I felt like Jinbei was holding back a bit against Who’s Who taking his attacks & being defensive until later on where he finally decides to finish off Who’s Who, the fight was like a mid diff for Jinbei so I don’t think he scales comparably to Who’s Who. He was definitely stronger. That said, Jinbei isn’t going down easily to most characters but I do have Kat beating him. He’s too much & outclasses Jinbei in the end but it’s certainly not a stomp or anything like that
I definitely think jinbei is stronger then who’s who. But there’s atleast some type of comparability considering who’s who was atleast able to draw blood from jinbei.
@@IMO3530 I would still put Jinbei on another tier/level tho, I don’t think drawing blood is enough to say they’re close or something like that especially when the fight itself was a mid diff & Jinbei ended it quick, also overpowered Who’s Who with armament haki when he chose to. I just think Jinbei still has lots more to show & was very defensive that fight for the most part. Good vid tho
@@handsmcgee8331 Even if he's a tier higher. Katakuri is multiple tiers above who's who. He's above Yc2, who're above yc3, who are above flying six like who's who. He'd get treated like ichiji was against katakuri. A lot of people jump gaps with jinbei but he really lacks feats to compare him directly with commanders. That or they give too much credit to things that ultimately did nothing against weakened characters like big mom.
@IMO3530 jimbe dead ass sat and tanked attacks from him straight up...we can't just ignore the fact jimbe pretty much had caution thrown to the wind in the fight and was lil brothering who's who
I’m getting sick of the Katakuri slander Katakuri is the top commander of a Yonko. Having another Yonko have THREE commanders who can beat him is just stupid
03:45 I always interpreted that Luffy thought that fighting her would be possible without Gear 4 but it would take long and eat up his stamina which he wanted to conserve for Kaido. So ending the fight rather quickly with Gear 4 was his idea.
Mochi issue aside, lets not forget that later on in the fight, Katakuri stops using his awakening and mogura spear and just coats his arms in armament and pretty much boxes luffy outside of buzzcut. And even that seemed to have the advantage against snakeman. If Katakuri can fight like that with just hands, then even that should be enough to defeat Jinbei. His own hand to hand combat and the giant speed gap is just too much.
Katakuri was holding back almost the entire time against luffy, then by the time it came down to the wire, his haki was too exhausted to put Luffy down easily even if he started being serious. Say what you want about katakuri, but he is a glass cannon, while luffy just had too much endurance and durability to outlast him. I think if jinbe manages to actually land one water boosted fishmen karate secret technique, katakuri would just die on the spot.
I actually agree with your analysis, bcz sadly a lot of powerscalers dont know how power creep thing works. That infamous "Wano`s power creep" was always much more related to Roof top rather than to Wano itself. Also, i liked your Ace video. When i was reading novel i used to think it wasnt future sight referring to Thatch`s advices with which it would be impossible to reach that level of haki. But i somehow missed that Ace had 100 battles with WB, so haki bloom in fight against strong enemy makes sense after you explained it. Keep going bro
@@saadabdullah5786 katakuri slams everyone below Sanji and that includes Jinbe lmao, Who's who is miles weaker than Kata, Jinbe doesn't have any Ob Haki feats or Conq Haki at all and his arm haki feats are against Who's who, who is like at best Doffy level with wanks 💀
2:27 You need to be in a calm state to use Observation in general Thats how marco got caught by fodder marines in marineford And how jozu got frozen They lost their cool cuz wb was having a heart attack Katakuri got hit because he could not use even basic observation haki Thats why he got hit The same is true for armamemt but you need concentration for that to work
It's funny that you think jimbei and who's who are somewhat comparable because of two drops of blood, in a story where people's fight last days.. Jimbei and ace where somewhat comparable before timeskip, they fought for 5 days. If you think who's who has a chance to win 1/10 fights you have to think harder, because even cp0 doesn't think that 😅. Something else, katakuri is a glass-cannon, you can look up on the internet the score of the fight between him and luffy, you'll understand why.
Plz don’t claim Perospero scale to Cat Viper. I hate this common misconception so I just write this short: Cat Viper and Inu> Rooftop Jack > 3 Mustakeers> Surlong Wanda and Carrot> Perspo Perspo said Carrot and Wanda solely lost bc of the weather not his power. Surlong form is taxing on the body and Wanda replies make it seem that Cat Viper just recently lost the form and Pero took an advantage of it rather than it’s an offscreen fight with Cat Viper fighting in Base for a bit of time.
I disagree with this entirely. What suggest 3 musketeers > both sulong carrot and Wanda. Or even one of them for that matter the only thing that supports this besides contextual emotion driven statements. This also doesn’t disregard the fact he’s portrayed relative to neko.
More than anything the reason the argument is used is to upscale Katakuri which still works here. Because cracker drastically outscales perospero. Perospero is relative to ichiji and wouid essentially lose to red hawk wci luffy. While cracker is relative to gear 4. And then Katakuri DRASTICALLY outscales him. It still help support the scale of Katakuri being far beyond the likes of people like jinbe and jack.
@@WindowLife. It’s already stated in both Zou that Carrot and Wanda are apart of Inu’s army in which case the Three Mustakeers holds the greatest command over those two and Carrot directly stated that they were above her at the end of Wano.
@@WindowLife. Not really relative to Neko. Again, Wanda states in surprise that Cat Viper is no longer in his Surlong form like he just lost it at that moment rather than fighting a long going battle in Base. It’s also been stated in both WCI and Wano that Surlong form is taxing on the body plus the added damage from their battle with Kaido vs Pero who only major fight he had was against Carrot and Wanda who he almost lost too so that why there’s a huge power gap between Jack and Pero
I disagree with the pespero argument I'd say cat viper was way more nerfed considering he just got done getting violated by kaido. He also just got done fighting in sulong witch has heavy draw backs
Perospero got a Bomb detonated in his face and lost an arm Fought His way to onigashima and arrived Using his Fruit (Wich takes stamina like all fruit usage does) Fought carrot and Wanda was going to kill Marco meaning he has the ap to put down Marco a first commander Then as is faced Cat viper Who is commander lvl relative And was portrayed to be jacks equal Injured yes Defeated by relatively the same enemy yes The only difference and it's a Point towards perospero Is perospero doesn't have passive Zoan buffs like Vitality and stamina Regen along with Extra durability
Completely agree with you, in the video you got all the points. My opinion is very similar to your. If the 1v1 would be on the ground in the middle of a island far away to any water source, katakuri would slam jinbe because he is phyisical better in almost everything and got better haki. If the fight is on the ocean yeah jinbe is very dangerous and in most of cases is a easy win for him, the greatest feat was against big mom. If the fight is in the middle of a island but with some source of water the fight would be very close.
Why does jimbe need water sources, his sweat is water, bodies are MADE of water(which fish man karate effects), jimbe tanks admiral attacks, blitzed BM(weekend or not, was she WEAKER katikuri)
I hope crocodile resurfaces soon and we see him get a glow up because I have a feeling bro is gonna be atleast yc1 level but I could be coping since he’s one of my favourite characters lol
Yep. And Luffy just judge goijg to G4 for 1ms, breaking out of it, one shotting her and going to base was gonna cost less stamina than getting hit on the head like that once or twice before he got out of her grip.
Except if any of the Robi Topo are above Katakuri than the whole lore fucking breaks. Kaido > Big Mom. That's for sure. What happens if the two crew clash if Who's Who > Kat? Big Mom crew get stomped. King has speed because Zoro fought Kaido. Queen maybe tag Kat. But the others aren't touching him.
that one scene with Ulti really screwed up how people see the power scaling in one piece. Luffy wanting to use G4 to deal with Ulti right away is much more likely than he needed that form to defeat her in a 1v1. narratively, 1st commanders are around the same power. luffy stalemated a heavily injured kat after he stabbed himself
He only wanted gear 4 to get away from her grip. He would probably take around 5 or 6 hits to defeat her. Remember she took heavy hits such as Yamato's haimei rakke, and especially Big Mom Laser cannon, and got up after. She has the most endurance out of the tobiroppos.
I think many people underrate Jinbe. Jinbe is a TANK, he's offensively powerful, he's fast, he has high battle iQ, great observation and armament Haki (advanced), fishman karate (also bypasses defenses) - which will exploit Katakuri's devil fruit as a weakness. This is the same Jinbe that took the magma punch that killed ACE, without a hole, didn't die. This is the same Jinbe that fought Ace, a logia user, Whitebeard commander, ON LAND (fishmen are much weaker on land), for 5 days to a draw, an Ace that defeated a prior Yamato. I do believe Jinbe would mid to high dif Katakuri. Jinbe doesn't fight like an idiot heavily like Luffy, Jinbe is more of a smart, tactical fighter like Sanji.
Funny how u pick which narrative you chose to use to fit Ur narrative Comparing katakuri who lost to a Luffy that kaido blitzed to nekomishi who is able to harm kaido you also ignored the fact neko was hurt and fatigued Power cliffing exists
Good video, but I expected you to make a cause how would Jimbe win or something, cause I think everyone thinks that Katakuri is stronger than Jimbe, but still a good video
Love u pointed out the actual mochi weakness water because for some reason people keep trying to tell me it's flames even tho we see katakuri himself use flame with mochi to increase attack power smh
we can see that the cat viper that fought peros was not at 100% for one and had just been fighting and was likely nerfed from just going nsulong also we can see that that once he turned sulong again he bodied perso so using peros to scale cat viper to wank katakuri is not a fair arguement
I agree it's not fair at all and trying to scale characters like that is weird kat clearly look how he beat this character who relative to this character and beat this character like jeez
The thing with speed is power which is very true but it's high speed either with flight, force of gravity, acceleration through other means. Just getting a running start isn't adding that much power to ulti blows
Look dude I got Jinbe as high as a second commander but SO FAR theres nothing he can do to TOUCH Katakuri, he doesnt have the speed nor the observation haki Water is a weakness for all devil fruit users, and if Ace had a 5 days battle with Jinbe right next to the water I see Katakuri doing the same but winning, cause hes stronger than Ace, specially rookie Ace Jinbe has GREAT armament, probably better than Kat, but not to the point where he wouldnt take damage from the hits Unstoppable donuts is crazy strong And again since Jinbe doesnt have the future sight nor the speed needed to hit Kat, I dont know how he wins I feel like people forget how hard it is to fight with Kat People maybe scale him based only in the time at wich he appeared in the story rather than looking at the actual abilities and how difficult it is for characters to have the right powers to beat him.
@@chaoskiller321choas3 Zoro should win at this point but he would need to improve his observation and/or his speed in the middle of the fight cause otherwise hes not that quick
Katakuri would low diff Jinbe. His abilities make him too troublesome to deal with. Jinbe falls short in all categories of combat. If sea water is nearby Jinbe can turn it into a mid diff Katakuri win
Jimbei will destroy Katakuri. Jimbei did way better against Big Mon than the Luffy who defeated Katakuri. Jimbei basically no-diff Who's-Who who is way stronger than Ulti and we all know Ulti and Luffy fight. Also, we haven't seen the Jimbei limit.
@metalme2306 no diffeed Whos Who? No who are you fooling? He broke through Jinbe's haki defenses on multiple occasions. Jinbe doesn't have a means of even landing a blow on Katakuri. Unless you believe he is faster than WCI Luffy. Because until he learned Future sight Luffy wasn't landing blows either
If you actually look at ulti gripping strength and ability to hold Luffy down. Her dinosaur is not known for it's grip strength but it's dome head. It has weak legs so it's more to ulti strength using her df and just how strong she is. To say Luffy needed a larger form to handle a bigger opponent. When Luffy should be way past needing forms to deal with bigger opponents in strength. He over powers giants in base or gear second
Overrall I agreed with part for jinbe winning but disagree with your take on katakuri beating whos whos 1. First of all we know katakuri don't have ryou so he can't real damaged ancient zoan as he want too 2. Ulti being stronger than katakuri is obvious since she can temporary clash with base luffy ( non serious) and goes for who whos too. 3. At the end of the day - I still respect katakuri but he isn't above them unless we see a stronger version of him later in the final arc.
@@christopherlake9667 so Xdrake and Apoo who are both as strong as the other tobi roppo, and they aren't far from Ulti or Who's who because the characters in that group are on the same level Xdrake apoo and two numbers couldn't beat two cp0 agents Yet an *injured* Izou almost took down both agents Nekomamushi is much stronger than izo let alone an injured version and perospero managed to overpower nekomamushi's base form. Both were injured btw. Nekomamushi base=Jack~Perospero>>injured izou>>tobi roppo Also supported by jack telling the tobi roppo not to bother with the scabbards Ulti didn't even do that well against Luffy, she pushed him down then Luffy got up and blitzed her, then Luffy was restrained off guard. Don't forget Luffy wants to save his strength for Kaido Btw Katakuri restrained and damaged gear 4. Idk if Luffy in act 1 was actually using future sight to not get hit by kaido. And he was still hurt and hit despite reading the future
Okay comparing how weak cat viper is to the first big mom son is just silly we know sulong can drain u to the put of almost dead so no in of that he was fighting kaido there is a power creep in wano just like dressrosa to wci kat do not have what it takes to damage kaido so implying the kat is over cat viper who can damage kaido yea come on Kat would even be able to put down jack u can’t make an agreement that he could, a weak luffy was tanking all his attacks Jack is way more tanker, there is no good reason u can use to say kat beats anybody would can damage kaido in wano even if it’s a little
@@IMO3530 I don’t remember anything like that either way if that is true u saying kat can beat Jack how, Kat couldn’t beat a way weaker luffy than Jack, u have nothing to say kat can beat cat viper at 100 percent or jack, I know u know what your talking about most of the time, and I know u have no good reason to justify Kat being able to beat queen or king or anybody who can tanks kaido’s attacks and damage him kat feats are really bad
All it takes to damage Kaido is dura neg. All the scabbards have dura neg. Their strength has nothing to do with this. Law literally beat Kinemon before Punk Hazard. On top of this not a single scabbard has reacted to a direct named attack like thunder baguya that is a focused attack rather than an aoe one.
I think you’re scaling has issues, because you’re not considering that Jinbe held off big moms fleet. This fleet had oven,smoothie, perespero, and eventually big mom who he has proven to be able to tag and react to multiple times. Jinbe has also been able to fight for days. Even if he can’t touch katakuri his haki would weaken over time, while Jinbe can defend his mochi attacks with water. Like he did with ace who has much higher dc than kata.
nope, kata has a huge speed gap with jinbei, also the bigmom jimbei brawled with didnt have haki cuz she has amnesia in her sweet break, katakuri slams jinbei, he can use future sight, jinbei cant
@@KingWildfire-rx3wp idk what I am saying is parosparo is around the same as oven who I think is the best of the triplets but he not far from Jack so bigmom has stronger top officer's
I saw a little bit of underrating to jack But ill say that jack was fighting for many days and inwarashi and nikamoshi was fighting separately So it's was a weakened jack vs them along side with And if prospero was relative to non soulung form nikamoshi but he got stomped on with relative ease in soulung form nikamoshi But soulung form inwarashi was having some hard time to fight jack who has already fought many soulung forms minks I do believe people start underrating katakuri nowadays but i don't think he is that strong ngl
Perospero>Tobi roppo Katakuri>>>perospero Katakuri>>jack Jack>Jimbe We saw in whole cake island Jimbe could do practically nothing to Katakuri. Haven't watched the video as I'm writing this, just gotta spread my gospel
even if bigmom couldnt breath shes still a emperor and was still beating the shit outta ppl. i also think jinbei is stronger than base luffy in whole cake. imo ofc. but i beleive near the end of op jinbei is gonna get conq haki tbh his goal of freeing the fishmen slaves and making them equal is insane and he would need to be stronger than he is now ofc.
katakuri mid-high diff. i think ppl underestimate jinbei, he pretty much mid diffed whos who. i think he scales around jack or the sulong for instance. but hes not high commander tier like katakuri in the water hes like mid-high commander tier atleast
I feel like katakuri is as strong as jack. Perospero is stronger than snack but weaker than katakuri. Jinbe wouldn't win vs katakuri on dry land but would get swamped if it was a battle at sea.
Why are we wasting time talking about perosero feats in Wano 😂😂😂 when it's his candy hax abilities that makes trouble. Plus jimbe is way stronger than cat viper
I know that Kat is winning, but dude your other arguments are copium, like the oven thing and getting hit by base Luffy, just accept the fact that kat got bullshit durability and weak AP😂
follow the twitter twitter.com/IMOonyt
frist follower :>
imo congrats on 4k subs
If it’s a 1v1 underwater, always bet on a Jinbe 🗣️🗣️
Sanji:
Zoro:
Nah it’s Arlong
@@glass7456 yes adlong would no diff everyone in the water as hell as jinbe😂
@@That.One.Kid_Jinbe held off Big moms FLEET, he fought ACE for days ON LAND. Zoro and Sanji aren’t beating him underwater
ZA WATER
I felt like Jinbei was holding back a bit against Who’s Who taking his attacks & being defensive until later on where he finally decides to finish off Who’s Who, the fight was like a mid diff for Jinbei so I don’t think he scales comparably to Who’s Who. He was definitely stronger. That said, Jinbei isn’t going down easily to most characters but I do have Kat beating him. He’s too much & outclasses Jinbei in the end but it’s certainly not a stomp or anything like that
I definitely think jinbei is stronger then who’s who. But there’s atleast some type of comparability considering who’s who was atleast able to draw blood from jinbei.
@@IMO3530 I would still put Jinbei on another tier/level tho, I don’t think drawing blood is enough to say they’re close or something like that especially when the fight itself was a mid diff & Jinbei ended it quick, also overpowered Who’s Who with armament haki when he chose to. I just think Jinbei still has lots more to show & was very defensive that fight for the most part. Good vid tho
@@handsmcgee8331 Even if he's a tier higher. Katakuri is multiple tiers above who's who. He's above Yc2, who're above yc3, who are above flying six like who's who. He'd get treated like ichiji was against katakuri. A lot of people jump gaps with jinbei but he really lacks feats to compare him directly with commanders. That or they give too much credit to things that ultimately did nothing against weakened characters like big mom.
@@IMO3530 dawg who's who's fingers broke from attacking jinbei's full body haki. When jinbei isn't sandbagging those two are not comparable
@IMO3530 jimbe dead ass sat and tanked attacks from him straight up...we can't just ignore the fact jimbe pretty much had caution thrown to the wind in the fight and was lil brothering who's who
I’m getting sick of the Katakuri slander
Katakuri is the top commander of a Yonko. Having another Yonko have THREE commanders who can beat him is just stupid
03:45 I always interpreted that Luffy thought that fighting her would be possible without Gear 4 but it would take long and eat up his stamina which he wanted to conserve for Kaido. So ending the fight rather quickly with Gear 4 was his idea.
Mochi issue aside, lets not forget that later on in the fight, Katakuri stops using his awakening and mogura spear and just coats his arms in armament and pretty much boxes luffy outside of buzzcut. And even that seemed to have the advantage against snakeman. If Katakuri can fight like that with just hands, then even that should be enough to defeat Jinbei. His own hand to hand combat and the giant speed gap is just too much.
Katakuri was holding back almost the entire time against luffy, then by the time it came down to the wire, his haki was too exhausted to put Luffy down easily even if he started being serious. Say what you want about katakuri, but he is a glass cannon, while luffy just had too much endurance and durability to outlast him. I think if jinbe manages to actually land one water boosted fishmen karate secret technique, katakuri would just die on the spot.
katakuri had all chances to turn luffy into yet another donut
Just remember guys rock beats rock because rock beats scissors and scissors beats paper the same paper that beats rock… case closed
@@zenonking2840 if rock tried to fight rock both would break
@@tfg6420 bruh you must be fun at parties
1:54 Jinbei wasn’t overwhelmed by Who’s Who at all. Jinbei just had a scratch that he couldn’t reach. 😎😎
I actually agree with your analysis, bcz sadly a lot of powerscalers dont know how power creep thing works. That infamous "Wano`s power creep" was always much more related to Roof top rather than to Wano itself. Also, i liked your Ace video. When i was reading novel i used to think it wasnt future sight referring to Thatch`s advices with which it would be impossible to reach that level of haki. But i somehow missed that Ace had 100 battles with WB, so haki bloom in fight against strong enemy makes sense after you explained it. Keep going bro
he didnt really have 100 "battles" it was more so Ace tried killing wb 100 times and got 1 tapped or stopped every time until the last one
jinbei bodies katakuri wanp power scaling is a thing bro katakuri compared to the straw hats debatable could only beat nami and usopp
@@saadabdullah5786 katakuri slams everyone below Sanji and that includes Jinbe lmao, Who's who is miles weaker than Kata, Jinbe doesn't have any Ob Haki feats or Conq Haki at all and his arm haki feats are against Who's who, who is like at best Doffy level with wanks 💀
the power creep was insane tho, you telling me bounceman got one shot just for him to come back 3 weeks later and match the same attack in base?
Great video man🔥🔥I'm tired of seeing people downplay katakuri to tobi ropo lvl.
0:28 " he was able to dodge a base bigmom"
like what bigmoms is slow as hell litterally anyone can land an attack on her
2:27
You need to be in a calm state to use Observation in general
Thats how marco got caught by fodder marines in marineford
And how jozu got frozen
They lost their cool cuz wb was having a heart attack
Katakuri got hit because he could not use even basic observation haki
Thats why he got hit
The same is true for armamemt but you need concentration for that to work
It's funny that you think jimbei and who's who are somewhat comparable because of two drops of blood, in a story where people's fight last days..
Jimbei and ace where somewhat comparable before timeskip, they fought for 5 days. If you think who's who has a chance to win 1/10 fights you have to think harder, because even cp0 doesn't think that 😅.
Something else, katakuri is a glass-cannon, you can look up on the internet the score of the fight between him and luffy, you'll understand why.
Plz don’t claim Perospero scale to Cat Viper. I hate this common misconception so I just write this short: Cat Viper and Inu> Rooftop Jack > 3 Mustakeers> Surlong Wanda and Carrot> Perspo
Perspo said Carrot and Wanda solely lost bc of the weather not his power.
Surlong form is taxing on the body and Wanda replies make it seem that Cat Viper just recently lost the form and Pero took an advantage of it rather than it’s an offscreen fight with Cat Viper fighting in Base for a bit of time.
Based take I hate when people use this argument
I disagree with this entirely. What suggest 3 musketeers > both sulong carrot and Wanda. Or even one of them for that matter the only thing that supports this besides contextual emotion driven statements. This also doesn’t disregard the fact he’s portrayed relative to neko.
More than anything the reason the argument is used is to upscale Katakuri which still works here. Because cracker drastically outscales perospero. Perospero is relative to ichiji and wouid essentially lose to red hawk wci luffy. While cracker is relative to gear 4. And then Katakuri DRASTICALLY outscales him. It still help support the scale of Katakuri being far beyond the likes of people like jinbe and jack.
@@WindowLife. It’s already stated in both Zou that Carrot and Wanda are apart of Inu’s army in which case the Three Mustakeers holds the greatest command over those two and Carrot directly stated that they were above her at the end of Wano.
@@WindowLife. Not really relative to Neko. Again, Wanda states in surprise that Cat Viper is no longer in his Surlong form like he just lost it at that moment rather than fighting a long going battle in Base. It’s also been stated in both WCI and Wano that Surlong form is taxing on the body plus the added damage from their battle with Kaido vs Pero who only major fight he had was against Carrot and Wanda who he almost lost too so that why there’s a huge power gap between Jack and Pero
I disagree with the pespero argument I'd say cat viper was way more nerfed considering he just got done getting violated by kaido. He also just got done fighting in sulong witch has heavy draw backs
Perospero got a Bomb detonated in his face and lost an arm
Fought His way to onigashima and arrived Using his Fruit (Wich takes stamina like all fruit usage does)
Fought carrot and Wanda was going to kill Marco meaning he has the ap to put down Marco a first commander
Then as is faced Cat viper
Who is commander lvl relative
And was portrayed to be jacks equal
Injured yes
Defeated by relatively the same enemy yes
The only difference and it's a Point towards perospero
Is perospero doesn't have passive Zoan buffs like Vitality and stamina Regen along with Extra durability
Completely agree with you, in the video you got all the points. My opinion is very similar to your. If the 1v1 would be on the ground in the middle of a island far away to any water source, katakuri would slam jinbe because he is phyisical better in almost everything and got better haki. If the fight is on the ocean yeah jinbe is very dangerous and in most of cases is a easy win for him, the greatest feat was against big mom. If the fight is in the middle of a island but with some source of water the fight would be very close.
Why does jimbe need water sources, his sweat is water, bodies are MADE of water(which fish man karate effects), jimbe tanks admiral attacks, blitzed BM(weekend or not, was she WEAKER katikuri)
I hope crocodile resurfaces soon and we see him get a glow up because I have a feeling bro is gonna be atleast yc1 level but I could be coping since he’s one of my favourite characters lol
He will defeat greenbull in the future
Oda showed me in a dream
@@animoments8969hmm, that’s quite the reliable source… I’m sold.
i think its close either way, powerscaling in one piece needs to be reworked, it seemed like Jimbei did more against Big Mom and Luffy did against Kat
Big mom could barely breathe but I see your point
Jinbe did nothing to big mom but push her off the boat with ocean advantage LOL
What did u mean by “before ar long got his blue haki”@@IMO3530
One piece has narrative powerscaling, whoever oda wants to win, will win, especially if theres gag characters involved.
That's in all stories dude, it's the writers job to make it believable or justify it, which Oda can be good or bad at at times.
“Ulti is stronger because she held Luffy forcing a transformation” do y’all know what leverage is?
Yep. And Luffy just judge goijg to G4 for 1ms, breaking out of it, one shotting her and going to base was gonna cost less stamina than getting hit on the head like that once or twice before he got out of her grip.
katakuri being constantly overrated will never fail to make me sick
I know right lol
Which is too funny to me
bitches saying he's weaker thqn ulti i'd rather have people say he can beat jinbe and marco than say that he'd lose to ulti
Except if any of the Robi Topo are above Katakuri than the whole lore fucking breaks.
Kaido > Big Mom. That's for sure.
What happens if the two crew clash if Who's Who > Kat?
Big Mom crew get stomped.
King has speed because Zoro fought Kaido.
Queen maybe tag Kat.
But the others aren't touching him.
Lol
that one scene with Ulti really screwed up how people see the power scaling in one piece.
Luffy wanting to use G4 to deal with Ulti right away is much more likely than he needed that form to defeat her in a 1v1.
narratively, 1st commanders are around the same power.
luffy stalemated a heavily injured kat after he stabbed himself
He blitzed her hybrid form in base I really doubt that tbh
He only wanted gear 4 to get away from her grip.
He would probably take around 5 or 6 hits to defeat her.
Remember she took heavy hits such as Yamato's haimei rakke, and especially Big Mom Laser cannon, and got up after.
She has the most endurance out of the tobiroppos.
To make it simple... Katakuri mid diff
I think many people underrate Jinbe. Jinbe is a TANK, he's offensively powerful, he's fast, he has high battle iQ, great observation and armament Haki (advanced), fishman karate (also bypasses defenses) - which will exploit Katakuri's devil fruit as a weakness.
This is the same Jinbe that took the magma punch that killed ACE, without a hole, didn't die. This is the same Jinbe that fought Ace, a logia user, Whitebeard commander, ON LAND (fishmen are much weaker on land), for 5 days to a draw, an Ace that defeated a prior Yamato.
I do believe Jinbe would mid to high dif Katakuri. Jinbe doesn't fight like an idiot heavily like Luffy, Jinbe is more of a smart, tactical fighter like Sanji.
I don’t care about the logic of this power scaling/vs video but your commentary is hilarious 😂😂😂
Commander vs number 4 in the straw hats? Jinbei ain’t taking katakuri down and that’s not a shot at jinbei. Katakuri is just that dude
Funny how u pick which narrative you chose to use to fit Ur narrative
Comparing katakuri who lost to a Luffy that kaido blitzed to nekomishi who is able to harm kaido you also ignored the fact neko was hurt and fatigued
Power cliffing exists
Sasaki is pathetic, he is honestly the weakest of the flying 6.
I would like your opinion on Sanji/Zoro vs Katakuri.
It s common sense kata loses
@@shwix6534 Yeah i agree on that, but there is a part of the community that are currently triping on some hard drugs, and they can't accept that fact.
That topics so over done but I’m planning on a bigger video “what would win in a yonko battle royal” which would include their crews
Sanji And zoro alone beat hin currently
Good video, but I expected you to make a cause how would Jimbe win or something, cause I think everyone thinks that Katakuri is stronger than Jimbe, but still a good video
Both of them are Don Krieg victims 🗿
Love u pointed out the actual mochi weakness water because for some reason people keep trying to tell me it's flames even tho we see katakuri himself use flame with mochi to increase attack power smh
we can see that the cat viper that fought peros was not at 100% for one and had just been fighting and was likely nerfed from just going nsulong also we can see that that once he turned sulong again he bodied perso so using peros to scale cat viper to wank katakuri is not a fair arguement
I agree it's not fair at all and trying to scale characters like that is weird kat clearly look how he beat this character who relative to this character and beat this character like jeez
Perespero had also been damaged before their fight so the argument that Cat Viper was damaged so scales way higher than Perespero doesn't make sense.
The thing with speed is power which is very true but it's high speed either with flight, force of gravity, acceleration through other means. Just getting a running start isn't adding that much power to ulti blows
Bro I’m begging you to make a boros vs Luffy vid
“Cat viper” instead of nekomamushi is a f*king crime.
Look dude I got Jinbe as high as a second commander but SO FAR theres nothing he can do to TOUCH Katakuri, he doesnt have the speed nor the observation haki
Water is a weakness for all devil fruit users, and if Ace had a 5 days battle with Jinbe right next to the water I see Katakuri doing the same but winning, cause hes stronger than Ace, specially rookie Ace
Jinbe has GREAT armament, probably better than Kat, but not to the point where he wouldnt take damage from the hits
Unstoppable donuts is crazy strong
And again since Jinbe doesnt have the future sight nor the speed needed to hit Kat, I dont know how he wins
I feel like people forget how hard it is to fight with Kat
People maybe scale him based only in the time at wich he appeared in the story rather than looking at the actual abilities and how difficult it is for characters to have the right powers to beat him.
Zoro or kat??
@@chaoskiller321choas3 Zoro should win at this point but he would need to improve his observation and/or his speed in the middle of the fight cause otherwise hes not that quick
IMO i saw the vid of ace it was awesome do you think if ace had lived he would have surpasses his father and other pirates or what
Definitely considering he was able to sort of contend with yonkos at the age of 20 I’ll have a video on “what if ace reached his full potential” soon
@@IMO3530 yeah thanks also make more one piece what ifs to we would all love that
These RUclipsrs know damn well most these fights are close but use the gay ass title to click bait. It’s business tho
Bro the fights are getting specifical every video💀
Katakuri would low diff Jinbe. His abilities make him too troublesome to deal with. Jinbe falls short in all categories of combat. If sea water is nearby Jinbe can turn it into a mid diff Katakuri win
Low diff is a stretch, High diff without water
Jimbei will destroy Katakuri. Jimbei did way better against Big Mon than the Luffy who defeated Katakuri. Jimbei basically no-diff Who's-Who who is way stronger than Ulti and we all know Ulti and Luffy fight. Also, we haven't seen the Jimbei limit.
Saying low dif is jus disrespectful 💀
@metalme2306 no diffeed Whos Who? No who are you fooling? He broke through Jinbe's haki defenses on multiple occasions. Jinbe doesn't have a means of even landing a blow on Katakuri. Unless you believe he is faster than WCI Luffy. Because until he learned Future sight Luffy wasn't landing blows either
@k.x.i.4710 not really. Until Luffy learned future sight he wasn't able to land attacks on Katakuri. Jinbe won't be able to either.
If you actually look at ulti gripping strength and ability to hold Luffy down. Her dinosaur is not known for it's grip strength but it's dome head. It has weak legs so it's more to ulti strength using her df and just how strong she is. To say Luffy needed a larger form to handle a bigger opponent. When Luffy should be way past needing forms to deal with bigger opponents in strength. He over powers giants in base or gear second
Overrall I agreed with part for jinbe winning but disagree with your take on katakuri beating whos whos
1. First of all we know katakuri don't have ryou so he can't real damaged ancient zoan as he want too
2. Ulti being stronger than katakuri is obvious since she can temporary clash with base luffy ( non serious) and goes for who whos too.
3. At the end of the day - I still respect katakuri but he isn't above them unless we see a stronger version of him later in the final arc.
Perospero managed to defeat nekomamushi who is much more powerful than the tobi roppo and Katakuri is levels above him
@@thearsalandombgaming wait what lol katakuri isn't stronger than tobi roppo
@@christopherlake9667 absolutely is read the story
@@thearsalandombgaming I read the story lol and pespero isn't stronger than them.
@@christopherlake9667 so
Xdrake and Apoo who are both as strong as the other tobi roppo, and they aren't far from Ulti or Who's who because the characters in that group are on the same level
Xdrake apoo and two numbers couldn't beat two cp0 agents
Yet an *injured* Izou almost took down both agents
Nekomamushi is much stronger than izo let alone an injured version and perospero managed to overpower nekomamushi's base form. Both were injured btw.
Nekomamushi base=Jack~Perospero>>injured izou>>tobi roppo
Also supported by jack telling the tobi roppo not to bother with the scabbards
Ulti didn't even do that well against Luffy, she pushed him down then Luffy got up and blitzed her, then Luffy was restrained off guard. Don't forget Luffy wants to save his strength for Kaido
Btw Katakuri restrained and damaged gear 4.
Idk if Luffy in act 1 was actually using future sight to not get hit by kaido. And he was still hurt and hit despite reading the future
The fact you had to give an environmental advantage for jinbei shows that katakuri speed blitzs.
Jimbei= YC2, i always say that. That’s been the saying for a long time, but for some reason Ppl dont hold this view as often anymore
Okay comparing how weak cat viper is to the first big mom son is just silly we know sulong can drain u to the put of almost dead so no in of that he was fighting kaido there is a power creep in wano just like dressrosa to wci kat do not have what it takes to damage kaido so implying the kat is over cat viper who can damage kaido yea come on Kat would even be able to put down jack u can’t make an agreement that he could, a weak luffy was tanking all his attacks Jack is way more tanker, there is no good reason u can use to say kat beats anybody would can damage kaido in wano even if it’s a little
The sulong form only brings you near to death when you havent mastered it. But when you do the repercussions
are close to none
@@IMO3530 I don’t remember anything like that either way if that is true u saying kat can beat Jack how, Kat couldn’t beat a way weaker luffy than Jack, u have nothing to say kat can beat cat viper at 100 percent or jack, I know u know what your talking about most of the time, and I know u have no good reason to justify Kat being able to beat queen or king or anybody who can tanks kaido’s attacks and damage him kat feats are really bad
All it takes to damage Kaido is dura neg. All the scabbards have dura neg. Their strength has nothing to do with this. Law literally beat Kinemon before Punk Hazard. On top of this not a single scabbard has reacted to a direct named attack like thunder baguya that is a focused attack rather than an aoe one.
Both are crocodile victims.
@the-meat-battles Facts
Bro the clickbait is insane
The “wouldn’t be a close fight” videos always say it would be a interesting or a close fight at the end
You right my fault 😭
@@IMO3530bro my friend sent me your doffy vs katakuri vid and as a doffy Stan it hurt me
I think you’re scaling has issues, because you’re not considering that Jinbe held off big moms fleet. This fleet had oven,smoothie, perespero, and eventually big mom who he has proven to be able to tag and react to multiple times. Jinbe has also been able to fight for days. Even if he can’t touch katakuri his haki would weaken over time, while Jinbe can defend his mochi attacks with water. Like he did with ace who has much higher dc than kata.
nope, kata has a huge speed gap with jinbei, also the bigmom jimbei brawled with didnt have haki cuz she has amnesia in her sweet break, katakuri slams jinbei, he can use future sight, jinbei cant
no she did not@@sheenakr7616
Kata is my fave character in one piece and i love jimbei but Kata hakis are overwhelming
3:04 you know what is silly, that you think Haki can seen so luffy making katakuri gush in blood was a anti feat
🧠💀
😭😭
It’s obvious katakuri is on another level
I might be wrong about what I’m about to say but for the next video assuming that ace scales to beginning of wano Luffy I think he wins
Parosparo not only under the 4 sweet commanders probably the triplets aswell
So you want to say that Oven and Daifuku are on par with Jack? OVEN AND DAIFUKU??? hell nah.
@@KingWildfire-rx3wp idk what I am saying is parosparo is around the same as oven who I think is the best of the triplets but he not far from Jack so bigmom has stronger top officer's
@@BDDterror Oven is the strongest among the triplets? So you're basically trying to say that Oven > Katakuri? Because it's just incorrect.
@@KingWildfire-rx3wp what how did I say oven over katakuri?
@@KingWildfire-rx3wp how old are you?
The honest and sad truth is that Jinbe gets clapped by Kata mid diff at max.
Katakuri was at same tier than blue flame Sanji like we see in the movie Pne Piece Red
fax, fishman karate is 2x stronger in water tho lil mistake there
Jinbei would Crush Katakuri. We haven't even seen him figth serious yet,
nice vid
Whos whos did not once overwhelm jimbe, put some respect of dudes name it wasnt a competition😭
But when he got his advanced blue haki 🗣️
Arlong... advanced blue haki? Wtf, we just making up stuff now?
It’s a joke 😭
wow
I saw a little bit of underrating to jack
But ill say that jack was fighting for many days and inwarashi and nikamoshi was fighting separately
So it's was a weakened jack vs them along side with
And if prospero was relative to non soulung form nikamoshi but he got stomped on with relative ease in soulung form nikamoshi
But soulung form inwarashi was having some hard time to fight jack who has already fought many soulung forms minks
I do believe people start underrating katakuri nowadays but i don't think he is that strong ngl
Perospero>Tobi roppo
Katakuri>>>perospero
Katakuri>>jack
Jack>Jimbe
We saw in whole cake island Jimbe could do practically nothing to Katakuri. Haven't watched the video as I'm writing this, just gotta spread my gospel
even if bigmom couldnt breath shes still a emperor and was still beating the shit outta ppl. i also think jinbei is stronger than base luffy in whole cake. imo ofc. but i beleive near the end of op jinbei is gonna get conq haki tbh his goal of freeing the fishmen slaves and making them equal is insane and he would need to be stronger than he is now ofc.
No way a devil fruit user would lose in water?💀
in water there is water vs Katakuri that kills him before jimbe
You got something against fishman?? You getting real spicy talking about jimbei 😂
katakuri mid-high diff. i think ppl underestimate jinbei, he pretty much mid diffed whos who. i think he scales around jack or the sulong for instance. but hes not high commander tier like katakuri
in the water hes like mid-high commander tier atleast
I feel like katakuri is as strong as jack. Perospero is stronger than snack but weaker than katakuri. Jinbe wouldn't win vs katakuri on dry land but would get swamped if it was a battle at sea.
I'll put my money on Jimbei. He did better against Big Mom than the Luffy who defeated Katakuri.
HOW TF DOES JIMBE FIGHT ACE 5DAYS STRAIGHT TO A STANDSTILL BUT IS SOMEHOW NOT AS CLOSE TO KATAKURI THEN HIM?!?!? yall bugging out hard😅
Why are we wasting time talking about perosero feats in Wano 😂😂😂 when it's his candy hax abilities that makes trouble. Plus jimbe is way stronger than cat viper
1:43 😭😭😭😭😭👍
Well of course Jinbei wins at sea, Katakuri can’t swim 💀
Why was this a question 😂 Katakuri for the win 🏆
Commentary getting out of hand ☠️💀
Katakuri high diff
Jinbe is YC2
While Katakuri is low YC1
So high diff
Naaa I need to see someone who says katakuri is stronger then an admiral
0:52 Big meme 💀
One of the strongest commanders? Bro is the weakest commander in the show
It's literally a mid diff for Jinbe lmao
katakuri would win on land 100%! Underwater Jinbei might have a chance.
8:29 Nawww Jin is actually whopping Kata on land
Lol
I know that Kat is winning, but dude your other arguments are copium, like the oven thing and getting hit by base Luffy, just accept the fact that kat got bullshit durability and weak AP😂
Lol
when whos who started racising jimbei neggedddddd
Jinbei is the best
katakuri wins
i wasnt frist :/
first