather than politician...
Learning as many languages as possible is a positive thing. Learning many languages make the mind sharp as well. I think Hindi, English as well as regional languages all are taught in the schools.
I think your confused By the term language and Knowledge both are different bro.
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Why Hindi? Hindi speakers learn Kannada Marathi Gujarati in syllabus? State language and English are enough for us
There are 20-30 common languages in India. You want people to learn all languages?
@@srinivasashree0000because hindi is easier than kannada and South Indian languages.
My mother tongue is Garhwali but I don’t mind speaking Hindi and English as well.
Thank you for this informative video! 👍
Soon your people will learn only hindi and english but will forget Garhwali😢😢😢, I know what hindi imposition did to Marwari and Mewari
@@AnarchistDoc I know bro but I don't care what language the people around me speak. No matter how many new languages we learn or come across, my family and I will always support our mother tongue. :)
@@RavinderSNegi You should care. It's a real threat.
@@AnarchistDoc i am also a garhwali. It’s not Hindi imposition that killed native languages. Hindi is a unifying language that was destined to be unifying language for entire county with no iLL intention. Native speakers should have their duty to keep their native languages alive. It takes another level of understanding in accepting and popularizing Hindi and keeping your mother tongue alive as well.
I am fluent in Garhwali and I have a very good knowledge of Hindi as well.
Don’t make unnecessary enemies. Hindi is refined to be fit for all Indians. It’s phonetics and base verbs are taken from Sanskrit directly hence it’s suitable for all Indians who speak their native languages.
@@RavinderSNegi bheji tye barmand ma chaaru lagyu chi?
gadwai ar kumaya hindi bana extinct whona ar tumu yakh yu chui laan ma kwe bat ni legni?
shame on you.....
If Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand and Delhi government can recognise Urdu as official language for Muslim appeasement (even if No Hindu & even 50% Muslims also can't write urdu) then what's the problem in recognising other languages? Now Most Hindi hindi speaking states has BJP govt. they should recognise all these languages, promotion of Hindi is ok but not recognising local languages is absolute foolish thing to do. Please atleast recognise Rajasthani, Awadhi and Bhojpuri.
Jharkhand has 16 additional official languages apart from Hindi which includes all local languages spoken in the state. You can imagine how linguistically diverse the state is 😅
Not everyone speaks Urdu in Muslim.
Not 50% .
It's nearly 80% muslims can't read and write Urdu .
And most of them recognise themselves as a Hindi speakers .
@@alhamdulillah826 tamilnadu and Kerala Muslims can't understand single word of Urdu .they can understand few words of Hindi which belongs to Sanskrit . And same Tamil malayalam have many Sanskrit words which same use in Hindi too .
And nearly only 1/5th Muslims recognise themselves as a Urdu speakers .
And only 1/6 muslims can read and write Urdu .
south indian and bengali muslims don't even speak urdu they take pride in their mother tongue
I am bodo, Bangladeshi go back from northeast
Forget Hindi learn Sanskrit that is the language of our great great grand parents we have to revive it back
😂
you are right ❤
Sanskrit was last used in 1350s largely
but i dont want my community should take hindi. i prefer my state should use english where it necessary. i m from jharkhand.
No bro
Actually no one spoke Sanskrit in old times
It's just h lipi and nothing more than that
Hindi sab samajh sakta hai. Even Maharashtra, gujrat, bengal, assam me bhi hindi log samajhte hai. It helps in communication.
Why cant hindi people learn telugu and kannada as we learn hindi in our schools?
It really helps us unifying
And on the other hand tamils anyway doesnt try to learn hindi or other indian languages except english 😤😤😤
If south PPL cannot learn a common language y wud anyone learn others mother tongue.
@@nayakpaswan we learnt hindi ok
Sb state ka apna language h...agar tum dusri ko apna language sikhane ko bolte ho to tum bhi khud 22 language sikho 😊
@@queen-.-.???
@@nayakpaswando you speak any South Indian language? Any Kannada Telugu Tamil Marathi
में मराठी हु but मुझे बचपन से हिंदी आती है🚩🙏🕉️
I'm also Marathi I don't like chindi language 😊😊
@@PATHM-f2uतो अंग्रेजी भाषा से इतना प्रेम क्यों हैं 🤔
@@gautamgoswami2855 because English is modern language
Because it's modern language of world @@gautamgoswami2855
@@PATHM-f2uenglish is not modern language it's western language
Official language status is also nominal. De facto many other languages are also officially used.
eg. Marathi is the sole official language of Maharashtra. Not Hindi, not English. But in practice Govt. of Maharashtra and the various Municipal Corporations under it also utilise English, and to a lesser extent Hindi. In Ulhasnagar, all signboards are written in English and Sindhi (Persian script) because of the high Sindhi population there. Govt. also runs Kannada language schools in Kannada villages in Solapur and Kolhapur districts. It is the responsibility of the government to adapt to it citizens and provide services in their language.
Only the central government has shown some level of pigheadedness when it comes to langauge.
Please, Maharashtra govt is worse. They are forcing private establishments to put up signboards in Marathi. If you want to make language adaptable, you need to let businesses decide for themselves - they will only succeed if they put the language used commonly by that locals in that area. So whatever language they choose without force is automatically the correct one. In Mumbai they used English for so long, so clearly that was not a problem. But govt forced Marathi. They pretend Mumbai is not multiethnic and impose Marathi and Marathi nationalism constantly, with inflammatory historical claims
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
I think govt and public sector companies should Hindi more than English but less than local language. Indian language should be focused on first then a foreign language like English.
@@akhileshkannan8421 English is not a foreign language anymore, it's not French. It is a binding language to our country and even and a native tongue to few Indians - but across geographical distribution, so it is a very fair language to use.
@@akhileshkannan8421 Eradicating Hindi is the only way to stop this arrogannt Hindi imperialist.
I have never seen such a detailed video on languages. Kudos to your efforts. I am sharing this video everywhere. ❤️
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality and at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
I am from Jharkhand and i grew up speaking Santhali, Hindi and English and a little bit of Odia...and even though i can speak/understand all of these languages, only one gives me my identity and its the reason why i put it above rest even though Santhali, Hindi and English are all my mothertongue..and i would hate for anyone to impose Hindi as official language on me and my tribe becaus emy tribal language is already dying as it is and instead of saving it, it would essentially demolish learning the language by the newer generation
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
Im Kannadiga..I speak n ❤ Hindi..but I hate forceful imposition of Hindi..
Why do we use English in every field of India? *(Why do we need English)*
1) India is a *"multilingual"* country & we have a different language family's *(Indo-european, Dravidian, indo-iranian sino-tibetan, Tibeto-burman, Semitic, astro-asiatic Etc..)* & India has no _-national language-_ or any _-monolingual policy-_ the country of India is a *"union system'* and "all languages are respected equally"
2) Only English is recognized and used as the *"2nd administrative language"* in all states of India. (After their state's official language)
3) English is the only language used in all fields of India *(science, technology, research, education, medical, business, job field, information, space field, Navy, etc..)*
4) India is mostly dependent on *"foreign income"* & So we need English in the field of 'business' and 'workplace'
5) English is emerging as the future *"lingua franca"* of India and the World
6) English is *"indispensable"* today and giving more value to "English" after our "State language" is also good for our financial empowerment.
7) Yes there is a language problem in India! So English has grown and is growing as a language to solve that problem, This is the reality! It is better to accept reality. And at the same time all the languages of India should be respected equally.
@@dontbeafraidimhere5421 👌
Bhojpuri should be added to our 8th schedule of constitution. We feel proud in speaking Hindi but bhojpuri should get it's right and thus we can introduce our bhojpuri in educational forums ... Jai Bhojpuriya , Jai Bharat
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yes it should be.................even Bhojpuri poets like Mahendra misir had played a very special role in the Indian independence...........and was sent to buxor jail.....for almost 8 years...........and he has given most of the Bihari.....folk songs......like Bidesiya,chaita,thumri,kajri,sohar.............etc❤
Magahi kyun nhi??
To chhattisgarhi bhi add honi chahiye
आपको इतना सालो बाद याद आ रहा है, भोजपुरी भाषा को संगबिधान में जगह मिलना चाहिए???
Had the British just made both Devanagari and Nastaliq as official script for Hindustani. This Hindu Muslim Hindi Urdu problem wouldn't have occured . My mother tongue is Urdu but I learned Devanagari script with ease on my own . As Urdu and Hindi are technically recognised registers of hindustani and mutually intelligible, learning another script wasn't difficult
Now Hindi & Urdu speakers should address themselves as Hindustani speaker or Hindustani community.
@@homelesslavie_vlogs9600 agreed. Infact to this day many people in Pakistan (both native and non native Urdu speakers) use this term to address native Urdu speakers
@@msr7373 are you Pakistani?
@@WojtekTheBear2005 yes
@Anathasayanam Iyyengar Tamil was never a connecting language in India's history.
If any language that was a connecting language, it was Sanskrit.
मैं मिर्जापुर उत्तर प्रदेश से अवधी भाषी हूं भारत के सभी छोटी भाषाओं का संरक्षण होना चाहिए।
Are you living in a shell? Mirzapur is not a part of Awadh it's fall in the bottom of East UP. And it's a part of Bhojpuri region
@@ellerosee मिर्जापुर भले ही अवध का हिस्सा ना हो,लेकिन यहां भी प्रयागराज जौनपुर की तरह ही अवधि ही बोली जाती है। भोजपुरी का क्षेत्र वाराणसी से शुरू होता है। बाहर बैठकर आप यहां की भाषा को नहीं जान सकते इसके लिए आपको मिर्जापुर आना होगा
Everyone has every right to speak their own language and no language should be imposed forcefully on anyone, be it Hindi or any other.
I don’t want government support for Hindi.
Speaking shouldn't be forced but learning a common language for example Hindi and English should be forced. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@@AnUchiha no. If a person finds the economic need to learn another language, that person will learn it. Government has no role in it.
@@AnUchihastop Hindi imposition
@@VijayThakurMD Why?
The Grafic earth, India in pixels, soch by mohak - unique channel which deals with geography.
Glad You Compared Our Channel With Other Two Great Ones⭐...
Ashrish Sir and Mohak Sir are Inspiration For me as Well....❤️
Maine bhi apni local dialect or language bhul Chuka tha...kyuki main Bachpan se apni language sunta tha but bolta nanin tha... Ab kuch saalo se Maine bolna suru kar Diya hai... Now I am good in it.
Nagpuri bhasa from jharkhand.
Ye 3rd generation hai Hindi ka... Kyuki mere grandfather was a Hindi teacher. But mere father abhi bhi itne fluent nahin hai... Our president Dropadi murmu ka bhi accent AA jata hai..
Thanks for your response.
Both channels are great but not Mohak.