ANALOG DELAY COMPARISON: BOSS DM-2W vs MXR Carbon Copy vs Ibanez Analog Delay Mini
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 мар 2017
- Three famous analog delays; The upgraded version of the Boss DM-2, the DM-2W Waza Craft edition, the MXR Carbon Copy and the newer version of the Ibanez AD-9, the Ibanez Analog Delay Mini. Hear the difference between them all. Let us know what you guys think!
Shop online:
Ibanez ADMINI Analog Delay Mini Pedal
www.musicbliss.com.my/guitar-...
Dunlop MXR M169 Carbon Copy Analog Delay Pedal
www.musicbliss.com.my/dunlop-...
Boss DM-2W(DELAY WAZA)
www.musicbliss.com.my/boss-dm...
Equipment Used:
Orange Dark Terror
Orange PPC212 w Celestion Vintage 30 Speakers
Fender Japan Stratocaster with Texas Special Pickups
MXR DC brick Power Supply
Shure SM57
Audio Technica AT2035
Audient ID14
Our vision is to be the special boutique shop that sells Professional and Branded equipment, gears that are easily available to our target market. We have intend to form good relationship with suppliers to get all equipment that are high in quality as well as being able to satisfy their musical needs.“Bliss” represents excitement, in which we hope that every customer that walks in or have any relation with us to constantly surprise and excite them with products that are in value.We believe music is a language everyone, can connect and build relationship with. Most importantly, we sell products that are genuine and are against counterfeit products.
Music Bliss Petaling Jaya HQ
No19-1, Jalan SM10,
Taman Sri Manja, PJS 3,
46000, Petaling Jaya,
Selangor Darul Ehsan
Malaysia
Tel: 03-77813596
H/P: 016-3111286
Operation Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 10am-8pm
Friday- Sunday: 10am-7pm
Website: www.musicbliss.com.my 
Видеоклипы
Hellllooooo everyone! We're moving most of our English language content with our host over to a new channel!
Do show some love & subscribe! Link right here:
www.youtube.com/@rhythmNbeard
Cheers!
- Dave
A fantastic review and true side by side comparison, in different tonal scenarios. Very helpful.
Beautiful playing man, what a great demo video.
Lovely playing man, thank you!
Fantastic demo---really well done, thank you.
Your playing here really moved me 💕
good job man. Thanks for the excellent review
Boss has something special to my ear ! !! This demo is absolutly brillant !!!!!!!!!!
This demo is the world-best.
Another great video man. Keep it up.
This was great, thanks!
Excellent demo, thanks.
Your playing is beautiful, great job!
Great job as usual.
Carbon copy always warms my heart.
Very good and helpful video!
Love the Boss DM-2w!
Always liked the Ibanez's clarity for an analog pedal. The long maximum delay time is great too. If you want a super dark delay to sit way back from the guitar, the other two are better picks. But for me, I like using a delay with some clarity so I can play off of it. Ibanez all day.
Love your playing. Great taste test. I have Flashback. The Boss wins for me.
I really like the modulation of the Carbon Copy, but I also like the lack of it in the DM-2w.
My favorite analog delay pedal was the 80s era Pearl AD-08 Analog Delay
Very helpful. Thank you.
Great review, and thank you! Just subscribed
Folks, this is how a pedal review demo video should be done. Great work bro
Thank you for your kind words!
Great demo. I think the MXR Carbon copy was the best of the three.
I really liked the Carbon Copy and the Boss at higher gain. The Ibanez Mini is great for the money but I feel like the repeats sound too busy and your dry signal gets lost in the mix.
Dude's likable.
It helps. Thanks.
Perfect comparison, many thanks:-) I like the DM2 for it´s the only one with expression pedal input for RATE, the repeats are cleaner and it´s old and new in one compact Boss package. Ibanez is the cheapest one and the CC has the modulation, but also sounds more mid-rangey..
Brilliant.
dalam banyak2 video demo ibanez admini, yang ni paling best.
I like all 3, the dm2w wins though! but if size and cost cost is an issue then the ibanez is a great option
Great great review. Because it sounds pretty good and its the cheaper, I am going to buy an Ibanez delay!
All sounded identical to me. I stayed for the beautiful music though.
oim a fan of the ibanez. your playing also seems more inspired when that ones on. maybe you like it the most too ;)
I do own one myself, so yeah....haha
Thanks for showing me my old Ibanez analogue delay is available again. Back in the day it was so much a part of my sound I used to complain about that, "The Edge" fellow nicking my sound. I love its "dirty" textured sound and response to the nuance of pick or picking pressure. I'm off to to Thomann for mine right now. Whatever happened to the original? No idea. Those were the days. 8-)
Quick follow up now I have have the pedal and have had a chance to use it - It does indeed re-create my old sound, there is nothing like its textured aura around a note. I do however miss the bigger knobs on the repeat and blend and since there's no marker for the centre setting on these small dials I will be painting a fluorescent line on both even though I tend to keep the same setting for a gig I like to know where it is for a quick set up or in case the pedal gets kicked.
I got one of those in a old pedalboard that I got for $300. It was the 18-volt version and I got more than $300 for that pedal alone, not to mention the logo on top cry baby from 67 or so, Boss T-wah, Arion Delay, mxr compressor, valley arts handmade fuzz face.... Just a wealth of great old pedals.
The beauty of the boss is it turns off and on silently
Really good playing and good compare. I’m about to return my Ibanez mini analog delay this week. Too bad. It’s almost there. Sound really good here though no doubt. I’m using mine with a synth so different application.
For me, Ibanez wins. Nice midrange presence and not as cluttered as the CC. Boss is also quite nice but in the price-performance ratio behind Ibanez. CC I personally find the worst.
Guitars pedals. All the best.many good .nice .quality. need to be taking good care , ....with it ....because, next buyer's. Will ....spent
Wow the boss is my least favorite here, really surprised, thanks for the video man.
Boss wins
The boss is the clearest, the other 2 are little bit
Muddy and darker
Great review, thanks for the video... one question, any thoughts on how the Flashback mini from TC electronics performs compared to these pedals? just wondering...
David Campos the Flashback is an digital delay, these ones are Analog delay. Completely different. But to answer your question, the Flashback will probably be a lot cleaner and brighter.
got it, thanks man... keep up those great vids!!
Well, it isn't my video, I'm just a stranger trying to help, haha! But you're welcome. :D
This is silly. It’s a valid question. The flashback is being discussed in the reply as if it doesn’t have a mode that emulates an analog delay. Flashback will “probably be a lot cleaner and brighter.” In 2290 digital mode, Ok. Not helpful, but whatever.
Do the volume drop when you kick in any of these pedal?
Not that I could remember with any of these models tested.
@@MusicBlissMalaysiaTV Thanks much
Interesting but I find the Boss the darkest and the Ibanez the brightest
Which one has better headroom and able to handle louder signal not clipping?
The Boss and Ibanez are pretty close with the amount of headroom. The Boss probably has more....we felt the Carbon Copy had the least among the three...
Thank you!
Is there a best option of delay that has tap tempo?
line 6 delay
Memory lane jr
That's what I call a true comparison. It would have been better with many amps, and many guitars, but it's ok. Congrats!I own one Carbon Copy for years. It's still sleeping in a bag. I tried the Boss DM-2w when it was released. It matchs so well with the Dual Rectifier Rev G (parallel fx loop) made in the 90's. As I play many of theses amps… I bought 5 DM-2w !!! I play this magic box in it's custom mode in wet/dry/wet system. This delay is the top of the top if you wanna shred with an ESP (mahogany+mapple+SeymourDuncan) in a Mesa Boogie. It's huuuuuge. It respects the high gain and, no, I disagree, the Boss has the darkest repeat, darker than the Carbon Copy. If you want something darker than darker then you have to play the almighty Way Huge Echo Puss. It's the best friend of the Rectifier about rhythm guitar, but it kills the sound in a Soldano SLO100. For this amp, you need the Mojohand FX Recoil, a kind of Boss DM-2, but for the Soldano loop. So the 1st question before buying a delay is : witch amp do you play, and what about the loop? Series or parallel? If you amp has a series loop, think about the Seymour Duncan Vapor Trail, or the top end delay over the world, in clean, crunch or high gain, the master jeidi of the bucket brigade delays : the JHS PantherCub. If you play an Engl Savage, a Bogner Ecstasy or a Mesa Dual Rectifier made between 1993 and 2010 (the Solo Head 2 channels Rev G and 3 channels, not the Multi-watts) then you must have the Boss DM-2w !!!About the Ibanez delay? LOL LOL LOL...
What do you recommend to me? I have a Friedman BE100 Deluxe as my main amp. I am mainly a hard rock player. I Always used my Maxon AD 900 but it takes too much place on my board, so I'm looking for a replacement that is as good as the AD 900...
I also want to say that I don't like the sounds he gets in this video when he adds gain probably because he doesn't place the delays in an effects loop. It sounds too distorted.
@@stefaanvanderpulst2547 I own the BE100, the 1st version, 2 channels. What I can tell:
As it's a 68' super Marshall like sound with one of the best serial loop on the market, the Carbon copy can works here. Not the Boss DM2 if you don't have a line mixer.
If you need a space ambiance : the Seymour Duncan Vapor Trail with the Strymon Flint in the 80's mode. Line mixer needed here. Try to play "Sorrow", from Pink Floyd, it's made for.
About line mixers, I use the Skrydstrup PL-1 (custom order made in Denmark) in the loop of my Soldano SLO (the original one, not the new one) : skrydstrup.com/audio-tools/loop-boxes/ The PL-1, or the PL-2 for 2 FX, is the top end line mixer.
I tried something like 10 other line mixers. Lehle? Only for clean, not possible with high gain. Xotic? It changes the sound. Especially in the Friedman loop : don't use Xotic here, its a counter-performance. The Xotix works with the Mesa Boogie Dual Rectifier Multiwatts only. And not with the old Rectifiers from the 90's. RJM line mixer and The GigRig wetter box ? Not bad, but the Skrydstrup is better.
Now, if you wanna play the serial loop with no line mixer, I would say : JHS PantherCub. To my humble opinion, and I own only something like 100 delays, not all the delays, the Panther Cub v2.0 is the best delay ever made in small format. It's inspired by the Boss DM2. I own the v 1.5 witch is better for me because there is an insert that I use for phase 90. But it's bigger and no more in production.
Now if you need something fat, the Way Huge EchoPuss is... huge :) to make your sound bigger with a short echo. Awesome for power chords. If you play stoner metal, this is the holy grail.
So depends the way you play, the kind of sound you want... difficult to say. As you said hard rock, I think you need a line mixer to keep a part of the sound dry. The Boss DM2 is made for the Van Halen tone. Even if Eddie used to put the delay front to the amp. So the option of a line mixer is great here. That's the reason why I think the Bogner Ecstasy is a better amp than the Friedman BE100. The loop of the Bogner can be switch from serial to parallel. You don't need an extra line mixer with an Ecstasy, it's already builted in. I own an Ecstasy 101A 30th anniversary loaded with 6L6s: this is the best loop ever.
All the delays I mentioned here are ok for shred. But it's not about who is the best. When you go for analog, you need a short and a long delay. A delay for the clean, one for the distortion. All the delays I mentioned here are OK with high gain and clean. For short delay, the Way Huge Echo Puss is the best, but it's really made for high gain than for clean. For long delay : the Seymour Duncan Vapor Trail or the JHS PantherCub. If you need a delay on the clean tone, the JHS PantherCub is top. With distortion, it sounds something like the Boss DM2. The Carbon Copy doesn't sound sexy, it's a shy delay... maybe you will like it. For me it's not good enough.
At the end, as always, it will depends of your tastes. And the guitar you play. I use mahogany guitars with Seymour Duncan humbuckers, a few Gibson LesPaul but mostly 2 ESP Horizon and 1 Mirage, custom shop of course. My fav pickups are, 1st, the Seymour TB14, and the TB12 witch is a kind of Pearly Gates. So, if you are a Fender Strat guy, what I told you is maybe... wrong.
My conclusion : your problem comes with the serial loop of the amp. I think the Boss Dm-2W is the best for you, but it needs a parallel fx loop. If you don't play with a line mixer, you need a delay with a mix knob. And the JHS do both : mix abilities and high end sound. There are others very good, but they are bigger. If you don't fear to buy a bigger delay, there is a very good one for serial loop amps : the Electro Harmonix Deluxe Memory Man 1100TT. And what is cool with this one? You can use a volume pedal (Ernie Ball for example) as an expression pedal for the mix knob of the delay. This is very praticle for live. You can engage the fx and mix it with the foot on the fly.
@@toom6087 Thanks for the detailed answer. I bought the Carbon Copy today , second hand in my neighbourhood for 90 Euro. Couldn't resist that deal! I'll see how that works..One thing I want to mention about the Friedman BE 100 Deluxe : the effectsloop is ultra transparant, I hear no difference if there is something (for instance my Maxon AD 900) in the loop or not. And I've got some buffers/boosters laying around (Tone Freak Buff Puff,Morley..) that could help ...
@@stefaanvanderpulst2547 The CC is OK in a Friedman loop, no mistake here. This is the basic. I just tell that it becomes magic with the JHS, when it stays tiny shiny with the MXR. So I would say, each time you will be able to try other delays, try them !
I really like the Ibanez but you're getting a crazy repeated switch click every time you engage it. I'm hoping that's not a consistent issue, if so it's the dm2w for me.
Is it possible because it's last in the chain? Better scenario would be 3 separate/side-chained loops?...input and output impedance, and buffer interaction removed, or lessened.... either way I like these vids, and appreciate how he lets notes naturally decay. Surprisingly, many demos do not. I think it shows a greater degree of musicality/sensitivity, already heard in the clips. I bet I'd have fun jamming with this Cat.
No that popping sound is just a flaw w the Ibanez
@@travishernandez2193 Read comments elsewhere that complain about that.
Just click it about 20 time before playing it. It's fine after the static discharge is dissipated @@travishernandez2193
The mini is a tad brighter (less warm). Other than that is excellent. 100% quality
1:19
1:26
1:30
great review but why no use a hss strat.. for humbuker men as me i can see the diference better
The Ibanez is pretty bright for an analog delay. I bet it'd pair well with the Carbon Copy.
Hmmm....we felt the Ibanez to be darkest though...and the DM2 to be the brightest....
Must be my headset
I a/b'd the Ibanez with a DM2W in a store and I agree with you, it's brighter. In other demos you can really hear how bright and chirpy the repeats get.
Did you mean the Ibanez or the DM2w ?
The Ibanez. I played one again today actually- while there is eventually a darkening of the repeats, the initial ones are among the brightest and chirpiest of any analog delay I've heard.
Ibanez wins.
The best MXR pedal is probably an compressor or something
all sound can make in 1 digital multi pedal 😅...im hear maybe same...
Are these in the loop?
Yes they are...
Thanks!
Ibanez sounds warmest, almost as warm as the old 18v AD-80 that it's based on. Boss is the most articulate, although he only uses the custom mode, which is cleaner sounding. Standard mode is warmer, like the original DM-2. Carbon Copy doesn't do it for me.
Yeah i came to realise this after the demo about the DM2's standard mode...dumb of me...lol
Ibanezはスイッチノイズ入るね
I heard it, too. Is that normal?
DM-2W is the best.
People often say Carbon Copy because they brought it new for over 50% cheaper than the Boss, so many people have it and flock to videos like this to defend their made in some dodgy county purchase. Its way too dark and sounds awful un the mix.
No soul (roll-off), compared to the old ones. :/
Brighter than early 80s digital delays, even!! :|