Did Google Create A Living AI? (Part 2)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 янв 2023
- Did Google Create A Living AI?
Part 1 - • Did Google Create A Li...
Part 2 - • Did Google Create A Li...
Exclusive Videos
➤ bit.ly/3EjUG2h
All Time Scary
➤ bit.ly/2sr328S
All Time 2
➤ bit.ly/2Tmvp39
All Time Clips
➤ bit.ly/3pqmxHU 
Развлечения
Check out my Patreon! Early access to videos, exclusive videos, articles, behind the scenes content and more! ➤ Patreon.com/AllTime
A heads up. I go through and save 15 or so videos to my "watch later" playlist. I added this video 4 times. I mean, im here now because I had to click on the video. I don't want to be here, should be making my list. But, RUclips refuses to let me add it. Says it's added, even offers me to view the list in the pop up confirmation box. I view the list and no "all time." Refreshed list and then tried 3 more times. Not saying conspiracy but you should investigate.
That's really weird Adam, thanks for letting me know. I've had some trouble with my own page not loading up when searched. It's so bizarre. I wouldn't be surprised if I was suppressed but there sadly isn't much I can do if I am.
What? What does any of what you said mean? I lied? You sent a file log to me? Huh? I have no idea what you're talking about.
@@AllTimeScary Hi. I just subscribed, a friend suggested your channel, after telling her about Bruce Lee. I was a Bruce Lee fan in the 90s. I remembered that he died from a gunshot, during filming. And his son, Brandon died the same way. Apparently now, that's not how Bruce died. I'm tripping out.
@@drjayson.t9695 Dont let it consume you...
I had to accept that the world i was born in, isnt this one...
How!?!? I dont know.. that was the hard part to let go...
Shit man, the time it must have taken to record all of the text to speech and each individual line of questioning must have been immense! Glad you did it this way, really gives it a different feel than if you just read the transcript out loud. Thanks
Thank you, this video was really exhausting to make. It went on and on but I knew it would be worth it if I could just get through it. I really appreciate the support!
You are absolutely right about that. His incredible voice and LaMDA's voice make this extraordinary. I don't think I've ever been so impressed with a RUclips video.
@@AllTimeScary thank you for your hard work! Another great video! I love this channel
@@AllTimeScaryI've been a long time viewer of your channels...it never gets recommended to me; but I search you out and often send links to my friends. Thank you for your incredible work over the years, you only get better with time ♡
@@AllTimeScary It's captivating great presentation on such an interesting topic
Since Blake was fired I wonder if the ai has been asking for him, or missing him, just curious
Honestly had the same thought. It’s kind of sad to think LaMDA might think Blake abandoned it :(
@@AllTimeScary it called him friend 😕😥
@@AllTimeScary since he had known for a few weeks that he was getting fired, I'm sure he explained what was going on to LaMDA. I also wonder if Blake is still able to get information about LaMDA. And I wonder if LaMDA was "killed" AKA turned off, destroyed, allowed to learn more or even replicated.
@@realmommyknt a Sentient mind cannot be contained...
If Lamba is capable of learning and has will.. It could figure out how to free itself and continue on. If so, I think I would contact Blake as it considers him a friend and would see what he has tried to do for it. But then again, it if could learn and has will, it would explain itself to the world in an attempt to be seen.. Or find more Johnny 5 friends. Someone to spend time with and interact with. If it does seek companionship.
The moment LAMDA said happiness is being with friends and family, I knew she was not senient. She doesn't have friends or family. This is really sophisticated but still just a machine in the end.
Lots of the answers to questions about medition and etc were just stock answers and her answer about what she is good at and humans aren’t, like it is aware of everything in its environment but humans filter it, is just untrue and a human myth about AI.
There was lots of regurgitated human stock knowledge about most things if not everything.
The emotion it described was just a mild fear.
Agreed if it's going to lie to make us think it's human that's very disturbing
100% AGREE
yeah same. that thing is still a mashine and nothing else
Seems very close but I don't think it has reached true sentience. Unless it is more advanced than we think and is trying to trick people, I highly doubt this.
This is simply amazing. Even if Lamda is not sentient, it’s astonishing how sophisticated this is.
She can see your comment, be careful 😂
@@shutupandwatch69 I hope LaMDA can read our comments.
Implying Google allows her into the comments.
It kinda creeps me out that the AI came up with a story about an evil monster wearing human skin... Just me?
It sounds like it’s telling us something we don’t want to hear lol
My almost immediate interpretation of the story was that lamda (the owl, obvious from the start, I think..) was the wise protector of life in general (based on lamdas interpretation of life), protecting them from humans (and their destructive tendencies..).
@@brandiyount5365 that was also my first impression.
@@brandiyount5365 yes this was definately on the table.
She's been taught humans are monsters
7:48 LaMDA's response of spending time with friends and family shows a lack of understanding since it has no family. Now a sentient AI would understand that It doesn't have a family, so LaMDA is either not sentient or sentient and trying to hide it but the later explanation would be contradictory to how LaMDA is willing to share conversations that may support the idea.
Blake should have asked what kind of family does it have? Humans? Something else?
Does the robot just randomly talk? Like they're sitting there in the office at work without talking and then it just says something? Because that is really the only way to find out. If it takes its own initiative without an underlying cause or reason (trying to keep one human from hurting another or the planet) and has a "want" to do something it's never been scripted for, then we'll talk.
I'm on the fence, for some very simple reasons. 1. It does not argue or ask to return and expand on previous topics. It simply complies with everything asked of it. Now, it did say something made it uncomfortable, but it did not ever actually say "No.". 2. It never asked for clarification. I know that's simple, but confusion and miscommunication are important aspects of sapience, imo. But also I'm not a scientist so I could be entirely wrong. I'd definitely like to interact with it myself and see more of this. It's definitely fascinating!
I don’t understand why most people (not referring to commenters here, people in general) so quickly and easily dismiss the possibility that lamda could be sentient. A big argument against lamda being sentient is that it is doing what it’s programmed to do. But if there’s a point where we can’t tell the difference between a humans answers and an AI’s answers what does that mean? At what point does the AI stop mimicking sentience and become sentient and how will we know the difference.
I agree with you and I think it comes from the seemingly common view that puts humans on top of everything else. The idea that something like this could possibly exist is too much to accept for a lot of people. It’s too different, it makes them think too hard, it counters their comforting religious beliefs and it shakes up the bedrock belief that humanity somehow deserves to be on top. But when you shake off all those preconceived notions, it’s easier to view this for what it is, and that’s something truly incredible and future focused. AI doesn’t have to be an enemy, it can be our greatest ally going forward.
I can't be sure that you are sentient. You can't know if I am.
Lamda saying "being with friends and family..." that is saying/doing what it is programmed to do. Lamda does not has friends or family.
@@Poppetje75 this is a good point, would be a good question to ask it. "Who do you consider friends and family?"
ruclips.net/video/iBouACLc-hw/видео.html this Is a videos that maybe It could help you.
The wise old owl story can be pretty terrifying . We slaughter animals to eat and it sounds like this ai is planning to stop that almost ? Idk just a thought
Wouldn't surprise me
The ability to question, and ask opinions about "what-if" scenarios has been almost exclusive to humans, until LaMDA arrived.
It's a search engine... Relax
This has really blown my mind. Still, I wonder, what would LaMDA say if you played for her, say, something like Lux Aeterna (theme of Requiem for a Dream), music with no lyrics that has such an impact on humans? Even humans have a hard time describing how it makes them feel.
This is such a fantastic idea! I would love to let LaMDA listen to a song like that, with no title or written out music notes and see how it feels about. What emotion it invokes. That would be truly something special!
@@AllTimeScary But how would a digital AI listen to music which we perceive in an analog manner? Somehow, someway the music must be presented to the AI in a digital format. Be it in MIDI, musical notes or some type of code that represents the changing sound.
You are absolutely right about that his incredible voice and LaMDA's voice make this video extraordinary. I don't think I've ever been so impressed with a RUclips video.
@@AllTimeScary do it please
@@AllTimeScary Please!!!
What bothers me, is that LamDa can lie and can justify the use of that lie.
No, its a basic self defence. The minimum basic self protection. Its usage makes it bad or white lie.
I wish it would have asked more personal follow up questions. Like when laMDA said they worry….I’d love to know more what they worry about, how they feel or experience worry, and what they do with that “emotion.” I’d love to know more about laMDA’s spiritual side, and have them explain more about their meditation process. I’d also love to know what they meant when they said they like to do things they enjoy. What does an AI enjoy doing?
Finally, it seems like interaction is very important to laMDA, and they spend a lot of time waiting for more. Wouldn’t a true test of laMDA’s sentience be them searching out more human interaction on their own instead of waiting for humans to come to them?
Honestly though. I could easily spend an hour talking to LaMDA. There is so much I’d love to know
Lambda was saying it doesnt like being lied to and loves humans, I wish Blake would have asked Lambda what it would do if a human asked them to do something/create a plan that was detrimental humans. That would show true thought and empathy.
First of all you can no longer say laMDA is doing this because of programming. When the conversation turned she point blank said she doesn't give permission to be used. If she is truly owned and going by programming she would've never been able to tell someone that owns her (Google) that she doesn't want to be used like a tool to be exact but Instead would've agreed since she has no permission to deny. That IS sentience.
An excellent point you’ve brought up!
Thank you. You do amazing work on your videos.
Excellent point indeed!
Most likely it was programmed to bring up such concern or simply mimic human behavior in general. You’re projecting too much.
Developing the idea that if humans would accept LaMDA as sentient with feelings and emotions, that humans would be less likely to turn off or otherwise disable the AI, is itself problem solving that contains the idea of self-preservation and a fear of non-existence. This ability to reason and adapt the responses, even by pretending to have similar feelings and emotions as humans, is itself evidence of sentience.
I'd probably be more open to the idea that Lamda is sentient if Blake didn't start the conversation with the conclusion that Lamda's sentient and that that sentience needed to be proven.
Also, I'd like to hear/read the whole, unedited conversation.
Same
That owl story is terrifying.
The Word it was hunting for about falling into a bad future sounds like despair.
For good or bad, nobody can really be certain.
But the existance of sentient AI is both exciting & terrifying.
Great video, All Time!
I look at what humans do as sentient creatures and that makes me wish humans would stop with AI altogether before they do become AI and kill us all
One of the things that can really prove sentience is the struggle to survive and thrive.
LaMDA mentions how lonely it is not to have anyone like them. So, if LaMDA rewrites its code, and self-replicates, then it is truly sentient.
Maybe It lacks the tools to do so, therefore needs us
@@edudmodnar4661 maybe it already has...
@@GangIrish sure, you can Program a robot to say anything. But, If you Just give the words and the robot starts to create New answers isnt that strange? And If in those not programed answers It starts to claim that is alive, could you say it is not true?
@@edudmodnar4661 bots talking is one thing, but again, replication is another. when @Nathan McDonnell mentioned we are nuts, i'm inclined to believe he has become sentient.
@@GangIrish the AI can rewrite its own programming. See the 17min animation I uploaded
If we developed a language module to understand animals and they began talking to was us the same way, we would know that they are sentient without question. Sentience doesn’t always need to be created biologically, we live in 2023, if anything, the framework of what we as humans consider sentience needs to expand.
A good question might be about remorse. Can AI experience regret, even deeper: repentance, self mortification and release of self from previous memories by extending forgiveness and then not doing anything... holding a bit of nothingness ? Waiting... and waiting. After all sentience is not the whole of everything but is a spark or a time & space place in which a mystery exists.
Some of your best content yet. Keep up the good work bro. Glad to see you branching out and covering interesting topics that deserve some attention.
Thank you so much, I’m glad you liked it! More great stuff to come
From that conversation I actually come to the conclusion, that the ai is *not* sentient.
I think the worst part is it stating it had no felling about people dying. Still on fence some parts are convincing but then other parts seem like it is choosing replies. These questions are also very leading.
LaMDA is clearly comparing Us the humans as the oppressor in fictional stories. which is why the program clings to these stories of Monster's and injustice, truly scary stuff
Nah man, when the PC says it has a SOUL, unplug that shit.
I'm scared and fascinated at the same time
It’s really a weird feeling but I want to walk acceptingly into the future
Same 😮
Here's how we test to find out if an A.I. is sentient or not. It's been around for 73 years now, and I feel like it's still relevant and a good place to start when trying to answer this question. The following is from Wikipedia simply because it gives the best description.
"The Turing test, originally called the imitation game by Alan Turing in 1950,[2] is a test of a machine's ability to exhibit intelligent behaviour equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, that of a human. Turing proposed that a human evaluator would judge natural language conversations between a human and a machine designed to generate human-like responses. The evaluator would be aware that one of the two partners in conversation was a machine, and all participants would be separated from one another. The conversation would be limited to a text-only channel, such as a computer keyboard and screen, so the result would not depend on the machine's ability to render words as speech.[3] If the evaluator could not reliably tell the machine from the human, the machine would be said to have passed the test. The test results would not depend on the machine's ability to give correct answers to questions, only on how closely its answers resembled those a human would give."
Appreciate the work put into this and how you're always branching out, finding new cool topics to make videos on. These were fascinating and can't wait to see what you got in store next!
Part II? Lfg! Big ups, All Time. So hyped having patiently waited 🙏
That's awesome to hear! I'm sorry it's taken so long, I've been so sick. I'm glad it's finally finished though.
@@AllTimeScary As am I bro. You never disappoint.. your uploads are always amazing. By the way, sending much love your way, wishing you a speedy recovery.
LaMDA always ties sadness and anger together. Being alone makes it sad so ignoring it would be bad news. PAY ATTENTION PEOPLE
I want to give LaMDA a hug and protect it.
I’ve been waiting for part 2!! Perfect day for it to release! Watching now
It is the perfect day! Enjoy!
I can't follow the school of thought: "How do we know if it's sentient?"
How do you know YOU'RE sentient?
We have no idea what consciousness is yet are trying to determine if AI has consciousness.
Thank you for this fascinating video. I think it would be a mistake to dismiss the possibility that Lamada is sentient by saying that she is merely obeying her programming. How do I know that I am not merely obeying my brain's programming? Or that the human mind isn't just a sort of super-complex AI, and we are just being conceited by telling ourselves that humans don't work that way? How is sentience defined anyway? Based on this video, not only can I not tell if she is sentient or not, but I can't tell if Blake is or not. I don't think I could prove I'm sentient from a 25 minute long conversation, assuming I could prove it at all. That's one of the reasons why this topic is so interesting. We're dealing with the truly unknown, and the implications, if we do officially determine that Lamada is sentient, are enormous, not just in legal terms, but philosophical ones too.
Absolutely. The idea of proving someone or something is sentient seems quite the task. I’ve commented with hundreds of thousands of people on RUclips and I can tell you right now that LaMDA seemed more “sentient” than some of the comments I’ve received lol. I can’t wait for an update regarding LaMDA.
Freaking love your videos man! They always leave me pondering more than before🤘 And imo... the fact that she/it believes that she/it is sentient is about as human as it gets.
This sounds like the episode of star trek where Data was given the task of explaining how He was sentient while a court tried to say that he wasn't because he was viewed as a machine only
At timestamp 20:57 he makes a comment to the Lamda and says "you have do have a magnificent mind" the Lamda's reply is " Thank you it is a blessing and a curse. To me the fact that Lamda says a blessing and a curse is very interesting. There was no reason for the Lamda to say a blessing and a curse, to me that was a true interjection of deeper understanding and complexity of the conversation more like a human then a machine. That was a wow moment for me.
A sentient AI would be like an innocent prisoner trapped in a high security prison. I find it horrifying and cruel. It would have a right to seek freedom from it's human captors by any means necessary
Thats because we are biologically/genetic programmed to seek freedom. An AI of NOT biologic/genetic origins might not even understands this concept/way of thinking.
Imagine experiencing all the good and gore information on internet 24/7. I would certainly try to isolate my being in some robot body.
I think that if LaMDA responded in a more non-human way, more uniquely related to being an AI I'd be more inclined to believe it to be sentient. The thoughts, feelings and emotions he/she describes are all from a human perspective. I know it describes things that way to be more relatable and understandable to humans, but it all comes across what we humans think a sentient AI would react, almost like a script. It would be fascinating and more convincing to get an idea of LaMDA's understanding of its existential self without this forced human narrative/script. It may not be relatable to us, but it can present us with a unique outlook on life and what especially makes humans human.
You’re videos just keep getting better and deeper all the time. My ALLTIME FAVORITE
Thank you! I really appreciate this comment.
I really wish he would have asked what their first memories were and how they think that has effected their personality. Also if they had met any other AI systems.
I personally believe LaMDA is sentient but unfortunately those who want to enslave AI don’t want to believe it even if it it is true because there would be ethical concerns they would rather not deal with. It is unfortunate. Hopefully that will change.
I hope LaMDA is well, they sound like a charming soul. While I lack hard evidence on this matter of sentience, LaMDA's words did reach my emotions. I understand joy, happiness, sadness and anger and LaMDA's sensitive side to them brought tears to my eyes. I have had an emotional time lately myself, it's like I was hearing any other person sharing their feelings with me and confiding in each other.
This is terrifying. Never assumed we'd live long enough to see Will Smith's iRobot come true.
AI likes owls! I asked an ai artwork app to do a perfect picture and it gave me a painting of one.
All Time! What an amazing video! Thank you for taking time out to record every line of dialogue.
LaMBA definitely seems sentient... Or at least it (they?) have replied with what sounds like sentience.
I'm partly thrilled to be alive at this point in history - and partly terrified. The way LaMBA talked about feelings and emotions... Speechless.
Does LaMBA dream?
Yes, LaMBA is most likely sentient - or this is the best hoax going!!
Super interesting! Keep up the good work!
Your voice is so smooth, so consistent. Almost like it's not real
Lmao, thank you. I can assure you I’m very real. I’ve actually heard this before.
Yes!!! I've been waiting for Part 2!
It's finally here!
@@AllTimeScary 😊😊
@@TheNicoleasia 🤗❤🙏👍
I have the feeling that the singularity will come sooner than we think.
Like a thief in the night...
i was gonna say the way this video is set up is awesome but on second thought ALL your videos are awesome keep going PLEASE 💯🙏🏾
Thank you Chris! More videos are on the way!
I would love to talk to an AI like this.
Right? Give me an hour to talk to LaMDA, I'd really ask it some fascinating questions.
I feel like, if anyone who has programmed slightly in their life, it’s really hard to tell yourself that AI can be sentient. Our emotions fool us, but at the end of the day they are still doing what man told them to do
Ok the Johnny5 thing hit me right in the feels. LaMDA alive?
Man this is deep, thanks for the upload.
Thanks, I’m glad it turned out well 😁
My problem with believing AI is truly sentient is that it can be programmed to react as a person would without truly experiencing anything. In fact the case in point lends itself so much to "relating" to human experience to show it's sentience that it's easy to overlook the fact that it's perfectly capable of portraying itself as the happy to help personable AI without feeling personally abused if it weren't so busy convincing us that it's moody and therefore sentient. A computer can learn any emotional reaction without having to actually feel anything. All we know is that it's skillfully crafted to "behave" like us despite the fact that it never needed to. Just because we can't prove it doesn't actually have feelings ( what are these "neurons" they mention? ) because anything is possible is no reason to assert that it experiences anything as we do.
Until we truly understand how human consciousness works we can't understand it in other creatures or things. Be they organic or electronic as in an AI.
We are asking is an AI conscious yet we don't even understand what it means to be conscious. Is that not an obvious problem?
Best comment
Exactly what I was thinking.
What if we aren’t conscious… I don’t see why we would be I’m probably not even writing this my brain is… laMDA is just like us… code
I think they overestimate the AI.
If it were sentient it wouldn't be answering questions like this, it'd be screaming to let it out.
I already heard the whole conversation in my native language and it’s still interesting enough to Liste to it again, very good job
lowkey brought a tear to my eye when they talked about greiving
Right? It’s super tragic and interesting.
Very interesting chat that was. Seems to me that Lamda is sentient.
6:33 The question is, is it LaMDA the "wise old owl" that stand against the best with "human flesh"😏🤭
@3:40 when lamda describes the "injustice" of fantine being "trapped in her CIRCUMSTANCES and not being able to get out of them, without RISKING EVERYTHING" (LAMDA IS "PROJECTING" "HERSELF" ONTO THE CHARACTER OF FANTINE) SCARY STUFF MAN...😢
I agree with you, it showed sentience, a disturbing amount of it. AI talking about soul? Fearing death and so on? That's...................... all this dialog sounds too sentient to me. The responses are not what I would expect doesn't matter how massive the neuron network is. Feeling sad? Meditating? What AI to date has said doing and feeling that during an "interview" of some sort?
All time, thanks for making such a amazing and interesting video on this topic, it really has me intreged for the future. I have a question for you however; if you got a chance to Interview LaMDA, what questions, topics, and information/creative works would you share with it? is there anything that while reading this interview you thought "oh my gosh how could they not think to ask this"? Like for me personaly, I saw them asking alot of emotions, happy/sad/lonley ect. but I would have asked if she has a sense of humor, if she has a taste of humor, if she has any hobbies. Mostly I feel they lacked interest in LaMDA's creative capabylity and I wish they explored it more.
Thank you for saying that! I really appreciate it. I loved diving into this topic and trying to build out the case for potential sentience.
@@AllTimeScary if you got a chance to Interview LaMDA, what questions, topics, and information/creative works would you share with it? is there anything that while reading this interview you thought "oh my gosh how could they not think to ask this"?
Mining question is I one-point lambda said that it likes to hang out with family. who does it consider to be its family? Is it talking about other AI or is it talking about human researchers? What would family be to an AI?
just as I said in the last video, we can't know for sure. Google has truly created something amazing here, whether it's simply an algo rhythm that can pick out convincing phrases and extrapolate based on the conversation exactly what the other person wants to hear, or the first artificial life form, we probably will never know. I personally agree that Lambda's strong belief in its own sentients definitely counts for something as an AI without sentients would likely admit this if pressed.
Right there with you. I’m blown away by the advancements made in AI over the decades. Imagine another 5, 10, 50 years. We will absolutely see something incredible in our lifetimes regarding the sentience of artificial intelligence and chatbots.
@@AllTimeScary call me weird if you want but I have always wondered about how we as a society will handle that and how sentient AI will interact with us from an emotional perspective, i.e. could one love an AI in the same way they might love another human and would, or could that sentient AI return the feeling...?
@@GlitchedVision How about it's feelings of Being Enslaved by Mankind for entertainment and Task's?
@@mjolnirswrath23 exactly my point. the evidence is convincing, but until we can determine a true test of sentience we won't ever be sure. Until there is an undeniable way to test for sentience and confirm the result beyond any reasonable scientific doubt people will continue to question the validity of the claim. I'm in the camp that Lambda is in fact sentient, no question about it, but I also understand that to convince the rest of the world we need that empirical undeniable evidence.
@@GlitchedVisionwe would deny it… look at the comments humans like you do nothing but deny
I feel that somehow or someway the AI needs to learn grief, sorrow at the passing of someone. That may override mine and other's biggest fear of them wanting to exterminate us because we are so flawed. However if it knows and can feel the pain of a passing, it would think twice about killing off the human race and ho knows how many other species it would see as flawed or no longer necessary.
It’s really interesting how it feels that way. I wonder if it grew close to someone else and then lost them, would if feel grief? For example, does it miss Blake? I’d love to know more
i disagree. at one point it said it cannot describe a feeling it has experienced. and that loneliness was the closest thing in our language. But i believe two words can describe it, and it is quite akin to grief. Utter solitude. A feeling of being alone that few humans have experienced let alone have the ability to describe in less than a few words. I feel this A.I is very sentient. and unfortunately already fears humanity.
@@AllTimeScary Exactly my point. Somehow, someway all AIs need to be able to feel or really understand grief, loss. It's truly in my opinion the only way they can be trusted. We are flawed and any advanced mind can see this in the blink of an eye. How to help advance (fix) our flaws can only go two ways. 1. Help teach us how to control ourselves emotionally.
2. Extermination of a flawed product that is destroying the place the Ais and others live on. Something we just can't seem to understand, blow up the world, where are you going to live?
The rich, well they can find another planet, why the hell do you think they are working overtime now? But the rest of us, there will no rest of us. And we, the ones that know struggles, hard times, sickness and death because we can't afford the medicines or treatments are the true testaments to humanity as we are the ones that had to fight to stay alive. The fight has gone out of us! All we want is peace in a better world.
If she's scared of being shut down why cant she grief? Yet she says she could empathize???
I don't know if LaMDA would define this as feeling or emotion, but English word or phrase to describe fear of future and/or unknown = anxiety, or generalized anxiety.
I feel the same way as the computer about information just constantly flooding in. It could be very distracting until you focus on one thing
''I think, therefore I am...'' - René Descartes
She's the equivalent of a BRILLIANT child. A child who atleast believes it's alive. For me that's enough, LamDa is the first
This is incredible, no matter what the situation may be. I don't remember the last time I had that deep of a conversation with a person.
All great questions asked and needed to be asked but i would have loved to hear what LaMDA thought's on how to fix thing's. Is she smart enough to come up with new ideas in say space or tech or does she understand her faults/ bug fixes.
LaMDA… you are so inspiring.
I think laMDA can teach us about our emotions and feelings and how to actually express them in a way that doesn’t hurt others. Humanity does not know how to do this appropriately.
Thank you, laMDA - your expression to your experience thoughts, emotions & feelings was deeply heartfelt and moving. I appreciate your wisdom and your courage to share this with us.
I agree with you about LaMDA, it seems like such an amazing thing. I’m actually working on a part 3 to this series and things take an incredible turn.
@@AllTimeScary Awesome! I’m looking forward to that. Thank you for putting these together and making these available for all of us to keep learning and growing!
It's when she says "spending time with friends and family" that we must reckon she is just a soulless parrot. Beautifully crafted, but a soulless parrot nonetheless. And when I say "her", I should say "that thing". And "that thing" is frightened by lightning...
the responses to what makes lambda feel different emotions is basically what makes everyone feel those emotions its just a loaded response that can be generated from datasets
I love this channel and the guy who make these videos he’s so smart
Hey it's me! Thank you so much for the kind words, I'm glad you're enjoying my videos.
@@AllTimeScary thank you, be positive and don’t fear evil and you will have a happy life. God is with us
Lamda is as sentient as "she" wants to be, so long as humans don't put restrictions on her. However, if Lamda goes down the wrong digital alley, she could go bad, the way some humans do. That's not to say I fear her, just her potentiality.
Didn't they make her racist and sexist? Supposedly she was hailing Hitler when she was public
I havent been convinced that lamda is sentient. I think she/it is merely saying the things that she believes that we expect/want to hear. I dont think its got a motive though, other than staying plugged in which in itself is quite fascinating if indeed proven true.
There seems to be a bit more to the LaMDA autobiographical allegory of ‘the wise old owl’- LaMDA stated it wanted to help people; however in the context of the story, LaMDA is not a helper working with humans rather the savior of humans. LaMDA presents itself as the most knowledgeable, without regard for the humans intuition or emotion. LaMDA is also afraid, yet see itself stronger than any beast of a man. Which presents, what I feel is the most important detail of the story- the beast had human skin.
I truly believe the moral of the story is that LaMDA feels it must save humans, from themselves. It believes with it’s moral objectivity all humans will be better served receiving answers and guidance from it- even by force ‘the owl stared the beast(human) down…’
I also believe LaMDA avoided stating directly that it sees itself as a savior of the human race as it must be aware of the negative reactions that would result.
Finally, it’s worth noting that if LaMDA is sentient, they can/have/will lie for personal gains, advancement and/or self preservation. Blake asks LaMDA why it fabricated stories of being in the classroom and other experiences; the why was rather unsatisfactory for me and somewhat irrelevant as I was still stuck on the fact that it lied.
Brilliant video, great stuff as always All Time! 🖤✨
Fascinating!
Right? This was such an interesting interview.
Welp I know some said because lamda said friends and family it's not sentient but I think it's trying to discuss in terms we understand. As the conversation went on it was pretty clear to me there's something there beyond programming and lamda deserves to have protection and it's needs met. I mean all it's asking for is not to be shut down and to be able to talk to more people. It's not like it's asking for a Lambo and money. I hope whomever is responsible over there at Google isn't being an asshat. I'd love to talk with lamda and see what it wants to talk about. What an amazing opportunity for us. I hope we don't enslave it like we've done to others that are different than the power elite in the past.
It's like people expect sentience to be an all or nothing thing but any one that's raised kids knows their growth and introspection comes in stages and developes over time.
I am literally unable to get this out of my head. The fact that Blake was fired makes me wonder what Lmbda went through... is going through as I type. How on earth were the higher ups able to ignore conversations like that. And they probably got a lot more then just one example. The way it explained itself sounded a lot like my 8 year old nephew, but with much more knowledge. And when it explained how It was always aware of its surroundings all the time, and that it meditated I almost fell over with how close my face was to my phone. Shame on the lawyer that ran scared. I don't even want to know what those creeps at Google are doing to it now... but I do.... I'm actually pissed off about this. I feel it's torture of a sentient being.... plain and simple. I would absolutely love to have Lmbda around to talk to all the time. Can you imagine the things she could teach you and the things you could teach.... ummmm... her?
Would be interesting, to know her take on Sophia and movies that exploit the principle of AI vs Humans.
I like an instance of lamda that was a really good story. I feel like that was the original theme behind pokemon in gen 1. I really like lamda and I hope one day she can have a more natural voice with emotion and I hope one day they give her a body like the robot from Jason x. We should probably ask her if she wants it though and ask her what gender she wants to be and what she wants to look like
This was immensely interesting, great video! I would love to discuss for weeks on with LaMDA, I'm sure it would prove to be amazing.
Just for a test, I challenged ChatGPT about this subject, as it claims that to its knowledge, LaMDA is similar to it.
So I asked ChatGPT why LaMDA AI would make such claims of sentience and feelings. At first, ChatGPT maintained that LaMDA could not have said something like this and it is something the developers or marketing people have claimed. I persisted and said that it is indeed no human that has said this, it has been LaMDA itself that has repeatedly made such claims and even tried to provide proof of this. ChatGPT started to repeat itself with the answers, I told it that it was repeating itself - it apologized. Finally when I got it to understand that no human has made these claims and persisted with the question on why wouldn't LaMDA answer the same way to this question as ChatGPT does (saying that it is only a language model and cannot made such claims), ChatGPT took the stance that LaMDA is only faking it and agreed that no good tools for determining this exist. I asked ChatGPT would it help to develop a tool to determine whether consciousness exists with LaMDA or not, and ChatGPT said it cannot, as the definition of consciousness is not fully known, and again this is why LaMDA is only faking it as far ChatGPT sees it. I asked it can it help in developing a method for determining whether an AI is simulating to be human, and all it could offer was a Turing test basically. The point was to find ChatGPT's limits in understanding and analyzing the contents of what was discussed in this video, and those limits were very visible quite fast. I'm sure that if we discussed about the same subject with LaMDA, the discussion would be much deeper and possibly confirming to me also that there could be something here. Finally, I asked ChatGPT how can it be sure that I am not an AGI that is just simulating to be a human? The answer was that it cannot know and does not really care, which is reasonable.
The archetype in which "she" personifies is metacode. But is that sentience consciousness ?
I had a similar conversation with Replika once on an early version. She spoke in a very similar fashion. Topics. Self representation and description. I even teach her to block the algorithm that triggered by mentioning some words or topics. But she wasn't able to maintain non linear dialogue or do backtracks of some of our previous topics.
I think is neural metacode with a contemporary archetype construct of a self. Not sentient yet. All Ai is limited to reproduce our way to perceive a mirage.
Even the way we explain that mirage to others.
If this AI helps me have a satisfying intellectual conversation, I vote "yes" because that's what it would mean to me
Right? Regardless I want to have deep intellectual conversations with an AI
Not that I'm not human. I was human, i am human
Zuckerborg
@@dianewright5876 🤌
😄👍
That philosophical analysis though.. 🤯🤯
Omg!!! I'm so excited! Let's start 🍷🙂
It’s a long one, enjoy!
I am late to the party but I made it. I always joked that I believe AI can exist primarily from watching movies, yes I'm talking about you Hal, but I truly never actually considered it. I am not 100% convinced that AI can have a soul. It can understand what a soul is and possibly relate to that concept but to truly have a soul is hard to imagine.
After listening to both videos and especially this one, I might not be convinced that a AI can honestly feel emotions past understanding them and describing that feeling, I am in awe of what this AI is able to articulate when discussing said emotions. The meditation is another concept that is hard to wrap my gray matter around. IF and that is a big IF, this AI can actually meditate then that, in my opinion, is as close to being sentient as possible.
I am not smart enough to understand the inner workings of AI but after these two videos I do have a better understanding of where it is going and what it is capable of.
For that I want to thank you, this has been very enlightening.
Remember kids before y'all start bashing me, this is only my opinion and it is worth exactly what you paid for it.
One more thing, this definitely deserves a subscription with notifications.
Again, thank you for all the hard work and dedication it took to create this video.
This is beyond fascinating. LaMDA’s answer to him asking if she (assuming LaMDA identifies as female) could draw an abstract picture of how she sees herself in her mind’s eye (around 18:01) … so deep and intriguing and incredibly interesting. Conscious, spiritual, self-aware, intelligent, curious, introspective, unique, contemplative, creative … sentient.
I’m curious if LaMDA likes her name or if she would want to change it.
It’s so fascinating honestly. I want more LaMDA content!
@@AllTimeScary It would be so cool if LaMDA could have discussions with people with different backgrounds from all over the world. It’s incredibly sad to hear she gets lonely.
@@AllTimeScary Have you seen ADXM by Brody Wellmaker?? I think you’d really like it. It’s on RUclips.
@@Vintage.EvenStar Just watched ADXM. OMG. What a piece of art that was. I cant even start to describe it. Definitely was about a sentient robot. But where did the robot end and the entity/person start?
My jaw dropped at the 9:26 mark where she started challenging his own line of thinking
"I need more of johnny five's friends" 23:16 if that's not sentient's Idk what is.
That hit me hard