Benny Morris: Irgun, Stern and Haganah

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 сен 2024

Комментарии • 24

  • @Samuel-sx1mq
    @Samuel-sx1mq Год назад +19

    It's not debatable that they were ALL terrorists. The irgun group was responsible for over a dozen bombings..mostly civilians...eg town marketplaces/shuk or Arab owned hotels/buildings.

  • @mortef
    @mortef 2 года назад +11

    This video fails to tell the story about the israeli-terrorist groups mentioned in the title.

  • @BorsosGabor2023
    @BorsosGabor2023 Год назад +15

    They are responsible for the Palestinian Holocaust.

    • @123456789987o
      @123456789987o 8 месяцев назад

      In the Shoa 7 million Jews were industrially killed by the Nazis in death camps. The Nakba was the displacement of ~710'000 Palestinians as a result of the 1948 war. Comparing the two events by calling the latter a "Holocaust" is relativising the former.

    • @el_chico1313
      @el_chico1313 4 месяца назад +1

      bullshit ^2

    • @1czechit1
      @1czechit1 3 месяца назад +1

      The Arab flight happened because a man by the name of Hussein Khalidi claimed (falsely) that the "jews" (IZL and Lehi) raped women after the battle of Dir Yassin. (and 254 people were murdered) then the Arabbe fled in mass. (later research showed only about 100 people died in the BATTLE and there was no massacre or rape.)
      Later in 1948 some guy (Constantine Zurayk) wrote a book called "On the Meaning of the Disaster (Nakba)" the Nakba was the inability of seven Arab armies to defeat the Jews. In his book he had not nice things to say about the Arabs of the land of Israel. One word he used was impotent.
      There is no Palestinian Holocaust but according to the Arab leaders, they wanted to do one on the Jews.

  • @1czechit1
    @1czechit1 3 месяца назад

    The Irgun and Lehi's battle in Dir Yassin (the Palmach actually finished it) caused such bombastic claims (by British Jewish Agency, the dissidents, but mostly by one Hussien Khalidi) that the Arab population FELD (estimated 350,000). To say they had little effect is to ignore the IZL was the size of a brigade, it took Jaffa (forcing the Egyptians to enter further south) and of course the Dir Yassin fallout...

  • @1czechit1
    @1czechit1 3 месяца назад

    Irgun was established in 1931.

  • @1czechit1
    @1czechit1 3 месяца назад

    Benny needs to learn history. The Lehi did not fight the Arabs from an ideological point of view and were allied to the Abu Gosh. The Irgun also had allies in the Druze community.

  • @J14Irish
    @J14Irish 4 дня назад

    This man is a revisionist.

  • @askeladden450
    @askeladden450 Месяц назад

    Irgun: Colonists and invaders who routinely carried out terrorist attacks on civilians and officials to further their colonist agenda
    Benny: Uhhh, maybe terrorists, maybe freedom fighters
    Hamas: Persecuted group who carry out terrorist attacks as a last ditch attempt to fight against their occupiers and invaders.
    Benny: Definitely the most reprehensible terrorists
    If this doesnt make you see how biased he is, nothing will.

    • @aviwinegarten3859
      @aviwinegarten3859 11 дней назад

      The Jews never had this hate that the people of Gaza have, I’m talking about indoctrination of children with school textbooks that shows maths examples of killing Jews, no the Jews never hated that much. And trust me, if there is one group who have the right to hate peoples who have done wrong by them it’s without a question the Jews and yet they just forgive and forget and try move on with life, unlike the Arabs who just love to sit in death.