Wow this man blew me away…. “If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose peace” “If you choose absolute justice, there will be war indefinitely “…. This is literally what I am going through in my life about all the people who have wronged me. You literally cannot change the past. It’s just a fact This is one wisemen!!!!! Peace on the world and in our hearts God we need your light!!!!
Peace should be an end goal sure, but Imagine slaves chose peace instead of liberty, would you support the oppressed to fight for their freedom? Should nelson mandela thats denounced as terrorist till 2008 by the US accepted apartheid in south africa and chose peace instead of retaliation?
Peace we pray and also that all people will know the love that Jesus has for them that they know you as their saviour, and great high priest our intercessor our best friend the lover of our souls amen 💕
yes peace is the first step always. A belief in higher justice to deliver what could not be given on the ground by us imperfect humans also helps. But absolute justice is impossible to deliver down here.....is why peace must be made first.....and a good system of trust and verify to slowly heal after it.
Great Interview and great perspective. He had direct family in a terrorist attack and was still able to advocate against revenge and for peace. The world would be a better place with more people like him.
@@lishaybachar yeah, sure. Then why did you fools vote that war monger, arrogant, brute yahoo in office? And polls in the past have shown high support by Israelis for violent retaliation and incursions in Palestine. Just read an analysis by Norman Finkelstein or Chomsky
One of the best interviews I've heard on the Israeli predicament, both internally and involving the Palestinians. The true voice of reason and sanity. Thank you Uval Harari and thanks to Piers for having him!
Limiting the whole conflict to Natenyahu & Hamas is the purpose of Israel deep-state that Yuval is serving. You can be a historian and writer but still servant of political regime. Don"t fall for it. They have done the same whenever aggression fails. Dont let sweet peace talk fouls you. He did nothing to stop the atrocities done by hus government. Do your research
You guys don’t expect much. This guy is so over his head here. He even admitted as much. He’s merely an historian. That’s it! You are both so gullible. Sad.
@@user-fs8tl7ni1wI disagree. History provides a view of the present circumstances. I think his viewpoints impart a degree of wisdom whereby a solution can begin to emerge if heeded.
You are operating out of an assumption that reality belies. He has zero formal education to place anything from history into perspective, other than military history of a defined period. Zero!
What an admirable man who still has a balanced humanist conversation on the topic despite having his relatives being the victims of this terrorist attack. That was a very powerful constructive and enlightening conversation.
I find it hard to see how people who've had their land stolen, their children slaughtered and the remaining survivors being stuffed into the world's only concentration camp for 16 years lashing out if they were able to break out of the concentration camp as a "terrorist attack." I guess according to your logic the slave revolts in 1831 had nothing to do with slavery and they were just terrorists too? Lets stop with this nonsense and come back to reality.
Noah said must go back to the Saudi deal. That's not the way. Start talking about a Palestinian State and forget the Saudi deal. The genocide in Gaza will be bad. Arab countries probably will go back on the Abraham Accords.
Yes, because he has the most powerful country backing them up (the usa),they have the luxury to be able to do that this way. What kind of peace is he talking about when their country is built on false rights and lies? They already raped other people’s countries and stayed there by force and by creating terrorism themselves! You should take many things into consideration!
Are you deaf? He condemned the atrocities against Palestinians and said they weren't justified. He called for dignity and hope and protection for Palestinian civilians. Don't makes stuff up to fit your narrative. Stick to truth.
He did but then he continued to say that Israel had to finish of Hamas. We have now seen for 3 weeks who is going to pay suffering for that. Remember Israel has no new casualties except for those hostages that are considered collateral damage.
I am Egyptian Pro Palestinian but have to admit that this man logic makes more sense than many ppl managing this conflict. Wish Israeli government listen to him.
Harari's profound understanding of history enables him to offer a remarkably balanced perspective on a conflict that's deeply personal. Thank you, Noah, for sharing such invaluable insights, and kudos to Piers for the exceptional coverage amidst this tragic conflict!
He offered unrealistic solutions. To keep Palestinians to only Gaza and the West bank. 1967 Israel illegally annexed plenty of Palestinians land. This is at the very least what they want back.
I totally understand but at least the guy was able to see both sides of the isle and consider some type of solution. Most guests just take their side and stick with it.
@@fernandomatara4299but the unfortunately israeli zionist govt IS 'aiming to kill every palestinian' and flatten gaza. It flouts every int law with the complete impuniy and backing of USA.
@@fernandomatara4299 there is no both sides..one side is literally living in an open air prison with check points under apartheid. that's not a lets look at both sides scenario..one side is clearly in the wrong..
I am an Egyptian and i am very happy to see reasonable humanitarian voices come out of israel. Yes peace is more important than justice and we are willing to forgive nakba but we need hope. Our people deserve better
You don't have to forget the Nakba, and Jews won't forget the expulsions from the Arab world, including Egypt. However you can agree to move forward and secure a safer life for your children, which Israel and Egypt have done
@jka461 jews always lived among us very peacefully. The oppression was done in europe not among Muslims. Jews moving to palestine after 1948 was due to the zinonist movement. We didn't expell them.
@@truth8422and yet they lived safely in Muslim countries for more than thousand years. While in this same time they were being slaughtered and expelled in Europe
The most balanced person i have seen on this debate so far. I wish more people and particularly politicians could talk about this issue with this level of maturity n humanity
Most of the Israelis think that way. I mean... Israel is angry on Hamas and their followers. But not on Palestinians that want peace and agree to 2 state solution.
I personally think that the Ex-Hamas leader's son is more reliable and balanced, Yuval Noh Harari is a very intelligent man, but he has a very dogmatic and inaccurate way of interpreting our reality in Israel, the dogma being globalist and a bit of a "woke" take on things.. so Yuval won't talk about how Hamas is popular in Gaza and its very much a Gaza grassroots movement, its not separate from Palestinians and that is why the west,Israel and the PLO are pushing of elections in the west bank for decades, cause Hamas will win, Hamas is rooted in Palestinian culture and the Islamic Jihad organization also..of course there are who aren't at all supporters, but its not such a large fraction as being sold The problem is that neither Yuval non other similar experts can provide a model for liberal countries who are fighting non-liberal forces on how to win and survive, there's no modern example of such a case..There's no advice for us in Israel, give territories? we did, failed and just risked us all, we are fighting a war with lawyers without trying to win it cause we're careful on so many levels against an enemy who could care less and uses it against us.
@@jj-uy6qs Oh I get it. After Hamas killed 40 baybies they understood that they got a bad rap and they need to turn this around with a propaganda on Israelis and say something like "Yeah, we killed 40 babies but Israel is killing a kid every 10 minutes" 😂 Rael mature.
Yuval Noah Harari is a very wise man. As an Israeli, I wish he would be an advisor to Israeli government. We need peace. Nobody wants deaths and revenge. All people, both Israelis and Palestinians, want a happy life. Not war.
A word salad to justify a Palestinian massacre with half truths. He forgot to mention that his uncles live in an occupied territory and probably killed or expel Palestinians to live there
I sincerely hope that viewers focus on the essence of this interview rather than getting caught up in the heated exchanges and mutual blame of a lot of other interviews. Yuval, possessing more compelling reasons than many to be resentful, maintains a resolute commitment to reason and expertise over emotional reactions. It is the scientists and historians who ought to lead and have prominent platforms for educating the public, rather than leaving that responsibility to aging, jaded politicians and attention-seeking showmen, obsessed with garnering likes and views.
Amen to that. If I'll have to watch another interview with another agressive flat-earth tiktok theater actor comedian shein activist I'll get a headache. For some reason the people who are actually stating facts and historical nuances don't need to scream and spit and curse.
What we are witnessing today in terms of bombing, killing, starving the people, and delaying the entry of aid is Netanyahu’s plan to seize the land of Gaza. Even if the cost of this is the death of defenseless innocents and children Imagine daily raids over a period of 24 hours a day, inflicting fear and panic in the hearts, interspersed with bombing that takes lives, then spreading terror again, and then comes bombing that takes other lives, what Netanyahu does throughout the hours of the day and throughout the days of the weeks.
@@amiramoustafa8711 What's your view on Hamas? How many Palestinians were killed by Hamas? Your side again trying to blame Israel and not willing to take steps towards cleaning your house from murderers.
Yuval, brother, I cannot imagine how much courage and clarity it takes to speak truth in a time like this. I want to thank you for speaking so fearlessly for peace. It testifies to the depth of your character.
I stopped watching when he said " people are stuck trying to correct the past " , dude if in my country " Algeria " people didn't try to correct the past , we would be still colonized by France.
I come from Iraqi Jewish family, I remember my grandpa used to tell us stories on how peaceful and prosperous his family life was in Iraq and how kind Iraqi Muslims to him. In 1948, him & all Iraqi Jews were forced to leave to Israel because Israel, U.S and UK told the Iraqi Gov back then to kick them out of Iraqi and send them to Israel and that is when all hell broke loose.
Historically Muslims are commanded not to harass minorities among them. I find it hard to imagine Arabs will turn against Jewish Arabs because again historically Arab tribes tolerated ethnic diversity within the tribes and the tribal confederations were pragmatic. Unsurprised that foreign elements were stirring the pot to drive migration of the Arab Jews. I see the yearning for that time of flourishing in the works of Jewish artists of Arabic backgrounds like Riff Cohen and the Kuwaitis
@@BioSlayer111 only the West seems capable of offering a vibrant, flourishing environment for creative endeavours. But even in the West, people from the world of Islam seem too hidebound by social proprieties from within their own set-up and by religion to avail of the arts on offer in abundance. This restrictive practice was not evident more than a hundred years ago among Jews in America.
למה אתה מפיץ קונספירציות כאלו. זה לא נכון. זה מתבסס על איזו שמועה של של פעיל אנטיציוני בשם נעים גלעד. שטען שציונים פוצצו בתי כנסת בהתבסס על איזה האשמה לא מבוססת של שלטונות עיראק הלאומניות אחרי שכלאו וגירשו את הפעיל הציוני מרדכי בן פורת. בן פורת הכחיש את האשמות הבזויות הללו ותבע אותו על הוצאת דיבה. חוץ מזה שבלי קשר אי אפשר לסמוך על שלטונות עיראק בזמנו בהתחשב שרק כמה שנים לפני הם שיתפו פעולה עם הנאצים והלהיטו את הפרהוד שרצח אלפי יהודים עיראקים בבגדאד.
@@rustshoo5068 there are some closed-in Jewish communities in the west like some of the NY based Hasidic/Haridim communities. Religion aside some people are more enterprising than others and not all Arabic or Islamic communities and countries align with your simplistic premise. There’s more wealth redistribution per capita in countries within the gulf region and Brunei. You’d say it’s because of oil but I’d say it’s because of stability and sound economic management. Venezuela and Nigeria have more oil but more mismanagement for the wealth to be redistributed.
So inspirational. Lets hope this gentleman's sense and humanity shines through the misery of this situation and allows both the Jews and Palestinians to move towards some sort of solution and peace. There need to be more voices like this on both sides.
Because civilians are not the targets of the bombing of Gaza... I've heard an audio recording of a Gazan civilian reporting that Hamas is shooting them for evacuating. You're falsely equivocating the actions of Hamas and the IDF. Having said that, civilian casualties are still civilian casualties, I think the best way to deal with the conflict is to get the entirety of the Arab and Muslim world to condemn and excommunicate Hamas, in hopes of getting them to release the hostages and leave Gaza. I would be in favor of helping the Gazans rebuild and find leadership that will allow them to live and prosper alongside us... But they need to accept our right to live in our ancestral homeland, as long as we're seen as enemies who stole their land, how can we help people who want us dead or gone?
@@lolkvadimtrue, now lets imagine a world with no hamas, let's call it the "west bank" yeah palestinians are still occupied, getting killed there and their homes and land stolen
What an insightful interview!! I think this is the best interview I watched so far on this recent conflict. Yuval was so unbiased and that makes it great.
Not at all. He is advocating for the Palestinians to forget and "get over it" because it is convenient for his side (and his controllers). Piers shows his bias in interviews clearly here. When it's someone who is Pro-Palestine, he starts by asking them about Hamas condemnation or some recent comments they made and asking whether they still stand by it or not (immediately starting an argument that is aimed at attacking their character, and nothing about the war and it's ongoing victims). When it's someone who is Pro-Israel, he starts with the victims who always happen to be Israeli (and now less than a quarter of the victims in Palestine). Digusting paid Schill.
@@loopfitnessacademy545 it is what it is! Israel were invaded in 1948 and they pushed back the Arab nations and took their lands! Have you ever heard of the Americans giving their land back? You sound like you've been dropped on your head. A confidently incorrect individual is akin to an idiot.
He wants Palestinians evacuated again from their lands so Israel will steal it, instead of ceasefire and inviting the UN. What about 1967 borders two states solution?
Kinda agree with him? The same people rejoice in the streets on 9/11 and hand out candies and sweets. Most people blame their leaders, Palestinians blame everybody else
@@newvibs5414the hostages are still alive, they still have a future, of course everything should be done to rescue them. But the idea is not to create more historical injuries. Very difficult to do, but that is the challenge
It was refreshing to hear a balanced perspective on your show, especially given the previous guests who seemed to only advocate for one side. This individual offered constructive solutions that consider both Israeli and Palestinian perspectives, illustrating the nuanced approach that is often lacking in discussions about the Middle East from the other side
I disagree, that the other interviews were advocating one side. They(most) did say there should be a ceasefire immediately, however the great usa vetoed it.
The problem with his vision is the fact That no one can promise that after the Palestinians will get a state they won't be ruled by a terrorist dictatorship government. When Israel left Lebanon with hope for peace They got Hezzbola threaten Israel existence, Israel left Gaza with hope to peace and they got Hammas as a governed terrorist organization. In the last couple years there's an ongoing terrorism against Israel from the West Bank and Gaza. Moreover Hamas is dedicated to destroy Israel and even the PLO doesn't recognize Israel existence and so the majority of Palestinians.
This is absolutely correct Arabs are slowly finding out they have been super stupid for the last that's why one after another they're making peace with Israel
Yuval: I am very grateful that you share with the world your extraordinary capacity for clear thinking. Your compassionate way of viewing things might catch on some day.
This was such a balanced interview. In fact, it was more like having a conversation. And no wander, this will never get as many views as it should. Those who are mocking both Yuval and Piers should watch the full interview ... Yuval acknowledged the plight of Palestinians, and he had good points. If anyone disagrees, then please disagree respectably.
Of course it's a calm interview when Piers lets him speak to the end, and asks questions that are catered to him. Besides, I would be calm too if I had the protection of the press, the US and the west, while killing women and children and blaming it on Hamas, and getting away with it, haha!
Don’t you see the difference between the Jewish or pro-israel interviewees v.s. The pro-Palestine/Hamas interviewees….. pro-Palestine just yell, deny, attack etc…. So obvious
@@AliFalah-s2l So you'd prefer a more emotional interview? Or maybe not interviewing prominent/intellectual individuals from the Israeli side at all? Peace is made with enemies, not friends. Maybe just listen to him?
Wow, Piers showed him empathy and was curious about how his family is doing, but he hasn't done that for anyone on the Palestine side. Just shows his bias and his inability to see the humanity of the Palestinian people.
Maybe because its the first time that he brings a person that actually knows what he is talking about? Recently the only people he is interviewing are retarded Pro-palestinian losers with an average IQ of 70 who did nothing serious in their lives and expect western people to listen to them. Another pro-Israeli that he interviewed was Ben Shapiro who happens to be smart (surprise surprise) A proud Israeli Helicopter pilot here.
Yeah he didn’t cut him off at all, like he just asks then be like” i dont give a f*** about his answer i wont comment on it”, cause piers didn’t stopped him to corner him
He is a wise man. "The past injuries should be healed and not be used an an excuse to inflict more injuries". He is also the author of the first-class book: Sapiens - A Brief History of Humankind
This interview is simply stunning - Imagine, just imagine, if politicians of this moral and intellectual calibre were in charge of Israel, the UK and the US
@@paulinskipukprogressive4903 You said (your comment implied) that politicians of such a calibre would be great - in Israel, the UK, and the US. But somehow, you didn't mention Palestinian leaders in this list. Is it because you think they are already of such a quality or because you believe it's beyond the wildest imagination?
and why is it being occupied? oh because hamas runs everything that goes on there. and hamas is say it with me… a terrorist organization that wants to annihilate all jews
considering Yuval is Klaus Schwab right hand man, i wouldn't' trust him as far as i would throw him. Even Hamas son , they are up to something. Don't say i didn't warn you
You people forgot everything what happened till now and Israel using Hamas to not to reach the peace. Hamas is made by Israel and the West. Do you remember that peace agreement and two states solution was signed with Arafat and Rabin in 1995 Rabin was killed by Israeli. They never want Palestinian state. All they want is to throw them out. Zionist and Germans and the west worked together to create Israel.
What brilliant about the stupid idea of using Israeli land has humanitarian relief zone where those areas where attack on 7/10 and when You have a barrage of rockets from Gaza and Lebanon in the north Right 500,000 Israelis are refugees Israel need to take care of it own citizens before sush ideas if it a un aid I should be a area a zone agreed by all parties right now is the south of Gaza And why again eagypt is no accountable for the close border and seize on Gaza
And what do you think was happening on the day of the Hamas attack? It was the liberal Israelis who let their guard down saying we are reaching the peace we need. Boom your enemy caught you unprepared.
What a difference the interviews on Israel people! They listen, don’t talk over, no violent aggressive attitude, they reply without deflecting at every opportunity. It tells the all story 🙏🇮🇱
Because the line of questioning is pro-israel lmao. Israelis start screaming when you ask them if ask to condemn if they're a terrorist, genocidal and apartheid state. Don't kid yourself, you know the other speakers weren't deflecting, they were being asked questions to propogate a highly biased pro-israel agenda.
Ummmm the Palestinian advocates were constantly interrupted, can you explain how they “deflected at every opportunity”? Did you miss the interviews from Israelis where they just wanna genocide the Palestinians? You are viewing both sides as a monolith.
One argument against Egypt allowing Gazan civilians to move en masse into Egypt is that there are Arabs who argue that Israel will say it is temporary. But as soon as the Gazans have left, the current Israeli government will not allow them back and will claim Gaza for Israel.
All the people in gaza who are not terrorists would like to have a better life in Egypt. Why do we need to decides for them what's better? give them the option to go to Egypt or any other country. It should be their choice, not people outside gaza.
That is indeed the fear and the lessons of the past have taught the Palestinians to stay put - if they leave they will never return but remain refugees - which is why Harari’s suggestion that Israel should take in Gazan refugees ( but not only women and children as he suggests) makes good sense - as they would remain housed on ancestral land. I can’t see this happening under the current Israeli regime however.
For all the whining against Piers in the comments section, critics should be most grateful that people get to hear the Palestinian plea. I for one would not have heard nearly to the extent I have with Piers' show. Ultimately, Yuval has had the best takes I've seen and has the capacity to make people listen (I hope it applies to others as it did for me).
Thank you Yuval - Your wisdom is extra-ordinary. Historical injuries cannot justify present injuries. Past injuries must be allowed to heal and not used as excuse.
Why should Palestinians be genocided and evacuated from their lands for Israel to steal it. Look at Palestine map in 1948. A better solution is the ceasefire. Bring the United Nations in to solve the problem. And give Palestinians their freedom in two states solution of 1967 guarded by UN.
@@iyadartHe’s a sociopath that’s an advisor for Klaus Shwab a very deceptive individual, and if you don’t know klaus Shwab I suggest you look him up and look up his past family history ties with Nazi Germany
I think this is the most well-balanced and intellectual people you have had out of anyone else since the attacks. I think his views and proposals are very interesting and positiveA welcome and fresh addition to your show. I hope he can come back in the future.
there will be no peace if there's no justice. How you can have a peace while some people or group feeling they have no right and are subjugated. Justice is prerequisite for peace.
@@AbdullahGurta Yes, this war in Gaza is not good for Israel because now they'll never be a two state solution and no equality for the Palestinians. The Israel's just don't seem to think about what is going to happen next.
Piers Morgan, Again, I congratulate you on the personal work you are doing as a journalist to try to find points in common between Israelis and Palestinians. It is great to hear people like Yuval Noah Harari, a historian and a brilliant author, explain points of view without being exalted by mere passion due to the HAMAS attack. This is the kind of negotiator Israel needs to try to solve this issue peacefully.
Manny people who live around gaza in Israel believe it also, didn't help them much... You can't have peace when you and the other side talk in different languages.
Then the Palestinians need to hear that message to. He also said this attack happened because they wanted to botch the peace process and normalization in the region. All the while Israel is being demonized all over the world and Jews are being threatned for being Jewish. This is all due to those "pro-Palestinian" hate filled protests. Tell me how Israel has not chosen peace every time.
One of the few guests of last week's interviews who actually is responding the questions asked by Piers, attempting to be as objective as possible and providing some constructive ideas to the future of Palestine-Israel conflict..
As a Palestinian, I agree with Mr. Harari on most of what he said. I think the solution to the problem is for Netanyahu to resign then make peace with the Palestinians where they can get their own land with dignity like other nations.
A lot of politicians would react/operate the same as netenyaho. Remove him and he needs to be replaced with an aligned left government that's peace driven. Alas Mr Harari said it early on in the interview that hamas needs to be removed, and the attack happened now because of the Saudis on the verge of signing deals with the Israel government. Unfortunately everything falls apart when Israel has to act aggressively in pursuit of removing Hamas. Collateral deaths occur, which happens in any war conflict. In this case hamas also causes some of that collateral with 1/3 of their missile attacks. Just like what happened in the hospital car park. Remove hamas first, after that vote in a left wing gov for Israel, then ensure Gaza isn't ruled by zealots and terrorists. Don't choke hold Gaza from within the borders (Hamas) and out (right wing Israeli gov). Spend money on education, business, and perhaps sport clubs. Allow the Gazan ppl to prosper and grow on their own innovations away from the tyranny of warmongers. Easier said than done though.
@@tomer_stern yes i do, i condumn them . What about you? Do you condumn the Israeli government for killing thousands of innocent civiliants, children, babies, people who had nothing to do with this war? Do you condumn the Israeli government for the occupation and forcing millions of Palestinians to move from their own homes? Do you condumn the Israeli government for taking out from the Palestinians their basic rights as humans? Isn't the things that hamas do that consider terrorism, Israel was doing much more, far worse and still do?
As an Israeli, the problem is both our sides have radical leadership. Hamas is doing horrors to both our ppl while Bibi is a complete facist. Ending Hamas' role in Gaza, putting the PA in charge of Gaza instead then demand the resignations of Bibi, Ben Gvir and Smotrich and with new leadership on both sides, we can begin a new era of peace
For once i agree with this guy at least to a degree. He sounds human and compassionate for once and his concern for women and children is something you can't disagree with
Hi anwarowerZ. Totally agree but I am wondering how easy it is for you to express respect for Israeli intellectuals. I have little knowledge of Egyptian society and politics so I am not assuming anything but just now polarisation is making it hard for us all I feel.
@@martifingers Sorry misunderstood your question! Yeah there are always some people who would call me names for this, but also others who would give themselves a chance to judge.
@@anwarowerZ Thanks for the reply. You are a little light of hope in this awful darkness. I hope people (and there must be many of us) can spread such light in the coming days and months. Salaam.
@@martifingers Thank you for your kind words! I don’t believe there is anything special about me though. I believe every human is a lover of peace and harmony by nature. The problem of the Middle East is the circle of hate. People who saw their families killed. People who got deported. It’s super hard for them to forgive. Then each party dehumanizes the other, and justifies whatever evil they do to them..We used to be more loving before this conflict! It tears my heart apart to know that this conflict made me waste the chance to grow with as much Jew friends on school as the Christian ones I have, and learn more perspectives through them. I honestly don’t know how we can revert this situation, but I pray that one day we live again in peace…
As someone from Ireland, I agree with him that no peace process gives perfect justice. Both the IRA and the UDF had to start caring more about the devastation they were causing everyone than getting a perfect justice.
I haven't heard one person that support hamas or Palestinians to have the clear ideas and the maturity to provide with unbiased intelligence knowledge of the situation a solution a really honest solution like this man. Palestinians should be listening to this guy instead of the leaders of hamas
I'm Israel and I'm tierd of my stupid right winged government, I want peace with Palestine and I want them to have good life and I know deeply that we can be brothers just like we are talking almost same language.tierd of war!!!!,
8 God, there is no god but He, His are the Most Beautiful Names. 9 Has the story of Moses reached you? 10 When he saw a fire, he said to his family, “Stay; I have noticed a fire; Perhaps I can bring you a torch therefrom, or find some guidance by the fire.” 11 Then, when he reached it, he was called, “O Moses. 12 I-I am your Lord. Take off your shoes. You are in the sacred valley of Tuwa. 13 I have chosen you, so listen to what is revealed. 14 I-I am God. There is no God but I. So serve Me, and practice the prayer for My remembrance. 15 The Hour is coming-but I keep it almost hidden-so that each soul will be paid for what it endeavors. 16 And do not let him who denies it and follows his desire turn you away from it, lest you fall. 17 And what is that in your right-hand, O Moses?” 18 He said, “This is my staff. I lean on it, and herd my sheep with it, and I have other uses for it.” 19 He said, “Throw it, O Moses.” 20 So he threw it-thereupon it became a moving serpent. 21 He said, “Take hold of it, and do not fear. We will restore it to its original condition. 22 And press your hand to your side; it will come out white, without a blemish-another sign. 23 That We may show you some of Our greatest signs. 24 Go to Pharaoh; He has transgressed.” 25 He said, “My Lord, put my heart at peace for me. 26 And ease my task for me. 27 And untie the knot from my tongue. 28 So they can understand my speech. 29 And appoint an assistant for me, from my family. 30 Aaron, my brother. 31 Strengthen me with him. 32 And have him share in my mission. 33 That we may glorify You much. 34 And remember You much. 35 You are always watching over us.” 36 He said, “You are granted your request, O Moses. 37 We had favored you another time. 38 When We inspired your mother with the inspiration. 39 `Put him in the chest; then cast him into the river. The river will wash him to shore, where an enemy of Mine and an enemy of his will pick him up. And I have bestowed upon you love from Me, so that you may be reared before My eye. 40 When your sister walked along, and said, ‘Shall I tell you about someone who will take care of him?' So We returned you to your mother, that she may be comforted, and not sorrow. And you killed a person, but We saved you from stress; and We tested you thoroughly. And you stayed years among the people of Median. Then you came back, as ordained, O Moses. 41 And I made you for Myself. 42 Go, you and your brother, with My signs, and do not neglect My remembrance. 43 Go to Pharaoh. He has tyrannized. 44 But speak to him nicely. Perhaps he will remember, or have some fear.” 45 They said, “Lord, we fear he may persecute us, or become violent.” 46 He said, “Do not fear, I am with you, I hear and I see. 47 Approach him and say, `We are the messengers of your Lord; so let the Children of Israel go with us, and do not torment them. We bring you a sign from your Lord, and peace be upon him who follows guidance. 48 It was revealed to us that the punishment falls upon him who disbelieves and turns away.'“ 49 He said, “Who is your Lord, O Moses.” 50 He said, “Our Lord is He who gave everything its existence, then guided it.” 51 He said, “What about the first generations?” 52 He said, “Knowledge thereof is with my Lord, in a Book. My Lord never errs, nor does He forget.” 53 He who made the earth a habitat for you; and traced in it routes for you; and sent down water from the sky, with which We produce pairs of diverse plants. 54 Eat and pasture your livestock. In that are signs for those with understanding. 55 From it We created you, and into it We will return you, and from it We will bring you out another time. 56 We showed him Our signs, all of them, but he denied and refused. 57 He said, “Did you come to us to drive us out of our land with your magic, O Moses? 58 We will produce for you magic like it; so make an appointment between us and you, which we will not miss-neither us, nor you-in a central place.” 59 He said, “Your appointment is the day of the festival, so let the people be gathered together at mid-morning.” 60 Pharaoh turned away, put together his plan, and then came back. 61 Moses said to them, “Woe to you. Do not fabricate lies against God, or He will destroy you with a punishment. He who invents lies will fail.” 62 They disagreed among themselves over their affair, and conferred secretly. 63 They said, “These two are magicians who want to drive you out of your land with their magic, and to abolish your exemplary way of life. 64 So settle your plan, and come as one front. Today, whoever gains the upper hand will succeed.” 65 They said, “O Moses, either you throw, or we will be the first to throw.” 66 He said, “You throw.” And suddenly, their ropes and sticks appeared to him, because of their magic, to be crawling swiftly. 67 So Moses felt apprehensive within himself. 68 We said, “Do not be afraid, you are the uppermost. 69 Now throw down what is in your right hand-it will swallow what they have crafted. What they have crafted is only a magician’s trickery. But the magician will not succeed, no matter what he does.” 70 And the magicians fell down prostrate. They said, “We have believed in the Lord of Aaron and Moses.” 71 He said, “Did you believe in him before I have given you permission? He must be your chief, who has taught you magic. I will cut off your hands and your feet on alternate sides, and I will crucify you on the trunks of the palm-trees. Then you will know which of us is more severe in punishment, and more lasting.” 72 They said, “We will not prefer you to the proofs that have come to us, and Him who created us. So issue whatever judgment you wish to issue. You can only rule in this lowly life. 73 We have believed in our Lord, so that He may forgive us our sins, and the magic you have compelled us to practice. God is Better, and more Lasting.” 74 Whoever comes to his Lord guilty, for him is Hell, where he neither dies nor lives. 75 But whoever comes to Him a believer, having worked righteousness-these will have the highest ranks. 76 The Gardens of Perpetuity, beneath which rivers flow, dwelling therein forever. That is the reward for him who purifies himself. 77 And We inspired Moses: “Travel by night with My servants, and strike for them a dry path across the sea, not fearing being overtaken, nor worrying.” 78 Pharaoh pursued them with his troops, but the sea overwhelmed them, and completely engulfed them. 79 Pharaoh misled his people, and did not guide them. 80 O Children of Israel! We have delivered you from your enemy, and promised you by the right side of the Mount, and sent down to you manna and quails. 81 Eat of the good things We have provided for you, but do not be excessive therein, lest My wrath descends upon you. He upon whom My wrath descends has fallen. 82 And I am Forgiving towards him who repents, believes, acts righteously, and then remains guided. 83 “And what made you rush ahead of your people, O Moses?” 84 He said, “They are following in my footsteps; and I hurried on to You, my Lord, that you may be pleased.” 85 He said, “We have tested your people in your absence, and the Samarian misled them.” 86 So Moses returned to his people, angry and disappointed. He said, “O my people, did your Lord not promise you a good promise? Was the time too long for you? Or did you want wrath from your Lord to descend upon you, so you broke your promise to me?” 87 They said, “We did not break our promise to you by our choice, but we were made to carry loads of the people’s ornaments, and we cast them in. That was what the Samarian suggested.” 88 So he produced for them a calf-a mere body which lowed. And they said, “This is your god, and the god of Moses, but he has forgotten.” 89 Did they not see that it cannot return a word to them, and has no power to harm them or benefit them? 90 Aaron had said to them before, “O my people, you are being tested by this. And your Lord is the Merciful, so follow me, and obey my command.” 91 They said, “We will not give up our devotion to it, until Moses returns to us.” 92 He said, “O Aaron, what prevented you, when you saw them going astray. 93 From following me? Did you disobey my command?” 94 He said, “Son of my mother, do not seize me by my beard or my head. I feared you would say, `You have caused division among the Children of Israel, and did not regard my word.'“ 95 He said, “What do you have to say, O Samarian?” 96 He said, “I saw what they did not see, so I grasped a handful from the Messenger’s traces, and I flung it away. Thus my soul prompted me.” 97 He said, “Begone! Your lot in this life is to say, ‘No contact.’ And you have an appointment that you will not miss. Now look at your god that you remained devoted to-we will burn it up, and then blow it away into the sea, as powder.” 98 Surely your god is Allah, the One besides whom there is no other god. He comprehends everything in knowledge. 29 Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. Read The Quran “I am to you a clear warner.” “That you shall worship none but Allah. I fear for you the agony of a painful Day.”
Pierce I have to say I might not agree with you on a lot of things, but thank you for your coverage and interviews on this global humantarian crisis that will change the whole world and I pray it is for the better (I am doing everything I can in my power to change it). The world is speaking and we need to listen.
8 God, there is no god but He, His are the Most Beautiful Names. 9 Has the story of Moses reached you? 10 When he saw a fire, he said to his family, “Stay; I have noticed a fire; Perhaps I can bring you a torch therefrom, or find some guidance by the fire.” 11 Then, when he reached it, he was called, “O Moses. 12 I-I am your Lord. Take off your shoes. You are in the sacred valley of Tuwa. 13 I have chosen you, so listen to what is revealed. 14 I-I am God. There is no God but I. So serve Me, and practice the prayer for My remembrance. 15 The Hour is coming-but I keep it almost hidden-so that each soul will be paid for what it endeavors. 16 And do not let him who denies it and follows his desire turn you away from it, lest you fall. 17 And what is that in your right-hand, O Moses?” 18 He said, “This is my staff. I lean on it, and herd my sheep with it, and I have other uses for it.” 19 He said, “Throw it, O Moses.” 20 So he threw it-thereupon it became a moving serpent. 21 He said, “Take hold of it, and do not fear. We will restore it to its original condition. 22 And press your hand to your side; it will come out white, without a blemish-another sign. 23 That We may show you some of Our greatest signs. 24 Go to Pharaoh; He has transgressed.” 25 He said, “My Lord, put my heart at peace for me. 26 And ease my task for me. 27 And untie the knot from my tongue. 28 So they can understand my speech. 29 And appoint an assistant for me, from my family. 30 Aaron, my brother. 31 Strengthen me with him. 32 And have him share in my mission. 33 That we may glorify You much. 34 And remember You much. 35 You are always watching over us.” 36 He said, “You are granted your request, O Moses. 37 We had favored you another time. 38 When We inspired your mother with the inspiration. 39 `Put him in the chest; then cast him into the river. The river will wash him to shore, where an enemy of Mine and an enemy of his will pick him up. And I have bestowed upon you love from Me, so that you may be reared before My eye. 40 When your sister walked along, and said, ‘Shall I tell you about someone who will take care of him?' So We returned you to your mother, that she may be comforted, and not sorrow. And you killed a person, but We saved you from stress; and We tested you thoroughly. And you stayed years among the people of Median. Then you came back, as ordained, O Moses. 41 And I made you for Myself. 42 Go, you and your brother, with My signs, and do not neglect My remembrance. 43 Go to Pharaoh. He has tyrannized. 44 But speak to him nicely. Perhaps he will remember, or have some fear.” 45 They said, “Lord, we fear he may persecute us, or become violent.” 46 He said, “Do not fear, I am with you, I hear and I see. 47 Approach him and say, `We are the messengers of your Lord; so let the Children of Israel go with us, and do not torment them. We bring you a sign from your Lord, and peace be upon him who follows guidance. 48 It was revealed to us that the punishment falls upon him who disbelieves and turns away.'“ 49 He said, “Who is your Lord, O Moses.” 50 He said, “Our Lord is He who gave everything its existence, then guided it.” 51 He said, “What about the first generations?” 52 He said, “Knowledge thereof is with my Lord, in a Book. My Lord never errs, nor does He forget.” 53 He who made the earth a habitat for you; and traced in it routes for you; and sent down water from the sky, with which We produce pairs of diverse plants. 54 Eat and pasture your livestock. In that are signs for those with understanding. 55 From it We created you, and into it We will return you, and from it We will bring you out another time. 56 We showed him Our signs, all of them, but he denied and refused. 57 He said, “Did you come to us to drive us out of our land with your magic, O Moses? 58 We will produce for you magic like it; so make an appointment between us and you, which we will not miss-neither us, nor you-in a central place.” 59 He said, “Your appointment is the day of the festival, so let the people be gathered together at mid-morning.” 60 Pharaoh turned away, put together his plan, and then came back. 61 Moses said to them, “Woe to you. Do not fabricate lies against God, or He will destroy you with a punishment. He who invents lies will fail.” 62 They disagreed among themselves over their affair, and conferred secretly. 63 They said, “These two are magicians who want to drive you out of your land with their magic, and to abolish your exemplary way of life. 64 So settle your plan, and come as one front. Today, whoever gains the upper hand will succeed.” 65 They said, “O Moses, either you throw, or we will be the first to throw.” 66 He said, “You throw.” And suddenly, their ropes and sticks appeared to him, because of their magic, to be crawling swiftly. 67 So Moses felt apprehensive within himself. 68 We said, “Do not be afraid, you are the uppermost. 69 Now throw down what is in your right hand-it will swallow what they have crafted. What they have crafted is only a magician’s trickery. But the magician will not succeed, no matter what he does.” 70 And the magicians fell down prostrate. They said, “We have believed in the Lord of Aaron and Moses.” 71 He said, “Did you believe in him before I have given you permission? He must be your chief, who has taught you magic. I will cut off your hands and your feet on alternate sides, and I will crucify you on the trunks of the palm-trees. Then you will know which of us is more severe in punishment, and more lasting.” 72 They said, “We will not prefer you to the proofs that have come to us, and Him who created us. So issue whatever judgment you wish to issue. You can only rule in this lowly life. 73 We have believed in our Lord, so that He may forgive us our sins, and the magic you have compelled us to practice. God is Better, and more Lasting.” 74 Whoever comes to his Lord guilty, for him is Hell, where he neither dies nor lives. 75 But whoever comes to Him a believer, having worked righteousness-these will have the highest ranks. 76 The Gardens of Perpetuity, beneath which rivers flow, dwelling therein forever. That is the reward for him who purifies himself. 77 And We inspired Moses: “Travel by night with My servants, and strike for them a dry path across the sea, not fearing being overtaken, nor worrying.” 78 Pharaoh pursued them with his troops, but the sea overwhelmed them, and completely engulfed them. 79 Pharaoh misled his people, and did not guide them. 80 O Children of Israel! We have delivered you from your enemy, and promised you by the right side of the Mount, and sent down to you manna and quails. 81 Eat of the good things We have provided for you, but do not be excessive therein, lest My wrath descends upon you. He upon whom My wrath descends has fallen. 82 And I am Forgiving towards him who repents, believes, acts righteously, and then remains guided. 83 “And what made you rush ahead of your people, O Moses?” 84 He said, “They are following in my footsteps; and I hurried on to You, my Lord, that you may be pleased.” 85 He said, “We have tested your people in your absence, and the Samarian misled them.” 86 So Moses returned to his people, angry and disappointed. He said, “O my people, did your Lord not promise you a good promise? Was the time too long for you? Or did you want wrath from your Lord to descend upon you, so you broke your promise to me?” 87 They said, “We did not break our promise to you by our choice, but we were made to carry loads of the people’s ornaments, and we cast them in. That was what the Samarian suggested.” 88 So he produced for them a calf-a mere body which lowed. And they said, “This is your god, and the god of Moses, but he has forgotten.” 89 Did they not see that it cannot return a word to them, and has no power to harm them or benefit them? 90 Aaron had said to them before, “O my people, you are being tested by this. And your Lord is the Merciful, so follow me, and obey my command.” 91 They said, “We will not give up our devotion to it, until Moses returns to us.” 92 He said, “O Aaron, what prevented you, when you saw them going astray. 93 From following me? Did you disobey my command?” 94 He said, “Son of my mother, do not seize me by my beard or my head. I feared you would say, `You have caused division among the Children of Israel, and did not regard my word.'“ 95 He said, “What do you have to say, O Samarian?” 96 He said, “I saw what they did not see, so I grasped a handful from the Messenger’s traces, and I flung it away. Thus my soul prompted me.” 97 He said, “Begone! Your lot in this life is to say, ‘No contact.’ And you have an appointment that you will not miss. Now look at your god that you remained devoted to-we will burn it up, and then blow it away into the sea, as powder.” 98 Surely your god is Allah, the One besides whom there is no other god. He comprehends everything in knowledge. 29 Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah. Read The Quran “I am to you a clear warner.” “That you shall worship none but Allah. I fear for you the agony of a painful Day.”
@@0xSylo he’s sociopath who’s an advisor for klaus Shwab he’s a psychopath you obviously don’t know him, he openly talks about keeping the youth docile with drugs and computer games to further their agenda
Those who argue passionately for the Palestinians' interest do not live in Gaza, they want justice at the expense of the peace of the Palestinians living in Gaza.
Watch his videos on transhumanism and eliminating free will. If you’re a sensible person you will come back and delete this comment. He’s not your friend 😂 you’re are a “useless class of people” in his own words🤦🏽♂️
Harari is speaking like Harari, clear and compassionate. When there is a choice between justice and peace, choose peace. This is universally true. Glad to see him in this form. Keep going. More power to you.
I am an atheist Iranian Australian. This conversation was informed, intelligent and wise. And what can I say about Yuval Harari? Every time I listen to this man my respect and admiration for him doubles. Yuval you are my brother and I kiss your hand.
I see Noah saying we should not look at the past, just focus on the future. The the most colonial statement I've heard in all of this. When people in South Africa talk of apartheid, those same former colonisers say "stop focusing on what we did to you", "don't dwell on the past, just look forward", whilst they still currently benefit from the the oppression they inflicted on black people.
Yuval Noah Harari is the voice the whole world needs to hear. He only speaks the truth and doesn't let his emotions dictate his thoughts. We hope for peace for both Palestinians and Isrealis.
I have listened to all of Piers’ interviews since the war started. It is clear that the Israeli speakers are more level headed, well spoken and possess a more humanitarian and constructive outlook towards a solution. Either it is because the Israeli speakers are better at getting their point across, or it is that the Israeli point actually makes more sense. However, I appreciate Piers’ willingness to bring both sides on for discussion. I am yet however to see a constructive Palestinian voice.
It's because Palestinians feel strongly that it is their land and so they feel like negotiation for their own property isn't right or fair. Israeli nationalists equally see it as God given land. In reality, it is a land in which many groups were exiled and expelled from. Arab conquest in the 7th century conquered and displaced Jews. If you go back far enough, everyone has been expelled. In my opinion, this is why as Yuval says peace is more constructive than justice. A compromise where Israel can exist whilst Palestinians are given human rights and their won state is what's needed..
Also u have to remember that Palestinian people dnt grow up in a normal world, they don't have any continuity or stability. They also dnt have access to education so they naturally wnt be able to articulate themselves as well as the rest of us. This is another outcome of living under an occupation. I think the Palestinians do a great job considering their lack of normality.
Are you joking with this? Piers does nothing but antagonise his Palestinian guests with the same repetitive questions and talking points just trying to get them to condemn what happened to Israel instead of actually listening or showing any empathy to what they’re saying. The Palestinian guests have been brilliant look at the views and public responses , piers has been nothing but abhorrent to them showing his bias from the start. Go find a clip of him asking an Israeli guest to condemn the killings of innocent by the IDF , I’ll wait
It’s no joke Danny. think you are correct though... Piers does seem biased. But in reality, so are you and so am I. So we need to look beyond biases and beyond history and beyond justice. Mistakes are committed and have been committed on both sides. We need to look beyond all that, we need to forgive and we need to move on peacefully. For the record, I am Jewish and I have lived in Israel and have family there. I recognize my bias. At the same time I have many many Arabic, Persian and muslim friends. People I call my brothers and sisters. Peace loving people need to get together from both sides to weld peace. Hamas I am afraid is not peace loving. And let me tell you there are many enemies of peace on both the Israeli and American side as well. I think what piers is trying to do is have the Palestinians recognize that hamas is not going to lead them to peace. Their methods are not constructive.
make this man a prime minister , or someone like him, and you'll have peace. and we might seen an end for this conflict. it is about time for god sake. 75 years it is enough from both sides.
From all the Piers interviews in past days I learned that AMC55F by Amazon is what it is about. not kidding. there is a reason that this is everywhere and it takes 5 minutes to know why. dont get irritated by the bots it is a real strong project saving li
shit. this looks like serious project of bots. all of those likes, and i saw this name "AMC55F Amazon" comes in different locations. probably some governmental.
your ignorance of history is astounding. In 1948 over 80% of the land was UNOWNED and UNINHABITED and UNSOVEREIGN, so in what world did the Arabs (who were intending to combine with Jordan) have legal claim to every inch of it? A better question is why did Jordan deserve the land over giving some parts to Jews with no where else in the world to be?? The Arabs could have partitioned the land and their lives would have remained unchanged, giving the Jews with no where else to go a piece of the Negev desert would have not impacted their life in any way, and the Nakba only happened because the Arabs stupidly opened in war vowing to “finish Hitler’s solution” and denouncing any Jewish sovereignty even on land they didn’t own or live in. Also the same number of Jews were kicked out of the Middle East. Do you see Egyptian Jews entering Egypt and slaughtering civilians in their homes because their grandparents were kicked out of the country simply due to their ethnicity?? THAT is choosing peace over justice. The Palestinians need to follow suit (in addition to taking accountability for getting us to this point and rejecting every peace offer)
Well by this logic, the Jewish popular certainly would resented the German people after the Holocaust. But look and behold as Yuval said they are now have a close relationship. Please try to not hold resentment for the past, it does not help to solve the problem. Have a good day
😂😂 My wife and I made a bet about how Piers would open this call. He did not disappoint us. Complete opposite of how he approaches pro-Palestinian guests. Still waiting for the question is they have something to condemn
What a stupid point. He's hardly going to ask him if he condemns Hamas, he's a Jew for Gods sake! Notice he answered the questions rather than diverting like the Mus lim apologists do? All they do is read the script Hamas gave them.
Read his books, I strongly recommend them. Yuval is extremely intelligent and his historical knowledge is impressive. I’m not surprised he has such a nuanced and intelligent response to this conflict.
He steal ideas from people and makes up a lot of stuff. Just look at the back of any of his books, very few sources. His books are easy and fun to read but definitly not someone to take seriously.
I believe in a 2 state solution as I don’t want Jews to suffer. I know they’re brainwashed but I want these Palestinians having their homes back! I want them to be treated like humans and get their dignity back. I want it to be a safe place for Palestinians to live without the IDF abusing them.
Piers did not ask him if he condemn the Palestinian killed But when he interview a Palestinian person the first question he ask if the condemns what Hampshire did
As an Arab I wish there are politicians like this reasonable gentleman on both sides. We just want peace and prosperity not revenge.
You need to condemn hamas
@shaneeudy1798 Obviously he does condemn Hamas. He sounds like an open minded logical individual.
if only Palestinians Can talk this way, unbiased and putting humanity first, but no way! they will never see through the shadows of hate for Israel.
@@NwaikwuGideon-vg1ewnah, this guy only got soft quration from pier, piers is pro- jews
the future depends on inteligent resonable people for sure!
Wow this man blew me away….
“If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose peace”
“If you choose absolute justice, there will be war indefinitely “…. This is literally what I am going through in my life about all the people who have wronged me. You literally cannot change the past. It’s just a fact This is one wisemen!!!!!
Peace on the world and in our hearts God we need your light!!!!
Peace should be an end goal sure, but Imagine slaves chose peace instead of liberty, would you support the oppressed to fight for their freedom? Should nelson mandela thats denounced as terrorist till 2008 by the US accepted apartheid in south africa and chose peace instead of retaliation?
true
Peace we pray and also that all people will know the love that Jesus has for them that they know you as their saviour, and great high priest our intercessor our best friend the lover of our souls amen 💕
@@ahmadqadoura6830this guy is also preaching on peace while promoting war on Gaza.
yes peace is the first step always. A belief in higher justice to deliver what could not be given on the ground by us imperfect humans also helps. But absolute justice is impossible to deliver down here.....is why peace must be made first.....and a good system of trust and verify to slowly heal after it.
Great Interview and great perspective. He had direct family in a terrorist attack and was still able to advocate against revenge and for peace. The world would be a better place with more people like him.
This opinion is every Israeli's opinion
@@lishaybachar yeah, sure. Then why did you fools vote that war monger, arrogant, brute yahoo in office? And polls in the past have shown high support by Israelis for violent retaliation and incursions in Palestine. Just read an analysis by Norman Finkelstein or Chomsky
He’s a talented historian and curator of history.
He knows better than most what the best and worst of humanity looks like.
This man is connected to the WEF. This man believes you should own nothing and be happy. I support Israel, but this man is horrible.
Shame!
One of the best interviews I've heard on the Israeli predicament, both internally and involving the Palestinians. The true voice of reason and sanity. Thank you Uval Harari and thanks to Piers for having him!
Limiting the whole conflict to Natenyahu & Hamas is the purpose of Israel deep-state that Yuval is serving. You can be a historian and writer but still servant of political regime. Don"t fall for it. They have done the same whenever aggression fails. Dont let sweet peace talk fouls you. He did nothing to stop the atrocities done by hus government. Do your research
ABSOLUTELY AGREE. The best interviews so far!
You guys don’t expect much. This guy is so over his head here. He even admitted as much. He’s merely an historian. That’s it! You are both so gullible. Sad.
@@user-fs8tl7ni1wI disagree. History provides a view of the present circumstances. I think his viewpoints impart a degree of wisdom whereby a solution can begin to emerge if heeded.
You are operating out of an assumption that reality belies. He has zero formal education to place anything from history into perspective, other than military history of a defined period. Zero!
What an admirable man who still has a balanced humanist conversation on the topic despite having his relatives being the victims of this terrorist attack. That was a very powerful constructive and enlightening conversation.
I find it hard to see how people who've had their land stolen, their children slaughtered and the remaining survivors being stuffed into the world's only concentration camp for 16 years lashing out if they were able to break out of the concentration camp as a "terrorist attack."
I guess according to your logic the slave revolts in 1831 had nothing to do with slavery and they were just terrorists too? Lets stop with this nonsense and come back to reality.
R u kidding me look into this guy. He’s a real scumbag
Noah said must go back to the Saudi deal. That's not the way. Start talking about a Palestinian State and forget the Saudi deal. The genocide in Gaza will be bad. Arab countries probably will go back on the Abraham Accords.
Yes, because he has the most powerful country backing them up (the usa),they have the luxury to be able to do that this way. What kind of peace is he talking about when their country is built on false rights and lies? They already raped other people’s countries and stayed there by force and by creating terrorism themselves!
You should take many things into consideration!
Most of the Israelis think that way.
Did he condemn Israel, Piers?
Are you deaf?
He condemned the atrocities against Palestinians and said they weren't justified.
He called for dignity and hope and protection for Palestinian civilians.
Don't makes stuff up to fit your narrative. Stick to truth.
For what ?
For protecting the Palestinians and Israelis?
For not allowing the Palestinians slaughtered more?
🤡
He actually did, you would have heard if you bothered to listened to the whole interview
@@bdfwhhsbNo he did not condemn so STFU
He did but then he continued to say that Israel had to finish of Hamas. We have now seen for 3 weeks who is going to pay suffering for that. Remember Israel has no new casualties except for those hostages that are considered collateral damage.
I am Egyptian Pro Palestinian but have to admit that this man logic makes more sense than many ppl managing this conflict. Wish Israeli government listen to him.
Harari's profound understanding of history enables him to offer a remarkably balanced perspective on a conflict that's deeply personal. Thank you, Noah, for sharing such invaluable insights, and kudos to Piers for the exceptional coverage amidst this tragic conflict!
You suggest me some of your favourite book to read plz
@@JayatiKhandit Sapiens by Harari, Supercommunicators by Duhigg, and Belonging by Geoffrey Cohen
Finally a guest with great perspective. He even offered solutions. Nice job.
He offered unrealistic solutions. To keep Palestinians to only Gaza and the West bank. 1967 Israel illegally annexed plenty of Palestinians land. This is at the very least what they want back.
Do not think for 1 second his solution benefits the Palestinians. It just cements Israel's illegal claims to stolen land.
I totally understand but at least the guy was able to see both sides of the isle and consider some type of solution. Most guests just take their side and stick with it.
@@fernandomatara4299but the unfortunately israeli zionist govt IS 'aiming to kill every palestinian' and flatten gaza. It flouts every int law with the complete impuniy and backing of USA.
@@fernandomatara4299 there is no both sides..one side is literally living in an open air prison with check points under apartheid. that's not a lets look at both sides scenario..one side is clearly in the wrong..
I am an Egyptian and i am very happy to see reasonable humanitarian voices come out of israel. Yes peace is more important than justice and we are willing to forgive nakba but we need hope. Our people deserve better
So you have never been in sinai you know how many Israelis who want only peace are visiting sinai, a lot
You don't have to forget the Nakba, and Jews won't forget the expulsions from the Arab world, including Egypt. However you can agree to move forward and secure a safer life for your children, which Israel and Egypt have done
@jka461 jews always lived among us very peacefully. The oppression was done in europe not among Muslims. Jews moving to palestine after 1948 was due to the zinonist movement. We didn't expell them.
@@shadimagdy8196 Your "holy book" literally calls them Dhimmi's.
@@truth8422and yet they lived safely in Muslim countries for more than thousand years. While in this same time they were being slaughtered and expelled in Europe
The most balanced person i have seen on this debate so far. I wish more people and particularly politicians could talk about this issue with this level of maturity n humanity
Most of the Israelis think that way. I mean... Israel is angry on Hamas and their followers. But not on Palestinians that want peace and agree to 2 state solution.
I personally think that the Ex-Hamas leader's son is more reliable and balanced, Yuval Noh Harari is a very intelligent man, but he has a very dogmatic and inaccurate way of interpreting our reality in Israel, the dogma being globalist and a bit of a "woke" take on things.. so Yuval won't talk about how Hamas is popular in Gaza and its very much a Gaza grassroots movement, its not separate from Palestinians and that is why the west,Israel and the PLO are pushing of elections in the west bank for decades, cause Hamas will win, Hamas is rooted in Palestinian culture and the Islamic Jihad organization also..of course there are who aren't at all supporters, but its not such a large fraction as being sold
The problem is that neither Yuval non other similar experts can provide a model for liberal countries who are fighting non-liberal forces on how to win and survive, there's no modern example of such a case..There's no advice for us in Israel, give territories? we did, failed and just risked us all, we are fighting a war with lawyers without trying to win it cause we're careful on so many levels against an enemy who could care less and uses it against us.
@@reuta123 if killing a child every 10 minutes is Israel being "angry" it says a lot about the mentaility in Israel.
@@jj-uy6qs
Oh I get it. After Hamas killed 40 baybies they understood that they got a bad rap and they need to turn this around with a propaganda on Israelis and say something like "Yeah, we killed 40 babies but Israel is killing a kid every 10 minutes" 😂 Rael mature.
@@vadsmixinglab11
Well put actually
Yuval Noah Harari is a very wise man. As an Israeli, I wish he would be an advisor to Israeli government. We need peace. Nobody wants deaths and revenge. All people, both Israelis and Palestinians, want a happy life. Not war.
Harari is one of my most favorite authors and I have read most of his books. I am so glad you had him on the show, Piers.
He's also trying to make everyone poor and own nothing and be happy. Absolutely evil human being
A word salad to justify a Palestinian massacre with half truths. He forgot to mention that his uncles live in an occupied territory and probably killed or expel Palestinians to live there
Yeah he’s a transhumanist and wants mechanical bees. He’s a bit weird and out of touch with nature and God but I’m not sure if he’s evil.
@@danielvodo1 Thankyou. I've been trying to post something similar on here - but it is being lifted immediately.
@@danielvodo1liar stop lying
I’m Egyptian Arab and this guy is very decent and balanced in his views. Totally
This opinion is every Israeli's opinion
If you’re egyptian then why are all of your subscrib channels are zionists😂
🤔Who you talking about Bru? Piers? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂You better start doing some research mate.
@@idanreg910It absolutely isn't.
I sincerely hope that viewers focus on the essence of this interview rather than getting caught up in the heated exchanges and mutual blame of a lot of other interviews. Yuval, possessing more compelling reasons than many to be resentful, maintains a resolute commitment to reason and expertise over emotional reactions. It is the scientists and historians who ought to lead and have prominent platforms for educating the public, rather than leaving that responsibility to aging, jaded politicians and attention-seeking showmen, obsessed with garnering likes and views.
I couldn’t agree more with you.
Amen to that.
If I'll have to watch another interview with another agressive flat-earth tiktok theater actor comedian shein activist I'll get a headache.
For some reason the people who are actually stating facts and historical nuances don't need to scream and spit and curse.
What we are witnessing today in terms of bombing, killing, starving the people, and delaying the entry of aid is Netanyahu’s plan to seize the land of Gaza.
Even if the cost of this is the death of defenseless innocents and children
Imagine daily raids over a period of 24 hours a day, inflicting fear and panic in the hearts, interspersed with bombing that takes lives, then spreading terror again, and then comes bombing that takes other lives, what Netanyahu does throughout the hours of the day and throughout the days of the weeks.
@@amiramoustafa8711 it’s like some sick game he’s got going on, may HELL be awaiting him on the other side!
@@amiramoustafa8711 What's your view on Hamas? How many Palestinians were killed by Hamas? Your side again trying to blame Israel and not willing to take steps towards cleaning your house from murderers.
Yuval, brother, I cannot imagine how much courage and clarity it takes to speak truth in a time like this. I want to thank you for speaking so fearlessly for peace. It testifies to the depth of your character.
Yuval Noah Harari is THE MAN!! "Don't try to go back to the past and change it. That is impossible. Focus on the future."
He’s a sociopath who’s an advisor for klaus Shwab people need to research them, they are not good people
He is delusional! He forgot where he lives.
Says every criminal who has committed a crime in what’s now the past
I stopped watching when he said " people are stuck trying to correct the past " , dude if in my country " Algeria " people didn't try to correct the past , we would be still colonized by France.
i literally read this comment as he was saying it🤯
This is the most logical and unbiased interview and the only way to end this conflict.
I come from Iraqi Jewish family, I remember my grandpa used to tell us stories on how peaceful and prosperous his family life was in Iraq and how kind Iraqi Muslims to him.
In 1948, him & all Iraqi Jews were forced to leave to Israel because Israel, U.S and UK told the Iraqi Gov back then to kick them out of Iraqi and send them to Israel and that is when all hell broke loose.
That does not seem to accord with the sentiment expressed by our historian here being interviewed, the picture you paint.
Historically Muslims are commanded not to harass minorities among them. I find it hard to imagine Arabs will turn against Jewish Arabs because again historically Arab tribes tolerated ethnic diversity within the tribes and the tribal confederations were pragmatic. Unsurprised that foreign elements were stirring the pot to drive migration of the Arab Jews. I see the yearning for that time of flourishing in the works of Jewish artists of Arabic backgrounds like Riff Cohen and the Kuwaitis
@@BioSlayer111 only the West seems capable of offering a vibrant, flourishing environment for creative endeavours. But even in the West, people from the world of Islam seem too hidebound by social proprieties from within their own set-up and by religion to avail of the arts on offer in abundance. This restrictive practice was not evident more than a hundred years ago among Jews in America.
למה אתה מפיץ קונספירציות כאלו. זה לא נכון.
זה מתבסס על איזו שמועה של של פעיל אנטיציוני בשם נעים גלעד. שטען שציונים פוצצו בתי כנסת בהתבסס על איזה האשמה לא מבוססת של שלטונות עיראק הלאומניות אחרי שכלאו וגירשו את הפעיל הציוני מרדכי בן פורת. בן פורת הכחיש את האשמות הבזויות הללו ותבע אותו על הוצאת דיבה.
חוץ מזה שבלי קשר אי אפשר לסמוך על שלטונות עיראק בזמנו בהתחשב שרק כמה שנים לפני הם שיתפו פעולה עם הנאצים והלהיטו את הפרהוד שרצח אלפי יהודים עיראקים בבגדאד.
@@rustshoo5068 there are some closed-in Jewish communities in the west like some of the NY based Hasidic/Haridim communities. Religion aside some people are more enterprising than others and not all Arabic or Islamic communities and countries align with your simplistic premise. There’s more wealth redistribution per capita in countries within the gulf region and Brunei. You’d say it’s because of oil but I’d say it’s because of stability and sound economic management. Venezuela and Nigeria have more oil but more mismanagement for the wealth to be redistributed.
So inspirational. Lets hope this gentleman's sense and humanity shines through the misery of this situation and allows both the Jews and Palestinians to move towards some sort of solution and peace. There need to be more voices like this on both sides.
Why don’t you ask him to condemn the bombing of civilians in Gaza like you ask every pro Palestine guest?
Having said that, I still enjoyed the interview. Some good points there. Thanks Piers
Because civilians are not the targets of the bombing of Gaza... I've heard an audio recording of a Gazan civilian reporting that Hamas is shooting them for evacuating. You're falsely equivocating the actions of Hamas and the IDF.
Having said that, civilian casualties are still civilian casualties, I think the best way to deal with the conflict is to get the entirety of the Arab and Muslim world to condemn and excommunicate Hamas, in hopes of getting them to release the hostages and leave Gaza. I would be in favor of helping the Gazans rebuild and find leadership that will allow them to live and prosper alongside us...
But they need to accept our right to live in our ancestral homeland, as long as we're seen as enemies who stole their land, how can we help people who want us dead or gone?
@@lolkvadimtrue, now lets imagine a world with no hamas, let's call it the "west bank" yeah palestinians are still occupied, getting killed there and their homes and land stolen
Bruh are you guys seeing all these bot comments flooding??
Bc he's not pro palestinian.
What an insightful interview!! I think this is the best interview I watched so far on this recent conflict. Yuval was so unbiased and that makes it great.
Not at all. He is advocating for the Palestinians to forget and "get over it" because it is convenient for his side (and his controllers).
Piers shows his bias in interviews clearly here.
When it's someone who is Pro-Palestine, he starts by asking them about Hamas condemnation or some recent comments they made and asking whether they still stand by it or not (immediately starting an argument that is aimed at attacking their character, and nothing about the war and it's ongoing victims).
When it's someone who is Pro-Israel, he starts with the victims who always happen to be Israeli (and now less than a quarter of the victims in Palestine).
Digusting paid Schill.
@@loopfitnessacademy545 it is what it is! Israel were invaded in 1948 and they pushed back the Arab nations and took their lands! Have you ever heard of the Americans giving their land back? You sound like you've been dropped on your head. A confidently incorrect individual is akin to an idiot.
agreed !!!! This is sickening to watch @@loopfitnessacademy545
@@loopfitnessacademy545so I understand you prefer death and suffering. Thanks for clarifying.
He wants Palestinians evacuated again from their lands so Israel will steal it, instead of ceasefire and inviting the UN. What about 1967 borders two states solution?
On israeli Channel 7, Rabbi Meir Mazuz says: if we were dealing with humans, we’d send humanitarian aid, but we’re dealing with animals
Kinda agree with him? The same people rejoice in the streets on 9/11 and hand out candies and sweets. Most people blame their leaders, Palestinians blame everybody else
Correct
Should we say the same What the Austrian Painter did?
I don’t think the Rabbi is a more a trouble maker than a wise man.
Very disrespectful to animals, as even animals don't do what Hamas did.
Yuval's ability to speak so rationally in such an emotional state... Inspiring.
1:47 best part. “People try to correct the past, people try to save the past, this is impossible… we need to look to the future”
spot on brother!! the past cannot be changed!! prayers to all the victims of the terrorist attack ❤❤
and that's how zionists gaslight the world.
Really then leave the prisoners with hamas , forget it about them
@@Hahahahaha778by israel on palestine
@@newvibs5414the hostages are still alive, they still have a future, of course everything should be done to rescue them. But the idea is not to create more historical injuries. Very difficult to do, but that is the challenge
It was refreshing to hear a balanced perspective on your show, especially given the previous guests who seemed to only advocate for one side. This individual offered constructive solutions that consider both Israeli and Palestinian perspectives, illustrating the nuanced approach that is often lacking in discussions about the Middle East from the other side
Nuance is a privilege.
I disagree, that the other interviews were advocating one side. They(most) did say there should be a ceasefire immediately, however the great usa vetoed it.
The problem with his vision is the fact That no one can promise that after the Palestinians will get a state they won't be ruled by a terrorist dictatorship government. When Israel left Lebanon with hope for peace They got Hezzbola threaten Israel existence, Israel left Gaza with hope to peace and they got Hammas as a governed terrorist organization. In the last couple years there's an ongoing terrorism against Israel from the West Bank and Gaza. Moreover Hamas is dedicated to destroy Israel and even the PLO doesn't recognize Israel existence and so the majority of Palestinians.
You know who this yuval guy really is?
This is absolutely correct Arabs are slowly finding out they have been super stupid for the last that's why one after another they're making peace with Israel
One of the few rational voices I have heard on this topic! Acknowledging pain on both sides and promoting focus on the future! Well said!
Pppp
Pppp
Ppppppppp
P
Watch his lectures on transhumanism … he’s literally an enemy to humanity
Thank you for such a moderate and objective interview 🙏
Admirable, but naive and foolish.
One of the best interviews on the war that I’ve watched. Modest and prudent solutions! He’s definitely anti-BB
Yuval Harari has some balls!!!
I'll quote him always now, peace over justice!!
I'm a Lebanese Arab and would like to say Thank you Piers for what you do ❤
piers is a filthy rodent, what you talking about
kisomak sharmota shou kalb be ashamed
Did you knew Mia Khalifa?
He is fair on som guests
Thanks for what? Taking the jewish side?
Yuval: I am very grateful that you share with the world your extraordinary capacity for clear thinking. Your compassionate way of viewing things might catch on some day.
Inshallah !
This was such a balanced interview. In fact, it was more like having a conversation. And no wander, this will never get as many views as it should. Those who are mocking both Yuval and Piers should watch the full interview ... Yuval acknowledged the plight of Palestinians, and he had good points. If anyone disagrees, then please disagree respectably.
Of course it's a calm interview when Piers lets him speak to the end, and asks questions that are catered to him. Besides, I would be calm too if I had the protection of the press, the US and the west, while killing women and children and blaming it on Hamas, and getting away with it, haha!
Yes, you are right on that but for ones whe hear a balanced view
There’s nothing balanced about what he’s saying 😂😂😂
Don’t you see the difference between the Jewish or pro-israel interviewees v.s. The pro-Palestine/Hamas interviewees….. pro-Palestine just yell, deny, attack etc…. So obvious
@@AliFalah-s2l So you'd prefer a more emotional interview? Or maybe not interviewing prominent/intellectual individuals from the Israeli side at all? Peace is made with enemies, not friends. Maybe just listen to him?
Wow, Piers showed him empathy and was curious about how his family is doing, but he hasn't done that for anyone on the Palestine side. Just shows his bias and his inability to see the humanity of the Palestinian people.
My thoughts exactly.
He has.
@@strombouts he's only done it after the fact. Never at the beginning of the interview
Look how Piers listens like a good boy.
He’s been doing that to both sides of late, doesn’t need creeps to make snide comments to stir the shit.
What a stupid comment
Maybe because its the first time that he brings a person that actually knows what he is talking about?
Recently the only people he is interviewing are retarded Pro-palestinian losers with an average IQ of 70 who did nothing serious in their lives and expect western people to listen to them.
Another pro-Israeli that he interviewed was Ben Shapiro who happens to be smart (surprise surprise)
A proud Israeli Helicopter pilot here.
Yeah he didn’t cut him off at all, like he just asks then be like” i dont give a f*** about his answer i wont comment on it”, cause piers didn’t stopped him to corner him
Pierce is discussing
He is a wise man. "The past injuries should be healed and not be used an an excuse to inflict more injuries". He is also the author of the first-class book: Sapiens - A Brief History of Humankind
This interview is simply stunning -
Imagine, just imagine, if politicians of this moral and intellectual calibre were in charge of Israel, the UK and the US
That's great, but do you condemn Hamas?
@@zeed5764 yes
Notably, you don't even try imaging this kind of leadership on the Palestinian side...
@@evgenystambulchik9035 what are you talking about ?
@@paulinskipukprogressive4903 You said (your comment implied) that politicians of such a calibre would be great - in Israel, the UK, and the US. But somehow, you didn't mention Palestinian leaders in this list. Is it because you think they are already of such a quality or because you believe it's beyond the wildest imagination?
Wow he even admitted and said “Occupied Territories”
😂😂
No he ment Hamas acucupied😅
yea the territories your crap fighting forces lost
You clearly don't know the guy
and why is it being occupied? oh because hamas runs everything that goes on there. and hamas is say it with me… a terrorist organization that wants to annihilate all jews
God bless this guy. He is a man with dignity and he values the life of civilians on the other side
Really? Doesn't look that much like a nan (grandmother) to me
Harari is a known zionist, he is not telling the truth
considering Yuval is Klaus Schwab right hand man, i wouldn't' trust him as far as i would throw him. Even Hamas son , they are up to something. Don't say i didn't warn you
I truly appreciate this sober and clear minded perspective. Voices like his give me some hope.
Finally a voice of reason and intelligent humanitarian solutions 🙏
You people forgot everything what happened till now and Israel using Hamas to not to reach the peace. Hamas is made by Israel and the West. Do you remember that peace agreement and two states solution was signed with Arafat and Rabin in 1995 Rabin was killed by Israeli. They never want Palestinian state. All they want is to throw them out. Zionist and Germans and the west worked together to create Israel.
What brilliant about the stupid idea of using Israeli land has humanitarian relief zone where those areas where attack on 7/10 and when
You have a barrage of rockets from Gaza and Lebanon in the north
Right 500,000 Israelis are refugees
Israel need to take care of it own citizens before sush ideas if it a un aid I should be a area a zone agreed by all parties right now is the south of Gaza
And why again eagypt is no accountable for the close border and seize on Gaza
Finally someone with solution and clear understanding of what's going on.
And what do you think was happening on the day of the Hamas attack? It was the liberal Israelis who let their guard down saying we are reaching the peace we need. Boom your enemy caught you unprepared.
What a difference the interviews on Israel people! They listen, don’t talk over, no violent aggressive attitude, they reply without deflecting at every opportunity. It tells the all story 🙏🇮🇱
Because the line of questioning is pro-israel lmao. Israelis start screaming when you ask them if ask to condemn if they're a terrorist, genocidal and apartheid state. Don't kid yourself, you know the other speakers weren't deflecting, they were being asked questions to propogate a highly biased pro-israel agenda.
Ummmm the Palestinian advocates were constantly interrupted, can you explain how they “deflected at every opportunity”? Did you miss the interviews from Israelis where they just wanna genocide the Palestinians? You are viewing both sides as a monolith.
Of course that’s your takeaway
One argument against Egypt allowing Gazan civilians to move en masse into Egypt is that there are Arabs who argue that Israel will say it is temporary. But as soon as the Gazans have left, the current Israeli government will not allow them back and will claim Gaza for Israel.
All the people in gaza who are not terrorists would like to have a better life in Egypt.
Why do we need to decides for them what's better? give them the option to go to Egypt or any other country.
It should be their choice, not people outside gaza.
@@danieleliyahu3014 I think Egypt gets a vote
That is indeed the fear and the lessons of the past have taught the Palestinians to stay put - if they leave they will never return but remain refugees - which is why Harari’s suggestion that Israel should take in Gazan refugees ( but not only women and children as he suggests) makes good sense - as they would remain housed on ancestral land. I can’t see this happening under the current Israeli regime however.
For all the whining against Piers in the comments section, critics should be most grateful that people get to hear the Palestinian plea. I for one would not have heard nearly to the extent I have with Piers' show. Ultimately, Yuval has had the best takes I've seen and has the capacity to make people listen (I hope it applies to others as it did for me).
As a pro Palestinian I appreciate this mans approach focused to peace, self determination and resolve. It’s the only way
Thank you Yuval - Your wisdom is extra-ordinary.
Historical injuries cannot justify present injuries. Past injuries must be allowed to heal and not used as excuse.
I wish the Palestinians felt the same way. Instead they remember every single slieght of hand and never let go of it. Naming things from 1948.
@@Adim1910they would have if they wouldn’t have been killed since 1948
My favourite guest outside of Bassem, so far!
Love Yuval, I truly think many could learn from his wisdom.
Imo Cenk and Bassem the best and wisest. This guy is also awesome.
Why should Palestinians be genocided and evacuated from their lands for Israel to steal it. Look at Palestine map in 1948. A better solution is the ceasefire. Bring the United Nations in to solve the problem. And give Palestinians their freedom in two states solution of 1967 guarded by UN.
As an Arab, I was always a fan of Yuval's works and after this interview, my respect for him reached another level.
@@iyadartHe’s a sociopath that’s an advisor for Klaus Shwab a very deceptive individual, and if you don’t know klaus Shwab I suggest you look him up and look up his past family history ties with Nazi Germany
I think this is the most well-balanced and intellectual people you have had out of anyone else since the attacks. I think his views and proposals are very interesting and positiveA welcome and fresh addition to your show. I hope he can come back in the future.
“If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose peace”
there will be no peace if there's no justice. How you can have a peace while some people or group feeling they have no right and are subjugated. Justice is prerequisite for peace.
@@AbdullahGurta Yes, this war in Gaza is not good for Israel because now they'll never be a two state solution and no equality for the Palestinians. The Israel's just don't seem to think about what is going to happen next.
One of the clearest minded Representative of Israel and the Palestinian conflict I've heard in a long time..
Piers Morgan,
Again, I congratulate you on the personal work you are doing as a journalist to try to find points in common between Israelis and Palestinians.
It is great to hear people like Yuval Noah Harari, a historian and a brilliant author, explain points of view without being exalted by mere passion due to the HAMAS attack.
This is the kind of negotiator Israel needs to try to solve this issue peacefully.
That show how much you are ignorant about the issue and how much was easy you were manipulated, ask me why ?
Yuval, we need leaders like you. “If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose peace” ill keep that one
Except Hamas will not seek that even if you don’t look for justice, So it seems unfortunately the only way to get peace is through justice.
Manny people who live around gaza in Israel believe it also, didn't help them much...
You can't have peace when you and the other side talk in different languages.
Then the Palestinians need to hear that message to. He also said this attack happened because they wanted to botch the peace process and normalization in the region. All the while Israel is being demonized all over the world and Jews are being threatned for being Jewish. This is all due to those "pro-Palestinian" hate filled protests. Tell me how Israel has not chosen peace every time.
One of the few guests of last week's interviews who actually is responding the questions asked by Piers, attempting to be as objective as possible and providing some constructive ideas to the future of Palestine-Israel conflict..
“If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose peace”
🙏
As a Palestinian, I agree with Mr. Harari on most of what he said. I think the solution to the problem is for Netanyahu to resign then make peace with the Palestinians where they can get their own land with dignity like other nations.
The Israeli side can criticize its own leadership and mistakes, but can you criticize your side, and condemn hammas?
A lot of politicians would react/operate the same as netenyaho. Remove him and he needs to be replaced with an aligned left government that's peace driven.
Alas Mr Harari said it early on in the interview that hamas needs to be removed, and the attack happened now because of the Saudis on the verge of signing deals with the Israel government.
Unfortunately everything falls apart when Israel has to act aggressively in pursuit of removing Hamas. Collateral deaths occur, which happens in any war conflict. In this case hamas also causes some of that collateral with 1/3 of their missile attacks. Just like what happened in the hospital car park.
Remove hamas first, after that vote in a left wing gov for Israel, then ensure Gaza isn't ruled by zealots and terrorists.
Don't choke hold Gaza from within the borders (Hamas) and out (right wing Israeli gov). Spend money on education, business, and perhaps sport clubs. Allow the Gazan ppl to prosper and grow on their own innovations away from the tyranny of warmongers.
Easier said than done though.
@@tomer_stern yes i do, i condumn them . What about you? Do you condumn the Israeli government for killing thousands of innocent civiliants, children, babies, people who had nothing to do with this war? Do you condumn the Israeli government for the occupation and forcing millions of Palestinians to move from their own homes? Do you condumn the Israeli government for taking out from the Palestinians their basic rights as humans? Isn't the things that hamas do that consider terrorism, Israel was doing much more, far worse and still do?
As an Israeli, the problem is both our sides have radical leadership. Hamas is doing horrors to both our ppl while Bibi is a complete facist. Ending Hamas' role in Gaza, putting the PA in charge of Gaza instead then demand the resignations of Bibi, Ben Gvir and Smotrich and with new leadership on both sides, we can begin a new era of peace
at last,thank you yuval. as an israeli citizen and a jewish woman i absolutely adore you. i want peace and i cry for my family and falestin families.
For once i agree with this guy at least to a degree. He sounds human and compassionate for once and his concern for women and children is something you can't disagree with
Egyptian Arab with a lot of respect and love for this guy ❤️ if only we had more of such characters on the political scene!
Hi anwarowerZ. Totally agree but I am wondering how easy it is for you to express respect for Israeli intellectuals. I have little knowledge of Egyptian society and politics so I am not assuming anything but just now polarisation is making it hard for us all I feel.
@@martifingers I am expressing my respect based on my objective judgment on what he just said.
@@martifingers Sorry misunderstood your question! Yeah there are always some people who would call me names for this, but also others who would give themselves a chance to judge.
@@anwarowerZ Thanks for the reply. You are a little light of hope in this awful darkness. I hope people (and there must be many of us) can spread such light in the coming days and months. Salaam.
@@martifingers Thank you for your kind words! I don’t believe there is anything special about me though. I believe every human is a lover of peace and harmony by nature. The problem of the Middle East is the circle of hate. People who saw their families killed. People who got deported. It’s super hard for them to forgive. Then each party dehumanizes the other, and justifies whatever evil they do to them..We used to be more loving before this conflict! It tears my heart apart to know that this conflict made me waste the chance to grow with as much Jew friends on school as the Christian ones I have, and learn more perspectives through them. I honestly don’t know how we can revert this situation, but I pray that one day we live again in peace…
As someone from Ireland, I agree with him that no peace process gives perfect justice. Both the IRA and the UDF had to start caring more about the devastation they were causing everyone than getting a perfect justice.
The West’s antagonists cry “No justice, no peace!”
Peace is more important now
I haven't heard one person that support hamas or Palestinians to have the clear ideas and the maturity to provide with unbiased intelligence knowledge of the situation a solution a really honest solution like this man. Palestinians should be listening to this guy instead of the leaders of hamas
You obviously only watch Western media.
As Malcome X said, "don't let the press make you love the oppressor, and hate the oppressed"
Powerful words Yuval, even Piers managed to listen well
Piers always listen to smart people. Now if you are a savage it's a different question
I'm Israel and I'm tierd of my stupid right winged government, I want peace with Palestine and I want them to have good life and I know deeply that we can be brothers just like we are talking almost same language.tierd of war!!!!,
"Israël is not a terrorist organisation" that's a huge leap of faith Yuval.
Hamas either don't call themselves terrorists.
Thank you gentlemen for this discussion! These are the voices needed to resolve this conflict.
I must appreciate this man's honesty, foresight, intelligence, and humanity. Hats off to you, Harari.
8 God, there is no god but He, His are the Most Beautiful Names.
9 Has the story of Moses reached you?
10 When he saw a fire, he said to his family, “Stay; I have noticed a fire; Perhaps I can bring you a torch therefrom, or find some guidance by the fire.”
11 Then, when he reached it, he was called, “O Moses.
12 I-I am your Lord. Take off your shoes. You are in the sacred valley of Tuwa.
13 I have chosen you, so listen to what is revealed.
14 I-I am God. There is no God but I. So serve Me, and practice the prayer for My remembrance.
15 The Hour is coming-but I keep it almost hidden-so that each soul will be paid for what it endeavors.
16 And do not let him who denies it and follows his desire turn you away from it, lest you fall.
17 And what is that in your right-hand, O Moses?”
18 He said, “This is my staff. I lean on it, and herd my sheep with it, and I have other uses for it.”
19 He said, “Throw it, O Moses.”
20 So he threw it-thereupon it became a moving serpent.
21 He said, “Take hold of it, and do not fear. We will restore it to its original condition.
22 And press your hand to your side; it will come out white, without a blemish-another sign.
23 That We may show you some of Our greatest signs.
24 Go to Pharaoh; He has transgressed.”
25 He said, “My Lord, put my heart at peace for me.
26 And ease my task for me.
27 And untie the knot from my tongue.
28 So they can understand my speech.
29 And appoint an assistant for me, from my family.
30 Aaron, my brother.
31 Strengthen me with him.
32 And have him share in my mission.
33 That we may glorify You much.
34 And remember You much.
35 You are always watching over us.”
36 He said, “You are granted your request, O Moses.
37 We had favored you another time.
38 When We inspired your mother with the inspiration.
39 `Put him in the chest; then cast him into the river. The river will wash him to shore, where an enemy of Mine and an enemy of his will pick him up. And I have bestowed upon you love from Me, so that you may be reared before My eye.
40 When your sister walked along, and said, ‘Shall I tell you about someone who will take care of him?' So We returned you to your mother, that she may be comforted, and not sorrow. And you killed a person, but We saved you from stress; and We tested you thoroughly. And you stayed years among the people of Median. Then you came back, as ordained, O Moses.
41 And I made you for Myself.
42 Go, you and your brother, with My signs, and do not neglect My remembrance.
43 Go to Pharaoh. He has tyrannized.
44 But speak to him nicely. Perhaps he will remember, or have some fear.”
45 They said, “Lord, we fear he may persecute us, or become violent.”
46 He said, “Do not fear, I am with you, I hear and I see.
47 Approach him and say, `We are the messengers of your Lord; so let the Children of Israel go with us, and do not torment them. We bring you a sign from your Lord, and peace be upon him who follows guidance.
48 It was revealed to us that the punishment falls upon him who disbelieves and turns away.'“
49 He said, “Who is your Lord, O Moses.”
50 He said, “Our Lord is He who gave everything its existence, then guided it.”
51 He said, “What about the first generations?”
52 He said, “Knowledge thereof is with my Lord, in a Book. My Lord never errs, nor does He forget.”
53 He who made the earth a habitat for you; and traced in it routes for you; and sent down water from the sky, with which We produce pairs of diverse plants.
54 Eat and pasture your livestock. In that are signs for those with understanding.
55 From it We created you, and into it We will return you, and from it We will bring you out another time.
56 We showed him Our signs, all of them, but he denied and refused.
57 He said, “Did you come to us to drive us out of our land with your magic, O Moses?
58 We will produce for you magic like it; so make an appointment between us and you, which we will not miss-neither us, nor you-in a central place.”
59 He said, “Your appointment is the day of the festival, so let the people be gathered together at mid-morning.”
60 Pharaoh turned away, put together his plan, and then came back.
61 Moses said to them, “Woe to you. Do not fabricate lies against God, or He will destroy you with a punishment. He who invents lies will fail.”
62 They disagreed among themselves over their affair, and conferred secretly.
63 They said, “These two are magicians who want to drive you out of your land with their magic, and to abolish your exemplary way of life.
64 So settle your plan, and come as one front. Today, whoever gains the upper hand will succeed.”
65 They said, “O Moses, either you throw, or we will be the first to throw.”
66 He said, “You throw.” And suddenly, their ropes and sticks appeared to him, because of their magic, to be crawling swiftly.
67 So Moses felt apprehensive within himself.
68 We said, “Do not be afraid, you are the uppermost.
69 Now throw down what is in your right hand-it will swallow what they have crafted. What they have crafted is only a magician’s trickery. But the magician will not succeed, no matter what he does.”
70 And the magicians fell down prostrate. They said, “We have believed in the Lord of Aaron and Moses.”
71 He said, “Did you believe in him before I have given you permission? He must be your chief, who has taught you magic. I will cut off your hands and your feet on alternate sides, and I will crucify you on the trunks of the palm-trees. Then you will know which of us is more severe in punishment, and more lasting.”
72 They said, “We will not prefer you to the proofs that have come to us, and Him who created us. So issue whatever judgment you wish to issue. You can only rule in this lowly life.
73 We have believed in our Lord, so that He may forgive us our sins, and the magic you have compelled us to practice. God is Better, and more Lasting.”
74 Whoever comes to his Lord guilty, for him is Hell, where he neither dies nor lives.
75 But whoever comes to Him a believer, having worked righteousness-these will have the highest ranks.
76 The Gardens of Perpetuity, beneath which rivers flow, dwelling therein forever. That is the reward for him who purifies himself.
77 And We inspired Moses: “Travel by night with My servants, and strike for them a dry path across the sea, not fearing being overtaken, nor worrying.”
78 Pharaoh pursued them with his troops, but the sea overwhelmed them, and completely engulfed them.
79 Pharaoh misled his people, and did not guide them.
80 O Children of Israel! We have delivered you from your enemy, and promised you by the right side of the Mount, and sent down to you manna and quails.
81 Eat of the good things We have provided for you, but do not be excessive therein, lest My wrath descends upon you. He upon whom My wrath descends has fallen.
82 And I am Forgiving towards him who repents, believes, acts righteously, and then remains guided.
83 “And what made you rush ahead of your people, O Moses?”
84 He said, “They are following in my footsteps; and I hurried on to You, my Lord, that you may be pleased.”
85 He said, “We have tested your people in your absence, and the Samarian misled them.”
86 So Moses returned to his people, angry and disappointed. He said, “O my people, did your Lord not promise you a good promise? Was the time too long for you? Or did you want wrath from your Lord to descend upon you, so you broke your promise to me?”
87 They said, “We did not break our promise to you by our choice, but we were made to carry loads of the people’s ornaments, and we cast them in. That was what the Samarian suggested.”
88 So he produced for them a calf-a mere body which lowed. And they said, “This is your god, and the god of Moses, but he has forgotten.”
89 Did they not see that it cannot return a word to them, and has no power to harm them or benefit them?
90 Aaron had said to them before, “O my people, you are being tested by this. And your Lord is the Merciful, so follow me, and obey my command.”
91 They said, “We will not give up our devotion to it, until Moses returns to us.”
92 He said, “O Aaron, what prevented you, when you saw them going astray.
93 From following me? Did you disobey my command?”
94 He said, “Son of my mother, do not seize me by my beard or my head. I feared you would say, `You have caused division among the Children of Israel, and did not regard my word.'“
95 He said, “What do you have to say, O Samarian?”
96 He said, “I saw what they did not see, so I grasped a handful from the Messenger’s traces, and I flung it away. Thus my soul prompted me.”
97 He said, “Begone! Your lot in this life is to say, ‘No contact.’ And you have an appointment that you will not miss. Now look at your god that you remained devoted to-we will burn it up, and then blow it away into the sea, as powder.”
98 Surely your god is Allah, the One besides whom there is no other god. He comprehends everything in knowledge.
29 Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.
Read The Quran
“I am to you a clear warner.”
“That you shall worship none but Allah. I fear for you the agony of a painful Day.”
Amen.
I like this man he is very reasonable and wise. We need more people like him in this world
Harari is a known zionist, he is not telling the truth
The first person from the other sidei on the show who has empathy...seems like a decent individual ...we need people like these
BIG difference in interviewing a respectable voice who honors the dialectical process. I’m reading Yuval’s Book now❤
His books are great, happy reading/learning!
he has a strong mind, one that refuses to give in to feelings of revenge and hate. This man is an important Israeli voice in these dark times.
He's a Evil WEF puppet!
Thats the voice of the israelis not only him
@@natybar-yosef9931 Israeli or not he remains an evil WEF puppet!
This was the best interview I’ve yet to see on this matter. Thank you sir!
Pierce I have to say I might not agree with you on a lot of things, but thank you for your coverage and interviews on this global humantarian crisis that will change the whole world and I pray it is for the better (I am doing everything I can in my power to change it). The world is speaking and we need to listen.
8 God, there is no god but He, His are the Most Beautiful Names.
9 Has the story of Moses reached you?
10 When he saw a fire, he said to his family, “Stay; I have noticed a fire; Perhaps I can bring you a torch therefrom, or find some guidance by the fire.”
11 Then, when he reached it, he was called, “O Moses.
12 I-I am your Lord. Take off your shoes. You are in the sacred valley of Tuwa.
13 I have chosen you, so listen to what is revealed.
14 I-I am God. There is no God but I. So serve Me, and practice the prayer for My remembrance.
15 The Hour is coming-but I keep it almost hidden-so that each soul will be paid for what it endeavors.
16 And do not let him who denies it and follows his desire turn you away from it, lest you fall.
17 And what is that in your right-hand, O Moses?”
18 He said, “This is my staff. I lean on it, and herd my sheep with it, and I have other uses for it.”
19 He said, “Throw it, O Moses.”
20 So he threw it-thereupon it became a moving serpent.
21 He said, “Take hold of it, and do not fear. We will restore it to its original condition.
22 And press your hand to your side; it will come out white, without a blemish-another sign.
23 That We may show you some of Our greatest signs.
24 Go to Pharaoh; He has transgressed.”
25 He said, “My Lord, put my heart at peace for me.
26 And ease my task for me.
27 And untie the knot from my tongue.
28 So they can understand my speech.
29 And appoint an assistant for me, from my family.
30 Aaron, my brother.
31 Strengthen me with him.
32 And have him share in my mission.
33 That we may glorify You much.
34 And remember You much.
35 You are always watching over us.”
36 He said, “You are granted your request, O Moses.
37 We had favored you another time.
38 When We inspired your mother with the inspiration.
39 `Put him in the chest; then cast him into the river. The river will wash him to shore, where an enemy of Mine and an enemy of his will pick him up. And I have bestowed upon you love from Me, so that you may be reared before My eye.
40 When your sister walked along, and said, ‘Shall I tell you about someone who will take care of him?' So We returned you to your mother, that she may be comforted, and not sorrow. And you killed a person, but We saved you from stress; and We tested you thoroughly. And you stayed years among the people of Median. Then you came back, as ordained, O Moses.
41 And I made you for Myself.
42 Go, you and your brother, with My signs, and do not neglect My remembrance.
43 Go to Pharaoh. He has tyrannized.
44 But speak to him nicely. Perhaps he will remember, or have some fear.”
45 They said, “Lord, we fear he may persecute us, or become violent.”
46 He said, “Do not fear, I am with you, I hear and I see.
47 Approach him and say, `We are the messengers of your Lord; so let the Children of Israel go with us, and do not torment them. We bring you a sign from your Lord, and peace be upon him who follows guidance.
48 It was revealed to us that the punishment falls upon him who disbelieves and turns away.'“
49 He said, “Who is your Lord, O Moses.”
50 He said, “Our Lord is He who gave everything its existence, then guided it.”
51 He said, “What about the first generations?”
52 He said, “Knowledge thereof is with my Lord, in a Book. My Lord never errs, nor does He forget.”
53 He who made the earth a habitat for you; and traced in it routes for you; and sent down water from the sky, with which We produce pairs of diverse plants.
54 Eat and pasture your livestock. In that are signs for those with understanding.
55 From it We created you, and into it We will return you, and from it We will bring you out another time.
56 We showed him Our signs, all of them, but he denied and refused.
57 He said, “Did you come to us to drive us out of our land with your magic, O Moses?
58 We will produce for you magic like it; so make an appointment between us and you, which we will not miss-neither us, nor you-in a central place.”
59 He said, “Your appointment is the day of the festival, so let the people be gathered together at mid-morning.”
60 Pharaoh turned away, put together his plan, and then came back.
61 Moses said to them, “Woe to you. Do not fabricate lies against God, or He will destroy you with a punishment. He who invents lies will fail.”
62 They disagreed among themselves over their affair, and conferred secretly.
63 They said, “These two are magicians who want to drive you out of your land with their magic, and to abolish your exemplary way of life.
64 So settle your plan, and come as one front. Today, whoever gains the upper hand will succeed.”
65 They said, “O Moses, either you throw, or we will be the first to throw.”
66 He said, “You throw.” And suddenly, their ropes and sticks appeared to him, because of their magic, to be crawling swiftly.
67 So Moses felt apprehensive within himself.
68 We said, “Do not be afraid, you are the uppermost.
69 Now throw down what is in your right hand-it will swallow what they have crafted. What they have crafted is only a magician’s trickery. But the magician will not succeed, no matter what he does.”
70 And the magicians fell down prostrate. They said, “We have believed in the Lord of Aaron and Moses.”
71 He said, “Did you believe in him before I have given you permission? He must be your chief, who has taught you magic. I will cut off your hands and your feet on alternate sides, and I will crucify you on the trunks of the palm-trees. Then you will know which of us is more severe in punishment, and more lasting.”
72 They said, “We will not prefer you to the proofs that have come to us, and Him who created us. So issue whatever judgment you wish to issue. You can only rule in this lowly life.
73 We have believed in our Lord, so that He may forgive us our sins, and the magic you have compelled us to practice. God is Better, and more Lasting.”
74 Whoever comes to his Lord guilty, for him is Hell, where he neither dies nor lives.
75 But whoever comes to Him a believer, having worked righteousness-these will have the highest ranks.
76 The Gardens of Perpetuity, beneath which rivers flow, dwelling therein forever. That is the reward for him who purifies himself.
77 And We inspired Moses: “Travel by night with My servants, and strike for them a dry path across the sea, not fearing being overtaken, nor worrying.”
78 Pharaoh pursued them with his troops, but the sea overwhelmed them, and completely engulfed them.
79 Pharaoh misled his people, and did not guide them.
80 O Children of Israel! We have delivered you from your enemy, and promised you by the right side of the Mount, and sent down to you manna and quails.
81 Eat of the good things We have provided for you, but do not be excessive therein, lest My wrath descends upon you. He upon whom My wrath descends has fallen.
82 And I am Forgiving towards him who repents, believes, acts righteously, and then remains guided.
83 “And what made you rush ahead of your people, O Moses?”
84 He said, “They are following in my footsteps; and I hurried on to You, my Lord, that you may be pleased.”
85 He said, “We have tested your people in your absence, and the Samarian misled them.”
86 So Moses returned to his people, angry and disappointed. He said, “O my people, did your Lord not promise you a good promise? Was the time too long for you? Or did you want wrath from your Lord to descend upon you, so you broke your promise to me?”
87 They said, “We did not break our promise to you by our choice, but we were made to carry loads of the people’s ornaments, and we cast them in. That was what the Samarian suggested.”
88 So he produced for them a calf-a mere body which lowed. And they said, “This is your god, and the god of Moses, but he has forgotten.”
89 Did they not see that it cannot return a word to them, and has no power to harm them or benefit them?
90 Aaron had said to them before, “O my people, you are being tested by this. And your Lord is the Merciful, so follow me, and obey my command.”
91 They said, “We will not give up our devotion to it, until Moses returns to us.”
92 He said, “O Aaron, what prevented you, when you saw them going astray.
93 From following me? Did you disobey my command?”
94 He said, “Son of my mother, do not seize me by my beard or my head. I feared you would say, `You have caused division among the Children of Israel, and did not regard my word.'“
95 He said, “What do you have to say, O Samarian?”
96 He said, “I saw what they did not see, so I grasped a handful from the Messenger’s traces, and I flung it away. Thus my soul prompted me.”
97 He said, “Begone! Your lot in this life is to say, ‘No contact.’ And you have an appointment that you will not miss. Now look at your god that you remained devoted to-we will burn it up, and then blow it away into the sea, as powder.”
98 Surely your god is Allah, the One besides whom there is no other god. He comprehends everything in knowledge.
29 Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.
Read The Quran
“I am to you a clear warner.”
“That you shall worship none but Allah. I fear for you the agony of a painful Day.”
This is the most reasonable and wise man I have heard so far on this conflict.
Harari is the best
His foundation is meditation, maybe you would enjoy that as well!
@@0xSylo he’s sociopath who’s an advisor for klaus Shwab he’s a psychopath you obviously don’t know him, he openly talks about keeping the youth docile with drugs and computer games to further their agenda
If you have to choose between justice and peace, choose peace. Well said
❤
Those who argue passionately for the Palestinians' interest do not live in Gaza, they want justice at the expense of the peace of the Palestinians living in Gaza.
Can we get more like like him? Sensical interviews like this are needed !!! 👏🏻
● Yuval Noah Harari - i have 100% RESPECT for you ok!!!! Thanks for everything ❤️💗❤️💗❤️💗
Watch his videos on transhumanism and eliminating free will. If you’re a sensible person you will come back and delete this comment. He’s not your friend 😂 you’re are a “useless class of people” in his own words🤦🏽♂️
Harari is speaking like Harari, clear and compassionate. When there is a choice between justice and peace, choose peace. This is universally true. Glad to see him in this form. Keep going. More power to you.
I am an atheist Iranian Australian. This conversation was informed, intelligent and wise. And what can I say about Yuval Harari? Every time I listen to this man my respect and admiration for him doubles. Yuval you are my brother and I kiss your hand.
That's good, but do you condemn Hamas?
I see Noah saying we should not look at the past, just focus on the future. The the most colonial statement I've heard in all of this. When people in South Africa talk of apartheid, those same former colonisers say "stop focusing on what we did to you", "don't dwell on the past, just look forward", whilst they still currently benefit from the the oppression they inflicted on black people.
he says it to both sides and he is right
Brilliant, balanced, and insightful interview.
Yuval Noah Harari is the voice the whole world needs to hear. He only speaks the truth and doesn't let his emotions dictate his thoughts. We hope for peace for both Palestinians and Isrealis.
I have listened to all of Piers’ interviews since the war started. It is clear that the Israeli speakers are more level headed, well spoken and possess a more humanitarian and constructive outlook towards a solution. Either it is because the Israeli speakers are better at getting their point across, or it is that the Israeli point actually makes more sense. However, I appreciate Piers’ willingness to bring both sides on for discussion. I am yet however to see a constructive Palestinian voice.
It's because Palestinians feel strongly that it is their land and so they feel like negotiation for their own property isn't right or fair. Israeli nationalists equally see it as God given land. In reality, it is a land in which many groups were exiled and expelled from. Arab conquest in the 7th century conquered and displaced Jews. If you go back far enough, everyone has been expelled. In my opinion, this is why as Yuval says peace is more constructive than justice. A compromise where Israel can exist whilst Palestinians are given human rights and their won state is what's needed..
Also u have to remember that Palestinian people dnt grow up in a normal world, they don't have any continuity or stability. They also dnt have access to education so they naturally wnt be able to articulate themselves as well as the rest of us. This is another outcome of living under an occupation. I think the Palestinians do a great job considering their lack of normality.
Are you joking with this? Piers does nothing but antagonise his Palestinian guests with the same repetitive questions and talking points just trying to get them to condemn what happened to Israel instead of actually listening or showing any empathy to what they’re saying. The Palestinian guests have been brilliant look at the views and public responses , piers has been nothing but abhorrent to them showing his bias from the start. Go find a clip of him asking an Israeli guest to condemn the killings of innocent by the IDF , I’ll wait
I totally agree with you and Yuval. Peace is more important than justice.
It’s no joke Danny. think you are correct though... Piers does seem biased. But in reality, so are you and so am I. So we need to look beyond biases and beyond history and beyond justice. Mistakes are committed and have been committed on both sides. We need to look beyond all that, we need to forgive and we need to move on peacefully. For the record, I am Jewish and I have lived in Israel and have family there. I recognize my bias. At the same time I have many many Arabic, Persian and muslim friends. People I call my brothers and sisters. Peace loving people need to get together from both sides to weld peace. Hamas I am afraid is not peace loving. And let me tell you there are many enemies of peace on both the Israeli and American side as well.
I think what piers is trying to do is have the Palestinians recognize that hamas is not going to lead them to peace. Their methods are not constructive.
make this man a prime minister , or someone like him, and you'll have peace. and we might seen an end for this conflict. it is about time for god sake. 75 years it is enough from both sides.
From all the Piers interviews in past days I learned that AMC55F by Amazon is what it is about. not kidding. there is a reason that this is everywhere and it takes 5 minutes to know why. dont get irritated by the bots it is a real strong project saving li
English is not understood 😅😅😅😅
Is this Israeli Propaganda? To hide potential valid comments by spamming the comment section with this crap? Hmm..
@@RAFIKI2029 Most likely a bot with the nonsensical thing about Amazon AMC55F. Somebody messed up with their bot programming.
shit. this looks like serious project of bots. all of those likes, and i saw this name "AMC55F Amazon" comes in different locations. probably some governmental.
@@we-are-2023 bot screwup
"don't try and go back to the past" - easy to say when you've kicked nearly a million people out of their land
It’s been done many times by the Jews. And in African countries and Japan. Wake up before it’s too late
your ignorance of history is astounding. In 1948 over 80% of the land was UNOWNED and UNINHABITED and UNSOVEREIGN, so in what world did the Arabs (who were intending to combine with Jordan) have legal claim to every inch of it? A better question is why did Jordan deserve the land over giving some parts to Jews with no where else in the world to be?? The Arabs could have partitioned the land and their lives would have remained unchanged, giving the Jews with no where else to go a piece of the Negev desert would have not impacted their life in any way, and the Nakba only happened because the Arabs stupidly opened in war vowing to “finish Hitler’s solution” and denouncing any Jewish sovereignty even on land they didn’t own or live in. Also the same number of Jews were kicked out of the Middle East. Do you see Egyptian Jews entering Egypt and slaughtering civilians in their homes because their grandparents were kicked out of the country simply due to their ethnicity?? THAT is choosing peace over justice. The Palestinians need to follow suit (in addition to taking accountability for getting us to this point and rejecting every peace offer)
Well by this logic, the Jewish popular certainly would resented the German people after the Holocaust. But look and behold as Yuval said they are now have a close relationship. Please try to not hold resentment for the past, it does not help to solve the problem. Have a good day
😂😂 My wife and I made a bet about how Piers would open this call. He did not disappoint us. Complete opposite of how he approaches pro-Palestinian guests.
Still waiting for the question is they have something to condemn
What a stupid point. He's hardly going to ask him if he condemns Hamas, he's a Jew for Gods sake!
Notice he answered the questions rather than diverting like the Mus lim apologists do? All they do is read the script Hamas gave them.
Very good and balanced view. This is a great man.
That's why I absolutely love Yuval Harari.
Yuval Noah Harari = 💩
And he would call you a "Useless eater"
@@davidelms893 i think these people are bots just like the ones spamming the amazon comment
Read his books, I strongly recommend them. Yuval is extremely intelligent and his historical knowledge is impressive. I’m not surprised he has such a nuanced and intelligent response to this conflict.
lol no thanks... talk about polluting your mind with zionist filth
He’s extremely intelligent, yet he is evil and one of humanity’s largest threats.
Read Ilan Pappe better
He steal ideas from people and makes up a lot of stuff. Just look at the back of any of his books, very few sources. His books are easy and fun to read but definitly not someone to take seriously.
@@japiro14 watch Dr Gabor Mate latest
I don’t see Pearce Morgan debate this guy like he does when he receives a pro Palestinian person
”I have ni horse in this race” hahaha such a clown
Yep, Piers argues with people who stand up for justice.
The nicest interview of the last few weeks . Thank you
Thank you. As a Muslim, I needed to see this.
I believe in a 2 state solution as I don’t want Jews to suffer. I know they’re brainwashed but I want these Palestinians having their homes back! I want them to be treated like humans and get their dignity back. I want it to be a safe place for Palestinians to live without the IDF abusing them.
As a Muslim person since this start he is the only reasonable man God bless him,,
This man hates God, read his book
Piers did not ask him if he condemn the Palestinian killed
But when he interview a Palestinian person the first question he ask if the condemns what Hampshire did
And yet he continually says “I’m neutral here I have no horse in this race” as if we all can’t see him treating the guests differently
This is quite possibly the most sane level headed man ive heard speak on this topic.
He's a sensible person who brings hope for humanity, and leaders should pay attention to wise individuals like him ❤❤
ah yes the man who said humans are insects is a wise man. hes a WEF shill.
Hope for humanity? Lol
I advise you to listen to his talks at the World Economic Forum (some of them could be found here on RUclips).
Thank you Yuval for your compassion!
9:00: "If you pursue absolute justice, you will only perpetuate war indefinitely" Food for thought.
His book Sapiens is on of the best books I've ever read. He is a class act.
This World needs more people like Mr Harari.....Well done!.
You obviously don’t know who he is
@@johnogrady_I love comments with zero substance to them, just writing ambiguous comments for the dull brained masses 😂
100%, explaining the reasons does not justify the atrocities, but it helps us to get to the solution. The reasons must be heard too