"United Nations And Hamas Are In Bed Together" Melanie Phillips | The Winston Marshall Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
- Prolific author and Times columnist Melanie Phillips joined me to discuss the ongoing war in Gaza, the failure of Human Rights, the moral corruption of international organisations and the endless stupidity of the British Conservative party.
Melanie has been a prophetic voice on many issues, best evidenced by publishing the book 'Londonistan' as early as 2006 and 'The Sex-Change Society' back in 1999.
She is as fearless with her opinions today as ever...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Linktree: linktr.ee/wins...
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE:
If you're liking the show and want to stay updated, don't forget to subscribe to our RUclips channel! Simply hit the 'Subscribe' button below the video, and then click the bell icon to ensure you get all our notifications. Thanks for your support!
FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
Substack: www.winstonmar...
X: / mrwinmarshall
Insta: / winstonmarshall
Linktree: linktr.ee/wins...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I completely lost faith in the UN when it put Saudi Arabia in charge of the council for women's rights. Melanie is 100% correct to call it a captured institution.
Melanie Phillips is just the best. She is intelligent, practical, and truthful. God bless her. 🙏
When the Jews are in trouble we’re all in trouble.
LOL. She said so many unfounded and silly things, easily to be demonstrated as such, that I've falled from the chair.
I'm baffled by the many comments that are just repeating such claim of "truth...whatever" without explaining anything at all.
Yet, you yourself don't give a single example of what she said wrong with your 'facts'. Instead just a blank statement!@@leonardoarmandoiarrusso1225
@@leonardoarmandoiarrusso1225your reply tells us all we need to know about your political persuasion.
@@stevemcmahon100 "Political persuation"?
What's the relation with the current argument?
Why are you pointing to that thing instead Providing the (missing) Fundamental informations by Phillips and trying to criticize what I stated, including references?
Please, act as an ADULT instead of writing nonsensical stuff.
I'm not Jewish, may I say I was shocked and appalled on Oct 7th and shocked to see people celebrating in Britain at this attack. What is happening in Britain? God help us.
Vote reform
First they came for the Jews.
@@maureensmith9328 Maybe they were celebrating that Israel received a few hours of the same treatment this occupation army had been dishing out for decades.
@@lindajoubert6205 maybe they were celebrating because they are easily lead morons
we need to hear more non-jewish voices like you. thank you from tel-aviv 💙🤍💙
Very brave woman to stand against evil
The Jewish genocide in Gaza is evil!
Very good woman. Supports Israeli supremacy and bombing refugee camps and 100 civilian deaths for "1 hummus member who we don't even know the name of".
She's standing up for her group interest, that's natural not brave...
She is evil and a liar
shes a paid zionist.
I am a British non Jew that is horrified by what I see on the streets, it makes me disgusted that this is happening in the UK. How can people be so backwards?
Read Reading Lolita in Tehran and see how insidious was the takeover of Iran by the Mullahs. Ditto Turkey with Erdogan. And the people in Egypt and Jordan are not as enlightened as their rulers. Jew hatred is spreading.
My understanding is that British people are a minority in their own country. They are being overrun by foreigners from the middle east.
we let them indoctrinate the children in school, we let Blair reform British law, that's what happened
1st century people will behave like this wherever they go! There is nothing different about an Islamist in Somalia, Sudan, Pakistan or in Londonistan.
Same here in France !
She is not wrong on any level. Thank you Winston for bringing the truth to us all x
Yes, she is. The United States and NATO intentionally violated the Minsk Accords in order to deceive Russia and that's according to two public statements made by Angela Merkel on television. We built more than two dozen military installations inside Ukraine. We funded the coup in 2014 that replaced the democratically elected president of Ukraine with a US puppet. Ukraine bombed the Russian-speaking people in eastern Ukraine for eight years. What about their human rights? This isn't Putin's fault, it's ours. We're the bad guy here.
she is wrong on several levels. sycophantic claims are tired at this point. im not interested in partisan positioning. just objective analysis.
@@LeGioNoFZioNThank you for pointing that out but can you tell us where she is wrong and if possible back it up with facts so you will not be like those ones who say something about a person but can't provide facts
@@LeGioNoFZioN Really? How so? If you could provide facts as to why she is wrong on several levels that would be helpful. Thanks
@@joce11Don’t expect a reply any time soon.😂
As Iranians we don't need Miss Phillips to understand the perverted methods of Islamists.
The West needs to hear this!
We send Love and hugs to our jewish (and Israeli) sisters and brothers from Iran.
We love you. We believe you. We know what you have been through, because it's been done to us since 1979!
Keep fighting.
We WILL win and overcome those bastards!
You know the truth better than anyone & we send the love to you as well 🎉
Have met some amazing Iranian people. So many good Iranians are refined and educated, yearning for freedom and yet living under such a brutal dictatorship who polices what they wear, what they're allowed to do and say, what they're allowed to think. My heart goes out to you and your brave rebels!
If anyone in the world thinks their Muslim neighbours won’t turn on them once they gain power is living in a bubble
They'll turn even before they gain power.
I have long known the UN to be evil. I am glad to hear someone finally spelling it out so clearly, Thank you, Melanie Philip.
Wait...the UN is the evil one for trying to feed children not the guys shooting children? Get out of here.
The UN at present is not independent. There were reports by the UN in 2016 regarding atrocities in Ukraine by SBU against the Ukraine people of abductions, torture , rape and murder by the SBU , these were ignored. OCSE produced reports on the same matter, also ignored.
The UN is the biblical beast
@JamesThompson-vs4kg I have been thinking the same thing!
@@JamesThompson-vs4kg LOL. Read Revelations 2:9
The UN needs to be defunded and kicked out of the US.
The UN must be proscribed globally.
The world is either blind or they choose to support the destruction of Israel ! UNRWA was always a curse against them as if the Arab resistance wasn’t bad enough on it’s own
Defunded, yes. I’m afraid of the coup the CCP would pull off if we kick the UN out of the US and it ends up in Beijing.
The US is running the UN…….!…..
@Adam -tj4oy, the UN needs to leave the influence of the USA, and set up elsewhere neutral.
I went to Israel for 10 months back in the 1990’s. I can report the terrorism and attacks they faced were frightening. Buses being targeted by suicide bombers in Jerusalem regularly. Also rockets being fired over the border from Syria. I left a Kibbutz in the North as it was terrifying having rockets being fired constantly. It was like living in a war zone. Imagine living for years and years under this circumstance and then Hamas slaughter young innocent lives, and you are told you are committing war crimes by attempting to destroy that terrorist group. The UN gave the Jews a state of their own in 1948. They are legitimate citizens. They were Israelites back in 1020BCE. It is genuinely their homeland.
As an English person I can see we have been abandoned by our own government and many of those people in power have foreign names?
Dear Thomas, now you know what it feels like to be American, and all the demonic political frustration there is too long suffer everyday. God bless all here.
London 27/7 👊🇬🇧
Ms. Phillips is truly a ray of light in the darkness.
"zionist are basically jews", what a ray of light..
Israel kills babies & toddlers On Industrial Scale! Disgraceful!!
It's not just the Jewish community who feel abandoned. The majority of the British people also feel abandoned by their own government.
I think most countries feel betrayed by their leaders, who seem to have a different agenda.
Americans too by both past administrations.
@@MishMichaeli Very accurate! The polls demonstrate one thing yet politicians do the opposite. There is considerable corruption going on!
It’s a silent invasion here in the US too
Why is the west letting in scum from other countries? Please explain how this is good.
Thank you Ms. Phillips ! Finally somebody is saying the King is naked!
Melanie Phillips always speaks with authority and wisdom. I take notice of her every time.
She is so bright, articulate and courageous. Thanks for having her on the podcast.
She really isn’t
@@trevaudioIs that your well thought out counter arguement?😂
@@trevaudioit sounds like your not the full pound up top
@@trevaudioA fact-free hollow argument, anything else to contribute?
@@trevaudio and who are you little insignificant person? a nobody!
I am not Jewish and I agree entirely with Melanie Philips about the UN, the ICC et al. They outlived their purpose some years ago
Bully for you. You're easily led, I see.
Yeah because this oppression has been going on for decades. I have uncles older than isn't-real lol
@@stephendoherty981 The only one delusional here is you. Truth is obvious and you’re the one believing the lies. Keep drinking that koolaid.
@@rgghjs9270 Yeah ok Hamas. Stop believing the propaganda. Get a clue.
@@stephendoherty981 No, it`s called common sense. Something you`re devoid of, I see.
Thank God 🙏 for Melanie Philip for being a genuine Voice, expressing the truth in the midst of the confusion, chaos and self destruction of our modern societies.
This woman is a visionary. Truly incredible, insightful, and innovative conversation. From beginning to end the evolution of dialogue is remarkable. Melanie is a hero.
I'm 71 and when I was 18 yrs old I remember my father saying that the UN should be dissolved. He said they are a waste of money and accomplish absolutely nothing.
Your Father was correct but he didn't finish the idea he was stating by leaving off the most important bit, their success at sowing division and spreading Marxist ideology around the planet.
I don't like the United States putting more money into the United Nations than anybody else and it seems like they turn around and kiss the rear ends of Chinese Communist party and China and the terrorists and RUclips may very well censor my comment again.. I just know that we either had undercover enemies before Joe Biden or more people around the world are coming out and literally world leaders and pushing their propaganda can't stand the USA now and it's been going on after Joe Biden was in office about 1 year. I just think it's ironic because Joe's had 50 plus years in politics and Trump's had all these years in business but he deals with people differently and he's still not going to take any bullcrap. I just don't get it because the United Nations is worthless and I don't think in my opinion it does any better than the national league because Japan got right up and walked out of there when they were confronted over the atrocities they committed in China 💔. The difference is today the there's more power to control money in the flow of it and Joe Biden could easily freeze the money of the cartels in Mexico & has NOT.
I don't like this anti-Semitism whether it's coming from the Muslims jihad or whoever or neo-nazis or cultural marxists.
I am moderate conservative but I'm what one would call center right but I'm not a MAGA FREAK. YES I BOUGHT A DONALD TRUMP HAT AND I EVEN BOUGHT ONE THIS YEAR FOR VIVEK Roma swami because I wanted him to be able to get up on the stage because he's a brilliant guy and I have watched him for years whenever he would come on Tucker at least twice a week before Tucker was pretty much relieved of his position at Fox News but that was part of the lawsuit settlement with Dominion.
I just think Tucker was funny but he's so nerdy..
He was right and I agree with him today when the government looks at us all like a bunch of "peasants". Does anybody really care about us? We are numbers we are money and we are votes to politicians and the political group DC and the bureaucracy. I can tell by the millions and millions of immigrants coming into this country on unvetted They Don't Care about anybody who's an American citizen or even a tourist. It's all about power and money and I swear I think it has always boiled down to that regardless of any civilization.
WHAT AN INTELLIGENT WOMAN!! SHE SPEAKS TRUTH!!
My dad said exactly the same.
How absolutely right your father was.
Why can we not have intelligent people like this in places of power.
Because Satan is the god of this world.
Because the majority of any large population (more than a few thousand) are collectively biased towards demagoguery. As far back as Socrates in ancient Athens, we've known that a population favours promises of welfare handouts and 'don't worry, let the Govt look after you' politicians, rather than the tough love of serious people like Melanie, Douglas Murray, Thomas Sowell, who would say and do what we need, not just what we want.
In this modern era of media and the cult of youth, woke, sexual status, ethnicity, the good people avoid politics like a plague, because they understand the reality is that our modern democracy favours the demagogue approach and censures the rationalist. to appease groups, collectives,..."the mob".
Because the systems are so corrupt and rotten to the core that actually decent people usually want no part in it, but rather to appose it and criticize it from the outside.
Especially considering the fact that you'd be under many corrupt and twisted maniacs' control from within these systems.
And also that you'll have to do a lot of twisted things to rise to certain positions and stay in them.
Decent and intelligent people justifiably do not want to lead.
It's the unfortunate outcome of human nature being what it is, and structures of power attracting the kinds of people they do.
They do exist there. However there's the permanent power of Civil Service. Which thinks it knows better and is THE self-perpetuating elite. To call them a service is a misnomer.
Because we have grifters in government, who are basically grifting, because they are mediocre entities!!
Yet, most people in their apathy, accept this atrocious reality!!
Every word that you are saying resonates with my personal thinking, beautiful said.
Thank you melanie for your clarity in conveying the messages of truth full of wisdom. God bless you. Peace to Jerusalem & glory to IDF / Israel
Melanie Phillips is a lone voice in the wilderness of chaos and ideological confusion... thanks Winston for bringing her to your show!!
There is also Douglas Murray...
There is also the brilliant Douglas Murray. He was interviewed by the Trigger boys on their YT channel. Fantastic interview. Murray summed up exactly how I think the silent majority feels.
There are others. Caroline Glick is one.
@@maseratifittipaldi Douglas, not Gordon...
@@rsr789 Sorry - Seems I have been watching too much Formula 1 in my youth ! 😬
Melanie is vastly intelligent and reasonable, its a pleasure to see her being interviewed by her equal.
Melanie is a brilliant woman. Great interview
Oh I do love listening to this woman!! So informed, so intelligent, so articulate, so impressive
So glad someone is listening and speaking about the reality of UN and Hamas. They are in bed together.
They have something in common. They hate God.
@@drivebyquipperThey Hate the West & Jews & Christians & Hindus.
I was a bit shocked that Winston didn't know this. There has been a LOT of reporting on UNRWA's involvement in terror activity from Gaza. And the UN is practically led by countries like China and Iran, that are completely pro-Hamas, even if China tries to hide it.
@@drivebyquipper you worship your ownership group, who worship the darklord
@@gmw3083 🎯
I’m a US citizen and we have been abandoned by our government.
So vote for Trump.
@@thk929 I plan to, but he’s not at all the answer. Our politicians aren’t going to get us out of this.
Better chabce with Trump than without him. No Democrat will do it.
@@yonason6047 agreed. I’m voting for him because of how the dems are trying to take him out. I’ll crawl over broken glass to do it and make the point.
They indeed have abandoned us
Get rid of UN, what a waste of money
You're Right on the money, ma'am! This hypocritical action against my brothers and sisters needs to stop! And Briben needs to back off on Pm Netanyahu; back off and stop holding up shipments that were promised to Israel!
This woman's courage is astounding! Melanie Phillips, I am in awe of your courage, intelligence, capability to bring this incredible information to the world's citizens.
Thank you Melanie Phillips. Thank you Winston Marshall. I give you all the credit fro bringing this information to all of us. This information, is "need to know" for all, ALL civilization.
This woman deserves all the honors, awards, given in the past to fake women, women of not much achievement, courage, principle, morals, virtue, intelligence. She deserves the Nobel Peace Prize. She deserves every journalism prize available.
Tucker Carlson, Dave Ribin, Ben Shapiro, Jordan Peterson, you must interview this woman. You must! America, American citizens MUST absolutely her from Melanie Phillips.
Yes. I agree. She is unbelievably spot on. A person of such caliber deserve to be recognized.
I strongly agree with Melanie on every count, especially in regard to the UN and America.
Is that because they are continually condemning Israel?
@@douglaslyle2519no, but because is the truth.
They dont condone anybody only israel
She is amazing. I'm not so deeply educated on a single one of the topics you and she covered, but I was riveted. I listened to this podcast in its entirety while doing nothing else. Unforgettable, and so informative that my mind is reconfiguring itself to fit in new pieces. Thank you for this electrifying conversation.
I was never a huge fan of Mumford & Sons, but I'm addicted to your podcast. Excellent!!
She is truly smart, honest and class act.
A voice to be heard I believe.
Thank you.
Melanie has expressed both my views and my feelings about what is going on against Israel. I am an Australian gentile. I am on the side of truth and justice. May God preserve Israel and all of us from this evil ideology.
WELL THE MAJORITY OF ARMED ANGLO AMERICANS, SIDE WITH HAMAS., BUT OF COURSE., IN THE U.S.A. WE DEAL WITH ILLEGALS INVADING OUR LAND ALL OF THE TIME.AND THE USUAL RESULT FOR THE INDIGENOUS PHILISTINE LAND OWNERS IS WHAT THE ENTIRE GLOBAL COMMUNITY REPEATEDLY CALLED GENOCIDE. THE ZIONIST LIARS FAILED WHEN THEY SET UP [ SHIN BET, THEIR OWN INTELLIGENCE PEOPLE ] AND HAD THEM MURDERD, AND TRIED TO BLAME HAMAS . NO ONE IS PLAYING., THIS IS NOT A TEST. IT WAS A MASSACRE OF JEWS, BY THE IDF, BEFORE THIS GENOCIDE BEGAN AGAINST THE GAZA CIVILIAN PUBLIC. HOW MANY U.S. SERIAL KILLERS HAVE KILLED MULTIPLE AMERICANS., WE U.S. LAW ENOFRCEMENT FIND THEM OUT., U.S. LAW ENFORCEMENT NOR THE ARMY GOES INTO THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY WHERE THIS MAN(FELON) IS, AND BLOW UP THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY. WHAT IDIOT DOES THAT., AND WHAT IDIOT CONDONES SUCH A MURPHY`S LAW???? OF COURSE ZIONIST ISRAEL IS NOT GOING TO GET A PASS ON GENOCIDE.ESPECIALLY WHEN THEY SET UP THEIR OWN [ JEWISH ISRAELI ] PEOPLE TO BE KILLED, SELLING MSM LINE OF LIES TO THE USUAL GULLIBLE AMERICANS., WHO, AS WE SEE THE ENTIRE GLOBAL COMMUNITY INCLUDING LEADING U.S. JEWS, STANDING WITH GAZA .,WHILE THE LONERS STAND WITH FELONS., DOES THIS LOOK LIKE A HAPPY ENDING? THE FOLLOWING DOCUMENTARY[MADE BY JEWS] IS CONDONED BY SHIN BET GIVATI, AND MOSSAD. PLEASE WATCH ruclips.net/video/fMXllVmTuKQ/видео.html&rco=1
what books have you read on the topic ??
I dislike that Melanie Phillips sees everything through the prism of Jewishness and that all NGOs have antisemitism at their core. Whilst some of this is the case, the obsession with Israel distracts from her argument. Her argument against international Marxism is sound and globalism is evil but this putting Israel at the core is obsessive.
Here is the God's word,
Malachi 4: 4-6: "Remember ye the law of Moses my servant, which I commanded unto him in Horeb for all Israel, with the statutes and judgments. Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the LORD: And he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers, lest I come and smite the earth with a curse."
As we know, John the baptist (Elijah the prophet, Mathew 11: 12-14) was murdered during Herod's "birthday" celebration.
These are his words, Mathew 3: 7-10: "But when he saw many of the Pharisees and Sadducees come to his baptism, he said unto them, O generation of vipers, who hath warned you to flee from the wrath to come? Bring forth therefore fruits meet for repentance: And think not to say within yourselves, We have Abraham to our father: for I say unto you, that God is able of these stones to raise up children unto Abraham. And now also the axe is laid unto the root of the trees: therefore every tree which bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire."
Christ-Messiah was executed as "blasphemer" and "rioter" by denunciation of clergy.
Then the betrayer, Israel by flesh, was destroyed for his sins.
Novadays "christians" are happy to have friends among Christ's persecutors. They love to visit temples of cursed land.
The problem is Devil runs the world. He is lier and murderer. This is the reason why herods and hitlers feel good while Christ is persecuted.
"Jesus" means "Jehovah is salvation". This is the name of Christ real christians are hated for.
"HalleluJah" means "Praze Jah" (Jehovah).
Psalm 83: 18: "That men may know that thou, whose name alone is JEHOVAH, art the most high over all the earth."
But, hipocrites doesn't want to know this.
That's why we've got the Gospel about the God's kingdom. Jehovah would put everything in order. He has anointed the king, Jesus Christ. The dead will be resurected and we'll meet our beloved ones again! :-)
PS. Amos 5: 25-26: "Have ye offered unto me sacrifices and offerings in the wilderness forty years, O house of Israel? But ye have borne the tabernacle of your Moloch and Chiun your images, the star of your god, which ye made to yourselves."
Hebrew pagans still using a star...
I know exactly how you feel - other than the Australian part. 🇨🇦
This woman is AMAZING! I hope she keeps speaking the truth.
bilions and billions people don't thinks so .
Israel kills babies & toddlers On Industrial Scale! Disgraceful!!
@@leszekladzinski73well I wouldn't expect religious ideologues to think she was, on the converse there are billions who find the theocracy of the disagreeing bilious.
@@leszekladzinski73 plebillions*
@@leszekladzinski73 they dont think at all, thats the issue, When we got gays for palestine, thats the only logical conclusion..
It’s amazing how this woman can explain such complicated issues and ideas so simply. I am always shocked how deep the Israel-“Palestinian” “Conflict” runs. This woman’s explanation is impressive! I’m completely gobsmacked! 😱 🤩
On RUclips (CHRISTIANITY & ISLAM DEBATES) very informative….
Melany Phillips is absolutely right.
Melanie Phillips…my heroine who has taught me much about the history and politics of the Middle East. I discovered her in 1991 when I was quite ignorant of that region. Thank you Melanie for all you have done and continue to do.
I feel the same, I watched the Triggernometry interview with her and gained everything that I should have learned at school.
Allow me to introduce you to Andrew Feinstein
You have chosen a very biased teacher indeed
Therefore you still know nothing
@@Saorsa-ql your response has not disappointed me!
@@GMN360
Indeed
Melanie makes excellent points regarding the impossibility of globalised 'human rights'.
Thank you, Melanie. Like never before, the world needs a voice of reason.
I applaud you Melanie for your knowledge, moral clarity and wisdom!
How wonderful to spend one and a half hours listening to such a sane, clear and sincere voice in this insane world, seemingly full of F-ing idiots. Thank you Melanie!
@marcuslewitzki4610
so so true 🙂
We are Stronger, Louder and Victorious,the hamas lie, pay the protestors and hate all peoples so don't fool yourselves.
❤ Exactly what I feel. Feeling confirmed now, that I am not crazy.
Melanie Phillips and Douglas Murray are the only Brits that really understand what is going on in the Middle East, and the only ones that have the intellect to explain it to people.
Two national treasures all of us are proud of.❤❤❤
😂😂😂😂😂 you’re hilarious
No, there actually are more.
Brilliant isn't she. Think she was on Sky News Australia last week.
The events of Oct 7th is a consequence of the psychotic 2 state solution theory. The Israelis left Gaza long ago and hamas is the result.
She is a very well spoken, intelligent woman. 👏👏👏👏🙏
Iam British n I hate what going on in london
One of the major flaws of the UN is that states that do not observ human rights are allowed to have a say about human rights in countries that observ human rights.
Evil incarnate.
That's why they are ridiculous and it's always shocked me anyone take anything they say seriously.
@@serenapimentel7372 The UK listen to every human right court going... 🎉🏳️🌈🤔🤦♂️🐍🔥💀
And this flaw has been used to the advantage of Western nations for some time.
Now that they are in decline are they complaining about unfairness.
If it was an issue it should have been handled earlier rather than only when Israel is affected. Talk about special treatment
LIKE ISRAEL ruclips.net/video/fMXllVmTuKQ/видео.html&rco=1
Happy Belated Birthday to Melanie Phillips (born on June 4th). So glad you came into this world.
What a articulate Lady
The human pride of people - evil presented as good. I cannot describe without biblical terms .Thank you Melanie Phillips for speaking out clearly
Thank you Melanie Phillips! Thank you Winston Marshall!
I support Mrs Phillips sentiments regarding disbanding the UN and ICC wholeheartedly.
😀
I am an American Jew and even I can see this is the holocaust being commited but by my own Jewish brothers. YOU DO NOT REPRESENT US!
ruclips.net/user/shortsqiQLalP_TBw?si=1n42v_ENieAHCRwd
I have never, never before, heard anyone express my own views, held since more than 30 years, on the UN, Israel, Nation states and the state of the world. Melanie Phillips is dropping truth bombs, time after time!
Agreed 🎉
Fabulous interview. I felt my views in echo! Very happy to hear Ms. Phillips and look forward to getting her book(s). Truly love her fervor & stance regarding the current rotten condition(s) in Britain and in my country, USA!
Thank you Winston. Yes, would have enjoyed learning her background abit. Ciao!
Totally With her! Abolish the UN!
Thank you Melanie. I am non Jewish but I have many Jewish friends and I will never forget when I was four years old going with my late Mum to her work. Her employers had escaped the holocaust. Please keep talking. 👋👋🏴🏴🏴🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
I'm a catholic living in the failed state of South Africa and I stand fully on Israel's side.
And South Africa had the opportunity to be the shining example across the world of a country overcoming "apartheid" but those politicians and their sycophants blew it
Yes , I stand with the wonderful Israel, from the failed South Africa , since 1994.
I’m not sure that you’re aware of Israel’s support of the apartheid government in SA back in the day. They did it because the government was allow them to steal your nation’s Uranium for Israel’s Nuclear development. Israel also support the murder of thousands of Christians in Armenia by supplying weapons to Azerbaijan. But go ahead….
@@skiboltskieskye1238No opportunity at all.
@@marimuller9530Israel is a failed state.
Thank you, Melanie, for being one of the few brave to speak the truth.
Thank you for talking to Melanie Phillips!
I recently saw the videos of Oct 7. I am appalled! I do not like Hamas, and they need to be held accountable for this massacre on a world level. My heart broke for the suffering of unarmed citizens being brutally killed, raped, kidnapped, no mercy for the old, handicap, babies, dogs, and the young people at the music festival attacked, thinking they were safe in bomb shelters, throwing grenades in there and laughing for killing many Jews.
@karenkennedy6........I feel the same way. EVERY COUNTRY SHOULD HAVE CONDEMNED HAMAS for the attrocities committed on that day.
@karenkennedy6331
Even more horrible is how the world has taken the side of Hamas over that of Israel, the side of the perpetrator over that of the victim.
PS - and by “world,” I mean world governments, not necessarily the people. Most Westerners side with Israel. I don’t know a out the others..
No one is taking the side of Hamas they should be held accountable for any actions against harming civilians but so is isreal its actions against civilians is also wrong and criminal
When isreal rejects independence investigations to be carried out lock's out the World press from entering Gaza and says things like 40 beheaded babies on October 7 babies baked I'm Ovens which have been retracted by there own media and press and debunked tells me that Isreals IDF are liars and war criminals that can't be trusted
The UN are a toothless organisation with fck all power against isreals War Crimes not just for what its doing now but for what it has been doing for the last 75 years
Give back the stolen lands. No problems no hostages
Thank you Melanie for such complete Truths about this evil war systems on our world. ❤❤❤❤😢😢😢😢😢
And somewhere on this planet a very, very small group looks down from their tower, they smile and think "it's going the way we want it to go..."
One of your best guests. Thank you Melanie Philips and Winston Marshall. 🇨🇦🙏🏼🙏🏽🙏🏾🇦🇷
Melanie Phillips is totally correct, we need people like this woman in power. Totally understands the dangers.
😂😂😂 she’s a liar
@@trevaudio You obviously do not understand the meaning of that word.
You want to check out what the Nazis did if you like this one
And yet, we keep voting for people like Obama and Biden.
@@dreinhard52
I understand perfectly well….she’s a liar, and completely discredited
Melanie Philips, you do things very clearly!!!!
Americans want out of the UN now.
Thank you for standing by Israel and publicly supporting us.
❤
Ms. Phillips- you are 100% bang on right about the UN! It's time to either disolve it or for England, the US, Australia, Canada, Mexico and ALL 'good' nations to leave it now!
Leave us Christians along.
Also if we dissolve it it will be to have Christians only united nations empire. Non-Christians not allowed. Your Non-Christians always bring your problems to Christians door steps.
She is actually misleading yoo.
Mexico abstained from the UN vote to release hostages.
@@iberns So what??
we all must get out of the UN
Massive respect to Melanie Phillips
Really respect Me Marshall’s honesty, if he doesn’t know he asks for clarification, most interviewers instead try to cover up the fact that they don’t know everything with phrases such as “can you clarify that for the audience or some viewers might not know” etc. Mr Marshall’s style makes it more engaging, we are with him on the same journey to find things out.
Ooh I hadn't really noticed that, but he does indeed. 😊
Yes, he has a lot of integrity as an interviewer, which makes me trust this channel more than others.
He's a Gutierrez apologist.
Melanie Phillips is 100% spot on about EVERYTHING! I stand and support Israel and hope and pray Israel stands strong and free.
It won't exist in ten years
we need more people like to speak out loud. There aren't enough people saying those things . Just as an example what happens in Europe now to Israelis is simply appalling . Thank you for supporting : )
[ ONLY. FULLY. WILL. , WHEN. THEY. REALIZE. THAT. JESUS. IS. THE. ONLY. WAY. TO. HEAVEN. ] ! .
UNWILLING. TO. HUMBLE. THEMSELVES. , AND. CRY. OUT. TO. HIM. ! .
[ NOT. B. WAITING. FOR. ANOTHER. SAVIOUR. ] ! .
READ. - REVALATION. , 13 : 16. .
JOHN. - 14 : 6. .
I. PRAY. U. ALL. READ. THIS. ❤❤❤.
Malinie Phillips you are a smart person who should be the prime minister of the United Kingdom if only politicians listen to your wise advice God bless you and your thoughts may you have a long long life you give me hope
I am gay, 6 on the Kinsey scale, and atheist. I know extremely well what fate the Islamomaniacs have in store for me. I know who my friends are and who my enemies are.
I couldn't agree with her more. The United Nations has to be abolished.
God bless Malenie, a voice of truth and wisdom desperately needed in these appalling times of lies and insanity.
I stand with Israel ❤❤❤
She is ignoring the truth and desperately trying to manipulate the truth…
Doubly blessed by such intelligent people! Thank you both for being great role models! God bless both of you and God bless Israel and God bless Britain and God bless America, again, please? 🙏 🕊️ Jus' Prayin'
I know someone who worked for a food program for the UN in Israel. They said when it came to caring about the suffering of Palestinian civilians in Gaza and the West Bank, Israel and Hamas were equally indifferent. Of course international law can't prevent such suffering when neither Amalek Israel nor terrorist Hamas observe it in Gaza or the West Bank. That's how you end up with a Lancet estimate of over 100,000 dead in Gaza, mainly children.
Winston, thank you very much for interviewing Melanie. To the point, I fully agree with her. Over the years I have watched the UN express anti-Israeli sentiment and attitude on every hand and at every given opportunity.
Finally an intelligent voice the world should listen to! Thank you for bringing us her wisdom.
This interview is really thought-provoking.
I'm Australian, I agree 100% with what Melanie Phillips says, & I'm utterly appalled.
Melanie is one of the best, honest, not sold out journalists, so rare today. Wonderful episode! Such a delight to hear 2 intelligent, truthful thinkers, not afraid to call a spade a spade..
Melanie is courageous with high moral clarity.
Melanie I'm a 1970s East African migrant who is not a Christian, Jew or Muslim & held the British values close to my heart.Unfortunately I totally subscribe to your viewpoint & worry about the younger generations 😢
1:35 This last statement is the MOST powerful statement to EVERY Nation, Culture and Family!
Thank you for the boost in Spirit.❤ Well worth 1.5 hours listening. She should be Ambassador🙏🌈🎯💯📣🗽🇺🇸✌🏾✌👍🏿
This Lady is absolutely brilliant.
I 100% agree with this women! She is brilliant.
Melanie Phillips = honest reporting @ its very, very best!!!
Really!
I would rename the United Nations to global consultation hours this would give it more legitimacy. And then invite countries that truly embrace the declaration of human rights and its values to form a more perfect Union ;-) - Totally agree with Melanie Phillips - thank you
Thank you for this great interview. I really like that the interviewer doesn't interrupt his guest unnecessarily but still corrects obvious errors like 2.6 children per women is indeed the right figure for generational renewal. I've been listening for over 25 years to Melanie or reading her articles/books. She's an exceptional lady. Great to know she has a website.
Superb assessment and summary by Melanie Phillips, tragic that we have so few journalists or commentators of her calibre
Since 1945 has History taught the world nothing!!!! Jesus H. Christ, these people have been slaughtered for who they are. If I wasn't nearly 70yrs old I would join the IDF. My prayers are with them all. 🏴🥋
GREAT INDEED! FEARLESS FRANK AND UTTERLY HONEST! MY HUMBLE SALUTE AND A MILLION CONGRATULATIONS!
She is a joy to listen to. Someone who is well spoken and knowledgeable.
what books have you read on this topic?
Smart and brave woman. Saying the truth simple and clear.
I have met melanie and she knows what she is talking about. She is very impressive.
I'm not Jewish, and I haven't felt safe enough to go into Central London since October 7th.
I have seen interviews of Irish women and children who are afraid to walk to school or the local shop. They are being attacked, and no one is talking about it. They have been sold down the river by their government
You guys gotta start standing on your back feet. Before you won't have your democracy anymore. Don't take for granted what your ancestors had fought for, so hard for you to have.
Does nobody wonder why so many thousands of decent human beings march for Palastine??? This is what apartheid States and, in this case, occupying forces murdering innocent civilians for many years should have to contend with. Boycott and Divest from this genocidal state that is stealing more land on a daily basis. Nathanahu flaunt maos with Palastine eradicated. People are not idiots. This woman might seem knowledgeable, but she also sounds racist, entitled, I could add to that and some of her remarks were blatent lies
@@OriMoscovitz Are you in Israel?
Snowflake. Run out of prozac?
Totally agree Miss Philips...
100% with Israel defenders of our Western civilisation....Ireland