Kate Winslet has an uncanny ability to make people cry. And the fact that she's singing this to Scrooge somehow makes this even sadder. Maybe because you know exactly what the situation is.
i remember when i first saw the clip, i nearly keeled over from shock to learn that she was the singer - what a voice! she should really sing more often.
incredible voice, never knew Kate could sing that beautiful, guess her talent runs everywhere, and the song is extraordinary, something to treasure, the song, but that voice, so soothing, remarkable.
I'm still amazed this is Kate Winslett , nothing personal; just didn't expect her to be a singer and actress. AMAZING song from beginning to end! Love it!
i love it her voice is amazing...she is a real talent...she can sing more....cause she really have a wonderful voice...not like other who think they are the best singers...she is an actress and she can sing also...but she can sing very good...and this is amazing
OH MY GOD.... ...I never even knew Kate had released a song. Never. I immediately googled this when I saw her name next to the title. It was a shock. She has a gorgeous voice - I never knew she could sing so beautifully. Sounds like an angel...
+LaueeeCarter I know right!!!!! I'm a huge Titanic fan, I hate it when people make jokes meant to be bad about it because it's like literally my favorite movie.
This song is so relevant for me right now. Rather than splitting up with my ex I should have stayed and supported him. He is the clever, compassionate, determined and hard working man I have ever met. I just wish that long distance had gone better while being at university. But I'm obviously not good enough for him as I didn't stay. and now I'm in a "rebound" relationship with someone I don't ever think I'll be in love with. If you have taken the time to read my sad confession, learn from my mistake. xxx
I know a lot of people who slagged this song off as well as Kate's singing abilities. But it takes an amazing singer to bring emotion to a song and to make people cry and in my opinion she has such a beautiful voice :)
Omg I remember being so young and sitting in my bedroom constantly sitting by the window and singing this song all the time...brings back so many memories
From the movie. As kids, we were always led to believe Scrooge was a mean old man. If you read the whole of Dickens' book you get to understand what a rotten childhood he experienced. His big mistake was letting go of the love of his life. If Kate had been around then he might have thought twice about it though!
When I broke up with my boyfriend I kept singing this song and now I feel empty without him, and now I wish I never broke up with him. And now I keep singing with song. I love u henry gill :'(
Kate Winslet has garnered many accolades to her name, but often overlooked is the fact that she is a bona fide one-hit-wonder. “What If” is her only entry on the chart (so far…), but don’t be duped : this is a piece of epic scale‼️ “What If”* is anything but a timid song. It is a truly soaring Disney-esque ballad, and there is no hiding spot. Kate Winslet might have humbly declared that while she could carry a tune, she definitely was not a singer**. Yet, there is more than enough evidence within “What If” to contradict her averment. BUT must we categorize, label, tag, pigeonhole all and sundry? NO‼️ AND can’t actresses and actors also sing beautifully now and then with no strings attached? YES‼️ Well, with that in mind, “What If”, performed by lauded actress Kate Winslet, remains SIMPLY ENDEARINGLY CHARMING. Period. 💜🎬🎶💚 * “What If” was recorded for the animated film “Christmas Carol : The Movie” (2001). ** Hum… Hasn’t Nicole Kidman uttered just about the same words time and again⁉️
This video is so touching I am a big fan of Kate Winslet and she is a huge inspiration in my life. She is a perfect role-model for me and what I believe in. And in the movie TITANIC.
This is so beautiful kate....I hope you get this message but you have the most angelic voice...heavenly in fact.I must admit that i didnt even know that you had such an amazing voice!Tell me do you write your own music?I have some songs that I have written that I would like you listen to.I think they would be great for your voice.your music brings tears to my eyes.what a wonderful lady you are.Thanks for sharing this with us all and bringing joy to the world. Sincerely Adam
A real beauty- outside and inside! I really have become spellbound to hear her mesmerizing voice with wonderful delivery of a beautiful song❣️I wish her success in this arena too like acting in the movie. 👌
i had this on a cd "now thats what i call music 50" in 2001 i played this song that much that i scratched the disk, i was 13 and had no idea of the emotion in these lyrics just loved her voice, wicked song
i can fully relate to this song. it always touches my heart everytime i hear it. so many "what if's" in life...at the back of my mind, this is what's playing everytime i talk to my ex. we're still good friends and we still love each other...but we're both leading different lives now. i'll never find someone like him for sure. i just wonder if we didn't walk out then...would it still be the same for us? i guess we'll never know...i love u crazy...i'll always will.
I never knew Kate Winslet was in the singing industry, until I saw this track under the trrack listing of a compilation CD named 'Most Relaxing Voices of All Times'. I see now why they named the CD that. Her voice it beautiful :)
I agree with you Gemma, I love this song, it reminds me of my dearly beloved family members who have passed away from the big 'C', I get emotional listening to this song
I never really know that Kate Winslet can sing and she had a beautiful voice.🤗🤗🤗
She sings just like Celine Dion!
""Cause I still love you more than I can say" never fails to make me cry
xxibkaren awwwwww that's sweet
Haha love the comments
When she said
"If i stayed, if you tried. If only we could turn back time" Hits like a ton of bricks 🥺
I feel you 💖
So true. I know that pain.
Kate Winslet has an uncanny ability to make people cry. And the fact that she's singing this to Scrooge somehow makes this even sadder. Maybe because you know exactly what the situation is.
teary eyes...😢😢😢
God, I love this song. Makes me cry everytime, it's such a beautiful song.
Gemma Kirkby So do I.
Same
Gemma Kirkby sí, es muy linda
Gemma Kirkby
It's not the song. It's these invisible onions ;)
Same here listened to it over and over again
HAPPY BIRTHDAY kate winslet.!!!!
Dear Kate winslet,
Stop making me cry !!!! xxx
sorry no chance
@Vidushi Dasgupta yrp
i remember when i first saw the clip, i nearly keeled over from shock to learn that she was the singer - what a voice! she should really sing more often.
incredible voice, never knew Kate could sing that beautiful, guess her talent runs everywhere, and the song is extraordinary, something to treasure, the song, but that voice, so soothing, remarkable.
Legitimately brings a tear to my eye. It's a question we all ask sometimes...what if? A question we should ask more often. Think about it...
beautiful song and beautiful voice! I always used to listen to it when i was younger and it is still as lovely as i remember.
Beautiful KATE WINSLET for this wonderful song.
Saddest part is in reality, there’s no what if. Once it’s gone, there’s nothing left but regrets.
I know the feeling............
That’s true 😢😭💔
Yes, that's true.
I'm still amazed this is Kate Winslett , nothing personal; just didn't expect her to be a singer and actress. AMAZING song from beginning to end! Love it!
i love it her voice is amazing...she is a real talent...she can sing more....cause she really have a wonderful voice...not like other who think they are the best singers...she is an actress and she can sing also...but she can sing very good...and this is amazing
OH MY GOD....
...I never even knew Kate had released a song. Never. I immediately googled this when I saw her name next to the title. It was a shock.
She has a gorgeous voice - I never knew she could sing so beautifully.
Sounds like an angel...
Oh finally,found it 😍 This is my favorite song. I always play this everytime I sleep back then when I was young.
What if I had never let you go.....
THAT'S WHY HE TOLD YOU NOT TO LET GO ROSE XD
+FLMproductions101 wait, is this song for Titanic? :o
+HazelEyes303 I don't think so. I'm pretty sure this was a theme song for the 2001 Christmas Carol.
Ohh okay haha.
+LaueeeCarter I knowse I was just making a joke :3
+LaueeeCarter I know right!!!!! I'm a huge Titanic fan, I hate it when people make jokes meant to be bad about it because it's like literally my favorite movie.
This is a great song and Kate has such a beautiful voice!
I Wish Kate Winslet would come out and sing some more. So beautiful. Thumbs up if you agree that it's a great song and so the singer!
Kate winslet is a powerful singer
U can say that again.
@@brittanymartin6122 kate winslet is a powerful singer
You could say that again
@@BooksfromaBiGuy Kate winslet is a powerful singeeerrrrrr
Say it again
Anybody here listening to this amazing song in 2020
im in 😁😁
Me... I didnt know kate winslet sing this song... Made me cry.
On and on
Me alright
me and singing it, too.. love this song as well as kate winslet
I just love this song! Great voice, great lyric!
Magic....🥰😘
Kate, we need more songs from you.
Beautiful song. You have a nice voice...Kate winslet..
amazing woman, amazing song, amazing voice!!!
LOVE IT! Its such a sweet, calm, emotional & relaxing song. 5 Stars!
xx
Wow didn't know she can sing like this. Wonderful song. I hope to hear more of her singing voice.
What a great voice
Oh my word! She sings so beautifully!!
Kate Winslet, you have a beautiful voice and you're an amazing actress :D
This iş really emotional great song and I love this song,Kate Winslet sings so beautifully!!
she's beautiful, i like hearing the sound of her voice....that's great
Einfach gnadenlos begabt...sowohl im singen als auch im schaupielern!
♥Love her!♥
I sang this ever since it came out and Kate sings beautifully
Sorry to hear about your loss. this a lovely song may good lord rest his soul in peace.
This song is so relevant for me right now. Rather than splitting up with my ex I should have stayed and supported him. He is the clever, compassionate, determined and hard working man I have ever met. I just wish that long distance had gone better while being at university. But I'm obviously not good enough for him as I didn't stay. and now I'm in a "rebound" relationship with someone I don't ever think I'll be in love with.
If you have taken the time to read my sad confession, learn from my mistake. xxx
Hannah Jackson. Same here.
same here
Hannah Jackson 😢😭i feel u😢
Hannah Jackson For the sake of the poor guy you're in a relationship with but don't love - please walk away and let him go.
I know a lot of people who slagged this song off as well as Kate's singing abilities. But it takes an amazing singer to bring emotion to a song and to make people cry and in my opinion she has such a beautiful voice :)
Makes me cry all the time, her voice is so beautiful
Omg!! I didnt know she sang!!!
even if i'm feeling on top of the world, hearing this song makes my cry immediately, its just so deep and the words really carry alot of meaning ;(
Ye):):):
I do not think she has the most amazing voice in the world BUT the song is beautiful and she sings it with many emotion. I love the song!!
I love this song!!! She is The Voice! 🥰
Omg I remember being so young and sitting in my bedroom constantly sitting by the window and singing this song all the time...brings back so many memories
I love her so much. She's perfection!
This song is SO beautiful... just like Kate!
From the movie. As kids, we were always led to believe Scrooge was a mean old man. If you read the whole of Dickens' book you get to understand what a rotten childhood he experienced. His big mistake was letting go of the love of his life. If Kate had been around then he might have thought twice about it though!
I love that movie
This movie version of the story ends on a hopeful note, with him at least getting to meet his former fiancée again.
Omg! I really love this song... She's a great singer
I never knew Jeanine could sing... LOL but I love Kate's voice, I SWEAR!
This song makes me cry it's so beautiful!💕❤️😭🤧
I never knew she could sing, but she is really good.
I love you Kate. You are the most beautiful actress. Xx ❤ ❤
When I broke up with my boyfriend I kept singing this song and now I feel empty without him, and now I wish I never broke up with him. And now I keep singing with song. I love u henry gill :'(
+lucy fullick lol
A friend of mine I'd not seen for years, I saw her perform this song at a flower show today. And now the song reminds me of her.
listening August 2020.😘 finally found this song, been looking for a long time .
Kate Winslet has garnered many accolades to her name, but often overlooked is the fact that she is a bona fide one-hit-wonder. “What If” is her only entry on the chart (so far…), but don’t be duped : this is a piece of epic scale‼️
“What If”* is anything but a timid song. It is a truly soaring Disney-esque ballad, and there is no hiding spot.
Kate Winslet might have humbly declared that while she could carry a tune, she definitely was not a singer**. Yet, there is more than enough evidence within “What If” to contradict her averment.
BUT must we categorize, label, tag, pigeonhole all and sundry? NO‼️ AND can’t actresses and actors also sing beautifully now and then with no strings attached? YES‼️
Well, with that in mind, “What If”, performed by lauded actress Kate Winslet, remains SIMPLY ENDEARINGLY CHARMING. Period. 💜🎬🎶💚
* “What If” was recorded for the animated film “Christmas Carol : The Movie” (2001).
** Hum… Hasn’t Nicole Kidman uttered just about the same words time and again⁉️
Awesome! will always be my favorite song. What if my dear.💖
i had no idea kate winslet could sing!! shes great
Loved this song since it came out :) So beautiful!
omg, this song brings back so many memories, i love it!!!
This song says exactly how i feel. the thoughts i cant say out loud! Every word means a lot !
This video is so touching I am a big fan of Kate Winslet and she is a huge inspiration in my life. She is a perfect role-model for me and what I believe in. And in the movie TITANIC.
But we are still asking ourselves: "What if?"
Great song, great sync. Well done.
Kate you're great!! :)))) Not just an actress also a singer.
MARVELLOUS GOD BLESS U WITH A WONDERFULLLLLLLL VOICE U MUST BE THANK FULL TO GOD !!!!
LIVE LONG KATE😁😁😁
This is so beautiful kate....I hope you get this message but you have the most angelic voice...heavenly in fact.I must admit that i didnt even know that you had such an amazing voice!Tell me do you write your own music?I have some songs that I have written that I would like you listen to.I think they would be great for your voice.your music brings tears to my eyes.what a wonderful lady you are.Thanks for sharing this with us all and bringing joy to the world.
Sincerely
Adam
I freaking love Kate Winslet! She is my favorite person on the Earth.
A real beauty- outside and inside! I really have become spellbound to hear her mesmerizing voice with wonderful delivery of a beautiful song❣️I wish her success in this arena too like acting in the movie. 👌
Love this, makes me remember my past
Love this song and you have done an amazing job with the video!! Xx
This is how i feel when i drop my sandwich
Kye Dysarthria lol
haha
LOL haha
You made me spit my juice got dammit
i had this on a cd "now thats what i call music 50" in 2001 i played this song that much that i scratched the disk, i was 13 and had no idea of the emotion in these lyrics just loved her voice, wicked song
My all time favorite song..
i was so shocked to hear that kate winslet sang this song ... she has a beautiful voice and it fits this song perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i can fully relate to this song. it always touches my heart everytime i hear it. so many "what if's" in life...at the back of my mind, this is what's playing everytime i talk to my ex. we're still good friends and we still love each other...but we're both leading different lives now. i'll never find someone like him for sure. i just wonder if we didn't walk out then...would it still be the same for us? i guess we'll never know...i love u crazy...i'll always will.
Same thoughts. :(
I can feel you..
I never knew Kate Winslet was in the singing industry, until I saw this track under the trrack listing of a compilation CD named 'Most Relaxing Voices of All Times'. I see now why they named the CD that. Her voice it beautiful :)
When my dad first left this was the song my mum played and I started crying but he’s back now xxx
love dis song soo muchh!.. 1 ov my fav songs!! xx
i didn't know that she was that good at singing...
its awsome :)
there always a What If in life & life goes on.
This song really moves me it really shivers down my spine I just love kate's singing voice.
I'm simply enravished... this song is sooo heart-felt and ... I just haven't words...
Oh My God! I didnt know she sang! this is such a good song :) her voice is so pretty
love it! :) i always heard it when i was little :)
This song was played at my daddys funeral rip daddy
Awww:( I'm sorry.
Sorry man.
Sorry😦
😥❤💙
i am completely blown away by her voice...i am totally singing this at my next singing competition...I'm so gonna win!...incredible song!
her and Celine are my faves!
Stunning voice!
Kate to Leo aka Rose to Jack... 😓💕
neva58 yes I know...
💔❤️💔❤️
'I'll never let go, I promise'
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Beautiful song ❤️
kate winslet?
+Dezzy she's an actress, she played Rose in Titanic
I agree with you Gemma, I love this song, it reminds me of my dearly beloved family members who have passed away from the big 'C', I get emotional listening to this song
gosh ,,, i never heard her singing before but she's so awesome :)
It's so beautiful! I Love this song!
I used to love this song so much. Since then, my music taste has moved on. I'm into metal and rock now, but I can still relate to this, somehow.
aww shes so sweet! Amazing voice! And shes great actress
so strong and meaningful makes me cry 😢
heartwarming song!!! Love it!!!
I love this song, it makes me think about the one I love more than anything
i lovvveeee this song , it's one of the best romantic songs ever