One big mistake mentioned by the professor: Government do not sell HDB at cost. Singaporeans pay for the land cost as well, which is about 50% of the price you pay for a HDB unit.
Omg yes! I'm so tired of people complaining. If they're not that happy, may be just leave???? don't stay, reap off all the benefits while complaining and bad-mouthing the place. Literally no where is perfect. It's all about your own priorities.
@@ebbyc1817 im talking about ppl who are not Singaporeans, coming here, reaping off benefits yet still complaining. Look, I'm lucky enough to have lived in many different places and everywhere has its pros and cons. I would really hate people coming to my country, living and getting benefits from it and then trash-talking it all the time.
@@cindyrose5w @cindyrose5w Trying to see it from your pov, I kind of get it, I felt when people complained about Brexit who happened to be immigrants to Britain, i.e. not citizens and unable to vote, who are you to tell the people from the country what they should and shouldn't do. The only thing I would push back on is the rhetoric of, people coming and "reaping benefits". Using the services where you are, while working and living there, is something we all do, wherever we are. It's not unique to being an immigrant. It's not like someone who wouldn't go to the doctor would suddenly go to the doctor, there. They would go to the doctor wherever they are. Or the opposite, if they don't go to the doctor where they were, they probably wouldn't go there either. Saying someone comes and reaps benefits is like saying, you come and you breathe, and then you complain, well they have to breathe. They would breathe anywhere they go. They are not breathing only because they are there. Say someone who couldn't get a job where they are, got a job there, so we call it a 'benefit' but they are also contributing, by working there, they are not just taking and not giving. It's a transaction. When they send their kids to school, they are paying to the school, either directly or indirectly. When they buy food, that goes towards the local economy. The people that are complaining aren't the ones that will come there with millions buy property and not do anything. Those people you wouldn't hear a sound from. No one who doesn't have to work is complaining, wherever they are.
@1:32 that is what I love most about about Singapore! It is EASY! One day I will visit Singapore!! Even in the U.S. there is bureaucracy that makes things take longer than it was to be.
Tell that to the local Singaporean who can't afford a HDB house. Elites like this Professor is different from the locals, Singapore government loves professors like these and other elites. So they pay these people 20k, 30k a month... and with that salary no one can be unhappy. Why don't you interview a local middle class or lower class professional or blue collar worker.
@@gohkr5062Please don't disgrace Singaporeans. You live within your means. Not happy with your pay? Do something about it. Hustle. Complaining will not solve anything.
And The Theatre Practice just down the road from SMU. All their shows have surtitles. So non Mandarin speakers can enjoy too. There is more than just SRT in Singapore.
There are more theatre to SRT. They may have renamed themselves to be Singapore Theatre Company (STC) BUT they are not the end all be all of Singapore Theatre scene. Explore The Necessary Stage, Checkpoint Theatre, Teatre Ekamatra (Malay theatre group but they have surtitles). 😂
I am surprised that the Belgian professor did not mention in his analysis of the Singapore economy that as non-PR foreigners comprise around 40% of the workforce, but do not enjoy any form of subsidy (be it education, health or housing), Singaporeans and PRs enjoy a massive indirect subsidy, which partly explains why they pay such low income taxes for comparatively good welfare. In most developed countries, legally resident foreigners qualify for at least some of the subsidised public goods. Even in HK, resident foreigners have access to the local healthcare and education system at no additional cost. In this sense, Singapore is more like the UAE rather than HK/Korea/Taiwan/Japan.
@@user-vt5ln7qq4j On the surface it sounds attractive to Singaporeans and PRs, right? However, it means that from a Singapore fiscal perspective, every foreign worker is much more of a net benefit fiscally than a citizen/PR. In other words, the higher the proportion of foreign workforce, the better for the Singapore govt finances. All residents (whether citizen/PR/foreigner) are subject to the same taxation rates and GST, but only citizens and PRs qualify for subsidies, pre-election vouchers and tax deductions. That is why the Singapore govt keeps pushing up the proportion of foreigners, despite most citizens objecting.......
The heavy subculture in Singapore is WORK. Strive for excellence. Nothing one does is ever good enough. Do more. Aim higher. Run faster. Maximize the time. Optimize the present. Result: strong on work-related relationship. Weak on personal relationship with spouse, children, very few close friends, if any. With the exception of ex-PM Goh Chok Tong who was very strong on EQ. We could feel his heart in the policies he implemented for the people. Ex-PM Lee Hsien Loong did a great job for Singaporeans & Singapore, too.
Singapore do have a strong cultural presence and activities that are totally different from western ones. Its also something that requires certain level of cultural knowledge, language knowledge and historical knowledge to enjoy those cultural arts whether it's a dance, painting, poetry, sports, theatre arts, stage performances, etc. Because these interviews (which are excellent) are between 2 non-Singaporeans or people who are foreigners, including Asian foreigners, naturally they are not aware of this part of the subcultures by ethnic groups' existence and are not predominately known and have a "high barrier of entry" to enjoy them.
Space wise, hdb maisonnette has the biggest floor space or find those jumbo flats (2x2bedroom flats but rare) but of course they’re not as big as a landed house. 😅 Added: he’s right about the local art scene, the recent censorship is an example. As for medical system, I think the govt adopted a “what u can afford” policy (medisave contributions and private insurance policies) rather than welfare system like the European countries, which I think it’s more sustainable in the long run. However, subsidies are there for various levels of SGreans based on income too.
That’s true! Everything works in Singapore. One thing that needs to be tackled is that lately the traffic is a bit chaotic with too many accidents , but apparently, it’s the same everywhere in the world. I believe, it has to do with the proliferation of bikes and delivery services
Another excellent interview with relevant questions and very insightful, substantial, factual and useful response information that is functionally applicable. Great job! And clearly with such great introspective charm and looks, professori clearly has the world 🌍 as his oyster. 😱👏👍😮😂👍🙏
The moment he mentioned the dancing at SMU, I knew exactly what he was talking about. There are quite a few dance groups among young people (mostly students) in Singapore, and the SMU underground is just a good free space they can practice at. It's lit up, the glass lets them see their moves, they can play music without disrupting people's peace at night, and it's spacious enough, so people just gather there. You'll sometimes see other things done that that require larger spaces like play rehearsals, music practice. Also, I'm sure he knows, but the idea of taking attendance for a university class is very course-dependent and I assume is particularly prevalent in SMU. Most STEM courses in the other universities are pretty similar to his experience in Europe where some students literally don't go for classes their entire undergraduate life.
@@cuclainne Generally rejected, unless there are exceptional circumstances, as was the case with LKY's grandson....Foreign kids can enrol in local schools, but this is subject to (a) passing the AEIS test; and (b) paying additional school fees; and (c) subject to a cap set by the MOE - anecdotally, only 20-30% of foreign students succeed in passing the AEIS. In any event many Westerners do not agree with the philosophy of the Singapore education system, and would not want to put their children through it.
My ex ang mo boss from Hungary is a PR, while his Indonesian wife who converted to citizen will be having his daughter enrolled into a local primary school next year. He downgraded from his condo to a 5r resale at the tengah area. Not many expat families are better in their financial planning.
Another race in Singapore is the Malay Singaporean. Not mainly Malaysians though many Malaysians work here or married to one. 😊 The Malays in Singapore are not necessarily Malaysians
I like how he said the result of lower taxes in Singapore is the lower state social support, i.e. full welfare state, which is intentional!! LKY was wise in realising that a free welfare system was unsustainable in the future because your country will eventually run out of money as it spends more than it earns... unless u r bloody rich with natural resources. I mean look at the lack of (or cut of) money for services now in U.K., France, etc. Furthermore, in a asian cultural context, a free handout runs a risk of creating a lazy workforce culture. And working hard for your worth is a sense of pride for asians. But Singapore is not totally without social support. Our system creates a balance where u need to help yourself 1st b4 getting help from the government. No one with no money will ever be turned away from medical care in Singapore. No one... but u must have exhausted all your personal resources 1st or else u will be depriving our country's resources for someone else. 😢
@@osirusj275 You can read more in the link below. Income earned - less than $20K, 0 tax - $30K, $200 tax - $40K, $550 tax www.iras.gov.sg/taxes/individual-income-tax/basics-of-individual-income-tax/tax-residency-and-tax-rates/individual-income-tax-rates
@@osirusj275 ok I know what u r saying; that we pay taxes n therefore am "entitled" to full welfare n pension benefits like other countries. But do u really think taxes collected in any country is ever enough to become a full welfare state? Even at 50%+? I don't really think so. Now i'm not an economics expert but we all (should) know that money don't grow on trees n nothing is for free. We will need more than just taxes for full welfare support... the economy, resources, investments, etc. all contribute to the treasury of the nation. That money is then used for services for the people; infrastructure, education, transportation, medical, etc. with some held for emergencies if possible (our reserves). How much is allocated depends on the govt. If u give/use too much for 1 area, u will need to deduct from somewhere else. Its a balancing act. U can't please everyone for everything. Now if your country is ULTRA rich like Saudi Arabia or Brunei, then everyone is Happy... until the money runs out n u can no longer sustain the welfare lifestyle u r used to. If the people don't understand this or the politicians fail to communicate this reality to the people, then u have protest, chaos n eventually the nation's collapse into poverty. So back to your question. Why if we pay taxes n we don't get what we want? It's because it's not only Your taxes paying for your welfare, it many many other people's money too. All of our money will be used to be pay for your welfare. And it may not be enough in the future unless the country continues to be prosperous. It's the same for individuals - we don't (usually) spent all our monthly salary once we get it. We keep some for savings/investments n another portion for spending. Only when we have exhausted our spending portion n there is no choice do we dare touch from our savings. The same should apply for countries as well... but many don't. So I guess for Singapore its like u depend on yourself 1st before u ask to use other peoples money. Spend within your means. Sorry for the long-winded comment. I'm sorry if I have offended anyone here, that was not my intend. Just sharing my outlook on the need for a nation's prudent spending. P.S. I DO wish for more social support too as it will benefit me n my family. Hopefully our situation improves in the future.
@@eseetoh It's much more than being about money and engage in a dog-eat-dog cycle of competition. Countless wars in Europe have taught the Europeans to form the EU and benefit from cooperation. Whereas in Singapore and Chinese society, we are taught to pitch ourselves against one another. There's probably 3-4 million PhDs in China, yet, Chinese economy is still stagnant and property market is causing financial turmoil among Chinese citizens. And even PhDs in China might not be able to get properly paid. Its not about being smart or hardworking. It's about how well your leadership is and how much your leaders care for its people.
I actually prefers Europe than SG. The life is more chill (shorter working hours, everyone chill by the river side eating and drinking after work or dancing along to music perform by buskers, etc), the weather is cooling, the air is also better (places slight away from the city), nice sceneries, able to travel to other European countries easily over the weekends via Eurail, etc.
I agree with what Simon said about the local arts scene and our lack of a distinct subculture because Singaporeans are more focused on amassing wealth rather than filling up the soul with creative, artistic pursuits.
Health care in Belgium to me is Top Quality especially in terms of human treatment. My sister in law was Belgian Flemish. She and my brother retired in Vietnam. After 5 years enjoying her time in a big villa by the ocean, she developed pancreatic cancer. Her diagnosis was done at the French Hospital in Saigon. The file was forwarded to Belgium. A doctor and a nurse flew to Vietnam and escorted her back to Brussels where she passed away a few months later. And the total cost is ZERO. i don’t think the US can take care of its citizen the same way in another 200 years. If you ever ended up in the emergency room here in California, their first question is Do you have insurance? Their Second question is May we have your insurance card? The American caste system is based on money and not determined by birth as in India.
As someone living in Belgium b4, what he said is the reason i left.. the medication is the result of illegal immigrate whom are so sick and no money to seek medical attention to move to belgium.. which is why the heavy tax.. VAT is 21% and Income tax is 55%
"Whether locals and foreigners are heavily separated in Singapore" ... shows Molly Malone's. Just walked by there the other day and thought I see more foreigners when I'm by boat quay in 15 mins then I see in weeks where I live
Healthcare system - when everything is free it is funded by taxpayers and is susceptible to abuse since it's free. Our govt hospitals are also quite heavily subsidised depending on your income level
Why Singapore 'does it'... Healthcare difference between Singaporeans/PRs and Foreigners... Singaporean and PRs have to serve Nation Service at age 18 for 2 to 2.5yrs... and then yearly for Reservist training up to 2 weeks yearly till they are 40-45....
35:20 I love it when people say "I think that is the meaning of life" and they talk about taking a year off, travelling, working in a bar, when they just graduated from college and masters and had no job experience. That means they have no money of their own and have the luxury of spending their parents money. If that is the meaning of live, being born rich, sure, I 100% agree, do that! Be born rich
That's a strange comment. I went to work in a bar because I needed money to survive. I got a loan to finance my studies and paid my own year of travel with money I earned working half time for 3.5 years of my first degree.
Just a reminder when comparing Singapore, 1st that Singapore is a country that is a size of city, therefore certain cultural developments might be restricted due to size. 2nd, Singapore is still very very young. We have yet gain the experience of long-term cultural development u see in other countries, despite our meteoric rise in 1 generation. Tks!!
@@limbehh8494 Hahaha another PAP WuMao Internet Battalion. You see, PAP supporters are always paid by tax money. If you love NS so much, please go and serve another 10 years. With your 10 years of service. You can replace 5 NSFs. Please also take only the recruit pay of $600 per month. The idea of a nation state requires an enemy, if there's no enemy, then there won't be a need for an army which collect taxes. That's why they always tell you this or that boogeyman is a threat and we need tax money to defend against the boogeyman. And for the case of Singapore, we didn't have enough money back in the early days, thus, our previous generation serving NS can only be paid with psychological pay. This psychological pay carries on till today where our NSFs are paid peanuts.
@limbehh8494 How much PAP pay you make this comment? Bloody paid off Internet Brigade! I have never heard my NS mates say that they love to serve NS. Everyone can't wait to SAF, Serve And Foff.
Of course better than Europe. Singapore doesn’t have people protesting in the streets week after week disturbing the peace of the country. Better than Europe is an understatement. It’s many times better than Europe without a doubt. I love to spend time in Singapore, as much as possible❤❤❤
Hi Max, the people you interviewed seemed to be ONLY from a certain segment of society from the higher Social Class whom are PRIVILEGED. Of course they would find Singapore “wonderful”. The only REAL reason they are here is probably the tax system on the wealthy seemed more palatable than the country they originated from. Get people from the lower WORKING CLASS and get different perspectives than the Rosy picture of Singapore which these interviewees are trying to paint!
Their lives in singapore are probably still better than they would have been at wherever they're from... or at least for whoever they're sending their salaries to back home. If other countries want singapore to look after their people they can try and negotiate for their country to become a colony of singapore.
@lunazero433 Yes, we have people where we live that send money back home. The difference being that only very few people here can afford to have full time nannies and house cleaners because we pay wages that are on par with everyone. Therefore, their lives are very similar to ours financially
We do have a vibrant local "theatre" culture for hundred of years at least. It is known as "Getai", during hungry ghost festival. Google it. We also have Thaipusam Kavadi type of trance dance, very entertaining. But all these are not your "European subculture".
People have commented Singapore is boring, lack cultural or artistic vibes like other cities such as London, Bangkok, Bogota as mentioned by the guest. I think most have been blinded by her success, forgotten that Singapore is still a very young city, not in the same league with centuries old cities. Flavours need time to emerge and evolve, and at least we have Singlish for starters.
most locals and even foreigners are too busy trying to make money, only do arty farty stuff once in a while, also even for a certain period in their lives. that was exactly what we did, now, just back from a long holiday in Europe, did not even bother to go for that stuff or even visiting museums or sites, it is like 20 years too late for us, instead, we find we like the parks and nature spots better. we like to be alone without too many people around. so different people different strokes. still, Singapore is too small, not enough critical mass for big arty farty stuff.
Wouldn't the difference in the income tax rates you mentioned (55% in EU n 22.5% in SG) account for at least some of the difference in social/health services? I really appreciate these interviews Max. Thank you for doing them. However, it does concern me that when your interviewees share their thoughts & perspectives, it is only part of the story, not the whole picture. What I mean by that is the difference you alluded to in this interview - expat v local experience is different. This is true across the world. But it is also true that your need for social & health services increased as you get older, that is, you are less able to engage in work and are therefore less able to afford these costs out of pocket. Anyhow, just my two cents on these X v Y comparisons.
2 dingen: - Belasting in België, dat is gewoon gelegaliseerde diefstal - Het volgende boek heeft me enorm geholpen bij het vertrouwen en bouwen op een team: Mathieu Weggeman, "Leidinggeven aan professionals? Niet doen!", Schiedam 2007.
What's WRONG in Singapore ? I'm gonna tell you.... Some people wear absolutely UNacceptable SOCKS color design ! 01:04 Who on Earth has that kind of taste ? Okay, maybe the Bits... Of course the Americans... and occasionally some Eastern European men 😂
It’s the very comfortable lifestyle that attracts the foreigners ,especially having a full time , live in helper, good salary ….. Wonder what will happen if there is a recession or economic downturn , will these foreigners forsake Singapore in droves ???
Yes it’s for the comfortable lifestyle , domestic helper, first class transport system , efficiency , etc When there is a recession , they run …., but citizens stay !
Singapore is interesting, for a shot while, then it gets a bit sterile and boring. It is a city state with not much else to explore beyond that and it is very expensive. Most people tend to travel out of Singapore if they want to live a little. SIngapore is quite good for rich people because the standards of living is high. Luxury apartments are nice, traffic is light because cars are ridiculously expensive, but there are no limits on the cars you can buy. Another thing to note is that you don't actually own your apartment for life! So it's worst than China. If you ask anyone if they prefer Singapore or Australia, even Singaporeans would pick Australia.
There are less fine arts and performing arts than Europe. Howver, there are K pops , J pops , Mando pop cultute / concerts here. The culture are different between different continents. There are many streets in Singapore with a mosque, chinese temple and a church or hindu temple within 100 metres.
Lots of Singaporeans are trying to run away, but if you have an expat position (for whatever reason), you can have many advantages while being exempted of the many disadvantages. I know foreign expats who love to live in Belgium, too. And mostly useless politicians and lobbyists. Sadly, Singapore is going down because the rest of the region is going up. Nowadays, you can be better in Bangkok or Hanoi. The Singapore education system lacks original out-of-the-box critical and creative thinking skills. It's too much a robotic workforce. So it won't last.
@oasislin4587 SG was taken as regional HQs for multinationals because of stability, an ant-like workforce, and the easily accessible boozing and whoring. Then came the port and openness to adopt technology. But what I'm saying is that the regional competition is getting stronger. SG will need to reinvent itself.
I was there last week and to live there would be great. My only problem is there just isn't enough day light. I starts getting dark around 5 to 530 in early September.
He is quite cocky and above the clouds. Does not sound he mix much with the locals. Yeah, things are easy and comfortable. Locals don't show especially in front of Caucasions expats. Silent and water runs deep.
SG been giving away job to malaysian, PRC that poilitic out local Singaprean big time, and take over! At least these Ang Mo talents come with added value, dont roll us over like our neighbour do. What talking you!
it's important to keep expats happy in Singapore. Look at what some cities did to their citizen and expat during covid , after the pandemic everyone leaves including big corporations . A big city takes decades to built , only a few years to destroy
Denmark has increasingly adopting hard stance or hard public opinions against refugee. And likewise the Belgium might follow that directions??? They used to provide very decent shelter or prospects for refugees seeking asylum, I guess not anymore.
So are our lifetime on earth.... and this "earth time lease" has no black and white, it can be taken away from us anytime without warning. I am grateful for what I have. 😊
Ah James, Since yr Brain has Calculated that the effect of 99 year Leasehold ownership IS the SAME as Renting, then why don't you take the easier Option & just Rent from the Landlord 🤑😉❓ It is Undoubted that since you're Strong in Math, the Financial Outcome is the same according to Wizard James 🤨‼️👏
Hi. We are Singapore eye, a Chinese media platform. We like this video of yours and would like to ask you if you can authorize this content for us. We will add Chinese subtitle into this video and convert this content into article by giving you credit. Thank you.
There is a poverty of theatre attendance in theatre, musical, and orchestral performance in Singapore largely because tickets are very unaffordable to the normal average citizens.
Can't expect Ah Lian, Ah Beng, Muthu, Siti and Ali in our HDB neighbourhoods to be appreciative of performing arts. I enjoy going to the theatres in Singapore and abroad because of my background....piano lessons when I was a kid, English literature at secondary and further education in England. Many with my background are living elsewhere. We are having too many newcomers from China and India replacing us. Mandarin is spoken everywhere now by those from Malaysia and PRC.
This channel seems to only focus on people who are rich and successful or those from the upper social class, this group of people tend to be rather right winged and pro-PAP. I'm sure if they interviewed people who are just ordinary citizens, the perspective will be very different.
I love the Arab countries as they were fair _ Iraq, UAE, Sultanate of Oman. Western offices are very disrespectful. Many people say the same. Very racist and disrespectful. Entitled colonialists. My husband spoke very highly of Russians too
After traveling to other countries, Singapore is really slow n inefficient. many things don't work due to many stupid restrictions. Things are so slow in Singapore that's why i migrated out of Singapore. Can't stand how slow things are in Singapore. Health care sucks n super inefficient. You can wait for months just to see a doctor. In Thailand I see a specialist immediately at an international hospital.
Seriously u want to talk about medical and education? Of course non citizens pay a high rate cos they are non citizens period. Where in the world would you find a place that it safe and progressive with such social harmony? not many I dare say. I mean if one still complains that Singapore is not good enough why stay.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
sorry about the socks
One big mistake mentioned by the professor: Government do not sell HDB at cost. Singaporeans pay for the land cost as well, which is about 50% of the price you pay for a HDB unit.
@@gohkr5062 In fact, Government sell HDBs (BTOs) below cost, with subsidies.
@@gohkr5062 I guess it is compared to private property land?
i like them
Thanks for highlighting the socks, which I overlooked initially.
Singapore is actually a great place to live in.No words can express it and the experience with almost everything is just awesome.Majulah Singapura.
This account belong to a PAP Internet Brigade.
As a Singaporean, i am very happy staying here. Dont complain la! Appreciate what we have. Welcome to SG.
Totally agree many respects 🇸🇬 from 🇬🇧
Omg yes! I'm so tired of people complaining. If they're not that happy, may be just leave???? don't stay, reap off all the benefits while complaining and bad-mouthing the place. Literally no where is perfect. It's all about your own priorities.
@@cindyrose5w You think Singaporeans should leave their own country?
Or you think every person who is not happy is not from Singapore?
@@ebbyc1817 im talking about ppl who are not Singaporeans, coming here, reaping off benefits yet still complaining. Look, I'm lucky enough to have lived in many different places and everywhere has its pros and cons. I would really hate people coming to my country, living and getting benefits from it and then trash-talking it all the time.
@@cindyrose5w @cindyrose5w Trying to see it from your pov, I kind of get it, I felt when people complained about Brexit who happened to be immigrants to Britain, i.e. not citizens and unable to vote, who are you to tell the people from the country what they should and shouldn't do.
The only thing I would push back on is the rhetoric of, people coming and "reaping benefits". Using the services where you are, while working and living there, is something we all do, wherever we are. It's not unique to being an immigrant. It's not like someone who wouldn't go to the doctor would suddenly go to the doctor, there. They would go to the doctor wherever they are. Or the opposite, if they don't go to the doctor where they were, they probably wouldn't go there either. Saying someone comes and reaps benefits is like saying, you come and you breathe, and then you complain, well they have to breathe. They would breathe anywhere they go. They are not breathing only because they are there.
Say someone who couldn't get a job where they are, got a job there, so we call it a 'benefit' but they are also contributing, by working there, they are not just taking and not giving. It's a transaction. When they send their kids to school, they are paying to the school, either directly or indirectly. When they buy food, that goes towards the local economy.
The people that are complaining aren't the ones that will come there with millions buy property and not do anything. Those people you wouldn't hear a sound from. No one who doesn't have to work is complaining, wherever they are.
Simon has attended a few of my Pilates classes. Lovely guy ! Nice to see him on here talking about Sg 🇸🇬
Intelligent guest. Singapore and smart people find each other because of matching values
@1:32 that is what I love most about about Singapore! It is EASY!
One day I will visit Singapore!!
Even in the U.S. there is bureaucracy that makes things take longer than it was to be.
The fact that he lived in Singapore for a decade and was able to deduce this much of Singapore's society is outstanding
Tell that to the local Singaporean who can't afford a HDB house. Elites like this Professor is different from the locals, Singapore government loves professors like these and other elites. So they pay these people 20k, 30k a month... and with that salary no one can be unhappy. Why don't you interview a local middle class or lower class professional or blue collar worker.
@@gohkr5062they would probably be boring, uninspiring with a negative outlook in life and have nothing of values to add besides complaining 😅
@@0o_KASHIII_o0 Half of them would have served in the Singapore military before. Singapore is just a playground for the rich.
@@gohkr5062there r lower income people everywhere in the world. Is that the their problem? 😅
@@gohkr5062Please don't disgrace Singaporeans. You live within your means.
Not happy with your pay? Do something about it. Hustle. Complaining will not solve anything.
Besides SRT, try Wildrice or Pangdemonium theatre ❤ I love the local productions
And The Theatre Practice just down the road from SMU. All their shows have surtitles. So non Mandarin speakers can enjoy too. There is more than just SRT in Singapore.
There are more theatre to SRT. They may have renamed themselves to be Singapore Theatre Company (STC) BUT they are not the end all be all of Singapore Theatre scene.
Explore The Necessary Stage, Checkpoint Theatre, Teatre Ekamatra (Malay theatre group but they have surtitles). 😂
I am surprised that the Belgian professor did not mention in his analysis of the Singapore economy that as non-PR foreigners comprise around 40% of the workforce, but do not enjoy any form of subsidy (be it education, health or housing), Singaporeans and PRs enjoy a massive indirect subsidy, which partly explains why they pay such low income taxes for comparatively good welfare. In most developed countries, legally resident foreigners qualify for at least some of the subsidised public goods. Even in HK, resident foreigners have access to the local healthcare and education system at no additional cost. In this sense, Singapore is more like the UAE rather than HK/Korea/Taiwan/Japan.
🎶 that's the way ah huh ah huh we like it ah huh ah huh 🎼
@@user-vt5ln7qq4j On the surface it sounds attractive to Singaporeans and PRs, right? However, it means that from a Singapore fiscal perspective, every foreign worker is much more of a net benefit fiscally than a citizen/PR. In other words, the higher the proportion of foreign workforce, the better for the Singapore govt finances. All residents (whether citizen/PR/foreigner) are subject to the same taxation rates and GST, but only citizens and PRs qualify for subsidies, pre-election vouchers and tax deductions. That is why the Singapore govt keeps pushing up the proportion of foreigners, despite most citizens objecting.......
Solid interview!
high quality interview. super
The heavy subculture in Singapore is WORK. Strive for excellence. Nothing one does is ever good enough. Do more. Aim higher. Run faster. Maximize the time. Optimize the present. Result: strong on work-related relationship. Weak on personal relationship with spouse, children, very few close friends, if any. With the exception of ex-PM Goh Chok Tong who was very strong on EQ. We could feel his heart in the policies he implemented for the people. Ex-PM Lee Hsien Loong did a great job for Singaporeans & Singapore, too.
Most work too hard till they are married to their job and divorced with their partners.
Singapore do have a strong cultural presence and activities that are totally different from western ones. Its also something that requires certain level of cultural knowledge, language knowledge and historical knowledge to enjoy those cultural arts whether it's a dance, painting, poetry, sports, theatre arts, stage performances, etc. Because these interviews (which are excellent) are between 2 non-Singaporeans or people who are foreigners, including Asian foreigners, naturally they are not aware of this part of the subcultures by ethnic groups' existence and are not predominately known and have a "high barrier of entry" to enjoy them.
That’s true. We are culturally rich.
very nice interview!!!
I love Singapore: would love to live there ❤
Space wise, hdb maisonnette has the biggest floor space or find those jumbo flats (2x2bedroom flats but rare) but of course they’re not as big as a landed house. 😅
Added: he’s right about the local art scene, the recent censorship is an example.
As for medical system, I think the govt adopted a “what u can afford” policy (medisave contributions and private insurance policies) rather than welfare system like the European countries, which I think it’s more sustainable in the long run. However, subsidies are there for various levels of SGreans based on income too.
Another great interview
Belgium is a very beautiful excellent quality of country.
That’s true! Everything works in Singapore. One thing that needs to be tackled is that lately the traffic is a bit chaotic with too many accidents , but apparently, it’s the same everywhere in the world. I believe, it has to do with the proliferation of bikes and delivery services
Glad he decided to stay here
There are many performances, art exhibitions, singing concerts just take nany expats didn't blend in or explore more
Another excellent interview with relevant questions and very insightful, substantial, factual and useful response information that is functionally applicable. Great job! And clearly with such great introspective charm and looks, professori clearly has the world 🌍 as his oyster. 😱👏👍😮😂👍🙏
The moment he mentioned the dancing at SMU, I knew exactly what he was talking about. There are quite a few dance groups among young people (mostly students) in Singapore, and the SMU underground is just a good free space they can practice at. It's lit up, the glass lets them see their moves, they can play music without disrupting people's peace at night, and it's spacious enough, so people just gather there. You'll sometimes see other things done that that require larger spaces like play rehearsals, music practice.
Also, I'm sure he knows, but the idea of taking attendance for a university class is very course-dependent and I assume is particularly prevalent in SMU. Most STEM courses in the other universities are pretty similar to his experience in Europe where some students literally don't go for classes their entire undergraduate life.
His kids do not integrate with local kids, because local kids are not allowed to enrol in international schools. This is Singaporean law....
I thought this is subject to MOE's approval?
@@cuclainne Generally rejected, unless there are exceptional circumstances, as was the case with LKY's grandson....Foreign kids can enrol in local schools, but this is subject to (a) passing the AEIS test; and (b) paying additional school fees; and (c) subject to a cap set by the MOE - anecdotally, only 20-30% of foreign students succeed in passing the AEIS. In any event many Westerners do not agree with the philosophy of the Singapore education system, and would not want to put their children through it.
My ex ang mo boss from Hungary is a PR, while his Indonesian wife who converted to citizen will be having his daughter enrolled into a local primary school next year. He downgraded from his condo to a 5r resale at the tengah area. Not many expat families are better in their financial planning.
Another race in Singapore is the Malay Singaporean. Not mainly Malaysians though many Malaysians work here or married to one. 😊 The Malays in Singapore are not necessarily Malaysians
In 1998, house prices came off 50%. Properties as an asset is not as safe as you think.
The problems in Belgium aren't going to disappear unless you work on them.
By stopping the islamification and import of foreign crime, terrorism and parasitism
I like how he said the result of lower taxes in Singapore is the lower state social support, i.e. full welfare state, which is intentional!!
LKY was wise in realising that a free welfare system was unsustainable in the future because your country will eventually run out of money as it spends more than it earns... unless u r bloody rich with natural resources. I mean look at the lack of (or cut of) money for services now in U.K., France, etc.
Furthermore, in a asian cultural context, a free handout runs a risk of creating a lazy workforce culture. And working hard for your worth is a sense of pride for asians.
But Singapore is not totally without social support. Our system creates a balance where u need to help yourself 1st b4 getting help from the government. No one with no money will ever be turned away from medical care in Singapore. No one... but u must have exhausted all your personal resources 1st or else u will be depriving our country's resources for someone else. 😢
dint you pay tax as well? if yes then why cant you get help first but need to exhaust your own resources before getting help?
NS for Singaporeans, jobs and scholarships for foreigners. So is HDB public housing for profit? If not, why tax so much for public housing?
@@osirusj275
You can read more in the link below.
Income earned
- less than $20K, 0 tax
- $30K, $200 tax
- $40K, $550 tax
www.iras.gov.sg/taxes/individual-income-tax/basics-of-individual-income-tax/tax-residency-and-tax-rates/individual-income-tax-rates
@@osirusj275 ok I know what u r saying; that we pay taxes n therefore am "entitled" to full welfare n pension benefits like other countries.
But do u really think taxes collected in any country is ever enough to become a full welfare state? Even at 50%+? I don't really think so.
Now i'm not an economics expert but we all (should) know that money don't grow on trees n nothing is for free. We will need more than just taxes for full welfare support... the economy, resources, investments, etc. all contribute to the treasury of the nation. That money is then used for services for the people; infrastructure, education, transportation, medical, etc. with some held for emergencies if possible (our reserves). How much is allocated depends on the govt. If u give/use too much for 1 area, u will need to deduct from somewhere else. Its a balancing act. U can't please everyone for everything.
Now if your country is ULTRA rich like Saudi Arabia or Brunei, then everyone is Happy... until the money runs out n u can no longer sustain the welfare lifestyle u r used to. If the people don't understand this or the politicians fail to communicate this reality to the people, then u have protest, chaos n eventually the nation's collapse into poverty.
So back to your question. Why if we pay taxes n we don't get what we want? It's because it's not only Your taxes paying for your welfare, it many many other people's money too. All of our money will be used to be pay for your welfare. And it may not be enough in the future unless the country continues to be prosperous.
It's the same for individuals - we don't (usually) spent all our monthly salary once we get it. We keep some for savings/investments n another portion for spending. Only when we have exhausted our spending portion n there is no choice do we dare touch from our savings. The same should apply for countries as well... but many don't.
So I guess for Singapore its like u depend on yourself 1st before u ask to use other peoples money.
Spend within your means.
Sorry for the long-winded comment. I'm sorry if I have offended anyone here, that was not my intend. Just sharing my outlook on the need for a nation's prudent spending.
P.S. I DO wish for more social support too as it will benefit me n my family. Hopefully our situation improves in the future.
@@eseetoh It's much more than being about money and engage in a dog-eat-dog cycle of competition. Countless wars in Europe have taught the Europeans to form the EU and benefit from cooperation. Whereas in Singapore and Chinese society, we are taught to pitch ourselves against one another. There's probably 3-4 million PhDs in China, yet, Chinese economy is still stagnant and property market is causing financial turmoil among Chinese citizens. And even PhDs in China might not be able to get properly paid. Its not about being smart or hardworking. It's about how well your leadership is and how much your leaders care for its people.
I actually prefers Europe than SG. The life is more chill (shorter working hours, everyone chill by the river side eating and drinking after work or dancing along to music perform by buskers, etc), the weather is cooling, the air is also better (places slight away from the city), nice sceneries, able to travel to other European countries easily over the weekends via Eurail, etc.
Good role model!
Many foreign expats chose Singapore for their family and kids to live in. I met a gentleman from Denmark who lived here for 21 years and counting.
❤❤❤❤❤. Singapore.
I agree with what Simon said about the local arts scene and our lack of a distinct subculture because Singaporeans are more focused on amassing wealth rather than filling up the soul with creative, artistic pursuits.
We only want the good ones.
"The host made me take off my shoes before he would let me go to his patio." No doubt the Belgium professor has been sufficiently localized already.
You know that there are foreigners who are also shoes-off at home 😅
Health care in Belgium to me is Top Quality especially in terms of human treatment. My sister in law was Belgian Flemish. She and my brother retired in Vietnam. After 5 years enjoying her time in a big villa by the ocean, she developed pancreatic cancer. Her diagnosis was done at the French Hospital in Saigon. The file was forwarded to Belgium. A doctor and a nurse flew to Vietnam and escorted her back to Brussels where she passed away a few months later. And the total cost is ZERO. i don’t think the US can take care of its citizen the same way in another 200 years. If you ever ended up in the emergency room here in California, their first question is Do you have insurance? Their Second question is May we have your insurance card? The American caste system is based on money and not determined by birth as in India.
As someone living in Belgium b4, what he said is the reason i left.. the medication is the result of illegal immigrate whom are so sick and no money to seek medical attention to move to belgium.. which is why the heavy tax.. VAT is 21% and Income tax is 55%
Think this is the expat n fam,when they went back 2his home country(they even brought)their help with them❤
Actually singapire has a lot of good points compared to other countries when we travel. Only bad part is the high living cost (housing one of course)
Smart guy
"Whether locals and foreigners are heavily separated in Singapore" ... shows Molly Malone's. Just walked by there the other day and thought I see more foreigners when I'm by boat quay in 15 mins then I see in weeks where I live
I see Malaysian, PRC in our heartland and all over SG as seem they now own us and yet complaing so much, so how?
Nice interview
Healthcare system - when everything is free it is funded by taxpayers and is susceptible to abuse since it's free.
Our govt hospitals are also quite heavily subsidised depending on your income level
Hello from Bucharest, Romania - a huge underrated city in Europe:)
Why Singapore 'does it'... Healthcare difference between Singaporeans/PRs and Foreigners... Singaporean and PRs have to serve Nation Service at age 18 for 2 to 2.5yrs... and then yearly for Reservist training up to 2 weeks yearly till they are 40-45....
❤❤❤happy that he chose to join the small SG family🫶🫶🫶
35:20 I love it when people say "I think that is the meaning of life" and they talk about taking a year off, travelling, working in a bar, when they just graduated from college and masters and had no job experience. That means they have no money of their own and have the luxury of spending their parents money. If that is the meaning of live, being born rich, sure, I 100% agree, do that! Be born rich
Never take advice from people that lived on easy (or rather, easier) mode
That's a strange comment. I went to work in a bar because I needed money to survive. I got a loan to finance my studies and paid my own year of travel with money I earned working half time for 3.5 years of my first degree.
Just a reminder when comparing Singapore, 1st that Singapore is a country that is a size of city, therefore certain cultural developments might be restricted due to size.
2nd, Singapore is still very very young. We have yet gain the experience of long-term cultural development u see in other countries, despite our meteoric rise in 1 generation. Tks!!
Singapore Private Limited. NS for Singaporeans, jobs and scholarships for foreigners.
I am a male Singaporean... NS is fine with me because nobody going to protect us except ourselves. Dat simply.
@@limbehh8494 Hahaha another PAP WuMao Internet Battalion. You see, PAP supporters are always paid by tax money. If you love NS so much, please go and serve another 10 years. With your 10 years of service. You can replace 5 NSFs. Please also take only the recruit pay of $600 per month. The idea of a nation state requires an enemy, if there's no enemy, then there won't be a need for an army which collect taxes. That's why they always tell you this or that boogeyman is a threat and we need tax money to defend against the boogeyman. And for the case of Singapore, we didn't have enough money back in the early days, thus, our previous generation serving NS can only be paid with psychological pay. This psychological pay carries on till today where our NSFs are paid peanuts.
@limbehh8494 How much PAP pay you make this comment? Bloody paid off Internet Brigade! I have never heard my NS mates say that they love to serve NS. Everyone can't wait to SAF, Serve And Foff.
@gohkr5062 oh really... those are sissy ya Then leave Singapore. Lol
Of course better than Europe. Singapore doesn’t have people protesting in the streets week after week disturbing the peace of the country. Better than Europe is an understatement. It’s many times better than Europe without a doubt. I love to spend time in Singapore, as much as possible❤❤❤
I feel like sg is like for the super smart people either in finance or tech
Hi Max, the people you interviewed seemed to be ONLY from a certain segment of society from the higher Social Class whom are PRIVILEGED.
Of course they would find Singapore “wonderful”. The only REAL reason they are here is probably the tax system on the wealthy seemed more palatable than the country they originated from.
Get people from the lower WORKING CLASS and get different perspectives than the Rosy picture of Singapore which these interviewees are trying to paint!
that's very true...
How do you get these smart people
I guess life is great if you are the fortunate ones to have these cleaners and babysitters. I would think their lives are quite different.
Their lives in singapore are probably still better than they would have been at wherever they're from... or at least for whoever they're sending their salaries to back home.
If other countries want singapore to look after their people they can try and negotiate for their country to become a colony of singapore.
@lunazero433 Yes, we have people where we live that send money back home. The difference being that only very few people here can afford to have full time nannies and house cleaners because we pay wages that are on par with everyone. Therefore, their lives are very similar to ours financially
We do have a vibrant local "theatre" culture for hundred of years at least. It is known as "Getai", during hungry ghost festival. Google it. We also have Thaipusam Kavadi type of trance dance, very entertaining. But all these are not your "European subculture".
People have commented Singapore is boring, lack cultural or artistic vibes like other cities such as London, Bangkok, Bogota as mentioned by the guest.
I think most have been blinded by her success, forgotten that Singapore is still a very young city, not in the same league with centuries old cities.
Flavours need time to emerge and evolve, and at least we have Singlish for starters.
Love your socks!
most locals and even foreigners are too busy trying to make money, only do arty farty stuff once in a while, also even for a certain period in their lives. that was exactly what we did, now, just back from a long holiday in Europe, did not even bother to go for that stuff or even visiting museums or sites, it is like 20 years too late for us, instead, we find we like the parks and nature spots better. we like to be alone without too many people around. so different people different strokes. still, Singapore is too small, not enough critical mass for big arty farty stuff.
What the pay of his job??
Wouldn't the difference in the income tax rates you mentioned (55% in EU n 22.5% in SG) account for at least some of the difference in social/health services?
I really appreciate these interviews Max. Thank you for doing them. However, it does concern me that when your interviewees share their thoughts & perspectives, it is only part of the story, not the whole picture. What I mean by that is the difference you alluded to in this interview - expat v local experience is different. This is true across the world. But it is also true that your need for social & health services increased as you get older, that is, you are less able to engage in work and are therefore less able to afford these costs out of pocket.
Anyhow, just my two cents on these X v Y comparisons.
2 dingen:
- Belasting in België, dat is gewoon gelegaliseerde diefstal
- Het volgende boek heeft me enorm geholpen bij het vertrouwen en bouwen op een team: Mathieu Weggeman, "Leidinggeven aan professionals? Niet doen!", Schiedam 2007.
So, did he serve the National Service?
why would he?... he is an expat for 10 years here and it has nothing to do with NS
What's WRONG in Singapore ?
I'm gonna tell you.... Some people wear absolutely UNacceptable SOCKS color design ! 01:04
Who on Earth has that kind of taste ? Okay, maybe the Bits... Of course the Americans... and occasionally some Eastern European men 😂
It’s the very comfortable lifestyle that attracts the foreigners ,especially having a full time , live in helper, good salary …..
Wonder what will happen if there is a recession or economic downturn , will these foreigners forsake Singapore in droves ???
I mean if you lose your job on an employment pass, don't you kind of have to leave
Luckily I'm a PR !
Yes it’s for the comfortable lifestyle , domestic helper, first class transport system , efficiency , etc
When there is a recession , they run …., but citizens stay !
Singapore is interesting, for a shot while, then it gets a bit sterile and boring. It is a city state with not much else to explore beyond that and it is very expensive. Most people tend to travel out of Singapore if they want to live a little. SIngapore is quite good for rich people because the standards of living is high. Luxury apartments are nice, traffic is light because cars are ridiculously expensive, but there are no limits on the cars you can buy. Another thing to note is that you don't actually own your apartment for life! So it's worst than China. If you ask anyone if they prefer Singapore or Australia, even Singaporeans would pick Australia.
There are less fine arts and performing arts than Europe. Howver, there are K pops , J pops , Mando pop cultute / concerts here. The culture are different between different continents.
There are many streets in Singapore with a mosque, chinese temple and a church or hindu temple within 100 metres.
Lots of Singaporeans are trying to run away, but if you have an expat position (for whatever reason), you can have many advantages while being exempted of the many disadvantages.
I know foreign expats who love to live in Belgium, too. And mostly useless politicians and lobbyists.
Sadly, Singapore is going down because the rest of the region is going up. Nowadays, you can be better in Bangkok or Hanoi.
The Singapore education system lacks original out-of-the-box critical and creative thinking skills. It's too much a robotic workforce. So it won't last.
Dude, speak only for yourself...
@oasislin4587 SG was taken as regional HQs for multinationals because of stability, an ant-like workforce, and the easily accessible boozing and whoring.
Then came the port and openness to adopt technology.
But what I'm saying is that the regional competition is getting stronger. SG will need to reinvent itself.
Have you heard of this Chinese saying ? A needle cannot be sharp at both ends.
No way Singapore is better than Belgium to live in.........
It is
Oh some adults definitely didn't unlearn the running up and down part lol
After saying so much has he converted singapore citizenship and gave up belgium citizenship? If not then it is all superficial talk.
I was there last week and to live there would be great. My only problem is there just isn't enough day light. I starts getting dark around 5 to 530 in early September.
night starts daily, all the year around, at 7pm until 6 to 7 am
Technically Singaporeans don't actually "own" the HDBs, they are leases which must be returned to the government after a certain number of years.
He is quite cocky and above the clouds. Does not sound he mix much with the locals. Yeah, things are easy and comfortable. Locals don't show especially in front of Caucasions expats. Silent and water runs deep.
Sounds like he is the artsy fartsy type and needs it to be happy.
Everything great when you are rich
The 'give us your credit card first' sounds very much like raffles hospital
Sad that Singapore is giving away jobs to foreigners. Glad they imposed the minimum hire for locals in all companies.
Sad that Singaporeans take jobs abroad
SG been giving away job to malaysian, PRC that poilitic out local Singaprean big time, and take over! At least these Ang Mo talents come with added value, dont roll us over like our neighbour do. What talking you!
Look at it from another perspective, everything is on the table for the taking, who wants it bad enough to move fastest to take it?
it's important to keep expats happy in Singapore. Look at what some cities did to their citizen and expat during covid , after the pandemic everyone leaves including big corporations . A big city takes decades to built , only a few years to destroy
Denmark has increasingly adopting hard stance or hard public opinions against refugee. And likewise the Belgium might follow that directions??? They used to provide very decent shelter or prospects for refugees seeking asylum, I guess not anymore.
Nice socks, Pipi.
Soooo.... are we just not gonna talk about those socks? 😂😂😂
Technically most Singaporeans don't own their house, it's long term lease.
No. We own our house for our lifetime, unless your life is longer than 120 years old, when you own a house from 21 years old.
@@muigeokou892whatever you call it to make you happy, but it is leasehold 99 years.
So are our lifetime on earth.... and this "earth time lease" has no black and white, it can be taken away from us anytime without warning. I am grateful for what I have. 😊
Technically our life belongs to God how long you live only Gods know
Ah James, Since yr Brain has Calculated that the effect of 99 year Leasehold ownership IS the SAME as Renting, then why don't you take the easier Option & just Rent from the Landlord 🤑😉❓
It is Undoubted that since you're Strong in Math, the Financial Outcome is the same according to Wizard James 🤨‼️👏
wow, the local who exist the building still wearing mask? is it take recently?
It's quite backwards zombie like. Critical thinking zero.
I see people still wearing masks even today....
Singapore is far better thsn any country to live if u can.overlook politics snd cost then it's ok
He is so hot
Hi. We are Singapore eye, a Chinese media platform. We like this video of yours and would like to ask you if you can authorize this content for us. We will add Chinese subtitle into this video and convert this content into article by giving you credit. Thank you.
There is a poverty of theatre attendance in theatre, musical, and orchestral performance in Singapore largely because tickets are very unaffordable to the normal average citizens.
Can't expect Ah Lian, Ah Beng, Muthu, Siti and Ali in our HDB neighbourhoods to be appreciative of performing arts. I enjoy going to the theatres in Singapore and abroad because of my background....piano lessons when I was a kid, English literature at secondary and further education in England. Many with my background are living elsewhere. We are having too many newcomers from China and India replacing us. Mandarin is spoken everywhere now by those from Malaysia and PRC.
This channel seems to only focus on people who are rich and successful or those from the upper social class, this group of people tend to be rather right winged and pro-PAP. I'm sure if they interviewed people who are just ordinary citizens, the perspective will be very different.
70% of the people voted for the PAP so what are u talking about?
Correction : GIC does not invest in Singapore nor Singapore companies to avoid creating inflationary pressures in the country. Temasek does.
Hmmm, why not interview Singaporeans who have left Singapore for good?😊
Living in Singapore and with the Agenda 2030 pin... I the t shirt 😅😅😂 very awkward
Body language shows no honesty in his words.
How about getting a local pay package?🤣
You can't just decide to move there though.
He proudly displays his WEF badge. 🤨- be careful with this guy.
I thought its World Cup..Belgium vs Singapore
I'm immortal 😂😂
I love the Arab countries as they were fair _ Iraq, UAE, Sultanate of Oman. Western offices are very disrespectful. Many people say the same. Very racist and disrespectful. Entitled colonialists. My husband spoke very highly of Russians too
After traveling to other countries, Singapore is really slow n inefficient. many things don't work due to many stupid restrictions. Things are so slow in Singapore that's why i migrated out of Singapore. Can't stand how slow things are in Singapore. Health care sucks n super inefficient. You can wait for months just to see a doctor. In Thailand I see a specialist immediately at an international hospital.
Renowned professor?
Seriously u want to talk about medical and education? Of course non citizens pay a high rate cos they are non citizens period. Where in the world would you find a place that it safe and progressive with such social harmony? not many I dare say. I mean if one still complains that Singapore is not good enough why stay.