Batman: The Long Halloween (1997) - Comic Story Explained

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024

Комментарии • 142

  • @dannymalt
    @dannymalt  3 года назад +39

    In my research for this video I learned about Batgirl’s complicated retconning over the years. Pre-Frank Miller Batman Year One, Batgirl was James Gordon’s daughter, but because of Year One they changed things. So Barbara Gordon (James’ wife) was not the mother of Barbara Gordon (Batgirl). Batgirl was made to be the daughter of James Gordon’s brother, so she was James Gordon’s niece.
    Later we find out though that James Gordon banged his brothers wife, and he’s actually Batgirl’s father anyway. Eventually Batgirl’s parents die, so James Gordon adopts her. So in a roundabout way, they made her his daughter once again.
    In the New 52, they retconned all that complicated nonsense, and just made Batgirl the daughter of James and Barbara Gordon, and the brother of James Gordon Jr. without it being ultra convoluted.
    I was going to explain this all in the video, but didn’t want to waste 5 minutes on it.

    • @ElMarko6994
      @ElMarko6994 3 года назад +1

      It’s all good Danny, thanks for another great video. I’ve been excited for you to do this because this is my second favorite Batman comic next to Arkham asylum by grant Morrison. But again thanks Danny! We appreciate what you do every week!

    • @irvingramirez2335
      @irvingramirez2335 3 года назад

      Dude I was planning to re read the story and I just found this on my feed your a hero my guy 💯 also this book inspired the new Batman movie

    • @mellogic
      @mellogic 2 года назад

      well thats dc comics every since they created the crisis of infinte earths a way of rebooting and retconned there time lines

    • @SnakeRoadComicsOfficial3677
      @SnakeRoadComicsOfficial3677 9 месяцев назад

      Classic Frank Miller; Always making things so complicated.

  • @fitnessbearsmirnov17
    @fitnessbearsmirnov17 3 года назад +34

    Military exercise training in Moldova 🇲🇩 and still get to watch another great Danny Video!!!

  • @BlazingOwnager
    @BlazingOwnager 3 года назад +10

    *Batman and Gordon blow up tens of millions of dollars*
    Gotham's City Poor: "YOU AHOLES!"

  • @LauraTeAhoWhite
    @LauraTeAhoWhite 3 года назад +27

    *Batman:* Don't break the law
    *Also Batman:* Commits assault, trespasses, commits arson, commits theft and damages property

    • @seantaylor424
      @seantaylor424 2 года назад +1

      ...Yeah, but those guys were dumb anyway.

  • @bobkelsh8277
    @bobkelsh8277 3 года назад +13

    Ya know....this is one of those timeless stories...the whole trilogy really. Love it love it love it

  • @Nojo88
    @Nojo88 3 года назад +7

    Happy to see this one! Thanks Danny!

  • @Dotherightthing4ever
    @Dotherightthing4ever 3 года назад +6

    Like always Mr. Danny, very nice video, writing text as I am listening along . Once again very nice hardwork representation. Thank you for sharing

  • @mechaocean
    @mechaocean 3 года назад +5

    Was waiting all week for this! Thanks Danny, I haven’t read this one so this was a great listen.

  • @elitebrothers4256
    @elitebrothers4256 3 года назад +14

    Very interesting that Poison Ivy hypnotizes Batman it's not often Batman gets passive even less getting saved by someone. usually he just pull some bat-anti-hypnosis bullshit

    • @reniorjd
      @reniorjd 3 года назад +4

      Younger Batman so less prepared also a Batman that just beginning to deal with supervillains.

    • @BoricuaKelfa
      @BoricuaKelfa 7 месяцев назад +1

      it is Bruce second year as batman. he isn't going to be as prepared as most batman's.

  • @josephl7367
    @josephl7367 3 года назад +4

    Just want to say that I appreciate all the work you put into your videos

  • @kelvinkelvin6200
    @kelvinkelvin6200 3 года назад +4

    You know, I’ve seen this channel a few times. And never payed it any mind. But after your cover of sweet tooth, The American vampire and now THIS!!! I have to say I truly appreciate and enjoy your channel. Thank you. And keep up to good work.🤗

  • @Sam-ep2yo
    @Sam-ep2yo 3 года назад +3

    Great story to cover - and, if I may add, great voices, Danny! I especially liked your take on the Calendar Man and the Joker

  • @domgeek5632
    @domgeek5632 3 года назад +27

    If you ever do a DC story again three stories that would be amazing to see is Kingdom Come, DC The New Frontier, and All-Star Superman.

    • @fredrikgranstrom6743
      @fredrikgranstrom6743 3 года назад +1

      kingdom come for sure

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад +12

      Yup for sure, all classics that would be fun to do.

    • @domgeek5632
      @domgeek5632 3 года назад +1

      @@dannymalt yeah. Especially DC The New Frontier. When I think of superheroes in a real world. I honestly think of New Frontier. Since it doesn't do the same as Watchmen or The Boys or anything else. It's truly unique in how it approaches it's concept of superheroes in the real world.

    • @eddefy22
      @eddefy22 3 года назад +1

      Kingdom Come, great comic, love the art and the story. Damn Magog! Let Superman work.

    • @jmgonzales7701
      @jmgonzales7701 3 года назад

      nver got the hype of the new frontier

  • @josephvasquez9392
    @josephvasquez9392 3 года назад +7

    This is one of the best Batman stories ever I hope the movie does it justice

    • @ElMarko6994
      @ElMarko6994 3 года назад +2

      Me too bro, I hope they don’t mess it up like with the killing joke

    • @t.l3846
      @t.l3846 3 года назад +2

      @@ElMarko6994 or like hush

    • @ElMarko6994
      @ElMarko6994 3 года назад +4

      @@t.l3846 yea I forgot they fucked that up too lol. But the killing joke makes me mad, I skip half the movie to get to where the comic starts. That Batman/batgirl relationship rubbed me the wrong way

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад +4

      The Dark Knight Returns adaptation was decent thankfully.

    • @t.l3846
      @t.l3846 3 года назад +2

      @@dannymalt tbh i think it's one of the best batman films, peter weller nails the voice.

  • @lovetriiippy6634
    @lovetriiippy6634 3 года назад

    You're unappreciated danny, no cap you deserve to be at least 100k subs

  • @theunwantedcritic
    @theunwantedcritic 3 года назад

    I’m friends with Tim sale on Facebook. Very nice guy. And I’m glad to see that you didn’t quit your channel after the whole Invincible situation.

  • @210SAi
    @210SAi 3 года назад +5

    This came out in ‘97?!? I could have sworn it was a late 80s story (Pre Keaton Batman movie....)

  • @perfectblue8443
    @perfectblue8443 3 года назад +1

    That was awesome
    Your channel makes me want to read more comics!

  • @epicsnail4614
    @epicsnail4614 2 года назад

    I loved that you specifically used that phrasing during the New Years murder

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  2 года назад

      Lol. True. It’s subtle, unless you know the twist you won’t think anything by my phrasing.

  • @detective___mcnulty
    @detective___mcnulty 3 года назад

    Thanks for your hard work making all these videos.

  • @OscarHernandez-zt2cz
    @OscarHernandez-zt2cz 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for making my week every week Danny

  • @bryanramsey9129
    @bryanramsey9129 3 года назад

    Glad your still going bud. Love the content.

  • @SL-mf4ve
    @SL-mf4ve 3 года назад +1

    Danny, could you please cover Batman Dark Victory someday , its not as well know so it seems interesting to watch and learn about . Great Video

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад

      Yeah, one day ill try and go through all the classic Batman stuff.

  • @CactusJackIV
    @CactusJackIV 3 года назад

    Love the channel! Keep up the awesome work!! I also love that Batgirl having the same name as her mom is confusing, but Jim Gordon Jr. isn't.....haha

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад +1

      In my research I learned that apparently at the time, Barbara Gordon (the wife), is not the mother of Barbara Gordon (the daughter). Batgirl is the daughter of James Gordon’s brother.
      Later we find out though that James Gordon banged his brothers wife, and he’s actually Batgirls father anyway. Eventually Batgirls parents die so James adopts her. In the New 52, they retconned everything, and just made Batgirl the daughter of James and Barbara Gordon without it being ultra convoluted.

    • @CactusJackIV
      @CactusJackIV 3 года назад

      @@dannymalt You're research is top notch as always. Have to love retconning, it always makes things less confusing or more confusing.

  • @andrewlewandowski8419
    @andrewlewandowski8419 3 года назад +4

    The holiday killer has struck again....not striked. Still love the story!

  • @Be.colorFULL
    @Be.colorFULL 2 года назад

    Loving your channel. Not sure how this could possibly have an equal rating to the Sandman series (at least the first 2 volume episodes I've watched so far) but it's definitely a fun one.

  • @sethswint1396
    @sethswint1396 3 года назад +5

    I need to understand why Batman just leaves Solomon Grundy in the sewers ? 😂 like he can’t do any harm 😂

    • @clownroshi3566
      @clownroshi3566 3 года назад +4

      Because grundy lives there. As long as you dont go down there grundy won't mess with you.

  • @qawal12
    @qawal12 3 года назад

    Excellent job Danny!

  • @Enterprise1230
    @Enterprise1230 3 года назад

    Doing great man with these vids. Keep it up and been looking foward to this series

  • @Dentei3
    @Dentei3 2 года назад

    Amazing 👏 thank you
    Pls do Dark Victory!

  • @douglasarthur2673
    @douglasarthur2673 4 месяца назад

    Frank Miller "forgot' about Batgirl. Funny, same thing happened to David Zaslav 😂

  • @killerdoogz2019
    @killerdoogz2019 3 года назад

    One of the only comics I got to read when I was in youth challenge badass your covering it bro.

  • @Deathtroopers09
    @Deathtroopers09 3 года назад

    Holiday killer-calendar man.
    Pumpkin-scarecrow

  • @showrovislam4309
    @showrovislam4309 3 года назад +3

    Can't believe you're covering this. Thank a lot.

  • @doomguydemonkiller
    @doomguydemonkiller 3 года назад

    Thank you for this one Dannymalt. I hope the movie is just as good!
    Btw, what are your thoughts on the Hellboy comic? Thanks!

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад +1

      I liked some of the movies, but I never got around to the comics unfortunately. They seem pretty cool tho, I almost took the plunge a couple times and was going to try and read em all, but never pulled the trigger on it.
      One character I’ve started going through is Conan The Barbarian. At Dark Horse they have a whole 20+ volume run, that covers his entire life story, I’m halfway thru it.

    • @doomguydemonkiller
      @doomguydemonkiller 3 года назад

      @@dannymalt awesome! I heard the Hellboy comic is great and rich in lore, and it would be awesome if you could cover it. But whatever you choose to do next, I can't wait!

  • @danielcyprian8946
    @danielcyprian8946 3 года назад

    Great video

  • @cocobrez
    @cocobrez 3 года назад +1

    Another Great vedio!

  • @RawB242
    @RawB242 3 года назад

    thanks alot Dan!

  • @randallrona9618
    @randallrona9618 Год назад

    One of the main inspirations for Matt Reeves' The Batman(2022).

  • @detective___mcnulty
    @detective___mcnulty 3 года назад

    Can you do Dark Victory?

  • @darrylcatay2295
    @darrylcatay2295 3 года назад +1

    The cancelation of Jupiter's Legacy is confirmation that the Super Hero Trope is playing out !

  • @TheLeapluv
    @TheLeapluv 3 года назад +1

    I Didn’t expected, The ending twist. Literally coming form nowhere!

  • @sodapants3328
    @sodapants3328 3 года назад

    Best bat story for Halloween for my liking haunted seasons and a mobster story that’s anchored with the super genre to compliment the holiday fantasy :3

  • @way2tehdawn
    @way2tehdawn Год назад

    Just figured out Julian Gregory in Calandar man, wow I've known this character for years and it literally just dropped that his name is of two differenct calandars. I always used to focus on the "Day" part.

  • @TevyaSmolka
    @TevyaSmolka 3 года назад

    great review on the long Halloween

  • @sjbrooksy45
    @sjbrooksy45 3 года назад

    Joker hit that dude with some Joker pocket sand!

  • @robusttherezinated9311
    @robusttherezinated9311 3 года назад +9

    This story sounds a lot like the dark knight plots

    • @prami1178
      @prami1178 3 года назад +2

      The movie was based off this comic and a few others

  • @t.l3846
    @t.l3846 3 года назад +1

    Top 3 batman story right here.

  • @WilliamBrandonLeopardhtliven
    @WilliamBrandonLeopardhtliven 3 года назад

    Thanks Danny!!!

  • @MrScroogedmcduck
    @MrScroogedmcduck Год назад

    So Fun. Thank you !

  • @chasetheace9277
    @chasetheace9277 3 года назад +2

    You should definitely get to Batman: Dark Victory👌👌

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад +1

      One day I’ll do a tour of all the classic Batman stories.

  • @mike14987
    @mike14987 2 года назад

    Have you read Batman: Dark Victory, Batman: The Cult, Batman The Killing Joke, Batman new 52 series, Dark Night: Metal and Death Metal.

  • @cianbarrett6177
    @cianbarrett6177 3 года назад

    Very gripping story but nails definitely do not have individual serial numbers on them 😂

  • @ahmeterhan1824
    @ahmeterhan1824 3 года назад

    Can you make a video about batman death by design comic book

  • @kaidose
    @kaidose 3 года назад +2

    Wow. Loved this story. Interesting how the film differs from the comic.

  • @ahuav1206
    @ahuav1206 3 года назад +1

    Happy to watch this!

  • @yeez13
    @yeez13 3 месяца назад

    Easily the most enjoyable read I’ve had with a Batman book…even if it’s actually pretty terrible and the plot holes/contradictions make it worse upon reflection.
    This is the kind of book you can show people who don’t read comics and really hook them with their potential

  • @BlazingOwnager
    @BlazingOwnager 3 года назад

    I'm surprised by how much The Dark Knight took from this. I didn't realize this was the book that a lot of it came from.

  • @samsmith8724
    @samsmith8724 3 года назад

    Does ANYONE get Greg Turkington of On Cinema vibes from our beloved Danny?

  • @3DarknessX
    @3DarknessX 3 года назад

    Damn... that was a hell of a ride.

  • @bK0TT0Nd
    @bK0TT0Nd 3 года назад

    love batts extra long cape!!

  • @pixieg2572
    @pixieg2572 3 года назад +1

    Rerelease invincible just do it over time with lines blanked out :( miss it

    • @pixieg2572
      @pixieg2572 3 года назад

      I’m sorry if I’m being pushy. You just put your soul into invincible and I’m feeling the effects of not having it here over time. Plus everyone is making videos after the fact and I don’t like their videos ( rob explains) as if they are culturing your idea because it’s popular now.

  • @killmonger5097
    @killmonger5097 3 года назад

    Damn Batman Banging Catwoman and poison Ivy lol

  • @petechambers1511
    @petechambers1511 3 года назад

    Dark Victory next. Another great tale. Seems that Danny predicts what I have just read or have just spent a load of cash on buying then tells the story. Happened with Invincible then The Boys and same again with The Sandman. Going by this logic I predict that Danny will do Fables (one of the best stories ever) and Powers in the near future. There are just so many good stories out there and most of them are not DC or Marvel.

  • @glenng8787
    @glenng8787 3 года назад

    23:46 so Earth Day is not a new thing?

  • @partofthetribe3277
    @partofthetribe3277 3 года назад +1

    I get why he did this comic now but I am not happy about having to wait till another Sunday to continue with dream

  • @michaeleyjakowl5975
    @michaeleyjakowl5975 3 года назад +1

    I REALLY FVCKN LOVE THIS CHANNELLLLLL

  • @mellogic
    @mellogic 2 года назад

    well i understand about the so many villains but it was suppose to symbolize the change in power shift from the mob to the psycho super criminals thats in gotham and its change

  • @itsjay6655
    @itsjay6655 3 года назад +1

    GREAT STORY 👍

  • @joshsmith9572
    @joshsmith9572 2 года назад

    Or "Eescape" lol

  • @Quietstrife
    @Quietstrife 3 года назад

    Lmao thanks for telling me who James Jr is. Honestly have never hear of him.

  • @saipelekima5675
    @saipelekima5675 3 года назад

    Can you do superior by mark Miller

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад

      One day. I want to try and go through most of Millars indie books.

  • @Sentient.A.I.
    @Sentient.A.I. 3 года назад +1

    Lets just talk about how sofia falcone is as big as grundy lol.

  • @damaniqphillip2756
    @damaniqphillip2756 3 года назад

    Awesome

  • @fredrikgranstrom6743
    @fredrikgranstrom6743 3 года назад +1

    this is the only absoulte edition I got

  • @robquin1525
    @robquin1525 2 года назад

    Rip Tim Sale

  • @vonserlos
    @vonserlos 3 года назад

    Ohhhhh Danny Boy....

  • @ElMarko6994
    @ElMarko6994 3 года назад +2

    Once again another great video from Mr.Malt lol. Appreciate it Danny, I always try to reply since that bullshit happened to you a couple months ago just to show that there are those of us who appreciate the hell out of what you do and every week for us. Thank you Danny!!!

  • @TorridPrime217
    @TorridPrime217 3 года назад +1

    Shouldn't this have been posted in October?

    • @t.l3846
      @t.l3846 3 года назад

      Not really, the film is out june. The films shudda came out in October.

  • @menzemnem844
    @menzemnem844 3 года назад +1

    DC is the best ...thxs

  • @deterdetz
    @deterdetz 3 года назад

    You da man, Danny!

  • @otisbob2375
    @otisbob2375 3 года назад

    Yes batman

  • @sjbrooksy45
    @sjbrooksy45 3 года назад

    Wait... so one of the richest people in the world was arrested for something and they had virtually no evidence? That DA would definitely lose their job.

  • @rocknflip66
    @rocknflip66 2 года назад

    (SPOILERS)
    It’s true there is 3 holiday killers. but in no way they did not work together.
    let’s break it down
    gilda dent: her motivation was to spend time with her husband. and by that killing off johnny, the irish mob and falcones right hand man. sickening that she would be the first to start this shit show.
    alberto: after the killings gilda did, the falcone mob was enraged thinking it was the maroni’s. this theory is that alberto may be working with his father carmine. he faked his death to take himself out of the picture. and behind the scenes fooling everyone including his aunt and sister. carmine then gives the hit on his enemies the maroni mob. it’s also why alberto did not kill the riddler, because alberto knew he is working alongside his father carmine, and to give him a warning.
    harvey: after the maroni’s thinking these killings where from harvey, sal wanted his revenge and gave harvey the acid. he took it further and stole the evidence of previous holiday murders and get back at carmine and vernon.
    In conclusion, at first gilda, alberto and harvey did not work with each other. but afterwards guilda then realizes that harvey was apart of it due to the evidence stole and later throws to the fire at the end. gilda must and should feel like shit. she started this shit show.

  • @evos469
    @evos469 3 года назад

    DC could have fixed it easily and just say Gordon's son is older than Barbara.

    • @dannymalt
      @dannymalt  3 года назад +1

      In my research I learned that pre-Batman Year One Batgirl was James Gordon’s daughter, but because of Year One they changed things. Barbara Gordon (James’ wife) was not the mother of Barbara Gordon (the daughter). Batgirl was made to be the daughter of James Gordon’s brother.
      Later we find out though that James Gordon banged his brothers wife, and he’s actually Batgirl’s father anyway. Eventually Batgirl’s parents die so James adopts her. In the New 52, they retconned everything, and just made Batgirl the daughter of James and Barbara Gordon without it being ultra convoluted.

  • @haruruben
    @haruruben 2 года назад

    Nails do not now nor have they ever had Serbian numbers on them… maybe Bats was just bluffing to get the guy to cooperate

  • @kingsrefuge
    @kingsrefuge 3 года назад +1

    Aawwwwwweee Ya gotta say the WHOLE thing. I'm a little disappointed in you right now Ahem "Solomon Grundy,
    Born on a Monday,
    Christened on Tuesday,
    Married on Wednesday,
    Took ill on Thursday,
    Grew worse on Friday,
    Died on Saturday,
    Buried on Sunday,
    That was the end,
    Of Solomon Grundy

  • @byronschexnayder875
    @byronschexnayder875 2 месяца назад

    🔥💟🖤 AWESOME VIDEO 🖤💟🔥

  • @frocurl
    @frocurl 2 года назад

    April fools day was actually the joker!

  • @afnan9388
    @afnan9388 3 года назад

    Batman 🦇 ❤️

  • @fireflame62
    @fireflame62 3 года назад

    I went to alberto's wedding sadly his son got killed by Gordon.

  • @fishyfaceism
    @fishyfaceism 3 года назад

    Danny malt is the goat

  • @joshsmith9572
    @joshsmith9572 2 года назад

    Why can't you say "the"...."thee" doesn't land very well

  • @Iankill2121
    @Iankill2121 3 года назад

    Unbelievably based

  • @irvingramirez2335
    @irvingramirez2335 2 года назад

    Hope you post Batman ego

  • @Bmega81
    @Bmega81 3 года назад

    Damn du long Halloween don't get a ten nothing does. Lol

  • @andikalutfi2699
    @andikalutfi2699 3 года назад

    #Batmanlonghalloween

  • @jmtsull8048
    @jmtsull8048 2 года назад

    21:05

  • @anthonyfrias5533
    @anthonyfrias5533 2 года назад

    I just saw the movie

  • @Ando1428
    @Ando1428 2 года назад

    i meant tails